News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by devchix on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:42PM (#19923570)
A recent episode of 99% Invisible: Play Mountain looked at how the playground got to be safe and boring.

"A two-year-old boy named Frank Nelson was climbing a 12-foot-tall slide in a Chicago park when he slipped through a railing and hit his head so hard that it caused permanent brain damage. The park system of Chicago was sued and had to pay out millions of dollars to Nelson’s family.

At that time, in the late 70s, there were no laws, or real industry standards when it came to the safety of playground equipment. Frank Nelson’s fall was one of a number of lawsuits that led the Consumer Product Safety Commission to publish the Handbook for Public Playground Safety in 1981. Then another standards organization, the ASTM, published its own guidelines. Pretty soon these rulebooks were in the hands of insurance companies and parks departments and school boards across the United States. To this day, almost all playgrounds have to be approved by a certified playground safety inspector.

And safety inspectors look for places where kids could fall, or get pinched, poked, or trapped. As you might imagine, all of these rules and regulations make the job of playground designers a lot harder. This is the reason why the playgrounds that you see everywhere all look more or less the same. A majority of playgrounds are “post and deck” systems with standard swings, slides, and monkey bars in one piece of equipment."

https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/play-mountain/

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by magicalhippo on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:42PM (#19924858)
A friend of mine designs playgrounds for kids, and is very good at it (his designs win 90+% of the competitive bids he enters).

He's also worked hard to put in place a playground safety inspector certification system over here.

One of his core ideas is that there are two types of safety: subjective safety and objective safety.

For example, kids quickly learn that falling from a height is painful, and experiences such as that teaches them how to evaluate their own safety when say climbing. This is the subjective safety.

However they're usually not going to be able to correctly evaluate the safety of climbing a playhouse where they might get their head stuck between two planks because the opening between the planks were just right for their heads to fit, but not their bodies. Or that the hood drawstring in their jacket can get stuck in small wedges and openings, especially dangerous near slides. Such issues go under the objective safety.

Now, his point is that you can make playgrounds which are objectively very safe, without making them any less exciting. Part of the excitement comes from allowing the kids to explore their subjective safety boundaries, but a lot comes from the design itself.

He often works with one of the major suppliers of playground equipment on their new designs, but a large part of his secret sauce is how he places that equipment on the playground. Many playground designers (which at least here are mostly landscape architects) seem to just put one piece there and another over there, without giving much thought to facilitating the flow of spontaneous play from one piece of equipment to the next.

Anyway, he could explain this a lot better than me. I just help him out with some presentations and such every now and then.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by hexane360 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:35PM (#19925398)
This seems really similar to techniques I've heard about in road design. A lot of safety improvements are pretty well compensated by changes in people's behavior. For example, if you make shoulders and lanes wider, people will feel like they're going slower and speed up to compensate. Even with things you wouldn't expect, like the dedicated/third brake light made mandatory for cars in 1986, there were significant changes in behavior (decreased following time) to compensate. However, there are many safety improvements that are more or less invisible to the end user. The best example is rumble strips -- they're never noticed until they do their job.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by geggam on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:56AM (#19927576)
Your idea works until you look at something like the autobahn. Having driven on it I can say what I feel the main factor to safety is driver behavior. I see more turn signals used and when someone is going faster the other folks tend to move out of their way.

Its more of a social mindset that creates safe roads than anything IMO.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by wongarsu on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:38AM (#19927732)
Driver behaviour on the Autobahn is not some accident. Germany has the most expensive drivers licence in the world due to the number of lessions you have to take to even be allowed to take the exams, with most people opting in to even more lessons to pass the exams. To pass the practical exam you have to drive pretty much perfectly (a small number of people never pass). So everybody knows how to drive correctly and has it drilled into them at least once in their life how important that is. Obviously with routine some things slip, but nobody wants to get rear-ended by a car going 120 mph on the Autobahn either.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by geggam on Thursday May 16, 2019 @09:12AM (#19928666)
So you are saying people are trained to be personally responsible?

I agree with that. The US has been training people to blame others for several decades now. The difference is obvious

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Haga on Thursday May 16, 2019 @12:37PM (#19930504)
It also empowered generations of risk averse people into positions of veto power. Removing them is surely not safe.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by hexane360 on Friday May 17, 2019 @02:35PM (#19942283)
>Your idea works until you look at something like the autobahn

Just because there are other methods to achieve safety doesn't mean the ones I mentioned don't work.

The Autobahn still has rumble strips and German cars still have airbags.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by natdempk on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:01PM (#19924975)
This is a really good take on safety and tooling that can be applied to a lot of things. Thanks for explaining this!

Do you have an example of a playground that he’s designed that highlights these principles?

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by solipsism on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:16PM (#19925036)
I like the dichotomy, but for me the names "subjective safety" and "objective safety" make no sense.

"Obvious dangers" vs "non-obvious dangers" seems like much clearer language, even if it's the case that there's a way to squint to make the terminology you used make sense. Kids will naturally explore the boundaries around obvious dangers.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Swizec on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:39AM (#19926431)
I think subjective/objective makes more sense than obvious and not. Subjective danger is things that feel dangerous but aren’t. Objective danger is things that don’t feel dangerous but are.

For example: a rollercoaster is subjectively dangerous but objectively safe. That’s its whole design objective, feeling dangerous while being totally safe.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by solipsism on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:43AM (#19926453)
Subjective danger is things that feel dangerous but aren’t.

That's not what the word "subjective" means. Language is malleable and all that, but "subjective" doesn't mean "feels like but isn't". Not even close.

Objective danger is things that don’t feel dangerous but are.

And wow, that's really not what "objective" means.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by luhn on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:32AM (#19926684)
Subjective (adj)

1) Dependent on or taking place in a person's mind rather than the external world.

2) Based on a given person's experience, understanding, and feelings; personal or individual.

#1 is exactly “feels dangerous but isn’t”. #2 also works because it fits into magicalhippo’s narrative about kids falling and adjusting their safety boundaries.

I won’t bother about “objective danger” because you didn’t either.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by iovrthoughtthis on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:19AM (#19926856)
Surely your qualm is with the “but isn’t” right? “It feels dangerous” is certainly subjective.

I think you’re not breaking things down sufficiently.

Subjective is how things feel, regardless of how they are.

Objective is how things are, regardless of how they feel.

Should probably replace feel with “are perceived” but feel is more contextual here.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by okusername on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:38AM (#19926701)
I think it's literally about dangers coming from the objects vs the dangers that are coming from the subjects behaviours.

You want to to eliminate unnecessary dangers introduced by the objects, and those are fully under the designers control. It's not reasonable or possible to try fully control the subjects to eliminate all risk.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by headcanon on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:05PM (#19925261)
+1 on seeing examples of this. I'd love to see what a "good" design looks like so I know what to look for should I become a parent.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by amluto on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:54PM (#19925493)
Here are some I like in SV:

Magical Bridge in Palo Alto. Caters to kids with developmental disabilities and kids who like to scramble over fun obstacles.

Magic Mountain in Coyote Point.

San Mateo Central Park. I think this one might be older than a lot of current standards.

For a playground that gets it all wrong, there’s a pirate ship structure in Vail, CO near the main base. It claims 5-12, but it ends up being very dangerous, even for adults, for all the wrong reasons. Hint to playground designers: make your slides as adventurous as you want, but give a good run-out before the slide dumps you on your arse two feet above the ground. That hurts without adding any sense of adventure.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by drewda on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:14AM (#19926329)
Magic Mountain in Coyote Point used to be so different. A giant mound of concrete that we'd ride down on cardboard sheets. This century's version with its metal slides is fine, but not the same.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ezconnect on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:59AM (#19926776)
In South Korea, playgrounds are everywhere. They look very very dangerous on my point of view because I've never seen those kind of design and activity when I was a kid. I've been here 4 years and I have never seen one get injured on them.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by lemming on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:10PM (#19925007)
That sounds really interesting. Does he have a website or something we could look at?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ethagknight on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:03PM (#19925797)
Does your friend have a website? If not, can you see me contact info? Email in bio.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by AriaMinaei on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:02AM (#19926788)
Yes it would be helpful if you could point us to some resources about playground design.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by maxxxxx on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:53PM (#19923668)
It’s a little like terrorism. You can have tens of thousands of people die from cars, smoking and obesity. But if a fraction of that dies from terrorists the whole country changes.

If one child gets hurt from a slide or abducted by a stranger the whole country changes to avoid this risk but all the other risks are silently accepted.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by MereInterest on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:56PM (#19925763)
Absolutely. I did the math recently to come up with a comparison for how many people heart disease kills. Suppose the Columbine massacre had never stopped. Rather, all day, every day, the same rate of death kept happening as during the 49 minutes of the attack. You would need 5 of those continuous attacks ongoing at all times in order to be equivalent to heart disease in the US.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by sopooneo on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:35PM (#19925942)
Does that account for likely years of life lost? If you die of heart disease at 65, that's many fewer years lost than someone getting killed at 15.

As gruesome/horrifying as these sorts of calculations are, I do take your point. We often get overly worried about unlikely dangers when obvious ones are staring us in the face.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by raverbashing on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:53PM (#19925999)
To be very honest heart disease is also overreacted against. Especially when people read things like "food x causes % increase in heart disease"

But in the end it is a "natural" cause of death., It's not like people wouldn't be dying of something else

20yrs extra? Sure. 0.5% increase in heart disease for people over 60? Don't waste my time

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by BurningFrog on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:52PM (#19925198)
I have to think a lot of kids died on playgrounds before the late 70s without that happening.

I'd guess that something changed at that time so the country was finally rich enough that this became a problem that got attention from The Powers That Be.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by daenz on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:51PM (#19923646)
You hit the nail on the head. From the article:

>“Many agencies fear being sued if a child gets hurt,” said Teri Hendy, the president of an Ohio-based playground consultancy, Site Masters. Ms. Hendy blamed outdated federal rules on playground design developed decades ago by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. She favors more flexible guidelines, arguing that playgrounds don’t have to be boring to be safe.

We got to this point because of lawsuits and regulation. Unless we make parents sign waivers for their kids to use the playground, we can expect more of the same. It just takes one lawsuit to ruin it for everyone else, so that's what organizations like these really need to protect themselves from.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ChuckMcM on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:41PM (#19924067)
The reality is different though.

There is nothing in this world quite so soul crushingly painful as having your child die while doing something that the parent and perhaps people in general, consider to be 'safe.'

For me, it took some time to fall madly and deeply in love with my spouse, and to my surprise I developed that attachment instantly to my children. That same sort of passion that you would do anything to keep them safe, to help them grow up to be the people you want them to be.

When a child dies doing something that "should" have been ok, it creates a searing, wrenching, soul destroying since of loss and guilt and anger and pain. No waiver, no explanation of statistics, no explanation of preventative measures, nothing can salve that wound. And so parents, even ones of limited means, have been known to invest everything they have, time, money, energy, into making someone pay in the hopes it will make the grieving parent feel slightly less pain.

It doesn't make for less pain of course, only time and distance can mute the pain, but that can't be explained either because the desire to do something is irrationally over powering.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by redff0000 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:48PM (#19924116)
Your child could have slipped when getting off a train and permanently injured themselves, or in any other number of ways.

Low probability high severity events trigger a cognitive bias that makes people attempt to make things '100% safe'. There are two problems with that.

1: nothing can ever be made 100% safe so those low probability high impact events still happen from time to time.

2: making things safe hits a steep diminishing returns curve after some point, and the opportunity cost of creating said safety level starts to outweigh the benefits of not creating it.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by loup-vaillant on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:30PM (#19924414)
To put it bluntly, the increased happiness of millions of children is worth a couple children's health, or even lives.

That's a tough sell, but that sounds reasonable (well, I can talk, I don't have children). This is basically the same reasoning Yudkowsky presented with his dust speck vs torture argument argument: a sufficiently widespread benefit, however small, will outweigh a sufficiently improbable horrible event.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by souprock on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:46PM (#19924539)
Well, I have a dozen kids, and I agree.

Of course, part of the reason for so many kids is to minimize the percentage of my family that would be lost if one did die. My wife's uncle had the postcard family, one boy and one girl in a cute little city house with a picket fence. The daughter died, and the father completely fell apart. He lost 100% of his daughters. It is too late for him to create a replacement.

Most families today are tiny. I think this has affected our perception of loss. The risk of 100% loss has become so great that people can't allow the risk of traditional play.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by justinator on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:37AM (#19926421)
Of course, part of the reason for so many kids is to minimize the percentage of my family that would be lost if one did die.

I think I just read the most insane sentence I'll read all year.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by bad_good_guy on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:40AM (#19926945)
How is it insane when this is the historic reason behind large families?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by justinator on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:44PM (#19931102)
I'm not touching, "but it's historical!", because that's a problematic idea in of itself. Lots of things are, "historical", but don't make sense in the modern world.

Say you had two kids, and you lost both. One way to think of it is your lost all the children you ever had. Fine.

Say you had a DOZEN kids, and you lost six of them. Same thinking as above, you've lost half the children you ever had. Ok, but you still lost six kids!. Six kids have to go through life knowing they have lost six siblings. Having that somehow be better is pure insanity. Or at the very least the utmost self-centered thing I've ever heard of - you're hoping that the loss off 6 out of 12 kids is somewhat less of an impact on yourself when compared to losing two kids?

These are human beings, not cupcakes you're bringing to a picnic. If you brought two cupcakes, and hoping to have one yourself, but both were eaten before you could have your own cupcake, that stinks - but you're just out of a cupcake. Then yeah: bring a dozen cupcakes to share, and have yourself your own cupcake.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by baud147258 on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:33AM (#19927463)
If I remember right, reducing child mortality actually decrease the number of children per family, so it's not that strange. Of course it's bluntly said and reductionist, but I think it has a basis in fact.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by stevesimmons on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:52AM (#19926751)
You've increased your likelihood of experiencing tragic loss 12-fold!
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ctack on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:29AM (#19926669)
Does your stance on redundancy of loved ones also extend to the number of spouses you have?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ctack on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:40AM (#19926714)
You might still want to learn how to deal with grief and loss though. If you had 12 kids to avoid the possibility of losing all of your kids or all of one gender of your kids, it might still happen anyway. What if you lose your favorite one? What if you still lose all of them? I don’t wish any of that on you or anyone, but I just have to say that breeding for redundancy to avoid the pain of loss strikes me as being, and this is putting it mildly, a tad immature.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by zbentley on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:52PM (#19924576)
I think that's kind of missing GP's point that, while

> the increased happiness of millions of children is worth a couple children's health, or even lives.

might be totally true, it's borderline-impossible to convince concerned (or worse, bereaved) parents of this in many cases, for human, not utilitarian, reasons.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by wallace_f on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:10PM (#19924677)
But is this really caused by grieving parents and not blood-sucking lawyers and idiotic bureaucrats?

I'm in Japan and there's a lot of dangerous playground equipment, hikes, stairwells, rooftop decks, onsens, alcohol that can be bought from vending machines, etc... And yet without all those 'experts'and authorities protecting society from these dangers, here it feels safety is many, many tiers better what we have in America.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Mirioron on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:53PM (#19924923)
But bereaved parents are only a small portion of the people at the time. They alone can't make changes. The rest of society has to agree to them.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Firadeoclus on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:28AM (#19927439)
> To put it bluntly, the increased happiness of millions of children is worth a couple children's health, or even lives.

I don't think that's an accurate reframing. The opportunity cost isn't just happiness (by making playgrounds boring, presumably) but also safety, and therefore lives, in other areas. When you hit diminishing returns trying to make playgrounds 100% safe, spending the same resources on e.g. road design will save more lives.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Noos on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:38PM (#19925683)
No, it isn't.

We can all survive with a little less happiness. If our playgrounds are a little more boring, we can all deal. (though if anything they are a lot nicer than the ones I grew up with) Happiness is a good that can come from many sources, and while it's nice to have, if it is reduced, we can usually adapt to it by finding a new source.

Happiness shouldn't be a reason to trade lives.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by joesb on Thursday May 16, 2019 @12:00AM (#19926025)
That reminds me of the villian robot in I, Robot movie. They don't want to harm human, they just want to keep them in the house, so that there is less crime, and less people die.

It may take away freedom. But freedom should not be a reason to trade lives.

Some may say the playground is about happiness, some may say it's about the freedom to experience.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by craftinator on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:40PM (#19924839)
Another thought that adds to this viewpoint: slightly more dangerous playgrounds teach kids how to play more safely, and they grow into adults who also know how to play responsibly. Kids who never get a chance to develop good balance (with the immediate feedback of bruises and scrapes) will not be as good at avoiding falls and other physical dangers as those who have good balance. They also won't know their own physical limits, and won't know which activities are too dangerous.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by lutorm on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:25PM (#19925079)
That's exactly the point. It's not that playgrounds should be more dangerous for the heck of it, or just because kids think it's more fun that way. It's because learning to deal with danger is an essential life skill and we are now depriving our kids of it.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by fjsolwmv on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:28PM (#19925096)
The discussion is about quadriplegia, not scrapes and bruises.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by craftinator on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:37PM (#19925134)
The discussion began on the topic of playgrounds and safety. All people have the risk of injury and death at all times. Some types of injury are not severe and have few lasting consequences, others are of the converse type. Paralysis is incredibly uncommon when compared to scrapes and bruises, which is why I brought up that subtopic.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by dragontamer on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:11PM (#19924283)
> Your child could have slipped when getting off a train and permanently injured themselves, or in any other number of ways.

But thanks to our laws, we don't have to worry about playground sets.

Low probability / high impact events are a fact of life and are a valid cause for regulations. Worker safety laws in the early 1900s were such that people more regularly lost fingers or even limbs in heavy machinery. It still happens today, but safety programs and safety regulations have made such events far less likely.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by loup-vaillant on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:38PM (#19924480)
There's a difference between playgrounds and work environments: as far as I am aware, workers aren't any more miserable in safer work environment. Children in "safer" playgrounds, are.

The value of life is not infinite. It is perfectly reasonable to sacrifice a few to improve the conditions of the many. Funnier, riskier playgrounds do exactly that.

That said, the article stated the "safer" playground engendered more injuries, mostly because bored kids were taking inconsiderate risks. The more dangerous playgrounds actually looked more dangerous, and the kids in them ended up taking less serious risks.

There's a good chance that more "dangerous" playgrounds are a one sided win. They could be better than the "safe" ones even if you disagree with my first two paragraphs.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Noos on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:42PM (#19925702)
...you are arguing we should sacrifice lives for fun. Not something particularly necessary, like how many here argue for self-driving cars in that way, but our kids are impoverished because gosh darn it, playgrounds aren't fun any more!

I find it a very poor argument.

The second part..eh, if true than there's merit to it, although I would wager dangerous ones would hurt far more. We did stupid stuff just as much as in the old days as in the new, but iron does hurt a lot more than plastic.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by a1369209993 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:24PM (#19925070)
> The value of life is not infinite.

Technically it is[0], but they're going to die in a century or so (if that) anyway, so anything that reduces quality of life enough is morally equivalent to killing them earlier.

0: at least to within measurement error

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by TomMarius on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:10PM (#19924684)
> The value of life is not infinite.

The whole western civilization is standing on the assumption that it is.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by maxerickson on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:10PM (#19925287)
This is observably not the case, in all sorts of situations.

Violence, vehicles, medicine, pollution, etc, etc, etc.

Of course we've gotten to a place where we spend lots of dollars preventing 1 statistical death, but not even tens of millions most of the time.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by TomMarius on Thursday May 16, 2019 @04:24AM (#19927137)
I don't see how it's observably not the case when my mother is working in a hospital where people are kept alive for decades just for the slight chance that medicine might evolve enough to cure them or they just wake up one day; when they are spending extraordinary amounts of money and time of dozens of researchers and doctors on experimental treatments, etc.

I don't understand how vehicles or pollution change anything. I never said there are no bad actors, there are in every civilization, and there are compromises you need to make but that doesn't mean you would not do anything to save someone. Awareness about pollution and its effects is just starting to exist. We didn't think it's bad a few decades ago.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by scarejunba on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:38PM (#19925949)
Assume this is true. The NHS is in the UK and run by the government. The NHS has a maximum spend on a single person.

The UK is part of Western Civilization. Therefore it rests on the assumption that life has infinite value. Therefore, the UK will spend infinite money to ensure a person lives.

A contradiction.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by TomMarius on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:40AM (#19926711)
OK, that's the UK, I'm not sure why it split off; thank you for pointing it out.

Any continental EU country will spend an unlimited amount of money to save someone. Even Ukraine will. Get your shit in the UK back together, I'd suggest.

Suggesting a maximal spend in my country would immediately lead to a revolt and change of government.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Firadeoclus on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:33AM (#19927465)
While there may be no explicit limit there are practical limits on what will be done to help a single person. Unlimited is not the same as infinite.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by TheDong on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:28PM (#19925360)
The concept of a micromort [0] argues that people often to put a value on their life, at least probabilisticly.

Valueing life is also not unique to western civilization. Yes, it values individualism highly, but confucian values are also highly concerned with humaneness and the value of life.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Joof on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:33PM (#19924447)
But it also means that we're neutering some really important mechanisms of human development. It seems very costly to squeeze out those teensy little bits of extra safety.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by InitialLastName on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:43PM (#19924516)
> Worker safety laws in the early 1900s were such that people more regularly lost fingers or even limbs in heavy machinery.

If it's regularly happening, it isn't a "low probability" event.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by wizardforhire on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:50PM (#19924559)
“The reality is different though. There is nothing in this world quite so soul crushingly painful as having your child die while doing something that the parent and perhaps people in general, consider to be 'safe.'”

Actually there is and by several orders of magnitude more painful, and it is this: Watching these same parents scream safety, proclaiming the presciouness of their children while simultaneously condemning entire populations to death by their implicit support of wars, racism, and the governments responsible. Granted it may not be as immediately appearant of a reaction than say watching your child suffer, but while experiencing the death or suffering of a child may heal with time, the systemic effects of these masses of “concerned parents” lingers on with us forever.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by dang on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:11PM (#19930813)
Please do not take HN threads into political or ideological flamewar. This is egregious, regardless of our opinions about the politics of war.

"Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by nemo1618 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:49PM (#19924902)
Ridiculous. The two are not even remotely comparable.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by dang on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:11PM (#19930807)
Please do not take HN threads further into flamewar, regardless of what another comment said.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by nemo1618 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:17PM (#19925600)
Your original comment claimed that merely watching the (alleged) hypocrisy of grieving parents was more painful than losing a child. That is very different from claiming that the collective suffering of millions outweighs the suffering of one parent. The latter is trivially true.

Anyway, do yourself a favor and send your comment five years into the future, to your 2024-self, via https://futureme.org. I guarantee you'll cringe, or your money back.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by gameswithgo on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:49PM (#19924555)
Playgrounds are still really fun for kids and they aren’t maimed as often. I think this is fine. Even with modern safe playgrounds it is stressful keeping young kids from hurting themselves.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Mirioron on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:56PM (#19924949)
But that's the point - you're not supposed to keep them from hurting themselves. You're supposed to keep them from hurting themselves too much.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ghaff on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:02PM (#19923734)
And IANAL but it's not clear that waivers would even help. Anyone can still file a suit and, presumably, a competent lawyer would argue that negligence on the part of the playground owner/operator contributed to whatever the accident was.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by maxxxxx on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:57PM (#19923696)
It’s a really tricky balance. On the one hand we should have rules that don’t allow building unnecessarily dangerous stuff (eg covering toys with lead coating) but on the other hand we shouldn’t expect 100% safety because the only really safe thing is something that doesn’t exist. It’s really difficult.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ken on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:06PM (#19924256)
I would say there's a significant difference between the chemical/biological danger from touching a material which appears basically identical to other safe materials and causes toxic exposure over time, and the physical danger from falling or being cut.

I want kids to learn that concrete is hard, and the harder you hit it, the more it will hurt. It's an easy lesson to learn, by trial-and-error, and transferable to many other situations. I don't want to make kids try to learn about lead poisoning by trial-and-error. They're not going to succeed at that. Even adults took 50 years of research to stop putting it in gasoline.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by fjsolwmv on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:31PM (#19925106)
I don't want my daughter to learn about diving into the concrete floor of a pool, or smashing her head into a concrete play structure, by trial and error.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by HankB99 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:34PM (#19925393)
Delicate balance is the word I would have used. As a scoutmaster (BSA in the US) It seemed to me that many of our youth have no comprehension of their own mortality. I used to try to impress upon them the necessity to stay more than one mistake away from disaster. I recall two incidents that demonstrated this.

At a winter camp out the scouts were explicitly warned not to sled on the side of the hill that had trees. One scout didn't heed and hit a tree. He left the campout in an ambulance.

Another scout - luckily at the bottom of sandstone bluffs - decided to see how close he could get to the pot formed by a waterfall. He lost his footing and went into the pot which still held water. He was not injured but had to walk the rest of the hike in wet clothes. It was about 45°F so he was pretty uncomfortable. (At this park several people die each year because they make the same mistake at the top of the bluffs.)

These are just the actions that resulted in a problem or serious injury. There were many times when the youth got too close to the edge - often literally - and were lucky enough to escape unscathed.

On a visceral level I agree with not being overprotective, but being underprotective may not always have the desired effect of instilling a desire to be aware of hazards. Moreover, are we willing to accept the occasional death or maiming of a young person so their cohorts can learn about danger?

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by JudgeWapner on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:49PM (#19924129)
why do people sue? Because of the ridiculous cost of healthcare. At any given public school, how many of those kids' parents have $15k - $50k to cover an orthopedic injury, ambulance/ER/surgery/overnight hospital bill ?

It's the same for the zero-tolerance fighting policies. Kids aren't allowed to fight back because the insurance company figured out that 4 hands throwing punches are worse than 2. The hospital bill is the same price whether the person with the broken nose is the bully or the victim.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by secabeen on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:26PM (#19924389)
>why do people sue? Because of the ridiculous cost of healthcare. At any given public school, how many of those kids' parents have $15k - $50k to cover an orthopedic injury, ambulance/ER/surgery/overnight hospital bill ?

It's not always the parents. Sometimes the insurance company will sue to recover costs.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by oska on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:47PM (#19925172)
> A majority of playgrounds are “post and deck” systems with standard swings, slides, and monkey bars in one piece of equipment."

This is not true where I currently live. It's a recently new suburban area (less than 15 years old) in an Australian city with a great number of parks scattered through it. Nearly every park has a playground and they are all different and all very high quality. Indeed, I'm quite amazed at how much money has been spent installing playgrounds. There is a great variety of what is on offer - some have latticed rope climbing nets, some have climbing walls, some have flying foxes, plus many other very imaginative features. They all have soft surfaces under them to cushion falls and most have a shade cloth over them. I am frankly envious of what is on offer to children these days - it is vastly superior and more exciting than what I had as a child.

Trees and other outdoor features still exist that are 'undesigned' and can provide significant risk and thrill to the more adventurous child who climbs up and on them. But I applaud the increased safety built into the modern playground. To me it appears to have spurred innovation and imaginative design, not hampered it.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by BurningFrog on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:49PM (#19925183)
Yeah, but you're not part of the US legal system, which OP was talking about.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Noumenon72 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:24PM (#19925634)
I am and noticed that almost every playground I take my nieces and nephews to has some unique feature that sets it apart. They're not nearly as standardized as McDonald's play places or adult fitness centers. Someone is either marketing variety or designing it.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by BurningFrog on Thursday May 16, 2019 @10:50AM (#19929538)
It would be interesting to compare it to playgrounds in other countries/jurisdictions.

There are probably already websites devoted to this...

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by phkahler on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:12PM (#19924691)
So the reason they look the same is because designs became standardized to make it easy to meet requirements AND cost. There are still some really great things at some playgrounds. A park near me built a new playground and it has a post and rope dodecahedron that must be 15 feet high. Kids climb and sit at the top. Falling could be pretty bad, but it looks cool af and kids like it.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by mc32 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:50PM (#19924567)
And yet, if you look, dangerous still lurks. Sharp metal, no failsafes if a critical part fails, “V-like structures which could snag an arm, etc. Now, to be fair, when a critical part fails, the systems are sturdy enough that the whole thing wouldn’t normally come crashing down.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by bobbyi_settv on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:54PM (#19925213)
Maybe it's okay though? Is there real evidence to back up the sentiment that kids have less fun (or get less exercise, develop less physical skills, etc.) in modern "safe" playgrounds?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by circlefavshape on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:22AM (#19927669)
THIS!

The playgrounds my kids played in when they were little were a thousand times cooler than the crappy playgrounds I had growing up