News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Theodores on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:31PM (#18743498)
The most eye opening discussion and research on this topic for me came from what Dr Richard Carrier has to say. He got down to the task of just doing the research like how a historian might, or how a scientist might. His standpoint is clearly atheist, but don't let that put you off. He uses logic, reason and applies that to how he weighs the factiness of the story.

Any of his talks on YouTube are a good introduction, if you want to learn more and are willing to have your opinion and assumptions challenged.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WUYRoYl7i6U

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Carrier

You don't have to 'believe' in the guy, however his methodology, knowledge of history and enthusiasm for the subject is not something you find in the priesthood.

He does not rate the probability of Jesus being a real person as that high, neither does he rate the existence of Ned Ludd as that high. He does trace where ideas were borrowed from and has read the bible extremely thoroughly. If you are interested in Christianity because it is part of our culture and history then I highly recommend taking time to hear what Dr Richard Carrier has to say.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dorchadas on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:34AM (#18744622)
> You don't have to 'believe' in the guy, however his methodology, knowledge of history and enthusiasm for the subject is not something you find in the priesthood.

It's not something you find among any credible scholar in the field. Carrier is fringe for a reason.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:19AM (#18745523)
There was a time where all "credible" scholars believed the earth was flat. Consensus changes.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dorchadas on Sunday December 23, 2018 @10:06AM (#18746433)
No, there definitely wasn't. 'Credible' scholars have known the earth is round since the Greeks. Archimedes even calculated the circumference.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @10:33AM (#18752557)
And Galileo?

Look, that’s not the point. Consensus undoubtably can change. The majority of historical scholars in this field are religious. I would love it if better evidence could verify the historical Jesus, rather than appeals to authority like you are using. There is compelling lack of evidence to prove Jesus as a historical figure. I never personally questioned it until seeing the lack of evidence.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dorchadas on Monday December 24, 2018 @04:24PM (#18754340)
Except there isn't a lack of evidence unless you require more evidence for Jesus than every other historical figure. Are you going to say there's now no evidence for Alexander the Great? What about Socrates? What about Pythagoras? That's the exact point so many people have tried to make -- there's just as much evidence, if not more, for Jesus than for these other people.

Furthermore, if it's an appeal to authority to rely on scholars in a given field (many of whom are agnostic or atheist, yet still realize that there probably was a historical Jesus), I hope you don't believe in anything science says. After all, saying you believe in global warming is just an "appeal to authority". And so is trusting Carrier. Speaking of which here's one (of many) sources detailing why Carrier's ideas fail [0] and are basically dogmatically motivated -- which is hilarious since it's exactly what you accuse religious scholars of.

Also, Galileo did not believe it was flat, and there's plenty of sources during the Late Middle Ages that basically state they knew the earth was a sphere.

[0] https://www.patheos.com/blogs/euangelion/2017/12/peer-review...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Monday December 24, 2018 @08:14PM (#18755258)
> Except there isn't a lack of evidence unless you require more evidence for Jesus than every other historical figure. Are you going to say there's now no evidence for Alexander the Great? What about Socrates? What about Pythagoras? That's the exact point so many people have tried to make -- there's just as much evidence, if not more, for Jesus than for these other people.

It's the exact point so many (apologists) make. Unfortunately it's not true.

Source: https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/7924

> Furthermore, if it's an appeal to authority to rely on scholars in a given field (many of whom are agnostic or atheist, yet still realize that there probably was a historical Jesus)

Exactly how what percent are atheists?

> After all, saying you believe in global warming is just an "appeal to authority". And so is trusting Carrier.

Yes, but the difference is we have evidence for global warming, but we don't for Jesus.

> Speaking of which here's one (of many) sources detailing why Carrier's ideas fail [0] and are basically dogmatically motivated -- which is hilarious since it's exactly what you accuse religious scholars of.

Did you link to the right article? This is a religious website, which merely shows one journal disagreed with Carrier. It has no mention of evidence against Carrier's claims nor does it show Carrier is dogmatically motivated. Is this all you got?

> Also, Galileo did not believe it was flat, and there's plenty of sources during the Late Middle Ages that basically state they knew the earth was a sphere.

FYI Galileo was imprisoned in the 1600s by the Roman Inquisition for promoting the idea that the earth was a sphere that revolved around the sun. Just because plenty of sources knew the earth was a sphere doesn't mean it was consensus. Plenty of scholars believe Jesus is made up, yet here we are.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Theodores on Sunday December 23, 2018 @03:03AM (#18745003)
Credible to whom?

After 2000 years of the indoctrination the defenders of the bible have got the art of defending the make-believe that is the bible down to a fine art. I did not say that everything that has ever came out of Richard Carrier's mouth is tantamount to the word of god and definitely to be believed. My point was that he asks the right questions, has done a lot of research that the bible bashers of this world haven't bothered to do and he has ways of discussing things in a non-black-and-white dualist way, going for probability and giving a value to how likely something is likely to be true.

Anyone with a serious interest in questioning assumptions long held by them about the bible needs to hear him out, to believe him or not, it is that questioning of faith that matters. There are plenty of atheists that believe that Jesus really did exist but he was an ordinary guy rather than of virgin birth and the son of god, an 'anti-capitalist rebel' of sorts.

What Richard Carrier does is to open up the idea that the whole bible is a contrivance, that this Jesus character did not exist and that his story was weaved together by religions that had gone before.

Logical fallacies are something we are all capable of. Your 'where there is smoke there must be fire' comment does not stand up to scrutiny.

Just twenty years ago it was not possible to talk about climate change in the world of weather forecasting and meteorology. That was actually way to controversial, and I am talking from being in the field twenty years ago. Yet by that point in time the idea had some scientific credibility for twenty years, and a century before that some had wondered what the consequences of pumping ever increasing quantities of carbon dioxide into the air might lead to, positing the 'crazy' global warming idea.

With the agreement of the Paris Accords the other week we have moved on from that, the 'fringe' view that was not considered 'credible' has moved on. Yet a mere twenty years ago people were saying 'climate change is fringe for a reason'.

There may be much to dislike about Richard Carrier, but to dismiss him without at least a link to a decent review of his work by one of these italicised credible scholars is a poor show.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:18AM (#18745518)
Disappointing to see this downvoted. I've taken the time to watch hours of videos from people on both sides of this fence. Richard Carrier takes the most sober approach to analyzing the evidence without bias by giving an actual probability to each argument/element.