News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by mcv on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @08:59AM (#21524054)
A co-worker is really impressed with all the improvements, but they seem to mostly be improvements over previous poor ideas from Apple, that other brands already had or never abandoned.

I admit, a 16" screen in a 15" body sounds really nice. But most of this is stuff other brands already had.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:03AM (#21524114)
The other brands don't have macOS. Running a Mac isn't just hardware.

People were annoyed because they don't want to run a different OS. Yes, you could get cheaper/powerful hardware somewhere else... but it's not macOS. Hackintoshes need not apply here.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by mcv on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:06AM (#21524154)
And that's the big thing that keeps surprising me: that there's no laptop maker that produces high quality laptops with their own custom super nice Linux-based but Mac OS-like OS on it. Everybody seems content saddling their hardware with Windows.

Thing is, Mac OS isn't as great as it used to be either. They used to be brilliant developer laptops, but Apple seems to want everybody in their walled garden.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by IMTDb on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:10AM (#21524209)
> that there's no laptop maker that produces high quality laptops with their own custom super nice Linux-based but Mac OS-like OS on it

That would be System 76 https://system76.com/laptops/adder with their pop OS linux distro https://system76.com/pop

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by kitsunesoba on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:20AM (#21524328)
PopOS is great but I think system76 needs to design their laptops from scratch instead of relabeling Clevo laptops if they’re serious about challenging Apple. Their laptops have the specs, but the fit and finish is just not there.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Finnucane on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:37AM (#21524544)
I have a Clevo laptop (a few years old now) and even at the time, it was not exactly state of the art in terms of weight, battery life, etc. It's proven to be a fairly tough beast (even having fallen off my bike and lived). It is, unlike many new laptops, relatively easy to open up for upgrades and repair. Getting Apple's 'fit and finish' means a closed box.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by violinist on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:00PM (#21526341)
That's true now, but it doesn't have to be. Before the retina MacBook Pro, the MacBook Pro used to be one of the easiest laptops to service. Opening it up, it was very easy to access almost every component.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Finnucane on Friday November 15, 2019 @02:26PM (#21547916)
Those days aren't coming back.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by miguelr2201 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:37AM (#21525270)
When I was searching for a new laptop, I stumbled upon this comment from a System76 employee that goes into more depth about the work they do on new laptops that seems more than just relabelling Clevo laptops.

https://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/5umefi/system76_refr...

At the end, I went for a Lenovo V330 on sale since I couldn't justify the price of System76 plus shipping outside the US at the time.

Disclaimer: I'm not affiliated with System76 in any way and have never owned a System76 laptop.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by mcv on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:48AM (#21525414)
I'm thinking about using PopOS on my Thinkpad X1 Extreme, as it's rumoured to be the only Linux that supports hybrid graphics, and it's specifically designed for developers and other creators (which Macbook Pros once seemed to be).

Their hardware, though, seems to be meh. Give me this on some high quality hardware.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by asciimike on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:50AM (#21526202)
I dual book my X1 Extreme with Windows 10 and Pop OS and it works about 98%. The trackpad is buggy as hell, auto date/time switch is broken, and a few other minor usability issues endemic to using Linux just drive me crazy.

I've been debating hackintoshing it (https://github.com/Errrneist/Hackintosh-Thinkpad-X1-Extreme) but it seems like eGPU support isn't there and that's one of the primary use cases I got for this laptop (CAD primarily).

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by captn3m0 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:47AM (#21524678)
They are working towards it. Their new server hardware (or mini PC, forget which one) was designed and fabricated in-house.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by auiya on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:25AM (#21524396)
Not until there are accompanying ecosystem apps on par with Logic Pro, Final Cut, etc... I've found with almost every linux distro there's always an area where it falls short.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by moooo99 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:42AM (#21524599)
It absolutely depends on which "Pros" your targeting. A software developer obviously has different needs in terms of software than a video editor or UI designer. I use Windows at work and at university. My private desktop has a dualboot install with Windows and popOS. Works perfectly fine for me
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Finnucane on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:42AM (#21524598)
Yeah, that is still a problem. I couldn't really move completely away from the Mac until I got to a point where I didn't need InDesign anymore. There's no good Linux substitute, even for money. Sadly Adobe has hidden away FrameMaker, which started as a Unix program.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:17AM (#21524299)
You're going to get some responses where people say System76 and Pop_OS!, but it really only visually looks decent and optimizes much of the Linux laptop experience. It still doesn't have, for instance...

- Application support for graphics editors that people need in 2019... you can either run macOS or Windows for this

- Built-in cross-device syncing like iCloud/CloudKit

- Smooth integration with peripheral devices (e.g, HandOff)

This list could be extended for quite a ways, as people seemingly want to ignore part of what still makes macOS great - you have very well done product integration across the entire stack. I want it to "just work" in 2019 so I can live my life instead of tinkering with an OS/hardware combo.

The analogy I like to give people is that buying a Macbook is kind of like buying a BMW after years building your own tuner car. I'll always enjoy building my own, but man... if my daily driver breaks, I just wanna pay someone to fix it. Gimme the luxury feel already.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by gowld on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:26PM (#21527555)
A Mac is like a BMW, flashy, expensive, and always in the shop for repairs.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:58PM (#21527975)
Compared to Linux on a laptop: the over-tweaked Mazda RX7 rolling down the road, loud as hell, where the slightest wrong bump may give you hours of fun/hell in fixing parts. You're also missing seats because you put a roll-cage in for whatever reason.;P
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by thomascgalvin on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:59AM (#21525556)
One of the things that stops a custom Linux distro from taking off is the lack of support for pro applications. If you can't run Creative Cloud natively, it's a non-started for many people in the target market.

> Thing is, Mac OS isn't as great as it used to be either.

That's 100% true. MacOS gets a little worse with each new release.

But there is still one area where MacOS shines: backup and restore. I've had the same user account on five different machines now, because I just restore from a time machine backup every time I buy a new Mac.

And I cannot think of an easier way to backup my wife's laptop than pointing it at our time machine server and letting it just work.

Time machine is the biggest thing keeping me on MacOS right now. If your fancy Linux distro solved that, I'd be very tempted to switch.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by computerex on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:07PM (#21526458)
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by numbsafari on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:21AM (#21524335)
Give a Pixel Book a try.

It has plenty of differences from Mac OS, but most of them are positive.

If Google could get Adobe on-board with Linux support, and built a consumer foot-print a la Apple, I'd probably go there.

Dealing with their crappy third-party resellers is just a non-starter. It says that Google doesn't stand behind their own product with their own customer service, and I just can't abide that.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by zchrykng on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:27AM (#21524418)
> It has plenty of differences from Mac OS, but most of them are positive.

Like what? The lack of all desktop software? It is only even halfway decent if you live out of a web browser.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by abnry on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:12AM (#21525737)
With crostini you can now run linux apps. It is still in beta.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by agloeregrets on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @03:40PM (#21529279)
I tried this by the way, you pay in performance in a big way. Even if you don’t need hardware acceleration the general compile performance is bad, about 3X longer on a large angular project than a MacBook Air.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by zchrykng on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:49AM (#21526176)
Ah, good to know. Haven't tried Chromebooks in a while because I didn't want only a browser. Might revisit when this hits stable.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by computerex on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:11PM (#21526522)
It's a dirty dirty myth that you can only run Chrome in ChromeOS: https://github.com/skycocker/chromebrew

You don't even need Crostini.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by numbsafari on Thursday November 14, 2019 @02:07PM (#21538317)
Yeah, I was running Firefox via crostini for a while and it worked really well.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Abishek_Muthian on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:20AM (#21525078)
>If Google could get Adobe on-board with Linux support

Google may convince Adobe to make one for Android like in iPad Pro which will function fine on Chromebook, there's no reason for Adobe to start supporting Linux.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by zchrykng on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:25AM (#21524395)
The biggest problem with that idea is that you would need to convince the developers who write Mac software to also develop for Linux. There are some really powerful pieces of software on Linux, but almost none of them are designed half as nicely as most Mac software.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by read_if_gay_ on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:58AM (#21525540)
> There are some really powerful pieces of software on Linux, but almost none of them are designed half as nicely as most Mac software.

That is probably not because Mac developers are inherently more "design affine" but because there is a very clear design standard on MacOS while Linux is basically a complete clusterfuck with 20 different desktops etc. So it's not as much a matter of getting Mac devs to also make stuff for Linux as getting Linux to be more standardized.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by zchrykng on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:47AM (#21526161)
Yeah, could definitely be a combination factors. Mostly I think it is that people who care about design have frequently gravitated toward the mac because of their nice design.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by wdn on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:14AM (#21524258)
There is nothing wrong with Windows.

What surprise me is on the laptop keyboard layout has dedicated Print Screen and Insert keys but no Home and End keys.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by mbel on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:20AM (#21524331)
Windows Update makes Windows barely usable. Weekly restarts to update OS at random points in time are unacceptable. There are plenty of other usability issues, for me lack of working Unix-like shell out of the box is one of them.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by wayneftw on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:49AM (#21524707)
It's crazy how a billion people and millions of developers are using Windows when it's barely usable. Is there some small possibility that you're wrong about this?

Also, does macOS have a Unix shell that you can just start using for your work out of the box or do you have to use something like Homebrew to bring it up to modern standards first?

Usability is certainly an opinion. I can get a Unix shell on any OS, have been able to for decades. But we don't just want a shell do we? We want a decent desktop environment with a good system for managing application windows... We want updates that don't cause problems. We want a good file browser.

macOS has none of these things, not out of the box and not even with third party utilities to fix things and fill in missing features.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by adjkant on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @04:19PM (#21529710)
> Also, does macOS have a Unix shell that you can just start using for your work out of the box or do you have to use something like Homebrew to bring it up to modern standards first?

I'll take a Mac terminal over any Windows one, every time. Speaking as someone who uses all 3 OS's at work. The hoops I've had to jump through on Windows just to do basic things are maddening. Mac's terminal experience is one of the reasons I keep going back to it. I'm truly confused how one prefers a windows terminal.

> We want a decent desktop environment with a good system for managing application windows... We want updates that don't cause problems. We want a good file browser.

Again, you just described Mac. Spaces work amazing and still have better behavior than the windows version that's trying to catch up. Snapping left/right is nice in theory but I don't actually use it that much unless I'm on a huge monitor. And I have no idea what issues you see with Finder, which is generally a super smooth experience for me. Again, I'm just really confused here.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by agloeregrets on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @03:39PM (#21529261)
I’m confused about your issues...

The current shell in macOS is zSh and the Mac wrote the book on window management (other than the windows snapping ideas, which, fair, but it is just one app. On the other hand, macOS is like a wonderful land between windows and Linux with ease of use plus all the power features.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by FpUser on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:04AM (#21524891)
"..Windows Update makes Windows barely usable..." I find this claim to be over exaggerated. I'm not exactly sure how their update schedule works exactly but in my case it updates some parts transparently without me needing to stop working. Updates that require reboot definitely do not happen once per week and never when I am in front of computer.

I have no problems with access to working "Unix like" shell either. My laptops and desktop are beastly and have no problem running Ubuntu in VM. WSL works like a charm as well. But I rarely use either since for Linux development work and for running servers I use real Linux computers in headless mode running NoMachine for remote access. Windows being used for developing Windows GUI software duh, and for productivity tools, Video, Photo, CAD, PCB design etc. etc.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by computerex on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:13PM (#21526567)
To be fair, I think these days Windows has a better auto-update story than OSX. They may both be equally annoying. I have suffered involuntary restarts on both operating systems.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:14PM (#21526577)
The big difference is that I can turn off auto update on OS X. It's not even on by default, although you are encouraged to enable it.

(Apple has the ability to forcibly push updates, but they almost never use it.)

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by computerex on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:44PM (#21527042)
I have never turned on auto-update, and I have had my work laptop restart on me without my permission. It simply showed me a dialogue box stating that the computer is going to restart upon hitting ok and that I better save my work. Where I work, we mob program, and this has happened to my team mates on many occasions.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:15PM (#21527399)
...well, I'm quite confused, because this has never happened to me.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by beefalo on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @02:45PM (#21528612)
It's happened to me frequently. I think it may be from corp device management forcing security updates
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @03:00PM (#21528779)
Ah, that explains it! Especially since GP was also referring to a work machine.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by AtlasLion on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:16PM (#21527410)
Windows has full linux distros installed from the store. Unlike mac that comes with outdated shell and yout have to trust whoever it is that runs brew.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by LeonThePro on Monday November 18, 2019 @08:43AM (#21564216)
Technically not yet, once WSL2 is mainline there will finally be proper Linux support in Windows. WSL1 is a series of shimmed calls to the NT Kernel and as a first implementation it’s pretty bad ass but to call it an environment for full Linux distros is misleading consider things like systemd are completely missing at the moment.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by antonyh on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:40AM (#21526074)
This is a solved problem now. It no longer does the restart thing (or hasn't for a long time). It gives a 7-day pause option too.

The two things that break Windows are spaces-in-filenames, and max-filepath-length. Urgh.

MacOS is broken in a different way: no more 32-bit (so the death of legacy applications) and notarization (need an Apple thumbs-up to run programs).

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Joeri on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:34PM (#21526884)
Windows updates go out once a month unless there’s a massive problem. If you’re seeing weekly restarts it is not microsoft that’s doing that.

I see a restart prompt about once every two months on my sole remaining w10 laptop, and it hasn’t forced a reboot on me in the middle of my work in over a year. Ubuntu prompts me to restart more often.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by teddyc on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:51AM (#21524727)
I dislike Windows too, but PowerShell is pretty nice if you are stuck in the Windows environment. It's not really a Unix-like shell, but it is comfortable enough compared to the rest of the ecosystem.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by rado on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:12AM (#21524976)
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by antonyh on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:37AM (#21526037)
That's build 10162. It's now on build 18362.

That's like comparing current MacOS with one from years ago which also has some weird UI things going on. In Windows, certainly some of these have been fixed but aside from being visual anomalies everything works.

The kicker for me is Apple hiding / removing the things I use, such as Keychain in the menu bar. OSX / MacOS is slowly getting worse.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by rado on Thursday November 14, 2019 @02:36AM (#21533543)
Windows is getting worse. They are adding crazy design ideas that they can't possibly support, with new UI quirks. While the foundation is tragically broken (typography differences etc). The new timeline has a hilarious hiccup in the animation that makes no sense at all.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by HeWhoLurksLate on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:11AM (#21524219)
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by yowlingcat on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:18AM (#21524315)
The challenge with Linux on the desktop is achieving a seamlessly integrated between drivers, software and hardware. Achieving even parity with OSX is a tall ask and likely extremely challenging, but I'm certainly rooting for them. Trying to install vanilla Windows and Ubuntu the other day on my desktop reminded me how much of a challenge playing the driver hockey game was. I eventually settled on a stable configuration (thank goodness), but it really dawned on me how much more I would have paid for something that worked perfectly out of box and remained working perfectly out of the box. My time is valuable! If I get an OSX laptop, I know I can rely on certain foundational things working without any tweaking which I _could_ do but would really rather avoid.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by lallysingh on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:10AM (#21524965)
Thinkpad on mobile system 76 on desktop.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by yowlingcat on Wednesday November 20, 2019 @08:51PM (#21590713)
You've got a point! I haven't tried a system 76 yet, but I have nothing but respect for them. To be honest, I wish they'd more aggressively compete for mindshare in the professional market than OSX -- imagine what the world would be like if the default startup/bigco laptop were a system76.

Beyond that, for the desktop at least, I didn't realize how competitive they were on cost -- wow! I'm not sure why, but it looks like I can't configure it in a 4GPU configuration. If I could, while there would be a price premium over what I paid for my devbox, I think it could be worthwhile given the polish.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by AtlasLion on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:11PM (#21527354)
Windows 10 has improved a lot and in many ways gives better user experience than MacOS. And for terminal needs, yout very an actual linux environment fully updated with latest software unlike the hack that brew on mac is.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Abishek_Muthian on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:38AM (#21526056)
>laptops with their own custom super nice Linux-based

They did, they're Pixelbook from Google. Once you build a competitive 'mass market' laptop with Linux, you'll inevitably end up with something like ChromeOS.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by criddell on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:19AM (#21525052)
People buy a Mac or Windows machine because they want to run Mac or Windows software. What good does a super high quality Linux laptop do for the person that needs to run Visual Studio?
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by basch on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:33AM (#21524485)
Thats basically huawei and deepin.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by albertzeyer on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:35AM (#21524516)
The quality of MacOSX just degraded over the last 5 years or so. It became buggier and slower. At this point, I would actually prefer Linux for my main desktop instead of macOS (if the hardware is well supported by Linux). I used to like macOS, but just as the hardware, it became worse and worse. So, comparing the MacBook with another notebook with similar hardware quality which is well supported by Linux, I would prefer the Linux notebook.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Frost1x on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:23AM (#21524359)
I recently went through the experience of having to adopt OS X after switching employers coming from primarily using unix flavors and Windows my entire career, avoiding OS X at every turn.

My summarized conclusion is that: OS X isn't that great. It's not "bad," don't get me wrong, but it's nothing marvelous. Perhaps at one point in time there was some advantage over a Windows or linux environment but at this point in time, unless you're tied to some package tied to a specific environment for some reason, just work with the environment you're most comfortable with. I don't know how much time I've had to waste adjusting to the OS X environment (especially muscle memory keyboard shortcuts I'm accustomed to), finding replacement niche applications that were environment specific, figuring out how to do basic tasks that are simply different.

On that note, avoid committing to a specific environment unless your application really needs to squeeze out every cycle of performance. It's 2019 and we have portable options now for most application demands.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:30AM (#21524450)
Your experience is just you finding what you like and then running up against something doing it differently. This is like moving to another country and complaining the culture is different.

In which case, move home or somewhere else more to your liking? There's nothing inherently wrong with the way things work on Mac.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Frost1x on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:21AM (#21525869)
I think the point was missed since this reiterates what I stated. The analogy isn't correct.

I have nothing against OS X but why switch if there's no justification other than for the sake of doing it (unless it's to satisfy your own interest, in which case: don't complain)?

Using the above analogy: why would I move from... NYC to HK if there's no reason to do so? Why push someone or promote a change from X to Y unless there's a justified rationale for it? Change for the sake of change isn't inherently justifiable in-and-of-itself.

Pushing OS X as being generically inferior (or superior) needs justification because I don't necessarily see it.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by ProZsolt on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:35PM (#21526909)
I agree with you. I have the same feeling with Linux. I'm on Mac and don't have any real upside changing to Linux.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by FabHK on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:35AM (#21524513)
1. I think we can agree that making a switch of OS imposes quite some costs. You made the switch to macOS and found it all right. Now imagine I'd make the switch from macOS to some other OS - I'm quite certain that it would be worse.

2. I've used Windows and macOS concurrently, and was always amazed at how bad the Windows experience was (though, yes, it has improved, and unfortunately, as alluded to by Gruber in his piece on the new MBP [1], Apple has paid too much attention to looks and not enough to functionality in the last half decade).

3. I found most "portable" options (eg Electron, qt, etc.) generally worse than native apps. Exceptions are pure CLI tools - they're great (use homebrew on the Mac to manage those!)

[1] https://daringfireball.net/2019/11/16-inch_macbook_pro_first...

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Semaphor on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:50AM (#21525443)
Disclaimer: My apple experience is pretty much limited to trying to figure out why Safari is the only browser once again not doing things right, to helping my mother with her iPhone and to trying to make iTunes work in an (imo) sane way.

> Now imagine I'd make the switch from macOS to some other OS - I'm quite certain that it would be worse.

My impression of everything Apple has always been "There is one god-given way to do a thing. And it’s wonderful". But as soon as you don’t want to do it that way, things become weird or impossible.

If that’s even close to the truth, it would make a lot of sense that the opposite road is hard as you are trained to do things one certain way only.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by FabHK on Thursday November 14, 2019 @09:39AM (#21535673)
> Apple has always been "There is one god-given way to do a thing. And it’s wonderful". But as soon as you don’t want to do it that way, things become weird or impossible

Interesting, I find hacking and automating and customising on macOS much easier than on Windows, with the UNIX underpinnings and command line tools and Automator and script support etc.

(iOS - agreed, that's a walled garden)

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by shantly on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:43PM (#21527765)
Yep, it's the high reliability & quality of the first party software (Safari, their office apps, notes, and so on), the excellent battery life (largely due to the software—run a browser other than Safari and watch that benefit take a huge hit), having a Unixy OS that's way less of a PITA on a laptop than Linux (ran it for years as my main OS, including on a Thinkpad, so yes, I'm familiar), and the touchpad that doesn't make me feel like I have to have a mouse to use the machine for more than five minutes, that keep me on board.

There were other things (good-enough port selection complementing the high battery life and good trackpad to mean I could just grab my laptop and go for nearly any situation, without taking anything else, being high among them) but they're gone now. It's basically the software and the trackpad keeping me around. I'd rather use a "worse" Macbook specs-wise than a Win10 or Linux laptop that's much better on paper, because the experience will still suck far less. Design, "thinness", trendiness, all that, don't give a shit. Give me a brick of a Thinkpad with an Apple trackpad, official macOS support, and a 20% lower price than a MBP at same specs, and I'll take that option in a heartbeat.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by enedil on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:54PM (#21527911)
That's not macOS, I'm using Linux on my MacBook for two years now and it feels pleasurable to use the touchpad just as it was before.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @04:32PM (#21529835)
No, this _is_ macOS - you won't have the same gesture(s), the fidelity, on other OS's. Apple goes to great lengths to ensure their trackpad is amazing on both the hardware and software side, and it shows. The drivers on Linux even running on a Macbook don't compare.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by canuckintime on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:06AM (#21524144)
> Yes, you could get cheaper/powerful hardware somewhere else...

would you agree with this change to your description?:

"Yes, you could get [better] hardware somewhere else..."

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by aequitas on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:14AM (#21524247)
I wouldn't. Maybe on pure specs, yes. But there is just no substitute for me for the trackpads Apple builds into their laptops. And the overall quality and longevity of the devices. I've only bought/got a new Apple device because I could, never because I had to (ie: it was broken/unusable).
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by mcv on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:27AM (#21524419)
My old Macbook Pro from 2011 just broke. But that's certainly a respectable lifespan. I never replaced it because no new Macbook excited me like that one: they were increasingly hard to maintain, glued components, no 17 inch screen anymore, and keyboards kept getting worse.

When it finally broke down, I got a Thinkpad.

This new 16" Macbook would be the first in years that I'd consider, but it's just a couple of months too late. I found my replacement.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by aequitas on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:55AM (#21524775)
I was afraid of having to go that path when Apple would continue with their direction in pro hardware. I was only allowed to use a Linux laptop (Dell) in my previous job and even with how customizable Linux is I just could never get comfortable with it.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by FpUser on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @10:19AM (#21525067)
" I've only bought/got a new Apple device because I could, never because I had to (ie: it was broken/unusable)."

Same case for me but desktops and laptops are Windows based. Laptops: very old Toshiba which was super nice at the time. After that gaming laptops from Asus and HP. All desktops are built to order from the components I chose.

Hardware problems during last 20 years:

3 hard drives had died (one on desktop, 2 on servers). Does not mean of course that I use the same one for 20 years. Keep upgrading them every once in a while as the amount of stuff I have to keep grows.

1 Video card from nVidia died.

1 Desktop began crashing. Further investigation revealed that thermal paste deteriorated completely and the CPU would shutdown after a very short while. Put new thermal paste and all works again like a charm.

Other then that I kept upgrading things but now it does not happen so often as the hardware became generally good enough for just about anything. Well I am sort of looking at that new 32 Core AMD for server when it comes out.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by AtlasLion on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:22PM (#21527495)
Not only on pure specs. By any measure you'd like. Apple device have some of the worst build quality of the industry. Watch a guy that repairs them daily list the issues for you. I'd challenge you to show a similar list of huge design flaws of any other manufacturer. https://youtu.be/AUaJ8pDlxi8
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:11AM (#21524222)
Not really, "better" hardware is subjective in a laptop. For all the complaining people do, Apple is very good about ensuring that the hardware in their machines works as expected and hits a solid baseline performance level for given tasks.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by wlesieutre on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:17AM (#21524291)
Except for the keyboard fiasco, obviously
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by theklr on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:21AM (#21525868)
Anecdotes ≠ fact
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by computerex on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:28PM (#21526789)
The butterfly keyboard had design flaws. This is a well known and well documented fact. There is literally an Apple keyboard repair program for the butterfly keyboard, and this new MacBook pro uses a different keyboard design altogether.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by FireBeyond on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:16PM (#21526607)
When something rises to the level of a recall, especially for Apple (who denied that logic board issues were an issue on two separate models of MBP for me for months before issuing recalls), it rises a bit beyond "anecdote".
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by theklr on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @02:03PM (#21528055)
I may have not been verbose in the first post, but it was intended to be less about the technical and more about how there's this weird demand culture just because we know a couple people who have a similar issue.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by wlesieutre on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @03:26PM (#21529113)
Slightly larger anecdata then: I have a group chat with some friends where we were discussing the 16" MBP announcement this morning. One computer out of six has (so far) gotten by with a reliably performing keyboard.

Some of the others haven't gotten bad enough to deal with shipping them off for repair, but that doesn't mean they're working acceptably.

But I'll concede it's possible that this all a coincidence and we're a very unlucky sample. There's probably not a good source of hard numbers, since Apple only know about the ones who were able to deal with getting it repaired. I read that they're trying to do next-day turnaround for in-store keyboard replacements now, but not all of us live anywhere near an Apple Store.

For another point of reference, a poll from Basecamp: https://m.signalvnoise.com/the-macbook-keyboard-fiasco-is-su...

Specifically take note of the 2018 numbers. 6 of 13 keyboards having problem, and if every single one of those was purchased the day the 2018 model was released, they're a maximum of 10 months old when the poll was taken. Many of them are likely newer than that. 6 out of 13 in less than a year. Even if there's a biased sample in who responded to this, that's a lot of bad keyboards.

Anyway, I’m glad to see a new keyboard design, and if I seem salty about it that’s because I’m personally annoyed at my 2016’s keyboard and all Apple can do about it is replace it with another of the same keyboard that will probably fail in the same way again.

EDIT - corrected my group figures. One person has a working keyboard. And for what it's worth, another person who works in IT hasn't seen an overwhelming failure rate in their office (knock on wood, he notes). But most them are using external keyboards for data entry (with numpads), so the internal keys aren’t used heavily.

His own MBP is counted among the failed ones though.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by weberc2 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:15AM (#21524278)
If that’s true, I haven’t found it when I’ve shopped for a laptop to install Linux onto. This wasn’t always the case, but right around the time of Windows 8 when everything needed a touchscreen and chromebooks were eating the low end of the market, good affordable hardware seemingly disappeared. I would have to spend $1500 to get something in the same ballpark as an entry level MacBook and it would still have profoundly terrible touchpad (whether running Linux or Windows, it never mattered), a mediocre keyboard, a plastic body, and noisy fans.

Chromebooks do offer better hardware per dollar than other computers, but you are (or perhaps were) pretty locked-into the ChromeOS, or at least none of the workarounds seemed palatable. So if you like ChromeOS then there is better value hardware out there, but Mac is it for the rest of us.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by computerex on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:31PM (#21526834)
There is a lot of competition in the laptop space now. Apple no longer produces hands down the best notebooks in terms of hardware. The touchpad on the new Lenovo/Dell laptops have gotten very very good. Same goes for screen quality.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by weberc2 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:40PM (#21526988)
Good to know. I'll have to check them out. My ~2015 Lenovo touchpad is utterly abysmal.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by kelnos on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:20AM (#21524329)
I've had the opposite problem: I love Apple hardware, but have never been a big fan of macOS. Unfortunately, since 2016 or so, Apple has been putting so much non-standard, proprietary hardware in their laptops (getting worse and worse every year) that the struggle to get Linux running well enough on them has been more than I've cared to deal with, so I recently jumped ship (junk like the Touch Bar and the general keyboard issues haven't helped my opinion either). I genuinely do like my new Dell XPS 13, but it still just doesn't have the same nice feel that a MacBook does.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by H1Supreme on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:12AM (#21524231)
> Hackintoshes need not apply here.

If it's just about running MacOS, they absolutely apply.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:22AM (#21524349)
MacOS as an experience includes things like proper handoff support, Messages support, and so on - things that historically become a pain in the ass with a Hackintosh.

So no, I don't consider it the same. It's a great hack if you want a ton of power for a build machine, but otherwise... I'd rather pay the financial cost up front and just be done with it.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Aperocky on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:43PM (#21527759)
The only thing linux/other laptop manufacturer need at this point is better touchbar.

There are nothing else making the macbook lines worth it. If Linux with hardware manufacturer come up with a standard for greater touchbar control, the mac will be out of circulation in no time.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Keyframe on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:38AM (#21524547)
You're saying that like macOS is a plus here.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Klonoar on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:40AM (#21524573)
...to those who choose to run it, yes, it is.

I've noted this in a few other comments here but there's more to it than just the base computing system. Apple products as an ecosystem dwarf whatever you'd cobble together in some homegrown Linux-based setup, and Windows in general just feels... really messy, like there's no clear consensus on how the ecosystem should work.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by 8draco8 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:15AM (#21524273)
Let's face it iOS and need for software for it is keeping Apple computers alive. If one day it would be possible to develop iOS apps on other operating systems Macs sales would crash.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by lawtalkinghuman on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:44AM (#21524631)
Citation needed.

Every software company I've worked in building websites/webapps (Ruby, Python, Java, HTML/CSS/JS/React/whatever etc.) tends to issue their developers with MBPs. None of them need to do so for Xcode to build Mac/iOS apps. A few people may opt for Lenovos running Linux, but they're a distinct minority who really likes compiling their own tiling window manager from scratch etc.

Why MBP as standard? Because you get a reasonably stable Unix box that also runs commercial business and productivity software (Office, video conference stuff), and the Adobe suite for the front-end/creative folks.

Windows is going after that with WSL. Linux is going after that with, err, GNU/Freedom I guess?

Writing Python/Ruby/JavaScript/Java/Go/Elixir/whatever hot new shiny, in Atom or Vim or VSCode, is about as easy on Linux as it is on Mac (and it is getting better on Windows with WSL). But when you've got to use some awful video conferencing corporate crapware, there's at least some chance it'll work on a Mac in a way it won't on Linux.

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Matthias247 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:09PM (#21526481)
Just a guess - but you are in the US, right? In most other places of the world I have not seen macbooks being used for non Apple related development tasks due to pricing.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by rimliu on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @03:29PM (#21529153)
I am in Europe, and in the country that used to be a part of USSR. The last four companies I worked for also offered Macbooks for developers by default.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by Matthias247 on Thursday November 14, 2019 @02:07AM (#21533423)
It's interesting to hear. I have not seen a lot of Macbooks in any of the companies I worked for nor the one we partnered with in germany. At least in software development, in creative domains (photo, video) things are different.

In north america Macbooks seem to be more or less the default hardware (also mainly my personal impressions - since I moved there).

Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by simonh on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @04:03PM (#21529526)
That seems unlikely given that the Air range are by far the most popular models, and are squarely aimed at the mass consumer market. Also it’s seems a bit unlikely the masses of people crowding in the Apple stores in the UK all the time are all developers.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by lawtalkinghuman on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:33PM (#21527642)
UK.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by AtlasLion on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @12:39PM (#21526970)
you get a reasonably stable Unix box that also runs some commercial business software and worst terminal experience than running full ubuntu on windows wsl. Ubuntu on WSL> brew on mac.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by simonh on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:34AM (#21524499)
The worldwide installed base of the Mac is 100 million. There only a bit over 2 million apps in the app store, so it seems unlikely a large proportion of those 100 million Macs are used to develop iOS apps.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by aikinai on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:30AM (#21524443)
You really think iOS developers are the majority of Mac sales? You can debunk that in two minutes of Googling.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by 8draco8 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:33AM (#21524490)
Be my guest. iOS devs and people that are locked with MacOS exclusive apps are most of the professional customers.
Re:16-inch MacBook Pro by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @09:50AM (#21524717)
Changing your assertion from Mac users in general to "professionals" is moving the goal posts a long way.

As of last year, roughly 10% of all personal computers on the internet are Macs. Do you think a majority of those--say 6% of all PC users worldwide--are iOS devs and other professional MacOS lock-ins?