News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by nugget on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:05PM (#20794040)
His statement reinforces the whole point of ZIRP: minimize the value of financial capital and maximize the value of human capital. Force investors to take on more risk. Entrepreneurs ironically may take on less risk since the value of labor relative to capital shifts in their favor.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by hogFeast on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:23PM (#20794571)
Do you know about the behaviour of German savers? It is fundamentally different to America, the UK, most other countries in Europe. The only similar nation anywhere is Japan...and even then, still significant differences.

The ECB is making a huge push, without any kind of democratic consent, towards a finance-based, American/UK-style financial system. This won't work because German savers have virtually no experience of such a system.

All that will happen is: banks go bust (more bust, most German banks are insolvent), and savers lose all their money. Either they hold their money in banks or they take it out and lose it all doing stuff they know nothing about (if we don't have an immediate recession, you will see French investment banks swarm Germany...French bankers have some kind of innate ability to produce bullshit derivatives aimed at savers with a conservative bank-led culture of saving).

It is kind of insane that we have got to the point where policymakers actively ignore markets. All that matters are the textbooks. But this doesn't work. You can't just transplant economic policies from another context and expect them to work the same.

That said, it will be nice to see Germany return to the early 2000s. Objectively, Germany has one of the most vulnerable and poorly functioning economies in the G10. Combine this with utterly insufferable, self-important policymakers and you have quite a nice example of natural justice.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Nimitz14 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:55PM (#20795114)
If the ECB doesn't do so Europe is doomed.

Since the inception of the Euro it's been clear to anyone with an economics education (not me, but this is the impression I've gotten reading commentary from anyone respectable), that Europe has some serious flaws (from a financial perspective) that will take decisive action to fix. One of those things is that Germany needs to start spending more. Unfortunately I don't see it happening. But I'm crossing my fingers than Macron can somehow pull a miracle.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rawland on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:29PM (#20795365)

    > One of those things is that Germany needs to
    > start spending more.
Why?

Especially on the individual - many will ask: Why spend, when you save for "bad times" or your kids' future? And more recently: Why spend, when you want to reduce your footprint on this planet?

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by graeme on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:13PM (#20795956)
It's more like "for the euro to work, Germany must spend more"

The Euro isn't sensible from an optimal currency perspective. In a good currency union, labour will be extremely mobile. But though labour can move freely in Europe, people tend to prefer their home country. Contrast to the US where people move much more readily and follow jobs.

So monetary policy has been too tight in areas like Greece that would have simply devalued their currencies in the past. Meanwhile policy seems to be too loose for Germany.

If you want to keep the monetary union, you can't crush Greece and other southern countries. So the Euro must devalue a bit to help them. But this cuts interest rates in Germany, discouraging spending.

Hence "Germany must spend more". It's more of a mechanical statement than a moral one.

Also spending could be using capital to buy a business abroad or infrastructure or somesuch, I think. Needn't necessarily be consumer goods.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by chii on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:05AM (#20797770)
the fundamental issue with the euro zone is that each member country still considers themselves a separate nation (and i m not talking about policy, but about the people). A greek national considers himself a greek, and not german.

In america, when a state has low revenue or high cost, it is subsidized by federal taxes. I.e., people from richer parts of the country "pays" for the poorer parts (e.g., infrastructure, or education etc).

In eurozone, this is rarely the case. I think a person in the US won't bat an eye if taxes are redistributed to a different state, but the amount of backlash that eurozone sees from this sort of redistribution (see brexit - they even believe in lies because it conforms to their worldview!).

Until the eurozone culturally and societally accepts itself as a single country with a single identity, there cannot be financial unity. Euro is a failure because of this imho.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Nimitz14 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:34PM (#20796059)
This is also how I understand the situation.

Btw I think you've got a typo:

> for the euro to work, Germany must save more

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by graeme on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:11PM (#20796547)
Thanks! Fixed it
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by pm90 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:48PM (#20796442)
> Why spend, when you save for "bad times" or your kids' future? And more recently: Why spend, when you want to reduce your footprint on this planet?

You're framing this in moral terms whereas it should be viewed as more in economic terms. Spending by Germans creates more demand for Goods and Services, encouraging economic booms in the rest of Eurozone. These developed countries would then develop the skills and accumulate capital to compete with their peers in Asia. That would be a huge win-win from a European perspective.

Honestly, this shouldn't be viewed as encouraging the average German to spend more of their savings, rather, the German Federal Government borrowing more + spending heavily on infrastructure building in Germany + the rest of Europe.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by ChuckNorris89 on Monday August 26, 2019 @07:00AM (#20798774)
>Spending by Germans creates more demand for Goods and Services, encouraging economic booms in the rest of Eurozone.

In theory. In practice however, all that negative rate money that people will borrow will all go to real estate causing the already high prices to skyrocket overnight while wages stagnate.

Goods and Services are already cheap enough that we don't need loans for.

When rates were high, property prices in Germany were cheap or at least reasonable as they were pegged to the income levels. When rates went down property prices went to have no correlation to salaries anymore as now every average Joe and his mom could go to the bank and max out a 30 year loan on as big of a house his bank could afford to give him.

That's how Germany went from being one of the cheapest housing markets in Europe to one of the most expensive in the last 10 years.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by pm90 on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:22PM (#20801082)
Why not build more housing then? Real estate speculation is bad but there seems to be actual demand for more housing if I’m reading your comment correctly.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Paradigma11 on Monday August 26, 2019 @05:22AM (#20798398)
Why would greece or italy grow because germany buys more chinese products?

Sure the € would depreciate a bit but there have already been currency fluctuations that did not show a big positive effect on the malingering economies.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Paradigma11 on Monday August 26, 2019 @07:47AM (#20799003)
Oops my bad, ment sick instead of malingering. Did not knew the negative meaning of malingering of pretending to be sick.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by bitL on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:50PM (#20795488)
This was more in context that Germany is underpaying its employees, i.e. the salaries are similar to France with much higher productivity, average pensioner gets less than somebody in Italy would get, and even Austria has higher wages now; not to mention Switzerland where wages are usually 2x higher. The theory was that if Germans were allowed to earn more, that would in turn propel economy; instead they are forced to save for worse times, companies/banks are super conservative in the time of expansion and not sharing any wealth, keeping their export advantage with stabilized cost of labor, leading to unnecessary suppression of growth that could have happened with increased domestic consumption.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:08PM (#20796531)
>This was more in context that Germany is underpaying its employees

Yep, at least in tech, German salaries are stupidly close to Eastern Europe now. All this because in EE the free market kicked in and did it's thing, forcing employers to compete for talent while German companies artificially cap salaries to fixed grids while complaining there's a talent shortage and pushing for immigration instead of wage increases.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Throw_Away_3278 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:39PM (#20796664)
What are fixed grids?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by ldp01 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:09PM (#20796963)
He probably means a table of standard ranks and salaries.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by throwaway34241 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:11PM (#20796973)
To add one more angle on it: everyone can't save money at the same time. Say you have 100B euros. The next year everyone can't just have 110B euros in total unless you print money.

What really happens is that 'savings' have two sides to them, and the other side is debt. So when people's savings go up by 10B, 10B of debt is created somewhere else (bank loans, government borrowing, etc) that enables that.

Having things work this way makes some intuitive sense. Savings are really a promise for goods & services in the future, so it makes sense that you have a matching promise to (forgo) goods & services in the future to counterbalance that.

In Germany's case, it's possible for the public and government to both save in aggregate only as long as trading partners go into debt (in euros). But if the debt becomes unsustainable, you will lose your savings that are the other side of that debt.

Now, everyone can try to save at the same time, but because it's impossible it doesn't work and you just go into a recession. That is, everyone stops spending, people lose their job, and even though they want to save they can't, so the impossibility is avoided.

Even though the basics aren't extremely complicated, it doesn't work like a household, and in many countries the average level of economics education seems to be about zero. There's a lot of public sentiment that everyone should should just save up and pay down debt, even though it doesn't make much mathematical sense how that could happen. I think there's a good chance people are elected at some point that handle things very badly.

On an single individual level there's no reason to avoid saving, it's a good idea. But someone has to take on the debt on the other side of that saving. If no one wants to (including the government), it seems reasonable for interest rates to trend negative.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:09PM (#20795609)
Because you can't really save for the future. You can only invest for the future. Saving only pays off when there's someone to take those savings and spend them on investments.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by marticode on Sunday August 25, 2019 @09:02PM (#20796762)
Spending more could be done by converting all those coal plants Germany has into renewables, or building better mass transit, or doing R&D for its industry, or providing better benefits for parents to raise its abnormally low birth rate, etc. Having money to spend is a good problem to have.

More generally speaking, Germany has excess saving and insufficient spending which creates problems for the other members of the Eurozone. Excess deficits are bad, but excess surpluses are also not good.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by nl on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:15PM (#20796563)
Others have addressed the mechanical points of this argument. I'm going to talk about the moral points:

Why spend, when you save for "bad times" or your kids' future?

By spending you keep companies in business where your kids will be able to work in the future. We often see a moral version of this argument framed as "buy local" or "buy American|German|Whatever"

Why spend, when you want to reduce your footprint on this planet?

Often lower impact choices cost more. By deliberately spending more money on lower footprint choices you are helping the planet. Good examples of this include high-efficiency appliances, extra house insulation, sustainable food sources etc etc.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Nasrudith on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:01PM (#20797144)
That highlights issues of trust and game theory as well - "saving" in some sort of way (including investing) provides security and can allow rising higher.

A moral arguement towards spending is looked at like you are trying to sell them sonething and/or fleece them. And they are technically right about that - accumulating wealth is what makes an individual rich.

Investment in the actual sense would be a win-win. Not speculation or buying goods for the sake of getting cash flowing but things which provide a return. It is similiar to why lending out money/buying stocks is infinitely better as an investment than just holding gold - they provide utility. Gold just sits there.

Of course investing reliably and safely is hard, especially when the behavior of others impact it and nobody has perfect information.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by chii on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:11AM (#20797788)
which is why investing in a bank's savings account is the natural way to "save". It's very safe, and still guarentees some level of profit that is not too far off from inflation.

Negative interest rates pulls that out under the rug, and forces people to take on extra risk than they currently do.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by perl4ever on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:46AM (#20797512)
"Often lower impact choices cost more."

This doesn't seem like a reasonable assumption to me.

If you spend $ to reduce your carbon output for example, the money circulates among other people, who average about the same usage of fossil fuels as the general population because after a few exchanges they are the general population. So if you are increasing your spending in the long run, you are increasing resource usage by that amount, no matter how virtuous the things you are spending it on.

That doesn't mean it's wrong to invest in something that saves you money in the long run, but if there isn't a payoff, then by default you shouldn't think you're helping the environment.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by nl on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:12AM (#20797793)
If you spend $ to reduce your carbon output for example, the money circulates among other people, who average about the same usage of fossil fuels as the general population because after a few exchanges they are the general population. So if you are increasing your spending in the long run, you are increasing resource usage by that amount, no matter how virtuous the things you are spending it on.

This is a second order result, and doesn't necessarily follow. For example, higher quality goods generally last longer, which reduces waste. Higher profit margins also lead to more room for sustainability in supply chains. Apple is a good example of this.

Richer people also generally have less children, which reduces the environmental impact further.

All in all I'd say that second-level effects are guessing at this point.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by perl4ever on Monday August 26, 2019 @07:55AM (#20799050)
Sure, that's exactly what I'm saying. Second level effects are guessing, so you should assume by default that spending more means using more stuff means damaging the environment more. Very often people say "it's complex" to evade the simple obvious conclusion because that conclusion is unacceptable.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by nl on Monday August 26, 2019 @09:25AM (#20799663)
so you should assume by default that spending more means using more stuff means damaging the environment more.

Sure, but I think it's ok to think about ways in which spending more can help. The OP did ask that question after all..

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by FabHK on Monday August 26, 2019 @05:34AM (#20798440)
a) you can't compare the finances of a household with the finances of an entire economy. It might make sense for a household to aim to be debt free, but an economy should have plenty of debt (mostly to itself) to build all the infrastructure you need to run a modern and productive economy. It's sustainable for an economy not only to be eternally in debt, but to go eternally into more debt (ie have a deficit), as long as the economy grows. Common sense intuitions don't really work, and are contra-productive, at the level of an economy.

b) insufficient aggregate demand can be a huge problem leading to recessions. What is sensible for the individual might not be sensible for the economy as a while.

c) Germany's infrastructure is decaying, and rates are as low as never before, even negative, ie the market is willing to pay Germany to borrow. Yet Germany refuses to borrow. It's perverse. Of course, unemployment in Germany is relatively low, but in Europe it's high. Some big construction projects in Germany would be a win-win.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wbl on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:08PM (#20796530)
Germans would be richer if they spent and earned more instead of saving and earning less to export more. Germany's current account imbalance threatens eurozone stability and lower rates in Germany are the solution.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wetpaws on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:20PM (#20797000)
Money is not a resource, it's just a number.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rorykoehler on Sunday August 25, 2019 @09:33PM (#20796858)
The economy isn't zero sum. More spending means more good times for everyone.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by samsonradu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:42PM (#20795785)
> If the ECB doesn't do so Europe is doomed

Doomed is a strong word, what does it mean? Sure, there are flaws in the common currency and the ECB policies might fail. Europe might be the next Japan for the upcoming decade with ±0% economic growth, that doesn't make it doomed.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:50PM (#20795828)
> Doomed is a strong word, what does it mean

The Euro could dissolve in lieu of national currencies. Borders may be redrawn and remilitarised.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by samsonradu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:05PM (#20795906)
Well, Europe will still be there, borders or not. Can you elaborate a bit on 'remilitarised'? Why would that be needed and when were borders last militarised? By militarised you mean customs officers?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:10PM (#20795932)
> Why would that be needed and when were borders last militarised?

Monetary problems tend to prompt populism. That comes with its standard variants of nationalism, fascism and racism. Harsher customs are the least of our concerns from this side of the Atlantic.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mcguire on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:09PM (#20796244)
I'm not JumpCrisscross, but I'm thinking WW1.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by imtringued on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:44PM (#20796418)
Leaving the Euro isn't the same as leaving the EU.
[dead]
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by dang on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:35AM (#20797882)
Nationalistic flamebait will get you banned here. No more of this please.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by nickserv on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:26PM (#20797023)
Because European countries have a long history of peaceful coexistence...
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by apexalpha on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:45AM (#20797916)
>Since the inception of the Euro it's been clear to anyone with an economics education (not me, but this is the impression I've gotten reading commentary from anyone respectable), that Europe has some serious flaws (from a financial perspective) that will take decisive action to fix.

The Euro set limits on how much countries were allowed to borrow and how high their deficits can be.

The only massive flaw it has is the believe that countries could be simply trusted to stick to these rules.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Smithalicious on Monday August 26, 2019 @04:46AM (#20798282)
The EU is not Europe and Europe is not the EU
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by repolfx on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:45PM (#20795804)
Europe isn't doomed and it can't have financial flaws because Europe is a continent. Its population isn't going anywhere.

The EU might well be doomed - it seems that's actually what you meant? I've noticed it's quite common for the EU's biggest supporters to use the word "Europe" when they mean EU, but please don't do that. It's a poor use of language and can come across as deliberately manipulative: attempting to graft the permanence of a continent onto a transient political institution. It really grates.

As for the financial flaws. The flaw is not that Germans must spend more but the other countries must spend less. Mere spending is not a useful goal - the ECB is trying (apparently successfully) to force Germans to spend their savings only to wallpaper over the fact that the EU member states continue to have lethargic economies that don't produce much worth spending money on, and to kick the can on a huge debt crisis.

Macron can't do anything - he's in no position to dictate to the Germans what to do with their money. Unfortunately the poor Germans, who are already owed vast sums by the rest of the EU (see: TARGET-2 trade imbalances), are probably going to end up losing all their savings to fund southern/French lifestyles for another decade or two. Their emotional commitment to the EU allows them to be financially exploited without end.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:26PM (#20801791)
Everyone spends less? we have a name for it, a recession
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by thefounder on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:57PM (#20795867)
So what's the solution for a United Europe? Brexit? EU prides itself to be more than just a "big trade deal".
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by repolfx on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:47PM (#20802023)
Europe should never be united. That's a terrible idea: why would you concentrate and centralise power to such a massive extent? Power corrupts and the EU institutions are already riven with it, the last thing people in Europe need is a massive Soviet-style bureaucracy attempting to control the entire continent at once.

Small is beautiful. Let's start by restoring the primacy of the country as an organising unit. Where there are no actual disagreements in policy, they can recognise each others standards and avoid trading friction. Where disagreements over policy do occur, then deviation in those areas should have no impact on unrelated areas.

The EU has become a monster that is willing to cut ties with important European countries entirely if they refuse any aspect of its dominion. Relations with both Britain and Switzerland are on the brink, despite both countries trying hard to be best friends with their neighbours. The EU is actually imposing trade sanctions on Switzerland because of a disagreement over something related to trade union law, so I expect it to get much worse in future as the EU continues to maintain near-totalitarian "with us or against us" politics against them.

Every attempt to unite Europe under a single government has led to disaster. This time around will be no different.

- A Brexit voter

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by thefounder on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:21AM (#20809835)
Do you think UK should be split as well? Maybe England should stop bankrolling Scotland and NR? Make England Great Again?

I don't think anyone wants the EU to become another Soviet Union. EU believers want a United States of Europe(more or less).

Small might be beautiful but it's weak. It goes with the wind. (i.e with the U.S, China, Russia). Brexit will only move UK closer to the US than to the continental Europe.

U.S doesn't use the same "with us" or "against policy", right? I heard U.S doesn't impose sanctions due various disagreements either... good luck! You forgot the Suez Crisis so fast!

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by repolfx on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:05PM (#20813905)
Maybe the UK should split - it's certainly pretty painful trying to keep it together.

Despite that I would have recommended Scotland vote to remain a part of the UK. Inconsistent? To a point yes, but with better technology, I might have changed my mind.

One key problem with fully splitting the UK is there's no identity card system so no chance of an internal border. If Scotland had split from the UK, its economy would have rapidly collapsed because the SNPs economic plans were all based on a relatively high price of oil and the oil price collapsed a few months after the referendum. A socialism driven economic collapse in Scotland would have caused a mass influx of Scots into England with no way to identify them or send them back. With an ID card it can be more like in Europe where you have to register, and there can be some notion of a soft border. Same applies for Northern Ireland.

I'm not sure why you think small means weak. Germany would seem to have disproved that notion twice in the 21st century. At any rate, I'm not arguing against military alliances, and given the only armies in Europe that are worth anything are the British and French, the EU will soon be relying almost entirely on France.

Or perhaps you have bought the idea that small countries "have" to sign trade deals with bigger countries. That's simply false.

Finally, what EU fans want is irrelevant. It's what they'll get that matters. Do you see the EU ever respecting a vote that doesn't go it's way? Do you see any real movement towards putting the EU Parliament above the commission and ECB? No, the "parliament" is a sham and the EU's response to democratic rejection is to ignore the result or try and force the population to comply.

You're going to get a new Soviet Union whether you want one or not. The inertial direction of travel is quite clear.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by thefounder on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:15PM (#20814978)
So you would support a UK split but it's not possible because there is no ID card system in place? Really? You realise that there would be a transitional period, right?

I'm not looking to convince you that EU is better than you think but this[1] open letter may help you understand some subtle differences between EU and SU.

https://ec.europa.eu/commission/commissioners/2014-2019/andr...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by repolfx on Thursday August 29, 2019 @01:12PM (#20831490)
Like I said, with the right technology in place I'd reconsider. I'm not emotionally attached to the union as many seem to be and the rest of the UK gets a terrible deal from Scotland in so many ways. My primary concern is that upon becoming independent Scotland might suffer a severe decline in living standards that would result in a large and sudden influx across the border, putting huge strain on England. A hard border would potentially solve that but at very high cost and significant inconvenience: one based on a solid ID system would be much better.

I don't recall any talk of ID cards or transitional periods to sort things out during the Scottish Indyref. Perhaps I missed it.

The reply to the open letter is what you'd expect and isn't reassuring. It makes a few errors.

Firstly, it's not looking forward. It states the EU today is not as nearly as bad as the USSR was at its worst. That's true and nobody argues that it is. However it's also not really relevant, because if you only start to object to a government at the point it's running gulags it's already far too late. To avoid a repeat of history, movement towards such a system must be detected and stopped early whilst it's still possible. That's why we need to look at the direction of travel and extrapolate.

Secondly, it's looking backward. It talks about how the UK was able to opt-out of the EU's worst ideas and talks about Thatcher. That was true in the past, but the EU has been getting more powerful over time and taking over more and more national responsibilities. The veto has been progressively weakened and now they want to abolish it entirely. Today's EU is not the same as the EU in Thatcher's day - it's significantly larger and much more hostile to "deserters", as Juncker has described the UK. And as the EU loves to keep telling the UK there is no more "cherry picking" anymore, i.e. opting out of their bad ideas. That era is over.

So what matters is what the EU will become, not what it is today or what it was 20 years ago.

And here is where the comparisons start to look bad.

Firstly and most importantly the EU does not recognise the democratic will of the people, whilst loudly proclaiming that it does. This is a major red flag. There is no effective way to control the Commission's agenda through voting.

It must be noted here that all communist regimes have Parliaments and they all have votes. In the USSR there was an elected body called the Supreme Soviet, whose members made the laws of the Union. The USSR was a dictatorship despite the existence of the Supreme Soviet because of a simple trick: all elected politicians had to belong to the same party, so there was no real competition of policies. It had the superficial appearance a democratic system without being one.

In the EU there are multiple parties and they do compete. The EU Parliament is neutered via a different means: the elected politicians can't control the executive or change the laws. This means they aren't really politicians and it's not really a Parliament, using standard dictionary definitions. It wouldn't matter if somehow a coalition of parties totally opposed to the Commission's agenda got elected: the Parliament lacks the "right of initiation". That also means there's no real point in having any party policies, so you see a wafer thin and artificial campaigns, where parties either have detailed manifestos that happen to align exactly with what the head of the Commission already wants, or you get protest parties that openly admit they can't change anything but say: elect us anyway just to 'send a message' (which is never received).

A good example of how unseriously the Parliament is taken is the way they were given a "vote" on the new head of the EU Commission, but the vote only had one option. MEPs could either support Ursula von der Leyen, or abstain. Votes with only one option are a classic symptom of communism; the sort of system that is happy to call itself a "People's Republic" but actually doesn't trust the people.

By the way, the EU does try to obfuscate a lot of this stuff by introducing mechanisms that theoretically are usable but in practice aren't. For instance there was briefly the Spitzenkandidaten system which meant the Parliament appointed the head of the Commission ... up until they appointed the wrong one, at which point that ability vanished. There's theoretically an EU Citizen's Initiative, but unlike Citizen's Initiatives in member states, this one can't be used to change the law or trigger a referendum. Actually they accomplish nothing even if you gather the required number of signatures (which is huge).

In the end the true nature is summed up by Jean-Claude Juncker: "There can be no democratic choice against the European treaties".

Another bad sign is the love of secrecy. In theory your countries national leader can influence the choice of Commission leader, except the decision of who gets the job is always made in secret and nobody knows who voted for whom or how the decision was made. This matters: the EU's own leaders have said in the past it's common for politicians to lie to their own voters about what they support. There is no public explanation how Ursula von der Leyen became head of the Commission. It could be fixed by making EU meetings be transparent but they refuse to do it. This pattern of secret meetings sans minutes crops up everywhere when you scratch the surface.

There are lots of other pieces of evidence the EU doesn't care about votes or democracy. For instance, in a democratic system you might have expected rejection by one of the biggest members to trigger at minimum some sort of reflection or debate. There hasn't been any - at the first meeting of the EU Council after the Brexit vote it wasn't discussed at all. The only topic on the agenda was creating an EU army - one that would report directly to the Commission.

Why does the EU need an army when there is already NATO? It doesn't, but totalitarian regimes do. Expect to hear more about this army's "peacekeeping" initiatives in future, albeit not for many years. The process of transforming into a Neo USSR is a slow one, fortunately.

The EU appears to implement rule of law, until the law gets in the way of the EU's aims and then it simply gets ignored. To quote Christine LaGarde on the Eurozone bailouts: "To save the Euro we broke all the rules. The treaties are quite clear. No bailouts."

Finally, loyalty to the EU strongly resembles the sort of loyalty to communism seen in the first half of the 20th century. Brexit has made this very clear by flushing it to the surface. Strongholds in academia, a belief in the superiority of 'expert' run government over democratic decisions, constant double-speak like a "People's Vote" (of the sort held in a People's Republic), a willingness to do whatever it takes to gain victory. Orwell had a lot to say on these topics.

I could go on but you get the picture. The EU looks superficially democratic and law-based, but blocks actual democracy at every turn and the law is enforced politically. It's a deep seated set of attitudes that can't be reformed. It will inexorably continue on its present path, with the EU getting steadily more powerful until it totally controls the member states, helped by large numbers of quasi-religious loyalists who will crack down and imprison anti-EU protesters under the guise of "hate speech".

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rexgallorum2 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:58PM (#20796196)
Years ago I had an elderly neighbour here in Germany who fell victim to financial fraud, wiring most of his his life savings--over $200k--to some dodgy bank account in Hong Kong. He thought he was buying shares in some kind of gold mine or something. He asked me for help because most of the information he had was in English. I quickly figured out that he'd been scammed, and very gently broke the news to him. He took it remarkably well.

This happened during the Euro crisis some years ago, and at the time it seemed that Germans with any kind of savings were desperately looking for safe places to put it. Lacking much in the way of financial literacy, many undoubtedly fell victim to professional crooks.

It's hardly any surprise that property markets across Germany started heating up around that time. Property is widely viewed as a safe bet. They call it 'Betongold' or 'concrete gold' for a reason. I know that isn't the only factor behind the vast increase in property values in many areas, but it's undoubtedly a major one, and I think we can expect this situation with interest rates to further inflate what is beginning to look like a bubble.

Nominal property values in the mid-sized city where I live have more than doubled in a decade--seems like a wild party after decades of relatively flat (real) property values.

It's something of a shock, given that earnings have hardly budged during the same period. One could argue that Germany was abnormally cheap 10 years ago in terms of both consumer goods and real estate, and it might be true, but the reality on the ground is pretty disheartening, particularly in light of political developments in places such as Saxony. I'm afraid the squeeze on people in the middle is going to fuel more political instability, or could at the very least be used to stir up trouble.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by krilly on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:33PM (#20794626)
Could you elaborate on how the behaviour of German savers differs to those in other countries?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:40PM (#20794673)
> Could you elaborate on how the behaviour of German savers differs to those in other countries?

European finance is bank based. Banks make most of the loans. Bank managers decide which projects get financed and which don’t. Investors put money in banks and let the banks make decisions.

American finance is market based. Bond buyers make most of the loans. Bond (and stock) investors decide which projects get financed and which don’t. Investors themselves make decisions.

Broadly speaking, the European bank-based model is moribund. It concentrates risks and is too conservative. The ECB is trying to change this, but it involves changing a social contract around how investors behave. This has happened without a broader debate, because Europe, and now we’re seeing a backlash in Germany.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:03PM (#20795183)
I don't think the ECB is trying to change anything fundamental. It is merely acting within its mandate to keep inflation from falling too far below 2%. That is what democratically elected politicians told it to do. Inflation forecasts are far below target:

https://www.ecb.europa.eu/stats/ecb_surveys/survey_of_profes...

It's not the ECB that is being unreasonable here. It's Germany. Why on earth would you run a balanced budget while getting paid for borrowing? That is just irrational beyond belief.

Fiscal policy is a national matter. It is Germans who need to have that debate you're talking about without constantly blaming the ECB for their own failings.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by luckylion on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:17PM (#20795285)
> Why on earth would you run a balanced budget while getting paid for borrowing?

You still need to pay the money back after you invested it. If those investments don't make a profit, you're in trouble. I mean, they could park it in ... maybe bonds? Oh wait.. ;)

There also no telling what the future brings. Borrowing to the limit while times are good leaves you no room when times are bad. A recession is on the horizon, it sounds foolish to shoot your powder before it hits.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:11PM (#20795622)
It's not like Germans are squirrels piling up acorns for the winter. They are keeping gigantic amounts of money in cash, cash that nobody wants. When the crash hits, they didn't do anything useful to prepare for it.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by luckylion on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:15AM (#20797802)
> It's not like Germans are squirrels piling up acorns for the winter.

It's exactly like that. They save not because "omg saving is so cool", they save for rainy days. Germans value predictability and security over short term consumption, though that is changing slowly.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:09PM (#20811186)
They didn't do that at all. Did they stockpile food, or gasoline? Did they build extra houses, or cars, or infrastructure. They did not. They put money in the bank. Money by itself doesn't do anything. It has to be invested, and right now the risk-free investments have negative interest rates.

It's hard for individuals to save the way squirrels do. Farmers could do it, but that's it. Now it requires governments, and Germans elected a government that refused to do it, and instead imposed balanced budgets instead. Now they are suffering the consequences of that.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:35PM (#20795401)
>Borrowing to the limit while times are good leaves you no room when times are bad

Times are bad. Germany is very likely in a recession right now and they have fallen back technologically. Now is the time to spend some money and it was never cheaper.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by majewsky on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:43PM (#20795447)
Exactly. And if we don't spend it on a proper Energiewende and to fix our crumbling infrastructure, we will pay it back 20-fold in a few decades.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by luckylion on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:03PM (#20795570)
Times are starting to look bad ... but that's my point: don't burn all your wood on the first day of winter when you'll likely still have months ahead.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:16PM (#20795651)
Don't forget that recessions have a self-reinforcing, psychological element that winters don't have. Money spent earlier may have a significant multiplier effect.

Also, I think spending money is too slow anyway, especially if it is spent on infrastructure, technology development, retooling an obsolete auto and energy sector, etc.

In my view, they are already very very late.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wbl on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:10PM (#20796546)
Germany has enormous borrowing capacity especially in a recession. Governments are not households.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by dragonwriter on Monday August 26, 2019 @05:43AM (#20798475)
> don't burn all your wood on the first day of winter when you'll likely still have months ahead.

The analogy doesn't hold since burning wood doesn't help shorten winter.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Paradigma11 on Monday August 26, 2019 @05:36AM (#20798450)
"Why on earth would you run a balanced budget while getting paid for borrowing?"

Because later you will have to refinance your debt on worse terms.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by duxup on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:15PM (#20797200)
>This won't work because German savers have virtually no experience of such a system.

What do you mean by that?

The incentive is just the same either way. So if they move it from say savings to some investment... not sure that requires huge experience. Most american's aren't savvy investors.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by MandieD on Monday August 26, 2019 @08:59AM (#20799478)
While some of us in Germany have betriebliche Altersvorsorge (employer old-age savings), it's nothing like an American 401k. Up to a certain limit much lower than a US 401k, I decide how much I want to contribute pre-tax, my employer tells me how it's generally being invested and what minimum rate I can expect, and I can decide at what point between ages 62 and 67 I want to start taking withdrawals (which are only in one lump sum or five tranches), but I have absolutely no control past that.

There are other retirement savings vehicles, but they're pretty much all annuities. Most Germans, including well-earning engineers like my husband, can't imagine receiving post-retirement income in anything other than a monthly pension; perhaps rent on apartments or houses they've managed to buy along the way. Remember that less than half of German adults live in home they own; renting the same apartment for 40 years is not unusual here.

Germans tend to be more skeptical about the stock market than Americans are. To balance this, they are also far more hesitant to borrow for consumption - my husband's family were slightly horrified that I'd financed the full cost of my car, on top of owing student loans. I didn't mention the credit card debt it took me a couple of years to finish off!

(Me: American who grew up watching my parents always make their payments, but pretty much always have a car loan and who took out some of the student loans I paid back because they absolutely had no discretionary savings.

Husband: German who grew up watching his parents buy 3-5 year old cars with bank drafts once their old one started spending too much time at the shop, and then gave him a bunch of their savings as a university graduation present that sat in his bank account until we bought our house 15 years later)

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by thecleaner on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:40PM (#20794666)
It would be great for German investors to stop being such cowards when it comes to risk taking. I am not sure where this culture even came from.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by scotch_drinker on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:09PM (#20794843)
If only we had a clue where it came from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation_in_the_Weimar_R...
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:22PM (#20794928)
You're saying that the less Germans learned from hyperinflation in the Weimar Republic is to hold lots of fiat money? Sounds backwards.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by scotch_drinker on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:20PM (#20796994)
What they learned is that solving problems with debt is bad. So they try to not have debt by saving a lot. The fact they do it with the same fiat currency system is another matter. But that history lesson is one the OP seems to be ignorant of.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rexgallorum2 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:17PM (#20796281)
Currency reform in 1948 also produced winners and losers. Worth a read.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by SquishyPanda23 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:57PM (#20795132)
People get to decide what to do with their property in a lot of countries.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by baddox on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:29PM (#20794607)
Guess it just sucks for people who make a modest living and want to save a modest portion of their income over many years.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wbl on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:11PM (#20796548)
They can put their money to work in the stock markets.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rorykoehler on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:43PM (#20797075)
Germany recently changed the law so you have to pay capital gains on unrealised gains so even that is expensive now.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by crucialfelix on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:44AM (#20797704)
Wow that's complicated. As you hold the fund, each year you need to recalculate estimated cap gains. You do get a credit if the fund goes down.

But what if I (German resident US citizen) leave the country before I sell the fund? They would have to refund all they had taxed; otherwise how do you reconcile that with tax in a new country of residence?

https://www.howtogermany.com/pages/germantaxesforinvestment....

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wbl on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:38PM (#20797297)
Well aren't there gains if you are being taxed?
[dead]
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:53PM (#20795093)
There's nothing honest or dishonest, sound or unsound about this. It's a question of what the role of money is in a given civil society. The US tends to view money as a tool for voting on which projects, companies, etc are most efficient.

Saving doesn't always mean saving money but rather saving value. If you own your house and land outright, would you not consider that "savings"? What about government bonds? Corporate bonds? Fixed-incomes? Dividend bearing stocks? Growth stocks? All of that is savings. Cash in a mattress is an unproductive asset, it's a waste of potential. An account at a bank that lends and kicks some back to you may be the most productive allocation in some circumstances but overwhelmingly it isn't. Money is only valuable when it moves.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by repolfx on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:54PM (#20795848)
Saving doesn't always mean saving money but rather saving value

Well, this is the crux of the issue. In the language I learned (British English) the word savings does refer exclusively to cash. Investment is an entirely separate concept, as are assets. I would never consider a house to be savings, because savings are there to provide a buffer if your income suddenly drops below your structural spending level - the proverbial rainy day. Selling a house takes a very long time and has huge overheads, plus, of course, you still need somewhere to live.

Unless your first reaction to e.g. losing a job is to immediately sell your house, your house is therefore not savings.

Government bonds? Great until they default.

Corporate bonds? Ditto.

Growth stocks?!?! The things that can easily move in value 20% in a single day? That's not savings, that's an investment at best or a risky gamble at worst.

Money is only valuable when it moves.

No, money is a store of value, that's literally a part of the definition of what makes something money. It is valuable because it lets you obtain resources later, without having to barter for them at that exact moment.

Money saved means you can lose your job and continue to buy things: that fact alone has value even if the money itself isn't moving right now. This really isn't hard to understand.

The demonisation of savings in our society is one of the most severe problems we face, if not the most severe. It's impossible to have any kind of justice or stability in the world if nobody has any savings, because they convinced themselves a tech stock is the same thing.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:17PM (#20811302)
The exact opposite is true. Savers have been spoiled for generations because they got a positive return without doing any work, or bearing any risk. Those days have ended, at least in Europe.

Nobody owes you a risk-free positive return. If investors don't need your money, then they don't need your money. Money is only a store of value over short time periods (and if inflation is high not even then). Money only has value because you can get it today and use it in transactions tomorrow. If you take that money and stick it in a mattress for a year, nobody owes anything for doing so.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Nursie on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:52PM (#20796156)
> No, money is a store of value, that's literally a part of the definition of what makes something money.

Not according to Merriam Webster - https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/money Nor the OED - https://www.lexico.com/en/definition/money Nor Collins - https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/money

In fact that little factoid you present is a hallmark of Austrian economic thinking and usually cryptocurrency enthusiasm...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mcguire on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:20PM (#20796295)
"The demonisation of savings in our society is one of the most severe problems we face, if not the most severe."

To an extent, you are right. Here in the US, anyway. But it is possible to go too far in the other direction as well.

If all of your disposable money is going into savings, you have no need to borrow money, so the bank isn't making loans, so the interest rate you receive has to fall. More importantly, if you are not spending money, the people you aren't buying from have no incentive to invest. The result is a stagnant economy.

Saving too much is almost as bad as saving too little.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by repolfx on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:13PM (#20802273)
I don't think there's any reason for an economy where people save responsibly to be stagnant. That's the error central bankers make. It's sort of like saying if you're not constantly taking ecstasy then your life is stagnant and boring - it might seem like that to someone coming down from an unsustainable lifestyle, but to people who aren't constantly on stimulants life seems just fine and not stagnant at all.

That is, if you judge an economy purely on the basis of "how much stuff is getting done" without caring about what that stuff is, or whether it's actually useful, then yes confiscating savings and making it impossible to actually keep stable money anywhere (which is actually called "economic stimulus"), well, it will appear to make your economy more dynamic. If you start taking into account economic stability though, well, the highs and lows of boom/bust QE-driven economics don't look so great.

So there's really no such thing as saving too much. How much to save is a very personal decision. If you over-save it means lost opportunities, unless you deliberately want to pass your wealth onto your children. But if you save too little, the results can be catastrophic unless the government bails you out, which creates the massive moral hazard that wrecks our global economy today.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by jay_kyburz on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:48PM (#20796127)
I speak mostly British English here in Australia as well, and here and I believe most people would expect you to have your savings parked somewhere doing something. Having your house paid off or even paying down the mortgage or an investment properly is still considered saving. Anything that could be converted back to cash if needed.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by kamyarg on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:38PM (#20796077)
I wish I could upvote twice, this is so true. It is funny when people forget what money was meant to be; "a store of value".
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mcguire on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:23PM (#20796317)
A "store of value", like putting money under your mattress, is, economically speaking, useless.¹

Remember the categorical imperative: "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can, at the same time, will that it should become a universal law."

¹ Beyond a point anyway. Keep 3 to 6 months' income readily available.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:15AM (#20797424)
I mean, you're arguing against a point I didn't make, but I'll take the bait anyway....

People should not be forced to go further out on the risk spectrum than they want to by government policy (which is what you are suggesting by saying that we shouldn't have what economists call sound money). Forcing them to do that distorts the economy. People should buy bonds because they think the extra risk is justified, not because there is no alternative.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by chii on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:23AM (#20797837)
and perhaps the situation has come to the point where low risk investments aren't available anymore. The banks (or ECB) cannot offer risk free interest rates anymore because there just isn't enough such investments to satisfy the demand.

The lever that policy has is interest rates, and by lowering it even more, it forces savers to adjust their view on risk - if they can handle the lowered interest because their risk tolerance is so low that they cant buy bonds or anything, then they will need to suffer the low rates.

It's just that a lot of people are in the situation where they cannot take on any risk with their savings. Historiaclly, banks being risk free is just a gimmick (even if the gov't is insuring the deposit). Banks's risks are diversified, and minimized. But if the economy is doing poorly, they cannot magically produce the low risk returns.

I think the only way forward is actually gov't spending sprees - invest in long term projects, like 100 year long projects, and make these projects the backbone of fiscal policy (print money, if needed). Long term projects that can derive value for all of society, such as establishing bases on moon/mars, mining asteroids, etc.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Monday August 26, 2019 @04:51PM (#20803633)
Another option is "sound money" (historically, this was gold). If you had a sound money option available, people could save wealth without going further out on the risk curve.

At this point, even high-quality corporate bonds are going negative in Europe, so people who want to save have to take a big risk.

In my opinion that is unnatural; it's a creation of central planners who forced everyone away from gold and into fiat currencies.

Gold is pretty risky now because it's not actually used as a currency and thus has low liquidity. If we all used gold as a currency, it would have high liquidity and it would be very stable. (I don't want to go back to gold because digital currency is far more practical, but I'm just making a historical point.)

> I think the only way forward is actually gov't spending sprees

That is going further in the direction of central planning and also further inhibits regular people from saving and investing safely and wisely. How is the middle class going to save and invest under this paradigm? I think the most likely answer is that they won't/can't, and the middle class disappears (like what happens with hyperinflation, e.g. Weimar Germany).

A recurring theme: I am really against central planning. The planners do not always get it right, and when they screw up big time, it makes the system collapse. When people are free to make their own choices the economy adjusts dynamically.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Monday August 26, 2019 @11:04PM (#20805997)
I guess what I don't understand is why we need to force everyone onto sound money. People who receive what they perceive as unsound money can use it to buy whatever would back sound money anyways, can they not?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:07PM (#20822945)
We don't need to force people onto sound money. People will adopt it naturally over time if it's better for them than fiat money.

However, there is no sound money right now. Bitcoin was designed to be sound money in theory, but it has to get a lot more liquidity first. Gold once was sound money, but also would need a lot more liquidity to be sound money once again. So we just have to wait. I'm not suggesting that we force it.

Fiat money seems destined to eventually collapse. There is a long road, but every time fiat money stumbles, it will be a little victory for alternatives. Investors have been fleeing into gold lately. Wealthy Chinese people have been fleeing into bitcoin to at least some small extent.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:19PM (#20811345)
Sound money is the surest route to destroying capitalism.

The middle class didn't disappear because of Weimar. (It was a mixed bag, because the hyperinflation wiped out a lot of debts.) They disappeared because of the Great Depression. Sound money caused that.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:12PM (#20822999)
> Sound money is the surest route to destroying capitalism.

I don't agree at all. But let's wait and see. That is a risk I'm happy to take. Sound money is honest money. A system that can't survive sound money is an unsound system.

Anyway, we probably disagree on the definition of 'capitalism.' We don't have capitalism now, we have a mixed economy with partial capitalism.

> the Great Depression. Sound money caused that.

I completely disagree. This is but one theory, and I don't think it's a good one.

> It was a mixed bag, because the hyperinflation wiped out a lot of debts.

Hyperinflation = no debts, but also no savings. So only the very wealthy with large portfolios in real estate or industry could survive financially. Everyone else reduced to poverty. (Granted, I'm no expert on Weimar history, so if that's not exactly accurate, I welcome corrections.)

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Thursday August 29, 2019 @06:52AM (#20828345)
Sound money destroys entrepreneurialism. Rather than investors taking risks to ensure a return for the future, they rely on the government to create risk-free investments for them.

The German economy recovered from hyperinflation, and was booming by the end of the twenties, only to be taken down by the Great Depression. Under Hitler, they abandoned the gold standard, and their economy recovered.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:19PM (#20795298)
>An account at a bank that lends and kicks some back to you may be the most productive allocation in some circumstances but overwhelmingly it isn't.

At least it's better than putting money in an index ETF, because bankers making loans do actually contribute to the capital allocation process in a meaningful way.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:30PM (#20795368)
I believe thats a decision everyone has to make individually, and that's the point :)
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:43PM (#20795444)
Of course, but we are discussing the macroeconomic effects of those decisions. Maybe I misunderstand ...
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:05PM (#20795588)
Oh no I might not have been clear. I'm just taking the position that allocating capital between cash and even index ETFs is meant to be a voting mechanism of how that capital can be most effectively utilized. You're right that active capital management via the bank represents a choice by someone with experience, but that doesn't mean that it's the best use of capital. Further, even if you invest in broad market ETFs you're still picking winners. We may actually just agree here :)
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:28PM (#20795721)
>Further, even if you invest in broad market ETFs you're still picking winners.

What you're not doing is provide capital to companies or contribute to the information processing that makes markets efficient (at least not very much).

Crucially, bank loans (as well as IPOs, rights issues and bond issues) provide capital. Trading existing stocks doesn't.

So when it comes to capital allocation, you're not picking winners and losers by buying an index ETF, because no capital is created at all.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:38PM (#20801924)
This is a legitimate question, does it not set the rates for any secondary offerings?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:20PM (#20794136)
But what people forget is it is not just "evil big corp" that has cash on hand which will be devalued in such a way. Individuals do too. Pension plans do. All those will also lose out. Why is there some bureaucrat in an office deciding how much my money gains or loses today? Maybe it would be better to go back to the gold standard.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:29PM (#20794210)
Nothing is stopping you from storing your savings in gold right now. You don’t need the gold standard for that.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by the-dude on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:33PM (#20794241)
Last week I stumbled upon an article which claimed the Dutch government ( NL ) has the power to claim all private gold in the country.

If it is true, I wonder if similar laws exist in other countries.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by cbanek on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:32PM (#20794238)
Other than needing to safely store your gold somewhere. I'm guessing there's probably also some insurance you could get to protect against loss? With a bank these are generally "free" with laws that protect deposits.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:40PM (#20794293)
If you trust others to keep it for you, there are companies that let you buy gold online that they will store for you, and there are even gold ETFs. If you have a brokerage account, buy some shares of GLD and you’re done.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rightbyte on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:49PM (#20794360)
If you don't trust the financial system surely you don't trust gold certificates either.

Dig it down ... atleast I would.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:54PM (#20794386)
The original comment mentioned the gold standard, which is just gold certificates used as everyday currency.

If you don’t trust that sort of stuff then the gold standard is totally irrelevant anyway.

[dead]
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:03PM (#20795178)
> Why can't we put money back "on gold?"

Why. To what end? Assuming a fixed amount of gold and a growing economy, you end up creating deflation, which in turn serves to exacerbate wealth inequality in the country. It makes old money wealthier over time. Deflation reduces lending (because it's a "risk free" ROI) and reduced lending slows down the economy. If you don't trust the government to administer the fiat supply, why on earth would you trust them to administer a gold-backed supply? The government is the one that ended it last time around.

If you believe gold is a better store of value by all means buy gold, or buy gold ETFs, mutual funds, shares in gold miners, go 100% gold. Drop it into a margin account, and borrow against it. That gets you everything you want and more. There's no reason to switch over to gold from fiat, in fact you're advantaged if you're the only one doing this and it is in fact better. History however shows us that's not the case.

And then what, we mine one asteroid [1] and your gold pile and all the money associated therewith is worthless?

[1] https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/1169605/Asteroid-news...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:16PM (#20796275)
> To what end?

Stopping inflation. The idea that my money is worth less today than it was yesterday is ridiculous. It's not a store of value, and violates one of the three tenets of currency.

> exacerbate wealth inequality

This does not strike me as a reason not to pass a policy. It is true only because Americans are by-and-large spendthrifts. We have gotten away from saving and personal responsibility. Maybe we wouldn't see the large increases in housing prices etc. if we didn't have this runaway creation of fake value based on leverage. I don't think it's sustainable, the economy is overheating, and we will hurt for it. Stagflation proved keynesianism wrong; time for a different approach of the government out of the economy.

More importantly, inflation is already a huge tax on the poor and unbanked. Every one else can recover at least some of the inflation tax; these people cannot.

Finally, deflation may not be as bad as every one thought. [0]

> If you don't trust the government to administer the fiat supply, why on earth would you trust them to administer a gold-backed supply?

I do in part, but there is no reason banks could not issue their own gold certificates. More importantly, the government is not the monolith as which you address it. The fed is separate and independent, and would fill this job (although I still would dispute the constitutionality of a federal reserve, some degree of weaning is probably necessary). This would reign in the profligate spending of the American congress, as the supply of loanable funds would shrink. It would also mean we can't just screw pension funds and individuals by inflating our way out of the problem. The wealthy can personally invest in the market and manage their own money (or hire those smart enough to do so), while every one else pays. Here's an excellent paper with more info: https://mises-media.s3.amazonaws.com/qjae11_1_1.pdf

Finally, inflation tends to encourage economic "fake growth". This is the kind of "growth" shown by sv unicorns, by hedge funds during an expansion, by those who push around rather than make money. Too much fake growth -> overheated economy -> a broader crash. Changes of that sort give the most powerful and most opportunistic the opportunity to profit rather than those with real value to contribute.

> And then what, we mine one asteroid [1] and your gold pile and all the money associated therewith is worthless?

By then we could probably switch over to a (non-bitcoin) crypto-currency. Though I'd blanch at the idea of the gov't creating one now, as it would be doubtless be used to track all spending to "combat money laundering" or some baloney.

My overall point is that we've taken the wrong approach to the economy. We've let this lefty-keynesian approach lure us away from a laissez-faire system with short-term gains and false promises of growth.

[0]: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/111715/can-def...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Nasrudith on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:11PM (#20797172)
Actually yes it is less valueable over time - because economies grow and goods become cheaper. An early pc may be about $900 in today's money. Now go further back to say the value of a barrel itself as cooping became more widespread. The currency in the past is a store of past value in transactions.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mcguire on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:30PM (#20796345)
Tying the growth of your economy to the amount of a metal you can dig out of the ground doesn't sound like a great idea.

Seems like a 1.2% growth rate.

[dead]
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:08PM (#20795214)
Don't be the guy advocating putting money into bitcoin to store value when we know 95% of all bitcoin trading volume is fake [1], the primary liquidity supplier in the space is currently being investigated by the NYAG for being a giant fraud [2] and the price is manipulated to serve exchanges looking to trim short and long positions. It's beanie babies for nerds. Parent said "safe" and BTC is about as safe as a chainsaw made of razor blades with no hand guard.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/22/majority-of-bitcoin-trading-...

[2] https://cointelegraph.com/news/tethers-trouble-with-new-york...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:48PM (#20795821)
arcticbull, I feel like you have a pattern of being too aggressive with me. Just pointing it out. I have a pattern of being too aggressive in the past and I am trying to tone it back. I appreciate having people to disagree with me, so please keep doing that. (Sorry if this comes across as patronizing, patronizing people is one of my greatest pet peeves.)

> Don't be the guy advocating putting money into bitcoin to store value

Well, I didn't. Bitcoin was designed to be sound and honest money on theoretical grounds. But it hasn't yet achieved the needed liquidity to be relatively stable in value. I hope it does some day, but I don't know if it will.

Anyway, the issues you are raising with your references do not worry me in the least. I have been watching bitcoin a long time and I think that's just short-term news. It's not part of the macro picture. It's like if you came back from a 20 year stint in a monastery tomorrow and watched the news---you would think for sure the world is ending tomorrow. Everything seems like a crisis in the moment, but it isn't.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:49PM (#20796705)
Truly apologize if I offended you ^_^ tone doesn’t carry well on the internet. I’m just stating my beliefs, and the “don’t be the guy” was a riff on the parent post. I also come here to have my beliefs challenged.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:55PM (#20797363)
You didn't offend me. Yeah, I didn't pick up on the "don't be the guy" thing being a riff on what I said, so that makes more sense.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Daido_M on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:57AM (#20797548)
An actual civil conversation between two mature people on the Internet! This brought a tear to my eye.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:50PM (#20795082)
> this is why bitcoin was created

I like the idea of cryptocurrency, but bitcoin is an awful store of value compared to gold. I haven't found a recent calculation for the beta of bitcoin, but it's something pretty crazy. Also, china controls over 2/3 of btc hashing power; I don't trust her with a penny.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:52PM (#20795837)
I don't agree with you, but I upvoted you. Bitcoin was designed to replay gold/fiat money, but definitely hasn't grown up yet in terms of liquidity. That's OK in my book.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by toomuchtodo on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:26PM (#20794185)
There is a penalty for assuming the future will always have value you’ll be able to extract.

Perhaps everyone will consider working less when your excess fiat has so little value.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by EliRivers on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:32PM (#20794236)
Why is there some bureaucrat in an office deciding how much my money gains or loses today?

How else would interest rates be set? If you want your money to grow all by itself just because you deposited in an account with an interest rate, how does that interest rate get decided if not by someone in an office? Someone, in an office, whatever tools they use to decide, has to make that decision, surely.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wongarsu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:46PM (#20794337)
The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm. Running that algorithm once a month and using it to set the bank's interest rate would be an interesting model that doesn't directly involve humans.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:48PM (#20794353)
> The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm

This is a good way to blow up a bank.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wongarsu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:06PM (#20794467)
I'm not saying the algorithm is trivial, as it has to take long-term factors into account, as well as the reaction of the market to the new interest rate, and of course add safety and profit margins. It would be quite a bit of work, but it's well aligned with the core-competency of banks.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:29PM (#20794606)
> It would be quite a bit of work, but it's well aligned with the core-competency of banks

It is, and it’s difficult. Perhaps fundamentally impossible, given it would have to predict consumers’ tastes and preferences to estimate B2C companies’ creditworthiness.

Rates are negotiated instruments, a combination of the return on safe assets today, the risk of that rate changing tomorrow, and the credit profile and availability of borrowers. There is no known algorithm which can robustly balance these variables. If it were discovered, it would be worth billions, perhaps more, and fundamentally change finance. Pretty much every crisis has a story about smart people thinking they’ve solved this problem in some narrow niche of the economy and then being shown disastrously wrong.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:17PM (#20796283)
> Perhaps fundamentally impossible

It can't be done by one individual for the whole market, but the invisible hand does a pretty good job. The principle of a market as a whole establishing prices, rates, etc. is widely accepted.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:17PM (#20795657)
If you calculated that interest rate, it would be negative. Ten-year German bonds have a negative interest rate. Cash savings pay less than bonds, so money in a cash account pays an even-more negative rate.

The only way banks could pay a higher interest rate would be to bear more risk, but that's how you get a banking crisis.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mruts on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#20794508)
Interest rates in the US are not set directly by the government. Instead the federal funds rate is a target rate that the Fed aims for by either expanding or contracting the money supply.

Also the TIBOR and LIBOR and all the other *IBORs aren’t set by the government either. Certainly government monetary policies affect these rates, but ultimately it’s a free market function.

Having the government directly set private lending rates is a very bad idea and would certainly result in disaster (much like how all other price controls are terrible ideas).

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by blake1 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:22PM (#20794932)
Very short term interest rates in the US are set by the Fed, pretty much at will.

Under normal conditions, they have an extremely strong influence on medium term interest rates as well by convincing the market that they will keep short rates high(low) in the future, while will then raise(lower) medium terms rates.

If that proves inadequate, like it did after the crisis, the Fed can buy and sell bonds directly to move medium to long-term interest rates.

The Fed may have a historical preference for relying on the first mechanism alone, but through some combination of these techniques, they can set any interest rate to any reasonable value almost at will.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mruts on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:55PM (#20796177)
Sure all of that’s true, but I think there’s a big philosophical and moral difference between changing the incentives of bankers vs forcing them to lend and borrow at a set rate. One relies on an efficient market and incentives while the other relies on coercion and force. It’s possible that the result of both of these systems are equivalent in many situations, but one is much more robust than the other because it still allows for price competition.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:23PM (#20794939)
> How else would interest rates be set?

By a free market, the same way it was set for a very long time. It gets decided by how many people borrow at a given rate, which will typically raise or lower the rate. Some one will make small adjustments around the broader market rate; if enough people make those small adjustments in one direction, the range moves.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:11PM (#20811222)
I'm not quite sure what you have in mind, but in a free market, interest rates in Germany would now be negative. People are demanding government action to prevent it.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by maxerickson on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:52PM (#20794379)
Do they mean public official?

Lots of interest rates are influenced by markets, where lenders and borrowers base their activity on available rates (if no one borrows at a given rate, a lender may seek business by reducing the rate...).