News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reindeerer on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:22PM (#18742521)
The historical accounts seem to support the idea that the story is a combination of multiple people. But the guy who got nailed to a cross was an actual historical event and became the focal point for the amalgam.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:11PM (#18742766)
>The historical accounts seem to support the idea that the story is a combination of multiple people

Which "historical accounts" support this idea? I've never such those among what we know...

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Retric on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:38PM (#18742588)
Lots of people where nailed to a cross. So, even that is not really very specific.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:10PM (#18742760)
The important part was not the "person nailed to cross", it was "person nailed to cross under such and such circumstances".
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by sjwright on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:33PM (#18743503)
The various books in the bible aren't even consistent, and we know that many people were running around claiming to be God or affiliated with God. If he existed, he was just one of many such people.

Meanwhile, bible scholars acknowledge that the books weren't written by people who had personally met Jesus, and don't even know precisely who the authors were—they are in fact anonymous—the names Matthew, Mark, Luke and John are just traditional.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel#Canonical_gospels

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reindeerer on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:53PM (#18742660)
Yeah absolutely, it's just this one guy's nailing that happened to become central around biblical retellings.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:14PM (#18742787)
Why should we believe that there is "one guy" whose crucifixion became central? Maybe crucifixion was just a well-known Roman execution method (remember that Christianity emerged during a period of Roman oppression).
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by toufiqbarhamov on Saturday December 22, 2018 @06:29PM (#18743107)
It would have only been ~100 years after Spartacus and his merry band were crucified along the road to Rome after the Third Servile War. Even if that was the only notorious crucifixion (and it was not), I think would be highly memorable around a century later.
[dead]
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by dang on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:45AM (#18744655)
Please don't unsubstantive comments, and especially not racial or nationalistic flamebait, to HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by anjbe on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:32AM (#18744616)
Crucifixion was a degrading and viscerally disturbing form of execution, with connotations not unlike hanging or the electric chair today. It was not the kind of thing to centralize one’s messianic cult around. The fact that it happened once is already so bizarre that the crucifixion is considered by historians to be one of the most certain truths of Jesus’ life story.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by Retric on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:44AM (#18746013)
Crucifiction was a common form of execution at the time. One of the really bizarre things from our perspective is just how many people where executed back then.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by anjbe on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:54AM (#18746057)
Crucifixion was indeed common. What I’m referring to as bizarre is the idea of the Messiah being subject to such a degrading, humiliating, torturous death, which ran totally counter to Jewish thought at the time (and indeed Jewish thought ever).
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @10:50AM (#18746691)
It runs counter to the mainstream Jewish thought of the past 1800 years regarding the messiah, but we are talking about a movement that was divergent from what ultimately became "mainstream Judaism" (i.e. the Pharisees). I would also point out that it is not so unique for a messianic claimant to be humiliated yet retain devoted followers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabbatai_Zevi

Nor would violating mainstream religious views be a terribly unique event when a new movement is picking up followers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob_Frank

It is also not as "bizarre" as you might think. Judaism two thousand years ago was highly fragmented, with many different movements all competing for followers and converts; there was no single body of "Jewish thought" at the time. There were different interpretations of the prophecies, and the earliest Christians followed one tradition of interpretations (this is clearly reflected in the gospels -- e.g. Matthew follows the Greco-Jewish tradition and the Septuagint).

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by redial on Sunday December 23, 2018 @09:46AM (#18746315)
Which is why christianity didn't find many followers among the Jews.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by cat199 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @02:31AM (#18744936)
to those asserting crucifixion was rare, the account also has jesus as crucified simultaneously with two thieves..

i doubt stealing would be as severe a crime as treason, so this would indicate that it was a common form of punishment

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by SpikeDad on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:26PM (#18742532)
Where's the historical evidence for your claim that the guy who got nailed to a cross was indeed the source of the "Jesus" mythology?
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:13PM (#18742779)
You seem to confuse the religious story of Jesus (miracles, resurrection, etc, the "mythology" in your terms) with the actual person who had followers and inspired a religion.

There's little doubt among scholars that there was a specific person at the start of this (and not some BS "Dan Brown"-like conspiracy).

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:26PM (#18742848)
Scholars who live in societies where the vast majority of people follow religions that consider Jesus to be a prophet or even a god. I have yet to see a good argument for why we should assume the Jesus of the bible was a single person leading a religious movement -- there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:23PM (#18743439)
>I have yet to see a good argument for why we should assume the Jesus of the bible was a single person leading a religious movement -- there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.

For one, the burden of proof would be on proving it was "multiple" people.

Second, we have a couple of references to a single person (Josephus, Tacitus).

Third, we know many other cases of a single founder, from Mohamed to Joseph Smith, Jr.

>there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.

How is that relevant. There were many, but one of them got off the ground. Why should there be 2 or 6 of them getting popular simultaneously?

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @09:58PM (#18744122)
The point is not that there were necessarily multiple movements that merged into one; rather, it is that there is no reason to rule it out. It is entirely possible that Jesus is a legendary figure based on various Jewish religious leaders with similar messages. The teachings attributed to Jesus are for the most part variations on Jewish precepts and religious themes; even the baptism, which scholars seem to insist was historical, is just a variation on Jewish bathing rituals (mikvah). So we have a man with a relatively generic Jewish name (i.e. Joshua, which in Aramaic is Yeshua or Yeshu, which in Greek is Jesus), who led one of a large number of Jewish cults based on variants of common Jewish religious themes, engaged in common Jewish practices, and was executed by an oppressive occupying force known for its cruel executions of Jewish leaders (see e.g. the "ten martyrs" of the Talmud). Why are we assuming that is a story about specific and real person?

Tacitus makes a vague reference to a "cristus" that could have referred to any messianic claimant (as "christ" is just a Greek word for "messiah"), and Josephus makes a similarly vague reference to people with very common Jewish names (Joshua i.e. Jesus, Jacob i.e. James). In both cases there are reasons to doubt that the references refer to the specific Jesus in the biblical or quranic accounts (the latter unquestionably having been written centuries after Jesus supposedly lived). In both cases the claims are not based on the authors' first-hand knowledge and the authors based their writings on what the earliest Christians had told them, something that may have already been merely a legend.

Again, it is possible that Jesus was really a person who led a religious movement two thousand years ago. I am only saying that other explanations cannot be ruled out because there is almost no evidence at all. At best all we can say is that the earliest Christians lived about two thousand years ago and by that point believed some version of the Jesus narrative. Beyond that I am not seeing the evidence for a historical Jesus.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Sunday December 23, 2018 @05:01AM (#18745328)
>The point is not that there were necessarily multiple movements that merged into one; rather, it is that there is no reason to rule it out.

Sure, no reason to rule it out, just many reasons to rule it improbable.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by owens99 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:21AM (#18745529)
> Second, we have a couple of references to a single person (Josephus, Tacitus).

These references have been largely debunked.

1. Josephus: https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/7437

"The evidence that the Testimonium Flavianum (or TF) is entirely a late Christian forgery is now as overwhelming as such evidence could ever get."

2. Tacitus: https://www.quora.com/Was-Tacitus-a-Christian

"With ultra-violet examination of the Second Medicean manuscript 'the alteration was conclusively shown', even though it wasn't possible to say 'who altered the letter e into an i'. The examination was made by Dr. Ida Giovanna Rao of the Laurentian library in Florence, in 2008. The alteration is also visible in an ultra-violet photograph."

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by krapp on Saturday December 22, 2018 @05:35PM (#18742876)
>there were plenty of messianic claimants at the time and plenty of Jewish religious movements competing for followers.

Yes, but to play... eh, Messiah's advocate... this doesn't discount the possibility of Jesus having been one of those claimants leading one of those movements, he just wouldn't have been the only one.

It doesn't lend credence to anything either, but it's not impossible that Jesus happened to lead the cult that won out, thanks eventually to Rome and the British Empire.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by bhaak on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:51PM (#18743598)
> thanks eventually to Rome and the British Empire

The British Empire? How so?

Rome obviously was instrumental for the success of Christianity, spreading along the roads of the Roman Empire, having a large population with the same language so you could reach lots of people with one translation Although Christianity wasn't alone in using these advantages. It eventually won out but Mithraism was a similar positioned religion.

After the rise of the Islam reduced the area of Christianity, European colonialism spread it over the whole world. If I had to single out one European nation with the most influence, I would have said it was the Spanish Empire and not the British.

Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @06:06PM (#18743006)
It does not discount that possibility, but it does leave open the possibility that "Jesus" is a legendary figure representing a fusion of various religious leaders over a long period of time.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by coldtea on Saturday December 22, 2018 @07:24PM (#18743448)
It wasn't a "long period of time" between Jesus and the first christians.
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by betterunix2 on Saturday December 22, 2018 @10:12PM (#18744162)
Maybe the legends developed over multiple generations before the first century. The first "Christians" would have just looked like another Jewish messianic cult, and would have looked more like the earlier messianic cults the existed before Jesus supposedly led his disciples than anything we think of as "Christian."
Re:What did Jesus really look like? (2015) by reindeerer on Saturday December 22, 2018 @04:36PM (#18742574)