W.r.t."self driving winter", I think Waymo are aiming to protecting themselves from that situation by developing close relationships with regulators, highlighting the "we're not them"-part and sticking to their safety-first approach.
Again, the measuring stick is real drivers. And real drivers are really bad at this stuff too.
For the comparison to hold you need to do the following:
- discount all the hours when humans are in adverse conditions and autopilot is not normally engaged
- remove motorcycles and other vehicles from the pool
After you do that Tesla is still much less safe than your average driver. Their whole spiel of taking the easy 80% in miles of driving and claiming victory has been debunked so often now it is getting boring. It's the remaining 20% where the fatalities are and which - coincidentally - are the hard bits.
The only story I see is politics and complexity, as opposed to moral clarity.
People (and the media) are going to focus on the accidents that would not have happened if self driving did not exist.
But machines make different mistakes, mistakes that humans would never do, and that's psychologically not acceptable to most people. All the actual accidents will be "freak" accidents that a human could never cause, and that scares people a lot more than "human" accidents like a drunk driver running someone over at a pedestrian crossing.
If I get killed by a drunk driver, my wife will at least have someone to rage at.
If I get killed because my car randomly decides to drive itself into a high up truck and I basically died because of stupid technology. I would hope that it doesn't end up killing my wife too out of rage that she's going up against a major corporation now.
That's kind of maddening.
It psychologically like being a passenger in a car with a good driver who has a history of epileptic seizures.
I think what would be accepted is if the self-driving car would have capabilities that surpass the best human driver (as opposed to the "average" driver). But we're a long way from that.
I agree with this but I think it implies that people also will not accept safe self-driving cars that take forever to get anywhere in traffic. Especially since a decline in average traffic throughput makes things worse for everyone in a car, self-driving or not.
I think this makes the problem much harder, since a lot of people do demonstrably take risks in their driving now, in the interest of saving time (even knowing intellectually that lives are on the line).
If you assume people drive 10K per year at an average speed of 33 mph, you’re driving ~300 hours per year. Slow that by 25% and it’s an extra 100 hours per year. If you assume 7.5 hours of sleep, you’d spend an extra 1.6% of your waking life in a car because of the slowdown. That’s killing a lot of time, even if not directly killing people.
frankly I don't think any of the teams who have demos are as close as they hint they are. there are just so many exceptions that it becomes maddening.
look, people road rage over the driving habits of others and the computer while it won't road rage has to react to those who infuriate others with their driving either because its reckless or just bad driving
some of my favorite conditions....
people stopping to let you out, how does the car know? people going out of order at an intersection?
* I do not let it drive where I think the situations are complex and obviously it does not have the ability to respond to traffic signals or make turns at intersections.
Yurikamome trams in Tokyo runs in L4-L5 and Tsukuba Express runs in L2, in SDC levels term. There was also a L4 PoC in Yamanote line so that’ll probably come by the end of this decade. Elevators had been L4 for like half a century as well, by the way.
In other words, getting trains to L4 is straightforward, and there's been a rollout for half a century. Making the jump to "doesn't even need the driver to handle emergencies," that's a task comparable in scope to getting cars from L2 to L4.
Would be really interesting if Waymo could prove this out somehow.
I'm driving southbound on Fair Oaks in Sunnyvale, approaching Arques. On the corner is a mini strip mall with a small parking lot. Out of the corner of my eye, I see a young child, maybe 4 years old, running around that parking lot being chased by his mother or caretaker.
Now, being well off the road and out of its universe of conditions that would be considered by an AI, he would be ignored. But I just knew, somehow, that this was trouble.
The kid, thinking this is a fun, impromptu chase game, then sprints directly into traffic right in front of me. I stop with a foot to spare.
Edge conditions: it's what's for dinner. (tm)
A human could see a group of kids looking in the direction of the street at someone occluded from view and realize the possiblity of a child dashing out onto the street well in advance. The self-driving car would have to detect, classify and react after the child comes into view. It is this kind of common sense AI that we cannot engineer our way out.
A couple days ago there was a viral post about how self-driving cars react to a 35 mph sign vandalized to look like 85 mph. A human would know that the sign is wrong - the self driving car would need this 'use case' programmed in - maybe have location based speed limits programmed in.
Reading the article:
> ‘It is worth noting that this is seemingly only possible on the first implementation of TACC when the driver double taps the lever, engaging TACC.’
It isn't a strict self driving situation, but makes for great click bait. I can't imagine that this isn't an easy fix (Tesla's are also easy to update collectively via software update, try doing that to human beings).
We should also be very clear that 88% success rate given for object detection and identification is against a relatively fixed set of static images[1]. And as far as I can tell from the paper[2], there's no indication of how long it takes to come to a conclusion on any single image, and no description of how much hardware was used to reach this rate of success, which to be honest, I'm surprised is so low.
Given all of that, it does not seem reasonable to assume that this 88% success rate has anything to do with how well object detection works in real-time using on-board computing power while the car is in motion. So, don't start planning to throw out your driver's license anytime soon.
[0] https://paperswithcode.com/sota/image-classification-on-imag... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ImageNet [2] https://paperswithcode.com/paper/self-training-with-noisy-st...
The best strategy for a resolution isn't to be accommodating. It's to physically shift your entire body to one side and make no eye contact to make it absolutely clear to the other person which side of them you'll be walking on.
And don't even get me started on the "automatic" windshield wipers.
Slowing down is also the best option for a tire tread or a shopping bag. The bag being less safe than you imply if it is filled with a box of nails or happens to wrap around a driveshaft or exhaust manifold.
Too many people my age and older will be apprehensive about giving up control, despite it likely being safer. So I think it is fair to say that in 20 years there will be many people who learned to "drive" with a self driving car and their parents and grandparents will refuse to give up driving themselves.
Once proven safe (or if a manufacturer directly insures the product) the cost to adequately insure a vehicle (as prices of what you hit continue to increase), especially an older vehicle, will increase. With income inequality where it is (and state minimums lagging) it has already become common to have underinsured drivers (and the upper middle class are already paying more through uninsured motorist protection).
When it comes to police enforcement, but especially jurisdictions that use traffic stops to find or create crime to fundraise; the expense of having traffic police in a world where > 50% of cars can do no wrong flips the model.
Finally, there is a large group of people who will not drive a car that's 7 years old or has over 100k miles; combining with less trained ability to do maintenance on more computerized cars. These people claim to be in control, but at one check engine light away from doing whatever a dealer tells them.
There's nothing wrong with driving a newer car and relying on the dealer service. Sure it's expensive, but if you can afford it then so what.
Maintenance needs in any modern car mostly comes back to value engineering. It's literally someone's job to optimize "how cheaply can we make this part, that it breaks just often enough that people won't complain".
The exact same thing is already happening for electric cars, and you'll need to spend exactly the same amount of time and money on service.
Furthermore, almost none of the service on a modern car is related to the combustion engine itself. It's mainly electronics, linkages, wheel beqrings, shocks, suspension, rust damage, tires etc.
If you think about it, a car that's done 200 000 miles at EOL has only been running for around 200 days continuously. A generator, or the engine on a ship, train, airplane etc. runs more than a full order of magnitude longer.
In my case, the “myth” very much matches my experience.
Seems obvious to me that the people who are economically forced by insurance rates into self-driving cars first would be the worst drivers. That means arithmetically that the remaining drivers will be better than average. So the rates for everybody should go down.
Or, another example, a big parking lot with a few buses, people unloading their stuff from the buses (let's at the end of a long trip), relatives/parents/friends pick them up at the parking lot. Relatively dense, many people moving, but still cars come and go. Plus a lot of packs/luggage here and there. Usually in these cases more cars want to enter the parking lot to pick up others, but of course people want to continue unloading, so some kind of balance forms.
What happens if the user is drunk? Well, naturally, the cop tells the car that it's a cop and just pick a different route.
And we shall see how well it will work.
Probably it'll take a (few?) decade(s) before a self-driving car should think it can safely wade through a crowd instead of going back and finding a good place to wait for user input :)
They’ve been peddling that these Level 5 Waymo cars were just around the corner. But they refused to disclose how the cars actually worked, and kept saying that their black box is so mysterious, that their scientists themselves couldn’t understand it, so there was no point in having the rest of us, mere mortals, try to understand it. Lies.
We are a long ways away from being able to trust a robotic car with our lives.
But to their credit, at least they realize that requiring a human to take over vehicle controls in a microsecond, is unrealistic. Ahem! Looking at another car company that thinks this is acceptable.
Objectively though they have started performing rides with no drivers in AZ.
https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/9/21000085/waymo-fully-driv...
They're very jerky at intersections where there's even a mild amount of uncertainty and really only go when it's very clear. It reminds me of lots of first time drivers reacting to new situations where safe is the best way forward. But if we had pure first time drivers, we'd be a gridlock at even a mild amount of traffic that enters and leaves the roadway.
Looking forward to this next set of 5 years. Hopefully us drivers will get replaced in 10? maybe?