News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack S-1 by dcosson on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:02AM (#19757565)
Don’t understand this take at all. The public is free to just not buy the stock if they don’t want.

You think the problem is that investors are leaving too much potential for growth on the table when companies IPO? They should wait even longer and keep more of that growth private?

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:11AM (#19757659)
I think a company going public should not operating at $150M losses using VC money...letting them cash out and profit by selling to the public.

I also think there are other fundamental benefits to the economy. Yes the public is free not to buy...just as non-accredited investors would be free not to invest in unregistered securities yet regulations are still in place for a reason to protect would be investors.

It doesn’t seem unreasonable that is your company operates at a $500,000,000.00 loss over 3 years you can’t avail yourself to the public market and sell your stock to non accredited investors.

Re:Slack S-1 by jdavis703 on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:18AM (#19757753)
I know people who are wealthy enough to be accredited investors. However I have way more financial literacy than some of these so-called accredited investors. That I’m forbidden from buying and selling certain assets only because I’m not rich enough (yet) really goes against the whole pull yourself up by your own bootstraps ideology.
Re:Slack S-1 by ska on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#19759929)
The pull yourself up by your bootstraps stuff isn't the issue here, it's risk management.

Accreditation is not in place to define who is informed and smart enough to make the investments, it is defining who can afford to take the loss, and who at least has the resources to do it properly.

Re:Slack S-1 by dcosson on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:10PM (#19760308)
There are lots of other ways for people with limited money to lose it, and there always will be. Casinos, lottery tickets, credit card debt, frivolous purchases, etc.

I can’t think of any reasonable argument why allowing a free-thinking adult to, say, put a bit of savings into a friend or relative’s new startup is so much worse than the rest of these that it needs to be illegal.

Re:Slack S-1 by ska on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:21PM (#19760424)
It's the imbalance of power. I don't think accreditation is perfect, but it is fairly reasonable. It is really, really easy to take advantage of naive investors.

Sure, there are probably examples of sophisticated investors who don't meet the criteria. But the numbers are tiny, and probably much smaller than the numbers who think they are, but are in fact not.

Don't forget, you are still allowed to lose your life savings at "regular" investing. And Casinos have different regulations constraining their ability to fool punters...

Accreditation was introduced as risk management, after all. Any time you do something like that you can have a few outliers who are negatively affected. But if the policy is basically sound, overall it is a net win. I think that is the case with accreditation. It's not there to stop you from investing $10k in your friends startup. It's to stop companies from bilking $10k from thousands and thousands of people. Could your friends & family case stand to be eased up a bit? Probably. Does it account for much in the overall scheme. Probably not.

Bear in mind the difference between intent and efficacy. All of the things you mention also have regulation or legislative constraints that in theory are also supposed to make it harder for people to naively get themselves in trouble. Why should investment be different?

For what it's worth, I also think it should be easier to invest small amounts in higher risk ventures - but that counterbalance should be to put limits on the structuring those ventures are allowed to do in order to offer it. Keep everything relatively simple and transparent, keep the terms and structure easy to understand without having to pay a decent lawyer 2k every time to review...

Re:Slack S-1 by freewilly1040 on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:24AM (#19758471)
Well there people who disagree and would like to invest in them. Why should your opinion be forced on them?
[dead]
Re:Slack S-1 by throwawaymath on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:17PM (#19759730)
Okay why not, I'll take the bait.

> There are people who want to invest in ICOs, Ponzi schemes

Ponzi schemes are fraudulent operations intrinsically designed to extract money from investors by misleading them. Slack is a software company with a cogent, well-defined plan to leverage unprofitability now into significantly greater profitability later. Not only are these things meaningfully different, they're categorically incomparable.

Even if Slack ultimately fails it has a reasonable plan of action that distinguishes it from fraud. The SEC does not exist to eliminate all risk from investor portfolios, that's impossible (and suboptimal!). It exists to (among other things) ensure the risk to investor capital occurs through the normal procedure of markets instead of outright fraud. For similar reasons most ICOs (and particularly fraudulent ones) are categorically dissimilar from a tech company going public at a net loss.

> others want to rape, murder...why should anyone’s opinions be forced on these people?

I can't believe I have to say this, but the two things you described are violent acts with directly violate the rights of other human beings. I'm not sure how much else needs to be said here. We started off at people being allowed to engage in risky but fundamentally legal and mundane investments, and ended up at fraud, rape and murder. Somewhere along the way we've gotten quite lost.

Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:31PM (#19759891)
My comment is not in a vacuum it’s a direct response to a comment that suggest regulation of a thing is improper because “people want to do it”. Your point is directly in line with mine...we can regulate things notwithstanding “people wanting to do it.” And that is not a reason to not regulate a thing, if people don’t agree with the merits of the proposed regulation, fine, but I think we both agree “because people want to do it” is not a reason to not regulate something.

I’m not saying slack is a fraud...I’m not even saying it’s a bad investment. People have read all that in to a concept.

Re:Slack S-1 by freewilly1040 on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:53AM (#19758812)
ICO’s and Ponzi scheme involve misrepresentations to the investor and/or theft
Re:Slack S-1 by will_brown on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#19759927)
But you agree people still want to invest in them right? I think ICO proved that there is a market for known fraud/pump and dumps, you may think you can get in and out and make a buck because a bunch of morons don’t see the fraud.
Re:Slack S-1 by EpicEng on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:07PM (#19761311)
>But you agree people still want to invest in them right

No... people may want to invest in them because they are being actively mislead. You can't just ignore the fraud aspect, it literally makes all the difference.

Re:Slack S-1 by blotter_paper on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:47PM (#19759421)
#NotAllICOs
Re:Slack S-1 by ssnistfajen on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:16PM (#19760374)
To sell to the public requires someone willing to purchase the shares first. That's how the market works. If someone invests in Slack despite the conitnued losses, it means they see value in the company based on existing metrics.

Barring companies from public listings based on some arbitrary numerical threshold is very unreasonable. Even more so when only the losses are emphasized in your previous comments while ignoring the revenue growth. That alone creates a very one-sided and biased view of Slack's financial situation.