- The economic strangulation of entire neighborhoods
- Disrupted access to health care and educational opportunities
- Disrupted access to one's place of employment (for a great many people)
- All of these disproportionately affecting, you know... lower income folks (and not so coincidentally, communities of color).
- The spillover affect of all of the above on the regional economy as a whole (and hence -- on tax revenues available to the same governments who need to fund this construction in the first place).
Stuff like that.
These are all valid concerns but taken together and they prevent anything from getting done. Good intentions, bad results.
Just not a "crazy" one.
Can't redevelop lower Manhattan because everything between Houston and 30th is a "historical building".
You know perfectly well this isn't true. Not even half of the lots in that area meet that description.
The main reason you "can't" just rip up and re-develop Lower Manhattan is... it's already one of the most sensibly built places on the planet - and so "redeveloping" anything beyond selected corners of it would basically be pretty stupid.
Oh and plus the fact that it's already owned and the land is like really expensive and stuff.
local governments are powerless.
Also nowhere near true, but whatever.
What? Almost everything between Midtown and Downtown is a 4-5 story walkup, how is that ideal? It's why they're redeveloping old office buildings in the Financial District to be apartments -- it's one of the few spots in lower Manhattan that allow high density housing.
> You know perfectly well this isn't true. Not even half of the lots in that area meet that description.
I was being slightly hyperbolic but the effect is the same. The strict height/density restrictions are intended to preserve the "historic" neighborhoods.
Central Paris has a residential density higher than NYC despite composed almost entirely of 4-5 story mixed use walkups. There are lots of reasons that this is a pretty ideal, human scale existence.
Those 4-5 story walkups in the East Village have a population density of 113,000 per square mile. If a half of NYC had the same density, our population could be 16 million people which is 2x the total population in NYC.
If the greater NY metro area (13,000 sq mi) had the density of 4-5 story walkups in the East Village we could house 1.5 BILLION people or many times the entire population of the United States. Of course all of this assumes linear scaling which is entirely inaccurate but the point is that 4-5 story walkup density is entirely sufficient to meet housing needs.
The challenge is getting other neighborhoods to 4-5 story walkup equivalent density.
4-5 stories (at 2-4 apartments per) is quite good density, actually.
And it's what you'd call a tradeoff, not a one-way restriction.
>Not when it's artificially restricting supply
Wrong. You are neglecting the very non-artificial fact that bedrock depth has always been the main limiting factor for that part of Manhattan between Midtown and FiDi, or more so that its only because of the uniquely solid and deep bedrock under FiDi and Midtown that skyscrapers exist here at all. If they could have built skyscrapers there, they would have. As building technology permits, gradually, they are. Regardless, the housing that does exist is simply not as you describe. When was the last time you spent any time in New York?
>It's good density for a mid-size city, terrible for a city as large (and growing) as New York.
The area we are talking about, between FiDi and Midtown, holds over 250k housing units for close to half a million people. 75% of those units feature 20 or more units. That's a range of about 100-150 people per acre. Manhattan overall contains 70k residents per square mile, across all boroughs its 27k per sq. mile, the highest density in America. That's not including office space, or the daily working and visiting population which is easily double that. Even Brooklyn has over 3x the density of Chicago and almost as many people. Its not Tokyo, but it sure as heck isn't Indianapolis, not even close...
Btw, we aren't ants. Quality of life is a thing and building density not to mention aesthetics and history are huge factors to the desirability and livability of the city. Go to Hong Kong if you want to live in a cage with 20 other people to a room in some modern-industrial neo-commie-block. You are basically picking on the only parts of the city with any actual character or beauty that anybody with a clue would want to live or visit and saying they should be destroyed because you ignorantly think that the most densely populated city in the country needs more housing density? Talk about artificial factors.
You don't just seize and destroy neighborhoods that have been thriving and integrated for 150+ years, like the East Village for example. Which seems to be what you're proposing.
(BTW I say "seize" because what you're proposing would never happen alone on any significant scale without eminent domain).
How so? Landlords would jump to sell their rent-controlled buildings to developers who are champing at the bit. City programs are the only thing preventing development from happening.
This is wishful thinking, on a number of fronts.
For example one does not simply "sell" (meaning, in the context of proposed redevelopment: purge all the tenants from) a rent-controlled building in NYC. Or even an existing coop or condo building, for example.
As you go beyond 5 stories the construction methods required to support the building change. (this obviously is an engineering consideration, you can get a little higher with good engineering). Thus this is ideal because you cannot get denser without increasing the costs to residents. For the poor a small apartment in a 5 story building is as cheap as you can get (this is just equal share fixed costs and ignores supply/demand, taxes, and all the other considerations that go into rent prices). We can build taller of course but the per unit rents must be higher to support the increased construction costs.
The best to honor the history of those neighborhoods would be to build and build and build until units became affordable again.
These are all valid concerns but taken together and they prevent anything from getting done. Good intentions, bad results.
As someone who follows closely the real estate press news and has some sense of zoning controversies (and for what it's worth own a building), I think your comment is full of hyperbole and false commentary.
There's massive development at the new "Essex Crossing" in the LES. There's massive development at Atlantic Terminal at the edge of downtown Brooklyn / Cobble Hill. Along Broadway in Brooklyn, in between the Bushwick and Bed Stuy border, tons of development. "Broadway Triangle", at the bottom of Williamsburg, tons of development. 1000 units coming online on Flushing Ave at the border of Bushwick and Williamsburg. Everything I just said is not "low density housing". It's medium and high density.
Astor Pl and along Bowery has existing construction, and even more planned! Hudson Yards..
I could go on and on but your comment is hugely misinformed. The controversies in NYC around "NIMBYism" are NOT the same as California, with ideas around single-family homes and such.
Suggested media sources in the future:
therealdeal.com
newyorkyimby.com
ny.curbed.com
Finally, density comes at a price. When those people leave their high density housing, where do you think they go? When they take a shit and flush the toilet, where do you think that goes?
The density has made much of Brooklyn a nightmare commute as it is -- it takes a year to build a 12 story or whatever building, but it takes decades to upgrade our shoddy infrastructure.
You know what the common theme here is? They're all poor or working class neighborhoods without the political organization to fight back against redevelopment. You know the only reason that they would bend over for the L is because of the trendy Williamsburg $$$.
There's no political will? There's political will for affordable housing, which is related to housing density. Hence the zoning changes are attached to below-market rates for 20-30% of the newly-built units. Next there's plenty of political organization with varying opinions - some want more, some want less of this development. It's all trending towards more.
Most of the stuff being redeveloped is re-zoning to residential to something that wasn't. Pfizer for Broadway Triangle, Rheingold in the case of that project, Essex Crossing was empty lots, Pacific Park unused / commercial stuff...
I'm done replying piecemeal to someone's emotive factual errors. I sent you some links in my previous comment to explore. I don't do "Reddit" style emotive discussions.
Yes? Essex Crossing is right near the LES NYCHA and was not at all a nice area until very recently. Furthermore, saying "Atlantic Terminal" is misleading -- they're not developing Fort Greene and Park Slope but that messiness up towards Fulton.
> I don't do "Reddit" style emotive discussions.
That's fine, although this is a forum for discussion. I'm not sure what you want here.
The only common theme I see here is that you never seem to acknowledge the gaping flaws people have identified in the arguments you're making. Instead you just keep changing the subject.
I'm not sure what the way forward is, and I wouldn't begin to know how to fix the corruption problem. But I do know that blatant hyperbole like the above can't possibly begin to help.
I suppose you could say somewhere like Syria is worse because they can't even try, but it seems a pretty defensible statement.
Eyeballing figures for certain other modern projects in comparable cities readily indicates this simply isn't true.
When you think back to the days when US governments had the ability to do everything, consider the downside. You get "great men" like Robert Moses who bulldoze everything and destroy communities, or build highways to make it difficult for "undesirable" minorities to travel.
Plenty is getting done in NYC.
Indeed, the changes in the last 15 years (due almost entirely to government intervention -- mostly at the city level) have been quite profound. The idea that local government is "powerless" is simply disconnected from reality.
Are we now considering "lower Manhattan" to be south of 30th?
At the end of the day it's arbitrary but I'd say the core grid part of the city is from 14th to 96th. Even within that it isn't perfect, for example Broadway goes whatever it feels like going, but mostly you aren't going to get lost there.
I almost feel like it would have been better to shut down Van Ness north of city hall entirely, and leave the sidewalks wide open and unfenced. Or only allowed bus traffic.
I worked with a contractor for Cal-trans 25 years ago. I'll give you an answer.
One month.
That's how long they said an overpass takes if you pre-stage everything and then shut the freeway down and work 24/7 till done.
They also say everyone just deals and local businesses don't go under when business slips for a month. But there is a lot of economic damage when construction goes on for years.
Edit: Old SF native mentioned to me that West Oakland went under during the BART construction because people couldn't get to their jobs for years. And the Castro switched from a working class neighborhood to a gay neighborhood because workers had trouble getting across Market. Workers left, gays moved up from Polk St.
They did 14 bridges in 10 weekends, cf. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/publicroads/12mayjune/...
I think that took a month or two to replace but the actual bridge work I thought only took about a week and a half. Can't seem to find it on Google. Anyone remember when that was?
https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/A-MAZE-ING-His-reputa...
https://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/30/us/30collapse.html https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/A-MAZE-ING-His-reputa...
Meanwhile the invoice from the state police billed for 14 whole weeks of traffic detail. I'm sure that's just a typo on their part... (For anyone unaware, state police billing for hours that were never worked is a recurring scandal that happens every couple years in MA.)
Public works projects are generally treated as a "feeding trough" so to speak in MA. It's good to see them getting done faster though. Fingers crossed that they eventually decide that fixing the commuter rail is cheaper than paying Keolis to be the scapegoat.
https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4525982,-122.1278058,3a,60y,...
Southbound there isn't much room. Northbound, seems like there is space directly adjacent to the bridge.
That area you see in Sat is part of the bridge they were rebuilding; the frontage road.
A fire took out a section of I-85 in Atlanta in March 2017. By May 2017, it was carrying cars again...one month ahead of schedule.
https://www.wabe.org/how-have-i-85-repairs-happened-so-quick...
Why the MTA can't do this kills me and partially explains why people screamed bloody murder about a complete shutdown. The signaling system alone is held together by the equivalent of tape and chewing gum.
https://ny.curbed.com/2018/3/29/17176200/new-york-subway-sig...
If I was in his shoes I would have just said, "Either deal with the loss of the L line, or agree to tolerate a less than 24/7/365 operating schedule." Alas, the L is the only line I know of which uses PTC, which is designed to alleviate some of these issues.
There is no third option.
Why the MTA can't do this kills me and partially explains why people screamed bloody murder about a complete shutdown. The signaling system alone is held together by the equivalent of tape and chewing gum.
It's bloody murder, as you say, to turn NYC, whose delis/bodegas, restaurants and bars stay open until 12, 2, 4 am, all night, into London, where most bars end at 11pm, and restaurants much earlier. Part of that is cultural and part of that is that service staff can't necessarily afford Uber (which was banned too, wasn't it), or taxis, which cost a fortune. Yes, the night bus, that IS something London has that NY doesn't (the buses in NYC are atrocious).
NYC would be a different city if they shut down subways at midnight. The existing maintenance is already a nightmare (and an alphabet soup of outage notices).
But bus rapid transit is real and many of the people who make this city run (my dad for many years drove a cab he picked up from a garage in LIC) already depend on buses for their last mile commute. It is entirely possible to do five years or a decade of overnight subway shutdowns with BRT supported by real enforcement and protected lanes while preserving the city's culture.
By definition, it's still considered public transit, but you are subject to the same traffic patterns and congestion as private cars (admittedly, an additional expense).
Subways and Light Rail avoid this mess entirely. Not that there aren't still problems (Signals, PTC v Permissive Blocks, etc.) but you're much less likely to be stuck somewhere for long periods of time not moving.
24/7 operation means higher costs and more random failures.
But, for the occasional trip the cost benifit tradeoff of the city saving vast mounts of money and reduced delays is worth a few people being inconvenienced.
Ahh, did not realize you where trolling about a world without bridges. I mean wtf dude, the inefficiency from running a 24/7 subway reduces the city's ability to afford more bridges.
Further, Manhattan is just not that big. Nowhere is very far from anywhere else when you step aside from the horrid congestion.
The commuter tax deduction lets you buy the cards with pre-tax money deducted from your paycheck, which is a substantial reduction up to 45% or so depending on your marginal tax rate. Of course, because it's using pre-tax money, it's giving a bigger discount to higher earners, which makes it the opposite of progressive, which seems opposite of what's intended.
Separately, seniors/disabled people pay half fare: http://web.mta.info/nyct/fare/rfindex.htm
You can't win.
Getting around London after the underground is shut is incredibly inconvenient, and even they have been moving the most important trains to all-night service.
What if it was done one line at a time weekly?
Seriously: do you think there is no model worth exploring here?
So, no buttered roll for you on the way to work in the morning because the bakery staff couldn't get to work at night.
The bodega on the corner is closed anyway because the morning people have to do the stock because it the overnight staff couldn't get in.
Garbage trucks block your way because the garbagemen couldn't get to work overnight.
There's no morning news because the thousands of people behind the scenes couldn't get to work over night.
The cleaning crew in your office vacuums while you're on the phone because they couldn't get to work at night.
There are hundreds of thousands of people who work overnight in New York City. Nine-to-five stopped happening in New York in the late 1700's.
For the record, the JMZ are running close enough to the L that, while an inconvenience, for many people in the Williamsburg/Bushwick/Ridgewood area, it is a viable alternative. The L isn't everything.
[1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.gothamist.com/amp/articles/...
Your examples are not convincing.
That's not what people are screaming about. Shutting down the L train for 5 hours, like the London underground, happens often and is OK. Shutting down the L train for 15 months is a completely different situation.
China will have 25,000 miles of HSR before the first part of the California HSR is completed.
[0] https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2018/january/incom...
I’m sure there are lots of reasons. I doubt the salaries are the only explanation.
With these advantages it’s quite likely that their ability to build infrastructure will enable them to take the number one spot in the world
The project itself benefits from labor+scale. They are able to scale manufacturing by declaring the size and scope of the project. Similar to what the US did with road-construction... hundreds of contractors appeared to manage interstate projects as it was a well-known, decades long effort.
The other factor is that the political environment in China allows for cheap, low friction seizure of land and homes.
The US is capable of doing the same thing -- we did it for 50 years to build the interstate system. What is missing today is the will at the Federal level to invest billions. States lack the ability to borrow/print sufficient funds to build like this at scale.
In other words, is it a function of efficiency in project management or cost-of-living?
Simple comparisons can hide a lot of confounding factors.
The alternative plan was recommended by a panel of experts convened by Mr. Cuomo, who called the new design a “major breakthrough’’ that had been used in Europe but had not been tried in this country.
“What these people have designed is the first of its kind in the United States of America,’’ said the governor who was joined by the engineering experts who had come up with the plan.
It is a political time bomb no matter who is in charge regardless if the damage was done by an Act of God (Hurricane Sandy).
The L Train's shutdown was going to occur for 15 months. That's a long time. I don't doubt that it was necessary, but i'd be livid if i lost my main commute for 15 months.
On the flip side, if its going to take 15 months with a full shutdown, it's going to take forever with a partial/slow service.
What do people think about a slow of service, then going into a full stop of service with significant communication? People would be nudged to find alternates and spill over isn't going to overwhelm alternate routes.
At least in the Brooklyn part, they previously shut down the M to beef it up to be able to handle the new riders. There has been ton of advertisement of the whole process, and descriptions about what to do instead. People have been planning around this for a while.
In other words, that's what's already happened.
I don't imagine something similar would work all that well in the Bay Area, though, since there's really only two routes to take up and down the peninsula, and both are near capacity already.
Looks like they did it again last summer, to a lesser extent [2]. I no longer live in the area, so don't have any firsthand knowledge of how smoothly that went.
[1]: https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/publicroads/04mar/01.c... [2]: https://www.in.gov/indot/3687.htm
One system starts emitting 50% more traffic and everything else falls over because everything is running at 80% of capacity all the time.
We're trying to combine our multi-region and failover efforts and I just know it'll take about a week for us to have all data centers running at more than 1/n of capacity. And then instead of having no war room when one data center goes offline we'll have one when anything hiccups.
Also, "just dig another tunnel" is not a simple proposition in Manhattan, ridiculous cost of the Second Avenue tunnel aside.
Other countries would shut this down and build then reopen, inconveniencing many. We will spend more and keep this going longer instead.
Another great example is on 101 freeway in california they just finished replacing a bridge in palo alto. They did not shut the freeway down while it was literally replaced from underneath the cars. It took 3 years and caused horrendous traffic daily. I wonder how fast it could have been done if they shut down 101 entirely on that stretch.
i know it’s easy to complain about how long these things take, but what would you rather have?