The Euro isn't sensible from an optimal currency perspective. In a good currency union, labour will be extremely mobile. But though labour can move freely in Europe, people tend to prefer their home country. Contrast to the US where people move much more readily and follow jobs.
So monetary policy has been too tight in areas like Greece that would have simply devalued their currencies in the past. Meanwhile policy seems to be too loose for Germany.
If you want to keep the monetary union, you can't crush Greece and other southern countries. So the Euro must devalue a bit to help them. But this cuts interest rates in Germany, discouraging spending.
Hence "Germany must spend more". It's more of a mechanical statement than a moral one.
Also spending could be using capital to buy a business abroad or infrastructure or somesuch, I think. Needn't necessarily be consumer goods.
In america, when a state has low revenue or high cost, it is subsidized by federal taxes. I.e., people from richer parts of the country "pays" for the poorer parts (e.g., infrastructure, or education etc).
In eurozone, this is rarely the case. I think a person in the US won't bat an eye if taxes are redistributed to a different state, but the amount of backlash that eurozone sees from this sort of redistribution (see brexit - they even believe in lies because it conforms to their worldview!).
Until the eurozone culturally and societally accepts itself as a single country with a single identity, there cannot be financial unity. Euro is a failure because of this imho.
Btw I think you've got a typo:
> for the euro to work, Germany must save more
You're framing this in moral terms whereas it should be viewed as more in economic terms. Spending by Germans creates more demand for Goods and Services, encouraging economic booms in the rest of Eurozone. These developed countries would then develop the skills and accumulate capital to compete with their peers in Asia. That would be a huge win-win from a European perspective.
Honestly, this shouldn't be viewed as encouraging the average German to spend more of their savings, rather, the German Federal Government borrowing more + spending heavily on infrastructure building in Germany + the rest of Europe.
In theory. In practice however, all that negative rate money that people will borrow will all go to real estate causing the already high prices to skyrocket overnight while wages stagnate.
Goods and Services are already cheap enough that we don't need loans for.
When rates were high, property prices in Germany were cheap or at least reasonable as they were pegged to the income levels. When rates went down property prices went to have no correlation to salaries anymore as now every average Joe and his mom could go to the bank and max out a 30 year loan on as big of a house his bank could afford to give him.
That's how Germany went from being one of the cheapest housing markets in Europe to one of the most expensive in the last 10 years.
Sure the € would depreciate a bit but there have already been currency fluctuations that did not show a big positive effect on the malingering economies.
Yep, at least in tech, German salaries are stupidly close to Eastern Europe now. All this because in EE the free market kicked in and did it's thing, forcing employers to compete for talent while German companies artificially cap salaries to fixed grids while complaining there's a talent shortage and pushing for immigration instead of wage increases.
What really happens is that 'savings' have two sides to them, and the other side is debt. So when people's savings go up by 10B, 10B of debt is created somewhere else (bank loans, government borrowing, etc) that enables that.
Having things work this way makes some intuitive sense. Savings are really a promise for goods & services in the future, so it makes sense that you have a matching promise to (forgo) goods & services in the future to counterbalance that.
In Germany's case, it's possible for the public and government to both save in aggregate only as long as trading partners go into debt (in euros). But if the debt becomes unsustainable, you will lose your savings that are the other side of that debt.
Now, everyone can try to save at the same time, but because it's impossible it doesn't work and you just go into a recession. That is, everyone stops spending, people lose their job, and even though they want to save they can't, so the impossibility is avoided.
Even though the basics aren't extremely complicated, it doesn't work like a household, and in many countries the average level of economics education seems to be about zero. There's a lot of public sentiment that everyone should should just save up and pay down debt, even though it doesn't make much mathematical sense how that could happen. I think there's a good chance people are elected at some point that handle things very badly.
On an single individual level there's no reason to avoid saving, it's a good idea. But someone has to take on the debt on the other side of that saving. If no one wants to (including the government), it seems reasonable for interest rates to trend negative.
More generally speaking, Germany has excess saving and insufficient spending which creates problems for the other members of the Eurozone. Excess deficits are bad, but excess surpluses are also not good.
Why spend, when you save for "bad times" or your kids' future?
By spending you keep companies in business where your kids will be able to work in the future. We often see a moral version of this argument framed as "buy local" or "buy American|German|Whatever"
Why spend, when you want to reduce your footprint on this planet?
Often lower impact choices cost more. By deliberately spending more money on lower footprint choices you are helping the planet. Good examples of this include high-efficiency appliances, extra house insulation, sustainable food sources etc etc.
A moral arguement towards spending is looked at like you are trying to sell them sonething and/or fleece them. And they are technically right about that - accumulating wealth is what makes an individual rich.
Investment in the actual sense would be a win-win. Not speculation or buying goods for the sake of getting cash flowing but things which provide a return. It is similiar to why lending out money/buying stocks is infinitely better as an investment than just holding gold - they provide utility. Gold just sits there.
Of course investing reliably and safely is hard, especially when the behavior of others impact it and nobody has perfect information.
Negative interest rates pulls that out under the rug, and forces people to take on extra risk than they currently do.
This doesn't seem like a reasonable assumption to me.
If you spend $ to reduce your carbon output for example, the money circulates among other people, who average about the same usage of fossil fuels as the general population because after a few exchanges they are the general population. So if you are increasing your spending in the long run, you are increasing resource usage by that amount, no matter how virtuous the things you are spending it on.
That doesn't mean it's wrong to invest in something that saves you money in the long run, but if there isn't a payoff, then by default you shouldn't think you're helping the environment.
This is a second order result, and doesn't necessarily follow. For example, higher quality goods generally last longer, which reduces waste. Higher profit margins also lead to more room for sustainability in supply chains. Apple is a good example of this.
Richer people also generally have less children, which reduces the environmental impact further.
All in all I'd say that second-level effects are guessing at this point.
Sure, but I think it's ok to think about ways in which spending more can help. The OP did ask that question after all..
b) insufficient aggregate demand can be a huge problem leading to recessions. What is sensible for the individual might not be sensible for the economy as a while.
c) Germany's infrastructure is decaying, and rates are as low as never before, even negative, ie the market is willing to pay Germany to borrow. Yet Germany refuses to borrow. It's perverse. Of course, unemployment in Germany is relatively low, but in Europe it's high. Some big construction projects in Germany would be a win-win.
Especially on the individual - many will ask: Why spend, when you save for "bad times" or your kids' future? And more recently: Why spend, when you want to reduce your footprint on this planet?