News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:52AM (#19757454)
Is there any other industry where a company can go public having lost $500,000,000 over the last 3 years?

I get it their “market share” is increasing every year and the loses are staying the same...and even that is not the full picture of a path to profit.

But if the company could turn a profit, then why not do it privately, show that and then go public? My guess like Uber and Lyft...they can’t turn a profit, and for any hope to turn profit they need this continual growth at a loss, and at some point the investors dump the bag on the public getting a return in a bubble they created and let the public fund the losses.

I think to balance the playing field with VC and private investment, companies shouldn’t be able to IPO with loses.

Re:Slack S-1 by evrydayhustling on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:06PM (#19758995)
Put another way, you're suggesting that "public investors shouldn't have access to loss making companies, regardless of growth". That would eliminate not just tech IPOs, but a majority of publicly traded companies period. Only 2700 (out of about 7500) currently make the cut: https://finviz.com/screener.ashx?v=111&f=fa_netmargin_pos&ft...

Like it or not, tolerating losses (preferably to accomplish growth!) has become a critical part of the capital landscape across industries. At least the tech sector is developing better metrics for comparing healthy and unhealthy growth, and generates enough growth (and later margins) to justify the risk in the first place. You'd be really disadvantaging small investors to not let them make the choice to participate at this stage.

Re:Slack S-1 by rogerkirkness on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:43PM (#19761108)
One could argue the entire purpose of investment capital is to spend it.
Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:11PM (#19759667)
>you're suggesting that "public investors shouldn't have access to loss making companies, regardless of growth".

No that’s not what I’m saying...there is a difference between a company that is registering for an IPO and an existing publicly traded company.

And let’s not pretend Tech companies IPOing at losses is somehow protection to small investors...I don’t see anyone clamoring to allow these small investor be allowed to get in on unicorns pre IPO.

Re:Slack S-1 by nugget on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:38PM (#19759963)
>I don’t see anyone clamoring to allow these small investor be allowed to get in on unicorns pre IPO

Really? This sentiment is blanketed all over HN and other investment forums. One of the major macro changes to the investment landscape is rapidly growing companies staying private longer such that the gains benefit a much smaller pool of investors.

Re:Slack S-1 by yeahitslikethat on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:18PM (#19761818)
Doesn't everyone want the option to get in on these deals before they've been pumped and dumped?

WE know the truth. The ipo buyers don't.

Re:Slack S-1 by tomc1985 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:05AM (#19763712)
Not sure why you're being downvoted. Most of the major IPOs of the last few years seem to follow that hump-into-oblivion pattern after public markets get in on it
Re:Slack S-1 by yeahitslikethat on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:39AM (#19763989)
I get down voted a lot. It's fine. People here don't like what I have to say. Little debate. Just down votes. I speak the true tho.
Re:Slack S-1 by yeahitslikethat on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:47AM (#19765792)
See!
Re:Slack S-1 by evrydayhustling on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:09PM (#19760306)
Ok, then why is loss-making more acceptable (safer for small investors) in a formerly profitable company than it is for a not-yet-profitable company?

And as others have pointed out you are exactly wrong about efforts to make public investment available earlier. Besides founders who would love to have more fundraising options, there is plenty of evidence and outcry that small investors are not getting access to economic growth: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/11/private...

Re:Slack S-1 by chc on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:55PM (#19761657)
> Ok, then why is loss-making more acceptable (safer for small investors) in a formerly profitable company than it is for a not-yet-profitable company?

One has demonstrated the ability to turn a profit and the other has not. This seems a bit like asking "Why is radiation considered a valid cancer treatment and rhino horn isn't when both have failed to help people before?"

Re:Slack S-1 by evrydayhustling on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:44PM (#19762029)
People have a lot better info than total profitability to answer "can this make money" or not. Financial statements (like this S-1) do their best to separate out how much is being spent to keep customers from how much is spent to acquire them. In lots of cases (including this one) the company has proved that they have a profitable relationship with existing customers, and that they have tolerable-and-dropping costs in acquiring new customers (in this case it looks like they are breaking even on new customers in around 9 months).

There are exceptions and sleight of hand (like when Uber doesn't reveal costs to get drivers, but this is 100% true for formerly-profitable companies too. You could make a much better argument for skipping on those, or by forcing more disclosure in S-1s. But painting broadly based on total profitability is just too simplistic.

Re:Slack S-1 by scarejunba on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:08PM (#19763332)
Dude, why don't you just not invest and leave the rest of us to lose our money? If I want to capitalize someone I should be allowed to. The accredited investor thing is already bad enough.
Re:Slack S-1 by randoramax on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:03AM (#19771458)
Because there is large a social cost with allowing regular people and retirement investment funds to waste money in scams. I'm not saying that Slack IPO is a scam. I'm saying that if a majority of public companies cannot turn a profit ever then nobody will ever be able to retire, except the Madoffs that we didn't catch.
Re:Slack S-1 by notSupplied on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:15PM (#19783903)
The Madoff scam has nothing to do with public companies being unable to turn a profit though.
Re:Slack S-1 by caprese on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:05PM (#19760825)
The answer is “yes, all industries where investors dont care about that”

and luckily for investors there is nothing else to invest in

Re:Slack S-1 by thegranderson on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:51AM (#19758112)
There are many industries where this happens. Biotech and drug development is particularly prolific in this regard. Often drug development companies spend tens to hundreds of millions creating a drug, only to have the whole company bought out by a large pharma company once it passes a certain testing/approval milestone. No profits for the company at all. [1]

Just because a business doesn't turn a GAAP profit doesn't mean it is not a worthwhile investment opportunity, nor that investors shouldn't have access to it so they can decide for themselves. There are many reasons why investors might want to back an unprofitable company - I won't go into them all here, as it differs dramatically by industry.

Keep in mind that a large part of the public market capital is from institutional investors who have just as much experience, if not more, as private investors.

No one has to buy shares in these companies. It is all a choice. "The public" is not some block of sorry schmucks who keep getting stuck with toxic investments pawned off by VC funds, and I'm not exactly sure why you seem to think "the public" is getting a bag dumped on them...

[1] Endocyte acquisition by Novartis for $2B, December 2018. Endocyte had ~$300m of accumulated losses and zero revenue prior to acquisition [1] Ablynx acquisition by Sanofi for $4.8B, May 2018. Ablynx had ~€370m of accumulated losses prior to acquisition

Re:Slack S-1 by cknoxrun on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:57AM (#19758861)
Indeed, I was at a biotech drug conference in Berlin last year and was astonished at how little direct research large pharma are engaged in. They've completely offloaded primary research to drug development companies. Maybe it has always been like that, but for me it was an eye-opener.
Re:Slack S-1 by xenospn on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:13PM (#19759695)
I would assume the smaller companies are much more efficient when it comes to R&D.
Re:Slack S-1 by zymhan on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:06PM (#19760831)
And if they don't have a breakthrough drug, they go bust and investors lose their money and employees lose their jobs.
Re:Slack S-1 by briandear on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:33PM (#19761042)
Same thing happens to tech startups. Same thing happens to local restaurants. In fact, the restaurant failure rate is much higher than most other businesses. Restaurants go bust all the time, losing money for investors (generally smaller time investors) and employees lose jobs. It’s called life. Success is never guaranteed. Is it better for someone to have had a job for a year and lost it than that job never having been created in the first place? Businesses are formed and fail all the time. In fact, that failure process is vital: it ensures capital is being allocated towards its most efficient use. Companies not being allowed to fail is what creates stagnation as available capital is consumed by inefficient enterprises rather than being redeployed to better opportunities. It’s the very essence of a market economy.
Re:Slack S-1 by djakjxnanjak on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:25PM (#19761431)
Let’s remember that a job is an arrangement where you are paid for work on an ongoing basis. If you choose to work for a startup, you assume the risk that this work opportunity will go away. But if that happens, the salary you already earned isn’t lost. You are not getting screwed on the trade where you give x hours and receive y dollars.

Working for a biotech startup instead of a big company, you accept this risk for the chance of a payoff in an acquisition.

Now, if your startup isn’t making payroll, GTFO.

Re:Slack S-1 by dredmorbius on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:32PM (#19761940)
They compartmentalise risk.
Re:Slack S-1 by scarface74 on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:26PM (#19761892)
I would say a “large part of the market is made up of institutional investors”. 45% and growing of the market is made up of passive index funds.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/19/passive-investing-now-contro...

Re:Slack S-1 by toasterlovin on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:36PM (#19759946)
Slack has a huge opportunity in front of them (become the messaging platform for every business that exists). They’re investing a lot of money to acquire all of that business (salespeople, travel, etc.). That is literally one of the main purposes of capital and access to capital is why you would take a company public.

And, specifically re: Slack. Unlike, say, Uber or Lyft, Slack has customers who have demonstrated that they are willing to pay what the service actually costs. The ride-sharing companies have not. The entire investment thesis for them is that they will somehow be able to increase prices at some point in the future, but they don’t actually have any indication that this is true. And I agree that they are most likely a bad investment. Slack, on the other hand, has a huge and rapidly growing book of extremely sticky business. To turn on profitability, they turn off their expenditure on sales people. They’re very different models.

Re:Slack S-1 by lispm on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:59PM (#19760195)
> Slack has a huge opportunity in front of them (become the messaging platform for every business that exists).

How about: being bought by Microsoft.

Re:Slack S-1 by dylanmclark on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:38PM (#19761078)
I don't think Microsoft would buy Slack given the money they've dumped into developing and promoting Teams. Seems they're too far gone at this point.

Disclosure: Work at MSFT, not on Teams.

Re:Slack S-1 by scarface74 on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:33PM (#19761955)
Hopefully they are smart enough not to fall for the sunk cost fallacy. But three other examples come to mind.

They bought Github even though they already had VSTS aka Azure Devops that offered free git hosting and they just abandoned their own browser engine for Chromium. Also they bought Xamarin.

Re:Slack S-1 by lispm on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:45PM (#19761127)
Not because of the software, but because of the customers and the dev team?
Re:Slack S-1 by dredmorbius on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:35PM (#19761971)
WhatsApp.

Microsoft would buy to prevent someone else from doing so.

Though its hold has weakened greatly, the Outlook, Exchange, and AD behemoth still own enterprise communications.

Re:Slack S-1 by irishcoffee on Friday April 26, 2019 @06:22PM (#19762269)
I was under the impression Facebook owned WhatsApp...?
Re:Slack S-1 by dredmorbius on Friday April 26, 2019 @08:06PM (#19762828)
Why they own it, and what they paid to do so, is the point.
Re:Slack S-1 by toasterlovin on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:08PM (#19760287)
Yeah, I actually think that’s a likely eventual outcome. I would be shocked if they haven’t already had discussions to that effect. It seems like a natural fit to me.
Re:Slack S-1 by scarface74 on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:30PM (#19761922)
Slack has a huge opportunity in front of them (become the messaging platform for every business that exists).

Isn’t that pitch what every startup tells investors?

“We only need to get a small share of this very large market”

Re:Slack S-1 by inkaudio on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:09PM (#19760854)
Slack has some customers that are willing to pay, there are millions of people who use Slack for free, Slack needs to find a cost effective way to cover those expenses. Slack service is not remotely unique, their competitors both large and small are profitable ie Basecamp/Microsoft/Google
Re:Slack S-1 by baby on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:04PM (#19760251)
I’m pretty sure people are getting more and more used to uber, ditching their car or not looking to get a driver license. It is becoming an essential part of our lives and I use it way more today compared to years ago when rides used to cost close to 0$ Due to their promotions or agressive pricing.
Re:Slack S-1 by toasterlovin on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:10PM (#19760321)
Most people are extremely constrained by costs. Take out the VC money and Uber is a taxi company that is easier to use. Difficulty of use is part of the reason people didn’t use taxis all that much. But a huge part of the reason is that taxis are really, really expensive.
Re:Slack S-1 by kerng on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:44AM (#19769738)
I'm not sure... in the old school enterprise Microsoft might be crushing them long term with O365 bundling.
Re:Slack S-1 by raesene9 on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:09AM (#19757640)
I was with you on the first part, in other industries such a loss making company might have difficulties going public.

But lost you on the second part. It's not for the SEC (in my opinion) to police who can and can't go private in terms of how their busines is doing.

That's for investors to assess when deciding whether, or not, to buy shares.

The SEC's concerns should (again IMO) focus on whether the company seeking to IPO has been truthful in their prospectus. As long as they're not misleading investors, that's fine.

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:27AM (#19757848)
>That's for investors to assess when deciding whether, or not, to buy shares.

Yes for a public company...but it’s the SECs job to regulate who can have public offerings to begin with.

As I’ve iterated in the thread it’s not legal to publicly offer unregistered private stock to non-accredited investors and let them choose to invest or not. The SEC protects investors and our markets.

Re:Slack S-1 by dcosson on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:02AM (#19757565)
Don’t understand this take at all. The public is free to just not buy the stock if they don’t want.

You think the problem is that investors are leaving too much potential for growth on the table when companies IPO? They should wait even longer and keep more of that growth private?

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:11AM (#19757659)
I think a company going public should not operating at $150M losses using VC money...letting them cash out and profit by selling to the public.

I also think there are other fundamental benefits to the economy. Yes the public is free not to buy...just as non-accredited investors would be free not to invest in unregistered securities yet regulations are still in place for a reason to protect would be investors.

It doesn’t seem unreasonable that is your company operates at a $500,000,000.00 loss over 3 years you can’t avail yourself to the public market and sell your stock to non accredited investors.

Re:Slack S-1 by jdavis703 on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:18AM (#19757753)
I know people who are wealthy enough to be accredited investors. However I have way more financial literacy than some of these so-called accredited investors. That I’m forbidden from buying and selling certain assets only because I’m not rich enough (yet) really goes against the whole pull yourself up by your own bootstraps ideology.
Re:Slack S-1 by ska on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#19759929)
The pull yourself up by your bootstraps stuff isn't the issue here, it's risk management.

Accreditation is not in place to define who is informed and smart enough to make the investments, it is defining who can afford to take the loss, and who at least has the resources to do it properly.

Re:Slack S-1 by dcosson on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:10PM (#19760308)
There are lots of other ways for people with limited money to lose it, and there always will be. Casinos, lottery tickets, credit card debt, frivolous purchases, etc.

I can’t think of any reasonable argument why allowing a free-thinking adult to, say, put a bit of savings into a friend or relative’s new startup is so much worse than the rest of these that it needs to be illegal.

Re:Slack S-1 by ska on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:21PM (#19760424)
It's the imbalance of power. I don't think accreditation is perfect, but it is fairly reasonable. It is really, really easy to take advantage of naive investors.

Sure, there are probably examples of sophisticated investors who don't meet the criteria. But the numbers are tiny, and probably much smaller than the numbers who think they are, but are in fact not.

Don't forget, you are still allowed to lose your life savings at "regular" investing. And Casinos have different regulations constraining their ability to fool punters...

Accreditation was introduced as risk management, after all. Any time you do something like that you can have a few outliers who are negatively affected. But if the policy is basically sound, overall it is a net win. I think that is the case with accreditation. It's not there to stop you from investing $10k in your friends startup. It's to stop companies from bilking $10k from thousands and thousands of people. Could your friends & family case stand to be eased up a bit? Probably. Does it account for much in the overall scheme. Probably not.

Bear in mind the difference between intent and efficacy. All of the things you mention also have regulation or legislative constraints that in theory are also supposed to make it harder for people to naively get themselves in trouble. Why should investment be different?

For what it's worth, I also think it should be easier to invest small amounts in higher risk ventures - but that counterbalance should be to put limits on the structuring those ventures are allowed to do in order to offer it. Keep everything relatively simple and transparent, keep the terms and structure easy to understand without having to pay a decent lawyer 2k every time to review...

Re:Slack S-1 by freewilly1040 on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:24AM (#19758471)
Well there people who disagree and would like to invest in them. Why should your opinion be forced on them?
[dead]
Re:Slack S-1 by throwawaymath on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:17PM (#19759730)
Okay why not, I'll take the bait.

> There are people who want to invest in ICOs, Ponzi schemes

Ponzi schemes are fraudulent operations intrinsically designed to extract money from investors by misleading them. Slack is a software company with a cogent, well-defined plan to leverage unprofitability now into significantly greater profitability later. Not only are these things meaningfully different, they're categorically incomparable.

Even if Slack ultimately fails it has a reasonable plan of action that distinguishes it from fraud. The SEC does not exist to eliminate all risk from investor portfolios, that's impossible (and suboptimal!). It exists to (among other things) ensure the risk to investor capital occurs through the normal procedure of markets instead of outright fraud. For similar reasons most ICOs (and particularly fraudulent ones) are categorically dissimilar from a tech company going public at a net loss.

> others want to rape, murder...why should anyone’s opinions be forced on these people?

I can't believe I have to say this, but the two things you described are violent acts with directly violate the rights of other human beings. I'm not sure how much else needs to be said here. We started off at people being allowed to engage in risky but fundamentally legal and mundane investments, and ended up at fraud, rape and murder. Somewhere along the way we've gotten quite lost.

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:31PM (#19759891)
My comment is not in a vacuum it’s a direct response to a comment that suggest regulation of a thing is improper because “people want to do it”. Your point is directly in line with mine...we can regulate things notwithstanding “people wanting to do it.” And that is not a reason to not regulate a thing, if people don’t agree with the merits of the proposed regulation, fine, but I think we both agree “because people want to do it” is not a reason to not regulate something.

I’m not saying slack is a fraud...I’m not even saying it’s a bad investment. People have read all that in to a concept.

Re:Slack S-1 by freewilly1040 on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:53AM (#19758812)
ICO’s and Ponzi scheme involve misrepresentations to the investor and/or theft
Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#19759927)
But you agree people still want to invest in them right? I think ICO proved that there is a market for known fraud/pump and dumps, you may think you can get in and out and make a buck because a bunch of morons don’t see the fraud.
Re:Slack S-1 by EpicEng on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:07PM (#19761311)
>But you agree people still want to invest in them right

No... people may want to invest in them because they are being actively mislead. You can't just ignore the fraud aspect, it literally makes all the difference.

Re:Slack S-1 by blotter_paper on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:47PM (#19759421)
#NotAllICOs
Re:Slack S-1 by ssnistfajen on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:16PM (#19760374)
To sell to the public requires someone willing to purchase the shares first. That's how the market works. If someone invests in Slack despite the conitnued losses, it means they see value in the company based on existing metrics.

Barring companies from public listings based on some arbitrary numerical threshold is very unreasonable. Even more so when only the losses are emphasized in your previous comments while ignoring the revenue growth. That alone creates a very one-sided and biased view of Slack's financial situation.

Re:Slack S-1 by mbesto on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:45AM (#19758047)
> I think to balance the playing field with VC and private investment, companies shouldn’t be able to IPO with loses.

If the investing community really thought this was a bad idea then these companies wouldn't IPO. Especially after the lessons learned from 2000.

Look, I get that people want to shit on unprofitable tech businesses, but in case you haven't noticed, investors absolutely love the financials on these companies. Why? Because their cashflows generate insanely strong tailwind effects.

I strongly urge anyone who likes shitting on to read what Bezos says on his earnings calls about earnings vs cash flow, or read Tren Griffin's blog.[0]

Good example...look at FB's FCF - https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/fb/financials/ca...

[0] - https://25iq.com/2014/04/26/a-dozen-things-i-have-learned-fr...

Re:Slack S-1 by rayiner on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:12AM (#19757682)
Is there any other industry where developing an instant messaging system can result in $500 million in losses despite $700 million in revenue?
Re:Slack S-1 by akincisor on Friday April 26, 2019 @06:06PM (#19762168)
Funnily enough, when I do design interviews, I often ask them to design a chat client - not the whole design, but bits and pieces, like the db schema or the API of the service.

What the interviews invariably show is that a chat client is not simple. It's extremely complicated, especially when you want it to work at scale. If you think it's a "simple" app, go ahead, try to make one - even on a whiteboard.

I can completely understand why instant messaging can get you $700 million in revenue. As for the losses -- they are invested in the future of the company and I think are justified.

"How hard can it be?" is something we ask about "simple" stuff everyday, and the answer if you dig deeper is almost always "Much harder than you think."

Re:Slack S-1 by dd36 on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:42PM (#19759372)
My thought as well. What on earth about Slack costs hundreds of millions to operate?
Re:Slack S-1 by mbesto on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:52PM (#19760105)
Guess what? You can actually see in an S-1 what it costs.

S&M = $233,191 for 2019

More than half their revenue is spent acquiring new customers...which, with a high likelihood, will net revenue over a N+1 year timeframe. This is an investors wet dream... I pay $1 now and I only need $.15 to operate that $1 every year for the next 7 years...that's a helluva return.

In other words...you can turn off the S&M tap and these companies could be profitable almost overnight.

Re:Slack S-1 by Spivak on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:20PM (#19760407)
I think your point still stands but some of that S&M can never be cut because of churn and is highly susceptible to interference from competitors.

Slack doesn't have that much lock-in and a lot of people have their sights on that market -- "Cheaper than Slack and bundled with Office365/G Suite" is an extremely tempting offer.

Re:Slack S-1 by TheGRS on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:38PM (#19760592)
Maybe, so far I've been in a few situations where we didn't go with Slack...only to go back to Slack. Part of the lock-in is their brilliant multi-org client. I can easily go back-and-forth between my company, a contract's IM, an alumni group of people in my last job and a group of local artists that like to talk to each other. Hell I've thought about luring most of my close friends from Facebook onto Slack.

Their API is also quite good IMO, which provides a sort of lock-in, though not a huge one.

Re:Slack S-1 by sjy on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:59AM (#19764776)
Do all your contacts work in the tech industry? I'm wondering if we're really backwards here in Australia, or if I've just had bad experiences. Slack-style messaging seems really uncommon outside tech, even though traditional AIM-style IM is used everywhere. I think a lot of enterprises could benefit from capturing corporate knowledge in searchable Slack channels, but the only teams I see using them are doing IT and software.
Re:Slack S-1 by bspn on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:18PM (#19768698)
> Part of the lock-in is their brilliant multi-org client

While not quite as fully-featured as Slack, Keybase offers this. I'm a member of multiple orgs and seamlessly change between conversations (both group and 1-on-1).

Re:Slack S-1 by rorykoehler on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:59PM (#19763300)
From my experience slack also has negative churn. People get used to it and automatically choose it the next time. You are correct about potential threats though.
Re:Slack S-1 by dd36 on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:11PM (#19761771)
What R&D does slack do to the tune of hundreds of millions per year?!? What G&A is over a hundred million a year? Do you use Slack?

Yes, they have a boatload of fat to trim. They can pull an Etsy move but is that not already baked into their valuation? I, frankly, don't care enough to look as I won't be investing. I just cannot believe their VC investors let them get that bloated - it's probably why they're pushing for an exit so fast. I also am not convinced Slack is very sticky. We switched to Mattermost last week and miss nothing about Slack.

Moreover, as I said in another comment: If there is all this money left to be made, why are their investors pushing them to go public? They should be riding that gravy train privately and cashing out a few years from now for 10x more...

Re:Slack S-1 by rorykoehler on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:02PM (#19763305)
The stickiness comes from the switching costs. We have so many integrations and while setting them up again isn't insurmountable it's a great example of unproductive busy work. Why bother?
Re:Slack S-1 by dd36 on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:16PM (#19763363)
Because you have thousands of employees and it gets expensive. It’s a luxury not a necessity and in leaner times, it’s easy to switch to something equivalent but free.
Re:Slack S-1 by acchow on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:56PM (#19763481)
> S&M = $233,191 for 2019 More than half their revenue is spent acquiring new customers...

This isn't a consumer product. They're not doing magazine and television ads. Why is S&M so expensive?

Re:Slack S-1 by dmoy on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:09PM (#19759654)
This is literally described in the S-1.

A large plurality of it is sales & marketing. The next biggest chunk is R&D.

Re:Slack S-1 by dd36 on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:21PM (#19761843)
Right. What R&D is slack doing that requires hundreds of millions of dollars? Or G&A? No wonder their investors are cashing out. They see that there are limits else they'd keep riding this as a private company.
Re:Slack S-1 by geodel on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:22PM (#19759787)
They need to pay about ~2000 employees including multiple hundred engineers who regularly yap about another JS/Electron stunt they pulled today.
Re:Slack S-1 by omarchowdhury on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:13PM (#19759686)
SF tech company salaries.
Re:Slack S-1 by theWheez on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:26PM (#19759829)
Acquiring more users!
Re:Slack S-1 by wbl on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:58AM (#19757517)
The SEC fundamentally believes it's ok to lose money investing. It's up to you to assess the investments and decide where to put your money.
Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:07AM (#19757617)
That’s not the point/issue though. The markets are regulated to protect consumers/investors...private companies can’t just have unregistered public offerings to non accredited investors...so it’s not just “up to you to assess the investments” there are rules and nothing is stopping additional rules to not permit registration of a public offering when the company is operating at a $150,000,000.00 annual loss or more to the point any loss.

Obviously not a popular idea here where everyone is trying to get in early and dump the bag on someone else, but that’s kinda the point of protections, some people won’t like them.

Re:Slack S-1 by ghaff on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:15AM (#19757715)
It's not an unreasonable position. To the annoyance of many here, for example, there are investments that are limited to high net worth individuals. It's not that big of a stretch to imagine additional regulations (whether from the SEC, the major exchanges, or a combination thereof) on which companies are allowed to go public.
Re:Slack S-1 by blantonl on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:12AM (#19757686)
It's not a popular idea here because:

  Capital is extremely cheap
  Markets are at record highs
  FOMO in tech right now is extremely strong 
I can't wait to see the sentiment in two years.
Re:Slack S-1 by icedchai on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:55AM (#19758162)
The question is... right now, is it more like 1995 or 2001?
Re:Slack S-1 by plankers on Saturday April 27, 2019 @07:18AM (#19764959)
People said bitcoin was a bubble. Can't wait to see the excuses and rationalizations when this one pops.
Re:Slack S-1 by icedchai on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:58AM (#19765837)
Yes, it will pop... but timing the market is impossible. We may have a good 4 to 5 more years of this.
Re:Slack S-1 by omarchowdhury on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:08PM (#19759647)
That can only be answered in hindsight.
Re:Slack S-1 by the_watcher on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:45AM (#19758048)
The rules are about what information is disclosed. The difference is that with public companies, there are rules about what actually gets disclosed and how often. That's why the general public is allowed to invest. It's about how much information is available, not what that information actually is. Investors need to determine whether or not they invest.

In no world is the SEC's role to determine whether or not a company's business strategy qualifies them to go public or not. That would be an absolute disaster.

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:39AM (#19758643)
>In no world is the SEC's role to determine whether or not a company's business strategy qualifies them to go public or not.

Profitability is objective...let’s not pretend what I’m suggesting is the SEC subjectively making a decision on a business judgement or business plan. Simply you want to register a security for public offering show a GAAP profit...I understand that’s not “how it works” or I wouldn’t have suggested it “should” be considered, I never said anything about SEC subjectively determining worthiness of an investment.

Re:Slack S-1 by askafriend on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:07PM (#19759635)
Their business is doing extremely well. They can turn on profitability any time they want.

As an investor, I would not want them to turn a profit at this stage with so much headroom left, especially internationally.

If they choose to go for profitability this early on, then I take it as a negative signal.

Profit is too simple of a number to focus on. It doesn’t tell any kind of story by itself. But it’s a tempting number to latch onto.

Re:Slack S-1 by EpicEng on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:14PM (#19761356)
You realize that you can very easily be proven wrong, right?

Amazon was "losing" more money in each year leading up to their IPO. By your logic we all should have been protected from investing in this obvious scam of a company, right? If you could go back in time and dump money into Amazon stock, would you?

Of course you would, because profitability is obviously too simplistic a measure to gate companies from going public. Also, the SEC isn't my nanny and I'm capable of reading an S1 to make my own decision. You seem to have an incredibly narrow understanding of the economics behind these companies.

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:43PM (#19762021)
>By your logic we all should have been protected from investing in this obvious scam of a company, right?

Based on my logic? I never said slack/uber/Lyft are scams, I even admit they may be good investments when they IPO...I even said profitability is not the full picture.

I never said the SEC was your nanny, I never said you couldn’t read an S-1...though based on your assertions I have to question you reading comprehension.

Maybe you could give me a comprehensive breakdown of how the market would be different if amazon did have to post profit before IPO, since you are so sure we would all be worse off...even non investors. Are investors, public markets and private markets really all better off? Is it possible amazon wouldn’t dominate and there be other companies competing in the space? Better jobs even more investment opportunites? I don’t think you could answer any of those questions with certainty.

Re:Slack S-1 by briandear on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:45PM (#19761132)
So if you want to fundraise, you must be profitable? If that’s the case, what’s the point of fundraising? A lemonade stand is more profitable than Slack, but the upside potential for Slack is vastly greater. So showing a GAAP profit suggests that a lemonade stand is more valuable and worthy of an investment than Slack?

Should Tesla be delisted? How about Amazon? They didn’t make a profit for the majority of their existence. GAAP profits as a condition of listing is just ridiculous. Almost all green energy companies lose money, so what you seem to be implying is that the public shouldn’t be allowed to invest in the Teslas of the world because they aren’t profitable?

An IPO is a fundraising event. That’s all. If we are to say that no company should be able to fundraise if they have loses, then very, very few companies would ever have access to capital. An IPO isn’t an endorsement by the SEC, not should it be.

Re:Slack S-1 by wbl on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:01PM (#19758925)
Why shouldn't public investors be allowed to support ventures that won't show a profit for a while? Think drug discovery oil drilling etc.
Re:Slack S-1 by wbl on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:04PM (#19761291)
The investors see the big number in the first table of the S-1. What more do you want?
Re:Slack S-1 by spullara on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:50PM (#19760692)
While you are still explosively growing reducing sales and marketing spend doesn't make a lot of sense. It allows competitors who out spend you to catch up. Instead you should analyze SaaS businesses by the "Rule of 40":

https://saasholic.com/the-rule-of-40-for-saas-and-subscripti...

For Slack, if they grew 84% and their profit was -35% they are well above a net of 40 with 49. It is pretty easy to see that if Slack stopped spending on sales & marketing and stopped growing engineering they would be massively profitable. Instead, they should get as big as they can as fast as they can as most markets are becoming winner take all.

Re:Slack S-1 by troydavis on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:08PM (#19759644)
> they can’t turn a profit, and for any hope to turn profit they need this continual growth at a loss, and at some point the investors dump the bag on the public getting a return in a bubble they created and let the public fund the losses.

Could you provide some data to show that companies which, at IPO, have any cumulative loss or a very large cumulative loss (as a percentage of valuation or offering size), perform worse as investments or as going concerns?

From your other comments, it seems like the foundation of your proposed change is that going public with significant losses is an attempt to get less-sophisticated investors to compensate more-sophisticated investors.

While there are many arguments against your proposed change, the first step seems to be establishing that the problem you’re trying to solve actually exists. I’m not convinced that it does (but don’t have data either way - that’s just anecdotal), and in fact many - maybe most - institutional investors in private companies continue to hold post-IPO shares long after the lockup (and gradually sell over 1-3 years simply to diversify).

As you investigate this, it might be worth reading about the “CAC payback period” and how it can lead to significant upfront losses: https://baremetrics.com/academy/cac-payback-period, https://kellblog.com/2016/03/17/cac-payback-period-the-most-...

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:17PM (#19759729)
>While there are many arguments against your proposed change, the first step seems to be establishing that the problem you’re trying to solve actually exists.

It’s clear not many here care to understand the problem, tech generally loves a good pump and dump...look at all the recent tech IPOs... how many of those were boot strapped vs VC backed? And VC backed tech IPOs were in the black?

It’s not about investor risk...its About leveling the playing field.

Again everyone here is screaming investor risk/their choice/don’t have to buy...I don’t see anyone advocating allowing small investors to get in on unicorn tech cos pre IPO. I’m not sure why everyone is pretending it’s about giving opportunity to the little guy...it’s about the need for VC to liquidate.

Re:Slack S-1 by chmod775 on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:38AM (#19757974)
Look closely at their revenue vs. their losses.

They could have been profitable in most years just by not increasing spending - which is entirely possible in their industry. Their expenses aren't really a function of the amount of customers they have.

So they consciously chose to not be profitable to grow their business instead (as they stated).

It's not like they couldn't be profitable if they wanted to.

Their business actually looks to be in an amazing shape.

Re:Slack S-1 by akiselev on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:43PM (#19761112)
Yes. Biotechnology and pharmaceuticals. It's relatively common for companies to IPO while they're still in clinical trials, which by definition means they can't earn any revenue (unless they sell some IP or research oriented products like biological models/reagents/etc to other pharma/biotech researchers on the side).

Tech companies with actual revenue have a step up in that regard.

Re:Slack S-1 by aaavl2821 on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:44PM (#19760642)
In biotech, most companies go public without any prospect of revenue for years. But these tech companies are actually burning more money pre-IPO than biotech companies -- the ~50 biotech startups that went public from 2018-Q1 2019 raised $150-180M in VC pre-IPO

However, in biotech these days, an IPO is a funding event, not just an exit. On average biotech companies that IPO do so ~3 years after Series A. Average post-money of recent biotech IPOs is $754M, and 20% see their share price double in the year after IPO. Many of these companies raise additional cash in the public markets before they are acquired. So in biotech, public offerings are analogous to late stage VC / growth rounds in tech, and IPOs in tech are more akin to M&A exits in biotech (although big M&A exits in biotech are actually happening faster than big IPO exits in tech)

Source is analysis I did of SEC filings: https://www.baybridgebio.com/blog/ipo_2018_q12019.html

Re:Slack S-1 by veritas20 on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:50PM (#19759463)
I think that your intentions are good, but approach may be off a bit. I agree that the SEC does protect investors and markets, but I do not agree that a company should be in the black before they IPO.

I think that your main concern is the public market funding VC capital returns. If so, then a more reasonable approach to prevent public market exploitation may be to require a lock up period for investors for a certain amount of time (not sure how you would determine this...) similar to how employees are often beholden to lock up periods post IPO.

Re:Slack S-1 by bryanmgreen on Friday April 26, 2019 @08:08PM (#19762841)
Two points:

1) I am 100% in alignment that companies should NOT IPO with losses. With no evidence or education to back on this, I'll just say I feel the opportunity for non-professional investors to put money into such unstable companies is an enormous risk - not just for themselves, but the economy as a whole. Maybe there needs to be a separate market for loss-leader investing.

2) With SAAS companies in particular, adjusting for profit can be easy and it boggles my mind they don't know this or are too egotistical to believe they should.

Slack's pricing model is way too expensive and their 1:6 Paid-to-Unpaid user ratio is evidence of that. They could easily merge their two paid tiers so paid accounts have a fuller product offering than the free version AND drop the price. If they convert half of their non-paid users through pricing adjustments they could be making a PROFIT without adding any additional expense.

Re:Slack S-1 by rorykoehler on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:04PM (#19763311)
If they did 2)it would muddy their metrics and design feedback loops. The way it is now they can better understand their power users
Re:Slack S-1 by azernik on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:25PM (#19760980)
Fast growth skews all of those numbers, because there's a lag between marketing/sales spending and the ensuing revenue - especially for SaaS businesses where revenue is subscription-based, and typically trickles in over a period of years.

To figure out the long-term sustainability of a business, you therefore have to compare spending, revenue, revenue growth, and churn rate (or a more complicated measure which Slack is using in this filing, Net Dollar Retention Rate) in complicated formulas that I don't know off the top of my head.

(Net Dollar Retention Rate over time is one of their three "Key Business Metrics", reflecting its importance in determining steady-state viability.)

Re:Slack S-1 by pbreit on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:25PM (#19760976)
Your question exhibits a lack of understanding of 1) IPOs (they are fundraising events) and 2) software (zero marginal costs = massive leverage).

Slack, Uber and Lyft can ==EASILY== turn a profit by slowing growth.

Re:Slack S-1 by kgwgk on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:24PM (#19761876)
Note that Slack's "IPO" is not a fundraising event and Uber and Lyft have marginal costs which are far from zero. (I'm not sure Slack is a "software" company, but Uber and Lyft definitely are not.)
Re:Slack S-1 by pbreit on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:56AM (#19764037)
While Slack's IPO is very unique, it is indeed raising money. Uber & Lyft book driver incentives as marginal costs but that's about it. Of course they are all software companies.
Re:Slack S-1 by kgwgk on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:13AM (#19764469)
From the S-1:

"USE OF PROCEEDS

Registered Stockholders may, or may not, elect to sell shares of our Class A common stock covered by this prospectus. To the extent any Registered Stockholder chooses to sell shares of our Class A common stock covered by this prospectus, we will not receive any proceeds from any such sales of our Class A common stock."

From Uber's S1:

"Cost of revenue, exclusive of depreciation and amortization, consists primarily of Core Platform insurance expenses, credit card processing fees, hosting and co-located data center expenses, mobile device and service expenses, amounts related to fare chargebacks and other credit card losses, excess Driver incentives, and costs incurred with carriers for Uber Freight transportation. Core Platform insurance expenses include coverage for auto liability, general liability, uninsured and underinsured motorist liability, and auto physical damage related to our Ridesharing products and Uber Eats offering. Excess Driver incentives are primarily related to our Ridesharing products in emerging markets and our Uber Eats offering. [...] As trips increase, we expect related increases for insurance costs, credit card processing fees, hosting and co-located data center expenses, and other cost of revenue, exclusive of depreciation and amortization, categories."

Cost of revenue was in 2018 $5.6bn (out of $11.3bn of revenue). The also provide "adjusted net revenue" excluding among other things excess Driver incentives and Driver referrals: in that case the cost of revenue is $4.3bn out of $10bn.

Uber's gross margin is below 60%.

Re:Slack S-1 by TheSoftwareGuy on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:14PM (#19760887)
It's well known that you have to spend money to make money, as they say.

No investor worth their salt simply looks at past profits and decides right then and there whether a company is a good investment, because past performance alone does not predict future performance.

You have to look at the business and economic landscape, think about the business model and make a calculation about how compatible they are. This is especially important for companies recently founded.

Re:Slack S-1 by briandear on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:23PM (#19760961)
Public or private ownership has no relevance to profitability. If a VC can invest in a “losing” company, how is that any different than allowing public markets to do the same? The loss is priced into the stock and with a “losing” stock there is opportunity for upside just as much as a “winning” stock — the public ought to be allowed to be allowed to have a piece of that opportunity just as readily as private markets.
Re:Slack S-1 by arcticbull on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:27AM (#19763777)
While I'm sympathetic to your argument in general, a Slack-type company is very different from Uber and Lyft because the former is effectively zero marginal cost. It's much more the classic Silicon Valley type software company. Uber and Lyft are very much not zero marginal cost businesses.
Re:Slack S-1 by baccheion on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:19PM (#19759757)
IPOs were historically done by unprofitable companies to raise funds. It's like seeking out VCs for another round of funding, but it's instead the public. Now, it's usually done to give insiders an exit.

What future growth would there be for buyers if the company went public already at its peak?

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:37PM (#19759958)
>What future growth would there be for buyers if the company went public already at its peak?

I never said anything about peak. I said profit. Certainly a company making profit may want to go public to finance growth to make more profit (ie peak).

IPOs/stock companies were not created for companies that were unprofitable.

Re:Slack S-1 by cortesoft on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:50PM (#19762070)
If a company is profitable, but there is a benefit to spending more money to grow faster, why wouldn't that company spend that profit to grow? If you believe growing the business is a good use of investor money, then wouldn't you also believe it is a good use of your profit?
Re:Slack S-1 by baccheion on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:17PM (#19772305)
It makes sense, but people do all sorts of things for many reasons or no reason.

New growth would have to be sustainable "indefinitely" or they'd have to worry about replacing it. In addition, even more revenue growth is then required to maintain the higher market cap.

Re:Slack S-1 by baccheion on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:05PM (#19760263)
If growth rate continues as they project, buyers get a larger future bump/multiplier.

What makes you say that? Proof? It was historically used to raise more funding to fuel growth, a function VCs can now fill (ie, then it would be likely to have a VC provide the larger sums required). Though VCs can fill such a gap, IPOs give insiders an exit.

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:50PM (#19762069)
>Proof?

It’s your assertion show me proof IPOs are for “unprofitable companies”.

Re:Slack S-1 by ummonk on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:59AM (#19758891)
>But if the company could turn a profit, then why not do it privately, show that and then go public?

Because their investors and employees want liquidity, and public investors want in on the pie. There isn't some rule that says companies can only public once they've stopped growing rapidly.

Re:Slack S-1 by moorhosj on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:41AM (#19758006)
This depends on what you mean by “industry”. If Uber and Lyft are transportation companies, Snapchat is a media company and Tesla is a car company, than there are multiple industries. If you think of all those companies as “tech” than, no.
Re:Slack S-1 by ddebernardy on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:47PM (#19761150)
I suspect there aren't many other industries where a company can go from zero to a $1.6Bn exit in a year and a half (YouTube) -- while losing money, no less. Or from zero to a $19Bn exit in 5 years (WhatsApp).
Re:Slack S-1 by idlewords on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:28PM (#19761454)
In most industries, after such a financial performance you exit quite rapidly in a different direction.
Re:Slack S-1 by dalbasal on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:26PM (#19759194)
..supply and demand. Theres demand for extremely high growth companies, especially if they seem to have a some path to profitability. Private investor demand, and public market/IPO demand too.
Re:Slack S-1 by matchagaucho on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:04PM (#19759609)
Investors are warming up to the SaaS/cloud model.

They see the losses as an acceptable customer acquisition cost for recurring revenue.

Speaking from personal experience, CLV for a Slack customer is 3+ years.

Re:Slack S-1 by diminoten on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:44PM (#19760641)
Because the company can't turn a profit until/unless it has access to the capital a public offering provides.

Think of companies more like hydrofoils on lava than like barges.

Re:Slack S-1 by blobbers on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:45PM (#19761131)
I think the bigger question is why they're losing so much money - from an operating perspective I'd expect costs to be really low.
Re:Slack S-1 by microdrum on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:13PM (#19761785)
There are tons of such industries. Medicine is one.
Re:Slack S-1 by ikarandeep on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:12PM (#19759056)
a lot of venture funds have a 10 year timeframe