The lever that policy has is interest rates, and by lowering it even more, it forces savers to adjust their view on risk - if they can handle the lowered interest because their risk tolerance is so low that they cant buy bonds or anything, then they will need to suffer the low rates.
It's just that a lot of people are in the situation where they cannot take on any risk with their savings. Historiaclly, banks being risk free is just a gimmick (even if the gov't is insuring the deposit). Banks's risks are diversified, and minimized. But if the economy is doing poorly, they cannot magically produce the low risk returns.
I think the only way forward is actually gov't spending sprees - invest in long term projects, like 100 year long projects, and make these projects the backbone of fiscal policy (print money, if needed). Long term projects that can derive value for all of society, such as establishing bases on moon/mars, mining asteroids, etc.
At this point, even high-quality corporate bonds are going negative in Europe, so people who want to save have to take a big risk.
In my opinion that is unnatural; it's a creation of central planners who forced everyone away from gold and into fiat currencies.
Gold is pretty risky now because it's not actually used as a currency and thus has low liquidity. If we all used gold as a currency, it would have high liquidity and it would be very stable. (I don't want to go back to gold because digital currency is far more practical, but I'm just making a historical point.)
> I think the only way forward is actually gov't spending sprees
That is going further in the direction of central planning and also further inhibits regular people from saving and investing safely and wisely. How is the middle class going to save and invest under this paradigm? I think the most likely answer is that they won't/can't, and the middle class disappears (like what happens with hyperinflation, e.g. Weimar Germany).
A recurring theme: I am really against central planning. The planners do not always get it right, and when they screw up big time, it makes the system collapse. When people are free to make their own choices the economy adjusts dynamically.
However, there is no sound money right now. Bitcoin was designed to be sound money in theory, but it has to get a lot more liquidity first. Gold once was sound money, but also would need a lot more liquidity to be sound money once again. So we just have to wait. I'm not suggesting that we force it.
Fiat money seems destined to eventually collapse. There is a long road, but every time fiat money stumbles, it will be a little victory for alternatives. Investors have been fleeing into gold lately. Wealthy Chinese people have been fleeing into bitcoin to at least some small extent.
The middle class didn't disappear because of Weimar. (It was a mixed bag, because the hyperinflation wiped out a lot of debts.) They disappeared because of the Great Depression. Sound money caused that.
I don't agree at all. But let's wait and see. That is a risk I'm happy to take. Sound money is honest money. A system that can't survive sound money is an unsound system.
Anyway, we probably disagree on the definition of 'capitalism.' We don't have capitalism now, we have a mixed economy with partial capitalism.
> the Great Depression. Sound money caused that.
I completely disagree. This is but one theory, and I don't think it's a good one.
> It was a mixed bag, because the hyperinflation wiped out a lot of debts.
Hyperinflation = no debts, but also no savings. So only the very wealthy with large portfolios in real estate or industry could survive financially. Everyone else reduced to poverty. (Granted, I'm no expert on Weimar history, so if that's not exactly accurate, I welcome corrections.)
The German economy recovered from hyperinflation, and was booming by the end of the twenties, only to be taken down by the Great Depression. Under Hitler, they abandoned the gold standard, and their economy recovered.
People should not be forced to go further out on the risk spectrum than they want to by government policy (which is what you are suggesting by saying that we shouldn't have what economists call sound money). Forcing them to do that distorts the economy. People should buy bonds because they think the extra risk is justified, not because there is no alternative.