News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by anonu on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:17AM (#19838346)
From the website:

How to avoid this scam: Don't answer or return any calls from numbers you don't recognize.

If the FCC is recommending we don't pick up our phones, isn't something really wrong with the system?

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by Waterluvian on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:40AM (#19838449)
Absolutely. The phone system is totally broken. A few years ago I disabled the incoming call part of my phone to everyone except a few family members and my wife. So far it's been great. Everyone who needs me emails me. I've yet to run into a situation where someone I needed to hear from would only call me.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by SomeHacker44 on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:47AM (#19838888)
Just not willing to do this. I never want to miss a call from someone talking about an emergency with a family member, the FAA calling about an unclosed flight plan, a recruiter (if job hunting), a delivery person, etc. I answer virtually all unknown numbers except the ones T-Mobile puts in as “Scam Likely.”

What I do not understand is, given that the phone is a computer, why there is not an on-phone IVR which can solicit a brief intro. I mean, I had tech that could do that for a landline 25 years ago.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by booleandilemma on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:56AM (#19838965)
My strategy is:

if I don’t know the caller they can leave a voicemail. If it’s not important enough for a voicemail, it’s not important.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by grawprog on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:14AM (#19839567)
The problem with this for me is my voicemail is now so full of spam messages from numbers I don't answer or block that I can't ever get any useful messages if there are any. A lot of the time my inbox remains full and I can't actually receive new voicemails. It's just gotten to the point where the new voicemail icon has become a permanent fixture on my notification bar I totally ignore.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by freehunter on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:17AM (#19839603)
Visual voicemail is one of the best things I've ever seen. Especially with transcription turned on.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by grawprog on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:41AM (#19839829)
I've never heard of this before. Unfortunately after checking it out, it looks like my carrier only offers it for iphones. This does look like a handy feature though.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by matwood on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:55AM (#19839986)
Google Voice will transcribe any VMs and send them as a text. The transcription is good enough to know if it's someone you need to call back or add their number to your block list.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by chadlavi on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:30AM (#19840307)
this is also done automatically in iOS through the phone app
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by matwood on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:05PM (#19840669)
I should check that out sometime. I've been using the GV one since long before it was offered on iOS.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by scruple on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:17PM (#19840791)
It can't transcribe the Chinese scam calls that I get 5x daily, though. I've taken to answering every call again recently because my family has some health stuff going on. Otherwise, I have to physically listen to every voicemail to ensure that I didn't miss an important call because someone in the hospital had a thick accent or any other benign software issue related to NLP problems.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by grawprog on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:12AM (#19840150)
I appreciate the suggestion, but I've disabled all the google things on my phone and don't plan on re-enabling them any time soon.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by dboreham on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:56AM (#19840556)
Hmm...I worked on this 25 years ago. Baby steps...
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by aeternus on Monday May 06, 2019 @03:48PM (#19843053)
The concept of a 'full' voicemail is also backwards. It should be implemented as a circular buffer, if full, the oldest gets replaced.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by ZeikJT on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:47AM (#19868763)
I wholly disagree. The system as it works today is miles better than a circular buffer. People trying to leave new voicemails are informed that there is no more room and thus they know that if it is important they should try calling back later.

If it just deleted old entries then it's possible someone left an important message and assume you'll hear it but then it just gets silently deleted.

Imagine if PC storage devices worked this way, it'd be chaos.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by simonblack on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:58PM (#19845466)
Use the 'this number not in use' tones (http://www.k3pgp.org/telezap.htm) as I described in my reply to 'SomeHacker44' above. That cuts out many (most?) garbage voicemails.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by ansible on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:39PM (#19841080)
That's weird.

I get calls from scammers occasionally, but they don't ever leave VM.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by grawprog on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:43PM (#19841122)
There's two I get regularly. One is from people pretending to be the Canada Revenue Agency. The other is a message in Cantonese, that according to my coworker who gets them too, is from someone pretending to be from the Chinese embassy basically saying the same thing as the fake CRA one. That you owe money and a lawsuit is being prepared under your name, without actually mentioning your name. The one from the 'CRA' is almost comical. It sounds like something a child would say. I've talked to the government enough to know how they talk. They also don't use odd voice concealing effects typically.

I actually called the number the CRA one left back once and a person with a French accent answered pretending to be from the CRA. I just said if they called my number again I was going to report them to the rcmp and then hung up. It stopped for a few months after that. I'm assuming if it was actually Canada revenue, they would have called back. All I was getting were the Cantonese ones. The CRA ones only started again recently.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by stOneskull on Monday May 06, 2019 @09:31AM (#19839205)
Same here. Makes sense. If it's important at all they'll leave a message.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by pavel_lishin on Monday May 06, 2019 @09:18AM (#19839114)
> why there is not an on-phone IVR which can solicit a brief intro.

Google has that, but I'm not sure if it's on-phone.

I'd wager someone could write an app to do this.

I would probably pay $50 for an on-phone version of Lenny; basically a voice-based chat-bot that keeps spammers occupied, without having to conference another number in.

( https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/d3b7na/the-story-of-lenny... )

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by cblades on Monday May 06, 2019 @09:26AM (#19839161)
I don't understand what's meant by on-phone, but the google feature asks the caller to introduce themselves and why they're calling, and transcribes the response for the user to read in realtime.

I use it for every number I don't know, and so far it's been 100% successful (in the sense that, afaik, no one who I wanted to hear from has hung up on Google Assistant).

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by ChrisArchitect on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:50AM (#19839928)
heard a review of this app a few days ago that reminded me of Lenny https://www.robokiller.com/ - apparently the conversations it spews out are pretty hilarious also. Annoyingly I can't figure out what the subscription rate is, but can try it for a week for free
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by ibarrac on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:42AM (#19840414)
I've been using this for the last 3 weeks and it works really well. It has blocked 21 spam calls up to now. After the free week they charge $30 yearly or $4 monthly.

You can set the spam calls to be answered with selected funny time-wasting recordings, but since that would be embarrassing if I get a call from a professional contact, I set them to be answered with a plain fax tone.

Now I am back to being able to pick up all calls that ring.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by pavel_lishin on Monday May 06, 2019 @01:29PM (#19841713)
Can you toggle over to the "funny recording" on demand? I want to be able to say "ok, let me get my dad", and push the button to waste their time.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by pavel_lishin on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:26AM (#19840265)
Oh! This, this could be what I'm looking for.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by Spoom on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:23AM (#19840236)
Not sure if the voice generation is actually happening on the phone but Call Screen is not conferencing in anyone AFAIK. It's pretty seamless. You get an automatic transcription interface to see what the caller is saying in real time, and can choose to pick up, ask some canned questions, get them to clarify what they said, or mark the number as spam and hang up. Often when I've suspected a spam call and started a Call Screen, they just hang up (which I consider a success).

(My opinions are my own, not necessarily those of my employer.)

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by pavel_lishin on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:25AM (#19840260)
Right, I understand that about Call Screen.

What I want, though, is an interactive bot, running on my phone, that will eat up telemarketer's time by pretending to be a real person, and responding to them in such a way as to keep them on the line for as long as possible.

I want to pick up a call from a scumbag, tell them, "hang on, let me get my dad", and press the "fuck you" button - which puts a fake doddering old man on the line for them to talk to instantly, without any more intervention required from me.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by beams_of_light on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:38AM (#19839791)
I've done this for my home phone number with Twilio using Studio. The last 2 options forward the call to mine or my wife's cell numbers. Everyone seems to hang up when they hear the IVR - neither of us have gotten a call forwarded from Twilio in over 2 months.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by technofiend on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:19PM (#19840840)
I realize this doesn't do much for your cell number already in the wild but if you want to migrate people over to a number that screens before routing to you, it's possible to do on the cheap.

I ported my landline number to Callcentric partially just to rid myself of the AT & T $75/mo charge and partially because of Callcentric's call handling.

Callcentric (and I'm sure others) allow call routing rules which include inputs for spam ranking, whitelist and IVR routing. You can upload your contacts, whitelist those for passthrough and then send anyone else to a simple "please press <fixed digit|random digit> " prompt first before routing to you if they pass the test.

https://www.thetelecomspot.com/grandstream-ht801.html

If you prefer to own the hardware yourself, it's possible to do the same by loading asterisk on a raspberry pi.

https://brezular.com/2019/01/02/asterisk-on-raspberry-pi/

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by simonblack on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:51PM (#19845432)
Set up your phone such that when you don't answer a call from a number you don't recognise, it will go to voicemail.

Set up your voicemail answering message to contain only two things: the tones that signify "This Phone Number Not In Use" (see http://www.k3pgp.org/telezap.htm) and a terse voice message, such as "Leave a Message", which imparts no usable information to the caller.

Now when the call goes to voicemail, two things happen: First, any robocallers will hang up when the hear the 'Not in Use' tones. Second, any humans will hear the 'Leave a Message' and they now have two options which are to hang up, or to leave a message asking you to call back.

You merely have to scan the voicemail messages and call back only those ones you choose to answer. The other 80% or more have been discarded 'automatically' before you get to hear them.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by eatbitseveryday on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:09AM (#19840114)
> why there is not an on-phone IVR which can solicit a brief intro

I believe Google Voice has this option. You enable it and it records them saying who they are, which is played to you to accept or reject.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by joncrane on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:08AM (#19840109)
I have a Google Pixel XL, and it has a built-in call screening feature from Google. It seems like exactly what you're looking for.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by goguy on Monday May 06, 2019 @02:05PM (#19842065)
How many calls are you actually getting? Even if it's one a day, who h seems extremely high, is it really that much effort to lose the 5 seconds it takes to answer and hang up straight away?
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by Piskvorrr on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @11:18AM (#19850286)
Depends. At some point, I was getting one about every two hours. Got a call rating/blocking app then, and hey presto, they all get blocked automagically. Machine v. machine: fatality! Apparently word gets around, as even the attempted calls decreased after about a month.

(And yes, I would probably be juggling significant state at the usual calling times; pushing and popping all that is far more than 5 seconds, even if that were completely lossless)

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by apollo_ on Monday May 06, 2019 @02:37PM (#19842399)
anecdotal: I've been getting 2-5 spam/scam calls per day. I cancel any incoming call that I don't recognize or am not expecting. The alternative is disruptive (leaving my desk, finding an empty conference room, answering, etc). The interruption costs far more than the time it takes to resolve.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by solotronics on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:05AM (#19840077)
There was an article on here a few months ago about how the organ donor system works. If you are on the list to receive an organ you get a phonecall and if you miss this call the organ goes to the next person on the list who picks up the phone.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by brewdad on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:36AM (#19840356)
Given the time constraints around organ donation and transplantation, this seems reasonable. If you only have a couple of hours before the organ is no longer viable you can't reasonably sit around hoping someone will return your call.

Ideally, you should be alerted that your position on the waitlist is approaching so that you know to answer any incoming calls in case it's "the one". I have no idea if this reflects reality however.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by rlpb on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @06:57AM (#19848248)
> Ideally, you should be alerted that your position on the waitlist is approaching...

I'm not sure the false hope would be an improvement. Unfortunately there are a whole bunch of emotional considerations that need to be made in this case.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by etrautmann on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:51PM (#19841219)
Yes, but there should be an automated system that sends email, text, and calls to multiple family members simultaneously
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by ysavir on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:54AM (#19838535)
Do you have any concerns over being an emergency contact for anyone? I've considered doing the same as you, but I fear the chance that a I would be contacted in such a scenario and wouldn't even know it.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by criddell on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:16AM (#19839585)
I'm pretty sure if it was an emergency, they would leave a message. For me, that's good enough.

Once the phone companies fix caller authentication, I'll probably be comfortable letting my guard down a bit. Correct caller ID would make my phone far more valuable and I'm always surprised that the big telecom companies don't compete on voice services more.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by Waterluvian on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:15AM (#19838667)
You should be consciously aware of who might emergency contact you anyways. Add them to your whitelist.

Edit: all good points. Yeah I guess that is a risk.

Also reminds me of this:

https://youtu.be/J-inCB3POqs

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by astura on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:55AM (#19838951)
Yeah, because when your spouse is getting rolled into emergency surgery after suddenly collapsing you'll definitely know what number is going to call you to inform you, so you'll want to whitelist that one. And when a drunk driver hits her car on a rural road in the middle of the night and her phone is trapped in the wreck, you'll want to make sure you whitelist the phone number of the passerby that stops to help. And when your elderly parents' house is burning down (along with their phones) you'll definitely know all the phone numbers of all possible emergency responders and neighbors, so whitelist all of them too.

That's not even considering mundane everyday stuff like delivery people/repair people who got lost or have to reschedule last minute. You might have the main number for the business whitelisted, but those sorts of calls usually come from the phone number of the day's driver.

The only people who think "just disable incoming phone calls" is a viable option either have no friends and/or family, very little life experience, or both.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by rjsw on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:47AM (#19839892)
All the hospitals that I know disable caller ID. Which seems pretty stupid to me, they could set it to the number of the main switchboard.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by cheerlessbog on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:02AM (#19839470)
There is usually a setting to allow unknown numbers through if they call again within a short amount of time. That may help with the emergency case.

Unfortunately the 2FA calls for my corporate login seem to come from different numbers each time..

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by jkaplowitz on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:52AM (#19839957)
I have that setting enabled, though I think it may be Android-only.

Do we know if people actually try twice in rapid succession often enough during emergencies, without special training to develop that habit?

I don't know the data on this, but I'd like to.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by brewdad on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:42AM (#19840412)
I would think the more likely scenario in this case would be to work through the list of emergency contact numbers (ie. cell phone, work phone, home phone) in succession rather than calling the same number twice.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by fjsolwmv on Monday May 06, 2019 @01:50PM (#19841924)
That's a useless arms race because spammers can easily call twice.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by cheerlessbog on Monday May 06, 2019 @03:55PM (#19843130)
You would think, but so far they don't seem to have figured that out.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by matwood on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:58AM (#19840018)
The problem is unless you have a home phone, you already can't rely on cell phones to have every call come through. Calls do not connect all the time, and end up going to VM anyway.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by malka on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:17AM (#19839601)
If people want to contact me, they can leave a message on my voicemail.

The only people who think "just disable incoming phone calls" is not a viable option either have no decent friends and/or family, very little life experience, or both.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by dwyerm on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:11PM (#19840726)
Will reverse-911 bother navigating your IVR? Will their automation leave a clear message?

I can tell you that calls from 911 don't come from the phone number '911'.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by malka on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:59AM (#19848604)
I haven received a single meaninful phone call in 10 years. yeah if its urgent, leave a message. Else you will not hear back from me.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by dsfyu404ed on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:19AM (#19838703)
You never know who's going to call from what number. Just yesterday I had a carrier I hired call me from the shipper's landline because the situation was going sideways and there was no cell service.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by moccachino on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:18AM (#19838693)
That's not really feasible. You might know for which persons you are the emergency contact but you can't possibly know from which phone you would be contacted in case of an actual emergency.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by slig on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:17AM (#19838687)
I believe the parent is taking about an emergency where the hospital calls, not the person.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by daviddavis on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:47AM (#19838487)
How did you do that? Is it possible with an iPhone?
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by ceejayoz on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:51AM (#19838519)
You can leave do-not-disturb on, and flag the people you want to exempt as VIPs.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by crsmith on Monday May 06, 2019 @01:24PM (#19841641)
Doesn't this block all other notifications too?
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by cbluth on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:46AM (#19838475)
I do this exact thing. I have also turned off all notification toast pop-ups on my phone.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by cm2012 on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:06PM (#19840677)
Doctor's offices will almost always only call you for fear of HIPAA violations.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by sib on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:13PM (#19840745)
My doctors either send email with a link to their secure messaging portal (meh) or a push notification to their mobile app which contains a messaging capability (much better).

This is much better than the old days of phone-only contact.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by dvfjsdhgfv on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:29AM (#19840304)
I use a variation of your system with two phones. One is like yours and I always hawe it with me, turned on. The second is for everyone else - delivery people, banks etc. I have it muted except if I expect a call. Every couple of days I check it only to find that there were no important calls. Once a year someone leaves a message and I call them back. This system works great, I don't remember when was the last time I had to deal with scammers and other people wasting my time.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by darkwater on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:11AM (#19838639)
Well, actually you cannot know for sure. If the person trying to call you has only your phone number as a mean to contact you, you cannot possibly know if their are trying or not to contact you. I understand you are assuming they are going to escalate somehow to get to you, but maybe it can't just be possible in some scenario.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by jasonhansel on Monday May 06, 2019 @08:27PM (#19845300)
My solution has been to switch my ringtone to a silent MP3 file. A good trick, since iOS doesn't let you disable all incoming calls (AFAICT).
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by brownbat on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:40AM (#19838453)
The FCC is saying the system requires whitelisting, but using your memory, rather than any technology from providers.

It is strange.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by amyjess on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:53AM (#19840534)
> How to avoid this scam: Don't answer or return any calls from numbers you don't recognize.

Unfortunately, this isn't great for a number of reasons:

1) The last two times I got a series of missed calls every two hours from somebody who didn't leave a voicemail, it was my credit card company (a different company each time) calling to ask me about a number of suspicious charges on the other side of the country that I sure as hell didn't make (I distinctly remember saying, on one such occasion, "What the hell is a Sheetz?"). Both of those times lead to me having my card declared stolen and the bogus charges reversed. If I didn't answer, I probably wouldn't have noticed the bogus charges.

2) My employer covers a large chunk of my phone + Internet bills. This is so I can answer emergency calls from our NOC whenever one of the important applications my team maintains goes kablooey. The whole thing with Android not resolving people's numbers right away includes them, as well. The call comes in as a long string of numbers, and if I miss it, it takes a few minutes before the long string of numbers resolves to a name on my contacts list. I'd rather not develop a reputation for snubbing our internal customers, especially not when they have an emergency.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by Bartweiss on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:44PM (#19841136)
> a series of missed calls... from somebody who didn't leave a voicemail, it was my credit card company

This is a huge part of why this system doesn't work. Perhaps 95% of the calls I get from unknown numbers either produce informative voicemails or are scams. But the ones that don't are often the most important calls I get, from sources like credit card companies and doctors. Depressingly often, the numbers they're using aren't even listed online to look up later.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by fjsolwmv on Monday May 06, 2019 @01:51PM (#19841942)
Why do you use a credit card from a company that (a) does not how to email you or notify you via app, and (b) dumps their fraud protection back onto you by forcing you to handle number misuse; and if the problem was actual fraudulent use, your card woud be canceled so how would reaching you on the phone help, as the response to fraud is to cancel your card # and issue another one?
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by userbinator on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:58AM (#19838572)
That's weird. I can understand not returning, since then you're the one originating and thus getting charged for the call, but for answering? Is there any landline service that charges for non-collect incoming calls?
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by brownbat on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @09:02PM (#19854956)
Not unique to this scam, but scammers often log whether or not someone answered and put you on a list for additional attention.

It's like how responding to spammers with "No, thank you!" will actually get you more spam.

Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by nulbyte on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:27AM (#19839688)
No, but prepaid wireless services may charge you for incoming calls.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by michaelmior on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:12AM (#19840145)
Are there any services that actually charge you additional fees for incoming long distance calls though? That seems to be the primary concern here.
Re:'One Ring' Phone Scam by Bartweiss on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:35PM (#19841038)
I can't find any evidence of major carriers doing this. There's discussion online to the effect that this has been true, but it looks like it was mostly a weird episode during the rise of cellphones where a call could be long distance but billed to the caller at normal rates, so the carrier would try to collect from the recipient.

If anyone knows of a scam in which simply picking up a call can produce extra costs, they should definitely share!