Re:Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January
by ajxs on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:06PM
(#21819950)
> Don't we think competition is good? What happened to cheering on free markets?
No? Not really? Obviously competitions is good when it drives innovation, which is beneficial for domestic industry as a whole. Competition is not good for competition's sake. It's not good competition when Western players fall behind. This isn't some kind of hypocritical failing of free-market doctrines. You either don't understand what it intended to accomplish, or are deliberately misrepresenting it. I suspect the latter.
> Why exactly do we want a Western duopoly to continue to exist in perpetuity?
... Why wouldn't we want our own players to dominate the industry? I don't think any kind of monopoly/duopoly is a good thing, but I don't really think that's your point. Your use of the word 'Western' betrays your intent here.
> If Western countries believed their own rhetoric they'd be helping Russia and China to compete on the world stage – it would be a win for the entire globe.
Um... no? China's exports becoming more competitive would not be a win for the entire globe, it would be quite the opposite.
> The West does not have some God-given or divine-right to remain on top of the heap...
Of course not, God didn't put us on top of the heap either.
> China (and India) are going to eventually catch up, it's just a matter of time, the only thing up for debate in my mind is whether it's sooner rather than later, and I believe in China's case it's going to be upon us sooner than we expect.
No? Not really? Obviously competitions is good when it drives innovation, which is beneficial for domestic industry as a whole. Competition is not good for competition's sake. It's not good competition when Western players fall behind. This isn't some kind of hypocritical failing of free-market doctrines. You either don't understand what it intended to accomplish, or are deliberately misrepresenting it. I suspect the latter.
> Why exactly do we want a Western duopoly to continue to exist in perpetuity?
... Why wouldn't we want our own players to dominate the industry? I don't think any kind of monopoly/duopoly is a good thing, but I don't really think that's your point. Your use of the word 'Western' betrays your intent here.
> If Western countries believed their own rhetoric they'd be helping Russia and China to compete on the world stage – it would be a win for the entire globe.
Um... no? China's exports becoming more competitive would not be a win for the entire globe, it would be quite the opposite.
> The West does not have some God-given or divine-right to remain on top of the heap...
Of course not, God didn't put us on top of the heap either.
> China (and India) are going to eventually catch up, it's just a matter of time, the only thing up for debate in my mind is whether it's sooner rather than later, and I believe in China's case it's going to be upon us sooner than we expect.
I wouldn't hold your breath.