News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:20PM (#20794136)
But what people forget is it is not just "evil big corp" that has cash on hand which will be devalued in such a way. Individuals do too. Pension plans do. All those will also lose out. Why is there some bureaucrat in an office deciding how much my money gains or loses today? Maybe it would be better to go back to the gold standard.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:29PM (#20794210)
Nothing is stopping you from storing your savings in gold right now. You don’t need the gold standard for that.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by the-dude on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:33PM (#20794241)
Last week I stumbled upon an article which claimed the Dutch government ( NL ) has the power to claim all private gold in the country.

If it is true, I wonder if similar laws exist in other countries.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by cbanek on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:32PM (#20794238)
Other than needing to safely store your gold somewhere. I'm guessing there's probably also some insurance you could get to protect against loss? With a bank these are generally "free" with laws that protect deposits.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:40PM (#20794293)
If you trust others to keep it for you, there are companies that let you buy gold online that they will store for you, and there are even gold ETFs. If you have a brokerage account, buy some shares of GLD and you’re done.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by rightbyte on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:49PM (#20794360)
If you don't trust the financial system surely you don't trust gold certificates either.

Dig it down ... atleast I would.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:54PM (#20794386)
The original comment mentioned the gold standard, which is just gold certificates used as everyday currency.

If you don’t trust that sort of stuff then the gold standard is totally irrelevant anyway.

[dead]
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:03PM (#20795178)
> Why can't we put money back "on gold?"

Why. To what end? Assuming a fixed amount of gold and a growing economy, you end up creating deflation, which in turn serves to exacerbate wealth inequality in the country. It makes old money wealthier over time. Deflation reduces lending (because it's a "risk free" ROI) and reduced lending slows down the economy. If you don't trust the government to administer the fiat supply, why on earth would you trust them to administer a gold-backed supply? The government is the one that ended it last time around.

If you believe gold is a better store of value by all means buy gold, or buy gold ETFs, mutual funds, shares in gold miners, go 100% gold. Drop it into a margin account, and borrow against it. That gets you everything you want and more. There's no reason to switch over to gold from fiat, in fact you're advantaged if you're the only one doing this and it is in fact better. History however shows us that's not the case.

And then what, we mine one asteroid [1] and your gold pile and all the money associated therewith is worthless?

[1] https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/1169605/Asteroid-news...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:16PM (#20796275)
> To what end?

Stopping inflation. The idea that my money is worth less today than it was yesterday is ridiculous. It's not a store of value, and violates one of the three tenets of currency.

> exacerbate wealth inequality

This does not strike me as a reason not to pass a policy. It is true only because Americans are by-and-large spendthrifts. We have gotten away from saving and personal responsibility. Maybe we wouldn't see the large increases in housing prices etc. if we didn't have this runaway creation of fake value based on leverage. I don't think it's sustainable, the economy is overheating, and we will hurt for it. Stagflation proved keynesianism wrong; time for a different approach of the government out of the economy.

More importantly, inflation is already a huge tax on the poor and unbanked. Every one else can recover at least some of the inflation tax; these people cannot.

Finally, deflation may not be as bad as every one thought. [0]

> If you don't trust the government to administer the fiat supply, why on earth would you trust them to administer a gold-backed supply?

I do in part, but there is no reason banks could not issue their own gold certificates. More importantly, the government is not the monolith as which you address it. The fed is separate and independent, and would fill this job (although I still would dispute the constitutionality of a federal reserve, some degree of weaning is probably necessary). This would reign in the profligate spending of the American congress, as the supply of loanable funds would shrink. It would also mean we can't just screw pension funds and individuals by inflating our way out of the problem. The wealthy can personally invest in the market and manage their own money (or hire those smart enough to do so), while every one else pays. Here's an excellent paper with more info: https://mises-media.s3.amazonaws.com/qjae11_1_1.pdf

Finally, inflation tends to encourage economic "fake growth". This is the kind of "growth" shown by sv unicorns, by hedge funds during an expansion, by those who push around rather than make money. Too much fake growth -> overheated economy -> a broader crash. Changes of that sort give the most powerful and most opportunistic the opportunity to profit rather than those with real value to contribute.

> And then what, we mine one asteroid [1] and your gold pile and all the money associated therewith is worthless?

By then we could probably switch over to a (non-bitcoin) crypto-currency. Though I'd blanch at the idea of the gov't creating one now, as it would be doubtless be used to track all spending to "combat money laundering" or some baloney.

My overall point is that we've taken the wrong approach to the economy. We've let this lefty-keynesian approach lure us away from a laissez-faire system with short-term gains and false promises of growth.

[0]: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/111715/can-def...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Nasrudith on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:11PM (#20797172)
Actually yes it is less valueable over time - because economies grow and goods become cheaper. An early pc may be about $900 in today's money. Now go further back to say the value of a barrel itself as cooping became more widespread. The currency in the past is a store of past value in transactions.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mcguire on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:30PM (#20796345)
Tying the growth of your economy to the amount of a metal you can dig out of the ground doesn't sound like a great idea.

Seems like a 1.2% growth rate.

[dead]
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:08PM (#20795214)
Don't be the guy advocating putting money into bitcoin to store value when we know 95% of all bitcoin trading volume is fake [1], the primary liquidity supplier in the space is currently being investigated by the NYAG for being a giant fraud [2] and the price is manipulated to serve exchanges looking to trim short and long positions. It's beanie babies for nerds. Parent said "safe" and BTC is about as safe as a chainsaw made of razor blades with no hand guard.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/22/majority-of-bitcoin-trading-...

[2] https://cointelegraph.com/news/tethers-trouble-with-new-york...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:48PM (#20795821)
arcticbull, I feel like you have a pattern of being too aggressive with me. Just pointing it out. I have a pattern of being too aggressive in the past and I am trying to tone it back. I appreciate having people to disagree with me, so please keep doing that. (Sorry if this comes across as patronizing, patronizing people is one of my greatest pet peeves.)

> Don't be the guy advocating putting money into bitcoin to store value

Well, I didn't. Bitcoin was designed to be sound and honest money on theoretical grounds. But it hasn't yet achieved the needed liquidity to be relatively stable in value. I hope it does some day, but I don't know if it will.

Anyway, the issues you are raising with your references do not worry me in the least. I have been watching bitcoin a long time and I think that's just short-term news. It's not part of the macro picture. It's like if you came back from a 20 year stint in a monastery tomorrow and watched the news---you would think for sure the world is ending tomorrow. Everything seems like a crisis in the moment, but it isn't.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by arcticbull on Sunday August 25, 2019 @08:49PM (#20796705)
Truly apologize if I offended you ^_^ tone doesn’t carry well on the internet. I’m just stating my beliefs, and the “don’t be the guy” was a riff on the parent post. I also come here to have my beliefs challenged.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @11:55PM (#20797363)
You didn't offend me. Yeah, I didn't pick up on the "don't be the guy" thing being a riff on what I said, so that makes more sense.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Daido_M on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:57AM (#20797548)
An actual civil conversation between two mature people on the Internet! This brought a tear to my eye.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:50PM (#20795082)
> this is why bitcoin was created

I like the idea of cryptocurrency, but bitcoin is an awful store of value compared to gold. I haven't found a recent calculation for the beta of bitcoin, but it's something pretty crazy. Also, china controls over 2/3 of btc hashing power; I don't trust her with a penny.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by javert on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:52PM (#20795837)
I don't agree with you, but I upvoted you. Bitcoin was designed to replay gold/fiat money, but definitely hasn't grown up yet in terms of liquidity. That's OK in my book.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by toomuchtodo on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:26PM (#20794185)
There is a penalty for assuming the future will always have value you’ll be able to extract.

Perhaps everyone will consider working less when your excess fiat has so little value.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by EliRivers on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:32PM (#20794236)
Why is there some bureaucrat in an office deciding how much my money gains or loses today?

How else would interest rates be set? If you want your money to grow all by itself just because you deposited in an account with an interest rate, how does that interest rate get decided if not by someone in an office? Someone, in an office, whatever tools they use to decide, has to make that decision, surely.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wongarsu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:46PM (#20794337)
The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm. Running that algorithm once a month and using it to set the bank's interest rate would be an interesting model that doesn't directly involve humans.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:48PM (#20794353)
> The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm

This is a good way to blow up a bank.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wongarsu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:06PM (#20794467)
I'm not saying the algorithm is trivial, as it has to take long-term factors into account, as well as the reaction of the market to the new interest rate, and of course add safety and profit margins. It would be quite a bit of work, but it's well aligned with the core-competency of banks.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:29PM (#20794606)
> It would be quite a bit of work, but it's well aligned with the core-competency of banks

It is, and it’s difficult. Perhaps fundamentally impossible, given it would have to predict consumers’ tastes and preferences to estimate B2C companies’ creditworthiness.

Rates are negotiated instruments, a combination of the return on safe assets today, the risk of that rate changing tomorrow, and the credit profile and availability of borrowers. There is no known algorithm which can robustly balance these variables. If it were discovered, it would be worth billions, perhaps more, and fundamentally change finance. Pretty much every crisis has a story about smart people thinking they’ve solved this problem in some narrow niche of the economy and then being shown disastrously wrong.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:17PM (#20796283)
> Perhaps fundamentally impossible

It can't be done by one individual for the whole market, but the invisible hand does a pretty good job. The principle of a market as a whole establishing prices, rates, etc. is widely accepted.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:17PM (#20795657)
If you calculated that interest rate, it would be negative. Ten-year German bonds have a negative interest rate. Cash savings pay less than bonds, so money in a cash account pays an even-more negative rate.

The only way banks could pay a higher interest rate would be to bear more risk, but that's how you get a banking crisis.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mruts on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#20794508)
Interest rates in the US are not set directly by the government. Instead the federal funds rate is a target rate that the Fed aims for by either expanding or contracting the money supply.

Also the TIBOR and LIBOR and all the other *IBORs aren’t set by the government either. Certainly government monetary policies affect these rates, but ultimately it’s a free market function.

Having the government directly set private lending rates is a very bad idea and would certainly result in disaster (much like how all other price controls are terrible ideas).

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by blake1 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:22PM (#20794932)
Very short term interest rates in the US are set by the Fed, pretty much at will.

Under normal conditions, they have an extremely strong influence on medium term interest rates as well by convincing the market that they will keep short rates high(low) in the future, while will then raise(lower) medium terms rates.

If that proves inadequate, like it did after the crisis, the Fed can buy and sell bonds directly to move medium to long-term interest rates.

The Fed may have a historical preference for relying on the first mechanism alone, but through some combination of these techniques, they can set any interest rate to any reasonable value almost at will.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mruts on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:55PM (#20796177)
Sure all of that’s true, but I think there’s a big philosophical and moral difference between changing the incentives of bankers vs forcing them to lend and borrow at a set rate. One relies on an efficient market and incentives while the other relies on coercion and force. It’s possible that the result of both of these systems are equivalent in many situations, but one is much more robust than the other because it still allows for price competition.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by big_chungus on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:23PM (#20794939)
> How else would interest rates be set?

By a free market, the same way it was set for a very long time. It gets decided by how many people borrow at a given rate, which will typically raise or lower the rate. Some one will make small adjustments around the broader market rate; if enough people make those small adjustments in one direction, the range moves.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:11PM (#20811222)
I'm not quite sure what you have in mind, but in a free market, interest rates in Germany would now be negative. People are demanding government action to prevent it.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by maxerickson on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:52PM (#20794379)
Do they mean public official?

Lots of interest rates are influenced by markets, where lenders and borrowers base their activity on available rates (if no one borrows at a given rate, a lender may seek business by reducing the rate...).