News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:26AM (#21222743)
Why should we send people further than orbit, rather than robots? Robotic missions have been huge successes - you could have teams of people lead many robotic missions instead of one very limited human visit.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by twic on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:28AM (#21223021)
You may be interested in "Dispelling the myth of robotic efficiency" [1]:

> There is a widely held view in the astronomical community that unmanned robotic space vehicles are, and always will be, more efficient explorers of planetary surfaces than astronauts (e.g. Coates 2001, Clements 2009, Rees 2011). Partly this comes from a common assumption that robotic exploration is cheaper than human exploration (although this isn't necessarily true if like is compared with like) and partly from the expectation that developments in technology will relentlessly increase the capability and reduce the size and cost of robotic missions to the point that human exploration will not be able to compete. I argue below that the experience of human exploration during the Apollo missions, more recent field analogue studies and trends in robotic space exploration all point to exactly the opposite conclusion.

[1] https://academic.oup.com/astrogeo/article/53/2/2.22/212515

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by mannykannot on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:43AM (#21223374)
This looks like a case study in tendentious reasoning - for example "This is because much of the scientific benefit of human missions will consist of samples returned, drill cores drilled and geophysical instruments deployed, all of which were demonstrated by Apollo on the Moon, but none of which have been achieved by the MERs nor will be achieved by the more capable (and vastly more expensive) Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) that is due to land on Mars in 2012."

MSL is "vastly more expensive" than what? Not Apollo, and not a human mission to Mars, which are the benchmarks that matter in this context.

I am not opposed to manned missions, but the case for their utility is thin, to say the least.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by bluGill on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:08AM (#21223510)
It is cheaper and easier for a robot to return samples from mars if that is what we want to do. However not by much: either way you now have to carry a rocket and fuel to mars to get back with. It is generally cheaper just carry a full lab and study samples on mars.

Where humans excel is on the spot decision making: looking around and saying "that looks interesting, I'm going to ignore the mission plan and go over there instead". That is where great breakthroughs are found, but it is also where mission control gets mad because the important things everyone was interested in don't get studied for something pretty but otherwise uninteresting.

We know from earth that there are some interesting geographical features that are only a couple meters wide: such features on mars would not be visible from earth. Thus whatever is on mars needs to recognize interesting things and find it. Humans intuitively recognize interesting things (and do better with just a little training). Teaching computers to recognize such features is a hard, partially unsolved problem.

On the moon you can do remote control of robots from earth and get the same level of power from a robot if you want it. (do not read can as we should - there are reasons to not do remote control) You can't do that on mars unless you are working at a speed of meters/day, so whatever is on mars needs to have local control to decide how to get around and what samples to get.

Robots generally do best for solved problems. A factory can replace 100 humans with saws with two robots and get more accuracy, but the shapes being cut out of a flat sheet of steel of a standard size. When you only need one part it is often faster to have a human with a saw cut it out (this is less and less true as the design to part chain gets better).

The truth is there are advantages to both.

At the current state of technology humans can do more than robots. However robots are enough cheaper that we use them anyway: we still don't have the ability to get anything back from mars. Ethically we will not send humans on a one way trip with enough supplies to live on mars for two weeks and then die, so humans are not an option yet.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:39AM (#21223722)
While robots will carry a certain array of sensors, imo a robotic mission has better ability to choose what to examine and choose what to spend time on, because the mission has experts that can think about these decisions for a week before making a call. The mission is under no significant time pressure when things go off-script.

The time pressure of a manned mission is significant - this ability to make decisions quickly is only necessary because of the time constraints of a manned mission and the need to be careful enough to get back. This time pressure can be a factor in making mistakes and irrepairably damaging the instruments or hardware you brought. In one instance, Apollo crew has destroyed a camera they brought by accidentally pointing it into the sun for example.

The flexibility of humans does not give any significant benefit if those humans don't have the time to use it. When every minute is planned for something, with some buffers to make mistakes, your ability to improvise only comes in to remedy your mistakes. And some are not fixable. The operation is exciting and all rests on the ability of 2-3 people and the preparation of dozens and their skill under time pressure.

A robotic mission has months to remedy some fuckups and come up with workarounds. Some things are not fixable either. But a robotic mission has all the knowledge of a team of experts and is not put on the spot - they don't need to be as superhuman. The operation is comparatively boring and rests on the ability of dozens of scientists and engineers. They don't have to prepare for contingencies as much, they can analyze a situation, compare plans, simulate consequences (such as software patches, hardware operation) and act on them.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dr_zoidberg on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:41AM (#21223744)
Not just on the spot decision making (there are human operators behind Curiosity after all), but improvising a solution to a problem that was not contemplated.

Take for example the lunar rover fender that broke, and they patched together a solution on the spot. And compare that to the Insight Lander mole, which found a particularly hard-to-drill rock and can't move from the spot (after all, it's a lander, not a rover). Now they are trying to push it with the landers arm, but there's only so much that can be done.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by beerandt on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:22AM (#21224064)
>Where humans excel is on the spot decision making: looking around and saying "that looks interesting, I'm going to ignore the mission plan and go over there instead"

This is where the real advantage is. Intuitive curiosity is not something AI is anywhere near being able to replicate in a useful way. Plus being able to explain why something is interesting and worth investigating. Look at image recognition- even where it's extremely accurate, in the instances where it screws up, we topically have no idea why. (Like confusing a leopard with a hair brush.) Which in the context of exploration is not very useful. If we don't know why the AI finds a feature interesting, then how are we (or the AI itself) supposed to know what to do about it? How to further study it?

Every other comparison between humans and robots is somewhat debatable depending on context and mission.

Secondary is certainly reaction time, especially in the context of timely investigation. As someone mentioned elsewhere with large scale drilling, many types of equipment still require a human operator with near-realtime feedback to be used effectively and efficiently in a non-specialized manor.

If a rover on Mars rolls around a boulder and spots a little green man, or a pink Martian rabbit, they're probably not going to hang around and wait to be studied. More likely, it might dig a hole, uncovering water or some other unknown material that's evaporated or sublimated before it gets instructions on how to react. Of course if it's a pink martian rabbit, we'll have to wait 8-12 years to develop and delete a new rover with trapping capabilities. :-)

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by j9461701 on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:16AM (#21223570)
> Compare the 35.7 km traversed in three days by the Apollo 17 astronauts in December 1972 with the almost identical distance (34.4 km) traversed by the Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity in eight years.

Yes, and the Rover costs 1/150th the price. We could send up literally a hundred rovers for the cost of the Apollo program and still have billions of dollars left to burn. We could build a giant Nolan Joker style money pyramid and roast marshmallows.

More-over all modern Mars missions are done on a relatively shoe-string budget using robots NASA knows are much less capable than they feasibly could construct. Basically Opportunity only went 34.4 km in 8 years because it was built by the NASA equivalent of 2 guys in a shed for beer money. Since the humiliating loss of Mars Climate Orbiter NASA has focused only on sending things to Mars they're not quite so afraid to lose, which means rather drastically reduced rover capabilities and lessened scientific payloads.

>Greatly increased efficiency in sample collection and sample return capacity. Compare the 382 kg of samples returned by Apollo with the 0.32 kg from the Russian robotic sample return missions Lunas 16, 20 and 24, and the zero kg returned so far by any robotic mission to Mars.

This is comparing apples to oranges. One of the great benefits of robots is they don't have to come back, which massively saves on the budget. Manned missions by necessity do need to bring about 3 x 75 pounds of dead weight (aka 3 man crew) back home, so you may as well have them line their pockets with rocks if you're just burning money anyway.

>Increased potential for large-scale exploratory activities (e.g. drilling) and the deployment and maintenance of complex equipment.

This I do agree with. Large scale drilling in the asteroid built would actually benefit from human presence, as it's far enough from Earth that light speed lag is non-trivial and mining in space will likely be a very complex, novel situation that will benefit from human level intelligence.

But just walking around on Mars, doing sample collecting? The case seems extremely thin. Especially as, even by the article's own admission, robots are improving to the point a human is only "1-2x better" than modern AI-assisted drones. Rather than the 1500x human-robot performance disparity the author highlights for earlier robots. Given the relative costs of people and robots, it's very much still tilted in favor of drones.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by andruby on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:22AM (#21223609)
You can't compare the price of the Apollo program with one Mars rover mission. The Mars rover missions built upon the discoveries and experience from the Apollo missions.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by keiferski on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:49AM (#21222833)
Robotic missions are multiple orders of magnitude less inspiring or interesting to society as a whole, probably because human beings like to see human beings doing things.

For a good example, consider that the Moon Landing was a global, civilization-wide event, whereas even the most famous robotic mission has never been anything more than a popular news item of the week.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:36AM (#21223692)
But the latter moon landings were news items of the week. And the latter shuttle flights weren't even that, unless they were carrying interesting cargo.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by KuiN on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:48AM (#21223797)
The last human on the moon was almost 50 years ago. Shuttle flights (barring obvious exceptions) were pretty routine; definitely not the most inspiring missions. But humans back on the Moon, or on Mars, in the 21st century and setting up colonies? That's completely different proposition.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:54AM (#21223849)
Building a colony on Mars or Luna, beyond the celebratory beginning, is brickie work in a spacesuit. The inspiration will pale rapidly.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:07AM (#21223943)
Even billionaires can find their lives boring. No human is safe from adapting to their environment and the banality of it.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:04AM (#21223921)
This is true, in the movie Apollo 13 it's portrayed as part of the plot that TV stations don't want to do a live broadcast of the mission. This is based on historical fact. Even Mission Control told them to cut it short because there was a Baseball game on. The broad public was only interested once something went wrong.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by travisoneill1 on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:53AM (#21224344)
Spacex did a 150m test hop and even that got 2.5 million views, so I think you are underestimating the interest. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYb3bfA6_sQ
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:05AM (#21224464)
Youtube Views < mainstream media reach.

Numbers at population scale are hard to think in.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by cpuguy83 on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:02AM (#21224435)
As someone who lived in Florida most of my life, I can say that people were/are still in awe of every rocket that blasts off... probably because we could see it happen.

Maybe not quite as interested as when things were first getting going, but that's human nature "meh I've seen it before".

But even so, watching the shuttle and SpaceX go up is definitely exciting to those who can actually see it.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by nine_k on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:14AM (#21223224)
> inspiring or interesting

That is, less of a... show?

What lasting effects of the moon landing(s) are there, to your mind?

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dotancohen on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:33AM (#21223320)
Yes, less of a show.

Ask around at NASA labs how people got into the industry. Among those who were born up until 1970ish, almost every single one will tell you that he was inspired by the moon landings. The trend goes on even outside NASA, when asking people in STEM industries.

Furthermore, I would argue - though I have not seen a study on it - that these are the most enthusiastic people, those who love their work.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by keiferski on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:55AM (#21223443)
If you want to build a ship, don’t drum up the men to gather wood, divide the work, and give orders. Instead, teach them to yearn for the vast and endless sea.

- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

Pretty apt for space travel, as well. The Moon Landing and Sci-Fi have probably done more for getting people into in science than a million textbooks and outreach programs.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by andruby on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:29AM (#21223642)
Indeed. Antoine de Saint-Exupéry did end up writing the The Little Prince [0], a renown novella about a space faring prince.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Little_Prince

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Gravityloss on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:06AM (#21222909)
You can first send robot to do slow and simple things, but once you want to do more, humans are much more effective.

From Steven Squyres, NASA Mars Rover Principal investigator:

> What Spirit and Opportunity typically achieve in a day, a human explorer could do in less than a minute. The Opportunity rover has traversed about 17 km in its five and a half year lifetime; this is less than the distance covered by two astronauts in their Lunar Roving Vehicle in a single EVA on Apollo 17.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dikei on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:15AM (#21223225)
What about the energy efficiency though ? Would it take less energy to keep the robots alive for 2.5 years than bringing 2 astronauts there and back ?
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dotancohen on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:59AM (#21223471)
Would you rather have 2.5 years of the same types of measurements (temp, pressure, magnetic flux) because you only sent those instruments, or a week of completely serendipitous data (orange regolith, the smell of lunar surface after reclosing the hatch, many others)?
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by bluGill on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:14AM (#21223555)
I need both for different reasons.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Retric on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:12AM (#21223213)
What an odd metric. The moon cars only averaged 30 km total per mission, meanwhile we can send a hundred rovers for the same price. That’s why people think sending humans for brief trips is pointless. It’s the instruments you’re sending that collect data and sending people means you get vastly less data back, for the same price.

Self sustaining colonization is a worthwhile goal. Having people wander around on the surface of the Moon or Mars does not get you there anymore than learning to jump really high can teach you to fly.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dotancohen on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:40AM (#21223353)

  > it’s the instruments you’re sending that collect data
When you know what data you want to collect (temperature, pressure, chemical composition) then I agree that robots are far more efficient. However, humans will measure the things that you didn't know were there. Discovery.

There were countless examples from the Lunar missions. Just as an example that comes to mind, we sent no colour cameras to the lunar surface as "there was nothing of colour to photograph". Despite that, I believe on the last lunar landing Schmidt (or Cernan?) noticed that the regolith was actually orange in some places.

You could argue that instead of a black and white camera, a colour camera could have been sent. But that is a different instrument package, and just as likely a million other sensor packages could have been sent. That is one human advantage - we have an extremely extensive array of sensors that come with us. In addition to those sensors, humans have processing and reasoning skills, dexterous hands, mobile legs, random-access memory, and are preprogrammed to solve problems, take interest in anomilies, and make connections between seemingly-disparate events.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dr_zoidberg on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:52AM (#21223835)
During Apollo, color cameras were sent to the moon (both photographic and video cameras). But the "disease" you're pointing at rings a bell in my mind: the JunoCam.

If it had been for the science team, Juno would've gone without it. It was added as a late-time PR addition, based on hardware from a previous mission (the descent imager of the Curiosity rover). And yet, it has given some of the most astounding images from Jupiter we've ever seen.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by baq on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:28AM (#21225295)
it was designed to do exactly that though, those images simply aren't that interesting from a scientific perspective - but the scientists finally understood that public perception of science is at least in the same order of magnitude of importance as scientific results themselves.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Retric on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:50AM (#21223818)
We did send color cameras to the moon. Earthrise being a rather famous example:

https://www.nasa.gov/multimedia/imagegallery/image_feature_1...

As are those color photos of the lunar flag:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Flag_Assembly#targetText...

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:56AM (#21223861)
Robotic missions have all the mental skills of humans, the decision making in a robotic mission is on-par if not even superior because of time constraints being virtually absent.

What robots lack as of yet are the motor skills.

Edit: I'm talking of course about non-autonomous missions.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Gravityloss on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:41AM (#21224233)
They are examples. I've heard about how a geologist on Mars could do so much.

But sending humans to Mars too early, they won't get any science or infrastructure development done, it's just going to be super expensive trying to stay alive, maybe plant a flag for political purposes. A mission probably could retire engineering risk and proof operational practices etc.

Even Apollo, with a very limited time run, had significant evolution of the missions.

With Mars the launch opportunity gap problem is significant, hurting iteration speed.

Anyway, for more than tiny scale space faring, we probably need to get our resources from asteroids. Asteroid resources are the key to space.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by martyvis on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:57AM (#21223461)
We can send hundreds but we didn't. The problem with the current generation of robots is that they pretty much need to have to plan out a full fault tree for every planned experiment and mitigate potential issues with a lot of prepared hardware. Humans can be sent with a fairly generic set of tools, instruments and materials and more readily adapt their plans and experiments too the situation. I'm sure robots get better every generation, but we aren't there yet.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by maxerickson on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:27AM (#21223631)
Odd that he didn't compare them to the human expeditions to Mars.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by _Microft on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:34AM (#21222773)
Robotic missions are cool. I'd certainly like to see more of them in inhospitable parts of the solar system!

Getting people out of Earth's gravity well and setting up a base somewhere that could grow by itself is super useful though. Imagine it like climbing out of a deep valley onto a plain (it's not literally a plain but the requirements regarding delta-v are so much lower when not going into a well at a planet). There are other valleys (or rather pits) in this plain (i.e. the gas giants, which have gravity wells that we wouldn't get out of again with current technology) but it's a lot easier to do useful stuff 'up there' once you don't have to climb out of Earth's gravity well each and everytime you want to do something out there.

Edit: Here's a graphic I just found: https://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2057669320

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by K0SM0S on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:56AM (#21223160)
This is totally right.

You might really like Isaac Arthur on YouTube if you don't know him already. "Orbital rings" [1] in his "Upward Bound" series might be just right your alley. Of course, there's so much more he produced, it's even hard to keep up. I personally dream of some "Megastructures" he suggests...

Actually already began myself to think of a Dyson Swarm around Earth (for starters) which could then serve as a positional basis for future orbital rings. He really inspired me to think bigger, now.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMbI6sk-62E&list=PLIIOUpOge0...

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:11AM (#21223973)
It's absolutely right, but I'd argue we should still send mostly robots from the moon. There are enough people on Earth to look at interesting things in the returned data and seize the initiative once anything new pops up.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by twic on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:25AM (#21223003)
A related visualisation is a delta-V map:

https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of...

AIUI this takes in the cost of both climbing gravity wells, and changing orbital speed and inclination.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by TeMPOraL on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:33AM (#21223053)
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Jaruzel on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:40AM (#21222793)
Obligatory XKCD:

https://xkcd.com/681/

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by _Microft on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:43AM (#21222809)
That's always a nice one. I had to exclude xkcd to find another graphic of the gravity wells because the use of this graphic is so widespread that it hid all other results.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by jacquesm on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:41AM (#21222798)
XKCD's are not obligatory. As I wrote before they are the clever person's reaction gif in many cases and only occasionally provide useful content.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Jaruzel on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:15AM (#21224003)
The 'obligatory' was tongue-in-cheek to be honest, I should have add the /s suffix.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by vidarh on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:14AM (#21223222)
Why should we do things instead of watching other people do them on TV?

If the purpose is purely functional, then to some extent I'd agree - there are a lot of tasks we can achieve faster and better with robots.

But we can't be there via robots in any meaningful way. Even if we manage to some day achieve perfect telepresence, the delay in response will make it continue to feel artificial.

And so there will always be at least some people with a drive to actually go there before we even start thinking about things like longevity of the species etc.

(another answer might be just because it's there)

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by amitparikh on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:42AM (#21222805)
Why are human missions so much more costly than robotic missions? Answer: Life Support.

If our (very) long-term goal is to stake humanity's claim on other planets/asteroids/etc., then it makes sense to work on improving and expanding Life Support capabilities in harsh environments. I see it as an investment in the future -- it may not seem to have immediate benefits, but these are key milestones and steps for reaching the ultimate goal.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Isinlor on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:39AM (#21223086)
It's not really the life support. It's the lower risk tolerance, the need to bring people back and the tyranny of the rocket equation.

You can just abandon a robot on Mars. But if you want to send people to the Moon or Mars you will need to send them with a spacecraft and fuel that will allow them to return. The tyranny of the rocket equation then forces you to build extra large rockets like Saturn V, SLS or Super Heavy Starship. You need exponentially more fuel as you increase payload mass in order to have the same capability.

SpaceX solves that with refueling in low Earth orbit, that allows to scale rocket fuel needs linearly with regard to payload instead of exponentially. And with refueling at the destination in case of Mars. But the need to bring fuel with you is still a big limitation for the Moon missions.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by avian on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:53AM (#21223433)
> SpaceX solves that with refueling in low Earth orbit, that allows to scale rocket fuel needs linearly with regard to payload instead of exponentially.

I don't think that's the case. The rocket equation has the delta-v under exponent, not the mass ratio. Fuel mass scales linearly with payload in any case.

I don't think orbital refueling changes any scaling laws. It just means you can launch several small rockets instead of one huge one. Total mass launched stays approximately the same.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dotancohen on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:08AM (#21223512)

  > But if you want to send people to the Moon or Mars you
  > will need to send them with a spacecraft and fuel that
  > will allow them to return.
Though you are correct for political reasons, there are more than enough people willing to take a one-way trip to Mars. I'm one of them. I love my family, but they know that if Patrick Forester calls me one day because he has only enough O2 for a one-way mission, I'm going.

I'd even go if the mission was to see which of the radiation, CO2, microgravity, nutrition, heat, or isolation kills me first, to improve that for the next bunch. I feel that the goal is that important. Lots of others feel as I do.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by nicoburns on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:50AM (#21222840)
> If our (very) long-term goal is to stake humanity's claim on other planets/asteroids/etc.

This doesn't seem realistic without revolutionary advances in Physics.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by kadoban on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:53AM (#21223138)
What advances in physics are necessary? I understand it to be an engineering, economics and political question.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by dikei on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:19AM (#21223247)
Well, if you want to colonized planets in other solar systems, FTL travel or Cryonics technology might be necessary.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by brohee on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:39AM (#21223345)
People willing to breed and die during the trip would work too. At which point it's a pure engineering challenge, albeit a hard one...

Sending humans to outside the solar system doesn't mean they have to be the same humans that departed.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by hobofromabroad on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:58AM (#21225004)
But then the question becomes what generation +1 wants?

This is probably going to be nearly as big a problem as the engineering one.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by shadowgovt on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:01AM (#21223897)
I'm personally a fan of the "plant a fucking flag on the planet" justification.

https://www.jwz.org/blog/2003/02/space/

Pure science isn't the only reason for NASA's existence. The ultimate goal is always humans further afield than anyone has ever gone before. "boldly expand frontiers in air and space" etc.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Tepix on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:59AM (#21223172)
SpaceX's goal is to establish an independent human presence beyond Earth to have a life insurance for humanity.

Stephen Hawkins agreed: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/05/05/stephen-hawking-human-extinc...

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Razengan on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:41AM (#21222797)
Because some of us want the hope of getting the hell out of here one day.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Lycake on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:51AM (#21222844)
With "getting the hell out of here" do you mean humanity in general or you personally. If you personally: Do you really think public spacetravel will advance that much in our lifetimes?

Personally I hope so, but I also doubt it will happen.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by bluGill on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:44PM (#21226653)
I expect it to advance far enough that I could get off of earth personally. However the competition for free (read government funded positions) will be fierce: I'm more likely to buy the winning lottery ticket 10 times in a row. Multi-billionaires will probably be able to buy a trip.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by jcranberry on Friday October 11, 2019 @04:22PM (#21228100)
In all likelihood, you'd be leaving this nice, hospitable planet with flora and fauna for an oversized dusty rock.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Razengan on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:28AM (#21245269)
Nevermind rocks, I would be glad to just even drift in space.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by melling on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:39AM (#21223723)
I’ve tried to make the case for this a few times on HN. Here are some threads from 2012 and 2014:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8750114 - 2014

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4314781 - 2012

Put the effort into developing advanced robotics to explore space:

“In 100 years, more humans will live off earth if we iterate with machines, etc now than if we move slowly trying to reduce the risk in order to keep humans safe."”

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by wnkrshm on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:35AM (#21224187)
Interesting. In my mind as well, it's too early for manned missions - everything we'd do will be similar to Apollo again: Short visits to show we can, then there's no plan to actually turn these achievements into a self-funding endeavour.

I applaud what SpaceX does because it extends our capability to do things in space and industrialize it. You need an industrial base to permanently house people.

This is mostly just opinion and dreaming but: I don't think we'll have people driving mining rigs on the moon, drinking a beer in their moon bar and missing home. I don't know whether human maintenance can even be a thing because regolith is so vicious to anything operating on the moon - you'd need so many people fixing the robots. That's why the real challenge is coming up with more robust automated systems.

I think new approaches to industrial operations can come from this (and maybe even post-scarcity approaches for Earth, if we see it's possible) if we have to plan and realize a remotely operated (or even automated) factory/mining site. Other than on Earth, there are no space constraints, everything is almost the same material, environmental effects on the moon are not a problem (yet). Any industrial site does not have to have the form factor of a terrestial one, it can be the size of ten airports and mostly consist of flat surface, where a few robots are driving around, moving tools and parts and goods.

But just as with human spaceflight, we have to find the business case for it.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by nickik on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:35AM (#21223689)
The real problem is that NASA Human Space flight has been a total shitshow while the Robotics has way better managment.

This is mostly a historic development of NASA and how politics influnces it.

So the problem is not fundamentally with Humans but rather with NASA organisations.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by Dumblydorr on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:13AM (#21223551)
Robots like Curiosity are very very slow. If we ever want to truly discover life on Mars, humans will likely be the ones to do it as they are just much more productive.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by ozmbie on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:32AM (#21223317)
We should be doing both.

Exploration of the solar system could be the greatest human endeavour of the next hundred or thousand years. Both manned and unmanned missions will be needed.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by coldtea on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:32AM (#21222769)
Because robots are not that flexible / multi-purpose?

Except if you mean T-1000 or something...

And because they eventually want go to Mars, have a little scientific colony, etc?

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by onion2k on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:42AM (#21222800)
Because robots are not that flexible / multi-purpose?

Considering the limitations causing a person harm would put on a mission, and the complexity of bringing them back to Earth again, I'd have thought it'd be more flexible to send a bunch of robots.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by TeMPOraL on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:26AM (#21223012)
I think it ultimately all boils down to launch cadence, which seems to be the driving force behind how things are done in space.

Launches are rare, which means you want to pack as much value generators into your payload as possible, which now means your payload is an expensive one-off workpiece (vs. a mass-produced item), which means extra risk, which means more safety requirements around integration and launch, which means more expensive launches, which means launching less often, ...

So if you're thinking of sending something to Mars for Science, people look attractive (mass produced, can do a lot per dollar spent on getting them qualified for mission), but life support requirements make this too expensive, so sophisticated one-off robots fly from time to time instead. Now if we could increase launch cadence and payload capacity, which is what SpaceX is working on, we could start sending people... or we could load the Starship with multiple cubesat launchers and a payload bay full of remote-operated or semi-automated rovers and drones. In few missions, we could blanket most areas of immediate scientific interest with robots. In this reality, higher payload capacity and launch cadence would drive demand, which means both the scientific robots could be mass-produced, and there would be more iterating on design, increasing the amount of missions that could be done by machines.

The way I see it, right now what SpaceX is doing to enable manned missions is pretty much aligned with what's needed to enable proper robotic missions.

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by martin-adams on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:58AM (#21222871)
One reason is that it creates a whole new set of challenges that require innovation to overcome. Those innovations then have secondary benefits that can improve humans down on Earth.

Here's a wikipedia page listing NASA spinoff technologies:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spinoff_technologies

Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by yreg on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:53AM (#21222849)
If we want to eventually develop technology to colonize the Solar system then human missions beyond the orbit are early steps on that road map.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by electriclove on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:27AM (#21224670)
Do both.. but whatever you do, don't hold back any progress on space exploration simply because there might be another option. We need to get stuff done. Yes, increase the number of robotic missions! Yes, send humanity further too!
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by carapace on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:15PM (#21226373)
Rationally, we shouldn't. We want to go, in part because space is so romantic. In reality space exploration is going to be like working in the deepest, most dangerous mine.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by neals on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:10AM (#21222926)
Robots also outperform humans in many other skills, Yet here we are, watching the olympics.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by aeternum on Friday October 11, 2019 @04:44PM (#21228292)
Sending robots is boring. I would much rather support funding for human missions.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by baq on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:24AM (#21225260)
a geologist with a shovel and a lab kit would do more science in a week than all the robots ever sent to mars altogether.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by bluGill on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:47PM (#21226674)
You are not wrong, but not correct either. The geologist will discover more in that week, but the robots have learned things about different parts of the planet that the geologist will never reach.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:36AM (#21222781)
Good news is, you don't have to go.
Re:NASA aims for first manned SpaceX mission in first-quarte... by de_watcher on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:46AM (#21222821)
yet