News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by jacquesm on Thursday February 20, 2020 @08:42AM (#22374976)
I actually prefer the Waymo approach over the Tesla and Uber approach. When there are lives on the line you simply do not cross certain lines and in the longer term Waymo will be the only player left whose reputation is still in one piece. That more than anything will decide whether self driving vehicles gain long term acceptance. Anything else will lead to a 'self driving winter'.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by mikejb on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:20AM (#22375207)
Interestingly enough, Waymo (back than Chauffeur) attempted the Tesla approach - and threw it out once they saw how people behave when the car "drives itself*".

W.r.t."self driving winter", I think Waymo are aiming to protecting themselves from that situation by developing close relationships with regulators, highlighting the "we're not them"-part and sticking to their safety-first approach.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by deegles on Thursday February 20, 2020 @10:01AM (#22375492)
My fear is that Tesla and Uber playing fast and loose with their development will lead to Waymo getting regulated as collateral damage.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by jacquesm on Thursday February 20, 2020 @10:12AM (#22375569)
Yes, that could indeed happen. But Waymo will likely be able to comply with such regulation whereas Tesla and Uber never will. The parties hurt hardest are those that would have played nice but that get nipped in the bud by the regulations before they are large enough to comply. So Waymo would benefit.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by ajross on Thursday February 20, 2020 @02:45PM (#22377922)
Tesla's getting enough hours under control at this point that they're likely to win the regulation battle for Uber simply by virtue of statistics, though. Obviously there has been the occasional tragedy (and there no doubt will be more), but the point where they launch the "Autopilot is provably safer than humans!" press release isn't too far out at this point.

Again, the measuring stick is real drivers. And real drivers are really bad at this stuff too.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by jacquesm on Thursday February 20, 2020 @03:11PM (#22378123)
That press release was sent out more than a year ago and it is about as fallacious as it gets and I'm surprised the whole thing keeps getting airtime.

For the comparison to hold you need to do the following:

- discount all the hours when humans are in adverse conditions and autopilot is not normally engaged

- remove motorcycles and other vehicles from the pool

After you do that Tesla is still much less safe than your average driver. Their whole spiel of taking the easy 80% in miles of driving and claiming victory has been debunked so often now it is getting boring. It's the remaining 20% where the fatalities are and which - coincidentally - are the hard bits.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by threatofrain on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:10AM (#22375140)
I’m not sure what brightlines exist in society for when lives are on the line. Lives are already on the line for human driving, so what is the moral story one would extract from the big picture of how people relate to driving today?

The only story I see is politics and complexity, as opposed to moral clarity.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by jacquesm on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:27AM (#22375261)
It's quite simple, actually: a self driving vehicle should be a monotonous improvement on non-self driving. In other words, all situations that are currently handled by regular drivers should be handled just as well or better for self driving to be socially acceptable. A statistical argument based on a reduction of overall fatalities including a number of new kinds of accidents will not be accepted.

People (and the media) are going to focus on the accidents that would not have happened if self driving did not exist.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by henrikschroder on Thursday February 20, 2020 @04:20PM (#22378744)
The problem is that we might not ever get to monotonous improvement. We can probably easily get to a state where self-driving would decrease the number of traffic injuries and fatalities in total compared to human drivers.

But machines make different mistakes, mistakes that humans would never do, and that's psychologically not acceptable to most people. All the actual accidents will be "freak" accidents that a human could never cause, and that scares people a lot more than "human" accidents like a drunk driver running someone over at a pedestrian crossing.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by jacquesm on Thursday February 20, 2020 @04:27PM (#22378802)
Yes, you got it perfectly. That's exactly my fear. And Tesla isn't helping with their marketing because they suggest we are further than we really are.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by coding123 on Thursday February 20, 2020 @08:28PM (#22380247)
That's exactly it.

If I get killed by a drunk driver, my wife will at least have someone to rage at.

If I get killed because my car randomly decides to drive itself into a high up truck and I basically died because of stupid technology. I would hope that it doesn't end up killing my wife too out of rage that she's going up against a major corporation now.

That's kind of maddening.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by AareyBaba on Thursday February 20, 2020 @07:14PM (#22379868)
Exactly. Accelerating and crashing into a barrier a human would easily avoid is not acceptable. https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2020/02/13/ntsb-r...

It psychologically like being a passenger in a car with a good driver who has a history of epileptic seizures.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by craftinator on Thursday February 20, 2020 @08:56PM (#22380351)
Strange, because there are a LARGE number of driving fatalities caused by this exact behavior every year. The common explanations are: driver dozing or falling asleep, unexpected curve with poor visibility, driver mistaking the shoulder for another lane, and driver striking median to exit ramp by misjudging a lane change. Humans do all of these things, on a daily basis. So by human standards, accelerating and crashing into a barrier is quite commonplace.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by timerol on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:47AM (#22375402)
The problem with your statement is that some people view handling a situation better as getting more cars through a bottleneck in a certain amount of time, and other people view better as making sure that all humans in the area stay safe.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by jacquesm on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:57AM (#22375451)
PR will never be about throughput but it will always be about safety. You'll never read 'due to Tesla's self driving abilities we can now push 3% more cars across the bridge'. What you will read (on page one, complete with 'shocking' picture) is 'Self driving Tesla crashes into bridge support'.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by Piskvorrr on Thursday February 20, 2020 @01:49PM (#22377513)
Which might mean that we are going to demand a safety level that's unattainable without decreasing throughput. In other words, human driving might be risky, but it's familiar, which apparently makes it tolerable.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by amelius on Thursday February 20, 2020 @06:09PM (#22379473)
> A statistical argument based on a reduction of overall fatalities including a number of new kinds of accidents will not be accepted.

I think what would be accepted is if the self-driving car would have capabilities that surpass the best human driver (as opposed to the "average" driver). But we're a long way from that.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by ph0rque on Thursday February 20, 2020 @07:49PM (#22380060)
That makes me wonder: who is verifiably the best human driver? I recall reading about a truck driver who went over a million miles without being in an accident. Probably someone like that?
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by amelius on Friday February 21, 2020 @05:49AM (#22382248)
Yes, difficult to answer, so I wasn't thinking of an actual person (similarly to how the average driver doesn't exist as a person). If you want to imagine someone, then perhaps the person who drives the president?
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by Piskvorrr on Friday February 21, 2020 @06:18AM (#22382360)
That's a very different skillset from a normal driver; in fact, I think that in driving The Beast aka Stagecoach, road safety is an afterthought to a host of tactical considerations: the goal not being "safe driving", but "keep the President safe, to the exclusion of anything else." With 4 MPG, this is a plainclothes APC, not a normal car ;) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presidential_state_car_(United...
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by snowwrestler on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:50AM (#22375413)
> a self driving vehicle should be a monotonous improvement on non-self driving. In other words, all situations that are currently handled by regular drivers should be handled just as well or better for self driving to be socially acceptable.

I agree with this but I think it implies that people also will not accept safe self-driving cars that take forever to get anywhere in traffic. Especially since a decline in average traffic throughput makes things worse for everyone in a car, self-driving or not.

I think this makes the problem much harder, since a lot of people do demonstrably take risks in their driving now, in the interest of saving time (even knowing intellectually that lives are on the line).

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by sokoloff on Thursday February 20, 2020 @07:33PM (#22379967)
If you slowed everyone’s traffic by 25%, how many human lives are wasted (though not ended) per year?

If you assume people drive 10K per year at an average speed of 33 mph, you’re driving ~300 hours per year. Slow that by 25% and it’s an extra 100 hours per year. If you assume 7.5 hours of sleep, you’d spend an extra 1.6% of your waking life in a car because of the slowdown. That’s killing a lot of time, even if not directly killing people.

Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by Piskvorrr on Thursday February 20, 2020 @01:51PM (#22377525)
Or, in the more optimistic case, SDV will come to areas where top speed is not a priority - think "bulk cargo".
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by henrikschroder on Thursday February 20, 2020 @04:21PM (#22378755)
Yeah, the place where self-driving will make the biggest impact first, is for long-haul truck driving.
Re:The Next Leap in Self-Driving: Prediction by Shivetya on Thursday February 20, 2020 @06:23PM (#22379565)
since I let my Tesla 3 drive I have to say, what is out in public is damn shy about what it does and will slow down for curves and the traffic aware cruise control seems to have a second sense. On the open highway if you are navigating on autopilot you can let it change lanes on its own but I still like to control that because I think it doesn't do it as soon as it should; I usually use the must confirm mode. It does react well to people who cut in and my car has dodged someone merging into my lane. Going to be interesting if there is any change to driving when the computer gets upgraded next week.

frankly I don't think any of the teams who have demos are as close as they hint they are. there are just so many exceptions that it becomes maddening.

look, people road rage over the driving habits of others and the computer while it won't road rage has to react to those who infuriate others with their driving either because its reckless or just bad driving

some of my favorite conditions....

people stopping to let you out, how does the car know? people going out of order at an intersection?

* I do not let it drive where I think the situations are complex and obviously it does not have the ability to respond to traffic signals or make turns at intersections.