News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by atlasunshrugged on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:14AM (#21058655)
Reading Twitter today I'm ashamed of how many people are commenting negative things about her and her work. Say what you will about the cause, but how brave do you have to be to be able to stand up and speak your heart to world leaders and to be a focal point of hate from political pundits and not back down? Certainly far more courage than I had at that age, or even have now.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by Freak_NL on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:43AM (#21058889)
I wish it was restricted to just Twitter or the usual suspects. Have you looked at the grey comments in this thread?

The amount of defeatism, unfounded scepticism, denial, and just pure and nasty ad hominem attacks is sickening.

The one potentially positive thing to note may be that denial and anger often come before acceptance. Eventually.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by srbby on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:50AM (#21058948)
I find using kids for political reasons to be problematic.

I find using emotions instead of facts to sway the political discourse to be problematic.

There are legitimate reasons to be concerned or even angry at this. Maybe not good enough reasons to create an account on Twitter and scream into the void, though.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by JeanMarcS on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:15AM (#21059184)
So what about Severn Cullis (12 yo then) ? What about Malala Yousafzai (16) ?

Is being young disqualifying for having strong opinions ?

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by djsumdog on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:53AM (#21059550)
What about the Nayirah testimony? (Which proved later to be entirely false, and led the United States into the first Iraq war)
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by c0nducktr on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:42AM (#21060021)
You're saying that the nayirah testimony is reason to disqualify all young people from voicing their opinion?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by whamlastxmas on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:52AM (#21060128)
Somewhat, yeah. You're overwhelmingly a product of your parents opinions and you're largely doing what they tell you to do or allow you to do. Because of this, it just comes across as shallow. Greta complained about how she should be at school and was blaming the politicians. In reality it's her parents' fault she's not in school.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by theK on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:39PM (#21063776)
Sorry mate but that point about complaints is completely wrong. A demonstration, whatever the type, is exactly that by definition. People interrupting their jobs because officials are not doing theirs well enough.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by mariushn on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:08AM (#21059127)
Kids have much more to lose from climate change than today's decision makers (most over 40-50 years old)
[dead]
[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by morgancmartin on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:23AM (#21059270)
Ugh, you're right, compassion gets the better of me yet again. To be honest, her brave stance has really made me feel so lucky for the way I was able to live my 16th year. Hard manual labor for low pay during the summers, social anxiety about my social status and the mind-numbing tedium of school were the absolute best. I can't imagine where she finds the strength to give all of that up.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by zorbash on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:24AM (#21058720)
Exactly, I even thought of taking a break off Twitter for a few months. It's getting more and more toxic, just like our environment. How can people express such hate, for a 16 old stating what should be obvious?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by chasd00 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:37AM (#21058830)
I'm not on Twitter but I know exactly what you mean. These days I check hackernews and a forum for a hobby I'm into and that's it. I'll read google news in the morning but I don't go too far (I stay away from opinion pieces).

it's just too toxic and I don't need that in my head.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by SolaceQuantum on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:43AM (#21058892)
In my experience even HN has had bad faith and low-substance discussion about certain topics like the recent Stallman ousting and tech employees claiming discrimination. They tend to be filled with people who make claims without understanding the context of events, then deny any provided context as illegitimate and continue on repeating their position.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by djsumdog on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:46AM (#21060061)
I highly recommend going in your profile settings and allow dead/flagged posts. This post has already been flagged and there are a bunch of interesting comments that are below the threshold of what you'd normally see.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by chasd00 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:00AM (#21059045)
touche, I admit nothing is going to be completely immune. It is the Internet after all.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by yc-kraln on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:16AM (#21059769)
I find the separation between "the internet" interesting. You mean... a connected group of all humanity?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by buboard on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:19PM (#21061768)
I find twitter really great. Not for discussing politics though, this is better left to echo chambers like reddit . But the universe of information and opinion there is really unparalleled. You just have to unfollow people who tend to retweet their political opinions even though they are are unrelated to their main feed; that's just rude behaviour.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by dzhiurgis on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:46AM (#21058914)
To each their own. I don't have much to follow, so I go to explore tab to see what Twitter suggest (pretty like this feature). I've noticed two opposing categories now, occasionally picking up same issue.

Group 1: Stock traders - example opinion "Greta is groomed by some sick fuck, no child should act like that".

Group 2: Software developers - mostly never about software; example opinion - a bit like OP.

So the toxicity I'm trying to avoid - anything about US politics, US news, guns, environment(when there's no tech discussed) gender or race.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by Jgrubb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:36AM (#21058825)
I stopped going habitually a few months back and it's been good. I still check every now and then and it seems to be getting something like 10% worse every month - not enough to notice if you check it every day but if only every couple of weeks the downward trajectory of the discourse and the overall sentiment is really noticeable.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by hkai on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:01PM (#21061571)
When you talk about being brave, what are the consequences that the person is facing, except being famous and being praised by the media? Would that person be expelled from school or put into a jail?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by SauciestGNU on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:24PM (#21061829)
People on the far right have attempted assassinations of political enemies lately. A high profile advocate of a cause perceived to be on the left places themselves in real physical danger these days.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by TheHwangover on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:44PM (#21063326)
being ousted by the media? having lies spread about you by people you never even heard of?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ocschwar on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:33AM (#21058797)
I haven't logged into Twitter for years now. And at this point the only Twitter posts I read are Ms. Thunberg's. Much healthier this way.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:24AM (#21058725)
I guess I'm just not sure what her work is that isn't already being done by others.

There are mobs of great people, scientists, activists etc... speaking truth to power about global climate change worldwide and have been doing so for decades.

I'm just not clear about what is remarkable about what she's doing aside from her being a teenager.

As a relevant counter example, Boyan Slat invented a plastic cleanup device at 16 and has made good progress getting it used in practice. [1] That seems like something that is novel and beneficial.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boyan_Slat

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by js8 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:57AM (#21059016)
Greta's innovation is bringing two important points into the discussion:

1. Why we talk about climate change being serious threat, yet we are acting as if nothing is going on?

2. What is the point of studying science, if politicians do not listen to science?

That, and her determination to strike (based on the two above points).

You can argue that neither argument is particularly difficult or complicated. They are rather obvious in hindsight. Well, there is a name for things like that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egg_of_Columbus

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by pnako on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:57AM (#21060861)
>2. What is the point of studying science, if politicians do not listen to science?

That's not really what's happening. From day one, in the eighties, the ones who have been vocal about this have been politicians. Al Gore, the IPCC, etc. I mean, most people can't name a single scientist advocating this issue. In France, just like in the US, the number one advocate on this issue is a TV show host. And in fact, the most well-known French scientist (turned politician) who talked about global warming (Claude Allegre) is what people would call a skeptic or denier...

What's happening today is that:

  1. in western democracies, people predominantly vote to ignore it
  2. in developing countries, leaders also choose to ignore it
Greta is protesting against point 1. That's not going to achieve much more. At this point, people have made their mind about the issue and I don't think the balance is going to be tipped significantly. I don't even understand what she's trying to achieve. She can shout at politicians as much as she wants, ultimately the power is held by the people of those democracies.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by js8 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:29PM (#21061893)
By "politicians" she means people in power, and by "listening" she means taking actions (or at least refraining from doing the opposite). That's what your examples lack.

> in western democracies, people predominantly vote to ignore it

According to polls, it is considered to be very important issue, see e.g. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/sep/15/americans-cl...

There was another poll and in European countries the support is even higher.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ocschwar on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:38AM (#21058840)
> I guess I'm just not sure what her work is that isn't already being done by others.

Making politicians uncomfortable about their careers. Lots of other people have tried and failed. She's succeeding.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by pnako on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:42AM (#21058876)
How exactly is she succeeding? Macron gave up on petrol tax increases after months of riots by yellow vests; I bet he'll keep responding to them and not to Greta.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ocschwar on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:47AM (#21060080)
Germany, meanwhile, just voted to increase the size of the Green party in the EU parliament. And even the CDU is caucusing with the Greens now. Macron's yellow vest capitulation was what, 4 months ago?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by pnako on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:46AM (#21060742)
Germany is an interesting case to say the least. After decades of campaigning by the Greens, and right in the middle of this global warming crisis, they closed nuclear power plants and started up coal plants again... But, fortunately, the coal plants were only temporary; Germany is now building a big pipeline to get natural gas from Russia.

As for France, there is not much more to do; the country's energy mix is largely nuclear + hydro and the industry has long left the country anyway. Macron could try to promote insect burgers, as they are trying in other countries, by in that case he'll get protests even bigger than the yellow vests :)

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by dvfjsdhgfv on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:44AM (#21059472)
I don't understand why you're downvoted. Everybody keeps putting the blame on politicians. But they're not independent, they need to listen to the people. Many people really don't care about something they don't believe is related to them in any way. They do care, however, about their money, expenses, jobs. These are the people that need to be educated so that they get more realistic. And the job of politicians is to give them a good alternative.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by fwn on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:48AM (#21058933)
> Making politicians uncomfortable about their careers.

While this could be true on some deeper level I don't think that this specific event is a good one to base such an assessment on.

Being invited to talk to the UN is a great honor from the political establishment and her speech got interrupted by applause several times. I only watched the speech itself, but I have difficulties to see evidence that people there were uncomfortable.

edit: This appears to be very controversial? Would someone care to elaborate?

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by happytoexplain on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:35AM (#21059378)
The gravity of the topic and its near-binary political divide are the main reasons - but this is true of all climate politics, not just this case.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by rusticpenn on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:30AM (#21058772)
Influencing people is vastly underestimated.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by pizza234 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:40AM (#21058857)
> Boyan Slat invented a plastic cleanup device at 16 and has made good progress getting it used in practice.

Evaluations about his project should be extremely careful, as [currently] there isn't any meaningful way to measure progress.

Both 2019 deployments failed, and interestingly, there is very little analysis of the second, aside the company's own reports.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by f3r3nc on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:29AM (#21058760)
sales is just as important as tech
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by djsumdog on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:33AM (#21058799)
I see her the same way I see parents who brings kids to various protests. I can see wanting to have your kids involved, but do they understand what you're standing for, or are you using them for your point?

Obviously she's older/a teenager, but this is still at it's core, an emotional draw. Has she authored papers and done the models? She's a spokeswoman. Even if the intent is different, it's still similar in means and effect to the Nayirah testimony.

[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by atlasunshrugged on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:26AM (#21058738)
I'm not going to comment on the autistic piece because I'm not qualified enough to know anything about how a person with autism acts but as far as media responsibility, I agree - but I think it's pretty clear that media (at least from what I see mainly watching US media) has abdicated all sense of responsibility for their programming and is entirely driven by what sells. If this is what sells and gets eyeballs then this is what will be on the air.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by chasd00 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:41AM (#21058870)
this is very true. they'll feed her to a pack of wolves if it will increase ad revenue.
[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by sjogress on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:02AM (#21059071)
How do you define risk?

At her age, and probably even more now, I'd be scared about how the media, politicians, neighbours, peers, and social media would treat me after such a speech.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ReptileMan on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:28AM (#21059307)
At her age (okay one year younger) I was busy overthrowing a communist government. One month at the barricades, in the dead of the winter against battons. Didn't consider myself brave at all.

We had teen driven revolutions and riots agains governments in the last decade. The least proteser at Gezi park was braver than her. Ditto for arab spring, Venezuela and now against Putin.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ocschwar on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:55AM (#21060171)
It's not a contest.
[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by atlasunshrugged on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:23AM (#21058714)
Maybe everyone already knows what you're going to say and they're going to ignore her but look at all the earned media she's getting. Maybe almost everyone in that audience is too jaded to care, but I'd bet that she's having at least some influence in creating a broader movement (or adding fuel to existing climate movements) globally around the issue. Even media circuses can be useful.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by srbby on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:25AM (#21058729)
It's going to end like the kids from "March For Our Lives" ended: swimming in complete irrelevance. The media are just milking these kids because emotions sell. All of this is boring and useless, and even the beginning of a worrying trend.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by maaaats on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:21AM (#21058699)
Yeah, I've seen lots of comments on how she's a left-wing puppet, or why they didn't get some scientist knowing what they speak about up there instead of a kid.

But

- Why is caring about climate left-wing?

- It's the same people ignoring the scientists, that write this crap, so no, a scientist speaking doesn't solve anthing. Unfortunately. It wouldn't have come to this then.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by shawnz on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:47AM (#21058923)
As a counterpoint, I am well aware of the reality of the climate emergency but I still believe Greta is being abused for PR reasons.

I agree an impassioned plea can be just as helpful as an expert opinion. But is she mature enough at that age to understand the consequences of the celebrity status that is being put on her through this?

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by spodek on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:42AM (#21059448)
I met her boat when it landed at New York and spoke a few words with her.

I saw her speak in a fireside chat and spoke with people who have spent time with her.

She's plenty mature.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by shawnz on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:35AM (#21061272)
With all due respect that doesn't really seem like enough exposure to understand how she is handling the fame.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ocschwar on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:53AM (#21060139)
As someone with an autistic kid, I'm in awe of her parents.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by nashashmi on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:36AM (#21058824)
I have seen such arguments where the individual is criticized instead of the words simply because the words are beyond argument.

Meaning she spoke strongly and powerfully and is difficult to argue against so they attack everything else.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by afiori on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:17AM (#21059207)
She is effectively preaching, there is no moral connotation in this statement, but her intention is clearly to rile up the masses and energize the so far slumbering climate activism.

Personally I like different a rhetoric rather than fatalism, but it is undeniable that she is successful and that this is probably going to be a net positive.

Regarding why some people react negatively to her I also understand that.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by fnordsensei on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:32AM (#21058786)
As far as I can tell, the reasoning is,

- The left-wing hates prosperity (and freedom).

- Prosperity comes from coal, oil, and cutting down forests to make cattle ranches. Freedom comes from buying weapons with the profits.

- Climate scientists/advocates say we have to scale back the coal, oil and forest bits, or we're flirting with extinction-level risks.

- Ergo, climate scientists/advocates are left-wing.

[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by maaaats on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:42AM (#21058881)
If that's so, couldn't the right instead find some acceptable ways to handle it (without increasing taxes), instead of sweeping it under the rug?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by lexapro on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:31AM (#21058777)
So spoiling the environment for everyone should be free?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by ocschwar on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:40AM (#21058858)
There's nothing stopping countries from lowering other taxes along with raising a CO2 tax.
[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by telesilla on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:44AM (#21058897)
We are observing many things out of the ordinary already. A good summary here - https://www.edf.org/climate/9-ways-we-know-humans-triggered-...
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by bsaul on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:12AM (#21059742)
What the link mentions is that we're observing CO2 concentration going from 2% to 3% of the atmosphere in over a few centuries, and that it's due to humans. This, on its own (that is, without the simulated consequences) isn't something that's likely to alarm the general public and make it dramatically change its lifestyle.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by neumann on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:59AM (#21059036)
Simulations and modelling is used to try and extrapolate trends to be predictive. And that is important, especially give the problems we are having right now. If people don't believe there are problems relating to climate change it is only because they aren't focusing on the right problem.

And why do we have this modelling? Because we are trying to understand where we are heading based on historical data trends [0]. It is a wonderfully hand-drawn infographic sourcing those cold hard facts [1].

[0] https://xkcd.com/1732/

[1] https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1732:_Earth_Tempe...

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:54AM (#21058994)
Mass extinction event not out of the ordinary enough for you?

Pretty sure I read somewhere extreme weather events are occurring more frequently.

[dead]
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by SolaceQuantum on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:48AM (#21058935)
Honestly, I can imagine only a 16 year old would have the confidence to be able to speak so sharply to people with significant political power. Teenagers are the most bullheaded people there are! They know everything!

Seriously though, I think it’s well established that teenagers are in the unique positions where they aren’t beholden to many of the adult pressures of the world, but also are old enough to have significant and strong opinions about things around them. It makes perfect sense for me that a particularly ornery teenager would go to such lengths for their given cause!

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by StavrosK on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:46AM (#21058912)
What speech in front of the UN, by anyone, is not coached?
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by Freak_NL on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:45AM (#21058903)
Why wouldn't she take advantage of coaching to help her get her (genuine) message across? I would, if I was speaking at the United Nations.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by faissaloo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:00AM (#21059038)
>If I were a 16 year old kid in front of the UN, I would be overwhelmed by the august honor of such a moment

But you aren't, you also don't have aspergers syndrome and were never mute.

Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by vharuck on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:46AM (#21058916)
While the average 16-year old may not be able to do this, it's unlikely no 16-year old would be capable, willing, and have a chance to do this. We can't use generalizations to dismiss individuals.
Re:'This Is All Wrong,' Greta Thunberg Tells World Leaders a... by krapp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:32AM (#21058788)
>Why is caring about climate left-wing?

It isn't. Why is it percieved as left-wing? Because President Reagan and business lobbyists pushed hard to associate climate science with a "big government, pro-regulation, anti-business" (in other words, "left-wing" according to their propaganda) agenda[0].

Also likely IMO because of associations between environmentalism, feminism and the left-wing hippie movement of the 1960s.

[0]https://www.vox.com/2017/4/22/15377964/republicans-environme...