News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by magicalhippo on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:42PM (#19924858)
A friend of mine designs playgrounds for kids, and is very good at it (his designs win 90+% of the competitive bids he enters).

He's also worked hard to put in place a playground safety inspector certification system over here.

One of his core ideas is that there are two types of safety: subjective safety and objective safety.

For example, kids quickly learn that falling from a height is painful, and experiences such as that teaches them how to evaluate their own safety when say climbing. This is the subjective safety.

However they're usually not going to be able to correctly evaluate the safety of climbing a playhouse where they might get their head stuck between two planks because the opening between the planks were just right for their heads to fit, but not their bodies. Or that the hood drawstring in their jacket can get stuck in small wedges and openings, especially dangerous near slides. Such issues go under the objective safety.

Now, his point is that you can make playgrounds which are objectively very safe, without making them any less exciting. Part of the excitement comes from allowing the kids to explore their subjective safety boundaries, but a lot comes from the design itself.

He often works with one of the major suppliers of playground equipment on their new designs, but a large part of his secret sauce is how he places that equipment on the playground. Many playground designers (which at least here are mostly landscape architects) seem to just put one piece there and another over there, without giving much thought to facilitating the flow of spontaneous play from one piece of equipment to the next.

Anyway, he could explain this a lot better than me. I just help him out with some presentations and such every now and then.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by hexane360 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:35PM (#19925398)
This seems really similar to techniques I've heard about in road design. A lot of safety improvements are pretty well compensated by changes in people's behavior. For example, if you make shoulders and lanes wider, people will feel like they're going slower and speed up to compensate. Even with things you wouldn't expect, like the dedicated/third brake light made mandatory for cars in 1986, there were significant changes in behavior (decreased following time) to compensate. However, there are many safety improvements that are more or less invisible to the end user. The best example is rumble strips -- they're never noticed until they do their job.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by geggam on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:56AM (#19927576)
Your idea works until you look at something like the autobahn. Having driven on it I can say what I feel the main factor to safety is driver behavior. I see more turn signals used and when someone is going faster the other folks tend to move out of their way.

Its more of a social mindset that creates safe roads than anything IMO.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by wongarsu on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:38AM (#19927732)
Driver behaviour on the Autobahn is not some accident. Germany has the most expensive drivers licence in the world due to the number of lessions you have to take to even be allowed to take the exams, with most people opting in to even more lessons to pass the exams. To pass the practical exam you have to drive pretty much perfectly (a small number of people never pass). So everybody knows how to drive correctly and has it drilled into them at least once in their life how important that is. Obviously with routine some things slip, but nobody wants to get rear-ended by a car going 120 mph on the Autobahn either.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by geggam on Thursday May 16, 2019 @09:12AM (#19928666)
So you are saying people are trained to be personally responsible?

I agree with that. The US has been training people to blame others for several decades now. The difference is obvious

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Haga on Thursday May 16, 2019 @12:37PM (#19930504)
It also empowered generations of risk averse people into positions of veto power. Removing them is surely not safe.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by hexane360 on Friday May 17, 2019 @02:35PM (#19942283)
>Your idea works until you look at something like the autobahn

Just because there are other methods to achieve safety doesn't mean the ones I mentioned don't work.

The Autobahn still has rumble strips and German cars still have airbags.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by natdempk on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:01PM (#19924975)
This is a really good take on safety and tooling that can be applied to a lot of things. Thanks for explaining this!

Do you have an example of a playground that he’s designed that highlights these principles?

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by solipsism on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:16PM (#19925036)
I like the dichotomy, but for me the names "subjective safety" and "objective safety" make no sense.

"Obvious dangers" vs "non-obvious dangers" seems like much clearer language, even if it's the case that there's a way to squint to make the terminology you used make sense. Kids will naturally explore the boundaries around obvious dangers.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Swizec on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:39AM (#19926431)
I think subjective/objective makes more sense than obvious and not. Subjective danger is things that feel dangerous but aren’t. Objective danger is things that don’t feel dangerous but are.

For example: a rollercoaster is subjectively dangerous but objectively safe. That’s its whole design objective, feeling dangerous while being totally safe.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by solipsism on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:43AM (#19926453)
Subjective danger is things that feel dangerous but aren’t.

That's not what the word "subjective" means. Language is malleable and all that, but "subjective" doesn't mean "feels like but isn't". Not even close.

Objective danger is things that don’t feel dangerous but are.

And wow, that's really not what "objective" means.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by luhn on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:32AM (#19926684)
Subjective (adj)

1) Dependent on or taking place in a person's mind rather than the external world.

2) Based on a given person's experience, understanding, and feelings; personal or individual.

#1 is exactly “feels dangerous but isn’t”. #2 also works because it fits into magicalhippo’s narrative about kids falling and adjusting their safety boundaries.

I won’t bother about “objective danger” because you didn’t either.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by iovrthoughtthis on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:19AM (#19926856)
Surely your qualm is with the “but isn’t” right? “It feels dangerous” is certainly subjective.

I think you’re not breaking things down sufficiently.

Subjective is how things feel, regardless of how they are.

Objective is how things are, regardless of how they feel.

Should probably replace feel with “are perceived” but feel is more contextual here.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by okusername on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:38AM (#19926701)
I think it's literally about dangers coming from the objects vs the dangers that are coming from the subjects behaviours.

You want to to eliminate unnecessary dangers introduced by the objects, and those are fully under the designers control. It's not reasonable or possible to try fully control the subjects to eliminate all risk.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by headcanon on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:05PM (#19925261)
+1 on seeing examples of this. I'd love to see what a "good" design looks like so I know what to look for should I become a parent.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by amluto on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:54PM (#19925493)
Here are some I like in SV:

Magical Bridge in Palo Alto. Caters to kids with developmental disabilities and kids who like to scramble over fun obstacles.

Magic Mountain in Coyote Point.

San Mateo Central Park. I think this one might be older than a lot of current standards.

For a playground that gets it all wrong, there’s a pirate ship structure in Vail, CO near the main base. It claims 5-12, but it ends up being very dangerous, even for adults, for all the wrong reasons. Hint to playground designers: make your slides as adventurous as you want, but give a good run-out before the slide dumps you on your arse two feet above the ground. That hurts without adding any sense of adventure.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by drewda on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:14AM (#19926329)
Magic Mountain in Coyote Point used to be so different. A giant mound of concrete that we'd ride down on cardboard sheets. This century's version with its metal slides is fine, but not the same.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ezconnect on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:59AM (#19926776)
In South Korea, playgrounds are everywhere. They look very very dangerous on my point of view because I've never seen those kind of design and activity when I was a kid. I've been here 4 years and I have never seen one get injured on them.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by lemming on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:10PM (#19925007)
That sounds really interesting. Does he have a website or something we could look at?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ethagknight on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:03PM (#19925797)
Does your friend have a website? If not, can you see me contact info? Email in bio.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by AriaMinaei on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:02AM (#19926788)
Yes it would be helpful if you could point us to some resources about playground design.