News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bonaldi on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:52AM (#20232353)
>On the face of it, the Slack UI works beautifully in Browser, Desktop and iOS clients.

It's not accessible. This alone destroys "beautifully".

But even beyond that, it's just not a good citizen or experience wherever it is. It's deeply single-paned and hence single-tasked: you can't open a conversation in a tab or separate window. And switching between conversations/threads/groups on any platform is much harder than it needs to be. Their quick-switcher is a quasi CLI bandage over this that increases cognitive load on the user.

The enterprise multi-slack experience is even more horrible as it expands that problem across multiple quasi-discrete instances.

On iOS it does unnatural things with text so you can't select portions to copy and paste.

On desktop it is so much of a resource hog it's our generation's version of Eight Megabytes And Constantly Swapping.

And this isn't intrinsic: none of this stuff was an issue when you could use IRC clients to access it. But they turned those off.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by Myrmornis on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:40PM (#20234612)
I use Slack every day in the Desktop Electron app and the iOS app.

Firstly, lack of accessibility is lack of accessibility. Beauty is a distinct concept. Your comment reminds me of the sign on the Berkeley/Oakland border that reads "Animal rights are human rights". Both are highly desirable, but that does not make them synonymous or coextensive.

OK, It's never occurred to me that I wanted a conversation in a different window.

You use ⌘-k to switch channels. Partially drafted messages are retained. I think I prefer that to a mess of windows that I'd have to manage though of course I don't mean to impose my preference on you.

I have the desktop client open and it's using about 800MB memory between the main process and 3 helper processes. I agree it's a lot, but it seems 100% standard for modern applications. Everything seems to be built around the assumption that people have a $2000 laptop like rich westerners might. So I don't agree with it but I wouldn't single out Slack for criticism beyond any other modern consumer tech company.

Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by jdm2212 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:52PM (#20234753)
Just my two cents, but I have to kill and restart the Slack app every morning because if left alone too long it starts eating 100+% of CPU and then becomes unresponsive (while still pegging the CPU). No other vanilla Electron app I've used does that.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by wbl on Friday June 21, 2019 @01:12AM (#20240033)
And people still mock my editor choice for being eight megabytes and constantly swapping.
Re:Slack Is Going Public at a $16B Valuation by bonaldi on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:28PM (#20238485)
It wasn't claimed to be "beautiful", it was that it "works beautifully". And if it's not accessible, for a serious amount of people, it doesn't work. At all.