News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Roritharr on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @08:47PM (#20228796)
Well deserved.

Their product-vision was clear, their execution focused on what mattered... and they didn't need to bend or break laws to succeed.

It's easily my favorite unicorn of the past decade.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by baby on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:35AM (#20230193)
Agree. About the breaking the law thing though: it's a B2B. Most "breaking the law" companies seem to be B2C.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by RodgerTheGreat on Thursday June 20, 2019 @09:38AM (#20232774)
Advertising companies like Facebook make their revenue by selling to advertisers, not individuals- they are emphatically a B2B company.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Quinner on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:46AM (#20234060)
They're both. They're selling a service to consumers, which they buy with their personal data. They then use that data to sell to advertisers in the form of better targeted ads.

They didn't even run ads for the first three years of their existence.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by naveen99 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:59PM (#20236100)
Are you saying they are bartering and not paying sales tax for their services and their customers personal data ?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by baby on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:38AM (#20233992)
I would argue that this is not totaly true. Everyone can advertise on Facebook (I did it myself without a company).
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by robohoe on Thursday June 20, 2019 @09:43AM (#20232830)
Probably because there is money to be made from advertising/sharing user data and human customers don't have the money to see you like businesses.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by geodel on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:02PM (#20228879)
> and they didn't need to bend or break laws to succeed.

I agree. There is no law against half-assed, bloated Electron based desktop software that can bring even recent hardware to its knees.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by rayiner on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:05PM (#20228894)
A chat client that takes multiple hundreds of MBs of RAM and sucks battery life prodigiously should be, if not illegal, at the very least a violation of unwritten international norms.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by astrange on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @11:40PM (#20229651)
It's actually not the first to do this. Adium (AIM) and Colloquy (IRC) switched to WebKit theming in the 2000s, when computers were /really/ too slow to run it.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by pferde on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:56AM (#20230532)
Oh wow. Now that should be illegal.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by pgm8705 on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:15PM (#20228936)
I've never experienced this very common criticism of slack on here. When I occasionally check, Slack is using around 500mb or RAM. A lot for a chat app? Sure. But it has little to no affect on either my 16gb or 8gb machines.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by ElFitz on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @10:42PM (#20229356)
I'm usually at 500mb... per workspace. And the loading times when switching workspaces / channels are just stupid.

Ended deleting the desktop client.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by kortilla on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:22PM (#20228970)
RAM alone isn’t the problem. The issue is that is so laggy and slow. Poor algorithms on 500mb of bad data structures can bring any modern machine to its knees.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by trymas on Thursday June 20, 2019 @03:37AM (#20230745)
It's 500MB RAM per tab/login/workspace (whatever it's called).

Office/company slack, project A slack, project B slack, ... and in no time slack starts to use more RAM than docker/VMs I am developing on.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by jodrellblank on Friday June 21, 2019 @03:36PM (#20245676)
Just reloaded the Slack tab in Firefox to clear down 1GB of RAM use.

As I do every day.

Every single day.

For the one single channel I join. with no PMs and no threads, no file transfers, no voice or video anything.

Maybe I wouldn't mind so much if it was astonishingly good. But it isn't. It isn't even basically competent, it's terrible. Terrible at scrolling back, terrible at editing previous lines, appalling at completing names properly, bad at search, and completely lacking at customizing when it displays 2MB animated gifs inline.

I would expect a 4Gb machine would mean I never have to check on a text chat client. Apparently not.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by welly on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:09AM (#20231118)
Slack is using 89mb here. I never notice it running, personally.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by shereadsthenews on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:04PM (#20228884)
Why does anyone use the app instead of the site?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by orhmeh09 on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:39PM (#20229065)
For me it’s a usability thing—I tend to lose track of SPA tabs, often by closing the window or not being able to differentiate them from content tabs. I do use web apps but I vastly prefer using my machine’s window manager and window buttons/lists.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by chii on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @11:35PM (#20229631)
I use a tool like applicationize (https://applicationize.me/) to make a chrome app for a site. It mimicks an app, but is running as a tab in chrome. Saves memory but gives the benefit of separate window and workspace management (I can tab to it, it can have icon etc).
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by rymate1234 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:12AM (#20230090)
I personally use a 3rd party client which uses actually native code rather than electron https://cancel.fm/ripcord/
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Spivak on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:21PM (#20228963)
The site also is a heavy resource hog but you're right that it's overall less.

There are plenty of lightweight clients that use the Slack API. I don't see why people complain so hard that the official client is heavy.

Weechat with Slack is a dream feels like the good-ole IRC days.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by shereadsthenews on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:38PM (#20229062)
The site doesn’t use any resources when I close its tab.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by sciurus on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:59AM (#20230304)
The desktop app doesn't use any resources when you close it either. What's your point?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by shereadsthenews on Thursday June 20, 2019 @10:39AM (#20233338)
That’s only true if you configure it in a particular way. By default it stays running when closed so it can notify you and update its badge.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by randomsearch on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:59AM (#20230550)
Using lots of browser tabs instead of applications appears to me to be a step backward in usability. Instead of relying on the window manager to organise your work, you add cognitive load instead.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by beatgammit on Thursday June 20, 2019 @03:30AM (#20230704)
Eh, you can just put Slack into it's own window if you're going to use multiple tabs for it. Personally, I just pin it next to my email and it works fine.

I'm not a fan of how much RAM or CPU it uses. I tried the desktop app hoping it would be better, but it seems like it's perhaps worse (I use Firefox, so

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by quickthrower2 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:23AM (#20231174)
Not great for web developers. We have enough tabs open and if every window is a chrome icon it’s a pain to find stuff. I’ve got karma tests running, selenium tests, incognito windows testing security etc etc.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by shereadsthenews on Thursday June 20, 2019 @10:41AM (#20233361)
If the other poster has the tan pinned then it is probably very easy to find. Perhaps even command-2 if it’s pinned in the second tab from the left.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mgalgs on Saturday June 22, 2019 @03:09PM (#20251163)
Not a great solution if your window manager groups application windows together (e.g. gnome shell and osx).
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by dingaling on Thursday June 20, 2019 @03:56AM (#20230818)
> Why does anyone use the app instead of the site?

Because on Android at least the website detects that you're on a mobile device and switches to read-only mode. Correct, you can't even post a reply without fudging user-agent or installing the app.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by saagarjha on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:02AM (#20231093)
Isn't the Slack app on Android native?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by estomagordo on Thursday June 20, 2019 @04:49AM (#20231042)
Why would I hide my chatrooms in several browser tabs? Sounds maddening.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by quickthrower2 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:21AM (#20231167)
As a web developer I’m often using my browser as a guinea pig. Hell a selenium test shut the whole shit down and hijacked it today. I’m not going to run slack in the browser.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by saagarjha on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:02AM (#20231091)
Slack is the only reason I used pinned tabs, FWIW.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by nunez on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:06AM (#20230059)
Can't make calls through the site with Firefox
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bborud on Thursday June 20, 2019 @03:18AM (#20230634)
You are not wrong :-). In fact, your second line is completely correct. However, Slack has lowered the standards for desktop software by being a really terrible piece of software. Which means that the professional in me wants to see a decent client before I'm happy.

What's more worrying is that we are rapidly moving away from an Internet based on open standards and into walled gardens.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by hellofunk on Thursday June 20, 2019 @04:59AM (#20231076)
My personal take is that, as long as profit remains a guiding priority for a society, there will always be much greater incentive to create a new and successful walled garden than to share and contribute to open standards.

This is made evident by countless technology firms and other industries.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by rubyfan on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:32AM (#20231750)
The internet’s previous models were doomed to fail. Service providers did not have a reliable monetization scheme. Client apps for open protocols have rarely had wide adoption and longevity, especially anything you had to pay for. I can think of plenty of examples of paid client apps from the late 90s/early 2000s... email clients, web, irc, etc. that just aren’t around because not enough people would pay for the client to sustain their development.

Slack and other tools are solving a problem customers have and they should be compensated for it, especially given much of their users are profit oriented enterprises.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bborud on Friday June 21, 2019 @10:04AM (#20242570)
And yet, the Internet exists because short sighted profit requirements were kept at bay, and eventually the Internet managed to create more value for society than any online service ever by a margin so large that logarithm of the difference is amazingly large.

I work for a telco. My assumption is that the profit margin for connectivity will first converge on zero and then it will drop below zero. There's so much value in the services above connectivity that connectivity won't need to be profitable.

Of course, nobody in my industry will want to talk about that, or even admit this is a real possibility, because it implies that connectivity will most likely be owned by those who make money on services on top.

If we think net neutrality is important today, we ain't seen nothing yet. And given how hard we have had to fight in the past to just about maintain some form of parity, I'm not extremely optimistic about the future.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by eeZah7Ux on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:46AM (#20231860)
> Slack and other tools are solving a problem customers have

...while creating others: fragmentation and lock-in

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by eeZah7Ux on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:19PM (#20234364)
> as long as profit remains a guiding priority for a society

Found the bug.

> there will always be much greater incentive to create a new and successful walled garden than to share and contribute to open standards

It's really a shame that most customers never learn and they keep accepting closed source/protocols.

While the world economy is quickly moving into endless vertical monopolies, history has shown that governments can sometimes wake up and restore competition.

Perhaps in 50 years using open standards will be encouraged e.g. by providing a tax discount

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by briandear on Thursday June 20, 2019 @04:03PM (#20236768)
> It's really a shame that most customers never learn and they keep accepting closed source/protocols.

I don’t care. I just want my tool to solve my problem so I can focus on creating business value at my job. I am sure we could all make our own hammers, but time spent making hammers is time lost from using them.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bborud on Friday June 21, 2019 @10:09AM (#20242620)
This isn't really what we're talking about. A better analogy are laptops, phones and tractors - which you are not allowed to repair and only work within a closed ecosystem that you either have to opt into our out of, and where opting out has an extraordinary cost.

I use a Mac. I'm part of the problem for having handed my money to an abusive, fraudulent company that is now squeezing all its users for more money for increasingly lower quality products. It used to be easy to buy into Apple's walled garden. But now choice of convenience over freedom is starting to cost me real money and that money buys less each year.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by codyb on Saturday June 22, 2019 @12:08AM (#20247968)
I’m interested in the lower quality part.

My Dad _just_ upgraded from an iPhone 5. Do you think his Xs won’t last as long?

I agree the laptop situation is a bit shitty. I hate the USB-C everything on my work laptop. Everything works fine on my personal computer but as soon as I plug my usb hub into a usb c adaptor everything stutters.

Love their privacy stance though. Best in the business for sure.

Also, what’s abusive? And what’s fraudulent?

Apparently their new monitors are very well priced. And building the same machine you’d get in a MacBookPro or different model ends up being more expensive or similarly priced.

I could be wrong, and I am, certainly, an Apple fan, but I will criticize when I think it’s appropriate and don’t hold views concretely.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bborud on Saturday June 22, 2019 @08:08AM (#20249158)
I don't know much about the X since I stopped at the iPhone 7 and I am probably not going to buy any of their exorbitantly priced phones. That being said, in their pursuit of thin phones they ran into design issues with boards flexing so that BGA components will eventually fail. They became aware of the problem and then proceeded to make the same mistake again in later models rarther than fixing the problem. (The flexing problem isn't that they will break after one "bending event", but rather than they fail over time as your phone is subject to mechanical stresses of what is within the range of normal use. Typically because the tiny balls under BGAs will let go)

I'm mostly talking about their laptops and their iMacs. The USB C connectors are of course inconvenient, but I actually like them. Again, the problem is that in their pursuit of thinness they ended up designing keys that are very sensitive to dust (and not very nice to use). In subsequent models they kept at it, so the quality of keyboards doesn't seem to be a priority. Some laptops have a tendency to develop display problems due to bad design. For instance blowing hot air on parts that can't take hot air or laying out connectors so that they will fail more easily.

Now these are design flaws, which brings us to the "abusive and fraudulent" part. If you want to get these things fixed under warranty you _may_ be okay. Except the process appears to be entirely decided by chance. For instance they have put moisture indicators inside the macbooks that not only react to liquid damage, but which turn from white to red (indicating moisture) over time depending on the humidity in the air where you use it. (Most people don't know how these things work, so they'll accept it). So they'll accuse you of having spilled liquid in your laptop and refuse to fix it even when this is not the case. Accusing their customers of lying isn't a very good way to behave.

In many cases they will also claim that your laptop is in need to expensive component replacements. Either because they claim that the component cannot be repaired or when their service technicians fail to correctly diagnose the equipment. The repair costs quoted are supposed to make you buy a new computer rather than fix the one you have.

On top of that they have the gall to claim that independent repair shops are somehow less qualified than Apple. Which naturally rings true in the ears of most people; they designed it so they should be the best to fix it, right? However, this doesn't seem to be generally true. Especially since Apple and their authorized resellers appear to have very limited diagnostic and repair capability and the qualifications vary.

When you do send in an Apple device, you have to be aware of the fact that it isn't Apple that repairs your equipment - it is a subcontractor. And they are not always the best.

Wich brings us to the bullying. Apple do their best to kill the independent repair market any way they can. Often by filing lawsuits against repair shops and then putting them out of business. When confronted with this they us their go-to excuses. Like protecting the consumer from unqualified repair shops.

They do this by denying independent repair shops access to the supply line - meaning they work hard to make it difficult to obtain spare parts and components. Compare this to, for instance, Samsung, which sell parts online to make it easy for repair shops to get the needed parts. In order to get parts for Apple products there is an entire market for broken laptops that are bought and sold to repair shops in order to provide donor boards for components.

Of course, then there is the fact that they seem to deliberately make things harder to repair or upgrade. For instance batteries that are glued in unnecessarily, increasing the chance of destruction if you try to replace them. Or soldering in components that the user may want to upgrade later (like RAM and SSDs). For instance on my mac mini the SSD is soldered in, but fortunately the RAM is socketed.

I became aware of the systematic nature of this about a year ago when starting to watch videos to learn how to solder surface mount components (I do a bit of electronics). I stumbled over people who repaired Macs for a living. I didn't come there for the rants, but when starting to research the issue a bit and speaking to a couple of people who also do this for a living, it became obvious to me how terribly Apple are behaving.

Two things struck me 1) diagnosing and fixing macs isn't rocket science. People are able to even as Apple tries to starve them for information. 2) most people don't know how electronics are fixed so of course Apple will get away with claiming they are protecting their users by not allowing independent repair shops to repair their stuff. Diagnosing and replacing broken components and cleaning up fouled circuit boards is not all that hard. Sure, you need the equipment, ability to read schematics and some ability to diagnose electronics, but there are people who do that for a living.

And you really do want to be able to pick your computer repair people just like you pick repair shops for your car. I use a mechanic I know and trust for my car - a guy who walks me through everything he does with my car and even shows me what he has done, and what he thinks should be done. I never use the brand workshop simply because those guys only follow procedures (which aren't always correct), I have no idea who works on my car and I have no insight into what is actually done or if the car is actually fixed or serviced correctly. If anything, my computer is even more important to me so of course I don't want some semi-qualified, random clown subcontractor of Apple, far away, to work on my computers.

The upshot of all this is that I feel very uncomfortable as a Mac user. Whenever I buy a Mac I am taking a huge risk. If something breaks I may not be able to fix it and the only option available to me might be to buy an entirely new machine. Even when the fault is due to a cheap component that takes 10-15 minutes to replace. Simply because Apple actively work to withhold spare parts from the market.

This is even more true if you buy one of their expensive models. The new Mac Pro may look nice, both in terms of specs, price and looks, but if it breaks, you have no way of knowing if you are going to lose your investment. Your machine may become completely worthless as a result of a trivial, cheap component breaking.

If I trusted Apple as a hardware vendor I would probably have upgraded my laptop to a newer model and I would probably have bought an iMac Pro rather than a Mac mini. But since I can't trust them I'm looking at starting to move away from Apple. My next laptop probably isn't going to be an Apple and my next desktop computer is probably not going to be an Apple since I need more power with less risk.

I'm really not fond of the idea of running Linux and having to depend on vmware to run Windows for a lot of the desktop stuff, but this may be the only viable route if Apple doesn't get their act together.

Enough text. Here are some videos.

Some reporting on Apple's fraudulent practices: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o2_SZ4tfLns

Example of repair: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDjwYf_GzK0

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Myrmornis on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:34AM (#20231764)
> However, Slack has lowered the standards for desktop software by being a really terrible piece of software.

You need to explain a claim like that.

On the face of it, the Slack UI works beautifully in Browser, Desktop and iOS clients. I'd quite like it to have code syntax highlighting. But really, what are you talking about?

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bonaldi on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:52AM (#20232353)
>On the face of it, the Slack UI works beautifully in Browser, Desktop and iOS clients.

It's not accessible. This alone destroys "beautifully".

But even beyond that, it's just not a good citizen or experience wherever it is. It's deeply single-paned and hence single-tasked: you can't open a conversation in a tab or separate window. And switching between conversations/threads/groups on any platform is much harder than it needs to be. Their quick-switcher is a quasi CLI bandage over this that increases cognitive load on the user.

The enterprise multi-slack experience is even more horrible as it expands that problem across multiple quasi-discrete instances.

On iOS it does unnatural things with text so you can't select portions to copy and paste.

On desktop it is so much of a resource hog it's our generation's version of Eight Megabytes And Constantly Swapping.

And this isn't intrinsic: none of this stuff was an issue when you could use IRC clients to access it. But they turned those off.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Myrmornis on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:40PM (#20234612)
I use Slack every day in the Desktop Electron app and the iOS app.

Firstly, lack of accessibility is lack of accessibility. Beauty is a distinct concept. Your comment reminds me of the sign on the Berkeley/Oakland border that reads "Animal rights are human rights". Both are highly desirable, but that does not make them synonymous or coextensive.

OK, It's never occurred to me that I wanted a conversation in a different window.

You use ⌘-k to switch channels. Partially drafted messages are retained. I think I prefer that to a mess of windows that I'd have to manage though of course I don't mean to impose my preference on you.

I have the desktop client open and it's using about 800MB memory between the main process and 3 helper processes. I agree it's a lot, but it seems 100% standard for modern applications. Everything seems to be built around the assumption that people have a $2000 laptop like rich westerners might. So I don't agree with it but I wouldn't single out Slack for criticism beyond any other modern consumer tech company.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by jdm2212 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:52PM (#20234753)
Just my two cents, but I have to kill and restart the Slack app every morning because if left alone too long it starts eating 100+% of CPU and then becomes unresponsive (while still pegging the CPU). No other vanilla Electron app I've used does that.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by wbl on Friday June 21, 2019 @01:12AM (#20240033)
And people still mock my editor choice for being eight megabytes and constantly swapping.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bonaldi on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:28PM (#20238485)
It wasn't claimed to be "beautiful", it was that it "works beautifully". And if it's not accessible, for a serious amount of people, it doesn't work. At all.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by staybythebay on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:57AM (#20232396)
Maybe people are generally jaded to to the slowness of cross-platform Javascript apps, but if you take a step back you can really see how bad it is.

I had people at my last job who had to quit Slack because of how hot it was making their laptops, and how much memory it was using.

At my current job, Slack is definitely one of my most rate limiting applications for how quickly I can get things done. Scrolling in chat, searching, switching channels- these are all actions that are extremely slow, and sometimes seem like they don’t work at all.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by rightbyte on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:04PM (#20234227)
Ye. It's silly how single page text search is now a hard problem to get done right with JS text edit fields.

It's the same thing with the Swarm review CI tool. If you diff a big enought file, but still quite small for a conputer, it get slow or crashes.

Also the same thing with MS Teams. The prior conversion are not loaded at startup and if you scroll it shows place holders instead of the text for some seconds.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by jumbopapa on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:52AM (#20231889)
The fact that the performance of the application is awful. You would think that a $16B company could move away from Electron and make native applications for their platforms.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by dthedev on Thursday June 20, 2019 @09:42AM (#20232817)
It's never been awful for me. Even when running it on an iPhone 6S, it has always been nice and responsive.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by danny_taco on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:31AM (#20233909)
It is native on iOS but not for desktop.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bborud on Friday June 21, 2019 @10:25AM (#20242740)
If you think Slack works beautifully you probably do not care about the things I find offensive about it. Like the slowness of switching contexts or the fact that it can only have one conversation on screen at any given time (which in turn makes the slow switching painful).

And this is before we get into the fact that it devours RAM and uses more CPU than is reasonable, making it somewhat pathetic if you think of programming as a craft.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by systemBuilder on Friday June 21, 2019 @12:32AM (#20239896)
Search doesn't work in slack! Have to use chrome incremental search!

Price/sales = 42, bubble stock ...

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by hiccuphippo on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:56PM (#20236054)
Check volt if you want a slack client: https://volt-app.com/

Other electron based apps like Discord perform better so I'm not sure why Slack is so crappy.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by skinnymuch on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:39PM (#20237660)
Have there been lots of updates? A few months ago it felt very alpha.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by raverbashing on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:10AM (#20231121)
Whenever I read those "slack sucks", "jira sucks" rants I can't help but think "kids these days" are spoiled

Hate slack? Try mIRC. Oh wait what's a "netsplit"? What do you mean I can't paste pictures or code snippets without going to a 3rd party service?

Hate Jira? Try Bugzilla/Trac or a multitude of other bug trackers.

"Oh the design sucks" really? Have you tried writing a Win32 app and make it look nice? Ok, try it with Qt (old Qt). Cool huh?

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by blub on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:21AM (#20231168)
IRC is better than you're suggesting:

* Netsplits would not be an issue, since most small to medium companies would use only one server. Even when they did happen to me in the past, the servers reconnected quite fast. I imagine a big corporation would be able to handle this rare failure case properly.

* DCC allows one to send files and since it's a direct connection, there is no 3rd party company in the US that's inserting itself in the conversation.

Jira is actually quite ok, I don't know why you're besmirching its name by comparing it to a bloated chat client.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by gutnor on Thursday June 20, 2019 @06:38AM (#20231492)
> Jira is actually quite ok, I don't know why you're besmirching its name by comparing it to a bloated chat client.

It takes a lot of heat because it is very customisable and get locked down in large corporation.

I worked in company that ran an old shitty very version on underpowered server and disabled feature like rich text editing but force you through a 5 page wizard with in total tens of mandatory field to fill for any jira ticket. People at that company used an excel file on a shared drive to escape the jira hell.

Also there is the crowd of Agile purist that complain that Jira is too bloated for agile and ignoring the extra feature is not good enough because mostly "trust issues".

More recently there are stuff like plandek that create metric on your jira usage. In the wrong hands, this is modern day LOC metric.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by trizzak on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:13AM (#20231641)
Agree 100%. Almost every Jira complaint I see is a byproduct of the way our company centrally manages and locks it down. Things like custom fields and workflows require submitting a ticket and waiting a few weeks. That said, it can still be customized and made to work well for most internal teams.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by raverbashing on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:32AM (#20231222)
> DCC allows one to send files and since it's a direct connection

since it's a direct connection it will never work in our modern nat'd/firewalled world, even between company branches (unless you have the whole company in the same VPN - but yeah don't do that)

Yes Jira is ok, it's just the target of (some) unfair hate like slack

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by roel_v on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:11AM (#20231627)
I'll admit I haven't been on IRC in 20 years, but while I remember fiddling with active/passive FTP settings and port forwarding every week at the very least, I do not remember any times where I had similar issues on IRC (using mIRC and later various Linux IRC clients, mostly Xchat and BitchX) in the 1890's. I don't know how it would have worked though, thinking about it.

(and I think from the above description of my typical computer use at the time, it's quite obvious what I was doing, and how that would have given me plenty of opportunities to run into all sorts of (compatibility) issues)

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by pteraspidomorph on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:41AM (#20231811)
When using DCC send in passive mode the sender listens on a local port (59 by default) and sends the receiver a CTCP message (an IRC protocol PRIVMSG message wrapped in \x01) containing their IP address in integer format and the port number. If the receiver accepts their client connects to the sender's open socket and the file is immediately dumped through the connection.

In theory there must be some scheme for forwarding the port through a firewall on the sender side, which might be setting the sending device as "DMZ". Or you can put the burden on the receiver by using active mode.

mIRC should really support UPnP by now but I don't think it does?

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by nailer on Thursday June 20, 2019 @06:18AM (#20231404)
Are you sure? Wouldn't it be a direct connection, just between two NAT gateways? With each using the ports to track which connection belonged to the host behind the NAT?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by zwily on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:16PM (#20234991)
If the connection is already established, sure. How did you establish it though? There are ways to hook clients up that are both NAT’d, (STUN, etc) but DCC doesn’t use any of them.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by nailer on Friday June 21, 2019 @07:46AM (#20241608)
You did a handshake to the NAT server, which passed it on to the destination behind the firewall?

I'm more a Unix person that a network person so it's possible I'm missing something, but I'm not sure what it is. Thanks for replying.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by wbl on Friday June 21, 2019 @01:13AM (#20240038)
Jira is too flexible so the right way to do things is never apparent.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by sagichmal on Thursday June 20, 2019 @06:10AM (#20231366)
I would literally and unironically prefer to run a company on mIRC/corporate IRC servers and Bugzilla than Slack and Jira.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by phtrivier on Thursday June 20, 2019 @06:55AM (#20231550)
Does anyone actually have data on which company is run with what.

Herding exists, but at some point I suspect the fact that more working business use the one rather than the other would have some meaning.

That being said, the good thing about mIRC / Bugzilla is that no-one prevents you from using them for your business, so go for it !

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by saltminer on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:54AM (#20232368)
>no-one prevents you from using them for your business

People who complain about these products probably aren't in the position to use something else, or they probably would have switched already.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by LyndsySimon on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:57PM (#20236077)
I agree.

I use IRC all the time, and IRCCloud makes it comparable to Slack.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by eeZah7Ux on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:47AM (#20231865)
+1
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by pmontra on Thursday June 20, 2019 @06:28AM (#20231449)
You could have a point with Slack but Jira is really terrible. I used it for a customer years ago and I'm so happy any other customer is using something simpler. Jira could be OK if operated by a specialized team paid to do project management and to shield developers from the complications of the tool. It's not only the design, it's the sheer amount of functionality. We don't need all of that.

I'd go with Github simplistic issues all the time instead of wresting with Jira. YouTrack from JetBrains is a reasonable compromise. Redmine is also ok.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mcv on Thursday June 20, 2019 @06:47AM (#20231516)
Every single one of my clients uses Jira, and nobody I've ever met had a problem with it. It works, it's flexible, it's pretty easy to use. It's the industry standard, and for good reason, as far as I can tell.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Myrmornis on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:30AM (#20231734)
Meet me.

I'm not sure what you're talking about. Confluence is OKish. But Jira is absurdly bad. I'm talking about the UI for creating Issues and Epics etc. The front-end devs that wrote it simply didn't have the ability. The parser for entering markup such as preformatted code blocks just doesn't work a lot of the time. The newer "Visual mode" just doesn't work a lot of the time. It simply needs to switch over to markdown and use a 3rd-party parser and renderer. The Visual Mode preview doesn't render using a fixed-width font. have you ever clicked on the little "Link" symbol in the top right of the text entry box? Obviously that should copy the current URL to the system clipboard. But they didn't know how to look that up on StackOverflow and instead made it a normal link to the current page (so you reload the page accidentally), with the link title saying

> title="Right click and copy link for a permanent link to this comment."

! You enter `bq.` to quote a line of text. This is all just some crap that someone with no design sense or standards came up with after 10 seconds thought.

I'm talking specifically about the quality of the UI. It is far, far, below the quality of UIs put out by respected modern products.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by nirvdrum on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:35AM (#20233956)
Not that it really matters much, but a lot of the design issues you're highlighting are due to the age of the software and Atlassian's seeming commitment to not breaking backward compatibility. In particular, Jira predates Markdown, so the software adopted the text formatter of the day, which was textile[0]. This is where the `bq.` syntax comes from. Jira didn't invent it from whole cloth -- it was adopted because that was the standard of the day. Likewise, it predates StackOverflow by a good 7 years. Some of the JavaScript used is old enough to be a college freshman.

As and end user, you may not (and probably should not) care about the historical context of its design decisions. But it's hardly the case that they hired a bunch of inept engineers. They've simply placed a large premium on backward compatibility and are still around today in large part because of that. Having said that, they really should find a way to support both Textile and Markdown if for no other reason than Bitbucket uses Markdown and it's confusing as hell having to switch between the two syntaxes if your company uses both products.

[0] -- https://textile-lang.com/

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Myrmornis on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:48PM (#20234707)
That's a helpful comment. Nevertheless

bq. commitment to not breaking backward compatibility

Backward compatibility with what? People's brains? We're talking about markup language and rendering right, which is not an API consumed by machines.

bq. it's hardly the case that they hired a bunch of inept engineers.

So why is the new "Visual Mode" WYSIWYG text entry mode so terrible? And why that absurd "link" icon in the top right of the text entry widget?

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by nirvdrum on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:24PM (#20235068)
Backwards-compatible with people's brains is one aspect of it, sure. No one likes a constantly evolving UI that shuffles things around. But, also backwards-compatible with already entered issues. I wholeheartedly agree they should support Markdown, but I don't think they can just dump Textile in the process either, since it'd affect a load of already entered issues.

As for the link issue, I'm not entirely sure what you're referring to. I have an icon that looks like the Android "share" icon and that drops down a dialog with a link to the current page and a target user field. The link icon in the text entry field just adds a textile formatted link. I'm probably just overlooking something, but I'm not seeing what you described. And I never use the visual editor, so I can't speak to its quality.

I should note that I don't work for Atlassian and never have, so I don't have a horse in this race. But I have been using Jira since maybe 2004 due to its early adoption by the Apache Software Foundation. Jira is hardly perfect, but it's the least bad issue tracker I've used. At some level, I'm sure it's just a matter of preference. E.g., I know plenty of people that laud the GitHub issue tracker and I don't get it. It works well enough for small projects, but is too limiting for any project of non-trivial size, IMHO. I also find more than 2 or 3 labels in the issue list to just be a distracting sea of colors.

I hope you're able to find something that works well for you. I'll add that if you're using an on-premise version of Jira in your company, there's a high likelihood that you're running a dated release. I've found that some of the more aggravating issues people run into have actually been fixed, but not deployed in their environment. If you can find access to a running instance of the latest version, you might find it to be a more less frustrating experience.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by tallanvor on Thursday June 20, 2019 @09:02AM (#20232432)
I've never heard anyone call Jira the industry standard. There's way too much fragmentation in that market for anyone to be able to make that claim.

Jira can work well or it can work very poorly. It really depends on what you're trying to do with it and what resources you're willing to pour into it. That's why some people love it while others hate it.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mcv on Thursday June 20, 2019 @10:32AM (#20233275)
It looks like the industry standard from where I'm sitting. Of all the companies I've worked for in the past 15 years, both as employee and as freelancer, I think only 2 didn't use Jira. 3 if I count my private projects (I used Pivotal).

In all that time, the only thing I've really heard people complain about, was when it was slow or down.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by wuliwong on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:28AM (#20233871)
I'll see your anecdotal experience and raise you mine: in 9 years I've only worked with one company that did use Jira.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bwat49 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:27AM (#20231717)
as a user (I do QA testing) I use JIRA every day and I really like it compared to other bug trackers I've used
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by quickthrower2 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:18AM (#20231154)
Slack has resources!
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:00PM (#20228863)
I don't know about "well deserved". They did it by holding people's data hostage. It's one thing to make your messages unsearchable or otherwise available in the UI until your pay, but holding your data completely hostage until you pay up isn't exactly a noble way to go about things. Even Facebook isn't this obnoxious about getting you a copy of your message history.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by colechristensen on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:27PM (#20228996)
Free is there to be a sales demo without deadlines with a casual shrug for people who aren't going to pay, I wouldn't ever use slack if it wasn't my intention to play and slack wouldn't miss me.

Choose your customers.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:28PM (#20229001)
I never used Slack out of choice either. I've used it because I was forced to due to others' decisions. So now I've lost a bunch of my communications due to others' choices that I had little control over.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by zbentley on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:47AM (#20231870)
...OK, so you chose to communicate on it in order to communicate with "others", presumably due to an employer wanting you all to use Slack. In that situation, your communications are often legally not your own property (though it is arguable, at least in the US).

If you're using it personally, the limits on message counts are made quite clear. Exceeding them makes export difficult or impossible without paying. So don't exceed them.

A huge chunk of Slack's value prop (after decent UX) is exactly the fact that they have all of your communications. No chat admins, servers to manage and back up, or networking hell to orchestrate non-text content sharing in a multiparty way. Also makes corporate folks who pay for it happy as they have pretty good auditability/retention controls--not perfect, of course, but better than a truly p2p/federated solution, and again: no infrastructure management needed.

You don't have to be happy with it, but those are features, not bugs, and are valuable to many.

You also just, y'know, don't have to use Slack. Nobody is putting a gun to your head. If the hill you want to die on is "I won't work for any company/team that uses this chat platform", well, that's your choice (hell, there's not even an argument to be made about ubiquity making it a false choice; Slack has plenty of competitors, both paid/hosted and FOSS/federated, in active use by big companies). But don't pretend that a lack of local history or easy export is some sort of highway robbery or hostage situation.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:04AM (#20231988)
No, I'm not referring to employment communications or personal communications. There are other categories where I've had no choice but to use the same communication channels others were using despite the content of my communications being emphatically mine.

Are you just trying to be infuriating?

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by 0xffff2 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @10:53AM (#20233491)
> I'm not referring to employment communications or personal communications.

What are you talking about then? All of my communications are either personal or employment related, almost by definition.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by wuliwong on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:38AM (#20233991)
I actually had the same question. Maybe community or neighborhood groups or volunteer activities? I'd probably just call all that personal but I could see a distinction.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by skinnymuch on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:46PM (#20237713)
Everything is personal or employer/business. Why are you assuming such malice from the person you responded to?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by igbrdjk on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:31AM (#20231735)
> So now I've lost a bunch of my communications due to others' choices that I had little control over.

I wrote a simple exporter using Slack api. It archives Slack from position of user, almost everything (like attachments).

But I'm not publishing it on GitHub because I don't want more people to use it, and don't want Slack to block mass api calls, and don't want slacks admins to know I written it and use it.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:35AM (#20231780)
Your exporter goes beyond the 10k limit for DMs on a free plan?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by igbrdjk on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:43AM (#20231828)
I didn't try on free plan. But maybe just run it incrementally, at least once every 10k messages.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:46AM (#20231857)
Well then you missed the entire point of my comment, which was specifically about the free plan, and specifically about when you haven't had a chance to run such a script incrementally.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by zwily on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:18PM (#20235005)
The exporter doesn’t export DMs at all, does it? (On any plan).
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by vehementi on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:06PM (#20239543)
Nah, this is a super slanted view of things. Their business succeeds because they've made a best in class amazing thing, not because everyone begrudgingly wants to see their history, lol
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:16PM (#20239596)
I'm not claiming they haven't made an otherwise great product, but if their business doesn't rely on this then why are they doing it?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by einpoklum on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:30PM (#20259107)
Slack is still inferior to IRC overall. Don't know what you're talking about.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by vehementi on Friday June 28, 2019 @12:40PM (#20306177)
What? Slack is objectively better in every way except the open source part
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by jazzyjackson on Thursday June 20, 2019 @10:55AM (#20233519)
Just double checked this and exported the history from my free plan -- in Slack I can only see messages back to November 2018, but the export includes all messages back to our beginning in 2016.

As others have said, this 'Standard Export' doesn't include direct messages and private channels, so there's still some amount of 'hostage taking'

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:36PM (#20235210)
And you're probably the workspace admin. I shouldn't need someone else's permission to export my own data either.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by jhallenworld on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:01AM (#20233577)
I miss this from Lotus Sametime: all of your conversations were stored in local XML files. It was very useful to "grep" through these to find some piece of information that someone told you years ago.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by danielscrubs on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:33AM (#20230183)
Huh. Wasn’t Facebook forced to add a export data button because of a law?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:42AM (#20230224)
I don't know exactly what made them add that feature or when that happened (it was before 2011, I think), but AFAIK they never outright blocked you from even viewing older messages. And even then it was possible to scrape it I think, if my Googling right now is any indication.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by pietroglyph on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:29PM (#20229005)
This is not entirely true. You can export all data from Slack, including data that’s normally hidden because you’re on the free plan.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:29PM (#20229010)
Really? How do I export the DMs I have beyond the 10k limit?
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by fpvracing on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:29PM (#20229007)
Is that still the case? That there is no way to export message history? I'm trying to find a way to publish messages from my Slack channel to my website in real-time so that I can give visitors a look at what they are signing up for. Similar to how Pieter Levels has nomadlist.com/chat/ set up (if anyone knows how he does that, please let me know).
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by johnmaguire2013 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:38AM (#20229924)
You could probably write an integration to do this using the real-time messaging API.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:33PM (#20229031)
It was as far as I was able to tell when I checked many months ago. I've seen no indications that anything has changed, but would love to hear otherwise...
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bjoernw on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @10:48PM (#20229389)
"Corporate Export On the Plus plan, Workspace Owners can apply to access a self-service tool called Corporate Export. This type of export includes content from public and private channels and direct messages. If Corporate Export is enabled for your workspace, Standard Export will not be available." https://get.slack.help/hc/en-us/articles/201658943-Export-yo...
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @10:51PM (#20229402)
Yes, which means they hold your data hostage until you pay, exactly like I said.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by blinzy on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:37AM (#20232216)
I don't use or even like Slack, but what is the problem with that?

I mean they are already giving you the oppportunity to use a limited version for free, you can't expect them to give you one of the most useful features imho when you are just using their resources and infrastructure in exchange for nothing; it doesn't make any business sense.

If I'm a non-paying user of Slack (or whatever other SaaS with a free tier) I am not entitled to anything whatsoever, I'd be grateful for the fact that they allow me partial functionality at all.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by skinnymuch on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:48PM (#20237731)
How is it hostage if you voluntarily used the software for free? They’re spending money accommodating your free usage.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by wuliwong on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:33AM (#20233925)
Slack has a completely different business model than Facebook. Facebook has no paid tier for its users, all the money comes from advertisers.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by senorjazz on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:13AM (#20232047)
What does "well deserved" even mean? Does it just mean not evading your privacy to generate income via ads? Does it mean not being too aggressive / abusive of customers?

Personally, I would just call that normal / decent behaviour. Alone, it doesn't mean you deserve a ridiculous billion dollar evaluation

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by mehrdadn on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:21AM (#20232117)
"Decent behavior" describes the process.

"Well deserved" describes the outcome.

So you might say the outcome is well deserved only if decent behavior comprised the process.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by einpoklum on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:26PM (#20259085)
It's IRC with auto-linkification. Well deserved? Pro-capitalists are crazy.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by archiepeach on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:21PM (#20234390)
I think the whole argument of "unicorns exploiting legal grey areas" falls victim to Hanlon's razor. I don't really believe these companies set out to bend or break any laws, it was more a case of the legal system not catching up fast enough. Uber started as a service to hire limousines, not a platform company.

If governments weren't so concerned with party politics, infighting and staving off populist surges, we'd probably have a proper definition for a "gig economy" worker by now. A definition that would allow them to keep the flexibility that they appreciate so much, whilst still having proper worker protections for sick pay, holidays and all the rest.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by i_love_limes on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:11PM (#20234949)
It's strange that you explicitly brought up Uber and still hold this opinion. Out of all the companies, they have most aggressively skirted labour laws in every country they are in, and have been selectively banned from some countries and cities due to their continual breaking of the law. Not to mention lobbying efforts to minimise the effects of labour laws.

They didn't start as a company for the sole purpose of exploiting legal grey areas, but they certainly have consistently done so since their inception.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by asdffdsa on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:08PM (#20234919)
Consumer ride-sharing (uber/lyft) is obviously exploiting "grey areas"