News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by loup-vaillant on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:30PM (#19924414)
To put it bluntly, the increased happiness of millions of children is worth a couple children's health, or even lives.

That's a tough sell, but that sounds reasonable (well, I can talk, I don't have children). This is basically the same reasoning Yudkowsky presented with his dust speck vs torture argument argument: a sufficiently widespread benefit, however small, will outweigh a sufficiently improbable horrible event.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by souprock on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:46PM (#19924539)
Well, I have a dozen kids, and I agree.

Of course, part of the reason for so many kids is to minimize the percentage of my family that would be lost if one did die. My wife's uncle had the postcard family, one boy and one girl in a cute little city house with a picket fence. The daughter died, and the father completely fell apart. He lost 100% of his daughters. It is too late for him to create a replacement.

Most families today are tiny. I think this has affected our perception of loss. The risk of 100% loss has become so great that people can't allow the risk of traditional play.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by justinator on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:37AM (#19926421)
Of course, part of the reason for so many kids is to minimize the percentage of my family that would be lost if one did die.

I think I just read the most insane sentence I'll read all year.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by bad_good_guy on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:40AM (#19926945)
How is it insane when this is the historic reason behind large families?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by justinator on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:44PM (#19931102)
I'm not touching, "but it's historical!", because that's a problematic idea in of itself. Lots of things are, "historical", but don't make sense in the modern world.

Say you had two kids, and you lost both. One way to think of it is your lost all the children you ever had. Fine.

Say you had a DOZEN kids, and you lost six of them. Same thinking as above, you've lost half the children you ever had. Ok, but you still lost six kids!. Six kids have to go through life knowing they have lost six siblings. Having that somehow be better is pure insanity. Or at the very least the utmost self-centered thing I've ever heard of - you're hoping that the loss off 6 out of 12 kids is somewhat less of an impact on yourself when compared to losing two kids?

These are human beings, not cupcakes you're bringing to a picnic. If you brought two cupcakes, and hoping to have one yourself, but both were eaten before you could have your own cupcake, that stinks - but you're just out of a cupcake. Then yeah: bring a dozen cupcakes to share, and have yourself your own cupcake.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by baud147258 on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:33AM (#19927463)
If I remember right, reducing child mortality actually decrease the number of children per family, so it's not that strange. Of course it's bluntly said and reductionist, but I think it has a basis in fact.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by stevesimmons on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:52AM (#19926751)
You've increased your likelihood of experiencing tragic loss 12-fold!
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ctack on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:29AM (#19926669)
Does your stance on redundancy of loved ones also extend to the number of spouses you have?
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by ctack on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:40AM (#19926714)
You might still want to learn how to deal with grief and loss though. If you had 12 kids to avoid the possibility of losing all of your kids or all of one gender of your kids, it might still happen anyway. What if you lose your favorite one? What if you still lose all of them? I don’t wish any of that on you or anyone, but I just have to say that breeding for redundancy to avoid the pain of loss strikes me as being, and this is putting it mildly, a tad immature.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by zbentley on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:52PM (#19924576)
I think that's kind of missing GP's point that, while

> the increased happiness of millions of children is worth a couple children's health, or even lives.

might be totally true, it's borderline-impossible to convince concerned (or worse, bereaved) parents of this in many cases, for human, not utilitarian, reasons.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by wallace_f on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:10PM (#19924677)
But is this really caused by grieving parents and not blood-sucking lawyers and idiotic bureaucrats?

I'm in Japan and there's a lot of dangerous playground equipment, hikes, stairwells, rooftop decks, onsens, alcohol that can be bought from vending machines, etc... And yet without all those 'experts'and authorities protecting society from these dangers, here it feels safety is many, many tiers better what we have in America.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Mirioron on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:53PM (#19924923)
But bereaved parents are only a small portion of the people at the time. They alone can't make changes. The rest of society has to agree to them.
Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Firadeoclus on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:28AM (#19927439)
> To put it bluntly, the increased happiness of millions of children is worth a couple children's health, or even lives.

I don't think that's an accurate reframing. The opportunity cost isn't just happiness (by making playgrounds boring, presumably) but also safety, and therefore lives, in other areas. When you hit diminishing returns trying to make playgrounds 100% safe, spending the same resources on e.g. road design will save more lives.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by Noos on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:38PM (#19925683)
No, it isn't.

We can all survive with a little less happiness. If our playgrounds are a little more boring, we can all deal. (though if anything they are a lot nicer than the ones I grew up with) Happiness is a good that can come from many sources, and while it's nice to have, if it is reduced, we can usually adapt to it by finding a new source.

Happiness shouldn't be a reason to trade lives.

Re:Making Playgrounds a Little More Dangerous by joesb on Thursday May 16, 2019 @12:00AM (#19926025)
That reminds me of the villian robot in I, Robot movie. They don't want to harm human, they just want to keep them in the house, so that there is less crime, and less people die.

It may take away freedom. But freedom should not be a reason to trade lives.

Some may say the playground is about happiness, some may say it's about the freedom to experience.