News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ryanisnan on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:33PM (#21808154)
I'm surprised that the market hasn't reacted more negatively towards Boeing regarding the Max 8 disaster.

Airlines operate on razor-thin margins (~1 to 2%), and several users of the Max 8 have had significant portions of their fleet out of service as a result.

Westjet [1], for example runs 124 planes currently. 13 of which are the Max 8. Over 10% of their fleet. Southwest Airlines [2], for example, runs 748 planes, 34 of which are Max 8s (with an additional 246 ordered), ~4.5% of the fleet.

The lawsuits that are surely incoming are going to pile-drive this company into the ground.

edit: [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WestJet#Current_fleet edit 2: [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_fleet#Curre...

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:45PM (#21808291)
> lawsuits that are surely incoming are going to pile-drive this company into the ground

Legally, everyone is indemnified up the wazoo.

Strategically, airlines are in a worse position if Boeing goes under. Not only do they lose the planes on order. They also lose their service and replacement-parts provider. The survivors would, in the medium-term, face an Airbus monopoly and, in the long-term, a Chinese-European duopoly.

As emotionally-satisfying as it may be to see Boeing go under for its arrogance, it's neither helpful nor likely. (A well-managed break-up, on the other hand...)

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by Despegar on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:20PM (#21808642)
>Strategically, airlines are in a worse position if Boeing goes under. Not only do they lose the planes on order. They also lose their service and replacement-parts provider. The survivors would, in the medium-term, face an Airbus monopoly and, in the long-term, a Chinese-European duopoly.

Boeing "going under" just means that shareholders will get wiped out, not that they cease operations.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by hackerbabz on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:16PM (#21810193)
I wonder if Lockheed Martin would get back into passenger jets.

Or Bombardier leads a Canadian aerospace resurgence.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by numpad0 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:02AM (#21810780)
I wonder if we will be to trust Mitsubishi designed wing root components should they fly.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by SkyMarshal on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:18PM (#21821744)
Bombardier is part of Airbus now.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @02:56AM (#21822796)
No they aren't; airbus has a stake in one of Bombardier's aircraft lines, that's all.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by nogabebop23 on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:57PM (#21810371)
>> Bombardier leads a Canadian aerospace resurgence.

Do we have enough tax dollars to finance such an event </s>

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by bilbo0s on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:03PM (#21809016)
That may be what the poster meant by "well managed break up".
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by marvin on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @01:58AM (#21811322)
This always baffles me. It's still the free market even if regulators sometimes step in to ensure that incentives are aligned and outcomes don't become systemically catastrophic.

In this case, it would be Boeing going bankrupt, and authorities stepping in to buy the assets to keep operations running if no other entity stepped in to do that. Then selling on the reformed company on the open market afterwards.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by starfallg on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:53PM (#21808922)
> Chinese-European duopoly

Unlikely. The Chinese is currently competing with Embraer (E-Jet E2) and Bombardier (C-series/A22x) with the Comac C919 which has problems with production. Since its first flight in 2017, there has only been 5 built.

Tech transfers has also slowed to trickle since the HSR fiasco with foreign rail technology absorbed and then re-exported. Nobody trusts the Chinese to play fair.

What's more likely if Boeing run into difficulties from the MAX damages is that it will restructure under Chapter 11 and re-emerge with the existing shareholders wiped out. This may involve a breakup, with the defence business separating from the commercial airliner business, but that's also unlikely due to how aerospace companies are run these days.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ummonk on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:14PM (#21809828)
The C919 is competing with the 737 and A320, and hasn't entered production yet. Are you mixing it up with the ARJ21?
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by starfallg on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @04:27AM (#21812027)
Yeah, the ARJ21 is in production and the C919 is in testing.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:11PM (#21809082)
The Chinese is currently competing with Embraer (E-Jet E2) and Bombardier (C-series/A22x)

AKA Boeing and Airbus.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:55PM (#21809394)
The C919 is a narrowbody jet aimed at the 737/A320. There are no Chinese widebody/twin aisle aircraft, now or anytime in the foreseeable future, that can compete with the 787/A350.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by djcapelis on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:13PM (#21809824)
In a huge leap of naming they’ve named it the C929 with initial flights in 2025 and EIS planned for 2027. It’s cool to think they probably won’t hit those dates but pretending like a roadmap doesn’t even exist is not.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CRAIC_CR929

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:59PM (#21810109)
The CR929 is vaporware: they're not even planning to begin construction of the first prototype until 2021. Also, it's "CR" for "China/Russia", since this is meant to be a joint venture between COMAC and UAC (Sukhoi). Which sounds like a great recipe to delay everything even further.

Also also, even if China does pull off the airframe, they'll still rely on Western jets to power it. China's first modern turbofan, the CJ-1000A, is not scheduled to go into service until 2030 (!) and even that is geared only for the C919: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACAE_CJ-1000A

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure China will get there sooner or later, as they've already demonstrated with high-speed trains and many other things. But timeframes for going from concept to a serious competitor in this business are measured in decades.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by igravious on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:33AM (#21812325)
Something I'd like to point out here, not taking away from any of your points.

If you think of Airbus as a multi-national consortium (as it rightly is: French, British, etc.) then a Chinese/Russian hook-up is not totally daft. You could make the same argument about "a great recipe to delay everything even further" about Airbus versus Boeing and yet Airbus appears to be doing okay.

Don't we think competition is good? What happened to cheering on free markets? Why exactly do we want a Western duopoly to continue to exist in perpetuity? If Western countries believed their own rhetoric they'd be helping Russia and China to compete on the world stage – it would be a win for the entire globe.

You make it sound like 2030 is a lifetime away. It's only 10 years. It's been less than a century since the last huge global conflict and it looks like China and Russia will be toe-to-toe with the West (ignoring that Russia is already largely Western) in commercial aviation, space-flight, nuclear power, possibly semiconductor production, you name it.

The West does not have some God-given or divine-right to remain on top of the heap – China (and India) are going to eventually catch up, it's just a matter of time, the only thing up for debate in my mind is whether it's sooner rather than later, and I believe in China's case it's going to be upon us sooner than we expect.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @08:53AM (#21813405)
I didn't say any of that. My point is simply that building large modern passenger aircraft is Hard with a capital H, and while I wish them luck, China still has a long, long way to go.

And FWIW, if you read up on Airbus's history, you'll see that their unusual structure and resulting internal politics have caused a lot of pain over the years (eg. the A380 superjumbo program). Ironically enough, Boeing got a taste of this too when they decided to outsource all the things when building the 787, which consequently went way over budget.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by igravious on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:24AM (#21812782)
Replying to myself. Airbus is a consortium of four countries: France, UK, Germany, Spain – started in the 60's. Basically China/Russia are 50 or 60 years behind!

Here's a recent doc about the most technologically advanced aircraft they've manufactured, the A350: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yutzg2NLwcU “Giant Aircraft: Manufacturing an Airbus A350 | Mega Manufacturing | Free Documentary”

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:43PM (#21819763)
Not to forget a joint venture with Canada.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ajxs on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:06PM (#21819950)
> Don't we think competition is good? What happened to cheering on free markets?

No? Not really? Obviously competitions is good when it drives innovation, which is beneficial for domestic industry as a whole. Competition is not good for competition's sake. It's not good competition when Western players fall behind. This isn't some kind of hypocritical failing of free-market doctrines. You either don't understand what it intended to accomplish, or are deliberately misrepresenting it. I suspect the latter.

> Why exactly do we want a Western duopoly to continue to exist in perpetuity?

... Why wouldn't we want our own players to dominate the industry? I don't think any kind of monopoly/duopoly is a good thing, but I don't really think that's your point. Your use of the word 'Western' betrays your intent here.

> If Western countries believed their own rhetoric they'd be helping Russia and China to compete on the world stage – it would be a win for the entire globe.

Um... no? China's exports becoming more competitive would not be a win for the entire globe, it would be quite the opposite.

> The West does not have some God-given or divine-right to remain on top of the heap...

Of course not, God didn't put us on top of the heap either.

> China (and India) are going to eventually catch up, it's just a matter of time, the only thing up for debate in my mind is whether it's sooner rather than later, and I believe in China's case it's going to be upon us sooner than we expect.

I wouldn't hold your breath.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by djcapelis on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:08PM (#21810154)
Yes yes yes. But even if everything plays out like you say I don’t think you can say there’s no foreseeable future in which this happens. Please engage with the actual plans and state the technical details you know rather than saying that China has no roadmap do a thing they have a roadmap to do.

Also let’s be clear if the C919 actually works out they will be a serious competitor. The market for wide body aircraft is the one that captures all the imagination and attention but the narrow body sales are the bread and butter. They absolutely do not need to succeed in this market right away to put a big dent in the duopoly.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:00AM (#21810770)
Also let’s be clear if the C919 actually works out they will be a serious competitor. The market for wide body aircraft is the one that captures all the imagination and attention but the narrow body sales are the bread and butter.

That's a pretty large if. Head west a bit to Russia and see how they're doing in the international market. The Sukhoi SuperJet is, by most accounts, a great plane. Sukhoi managed to sell to the Mexicans (Interjet) and Irish (CityJet) and both got rid of them quickly. Being a threat to Boeing/Embraer and Airbus/Bombardier goes well beyond the complex task of building an airliner.

Sukhoi and Comac are still hugely dependent on the west to build these planes. Avionics and engines especially. The metallurgy required to build a modern turbofan engine is incredibly exotic — outside of France, England, and the US it's simply not there. The Superjet didn't fare well -- the Russians collaborated with Safran and the result was a unreliable engine that was hard to find replacement parts for. The Russians are also currently peddling the PD-14 that competes with the 20+ year old CFM56. Comac skipped that step and went straight to GE.

Comac abandoned carbon fiber for the wings in favor of aluminum. While the C919 wings are built in China, I believe they're a European design (Comac's previous stillborn attempt at an airliner used Ukraine's Antonov for the wings).

They absolutely do not need to succeed in this market right away to put a big dent in the duopoly.

Sure they do. Network effects are huge with airliners. If your Embraer breaks down away from your maintenance base chances are you can buy / borrow parts from another airline. If you're the only one around flying, you're entirely reliant on the manufacturer — and Comac doesn't have any sort of international support network.

Bombardier and Embraer both developed competitors to the 737 on the small side, both nearly went bankrupt, and both were eventually acquired. Unfortunately when you're a widget salesman like McNerney everything looks like a damn commodity. While McNerney's actions set Boeing back quite a bit, Comac is a far smaller threat than he thought. If Boeing can deliver on a MAX replacement it's doubtful that Comac will move the needle much in the next 10-15 years.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by apendleton on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:45AM (#21811525)
> both nearly went bankrupt, and both were eventually acquired

Nitpick: in Bombardier's case at least, these were separate events. The acquisition wasn't to deal with bankruptcy (they got a Canadian government bailout for that), but rather to gain access to Airbus's US manufacturing facilities to avoid import tariffs on US deliveries, which became necessary following a Boeing anti-dumping complaint that would have made the C-Series prohibitively expensive to US carriers.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:02PM (#21817311)
Nitpick: in Bombardier's case at least, these were separate events. The acquisition wasn't to deal with bankruptcy (they got a Canadian government bailout for that), but rather to gain access to Airbus's US manufacturing facilities to avoid import tariffs on US deliveries, which became necessary following a Boeing anti-dumping complaint that would have made the C-Series prohibitively expensive to US carriers.

My recollection is that Bombardier made (rejected) overtures in Boeing's direction before the trade spat. In either case BBD has gotten out of the commercial aircraft business completely, in large part due to the cost of developing the C-series.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by djcapelis on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:04PM (#21815634)
Sukhoi and Comac are still hugely dependent on the west to build these planes. Avionics and engines especially.

Boeing and Airbus don’t build their own engines. I don’t expect COMAC to try that in their first rodeo.

The metallurgy required to build a modern turbofan engine is incredibly exotic — outside of France, England, and the US it's simply not there.

If you’re betting on metallurgy to be the barrier to keep western technological advantage alive I think you’re in for a surprise.

Comac abandoned carbon fiber for the wings in favor of aluminum.

So they have gone back to using the material used to build every other narrow body plane on the market in this size category. I admit, a new design should use carbon fiber, but given that no one else is yet...

Sure they do. Network effects are huge with airliners. If your Embraer breaks down away from your maintenance base chances are you can buy / borrow parts from another airline. If you're the only one around flying, you're entirely reliant on the manufacturer — and Comac doesn't have any sort of international support network.

First off, airlines have purchased a ton of E175 family aircraft.

Second off, while a large international distribution is important, you don’t need to compete in the wide body market to get it.

Third off, COMAC can focus on the Chinese market to start and take it region at a time slowly expanding across Asia. From there South Asia and SEA is easy and both are big markets, Russia would welcome it with open arms and then they can take a whack at the middle eastern market and also be competitive anywhere Airbus and Boeing aren’t really playing that hard anyway. (Africa, etc.) All this well before getting around to Europe or North America.

If Boeing can deliver on a MAX replacement it's doubtful that Comac will move the needle much in the next 10-15 years.

Let’s see Boeing deliver the MAX again first.

I think it would be easy to win a bet that COMAC delivers C919 to commercial airline customers before Boeing delivers a new narrow body design to replace the 737 family.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:39PM (#21819731)
The C-Series is using carbon wings, and an absolute fuckton of carbon fiber everywhere. I've seen tech that goes into their carbon fiber parts and geometries, it's incredibly impressive, and I'm confident Bombardier more or less got it down.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by djcapelis on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @12:49AM (#21822207)
It’s seemingly an excellent aircraft so far but it is not in the same size class as the C919, B737 or A320. In that market carbon fiber hasn't really hit yet. It clearly will in the next generation since the size class down (this market) and size class up (787, etc) both are carbon fiber designs. But the 737/320/919 size class isn’t there yet.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @08:17PM (#21831219)
It’s seemingly an excellent aircraft so far but it is not in the same size class as the C919, B737 or A320. In that market carbon fiber hasn't really hit yet. It clearly will in the next generation since the size class down (this market) and size class up (787, etc) both are carbon fiber designs. But the 737/320/919 size class isn’t there yet.

They're all (C-Series/A220, C919, 737, A320) roughly the same size, but the C919 is antiquated and struggles to compete with the NG and CEO. Meanwhile the C-Series sets the benchmark. Even so, the C-Series was extraordinarily difficult to sell until Airbus stepped in. Comac, with dramatically less experience than Bombardier, will have an even more difficult time trying to unload the C919 (outside of China).

The C919 is specced out at 168 people in a one class layout with an overall length of 38.9 meters, the CS300 seats 160 with an overall length of 38.7 meteres. That puts both between the 737-700 and 737-800 (or A319 and A320) in capacity. Range-wise the CS300 and CEO do well over 6,000 km. The C919? Even with current generation turbofans it can only do 4,000-5,500 km. The NG slots in between (but closer to the C919).

The C919 is at least a generation behind the C-Series and NEO and is not a threat to either Boeing or Airbus. Hell, Comac doesn't even have a western cockpit for the C919 where Bombardier was toying with a stretch of the C-Series.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:46PM (#21817875)
If you’re betting on metallurgy to be the barrier to keep western technological advantage alive I think you’re in for a surprise.

It's worked out well for the past 70 or so years. Industrial espionage can only go so far, that's more or less why the Russians dominate the rocket market.

So they have gone back to using the material used to build every other narrow body plane on the market in this size category. I admit, a new design should use carbon fiber, but given that no one else is yet...

The MC21 and C-series use carbon fiber wings and the MC21 also uses a CF wing box. Comac is targeting planes from 20-30 years ago. Even if it were perfectly reliable, it's nowhere near competitive with what's on the market now. If that extra few percent of fuel burn weren't important there'd be no market for the NEO or MAX.

First off, airlines have purchased a ton of E175 family aircraft.

That's the entire point. Without that scale support becomes that much more difficult and expensive.

Third off, COMAC can focus on the Chinese market to start and take it region at a time slowly expanding across Asia.

Yeah they've tried. The ARJ went over like a lead balloon. The domestic airlines haven't warmed up to Comac, and it's highly unlikely the C919 will move the needle much.

From there South Asia and SEA is easy and both are big markets

With a strong anti-Chinese sentiment (Malaysia, Vietnam). Perhaps more importantly SEA sees a lot of short-range widebody service which the C919 doesn't help with.

Russia would welcome it with open arms

Russia would welcome a direct competitor to its homegrown offerings? That seems unlikely for the C919 and unlikely even if we're talking about a hypothetical plane built in a Sino-Russian joint venture. Although why would they partner? Russian avionics aren't going to be accepted internationally, Russian engines are woefully inefficient. Comac struggled with the Ukranian wings on the ARJ. Maybe a carbon fuselage, but are the Russians anywhere near being able to do that?

and then they can take a whack at the middle eastern market

The shrinking middle east market? Emirates/flyDubai (who's got both Airbus and Boeing wrapped around their fingers is scaling back their growth (to put it delicately).

and also be competitive anywhere Airbus and Boeing aren’t really playing that hard anyway. (Africa, etc.)

How welcoming will Africa be as they slowly come to terms with how screwed they are by the Belt & Road initiative? Sure, maybe CCP applies pressure to make sales. That's not going to translate to any sort of European or American success though.

Let’s see Boeing deliver the MAX again first.

I suspect that's not going to happen.

I think it would be easy to win a bet that COMAC delivers C919 to commercial airline customers before Boeing delivers a new narrow body design to replace the 737 family.

Boeing began working on a 737 replacement before the MAX program was begun, meanwhile Comac pushed the EIS target for the C919 back to 2022. As Aviation Week pointed out last year the C919 needs about 33 hours per month of flight testing for a 2021 EIS, in practice they're seeing about 5 hours per month. So, maybe.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ummonk on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:22PM (#21817589)
I expect Comac to do a much better job on supply chain support than Sukhoi did. Russia in general has always been troublesome for parts supplies for its exported equipment, whereas China has a much more consumer-friendly culture and is likely to invest heavily in making the C919 a success there.

The bigger issues I expect for the C919 will be fuel-efficiency, and trust that it is a safe plane. The fact that they're building it from scratch when the main competitors are using refreshed old designs of the 737 and A320 might help it achieve competitive fuel-efficiency, but it remains to be seen. Safety trust will be hard to make up, but a possible pathway would be to have Chinese airliners and cargo companies use it first to establish a track record free of major accidents before getting sales to international airliners.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @03:01PM (#21818084)
I expect Comac to do a much better job on supply chain support than Sukhoi did. Russia in general has always been troublesome for parts supplies for its exported equipment, whereas China has a much more consumer-friendly culture and is likely to invest heavily in making the C919 a success there.

I wasn't aware that China had built much of a reputation for international customer support.

The fact that they're building it from scratch when the main competitors are using refreshed old designs of the 737 and A320 might help it achieve competitive fuel-efficiency, but it remains to be seen

There's not much to see. The C-series is the one to beat and so far the assuredly optimistic, published specs (per Wikipedia) for the C919 don't come close to the CS300.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by danmaz74 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @08:28AM (#21813204)
The difference here is that China has a rich (and growing) internal market.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by djcapelis on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#21815409)
Yep! Which means it doesn’t even have to be better to win orders. It just has to be vaguely sufficient. Which is legitimately a tall order. But!

Let’s also remember there’s a government entirely willing to subsidize the growth of a native product. Russia already has an 80 year history of taking wildly diverse and frankly oddball aircraft designs and turning them into things that actually fly. Anyone who thinks that them partnering with a Chinese company can’t build a widebody isn’t paying attention. Who knows if it’ll be any good, it may not be competitive. But will they be able to make something that flies?

I’d happily bet on it.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:11PM (#21817433)
Russia already has an 80 year history of taking wildly diverse and frankly oddball aircraft designs and turning them into things that actually fly. Anyone who thinks that them partnering with a Chinese company can’t build a widebody isn’t paying attention.

Well that's changing the goalposts just a bit. It's likely that the Chinese can churn out a widebody, but Comac couldn't even pull off a warmed over DC-9. They've got less experience than any of the Russian companies and it's pretty much a given at this point that they won't be successful.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by nickjj on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:54PM (#21808397)
> Strategically, airlines are in a worse position if Boeing goes under.

It is an interesting situation for airlines.

Boeing is kind of a leaky abstraction layer on flying. End users deal with the airlines, not so much Boeing directly.

For example, if Amazon ships your package and it comes 4 days late because FedEx screwed up, you're going to likely think negatively of Amazon not FedEx. Because from your POV it's "Amazon said it will be here today but it's not".

Likewise if a major US airline's plane went down due to Boeing's fault it would probably ruin the entire airline. It gets even more weird when you think about airlines making questionable decisions to push Boeing into making poor decisions or knowingly operate when captains of those airlines are aware of the faults but the airline still flies them anyways and this is where it leaks.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by sfifs on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:47PM (#21809699)
Airlines know that which is why the PR has been particularly brutal on Boeing. Everyone has tried to shift blame to Boeing overtly or covertly even as Boeing tried to shift blame to pilots, regulators, airlines etc. In this particular case, Boeing's PR machinery got overwhelmed and in this day and age of high social value if authenticity, the bland corporate legalese speak adopted by its spokespeople hasn't helped.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ken on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @01:27AM (#21811188)
> For example, if Amazon ships your package and it comes 4 days late because FedEx screwed up, you're going to likely think negatively of Amazon not FedEx. Because from your POV it's "Amazon said it will be here today but it's not".

I don't think that's true. Everyone I know seems to have a favorite of {UPS,FedEx} and thinks the other one is garbage. And people pretty universally hate the USPS. Amazon is trying to get into the delivery business, but people still recognize that there's usually a third-party shipping company that actually puts the box at their door.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by room271 on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:04PM (#21808501)
But the airlines know that Boeing will never go under because the US government would (justifiably) never let that happen for strategic reasons.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by munk-a on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:39PM (#21808794)
Boeing has burned a lot of political and public capital recently so they may actually be in hot water over this. As a Canadian I'm still pretty outraged over the stupidity that the US carried out at Bombardier - Boeing basically told the US Government "Hey, those Canadians are better than us at everything" and then the US Government said "Oh, poor baby, well we'll just help the free market out with a 300% tariff."

Thanks free market economics!

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by duckymcduckface on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:42PM (#21809677)
Althought as a Montrealer I am really unhappy that the C-series is now called the A220, I was very happy when Bombardier basically bitch slapped Boeing by getting Airbus to buy it and make it in the US.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by munk-a on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:44PM (#21809688)
It was hilarious to watch the Airbus licensing, but Bombardier also got the raw end of the deal - with the corner they were backed into they're going to end up seeing a lot less revenue off that model then they had planned.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:01PM (#21810412)
> they're going to end up seeing a lot less revenue off that model then they had planned

Per unit. Lifetime revenues could likely be higher given the heft of Airbus’ marketing machine.

Agree, however, that it compounds Boeing’s image as a distracted company.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by chrisseaton on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:26PM (#21809574)
The US needs Boeing for military planes.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by tropo on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @08:15PM (#21820854)
Canada did that with dairy products. Fair is fair.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by astrodust on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:39PM (#21809656)
Hence Boeing will never improve, it'll just be in a perpetual death spiral.

See also: Bombardier.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by yskchu on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:39AM (#21812883)
There's no way Boeing will be going "under" just because 1 model of their planes is impacted

737 MAX is impacted but there's still 737 NG which doesn't have these issues

And then there's 747, 767, 777, 787 which are still under production

This is just the commercial plane side of the business, there's the huge defence side as well

Finally, Boeing has been playing this game a long time, very well connected in gov and congress, and its business impact many states and employees. Boeing is basically too big (and too well connected) to fail; even in the worst possible case, they'll probably get a bailout.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by stevehawk on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:51AM (#21812972)
While I agree with you, I just want to point out that the 747 as an airliner is no longer made and airlines would not likely go back to it. Many are still flying them but they are being phased out for financial reasons. Their manufacturing continues as a cargo plane though. Passenger wise, the last one was made in 2017. https://money.cnn.com/2017/07/19/news/companies/the-last-747...
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by zaphirplane on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:11PM (#21808573)
> Boeing goes under

We are way way far from that and if it does come close I would bet on bailouts and government intervention Boeing isn’t going to go under

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by tempguy9999 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:00AM (#21812680)
> indemnified up the wazoo

Really? Are you sure boeing is, given the cost-savings that not being insured would make (I mean the mgmt is clearly penny-pinchingly stupid enough).

But even if boeing is insured, you can bet your butt the insurers will have an explicit or implicit clause that voids the insurance on 'reasonable grounds', and they will argue (correctly) that knowingly producing flawed products (when it became evident at least) matches that getout perfectly.

Even if they lose the insurers will basically move into a courtroom, sleeping bags and all, to tie things up forever. It's cheaper than paying out.

My opinion anyway.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by TuringNYC on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:43PM (#21810032)
>> As emotionally-satisfying as it may be to see Boeing go under for its arrogance, it's neither helpful nor likely. (A well-managed break-up, on the other hand...)

Not Likely is the key word here. They are large and have a strategic value to the US and hence Too Big To Fail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Too_big_to_fail

I'd bet the US Government steps in to re-structure and backstop as required to save the company. There are numerous ways we've discovered to do so post 2008.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by oska on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:54PM (#21810081)
> There are numerous ways we've discovered to do so post 2008.

All of them bad. Companies should fail and keeping bad companies alive via artificial means is bad. You get zombie companies and eventually a zombie economy (see Japan).

(And "Too big to fail" is a phrase meant to identify a problematic ideology, not a bailout excuse).

Boeing failing doesn't necessarily mean that the USA loses their technology and production facilities. It does mean some substantial losses to investors in the company, but that should be part of the risk of investment.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by mehrdadn on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:00PM (#21810114)
I don't think the parent was endorsing this approach. It seemed like the opposite to me.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by TuringNYC on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:05PM (#21810137)
Correct. I'm the parent. Not endorsing this. Just accepting the reality. Most off our TBTF bailouts were unnecessary in my opinion, or if actually necessary, the bailouts were insufficiently punitive to investors. Most of it comes down to the political power and DC influence of the company management.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by dirtyid on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @01:52AM (#21811288)
>Too big to fail

Maybe too strategically important to fail is more apt.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by hinkley on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:38PM (#21808789)
Didn't the US government already "manage" us into the McDonnell Douglas merger in the first place?

"We're from the Government and we're here to help," indeed.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by rswail on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:41AM (#21812362)
Considering the military industrial complex is what created all of these firms in the first place, people complaining about the government rearranging them does not make sense.

There are a lot of complaints about China's "State Owned Enterprises" taking advantage of their ties to the CCP and government.

Boeing/Lockheed/Raytheon etc are the same but with the pretense that they are public companies with shareholders that have a say in how the company is run.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by wayoutthere on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:48PM (#21808329)
> The lawsuits that are surely incoming are going to pile-drive this company into the ground.

Boeing is one of the most heavily subsidized companies in the world -- right alongside Airbus. They are a strategic asset to the United States far beyond their market value. The market knows this, hence why their stock is not being hammered.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by apatters on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:50PM (#21810343)
Isn't it bad government policy to be strategically dependent on a single company? Boeing enjoys its dominant position in large part due to US government policy and the US military's procurement policies (in the 80s there were over 20 major defense contractors, now there are only six). It seems to me like the government has been shortsighted in letting things get to this point.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by _trampeltier on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:16AM (#21810850)
There was once a story here one HN (1 or 2 years ago) about this. There is often just one or so company who can prduce some special parts. So a large company started to buy a lot of these small but important companys. After that, they raise the prize by factor of ten or so.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by allovernow on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:47PM (#21808871)
Indeed. Though personally I feel perhaps Boeing should be left to fail, I'm considering going long if the stock slides further in the short term because I anticipate some form of bailout/buyout.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by CharlesColeman on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:18PM (#21809149)
> Indeed. Though personally I feel perhaps Boeing should be left to fail, I'm considering going long if the stock slides further in the short term because I anticipate some form of bailout/buyout.

I don't want to see it wind down as a going concern, but I wouldn't mind a bankruptcy and seeing the executives and board of directors fired with their compensation clawed back.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by CydeWeys on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:56PM (#21809745)
It's unbelievable that the CEO still has his job.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by kn0where on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:05PM (#21810138)
The shitstorm is far from over; who would want this on their plate? Better to let the current guy ride it out and then replace him once things can’t get any worse.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by RomanBob on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:30AM (#21815180)
Instead of being fired with $50 mil severance package?
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by rswail on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:43AM (#21812378)
The only people that would suffer in a Chapter 11 would be the pensioners of Boeing. If anything, the executives would get bonuses to keep them in place during the restructuring.

The already perilous union jobs, with good benefits etc, in Seattle would be lost and there would be a race to the bottom by other states to claim the production facilities.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by RomanBob on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:29AM (#21815170)
>a race to the bottom by other states to claim the production facilities.

Instead of a race to the top where people can just say five infinity dollars?

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ismail on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:25PM (#21809205)
I am not from the states. both of the comments below indicate that Boeing is a strategic asset. Other comments also express similar sentiments.

What is the logic for this? why is this the case?

“They are a strategic asset to the United States far beyond their market value.”

”the airlines know that Boeing will never go under because the US government would (justifiably) never let that happen for strategic reasons“

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by mdorazio on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:42PM (#21809673)
Boeing is not just a commercial aircraft manufacturer, it is a commercial and military equipment & services giant. Commercial aircraft account for 60% of its revenue, but the other 40% is military aircraft (including fighters and drones), satellites, missiles, and all kinds of defense department contracts. You cannot sink the company without significantly impacting US intelligence and military capabilities fairly quickly.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by __jal on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:29PM (#21809224)
They are are the equivalent of Airbus - a national champion for both commercial and military contracting.

Imagine the US military going to another country hat-in-hand to buy aircraft.

That's why.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by inferiorhuman on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:47PM (#21809345)
Imagine the US military going to another country hat-in-hand to buy aircraft.

You mean like with the Harrier or Eurocopter? Or more like the KC-30 where Boeing protested until Airbus dropped out?

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by argonaut on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:00PM (#21810402)
The US military didn't have to buy those hat-in-hand.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by wayoutthere on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:10PM (#21809805)
Boeing is a defense contractor that has well-developed supply chains. If we got into a shooty war and needed more airplanes, Boeing can build them. You don't want to be caught going into a shooty war without the ability to reinforce your equipment. And if you do, you can convert the commercial manufacturing capacity to military to much greater effect if the commercial side is already at super-scale. The capability is worth the subsidies IMO.

Boeing also ensures American interests dominate the skies around the world. There just aren't that many manufacturers of aircraft, and Boeing spreads American influence / values across the globe as an essential part of infrastructure. Airbus does the same for the EU.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by nogabebop23 on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:56PM (#21810366)
I'd like some of these raxor thin margins! They are up in every category with the exception of a small drop in utilization for both the 3rd quarter and YoY, with essentially no more employees and better fuel efficiency:

"Our 2019 third quarter financial results reflect net earnings of $119.4 million and diluted earnings per share of $1.02, representing our second most profitable third quarter and our overall third best quarterly performance in our 23-year history."

Also according to their own report their fleet numbers 180 airplanes.

FInally:

"We continue to adjust our flight schedule through the end of 2019 as a result of the ongoing closure of Canadian airspace forthe Boeing MAX series aircraft impacting our fleet. Our contingency planning and proactive schedule adjustments enable us to reduce last minute flight cancellations and unexpected travel disruptions, however, certain routes have been temporarily suspended as a result of aircraft inventory shortages."

Wanna bet they suspended certain routes that were not very profitable like interior, non-hub routes?

https://www.westjet.com/assets/wj-web/documents/en/investorM...

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by hudibras on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:58AM (#21813010)
A good rule of thumb is to never believe it when a company or industry says they have razor-thin margins.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @08:02AM (#21813041)
That works at least until their cash flow seizes up and they need a huge bail out. The car industry is a good example of a margin thin one.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by themagician on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:49PM (#21808339)
Boeing will be fine. By the end of next year everyone will have forgotten.

Even if Boeing wasn't fine, it would be fine, because the government would just bail them out.

Investors know this and ignore the drama.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by alasdair_ on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:24PM (#21809197)
The US government will ensure Boeing as an entity continues to exist, but that doesn't mean existing shareholders will keep their equity at the current valuation.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by 8bitsrule on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:57PM (#21810095)
> the government would just bail them out.

Good thing for the proponents of the supposed 'wisdom of the market'. Nice of US to help keep that 'wisdom' alive.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by rwc on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:45PM (#21808852)
Boeing already cleared their obligation to Southwest for 2019 with a $125 million payment. Nothing to sneeze at, but far from anything nearing a "pile-drive".
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by zaroth on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:39PM (#21810007)
No, the $125 million was just the portion set aside for Southwest employees.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by Aloha on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:04PM (#21808507)
Boeing is sitting on a big giant huge bucket of assets. In the long term, this is a blip.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by JohnJamesRambo on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:57PM (#21808963)
Isn’t the problem that all of our mutual funds just keep buying Boeing stock no matter what bad things happen?
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by kyrieeschaton on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:54PM (#21810731)
Most index funds are in some matter market weighted. So when the price crashes, they buy less, and vice versa. You can see how this could have some odd effects, but the thesis is that heavily leveraged smart money washes it out.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by pcurve on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:32PM (#21808727)
They are down 25% from the high. That's a lot.

But if you look at their 50 year chart, it had recent run up of 3-4x in just past 4-5 years.

It's quite possible there's some serious downside, but only through series of bad news like this.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by o-__-o on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @01:12AM (#21811119)
Assume there are 75 planes that will not be delivered. At an average of $125m per plane, that’s $9B or 7% of their assets. They can simply payback that money with all cash on hand and everyone is whole.

Boeing stock is down about 3% today which lines up with the numbers above. Boeing is not going anywhere. Maybe shave another 10% for them to remake the MAX (new 7x7) and fix their image problem and by mid decade no one will remember how to spell MCAS

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by markus_zhang on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:48PM (#21808317)
Boeing is one of the pillars of the American economy and the market as well. Dumping the stock will hurt pretty much every fund that invested on it, plus Dow will plunge just because of this one stock if it's getting dumped.

Boeing, as well as many other firms, are just too big to fail suddenly.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by hinkley on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:45PM (#21808845)
There was a really weird moment for me about ten years ago when I realized Apple could pay cash to buy Boeing. I mean, obviously they wouldn't, but something is off about the scale of it all.

Are we sure it's a pillar? Perhaps if you take all of the suppliers and partners it represents, sure. But by itself, I don't think it really look all that impressive.

After The War, the US government was careful to keep domestic manufacturing 'healthy' which turned into 'fat and happy' which has now turned into I-don't-know-what, but I wonder if subsidies-as-defense-policy should be putting more energy into other industries.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by gniv on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:56PM (#21809403)
Interesting comparison. I guess the difference is that the supply chain of Boeing is mostly in the US, whereas for Apple it's mostly overseas.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by kyrieeschaton on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:56PM (#21810737)
It gutted "domestic manufacturing", it lavished largesse on the military-industrial sector specifically (and even there, the post Cold War consolidation that Warren Christopher specifically promoted is one of the reasons the aerospace sector is such a mess).
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by markus_zhang on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:12PM (#21809094)
Yeah including all those peripheral dmg if it falls suddenly. I'm mean might be able to afford I'd it declines overtime, but a shock is going be very scary.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by munk-a on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:54PM (#21809389)
Honestly, I don't know why Boeing has this image of being such a vital cog in America - America isn't wholly dependent on Boeing and if it was that'd be a generally terrible thing anyways.

Also, who cares about the Dow plunging if it's for such a clear and explicable reason - it's usually used by politicians to gauge mysterious impacts on the economy, when you know the cog that broke to cause the numbers to swivel it's a pretty useless metric - you already know the thing.

It's sort of like not wanting to go into maintenance mode to deploy a big infrastructure patch because being forced into maintenance mode is bad - yea, it is, and if you can avoid taking servers offline go ahead and do that - but if you can't then just eat the outage as it's probably better to upgrade things than to refuse to upgrade due to the fact that it will expose the fact that you had to upgrade.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by AlexCoventry on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:14PM (#21810489)
> Also, who cares about the Dow plunging if it's for such a clear and explicable reason

The enormous fraction of people who have their retirement savings tied up in the stock market, that's who.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by rpiguy on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:20PM (#21810536)
Who cares if the Dow plunges? The largest block of active voters, retirees and those near retirement who live off or will be living off their investments.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by hackerbabz on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:19AM (#21811412)
Is this why they should have 90% or more of their fund in bonds by now?
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by rpiguy on Friday December 20, 2019 @12:36AM (#21841943)
That is sound and oft repeated advice, but I do wonder how many people actually follow it. Anecdotally my parents are half retired and still have most money in stocks, as did one set of my grandparents. They lost a huge amount of their retirement in the .com crash and worked into their mid-70s to recover it. The other set of grandparents put everything into CDs and stable investments. The set of grandparents that lost it and had to get it back still ended up with 5x the money as the more risk averse pair.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ddalex on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @10:08AM (#21814156)
China has 90% of their funds in US bonds by now (called dollars), and what good does that do them ?
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by hackerbabz on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @08:38PM (#21820967)
It gets them stable 2% interest every year with almost 0% risk of default.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ajross on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:02PM (#21809004)
A quick google says Boeing is the 28th largest US company by both revenue and market cap (interesting that they line up exactly), sitting next to "pillars" like the Home Depot and PepsiCo.

We'll be fine.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by generatorguy on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:03PM (#21810126)
It takes a lot less skill and knowledge to build another retailer or soft drink company than one that designs and builds cutting edge airplanes.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by ajross on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:32PM (#21810268)
Arguably, sure. But it's not an engineering argument. The point was responding to comments like "Dumping the stock will hurt pretty much every fund that invested on it, plus Dow will plunge just because of this one stock if it's getting dumped."
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by olefoo on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:03PM (#21808497)
> too big to fail suddenly

Also known as "a systemic risk".

This is the downside of allowing the concentration of economic power in too few hands. It's like other large scale systems. Yes there's a lot of redundancy; but that redundancy serves a purpose.

Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by rodgerd on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:20PM (#21809159)
All the central planning of the old Soviet Union, with none of the pretense to public good.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by cft on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:04PM (#21808498)
The market assumes that Boeing is too big to fail and largely ignores this news. I made quite a lot on the short term BA calls after the Ethiopian disaster. Long term, the crony consolidation of Boeing, Lockheed and Douglas commercial airplanes will probably greatly diminish the US market share in lieu of the new East Asian competition. But unfortunately no effective long-term short instruments exist (with a time horizon of 5-10 years). I think if they existed, they would have dampened the stock market bubbles.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by selimthegrim on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:41PM (#21808807)
SWA and AA are morally responsible for some of these design choices. I’m sure they would come up in any suit vs Boeing
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by bumby on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:52PM (#21808919)
Is this regarding the airline delivery pressure that influenced schedule or some other mechanism?
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by selimthegrim on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:55PM (#21809398)
Not just schedule but design, training (SWA incentives)
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by briandear on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:53PM (#21810723)
Except none of their pilots crashed the plane despite flying an order of magnitude more flights than Ethiopian or Lion Air. The difference is that US pilots are far better trained and maintenance doesn’t skimp like Lion Air had a long history of doing. The Lion Air plane should have been grounded when the the AOA sensor was reported bad on the flight the day before the crash. The executive in charge of Lion Air maintenance should be in jail: they let the plane fly knowing the AOA sensor was faulty. The MEL for that airplane required the AOA sensor. For some reason we let Lion Air off the hook, but look at their history: one of the most dangerous airlines in existence and that isn’t Boeing’s fault.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by megablast on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:58PM (#21809419)
Index funds are so big now, the market rarely moves down.
Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January by notatoad on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:45PM (#21808292)
>The lawsuits that are surely incoming are going to pile-drive this company into the ground

I'm sure the lawsuits are coming, but we're talking about Boeing here. "pile drive them into the ground" might be a bit of an overstatement. Worst-case scenario, they have to be bailed out by the government.