News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by anonymousab on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:44AM (#21947553)
>Sure, but I don't see a good alternative

Allow users to votekick and voteban. Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

These are tools and approaches that we had in past games and while they are not perfect, they are better than these black box invasive anticheat solutions born from a desire to avoid giving community control to users.

>Sacrificing a small percent of your playerbase in the name of having a functioning online system at all seems like a reasonable solution to me

Only if you provide a robust and empowered support staff to quickly unban and resolve false positives. That is, actually take responsibility, which is something game developers and major publishers seem allergic to.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:37PM (#21948191)
Seems to me the shift to "Matchmaking" style online multiplayer has caused a whole lot of problems that weren't that big a deal back in the "community server" days. I personally think one can blame the rampant toxicity of players on this removal of the community aspect.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Saturday January 04, 2020 @01:57AM (#21953374)
> I personally think one can blame the rampant toxicity of players on this removal of the community aspect.

I think this happens way more than people realize. A great example is League of Legends, which is known for its toxic community.

They throw you in a game with 4 other people. If 1 of them decides to be an asshole you're stuck for a minimum of 20 minutes + the 10 it took for queue + lobby. So you're FORCED to stay in this game for 30 minutes because you got an asshole teammate.

Imagine playing a game of pickup basketball where one of your teammates started scoring for the other team and you were forced to continue playing the game out rather than simply leaving. Of course your community is frustrated.

And the response anytime people ask for changes to help with the situation is that they can't because someone might abuse it to save their rank.

If it were me, I'd create a system where you get free games and treat it like a currency. If someone is being an asshole, just turn in your token, you leave the game unpunished and you get to flag the player(s) that caused you to do it.

I stopped playing the game because of the completely lack of control over your own destiny.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by SerLava on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:11AM (#21954023)
>If it were me, I'd create a system where you get free games and treat it like a currency. If someone is being an asshole, just turn in your token, you leave the game unpunished and you get to flag the player(s) that caused you to do it.

The issue there is that the game has 10 players in it.

Say you have only 3 "leave" tokens per month. That's small and will probably only slightly address the issue.

If the average player plays 30 games a month, they can leave up to 10% of their games.

And if someone uses this "leave" token, can you really punish the other players for not wanting to play a broken match? You can't require them to burn their own leave token. So it's one leave token, and everyone can leave.

If 10 players leave 10% of their games... then on average, there's one missing person per game. And most of those games will simply end.

Then, when you have 5 losing players, they have 15 tokens between them per month. With 30 games a month, your players can leave very roughly half the games.

Matchmaking aims for 50/50 win/lose.

You could literally just leave every losing game. And the other team would do this if you were winning.

You would only really get a few serious games toward the end of the month when all 5 or 10 people happen to run out of coins.

This system would actually probably just make people scream death threats at their own teammates for doing too well because the only proper way to win a game would be to eke it out at the last second.

In other words, the toxicity is built in to MOBA gameplay inherently and can only be suppressed.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:37AM (#21955071)
Actually, you just went into detail explaining why it's a good idea.

In chess you'll see one player or the other reach over and lay their king over. It's an admission that, while the game isn't technically done, it's unwinnnable. So out of respect for time they simply acknowledge the loss and move on.

If, as you say, most losses see someone use a token, great! That's the point. They use the token, everyone leaves the game. It's done. The winners win, the losers lose.

Now imagine that you're playing and you're winning, but you're an asshole because you're smurfing. One of your teammates tosses out his token, you lose. Now also imagine this keeps happening because you're an asshole. It incentivizes you to stop being an asshole.

Imagine you're playing and 10 minutes in one of your teammates disconnects. Lets assume they're in a storm and the electricity went out. at minute 12, you use your token and move on. You weren't forced to play out a 30-40 minute game. You just moved on.

Imagine that game where your team is literally dying once/minute at minute ten. You just use your token and move on.

---

The only real counter-argument to this is that it might affect people's ranks. People will have losses they may have otherwise won. Or wins that they might otherwise have lost.

This is true.

Do you know what else is true?

The game is riddled with smurfs. People will win or lose games by just being matched with a smurf. The game has autofill. For those not aware, autofill means the game forces you to play a position you don't normally play. People will win or lose games due to nothing more than an algorithm making a decision. The game has streamers who specialize in "bronze to challenger" streams. The people in those games will win or lose due to nothing more than matchmaking.

These are all basically random chance, and what they do is make the error in the ELO system larger. Riot enforces autofill in the interests of short queues. It explicitly allows smurfs and streamers in the interests of marketing.

So Riot has already accepted the random wins and losses.

The question is, can we do it in a way that decreases player tension. The answer is yes.

This isn't about creating a perfect system. This is about the fact that the game currently has a ton of variability from imperfections due to Riot making compromises. The question is how can do it while giving the players more agency over themselves?

And I haven't even spoken about how BAD riot's matchmaking is. It's seriously bad.

I remember a game I had where I was forced bot lane by myself because my support never connected. For those not familiar with the game, this means I was playing in a 1v2.

And I got huge. I took over the game. And not because the opponents went diving under my turret (note: turrets will damage the opponent), but because I just straight up punished them for positioning mistakes and killed them. I legitimately pulled a double kill with first blood in a 1v2 with no jungler help.

In postgame chat, someone on the other team asked me if I was a smurf. Technically no, but I sure as hell was smurfing in that game. Riot's matchmaking should NEVER have placed me in that game.

The fact that it does adds even MORE variability. It gives more random wins and losses to players. It increases the error rate of ELO in the game.

The community has a common sentiment: 80% of the games you play you have no agency in whether you win or lose. You just have to accept it and move on. But 20% of the games you do have an effect and to climb you need to be more consistent so that you're winning in that 20%.

The point is this: The issues of uncontrolled wins and losses already exist in the current system. It's just you're also forced to stay in a game for another 20-30 minutes, and that just increases everyones frustration.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by SerLava on Thursday January 09, 2020 @05:01AM (#21999892)
>he only real counter-argument to this is that it might affect people's ranks.

No. The difference between chess and and MOBA is it's 1v1 instead of 5v5.

The counter argument I'm implying here is that nearly every game would go like this:

-Game start

-Lane phase begins

-Top laner dies at level 2

-Top laner tries to get revenge at level 3, dies again.

-Top laner unilaterally spends the token to jump into another game. It's game over. You spent 15 minutes getting a game together, and 5 minutes loading the game, and 3 minutes for the boring part of gameplay to start, so that you could experience 2 minutes of the boring part of gameplay. That will be every game. It's already a decent amount of games with the punishment.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by nkrisc on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:11PM (#21948611)
I have to agree. There were good alternative approaches. For example, I used to play Battlefield 1942 a lot when it was current. A lot of the larger communities had public servers, but also private servers that only people who the mods got to know would be whitelisted for. In the more well-run communities, the mods would hang out and spend some time on the public server to keep order, or were at least accessible (via TeamSpeak, often) if they weren't actively on it.

Cheaters quickly got banned from the public servers and people who stuck with the community could enjoy the private server where they knew there'd be a good group of people and usually very little toxicity.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by CodeWriter23 on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:20PM (#21949900)
I made some really good friends playing 1942. Guys I met up with IRL, in other states even. The only probs we had were the “defeat the ceiling by flying upside down” pilots and trash talking with other clans could get a little spammy. The rivalry was welcome though and we mostly resolved it by kicking ass on various ladders. And occasionally getting our asses handed to us. WoW coming along and deflating our numbers made me sad.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by nkrisc on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:43PM (#21951884)
Funny, it was the launch of WoW that got me to stop playing. A bunch of the folks I played with made a guild and left bf behind mostly.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Mirioron on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:13AM (#21953433)
The problem is that there's a huge skill difference in games like League of Legends. Matchmaking has made some players improve so much that if you throw them into community servers then other (weaker) players end up not having fun. This is less of a problem in a shooter, because there are no real penalties for dying (other than score), but in a game like LoL it quickly snowballs out of control.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by debaserab2 on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:29PM (#21950574)
I see what you mean but I do think in some ways the community servers also insulate and protect a lot of that toxicity and even allow it to be amplified. Being a new player and joining the "wrong" community server can be a pretty toxic experience.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Nasrudith on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:06PM (#21948553)
There were plenty of toxic jerks online period with community lobbies. Although if you found a good server or set of them it mitigated the exposure. A big difference experience wise but the underlying problem was the same.

Ranked Ladder, PUG Teams, PVP, and especially "griefing mechanics" related to losses for the loser from the stakes can all cumulatively contribute to toxicity.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by baby on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:22PM (#21951796)
I can tell you that there were a huge number of cheaters back in the days as well.

The bigger problem now are f2p games were cheaters don’t have to re purchase a game after getting banned.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:08PM (#21949201)
My hot-take as a smaller game designer is that I am skeptical that global competitive ladders are good design. I admit that's fringe, and I'm not going to fight people over it. But I can't imagine myself ever designing a system like that for any of my games.

First, I think these systems ignore technical realities, and design has to pay attention to real-world constraints. Blocking cheaters is insanely hard, and almost no real-time games that I know of do it at what I believe is an acceptable level.

It's a nice idea that I don't think is technically supported, in the same way that it would be a nice idea if my photorealistic MMO didn't have loading screens anywhere and loaded everything instantly. It's not good design to spend a bunch of effort hinging your game design on something that's not technically possible for you to do.

Second, I think these systems ignore player incentives. I think that global competitive ranking encourages the worst of playerbases, that skill is an arbitrary mechanism to optimize on instead of something like how close each match was, or player-reported satisfaction levels, or variety of play-styles, or any other of a dozen other metrics.

Third, caring about bots radically shrinks your design space. You can't have exploits, players have to have a "right" way to play, modding has to be more limited. It shrinks the game not only in the sense that it makes your systems more complicated -- it fundamentally shrinks what your game can do as a game, and how your game can evolve with the rest of the medium.

Finally, not only is skill not a particularly rewarding metric to optimize on when what you really want is for your players to have fun, most of the problems with automation explicitly only are a problem for competitive matchmaking. If you're optimizing for player-reported satisfaction, you probably don't care if people are botting your game, because successful bots will be optimizing for creating good matches instead of for just winning[0].

Personal plug, with my current project, Loop Thesis, LAN play is the only multiplayer. I only want people to play with friends, and I'm not trying to build some kind of community or network. That decision has simplified my architecture so much, the game is so much more modder friendly, the networking code is so much simpler, everything is nicer, and more stable, and more player friendly, because I don't have to care about bots and cheaters.

Future games that I make, even if they include global matchmaking, will not have global competitive rankings. My personal take now has become that 90% of the time these systems are a design antipattern.

It's counterproductive. I want players playing my game to have fun. I have to ban bots because they make the game not fun. The reason the bots make the game not fun is because all of my design hinges fun on giving players an optimization problem that I explicitly don't want them to solve in creative ways. The bots are solving the optimization problem too well. So getting rid of that optimization problem, getting rid of the rankings, makes so many other design/engineering problems go away. The bots aren't the problem, the optimization problem is the problem.

[0]: https://xkcd.com/810/

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:36PM (#21950044)
I agree with you wholeheartedly. I played countless hours of the first destiny. I loved exploiting all the glitches and finding new ones. The pvp was chaotic and random. Some matches I topfragged, others bottom.

I've tried going back to destiny several times over the past few years. It's too clinical. The good glitches get overnight patches. The bad ones last forever. The pvp is a non-stop sweat fest of me getting killed over and over and over and over. It just stopped being fun.

I game to escape the mundane reality of my relatively poor lot in American life. As soon as I start feeling that way when playing a game it's all over. I haven't found a game since the original destiny that gives me that escape. Games like pubg, fortnite, csgo, cod, battlefield, halo, all feel the same to me. I don't like most indie games, or 3ps, and don't have the time for games like ksp, factorial, civ and can't get immersed in single player games anymore. So my options are limited. It's been good though. With virtually no games worth investing money into a PC, console, or iaps, I've broadened my social circle and learned new skills. I imagine the market is going to swing back around to cater to the coop centered gamers when they realize that middle aged families with teenaged children or older have far more disposable income than the current demographic of school aged kids and young adults.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by AgentME on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:34PM (#21952415)
Something I've loved to prevent games from getting too clinical is when custom/modded maps are popular. It's fun when you're in a match on a custom map and gametype that no one has seen before and everyone is on a level playing field of trying to figure it out as they go. Halo has been one of my long-time favorites for enabling this sort of thing.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by rs23296008n1 on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:44PM (#21951887)
Been there. We just load up an old copy of openarena on our server and as a group play that. Simple FPS you can jump in and out of.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by notSupplied on Saturday January 04, 2020 @08:18PM (#21958915)
"The pvp is a non-stop sweat fest of me getting killed over and over and over and over"

Isn't this an argument for skill-based matchmaking rather than against it? (Since the OP whom you agree with makes a case against optimizing for SBMM, I presume you're also against it)

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:05AM (#21978556)
Before sbmm matches had a wider range of results for me. Last I played, with sbmm, matches were consistently average.

In other words. I love the idea, and the feel of overwatch which uses sbmm. However the game stacks teams to make matches frustrating.

Some games I'll be the highest rated player on the team and have an amazing game. Despite playing better than my average I will still lose skill rank points if my team loses. Conversely, I can spin in spawn for an entire match, get carried to a win and gain points. By naively averaging team vs team the fun is taken out of the game because too many factors are ignored when averaging leading to exploitable metrics. Exploitable metrics left unchecked causes a games community to splinter, shrink, and grow toxic as more players get frustrated and quit leaving behind a less savory group.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by selimthegrim on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:17PM (#21951360)
Space Station 13?
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by drivebycomment on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:35PM (#21950043)
League of Legends doesn't seem to suffer from bots - if you don't want to believe me, check out https://www.reddit.com/r/leagueoflegends/comments/eieyz2/why... , and their regional rank system works well enough and not only useful and provide good values to the players, it is absolutely necessary at higher ranks.

Likewise, AFAIK, dota2 doesn't seem to suffer much from bots, and their rank system seems to work ok.

Arguably Fortnite / Overwatch / PUBG style games do suffer from aimbots, but whatever downside they bring, those games seem wildly successful. And the regional / global ranking system seems integral to their success.

Given that a large number of highly successful games do have it, I don't think your argument has much of a merit - it's surely a challenge to implement them but it seems like a worthwhile problem to solve, rather than avoid, at least if your goal includes global / regional success beyond small niche.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:30PM (#21950579)
Not going to argue get into an argument on this, but I believe a large portion of both League and Dota's widespread community toxicity problems have their roots in the global ranking systems that they use. I also think that their ranking systems make them much, much less accessible to new players, and encourage their existing playerbase to experiment less.

To the extent that some games can legitimately get away with global competitive ranks without suffering bots, that doesn't mean it's a healthy choice for every (or even most) other games. Of course, no design rule is absolute, we're just speaking in generalities.

That being said, both League and Dota are investing massive resources to prevent botting on a system that arguably would be just as if not more enjoyable if it was redesigned. I feel the same way about games like Overwatch, even some inherently globalized systems like Pokemon Go that would be difficult to change -- I don't personally believe the ranking systems are making them better. I think they're there because they're expected to be there, not because they're reinforcing the core design of the game.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by munmaek on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:43AM (#21953540)
This is wildly offbase.

The toxicity, for the most part, doesn’t come from ranks. It comes from being stuck in a bad game for 20-60 minutes. Competition just exacerbates it because now ranks/points/money are on the line.

I’m talking about being stuck with an asshole that rages for any number of reasons, then decides to kill themselves the whole game to the enemy (feeding). Or people who flame you for any number of reasons. And you can’t quit because then you get a strike for being the first person to abandon the game, with penalties for doing it more than a few times.

Being 1 person down in a 5v5 can be incredibly hard to come back against. This is also why Overwatch is so incredibly toxic. A 5v6 fight is almost unwinnable, one person throwing is enough to lose the match. Dota handles this with comeback mechanics, but that’s only if a player actually disconnects/abandons. If they stay in the game purposefully throwing, you’re trapped and out of luck. Unlike Overwatch, TF2 isn’t quite as toxic because matches consist of 24 or 32 players, meaning each person’s actions aren’t as crucial as a 5v5. You can also freely leave and join casual matches. For the majority of the playerbase, that’s fine. Ranked introduces a bit of toxicity but that’s unavoidable in a team game. It’s also unavoidable whenever you have anything at stake- whether it’s money or points, etc. That’s just the nature of competition. No one forces anyone to play ranked matches instead of casual ones.

Competitive ranks and matchmaking can be fun, but you have to balance it right. With team games it’s very difficult, but it would be the same without a global rank system. Actually it would be worse because of imbalanced matchmaking.

And for many people, that rank is -why- they play. It’s fine to not be competitive like that, but understand that a lot of people are indeed competitive like that. Ranks are an indicator of skill and time invested, and there’s no reason to take that away from people just because one personally doesn’t care for ranked or whatever. Dota still has casual mode, and it’s still toxic, because of the length of the matches and having to rely on random teammates.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Mirioron on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:24AM (#21953464)
The game wouldn't work without a ranking system. At least you can't go from a matchmaking system back to one without, because there's a segment of the player base that is so good that if you throw them together with the average player then the average player won't have much fun. Games like LoL and Dota snowball too hard for it to be fun to lose at every stage of the game. It also wouldn't be much fun for the good player, because they won't face a challenge.

Also, I have some severe doubts about the origin of toxicity in that game being in the matchmaking system. Dota was the game where you were abused as a noob when you started out ("welcome to dota, you suck"). It's a niche game from 2003 after all.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by nwallin on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:42PM (#21952730)
If you think DotA2's matchmaking is unfriendly to new players, I don't think you ever experienced DotA1 matches. Every single game was wildly unbalanced, and as a result of one or so players, every single game was an absolute stomp where the losing team never had a chance.

The skill gap between good and bad players is ludicrous. It's like putting LeBron James against middle schoolers. There simply isn't a fun game when the game is determined by the singular best player, and the other nine players are being carried to victory regardless of their contribution, or being pounded into the dirt because they're less than exceptional.

I could never go back to random matchmaking after experiencing global rankings.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:57PM (#21952787)
Of course, using a bad metric is often better than using no metric at all, but it doesn't follow that the current strategy is optimal.

It especially doesn't follow that global rankings should be a user-visible metric, or an explicit player motivator (a la seasonal rankings). People don't bot because they're unhappy with the players they're matched against. They bot because they want a publicly visible number to get bigger and because player rewards are locked behind competitive rankings.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Mirioron on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:27AM (#21953486)
But there are no bots available that can play the game for you competently. Even deepmind had to have quite a few restrictions to do so and such a system most likely can't even learn an evolving metagame.

People who join ranked want to compete. If you don't want to then there is another queue available that's not a public ranking.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Saturday January 04, 2020 @12:01PM (#21955936)
> But there are no bots available that can play the game for you competently.

Then who cares whether or not players bot? Let them. Heck, go all the way and actively support it if it's not an issue.

On the design side, I'm seeing a number of people commenting on here that getting rid of a publicly-facing global ladder would mean that these games couldn't be competitive. I don't believe that's true. We have wildly competitive games in the physical space that don't use global ladders, and they don't suffer for it.

Global ladders are a very specific, very narrow mechanic -- they have some advantages for competitive play, and a whole lot of downsides. And we have options. At the very least, even if we do nothing else, we can shrink the size and make them regional. Or because things are digital we can throw out geography entirely and base them off clans.

Competition in small groups is often preferable to competition in large groups anyway, since that can foster rivalries, and because repeat matchups between competitive players are usually more interesting than random ones.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:27AM (#21953480)
leagues toxicity has its roots in them not allowing players control over themselves. You can get stuck in a game with an asshole and they force you to play it out. That would put anyone in a shitty mood, and is why I stopped playing the game.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by discreditable on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:15PM (#21951351)
> League of Legends doesn't seem to suffer from bots

Depends on where you look. I used to see them a lot in certain game modes and when playing with friends that were new. As one commenter put it:

> To play devil's advocate here -- If you were to play summoner's rift AI games, ARAM, or even some summoner's rift on a sub-30 account late night EST you will be DROWNING in bots. They are EVERYWHERE. They also go almost entirely unpunished. You can track their summoner ID's through OPGG and watch them play the same champion 24 hours a day until 30, change name, and swap champions entirely.

> I tried to get some friends to come to league, and they all quit because their teammates were AI every single time. Not "lul ur bad r u a bot??" but a literal bot grinding exp to sell level 30 accounts. Sure, scripting Xeraths/Cassio's are much more rare -- but League has a huge bot problem sub-30.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Icathian on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:21PM (#21950995)
See, this is just absolutely true. When 7 or so of the top 10 most successful games of the last decade all share features like global matchmaking, you can't tell me those features bring more trouble than value. I agree there are hard challenges there, maybe ones that cannot be solved perfectly, but for success at that scale they are clearly worth attempting.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:35PM (#21951074)
7 of the 10 most successful games of the last decade listed here also offer in-app purchases.

I don't ignore success -- Overwatch, League, Dota, and Fortnite are all objectively well-designed games. But that doesn't mean that every decision they make is good design. If success was the only metric I used to judge design quality, I would have to conclude that Farmville was a better game than Hollow Knight.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by drivebycomment on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:50PM (#21951601)
I do agree Hollow Knight is a so much better game than Farmville (and most games, for that matter).

But in this case, global/regional matchmaking is an essential part of those successful games and their game experience (unlike in-app purchases which are essential for moneymaking but not essential for game play experience). If those games didn't have regional matchmaking, they would provide very different experience.

You keep saying you believe the global matchmaking is not important, but I'm afraid you have presented no coherent argument or evidence so far - hence it looks like you're simply ignoring the reality unfortunately. Given how much core part of the experience the global matchmaking is for those games, the onus is on you to prove the otherwise. So we'll likely have to agree to disagree.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by VRay on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:54PM (#21951195)
Those online competitive team games are pretty unfriendly, though. If you try something new or fail to keep up with the latest flavor-of-the-month playstyle, people will flip out on you. You're suddenly preventing this guy from realizing his life goals of climbing to the top of the ladder and becoming a world-renowned player.

I love MOBAs, but I can't bring myself to try out LoL or DotA2 again since I don't want to deal with angry teammates

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by jfim on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:24AM (#21953468)
> I love MOBAs, but I can't bring myself to try out LoL or DotA2 again since I don't want to deal with angry teammates

I don't know about lol, but DotA 2 has a setting to mute all chat, so you're just playing with quiet teammates. They can still ping the map and use the chat wheel, but that stops pretty much all the chat abuse, especially if you're stuck with a 4 stack that picks on the lone player.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by MereInterest on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:49PM (#21951587)
Value to the company is not necessarily value to the players.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by dylz on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:41PM (#21951528)
They've shut down entire game modes PACKED full of bots.

Low level ARAM and TT you would often have out of 10 players, 1 = you, 9 = leveling afk bots that run around to prevent auto-kick.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by stefan_ on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:19PM (#21952063)
What improvement can a cheat offer a League of Legends player?
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Banditoz on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:36PM (#21952426)
I think the big one right now is dodging skillshots, or having the cheat make skillshots for you.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by naniwaduni on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:29PM (#21951833)
> Second, I think these systems ignore player incentives. I think that global competitive ranking encourages the worst of playerbases, that skill is an arbitrary mechanism to optimize on instead of something like how close each match was, or player-reported satisfaction levels, or variety of play-styles, or any other of a dozen other metrics.

I think you're totally missing the point. Computing a global competitive rating isn't intended to optimize for skill. Rating is a proxy for skill, sure, but generally it's being used in matchmaking because (a) rating gap is a not-completely-terrible proxy for closeness of matches (because skill gap is a decent proxy for closeness of matches), which contributes to player satisfaction, and (b) you can derive it from easy-to-measure data and while there are fiddly details, everyone is roughly on the same page as to what you're trying to approximate.

It happens that, once you compute that, it's really tempting to sort and report. Perhaps that's a mistake and invites the worst of people's instincts to make numbers go more and bigger.

This still has the constraint that all the players are playing the same game, but as long as you can somehow avoid ascribing value to rank placement then many forms of cheating just stop mattering; the cheaters self-sort themselves into a tier where they don't interact with anyone who can't deal with them.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:32PM (#21952133)
I think my argument there would be that despite common assumptions, rating is actually a very poor proxy for skill, and an even worse proxy for a good match-up. Similarly skilled players won't always like to play with each other. Nor do I think that win-percentages are the only metric we have to work with -- most multiplayer games have reams of much better data to sort through, particularly in games with high variability of play-styles, player types, and team compositions and setups (games like League/Hearthstone/Overwatch, etc...)

That being said, I would be more amiable to a system that used player skill as a matchmaking tool if it didn't report those numbers to players.

However, I'm not sure I would say that sorting and reporting is usually a side effect or minor mistake on top of those systems, given that many of these games have seasons, rewards, an entire meta-game built on top of their rankings. The rankings aren't just serving the purpose of getting players matched together -- they're serving as player motivators. The responses that players have can't be seen as a purely accidental side-effect when designers are going out of their way to present this information to the player and to encourage the player to pay attention to it.

Hearthstone is a good example here. Hearthstone has brilliant design, but its ladder system is horrible and dumb. It explicitly encourages net-decking and grinding instead of experimentation. Fast decks are objectively better than slow ones with the same win percentage, because ranking is largely determined by win percentage combined with the number of games you can fit into a season.

Season rewards are then tied to rank, so the best way to get new cards if you want to experiment is to build a boring deck and grind. This is despite the fact that for most players, knowing within the first few turns whether or not they're going to win is not fun.

So of course people bot Hearthstone, because before you can build creative fun decks and play against interesting people with interesting strategies, you have to pay the "fun tax" of grinding on the ladder. Everything brilliant about Hearthstone is bogged down by being tied to this kind of toxic experience.

There's no way to say this about such a popular game without sounding naive, and I'll take the criticism, but I do not believe for one second it would be difficult to build a better public ranking system for Hearthstone, especially given the ludicrous amount of player data they have. Even something as simple as balancing rank with deck variety so players got fewer rewards the more times they played the same cards would go a huge way towards getting rid of net-decking.

These systems do increase engagement among very invested players, so maybe that's the only intention. But to heck with engagement -- is laddering at the higher ranks of Hearthstone fun? People do it, people say they enjoy it. Again, I'll take the criticism a statement like this warrants, but I don't believe them. I don't believe the experience of grinding a single 55% win-rate deck for hours and hours is an experience that is worth having or producing.

And when I think about why players do that, the only cause that comes to my mind is, "the game tells them to."

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Mirioron on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:37AM (#21953522)
>That being said, I would be more amiable to a system that used player skill as a matchmaking tool if it didn't report those numbers to players.

Almost all of these games have an "unranked" mode in matchmaking that doesn't publicly report your rank.

>Hearthstone is a good example here. Hearthstone has brilliant design, but its ladder system is horrible and dumb.

Hearthstone is probably the worst collectible card game I've ever played. The actual gameplay of it is poor and heavily RNG reliant. It's not bad if you put in an inordinate amount of hours into it, because then you'll get a feel for what the opponent likely has and how likely you are to succeed, but this is generally not something you can just easily reason about without an absolute metric ton of experience. That's why net decking is so common - it's too difficult for most players to figure out near-optimal combinations, because they don't have as full of an overview of the game as the experienced players. The search space is just too large.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Saturday January 04, 2020 @11:23AM (#21955712)
> Hearthstone is probably the worst collectible card game I've ever played.

:shrug:

I'm not going to argue about what games are good. Substitute out another online card game you like, I promise 90% of the time it will have the same problem. My experience with MTG Arena has taught me that net decking there is just as common, and I consider MTG to be a much more skill-based game than Hearthstone.

Like Hearthstone, MTG Arena has "unranked" modes, but like Hearthstone, the majority of rewards and design is meant to force you into ranked modes.

> it's too difficult for most players to figure out near-optimal combinations

Take a step back. Why do most players feel that they need to find near-optimal combinations? We have a ton of research on card-game archetypes going back over a decade. It is generally understood by every designer in the field that competitive optimizers are one player archetype of many, and often not even the largest one. But the design of our ranking systems explicitly encourages players to become competitive optimizers to the exclusion of every other archetype.

Of course, everyone wants to build good decks, but the experience of playing paper MTG with people even in semi-competitive settings is often very different than the experience of playing MTG Arena -- the "need" to optimize is on a whole new level. It's the same game, but the incentive structures of the metagame that surrounds it changes how the players act.

That's not to say that competitive players don't exist, but it is to say that in every area of card-game design, we recognize that the design space needs to be wider than that. And in our ranking systems, we don't. It's also not to say that stuff like tournaments are bad. It is to say that every online card game I have ever played suffers from these problems, and every one of them uses the same exact ranking system, and maybe the problems are related to that common element.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Mirioron on Saturday January 04, 2020 @06:44PM (#21958488)
>Like Hearthstone, MTG Arena has "unranked" modes, but like Hearthstone, the majority of rewards and design is meant to force you into ranked modes.

Is it that the game designers sat down and deliberately designed a system to get you to play more ranked or did the players demand rewards for ranked (or the designers anticipated such a reward)? I've seen the latter happen in an online game. The players in World of Warships demanded more rewards after seeing the initial competitive game mode (team battles). Eventually the developers gave it to them.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Saturday January 04, 2020 @08:52PM (#21959057)
That's very possible -- a lot of game features come out of that process.

But, I would say the responsibility of a designer is to be able to parse player feedback and disregard bad suggestions. If your players knew how to design a game, they would be game designers.

One of the big reasons design is so hard is because you're trying to understand another person's motivations better than they themselves do. Feedback shouldn't be ignored, but neither should it be implemented verbatim. Players just aren't good at sussing out their own motivations -- they'll tell you, "we want more rewards for ranked" instead of "we don't want to feel obligated to dip into unrelated game modes", or "we want to feel more like we're progressing towards something."

Players also aren't good at giving feedback about what feels wrong, their feedback instead takes the form of half-thought ideas of how to fix what feels wrong. Responding to that feedback means digging under it to find out the actual problem and addressing that specifically.

Note that this isn't just me talking. Rosewater himself has talked about this phenomenon a lot in his design blog on MTG, and he has a good quote on this[0]:

> The key is whether or not what the players want will in the end make them happy. Players ask for things all the time that if we actually gave them would make the game less enjoyable for them. We do spend a lot of time trying to understand what they players want, though, because when we are able to give players things they want, we do.

The point being, I have no doubt that if MTG Arena announced tomorrow that it was getting rid of ranked rewards and seasons, the playerbase would be livid. I still suspect an alternate system for rewards would be better in the long run.

[0]: https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/making-magic/s...

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:29AM (#21953491)
> I think my argument there would be that despite common assumptions, rating is actually a very poor proxy for skill

you can't know that without knowing the specifics of how that rating is generated.

I promise you ELO for chess is a hell of a lot more accurate than ELO for league.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Saturday January 04, 2020 @11:27AM (#21955734)
I do know how the specifics of how these rankings are calculated because they're publicly visible[0]. I'm not arguing that behind the scenes Hearthstone's matchmaking isn't sophisticated enough (although it probably isn't), I'm arguing that publicly, the public mechanisms for determining rank are really bad and encourage bad play habits.

Hearthstone ranking is not a good proxy for skill, it's a good proxy for the amount of time you have to play and the speed of your deck. Objectively, the best strategy to get good ranks at Hearthstone is to build a fast, >50% win-rate deck and then to grind. That's not a good proxy for skill.

[0]: https://hearthstone.gamepedia.com/Ranked

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Sunday January 05, 2020 @04:52AM (#21960545)
I'd love to see the details on League of Legends ranking algorithm.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Sunday January 05, 2020 @11:54AM (#21962156)
Sure!

https://dotesports.com/league-of-legends/news/league-of-lege...

> As players win games in ranked, they gain League Points, also more commonly known as LP. They also lose LP when they are defeated. Upon reaching 100 total LP in a given division, players enter a promotion series to try and get to the next available division.

> Players must win a majority of their games in order to advance to the next division. Promotion series within certain ranks, like Bronze III to II, are a best-of-three series. From one rank to the next, such as Silver I to Gold V, promotion series are best-of-five instead.

> If a player doesn’t win that amount of games, then they’ll need to get back to 100 LP to try again.

----

Yes, the exact details of how your MMR is calculated is kept secret, but it doesn't matter if you still know exactly what you need to optimize for: winning sequential games, often in chunks, and going out of your way to avoid losing streaks which can result in demotions.

Arguing that hiding the exact MMR formula means that players won't alter their behaviors to fit its approximate contours is like arguing that because Google's page-rank algorithm isn't public that SEO is not a thing.

(Some of) the consequences of this setup include:

A) losing matches becomes much more costly, which exasperates the problems League has with feeders and trolls, and lends itself to a more toxic environment.

B) Experimentation and learning new heroes is best done off of the ladder until you feel like you're competitive with that hero. Experimenting on the ladder is not only bad for your rank, it's also likely to get you reported by other teammates as a feeder (see the toxicity mentioned above).

Players are effectively optimizers. If you give them a system with a clear success metric (ie, a public rank going up), they will optimize their play-style to fit that system. Designers often assume players will stop doing this at some point. They won't grind in an RPG because that's boring. They won't bot a competitive game because that's not fun for other players.

Most players don't think in those terms during gameplay (myself included). Thinking that way is hard. As a designer, if you want a player to optimize for creating a fun experience for themselves and others, you have to explicitly build your publicly-facing systems to encourage that behavior.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:10PM (#21972725)
That's an overview, not specifics and not details (verbiage that first you and then I used). It's a shitty sleight of hand, so I'm going bring this back around and then I'm done with you.

You stated that rank is a poor proxy for skill. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21952133

I stated you can't know that without details. Knowing that winning gives you more LP and losing takes it away is not detail nor specifics.

You can't know, but you're going to hold onto that branch rather than be a little introspective and consider that you may be wrong.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by clarry on Saturday January 04, 2020 @06:34AM (#21954330)
> Personal plug, with my current project, Loop Thesis, LAN play is the only multiplayer.

What do you mean by this? A lot of game developers seem to be obsessed with the term "LAN" but I don't really understand how that has anything to do with application level network protocols that build on IP, which does not care about physical network topology.

It is very irritating because each developer seems to have their own made-up definition of "LAN." For example, there are games that won't let you connect to IP addresses outside the private ranges. There are games that won't let you enter an IP at all, and instead require the host to be found by broadcasting on your subnet. There are games that won't let you connect across subnets for other, arbitrary reasons. And then there are many games where they use the term LAN but it has nothing at all to do with LAN and works exactly like online multiplayer in any old game -- select the host (or enter its IP) and bam you're connected, whether the connection is local or intercontinenal is none of the game's concern (this is how it should be).

I have no idea what I'm buying whenever I see a game that sells "LAN multiplayer."

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by danShumway on Saturday January 04, 2020 @10:58AM (#21955552)
There are no centralized servers for Loop Thesis, and each server hosts one game.

The game ships with tools that allow players to very quickly connect to running games on the same network as them, even if they don't have anything installed. Anyone with a copy of the game can turn on hosting, and the game will not only handle being a server, it will also serve a web-based client for the game.

In practice what that means is that if you own the game, you can pull out your laptop, connect to someone's wifi, turn on hosting, and all they need to do is visit a local IP on any of their devices[0] and they are instantly playing with you.

Of course, networking doesn't force you to be behind a NAT, so there's nothing preventing you from hosting a server on Linode and exposing that IP publicly. But aside from some token authentication options, the game isn't designed to handle a bunch of public anonymous connections. The server also isn't persistent; it's assumed that once you're done playing you will shut the client down, which will also shut the server down.

Short version, you have a traditionally hosted server with an IP address, and it's not pulling any fancy tricks to force you to set that server up in a specific way. But it's not designed to be a persistent server with uptimes of like a month or something, and it's designed to handle a few connections from people that you know. The out of the box experience is going to give you a Intranet IP, not a public one, and if you want to get it working over the public Internet for some reason, you'll need to handle stuff like port forwarding yourself.

That means: no matchmaking (one game per server), no public server lists[1], only minor authentication and anti-spam options, and transient servers that disappear when play sessions are over. Loop Thesis isn't technologically restricted to a LAN, but the experience is designed for drop-in, friends-get-together LAN play.

[0]: No promises, but I am experimenting with touch controls for phones.

[1]: Unless the community builds them and maintains them on their own.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by ookdatnog on Saturday January 04, 2020 @06:25AM (#21954291)
I agree with your points. I used to play online shooters with private servers when I was a teenager, and I actually enjoyed the fact that you had a mix of skills on a given server at a given time, as well as the feeling of running into the same people when you frequent certain servers (i.e. a feeling of community).
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by wyldfire on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:13PM (#21949843)
> Allow users to votekick and voteban. Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

This might still be the best compromise but it is terribly frustrating to be accused of cheating because of different skill levels or tactics.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by McAtNite on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:23PM (#21949922)
Not to mention the ease that that feature can be abused. What’s to stop the opposing team from just vote kicking the top players on your team?

I spent my entire middle school life playing Starcraft. When SC2 came out the same rush tactics I learned in SC1 worked. I was often accused of hacking simply because I had years of experience tweaking the fastest build method.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by vitaflo on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:54PM (#21950787)
>Not to mention the ease that that feature can be abused. What’s to stop the opposing team from just vote kicking the top players on your team?

This is exactly what happened when they had this feature in Overwatch. One of the top (legit) Widow players could not find a game because everyone he played against vote banned him from their games. He was basically unable to play the game because he was too good at it.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by bsder on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:49PM (#21952929)
Sure, but you have to expect that. So, you look at the votebans, and you zap the people doing it unfairly. Or, even better, a voteban, legitimate or not, always costs you something--so you think twice before swinging the hammer.

These systems always seem to fail because there is no accountability. You can't allow actions without accountability for those same actions.

The problem is that accountability means involving humans and humans don't scale.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by celticmusic on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:30AM (#21953497)
people didn't want to play with him, I don't see the problem.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by freeopinion on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:13PM (#21950934)
I hear ya. Everytime I show up at the elementary school basketball court down the street, all the little kids complain about my skills. They never let me play.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by smabie on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:46PM (#21950154)
Assuming you need a majority to ban and teams are equal, everything?
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by 15155 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:28AM (#21955032)
I've seen this handled by not allowing the enemy team to initiate a votekick/voteban against a member of the other team.

This method has problems, but those could be rectified later via human moderation and other means.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by 14 on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:58PM (#21950283)
Agreed. I play War Thunder and have had a couple times been accused of cheating. I would not risk my annual paid account to sit there and cheat. I have invested thousands of hours on that account and that alone is worth way more then any money. I do not cheat is my point. But at times I just blast a shot across the board and you hit a guy. So how do you distinguish between god shots and cheating?
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by BookmarkSaver on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:04PM (#21950869)
There are some ways, but they are often somewhat invasive, and basically none are possible for a human player to use while in game.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by daenz on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:07PM (#21952010)
True, but when you get accused of cheating for having a wicked hot streak, you know it's kind of one of the best compliments you can get :)
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by debaserab2 on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:21PM (#21950517)
> These are tools and approaches that we had in past games and while they are not perfect, they are better than these black box invasive anticheat solutions born from a desire to avoid giving community control to users.

There are still games with votekick/ban. They work for cheaters, but the collateral damage that comes with votekick/ban is far, far greater than anticheat wave bans.

People votekick for very petty reasons and people often reflexively vote yes on the assumption that the votekick is done in good faith.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by jimmaswell on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:29PM (#21952393)
Reminds me of Rainbow 6 where you're kicked the instant you lose a gunfight or anyone just doesn't like you.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by reroute1 on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:49PM (#21950727)
That depends on the community, if there is a mature group of people playing these aren't really big issues. Not that it's going to fix everything, but when I play games with these features they seem to help more than they are abused.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by jdnenej on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:05AM (#21953410)
Vote kicks rarely seen to work because the rest of the players don't know what is going on. A vote starts and you think "wait what, what did they do" even if someone says "they were cheating" most people playing wouldn't have seen it and have no idea if this is true.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by ssully on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:08PM (#21947827)
> Allow users to votekick and voteban.

This is usually just a band aid and can be pretty ineffective in a game like Battlefield where there are a large number of players in a single match. Specifically, a cheater has to be really obvious for enough people to notice and actually care enough to cast a vote.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by anonymousab on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:26PM (#21948065)
If the cheater isn't obvious enough then they aren't having much worse of an effect than a really good player.

But that's why I mention giving server control to users; they can experiment with their own alternative anti cheat and moderation solutions.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by EamonnMR on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:16PM (#21947937)
I, for one, only notice when it's a real obvious cheater. And in those circumstances the perception of a fair game would go way up if we where able to ban the fool ourselves as players.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by salawat on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:27PM (#21952671)
Back in my Halo CE days, I got tons of mileage out of a util called sightjacker. It'd basically allow for one to view exactly what the other player was seeing and doing in their client.

The cheats became quite trivial to pick out, because their aim was never natural. It was always pinned on the target and stuck like glue or smooth and natural until they got close to targets.

I'd just sit back and occasionally sight jack people I hadn't met who entered the server, and the banlist slowly grew over time. The other players would stick around, so it obviously at least resulted in good games.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by janoc on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:49PM (#21949613)
Plus this is easily gamed - most games where voting has been enabled just had storms of vote requests being generated.

Some by butt-hurt snowflakes that can't handle better players but most by explicit trolls trying to cause mayhem, spam and hopefully getting someone kicked for fun. At some point the voting gets either ignored or disabled outright.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Terr_ on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:02PM (#21949743)
IMO this goes to how per-server "communities" were destroyed by the rise of new business models involving follow-on purchases.

Previously (e.g. CS 1.x) you could have a loose federation of privately-run servers, with a certain amount of darwinian-selection for good or bad communities.

However once GameCo starts selling exclusive skins and weapons and XP-boosters and things, they can't allow the possibility of rogue servers just unlocking everything, so everything was brought together under a corporate-hosting-only umbrella. This also destroyed the capacity to leverage volunteer admins, unless the company invested in a mechanism for "you pay we host" servers.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Tyr42 on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:17PM (#21949870)
TF2 managed to have private server, and was the origin of HATS. I'm not sure I see that your logic is sound.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by baby on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:21PM (#21951790)
None of your solutions make sense. Which is obvious to anyone who has played a game with cheaters.

> Allow users to votekick and voteban.

People love to say others are cheating when they are losing. Not going to work.

Allowing users to provide their own solutions? That’s funny you say that. Tournaments and leagues on CS pretty much made you install software that would periodically take screenshot of your computer to prove you were not cheating.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by philliphaydon on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:42PM (#21952168)
> Allow users to votekick and voteban. Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

I used to play Counter Strike starting at Beta 1.3, on a 56k modem. In NZ we had some team who went off overseas to represent NZ in a competition. They lost the first round. After they got back I found their practice server. They didn’t seem to mind if randoms joined. I got 3 headshots and they banned me for “cheating”

My point is, if you leave it up to the players. They will kick and ban anyone for any reason because they can. You simply cannot rely on such a system.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by hutzlibu on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:57PM (#21952230)
Your cheating guys lost in a real contest. Seems to be a working system.

And idiots are idiots, I don't want to play with them anyway. So if a server is full of them who kock people for the sake of it ... then I just choose a different server.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by mattigames on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:18PM (#21952339)
In many many games you don't have any alternative to "playing with idiots" so no, it wouldn't be a working system in any significant way.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by lossolo on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:59AM (#21947714)
> Allow users to votekick and voteban. Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

How would that work in case of MMORPG with open world ? One clan would votekick competing clan? Any group votekick whoever they want? Or in case of FPS games lets vote to kick player X because he is just too good (killing us all) so he is cheating for sure?

> Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

Dosen't apply for most MMO games.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by WorldMaker on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:35PM (#21948852)
> How would that work in case of MMORPG with open world ? One clan would votekick competing clan? Any group votekick whoever they want?

Checks and balances. It's a political problem at that point. MUDs had sometimes very traditional political institutions for bans/player behavior issues, and the same can directly apply to MMOs: "councils of multiple clans", for instance. You can already think of most corporations running MMOs as "BFDLs" (benevolent dictators for life) and there's good reason to ask them to add juries/trials for a more open democratic process to bans, as one common political solution to dictatorship. The same obviously goes the other direction that if players want more involvement in bans/kicks, they need structures like juries/trials to keep things transparent and to bubble up such issues as appropriate.

You can't always solve political problems with technical solutions, but more importantly sometimes technical problems have good political solutions.

>> Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

> Dosen't apply for most MMO games.

Arguably it should. At the very least for long term archival, MMO games should feel more pressure to provide server software access to players to host their own servers. There's also a lot of interesting history associated with MMOs that had open servers (many MUDs), or reverse engineered server shards (things like various Ultima Online player-created shards). Even if most players would prefer a "canon" experience in BFDL hosted shards, that isn't necessarily a strong reason to avoid offering players a choice to host their own servers. Arguably most good MMOs hosting your own server cluster is a great amount of effort and would be A) self-limiting (only certain groups of players would have the combo of resources/interests/skills), and B) at least somewhat useful to the game owner themselves as a form of CI/CD test (if other people can reproduce your Production environment you are more resilient against possible mistakes/failures in your Production environment).

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by munk-a on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:15PM (#21949850)
MUDs, while wonderful, occasionally devolved into closed ecosystems where RP enforcement and opinions ended up creating a toxic community with the playerbase eventually shrinking to nothing. MUDs are amazing but I think they're a bad example to call on in this case.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by WorldMaker on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:01PM (#21950318)
I don't know, I feel like that only mirrors/emphasizes/complements my point: yes, political solutions are hard (we still refer to the USA as a political "experiment" 200+ years on, for some good reasons), but they are possible (versus trying to handle things entirely technically that are by their own nature political; as other arguments in this thread and elsewhere point out, dealing with bad actors that are people will almost always be at least somewhat political).

Political solutions can clearly fail, and that becomes another reason to allow players to run their own servers as it is an "out" in the case of a political solution failing (a different sort of resiliency to the technical sort).

MUDs also have tales of successes. Times when political alliances defeated griefers and the community was stronger for it. Partly because of the relative ease of spinning up MUDs there are so many stories and experiments out there to choose from / learn from. MUDs were an early laboratory for what became MMOs in so many ways, and it will always be easier to reproduce studies done in that sort of a laboratory setting, including the failures. In science often the failures are the greatest learning experiences leading to the most interesting hypotheses.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by anonymousab on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:14PM (#21947910)
The false positive of someone getting kicked for being too good is a better negative outcome than the false positive of a ban, especially in an opaque system with poor support staffing and resolution processes. When users can trivially provide and administrate and experiment with their own servers, then the effect of not being able to return to the same server is lessened.

>MMO games

They're a different beast entirely. But in the case of battlefield, you have a capped playercount that is orders of magnitude smaller than an MMO, and much more manageable.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by zttxc on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:35PM (#21948167)
You have no idea of how much a votekick system will get abused. Nobody would ever seriously consider such a system in 2020.

Teammates will kick you out for stealing kills from them. Teammates will leave bots on even if they are flagrant bots if they are helping the team. Enemies will kick you out if you are too good.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by briffle on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:44PM (#21949577)
I play many games that still have vote/kick. (Most often, Insurgency). The 2 most common vote kicks are an idle player that is the last player left on a team, and the guy sniping with a 40/3 K/D ratio, and a ping of > 300ms, that doesn't respond to any chat or voice chat, etc.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by anonymousab on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:49PM (#21948998)
I play in custom servers for plenty of games that have vote kick and ban systems. The games themselves may be old, but the players range from fresh to old guard. Valve FPS games were / are particularly good for this.

>Teammates will kick you out for stealing kills from them

Then you find another server that has fostered a better community. Or even start your own.

Even if the ratio of absolute mean-spirited jerks to decent players was 10:1, that's more than enough well intentioned players to foster good server communities. But I suspect the actual number is closer to a reversed amount.

Obviously MMOs would be a different beast, but the type of cheating you're trying to defeat - the threat model - is often different than wallhacking autoaimers.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by zttxz on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:20PM (#21949327)
Sorry, I am talking about MMOs exclusively. Some of those also have you compete not only against the enemy team but also against your own team for ranks
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by jeltz on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:09PM (#21948587)
Why would it be abused more today? It was not abused that much back when I played Quake 1 and Quake 2.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by hinkley on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:33PM (#21948832)
I believe the loot system changes in WoW were inspired by occurrences of groups of people joining matchmaking together, then kicking a person after the boss died and taking all the stuff for themselves. I only saw this sort of behavior firsthand once or twice, but I’ve heard from others who thought it was widespread.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by zttxc on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:41PM (#21948919)
And in WoW too, given how the honor rank system works, imagine if people could kick others from battlegrounds: they would kick those with higher ranks so they could climb the ranks faster themselves.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Nullabillity on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:21PM (#21950507)
So.. don't design systems that encourage toxic behaviour?

In the case of WoW, they realized their mistake and ripped out the global PvP ladder over a decade ago.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by zttxz on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:44PM (#21950699)
Classic has the ladder again :)
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by catalogia on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:05PM (#21951282)
Then don't buy it! If the product is known to be defective, resist the marketing and be a savvy consumer who doesn't buy products known to be faulty!
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by catalogia on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:00PM (#21951238)
> "You have no idea of how much a votekick system will get abused."

Votekick systems used to work great for many games. They don't work in games with global ranking systems because those ranking systems create toxic incentives. Once games become "serious business" instead of casual fun, the knives come out.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by perl4ever on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:30AM (#21953498)
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by fzeroracer on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:25PM (#21949939)
> Allow users to votekick and voteban. Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.

If you want to see a game where that effort fails, one needs not look further than Mordhau. It's an incredibly awful community where players will initiate votekicks simply for getting killed, and cause players to get kicked/banned because the community finds overabusing the feature to be funny.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by LaGrange on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:35PM (#21950039)
> It's an incredibly awful community where players will initiate votekicks simply for getting killed

...lol, that's nothing, expect people getting kicked for having a feminine voice.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by fzeroracer on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:40PM (#21951525)
Well yes, that was more or less a benign example of the community issues in Mordhau. I wasn't too interested in getting into a deep argument on the issues of extremely toxic communities and the various *phobic issues within because that inevitably causes bad faith arguments here sadly.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by nerdponx on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:45AM (#21947574)
Only if you provide a robust and empowered support staff to quickly unban and resolve false positives. That is, actually take responsibility, which is something game developers and major publishers seem allergic to.

It costs money to hire, train, and oversee said staff. Game companies don't want to spend that money.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by sidlls on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:18PM (#21947962)
They would be more inclined if gamers were willing to pay the additional cost. Unfortunately they rarely are. The gaming community, especially the hard core community, is one of the most oddly-miserly communities I’ve ever seen. Some of them will spend thousands on liquid cooling and high end graphic cards, specialized input devices, etc., but balk or even rage at paying an additional few bucks over the lifetime of a game for improved features and support.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by zttxc on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:32PM (#21948827)
Uh? Have you seen the price of AAA games?
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by sidlls on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:38PM (#21948886)
They’re flat for years. Ten years ago a premium AAA title would typically release at $49.99 to $59.99 and still have expansions and other DLC for sale.

In constant dollars the retail price of top-end games is basically flat, or even lower now.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:47PM (#21950166)
Your argument is disingenuous.

Most aaa titles have significant dlc that hardly expands the game. Gtav is an exception, and that's only because stupid/rich people whale on shark cards. Also repeat purchases from banned players.

Cod is now $120/yr. Without and iaps. If you don't buy the dlc you'll have a hard timemaking friends and playing pvp.

Most games are like that now. Looking at title prices is a flawed metric. A good metric total cost of all iaps. If there are unlimited purchases available then you can be sure that the game has been crippled to coerce vulnerable players into spending irrational amounts. This trend is unethical and everyone involved in allowing this to continue is no better than the sacklers.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by sidlls on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:59PM (#21950292)
Games ten years ago had DLC, too. Certainly not as much but it did exist, and often was priced on par with equivalent DLC offered today.

Also, it’s frequently the case that DLC today has development and maintenance costs that the base retail package simply doesn’t.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:10PM (#21950402)
Ten years ago it wasn't common for dlc to have unlimited purchases or even for the cumulative price to double the base cost. Now, it's rather common for games to have gambling mechanics that put a floor on the cost of time limited items that is measured in the hundreds or thousands of dollars.

I have less of a problem with buying a game and its season pass for $120 than I do when I buy a game and season pass for $120 to find thousands of dollars in iaps required to get everything. This trend is disgusting and I for one have written off all companies with even a single product engaging in this. This includes Blizzard, rockstar, Microsoft's label, bungie, Activision, ea, etc. To earn my purchases they'll need to ditch all the unethical iaps and find an ethical and sustainable business model. Though I'd rather see them go bankrupt and firesale all their ip to indie studios.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by sidlls on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:12PM (#21952034)
The market exists in its current state because the gambling/loot box/DLC whales subsidize the rest of the market, because by far most of the rest of the market think they're entitled to $200 worth of content and support for $60 at retail and are very vocal about it.

I'm the last one to defend Big Business in any industry, but I've seen the gaming industry from the inside and as a consumer. Here's my opinion: gamers are absolutely the worst customer base I've ever seen.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:58AM (#21954198)
That's easy to say. There's certainly no dearth of miserable people that play video games and try to being everyone there down with them too. But these peoplealso act these ways in real life too.

I don't feel entitled to a $n game for less than $n. However, if a company sells 0.5 of a $n game for the $n price I will take issue with them. There is no shortage of half assed games sold with dlc and gambling for aaa prices. No man's sky is the epitome of this. How they didn't get arrested and sued for fraud/false advertising boggles my mind. The industry is ripe with huge promises from the scummy advertising department, that turn out to usually be a shadow of what was promised.

Studios cut just about every corner, blatantly reuse assets yoy in dlc/new titles, skimp on infra, and have the audacity to complain about the players being cheap? The industry has pushed away so many deep pockets with these awful tactics. Try delivering good products first without selling me a bridge.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by catalogia on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:27PM (#21951027)
> This trend is unethical and everyone involved in allowing this to continue is no better than the sacklers.

This is one of the reasons I dropped out of the gaming market almost entirely. The way I see it, 'gamers' are some of the least savvy consumers on the planet. They continue to buy games from companies they know have burned them numerous times. In some markets, consumers are known for holding decades long grudges against companies that have wronged consumers, but not gamers. Gamers seem to be exceptionally forgiving and naive in this regard, and that lets games companies walk all over them.

Invasive rootkit DRM, games broken on launch, games broken forever with the expectation that community modders will donate their labor to fix it for free, games that don't facilitate community servers, games that are split in two before launch with half the game being labeled "DLC", thinly veiled skinner boxes designed like slot machines designed to encourage binge-play ("grinding for rare loot") and sometimes designed to extract even more money from players who've already purchased the game ("lootcrates".) A DRM company, widely beloved by gamers, being forced by the courts to revise their abhorrent returns policy (https://www.engadget.com/2016/12/23/valve-steam-fined-2-mill...) Shit, I've had 'gamers' get fuming mad at me before for not worshiping at the altar of Valve, as though it were religious heresy for me to criticize a for-profit American corporation.

Even when the 'gamer community' recognizes something as broken, they seem to forget by the time the next game comes around. Just look at the history of Bethesda releases. Morrowind was broken but somewhat novel. Oblivion was again broken, though perhaps with some of the edges rounded over. Next was Fallout 3, which was still broken. Skyrim was very broken, at this point the pattern should have been obvious to everybody paying attention, and to be fair to the gamers the brokenness of Bethesda games was becoming a meme at this point. Fallout 4 comes around and it's their most nerfed game yet, but still broken as fuck. How could anybody be surprised at this point? Yet people still bought that, and they even bought the next game, Fallout 76, which was the most egregiously Bethesda broken game yet. Currently the 'gamer community' recognizes Fallout 76 and Bethesda as dumpster fires, but will they buy the next Bethesda game? I'd bet on it. When it comes time to vote with their wallets, I wager they'll be compliant consumers and do as the marketing tells them to. Even when they learn, they don't learn. The lesson doesn't set in, a new game is released, and the cycle continues.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by friendlybus on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:05AM (#21959755)
Games are games, game companies are games too. People want to be in this world where you can play with anything, broken and burned is part of the game. There's no difference between company, customer and product, it's all play.

A straight up and down company like IBM or Ford would not dominate in the games industry. Valve, ea, bethseda are leaders in play. They give you the opportunity to play religious heresy, or witness a fallout 76 firestorm. Where else do you get to play with a billion dollar company?

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by logfromblammo on Friday January 03, 2020 @12:05PM (#21947798)
Those game companies could always exit the company-hosted company-moderated multiplayer space and go back to either privately-hosted servers or single-player games.

If you can't accept the costs of central servers, don't make them an essential part of your business model.

Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by chungus_khan on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:54PM (#21949047)
If that's the case then they can enjoy paying my refund, just like Blizzard did way back when.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by babypuncher on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:44PM (#21951113)
Surely you can see how mob mentality makes vote kicking and vote banning a terrible idea
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by close04 on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:50PM (#21951155)
That would quickly turn into a popularity contest rather than a cheater elimination tool. I'm not really qualified to tell the difference between a cheater and a really good player on many occasions. I can vote for lack of fairplay of course but give the average player a chance to vote and they'll quickly vote out anyone they don't like.
Re:EA is permanently banning Linux players on Battlefield V by vlozko on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:07PM (#21952563)
Battlefield 4 had rentable servers. It wasn’t fun getting kicked for being good, despite playing on a PS4 where cheating didn’t really exist.