News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dvh on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:09PM (#18742462)
Do we even know he was a real person and not combination of 2 or 3 men with similar fate?
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by jimmytucson on Saturday December 22, 2018 @09:05PM (#18743928)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus

Pretty interesting:

> Virtually all New Testament scholars and Near East historians, applying the standard criteria of historical investigation, find that the historicity of Jesus is effectively certain ... with very few exceptions such critics generally do support the historicity of Jesus and reject the Christ myth theory that Jesus never existed.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:09AM (#18745494)
Virtually all is an overstatement. Perhaps the vast majority, but the vast majority are also practicing Christians.

See Richard Carrier's youtube videos on this topic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTllC7TbM8M

There's not compelling evidence for the historicity of Jesus. Yet there's compelling motivation for early Christians to say he was a man who lived and not simply a god. Being related to someone who knew him in real life actually could bestow power and influence in the early Christian community.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by UncleMeat on Sunday December 23, 2018 @10:29AM (#18746587)
Youtube videos aren't exactly the best example of scholarly work. Look at the people who are respected by academics rather than trying to evaluate the contents of a field that you aren't trained in.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @10:34AM (#18752559)
I have looked at all of them. If you can point to specific arguments, I would love to engage.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by craftyguy on Sunday December 23, 2018 @03:07PM (#18748025)
Neither are Wikipedia articles.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @10:36AM (#18752567)
Please don’t jump to conclusions, I have looked at the actual research and also read the books. None of the common cited evidence for Jesus as a historical figure holds up to scrutiny. If you can give one example that can, it would help me a ton. I’d love to be wrong and understand Jesus as an actual historical figure.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reitanqild on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:43AM (#18761143)
Late but this Quora answer has some details:

https://www.quora.com/Did-any-of-the-Bibles-contributors-act...

I cannot verify it all right now, I'm more of a practical guy when it comes to Christinanity, but a few of the writers from the new testament were followers, and two (?) were his step (if you belive in it like me) brothers.

For a common bloke from 2000 years ago multiple written sources from people who met him first hand should count as pretty well documented.

I'm not saying you should believe everything they wrote (although I do) I'm just pointing out that the basic facts are very well documented given the circumstances.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by nikbackm on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:10PM (#18742761)
I found this a good overview for that question.

https://www.quora.com/Do-credible-historians-agree-that-the-...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by burlesona on Sunday December 23, 2018 @01:43AM (#18744807)
I agree, the Quora explanation is pretty good.

TLDR; the evidence that Jesus was a real person is very strong, and stronger than many other historical figures (the article mentions Hannibal), whose existence is not considered controversial.

As a religious figure Jesus is inherently controversial, which is what probably attracts the skepticism and interest in trying to cast doubt on his existence.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:11AM (#18745502)
I recommend this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTllC7TbM8M

Richard Carrier actually counters each argument in the Quora post pretty convincingly.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:09PM (#18742752)
Yes. The first major bunch of followers were not that far removed from his death, and we have a couple of historical accounts (exactly a couple, to be precise).
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by eponeponepon on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:22PM (#18742825)
One of those accounts uses a different name for him ("Crispus"? Maybe? You'll have to forgive me not looking it up, but it eludes me and I don't want to disappear down a wiki-rabbithole when I should be wrapping presents..!) and has later been interpreted as referring to him; the other account is a focus of great controversy as to its genuine age.

I'm not necessarily trying to pull your point apart, just pointing out that it's not clear-cut. Personally I've never really made my mind up, but at the moment I lean more towards a conglomeration of folk-tales and the lives of several men. I'll probably change my mind again soon.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dragonwriter on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:55PM (#18742961)
> One of those accounts uses a different name for him

I think you are probably remembering a (disputed) claim based on an edit made in a particular later copy that Tacitus (one of the earliest independent sources on both Christ and the early Christian community, particularly in Rome) referred to the Christian community in Rome as “Chrestians”, immediately before using the standard rendering of Jesus title as “Christus”. Even if Tacitus did use “Chrestians”, that name for the early community is attested in other sources (and even tied and used alongside Christian in some inscriptions from that community, IIRC), his reference to Christ did not use any alternate title,

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:44AM (#18745602)
Have you heard that "Christus" is also believed to be an interpolation?

https://www.ex-christian.net/topic/65072-richard-carrier-chr...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dragonwriter on Sunday December 23, 2018 @03:44PM (#18748200)
I wasn't familiar with Carrier’s claim to that effect, but it doesn't seem to have widespread acceptance and seems (from the secondhand description you provide) to ignore what seems to be generally accepted from outside evidence about the term “Chrestianos”.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @10:28AM (#18752534)
There’s evidence to the contrary as well. The jury is still out on who the Chrestianos refers to. Honestly, I need to look into it more myself. But it asks the question, why would someone change it in the first place? Not to mention the word Christus is also a forgery. I am open to being wrong, just thought you should know these are forgeries.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by toufiqbarhamov on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:17PM (#18742496)
No, although typically the opposite claim is made. That people named “Joshua son of Joseph” lived at that time, that various revolts and religious upheavals occurred is pretty certain. That one guy fitting the rough description of Jesus was behind it is not. The history of Christianity doesn’t really start in earnest for hundreds of years after the supposed death of Christ in any case.

People today can’t even agree on the details of Elvis’ life... now imagine if Elvis had lived a few hundred years ago, and we’re all working from quaternary+ sources. Then fast-forward a thousand or so years of very intentional document editing and re-editing, translations and re-translations, and all of the incredible wealth and power hinging on it for centuries.

How accurate would accounts from those times be expected to be?

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by vivekd on Saturday December 22, 2018 @08:17PM (#18743702)
>although typically the opposite claim is made. That people named “Joshua son of Joseph” lived at that time, that various revolts and religious upheavals occurred is pretty certain. That one guy fitting the rough description of Jesus was behind it is not

That doesn't seem quite fair because it's almost certain that the guy named Jesus was not behind the upheavals of that time. That was about the Jewish revolt against the Romans which Jesus was not involved in at all. Also, while Christianity didn't start in earnest until about two hundred years after Jesus' death, stories of his life were written down as early as 60 years after his death.

It's very difficult in a society like ancient Israel to fake the existence of a person, people had clan allegiances, they kept track of genealogies and would be able to tell right away if the writings concerned someone who didn't exist.

There were translations but that's irrelevant because we have the original dead sea scrolls with the earliest ones dating to a few decades after his death. A time when wealth and power did not hinge on this. We're not solely working with edits and re-translations.

I think there's a bias against religious figures that inform people's arguments when they say it's all uncertain - when in reality the evidence is pretty good that he did exist.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by toufiqbarhamov on Saturday December 22, 2018 @08:39PM (#18743809)
Details of his life may have been written down then, but the sources we have aren’t those sources, just edited and translated retellings of those supposed stories with about 1800 years of politically and religiously motivated games of telephone between us and them. I have to ask, the Dead Sea Scrolls date from between about a century before Jesus’ purported life, to about a century after his death and as far as I know make no mention of him. I wasn’t claiming that the language is somehow untranslatable, but that we don’t have anything like contemporary sources, only people who hundreds of years later claim to have access to those sources.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by grumpydba on Saturday December 22, 2018 @08:20PM (#18743716)
> The history of Christianity doesn’t really start in earnest for hundreds of years after the supposed death of Christ in any case

There are several Christian writings dated from the first century after his death. Paul's letters, the didache, Flavius Joseph, some talmudic writings, John's disciples writings to name a few.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by vibrolax on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:36PM (#18742579)
Loved your comparison to the historical Elvis. Whenever I saw news articles reporting on artifacts purportedly related to the historical Jesus, I always thought how little we know about the historical Shakespeare.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by toufiqbarhamov on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:11PM (#18742768)
Or indeed, some people don’t even believe that Shakespeare wrote his plays! As passionate as people can be about Shakespeare, it’s nothing compared to religion, and record keeping and sources of information on Shakespeare are a lot easier to come by than anything from a couple of millennia ago.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by sjwright on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:23PM (#18743443)
All we can say is that Shakespeare was credited for his plays. It's functionally impossible to know who wrote them, at best we can hypothesise based on an analysis of his writing—and such analysis doesn't bode well for Shakespeare as the author...
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by djur on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:51PM (#18743599)
Your initial point is true about just about anyone who wrote more than a certain amount of time ago. It's true of Jonson and Spenser and Marlowe, too. The latter point is just false -- textual analysis is entirely consistent with the historical evidence (such as the writings of his contemporaries) that William Shakespeare of Stratford-upon-Avon wrote the works of Shakespeare.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by sjwright on Monday December 24, 2018 @01:31AM (#18750777)
Interesting; I was led to the impression that Shakespeare's writings showed a level and stratum of life experience that would have been beyond his reach or means.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:31PM (#18742546)
I have often wondered about this; I have read in various places that scholars believe there was a historical Jesus but this always seems like a pragmatic stance to take in societies where the vast majority of people believe that he was either a prophet or a God (which covers almost everywhere where this question would be considered worthy of any serious study). Yet there are some issues that I see:

1. "Yeshua" or "Yeshu" were relatively common Jewish names at that time (it is just "Joshuah" in Aramaic), so vague references in non-Christian writings to a "Jesus" of some kind may not refer to the same person. How many people named "Joshuah" might have led a group of disciples during a period where dozens of messianic claimants were trying to rally followers to one cause or another?

2. It is well known that the bible was subject to extensive editing prior to its official canonization, which makes it somewhat questionable as a historical document. At best we can only derive vague information about big social movements IMO -- no doubt there were Jews who taught the things attributed to Jesus, but I personally hesitate to go further and claim that the bible is an accurate account of a single person's movement.

3. The chaotic schisms in the early centuries of Christianity makes me doubt that useful historical information about the founders of the movement actually survived. The different Christian movements preserved the documents that best supported their cause. Who knows what historical information is not available today that would totally change our views on the topic.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Casseres on Sunday December 23, 2018 @09:56AM (#18746374)
> 2. It is well known that the bible was subject to extensive editing prior to its official canonization, which makes it somewhat questionable as a historical document.

I've never heard this claim before.

The Dead Sea Scrolls prove that written copies made through the centuries were accurate copies.

The only editorialization of the Bible was church councils deciding which books/letters to include in the Bible, not to edit them.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @10:11AM (#18746468)
The Gospels:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-source_hypothesis

This all would have happened before the various councils decided what would be considered canonical, and the councils themselves probably had no idea that it had happened.

As for the dead sea scrolls, all it shows is that the final forms of the books in the Hebrew bible and related extrabiblical works existed prior to the canonization. It is pretty clear that the Hebrew bible was edited in prior centuries:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Documentary_hypothesis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_Isaiah#Authorship

etc.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by jonawesomegreen on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:19PM (#18742502)
I really enjoyed this book on the topic:

“Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth is a book by Iranian-American writer and scholar Reza Aslan. It is a historical account of the life of Jesus and analyzes the various religious perspectives on Jesus as well as the creation of Christianity.”

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zealot:_The_Life_and_Times_o...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by 1over137 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @06:47PM (#18743232)
Probably not the most impartial author on the topic though, as as he is a theist and self-proclaims himself as a "genuinely committed disciple of Jesus of Nazareth".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reza_Aslan#Religious_views

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by idontpost on Saturday December 22, 2018 @08:35PM (#18743793)
Who could possibly be considered an impartial author on the topic?

Surely not any Christian or any atheist. Not any Muslim either. I suppose Buddhists wouldn't have any particular stake in whether a historical Jesus existed.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by 1over137 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @09:13PM (#18743960)
Why not an atheist? Not believing in his divinity doesn't preclude objective analysis of whether a human named Jesus existed. But, yes, surely not any Christian, who by definition believes Jesus exited.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by amatthew on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:13AM (#18744568)
Why not either? For both the Christian and the Atheist, honest scholarship is inseparable from their beliefs. It's hard to imagine either changing their beliefs from the evidence they could find.

The consequences of being able to prove with certainty either that Jesus existed and is who Christians claim him to be, or did not exist or was not divine would have tremendous consequences on the lives of hundreds of millions people who do not ascribe to the proven belief.

They could say "I am intellectually honest and will change my beliefs depending on the evidence," but we both know that 1. Concrete evidence strong enough to convince someone to change their beliefs, beyond what is already known, likely does not exist. And 2. Their current beliefs already match their known evidence so any additional information is unlikely to radically change their beliefs, only be accounted for and integrated into their current belief system.

I'm not trying to say all scholarship is biased or we shouldn't believe anything. In all likelihood, most people are not deliberately lying or falsifying anything.

What does that mean about which scholarship to trust? I have no idea.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by jkaplowitz on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:39AM (#18744635)
Here's the difference:

Christians (ignoring some defunct or very rare forms) have it as an article of faith that Jesus was a real historical human who was also divine.

Atheists would deny that Jesus or anyone else was God, but there is nothing about atheism that is opposed to duly considering possibly trustworthy evidence that the Jesus whom Christians believe on faith was/is God may have indeed existed as a real historical human.

At the same time, unlike (for example) Muslims who believe Jesus was a human prophet but not himself divine, atheists don't have any specific belief about Jesus's human historical reality at all. If the evidence shows that he was made up by combining bits of multiple people's teachings, atheism is unaffected.

Therefore, an atheist's writing about this question is, all things being equal, more likely to neutrally consider all the available the secular observable facts about the question, without influence from religious motivations, than a Christian's.

However, that italicized precondition is usually false.

Real writers vary in their approach to scientific and historical rigor, being imperfect humans themselves and not abstractions. So an individual Christian could well be a more trustworthy source on this than an individual atheist, or vice versa.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by 1over137 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:52PM (#18749730)
amatthew: by definition, being Christian means one believes Jesus existed. How does one objectively consider the non-existence of Jesus if one has already arrived at a conclusion? That's some serious cognitive dissonance.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by amatthew on Sunday December 23, 2018 @09:47PM (#18749925)
Yeah, I agree with you there. I was trying to make a point closer to what jkaplowitz above mentioned in their last three paragraphs.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by sjwright on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:12PM (#18743374)
Given that Aslan describes outspoken atheists as "fundamentalists" I would take anything he says about religion with an enormous grain of salt. Aslan claims to speak about religion while choosing to remain willfully ignorant about irreligion; therefore you can't expect his views to be academically rigorous or well thought through.

As for his book, I realise that book publishers like to give their products sexy titles, but the title can't possibly be paid out in any non-fiction sense as we have exactly zero contemporaneous written accounts of Jesus' life. Anything he has written could only be a further digestion of the already contentious writings haphazardly collected into the book we now know as the Christian bible.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dmckeon on Saturday December 22, 2018 @10:14PM (#18744164)
If you were to read the book, you might find it more about the times than about the man. The context of the time and the place and the various social and religious movements in the few decades before, during, and after the life of Christ informs the reader, and is worth a reading.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by sjwright on Sunday December 23, 2018 @02:03AM (#18744859)
Given that it's all bunch of vague speculation based on writings—and given the character of Jesus is certainly fictional—this would be a more interesting digestion of the material:

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/artshums/depts/trs/events/jandb/index....

https://soundcloud.com/kings-college-london/jesus-and-brian-...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by croisillon on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:15PM (#18742487)
you might like this article: http://www.adamgopnik.com/what-did-jesus-do
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by danielam on Saturday December 22, 2018 @09:26PM (#18744014)
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by EGreg on Saturday December 22, 2018 @06:02PM (#18742990)
Well, here is why I think Jesus very likely existed and taught:

The Church today follows the teachings of Paul, that the Law is obsolete, nailed to the cross and no longer binding. The Church teachings give the Chuch great authority in determining what people should do, church leaders are called Father etc. The Church was supposed to be for all nations.

And yet... Jesus is described in the gospels exactly saying the opposite! “I came to save the lost sheep of Israel.” When a young man asked how to be saved, Jesus said “follow the Law”. He always taught to follow the law, and never once said it would be obsolete after his crucifixion.

Why would the Church invent a person so inconvenient to their own dogma? It is the ultimate criterion of embarrassment — of the very canonizers themselves!

They only would have done it if the original founder of the Way realy existed and was a Jewish teacher who taught Jews. Why else would they invent something so seemingly at odds with their own teachings that people throughout the centuries (like Thomas Jefferson) called Paul “the great corruptor of Christianity”?

I would further say that the original Church of Jesus existed in Jerusalem and was led by his brother James and also by Peter. They told Paul that rumors have come that he is teaching Jews to turn away from the Law, and told him to pay for some purification rites to show this is not true. Paul obliged. They also penned a letter to Gentile Believers which Paul was to take to them, invoking the Holy Spirit and instructing them in essentially the Noahide Laws. Paul in his letter to the Galatians however said they had “nothing to add” to his message excep that he “remember the poor, something I have been eager to do all along”.

In short, the founder existed, the Church existed, and would have been the dominant Church if not for the Judaic wars and the destruction that happened as a result.

I think that Christianity as we know it today, came from those beginnings and then spread to other churches.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by cabaalis on Saturday December 22, 2018 @08:57PM (#18743892)
I'm not a religious scholar but I am religious.

> Jesus said “follow the Law”. He always taught to follow the law, and never once said it would be obsolete after his crucifixion.

I've always interpreted those conversations to be Jesus attempting to spread an idea that the religious institutions of the time had lost sight of the message of love and peace in return for control and power.

If you read it with Jesus speaking knowing that members of his audience are members of those power groups, you get the sense that he is very, very carefully choosing his words.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by mbfg on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:33PM (#18747241)
If you were a maximally powerful being and wanted to explain important concepts to all mankind, would you use such incredibly nuanced wording to do that (if you are even right)? That seems like a horribly terrible plan and implementation.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by grumpydba on Saturday December 22, 2018 @08:25PM (#18743735)
> Jesus said “follow the Law”. He always taught to follow the law, and never once said it would be obsolete after his crucifixion

He said the law would not change until all is accomplished. After drinking the vinegar, before dying, he said "all is accomplished". Paul's teachings are thus consistent with this.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by EGreg on Saturday December 22, 2018 @09:44PM (#18744083)
No, that's only if you read the English translation. In the original Greek, the two words are very different.

The original context is from Matthew 5:18, which could potentially have been written in Hebrew:

"17 “Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill. 18 For assuredly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass away, one [a]jot or one [b]tittle will by no means pass from the law till all is fulfilled. 19 Whoever therefore breaks one of the least of these commandments, and teaches men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever does and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20 For I say to you, that unless your righteousness exceeds the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, you will by no means enter the kingdom of heaven."

Notice a few things:

1) Heaven and Earth have not yet passed away, many Christians ignore this part completely, but it needs to be explained why it was mentioned. It would seem the obvious reason is that "all will be accomplished" around the time that Heaven and Earth will pass away, including spreading the gospel to everyone. In another place Jesus says "And this gospel of the kingdom will be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all nations, and then the end will come."

2) Notice that even those who ARE in Heaven will be called Least if they set aside even the smallest commandment and teach others to do so. Thus, even Christians need to be concerned with the Law. Literally nowhere did Jesus even bring up the idea that the Law will be obsolete. That is an idea originated by Paul.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by cat199 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @02:28AM (#18744927)
> Notice that even those who ARE in Heaven will be called Least if they set aside even the smallest commandment and teach others to do so.

yet he healed on the sabbath.. sooo..

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by grumpydba on Sunday December 23, 2018 @04:50AM (#18745295)
He also abolished repudiation.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by i-am-that-i-am on Saturday December 22, 2018 @11:13PM (#18744378)
My understanding is that Jesus was talking specifically about the moral law, that which is "written on our hearts."
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by EGreg on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:57AM (#18744683)
That is a distinction made later, it's nowhere in the Bible even. Certainly never mentioned by Jesus. He explicitly said people who don't follow even the smallest commandment are to be called least in the kingdom of Heaven. No distinction between moral law or not. And look at James 2:10 he says the same thing, written AFTER Jesus was on the cross!
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by grumpydba on Sunday December 23, 2018 @04:49AM (#18745293)
The final word he used is "tetelestai", wish can be translated by paid in full. The meaning is there.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by EGreg on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:39PM (#18747279)
It actually means "it is finished". But even "paid in full" is very different from "all the prophecies have been fulfilled". There are still prophecies coming up. As I said, Heaven and Earth did not pass away. What was the point of mentioning them, in your view? It's pretty clear Jesus was talking about the end times.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by mattigames on Saturday December 22, 2018 @11:57PM (#18744524)
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reindeerer on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:22PM (#18742521)
The historical accounts seem to support the idea that the story is a combination of multiple people. But the guy who got nailed to a cross was an actual historical event and became the focal point for the amalgam.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:11PM (#18742766)
>The historical accounts seem to support the idea that the story is a combination of multiple people

Which "historical accounts" support this idea? I've never such those among what we know...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Retric on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:38PM (#18742588)
Lots of people where nailed to a cross. So, even that is not really very specific.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:10PM (#18742760)
The important part was not the "person nailed to cross", it was "person nailed to cross under such and such circumstances".
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by sjwright on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:33PM (#18743503)
The various books in the bible aren't even consistent, and we know that many people were running around claiming to be God or affiliated with God. If he existed, he was just one of many such people.

Meanwhile, bible scholars acknowledge that the books weren't written by people who had personally met Jesus, and don't even know precisely who the authors were—they are in fact anonymous—the names Matthew, Mark, Luke and John are just traditional.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel#Canonical_gospels

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reindeerer on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:53PM (#18742660)
Yeah absolutely, it's just this one guy's nailing that happened to become central around biblical retellings.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:14PM (#18742787)
Why should we believe that there is "one guy" whose crucifixion became central? Maybe crucifixion was just a well-known Roman execution method (remember that Christianity emerged during a period of Roman oppression).
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by toufiqbarhamov on Saturday December 22, 2018 @06:29PM (#18743107)
It would have only been ~100 years after Spartacus and his merry band were crucified along the road to Rome after the Third Servile War. Even if that was the only notorious crucifixion (and it was not), I think would be highly memorable around a century later.
[dead]
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dang on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:45AM (#18744655)
Please don't unsubstantive comments, and especially not racial or nationalistic flamebait, to HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by anjbe on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:32AM (#18744616)
Crucifixion was a degrading and viscerally disturbing form of execution, with connotations not unlike hanging or the electric chair today. It was not the kind of thing to centralize one’s messianic cult around. The fact that it happened once is already so bizarre that the crucifixion is considered by historians to be one of the most certain truths of Jesus’ life story.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Retric on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:44AM (#18746013)
Crucifiction was a common form of execution at the time. One of the really bizarre things from our perspective is just how many people where executed back then.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by anjbe on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:54AM (#18746057)
Crucifixion was indeed common. What I’m referring to as bizarre is the idea of the Messiah being subject to such a degrading, humiliating, torturous death, which ran totally counter to Jewish thought at the time (and indeed Jewish thought ever).
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @10:50AM (#18746691)
It runs counter to the mainstream Jewish thought of the past 1800 years regarding the messiah, but we are talking about a movement that was divergent from what ultimately became "mainstream Judaism" (i.e. the Pharisees). I would also point out that it is not so unique for a messianic claimant to be humiliated yet retain devoted followers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabbatai_Zevi

Nor would violating mainstream religious views be a terribly unique event when a new movement is picking up followers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob_Frank

It is also not as "bizarre" as you might think. Judaism two thousand years ago was highly fragmented, with many different movements all competing for followers and converts; there was no single body of "Jewish thought" at the time. There were different interpretations of the prophecies, and the earliest Christians followed one tradition of interpretations (this is clearly reflected in the gospels -- e.g. Matthew follows the Greco-Jewish tradition and the Septuagint).

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by redial on Sunday December 23, 2018 @09:46AM (#18746315)
Which is why christianity didn't find many followers among the Jews.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by cat199 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @02:31AM (#18744936)
to those asserting crucifixion was rare, the account also has jesus as crucified simultaneously with two thieves..

i doubt stealing would be as severe a crime as treason, so this would indicate that it was a common form of punishment

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by SpikeDad on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:26PM (#18742532)
Where's the historical evidence for your claim that the guy who got nailed to a cross was indeed the source of the "Jesus" mythology?
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:13PM (#18742779)
You seem to confuse the religious story of Jesus (miracles, resurrection, etc, the "mythology" in your terms) with the actual person who had followers and inspired a religion.

There's little doubt among scholars that there was a specific person at the start of this (and not some BS "Dan Brown"-like conspiracy).

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:26PM (#18742848)
Scholars who live in societies where the vast majority of people follow religions that consider Jesus to be a prophet or even a god. I have yet to see a good argument for why we should assume the Jesus of the bible was a single person leading a religious movement -- there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:23PM (#18743439)
>I have yet to see a good argument for why we should assume the Jesus of the bible was a single person leading a religious movement -- there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.

For one, the burden of proof would be on proving it was "multiple" people.

Second, we have a couple of references to a single person (Josephus, Tacitus).

Third, we know many other cases of a single founder, from Mohamed to Joseph Smith, Jr.

>there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.

How is that relevant. There were many, but one of them got off the ground. Why should there be 2 or 6 of them getting popular simultaneously?

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @09:58PM (#18744122)
The point is not that there were necessarily multiple movements that merged into one; rather, it is that there is no reason to rule it out. It is entirely possible that Jesus is a legendary figure based on various Jewish religious leaders with similar messages. The teachings attributed to Jesus are for the most part variations on Jewish precepts and religious themes; even the baptism, which scholars seem to insist was historical, is just a variation on Jewish bathing rituals (mikvah). So we have a man with a relatively generic Jewish name (i.e. Joshua, which in Aramaic is Yeshua or Yeshu, which in Greek is Jesus), who led one of a large number of Jewish cults based on variants of common Jewish religious themes, engaged in common Jewish practices, and was executed by an oppressive occupying force known for its cruel executions of Jewish leaders (see e.g. the "ten martyrs" of the Talmud). Why are we assuming that is a story about specific and real person?

Tacitus makes a vague reference to a "cristus" that could have referred to any messianic claimant (as "christ" is just a Greek word for "messiah"), and Josephus makes a similarly vague reference to people with very common Jewish names (Joshua i.e. Jesus, Jacob i.e. James). In both cases there are reasons to doubt that the references refer to the specific Jesus in the biblical or quranic accounts (the latter unquestionably having been written centuries after Jesus supposedly lived). In both cases the claims are not based on the authors' first-hand knowledge and the authors based their writings on what the earliest Christians had told them, something that may have already been merely a legend.

Again, it is possible that Jesus was really a person who led a religious movement two thousand years ago. I am only saying that other explanations cannot be ruled out because there is almost no evidence at all. At best all we can say is that the earliest Christians lived about two thousand years ago and by that point believed some version of the Jesus narrative. Beyond that I am not seeing the evidence for a historical Jesus.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Sunday December 23, 2018 @05:01AM (#18745328)
>The point is not that there were necessarily multiple movements that merged into one; rather, it is that there is no reason to rule it out.

Sure, no reason to rule it out, just many reasons to rule it improbable.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:21AM (#18745529)
> Second, we have a couple of references to a single person (Josephus, Tacitus).

These references have been largely debunked.

1. Josephus: https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/7437

"The evidence that the Testimonium Flavianum (or TF) is entirely a late Christian forgery is now as overwhelming as such evidence could ever get."

2. Tacitus: https://www.quora.com/Was-Tacitus-a-Christian

"With ultra-violet examination of the Second Medicean manuscript 'the alteration was conclusively shown', even though it wasn't possible to say 'who altered the letter e into an i'. The examination was made by Dr. Ida Giovanna Rao of the Laurentian library in Florence, in 2008. The alteration is also visible in an ultra-violet photograph."

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by krapp on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:35PM (#18742876)
>there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.

Yes, but to play... eh, Messiah's advocate... this doesn't discount the possibility of Jesus having been one of those claimants leading one of those movements, he just wouldn't have been the only one.

It doesn't lend credence to anything either, but it's not impossible that Jesus happened to lead the cult that won out, thanks eventually to Rome and the British Empire.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by bhaak on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:51PM (#18743598)
> thanks eventually to Rome and the British Empire

The British Empire? How so?

Rome obviously was instrumental for the success of Christianity, spreading along the roads of the Roman Empire, having a large population with the same language so you could reach lots of people with one translation Although Christianity wasn't alone in using these advantages. It eventually won out but Mithraism was a similar positioned religion.

After the rise of the Islam reduced the area of Christianity, European colonialism spread it over the whole world. If I had to single out one European nation with the most influence, I would have said it was the Spanish Empire and not the British.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @06:06PM (#18743006)
It does not discount that possibility, but it does leave open the possibility that "Jesus" is a legendary figure representing a fusion of various religious leaders over a long period of time.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:24PM (#18743448)
It wasn't a "long period of time" between Jesus and the first christians.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @10:12PM (#18744162)
Maybe the legends developed over multiple generations before the first century. The first "Christians" would have just looked like another Jewish messianic cult, and would have looked more like the earlier messianic cults the existed before Jesus supposedly led his disciples than anything we think of as "Christian."
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reindeerer on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:36PM (#18742574)
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Theodores on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:31PM (#18743498)
The most eye opening discussion and research on this topic for me came from what Dr Richard Carrier has to say. He got down to the task of just doing the research like how a historian might, or how a scientist might. His standpoint is clearly atheist, but don't let that put you off. He uses logic, reason and applies that to how he weighs the factiness of the story.

Any of his talks on YouTube are a good introduction, if you want to learn more and are willing to have your opinion and assumptions challenged.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WUYRoYl7i6U

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Carrier

You don't have to 'believe' in the guy, however his methodology, knowledge of history and enthusiasm for the subject is not something you find in the priesthood.

He does not rate the probability of Jesus being a real person as that high, neither does he rate the existence of Ned Ludd as that high. He does trace where ideas were borrowed from and has read the bible extremely thoroughly. If you are interested in Christianity because it is part of our culture and history then I highly recommend taking time to hear what Dr Richard Carrier has to say.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dorchadas on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:34AM (#18744622)
> You don't have to 'believe' in the guy, however his methodology, knowledge of history and enthusiasm for the subject is not something you find in the priesthood.

It's not something you find among any credible scholar in the field. Carrier is fringe for a reason.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:19AM (#18745523)
There was a time where all "credible" scholars believed the earth was flat. Consensus changes.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dorchadas on Sunday December 23, 2018 @10:06AM (#18746433)
No, there definitely wasn't. 'Credible' scholars have known the earth is round since the Greeks. Archimedes even calculated the circumference.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @10:33AM (#18752557)
And Galileo?

Look, that’s not the point. Consensus undoubtably can change. The majority of historical scholars in this field are religious. I would love it if better evidence could verify the historical Jesus, rather than appeals to authority like you are using. There is compelling lack of evidence to prove Jesus as a historical figure. I never personally questioned it until seeing the lack of evidence.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dorchadas on Monday December 24, 2018 @04:24PM (#18754340)
Except there isn't a lack of evidence unless you require more evidence for Jesus than every other historical figure. Are you going to say there's now no evidence for Alexander the Great? What about Socrates? What about Pythagoras? That's the exact point so many people have tried to make -- there's just as much evidence, if not more, for Jesus than for these other people.

Furthermore, if it's an appeal to authority to rely on scholars in a given field (many of whom are agnostic or atheist, yet still realize that there probably was a historical Jesus), I hope you don't believe in anything science says. After all, saying you believe in global warming is just an "appeal to authority". And so is trusting Carrier. Speaking of which here's one (of many) sources detailing why Carrier's ideas fail [0] and are basically dogmatically motivated -- which is hilarious since it's exactly what you accuse religious scholars of.

Also, Galileo did not believe it was flat, and there's plenty of sources during the Late Middle Ages that basically state they knew the earth was a sphere.

[0] https://www.patheos.com/blogs/euangelion/2017/12/peer-review...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @08:14PM (#18755258)
> Except there isn't a lack of evidence unless you require more evidence for Jesus than every other historical figure. Are you going to say there's now no evidence for Alexander the Great? What about Socrates? What about Pythagoras? That's the exact point so many people have tried to make -- there's just as much evidence, if not more, for Jesus than for these other people.

It's the exact point so many (apologists) make. Unfortunately it's not true.

Source: https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/7924

> Furthermore, if it's an appeal to authority to rely on scholars in a given field (many of whom are agnostic or atheist, yet still realize that there probably was a historical Jesus)

Exactly how what percent are atheists?

> After all, saying you believe in global warming is just an "appeal to authority". And so is trusting Carrier.

Yes, but the difference is we have evidence for global warming, but we don't for Jesus.

> Speaking of which here's one (of many) sources detailing why Carrier's ideas fail [0] and are basically dogmatically motivated -- which is hilarious since it's exactly what you accuse religious scholars of.

Did you link to the right article? This is a religious website, which merely shows one journal disagreed with Carrier. It has no mention of evidence against Carrier's claims nor does it show Carrier is dogmatically motivated. Is this all you got?

> Also, Galileo did not believe it was flat, and there's plenty of sources during the Late Middle Ages that basically state they knew the earth was a sphere.

FYI Galileo was imprisoned in the 1600s by the Roman Inquisition for promoting the idea that the earth was a sphere that revolved around the sun. Just because plenty of sources knew the earth was a sphere doesn't mean it was consensus. Plenty of scholars believe Jesus is made up, yet here we are.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Theodores on Sunday December 23, 2018 @03:03AM (#18745003)
Credible to whom?

After 2000 years of the indoctrination the defenders of the bible have got the art of defending the make-believe that is the bible down to a fine art. I did not say that everything that has ever came out of Richard Carrier's mouth is tantamount to the word of god and definitely to be believed. My point was that he asks the right questions, has done a lot of research that the bible bashers of this world haven't bothered to do and he has ways of discussing things in a non-black-and-white dualist way, going for probability and giving a value to how likely something is likely to be true.

Anyone with a serious interest in questioning assumptions long held by them about the bible needs to hear him out, to believe him or not, it is that questioning of faith that matters. There are plenty of atheists that believe that Jesus really did exist but he was an ordinary guy rather than of virgin birth and the son of god, an 'anti-capitalist rebel' of sorts.

What Richard Carrier does is to open up the idea that the whole bible is a contrivance, that this Jesus character did not exist and that his story was weaved together by religions that had gone before.

Logical fallacies are something we are all capable of. Your 'where there is smoke there must be fire' comment does not stand up to scrutiny.

Just twenty years ago it was not possible to talk about climate change in the world of weather forecasting and meteorology. That was actually way to controversial, and I am talking from being in the field twenty years ago. Yet by that point in time the idea had some scientific credibility for twenty years, and a century before that some had wondered what the consequences of pumping ever increasing quantities of carbon dioxide into the air might lead to, positing the 'crazy' global warming idea.

With the agreement of the Paris Accords the other week we have moved on from that, the 'fringe' view that was not considered 'credible' has moved on. Yet a mere twenty years ago people were saying 'climate change is fringe for a reason'.

There may be much to dislike about Richard Carrier, but to dismiss him without at least a link to a decent review of his work by one of these italicised credible scholars is a poor show.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:18AM (#18745518)
Disappointing to see this downvoted. I've taken the time to watch hours of videos from people on both sides of this fence. Richard Carrier takes the most sober approach to analyzing the evidence without bias by giving an actual probability to each argument/element.