Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by SmellyGeekBoy on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:20AM
(#19777357)
I've never been keen on SBCs using "Pi" in the name to ride on the Raspberry Pi's coattails. I'm surprised the Raspberry Pi foundation aren't more protective of it, if I'm honest.
At least in the case of the Banana Pi etc the board is the same form factor and fits into existing RPi cases, and even runs on the same architecture. This thing has literally nothing in common with the RPi apart from being another SBC.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by Zenst on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:23AM
(#19777634)
Totally agree, though reminiscent of the early days of PC's with IBM (the OS and PC name..) and again naming conventions with Intel (they wanted to trademark 386 etc and was told they could not do that with numbers - hence they started using the Pentium brand they could trademark along with a massive campaign of Intel Inside...).
Lucky the more savvy consumer see's right thru this tailgating and more so in the realms of arm SBC's.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by gmiller123456 on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:39PM
(#19781263)
>But equally, Raspberry could not trademark "Pi" or indeed "Raspberry"
One very close counter example would be "Blackberry". You absolutely can trademark common words for use in specific markets. Another infamous example is "Apple" as both a computer company and a music label. Had there been other computers already using "Raspberry" or "Pi", they likely would have run into issues using "Raspberry Pi".
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by Zenst on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @03:13PM
(#19790948)
Yes, though in Apples case they fell foul of Apple records and eventually settled that they would not do anything music related. That changed, though they financially better placed to handle and settle that issue than the initial conflict.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by morganvachon on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:55AM
(#19777490)
Agreed, I saw $35 and "Pi" in the headline and immediately thought there was already a successor to the Pi 3B+. I'm not exactly disappointed to see a $35 Cherry Trail SBC, that's a phenomenal price point for such a device, but it's definitely misleading.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by HeWhoLurksLate on Monday April 29, 2019 @09:12AM
(#19778024)
At this point, I kind of feel like the "Pi" moniker is useful for conveying a sense of size & I'm not really offended by the fact that a bunch of companies are bringing their own products to the market and doing stuff like "Orange Pi" or "Banana Pi" or "Cherry Pi" or "Atomic Pi" or "Vanilla Pi" or any other name with Pi in it, or Google's AI thing that has a different size but incorporates the Pi HAT spec.
I do agree though, it would be nice to see some more cohesiveness in the system, but the Pi that started it all isn't perfect for everything either.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by tracker1 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @12:54PM
(#19789636)
This thing seems to be 2x the size though (more if you include heatsink height). Of course even rpi has a smaller version... so, meh.
I think it seems like a really powerful board for the price, though I do wish they full kits (+case and power) were a bit closer to the raw board price. After you add them it's often 2x the price.
Not that it would actually get me closer to done any faster. I have a kit by my desk I haven't even opened for 6 months. The last one is running various emulators in the living room. This board seems to do well enough for Playstation and Sega Saturn emulation from a couple youtube videos that came up yesterday.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by steve19 on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:18AM
(#19776018)
The price to performance is crazy. If this had an extra ethernet port it would be the go-to router.
What is really lacks is a easy power supply option. No barrel jack and it needs up to 20w so more than regular usb can supply. The breakout board, which I assume as a barrel jack, is not for sale on amazon yet.
I don't think antennas are included, and I don't know if they are absolutely required.
Edit: I don't see any sata or pci interfaces which is disappointing. Also the power breakout board has screw terminals not a barrel jack.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by CaptainJustin on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:32AM
(#19776063)
Ordered four of these last week and planning on running them as a K8s cluster. You are correct about the power interface not being ideal. My current plan is to hook my cluster up to an old computer power supply. For those who are curious these things can draw around 4A at 5V.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by consp on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:45AM
(#19776336)
Wouldn't it be cheaper in the long run to run it from one PSU's 12v line and buy two (or four) 12/5v step down converters? 10A versions aren't even that expensive and the loss of running the PSU on only 20W will be huge (below 50% efficiency for sure).
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by nreilly on Monday April 29, 2019 @04:07AM
(#19776654)
Keep in mind that all the Pine64 hardware has a 3 month warranty [1] that requires shipping the faulty device back. This made me very hesitant to buy any of their stuff.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by thinkmassive on Monday April 29, 2019 @11:22AM
(#19779161)
"All single board and accessories sold on the Pine Microsystems Inc. (PINE64) store are entitled to a 30 days Limited Warranty against defects in materials and workmanship."
I searched the linked page for "90" (days) and "3" (months) with no results, other than the "30 days" mentioned above. Where do you see 90-day warranty?
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by kingosticks on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:57PM
(#19781470)
There's also the new-ish Odroid-N2 which offers similar (supposedly better) performance for a similar $ premium. It's based on an Amlogic S922X rather than Rockchip.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by Fnoord on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:00AM
(#19776164)
Less than half the price of an Asus Tinker board. Similar specs. 2 GB RAM isn't much though. If you want to run something like Splunk it won't work. My GPD Pocket 2 has 8 GB RAM. What kind of antennas are you referring to? Raspberry Pi with WLAN doesn't have any either. As for ethernet port you could probably use one via USB.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by steve19 on Monday April 29, 2019 @04:25AM
(#19776726)
The Atomic Pi Amazon page spec list says antennas not included. That could well mean external antennas are not included (I can see there are connections for them) but there might be PCB antennas (copper tracks on the board itself that act as an antenna, like on a rpi or ESP8266).
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by A2017U1 on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:23AM
(#19776245)
Does a router need that much compute? I've just moved and the walls here attenuate wifi signals dramatically. Was thinking about building my own router and bumping up the signal power. That or some sort of repeater.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by steve19 on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:05AM
(#19776417)
Routing gigabit with a stateful firewall does require a fair bit of computing power. But that is not going to solve your wifi signal problem. Use a mesh wifi setup to solve that one.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by A2017U1 on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:28AM
(#19776497)
Thanks mate, been weighing up the options. Was not prepared for how bad it can be with thick rebar concrete walls. Only a few meters away from router and yet terrible signal. Far outside through a glass door has perfect signal.
Ethernet over power and a mesh of AP's seems to be the best way.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by pizza234 on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:01AM
(#19777066)
It depends on the functionality. A VPN router (although it's likely not your case) has a ceiling of 2 MBit/s on an RPi 3b (with a standard, single-threaded, OpenVPN configuration), which is relatively little.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by Tharre on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:40AM
(#19777429)
This can't be right.
Granted, I've not been running OpenVPN lately, but with WireGuard I'm saturating the internal USB-ethernet adapter of the pi long before I'm running out of CPU power.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by jsight on Monday April 29, 2019 @09:03AM
(#19777946)
No, routers do not require much CPU power. Typical consumer routers often have really limited CPUs. The biggest issue is getting enough bandwidth out of the Ethernet ports. For example, a Pi 3B+ can only handle 200Mbit or so. Whether that is enough for you will depend upon your WAN speed.
Having said that, I'm less sure about your use case. You might could load OpenWRT on it and set it up to relay a wireless signal, but I doubt the performance would be great.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by jsight on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:54AM
(#19777879)
I'm not sure why you would need anywhere near this level of CPU for a "go-to" router. Many of the ARM-based systems with gigabit and USB3 are perfectly suitable as routers.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by lpcvoid on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:04AM
(#19778421)
Because you maybe want something like pfsense to run with some filter rules, or you may want a long term VPN connection, which even with AES-NI Instructions still requires substantial CPU power for high speed connections.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by jsight on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @04:45PM
(#19791767)
VPN is a good point. I don't think that I could get anywhere near 100Mbit with my Pi on OpenVPN, though in practice it is enough for what I need it for (access to home automation and maybe a couple of cameras).
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by jsight on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @04:47PM
(#19791785)
I guess that is possible, but I think it is just as likely that people just overestimate the requirement. My Pi is practically idling while pushing ~100Mbit between the builtin Ethernet and an external dongle. Routing really doesn't take as much CPU as people think, even with a few rules for things like bandwidth monitoring on a per IP basis.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by ChrisRR on Monday April 29, 2019 @05:40AM
(#19776989)
The consensus in the comments seems to be that these boards were designed for another product that was scrapped and now being sold off as a SBC. So stock is likely to be extremely limited.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by kingosticks on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:35PM
(#19781219)
Videocore 4 processors were also used in a bunch of phones and media boxes. The fact the Raspberry Pi was built on it was more because Eben Upton had worked on it.
But it is fair to say they wouldn't have fabbed anywhere near as many had it not been for the Raspberry Pi.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by EamonnMR on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:44AM
(#19777216)
I got one of these as an emulation box because a retropi couldn't handle the N64 games I wanted to run, and for that purpose it's worked brilliantly. It's pretty cool that it's x86-I plan to try and do some WINE gaming on it as well which isn't possible on, say, a retropi. I haven't tried the official images, but it runs fine with the standard Ubuntu image.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by laumars on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:55AM
(#19777258)
WINE will run on the Pi albeit you need to run it on top of x86 emulator. I've seen examples using qemu but there are guides online using other tools too. I've not tried it myself but from what I've read it's still fast enough to run some Windows games.
Obviously if you have an x86 box then that would be better suited. But the above is worth mentioning just in case anyone else should read your comment who doesn't have any besides a Raspberry Pi but still wants access to retro games for IBM-compatible machines.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by laumars on Monday April 29, 2019 @11:27AM
(#19779214)
You would expect so but I haven't tried it personally because I had a spare NUK laying around anyway.
I think the real question is how old or recent are the games you're wanting to play? Games consoles would have to be emulated too and the Pi can still pull of some N64 and PS1 games.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by EamonnMR on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:29PM
(#19783201)
Some N64 games are too much for the Pi, which is why I got one of these things. I imagine other games from the 90s/very early 00s should run on it. Will probably update the post if/when I do.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by ujuj on Monday April 29, 2019 @04:39AM
(#19776775)
What about power consumption?
I have a RPI 3B+ at house that runs Docker containers, these would be a major step up in terms of image compatibility, but I'm worried about a major step up in terms of electricity cost too.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by jokowueu on Monday April 29, 2019 @05:04AM
(#19776853)
Reading the comments . It seems almost half the power requirement is needed to power the amps for the audio . So if ur not using it u won't reach that power use
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by gmiller123456 on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:49PM
(#19781364)
Just a fair warning to anyone thinking about backing anything on Kickstarter: You have absolutely no legal recourse to against a company that doesn't deliver your goods. You pay Kickstarter, Kickstarter pays the company. Kickstarter is the only one who can enforce their terms against the company, and they're notoriously famous for refusing to do so. There is a long list of Kickstarter campaigns where the founders just took the money and ran. Even ones where the founder appears to have all of the best intentions fall apart.
Not saying to never back any croudfunding, but know what you're getting in to. From what I've seen, you get better odds at a casino.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by abrugsch on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @03:56AM
(#19785939)
I wouldn't put kickstarter odds THAT low... I've backed dozens of campaigns now and so far had exactly one that has totally failed to deliver (the company went flat out bust after getting royally screwed by all of their supply chain - Next Thing Co, the people that made the C.H.I.P and pocketCHIP - in themselves successful KS projects) and one that is in forever development - Star Citizen, but at least they drop regular alpha versions...
For everything else I have alt least gotten my product eventually. though I do pick my backs very carefully. I admit there is a lot of obvous vapourware though, but it's easily balanced out by genuine people trying to get a product off the ground, and are usually smaller in scope with much more realistic targets. They don't usually make headlines though ;)
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by gmiller123456 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @01:06PM
(#19789768)
I actually got my CHIP, though I ordered it on their website and not Kickstarter. I got screwed on the Peachy Printer. While I technically didn't get screwed on the M3D Printer, it was delayed so long, cheaper and better printers where available by the time I got mine. The closest I came to backing another was the "ABC of Connection" book. It was supposedly a book that was already done, and just had to be printed, so how could that fail? He never delivered the printed material, but eventually delivered a PDF. The PDF showed it was far from complete, and the dates in it showed he hadn't done any real work on it since taking the money. The whole time he was claiming issues with the printer, when it was no where near ready for printing.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by abrugsch on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @10:49AM
(#19797485)
It wasn't the actual CHIP... I got my CHIP and a pocketCHIP. I had a great e-mail relationship with one of the founders prior to pCHIP release, and the community was excellent. I was actually talking about voder though which was mid development when the financial rug was pulled out and NTC just quietly vanished with all the cries of "where's my CHIP?" in the forum...
That's unfortunate about your printer and book. I've backed book (Bitmap books visual commpendium series) and music projects (Chris Huelsbeck Turrican anthology and SIDologie - Sidology took a while to complete but the end result has been stellar) and to date they have all been excellent.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by throwaway9d0291 on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:34AM
(#19776521)
Minor nitpick but "10-bit HEVC" or "10-bit H.265" would be better terms. x265 is just an encoder for HEVC/H.265 and devices don't decode x265 output specifically, they decode HEVC/H.265.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by asgeir on Monday April 29, 2019 @05:42AM
(#19776997)
From my experience the Z8350 should be capable of decoding 1-2 1080p60 through VAAPI and rendering with OpenGL. Have you tried using mpv from the command line without XOrg running? i.e. something like: mpv --hwdec=vaapi --opengl-backend=drm --drm-connector=1.HDMI-A-4 ...
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by verall on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:23AM
(#19776243)
No, only has 8-bit hw decoder and this thing would prob not be able to software decode 1080p h.265. 1080p h.264 10-bit (also would need to be sw decoded) would be rough.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by Splognosticus on Monday April 29, 2019 @09:40AM
(#19778243)
I've got a tablet[1] that uses almost the same CPU. When I got it they were $80 and it's better than it has any right to be at that price, but it performs about like a 2002-ish Pentium except with hardware video acceleration. If I wanted maximum performance for the dollar I wouldn't go with an Atom.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by EamonnMR on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:45AM
(#19777221)
The possibility of running old windows apps is a nice feature. Also you can use the usual images of your favorite Linux distro rather than needing an ARM build.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by morganvachon on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:57AM
(#19777502)
> Also you can use the usual images of your favorite Linux distro rather than needing an ARM build.
Can you though? It depends on what kind of BIOS/UEFI this thing runs with. I'd be curious to see if it's a standard x86 BIOS setup or something more proprietary/less common that requires a special bootloader.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by rubyn00bie on Monday April 29, 2019 @04:21AM
(#19776714)
Hell yes. This is a cheaper looking latte panda... though the panda you can get 4GB RAM (~$149)... I’m really hoping to see more x86 based single board computers. The ARM manufacturers I think have gotten a bit lazy and could use some competition... plus running x86 chips does make life a lot easier for more complex applications.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by tyingq on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:30AM
(#19777679)
There are, like the UDOO x86 or LattePanda, but they get fairly expensive.
A used Asus Chromebox is often a better route. You can flash the bios and run regular Linux. Then you get a nice case, power supply, and regular dimm slots.
Re:$35 Atomic Pi Cherry Trail Linux SBC
by zaarn on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:40AM
(#19777759)
I have an itch to cram as many as possible into a 2U or 3U rack case just to get a massive cluster of compute going. It would certainly be an interesting project.
At least in the case of the Banana Pi etc the board is the same form factor and fits into existing RPi cases, and even runs on the same architecture. This thing has literally nothing in common with the RPi apart from being another SBC.
Lucky the more savvy consumer see's right thru this tailgating and more so in the realms of arm SBC's.
But equally, Raspberry could not trademark "Pi" or indeed "Raspberry", though they could trademark "Raspberry Pi" - https://www.raspberrypi.org/trademark-rules/
Though, as they wanted to recreate the early fun days of computing, this whole `plagiarism` angle sure does rekindle some nostalgia.
One very close counter example would be "Blackberry". You absolutely can trademark common words for use in specific markets. Another infamous example is "Apple" as both a computer company and a music label. Had there been other computers already using "Raspberry" or "Pi", they likely would have run into issues using "Raspberry Pi".
Just checked for a wiki entry and good to see my memory of that era not that bad: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Corps_v_Apple_Computer
Along with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention
Play a factor in trademarks and copyright.
Then the variations in each country of what you can and can't trademark/copyright.
I do agree though, it would be nice to see some more cohesiveness in the system, but the Pi that started it all isn't perfect for everything either.
I think it seems like a really powerful board for the price, though I do wish they full kits (+case and power) were a bit closer to the raw board price. After you add them it's often 2x the price.
Not that it would actually get me closer to done any faster. I have a kit by my desk I haven't even opened for 6 months. The last one is running various emulators in the living room. This board seems to do well enough for Playstation and Sega Saturn emulation from a couple youtube videos that came up yesterday.
What is really lacks is a easy power supply option. No barrel jack and it needs up to 20w so more than regular usb can supply. The breakout board, which I assume as a barrel jack, is not for sale on amazon yet.
I don't think antennas are included, and I don't know if they are absolutely required.
Edit: I don't see any sata or pci interfaces which is disappointing. Also the power breakout board has screw terminals not a barrel jack.
[1] https://www.pine64.org/?page_id=443
I searched the linked page for "90" (days) and "3" (months) with no results, other than the "30 days" mentioned above. Where do you see 90-day warranty?
https://www.raspberrypi.org/magpi/pi-zero-w-wireless-antenna...
Granted, I've not been running OpenVPN lately, but with WireGuard I'm saturating the internal USB-ethernet adapter of the pi long before I'm running out of CPU power.
Having said that, I'm less sure about your use case. You might could load OpenWRT on it and set it up to relay a wireless signal, but I doubt the performance would be great.
But it is fair to say they wouldn't have fabbed anywhere near as many had it not been for the Raspberry Pi.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/VideoCore
https://amzn.to/2IV6tKN
Setup notes: http://blog.eamonnmr.com/2019/04/atomic-pi-emulation-setup-n...
Obviously if you have an x86 box then that would be better suited. But the above is worth mentioning just in case anyone else should read your comment who doesn't have any besides a Raspberry Pi but still wants access to retro games for IBM-compatible machines.
I think the real question is how old or recent are the games you're wanting to play? Games consoles would have to be emulated too and the Pi can still pull of some N64 and PS1 games.
This is why I said "some" in previous post :)
> Will probably update the post if/when I do.
Please do. I'd be interested to know
Not saying to never back any croudfunding, but know what you're getting in to. From what I've seen, you get better odds at a casino.
I'm not aware of any remote desktop supporting H265 or VP9 encoding on Linux, and offering a matching low latency (cf https://flickstiq.com/2018/05/nvidia-gpus-outperform-amd-for... )
[1] https://forum.kodi.tv/showthread.php?tid=307065
[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01MYZEPGP/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b...
Can you though? It depends on what kind of BIOS/UEFI this thing runs with. I'd be curious to see if it's a standard x86 BIOS setup or something more proprietary/less common that requires a special bootloader.
A used Asus Chromebox is often a better route. You can flash the bios and run regular Linux. Then you get a nice case, power supply, and regular dimm slots.