News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by pjc50 on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:45AM (#17731908)
"In a nutshell, that’s why this story matters: because the hate preached on anti-cycling Facebook pages isn’t confined to the digital realm. It’s a poison that bleeds from the screen into the real world, where aggression towards cyclists is very real, and very deadly"

Goes for a lot of other things too.

Cycling seems to be a really inflammatory subject for online discussion, and I've never really been sure why; it seems like a kind of identity politics.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by KozmoNau7 on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:15AM (#17732285)
As a bicycle and public transit commuter and former car commuter in Copenhagen, I have a saying: When I'm driving, I find cyclists annoying, but when I cycle, I find cyclists even more annoying.

There are a ton of cyclists who just don't give a shit. They'll blast past you at intersections, cutting into other lanes, they'll swerve directly in front of you and brake, they'll jump on the sidewalk, they'll completely ignore pedestrian-only zones, they'll randomly cut to the left or right of turning cars, the list goes on. Some people bike in completely irrational and unpredictable ways.

Often I'll pass someone (I'm a reasonably fit and speedy commuter on a good bike), only for them to place themselves right in front of me at the next red light, and then take forever to get up to speed, so I have slooooowly get up to speed behind them and then pass again. Repeat ad infinitum. Most of the time, the slowpokes are on their phones (hand-held, obviously) and/or swerve all over the place, putting everyone in danger. Or they ride two abreast while chatting, completely blocking the bike lane and ignoring people ringing their bells behind them.

It really pains me to see people act like that, because it completely sours the relationship between different types of traffic, casting a bad light on the rest of us. Sometimes it seems like they're deliberately out to piss off drivers, which is not a healthy long-term strategy.

That was a bit of a detour, but my point is that the problem exists on both sides. There are definitely both asshole cyclists and asshole drivers. On the cyclist side, I think part of the problem is that a lot of people don't really know the traffic laws, or they don't think they apply to cyclists.

This is certainly not meant to downplay the shitty actions of many drivers, I've seen some absolutely horrendously irresponsible driving here as well.

As for why it's such an inflammatory subject, that's simply the case for any discussion involving cars. If you read car forums, people are very quick to go flying off the handle, and there are usually some pretty extremist and very vocal members. Car culture is very opinionated and to a lot of car people, their cars are direct extensions of their personalities and egos. Cyclists challenge their "rightful ownership of the roads", and are therefore an enemy.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Freak_NL on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:55AM (#17731940)
It seems like a regional thing though. In many European and Asian countries there may be animosity between some cyclists and some drivers of cars, but not the extreme polarisation seen in American (perhaps Australian and a few other countries too?) communities.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by michaelcampbell on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:47AM (#17733174)
There's a few things going on that I see (in the US), and probably many I don't.

* Most US roads are not bicycle ready. They weren't designed to have mixed vehicles, they weren't built for it, and they don't do it well.

* Cyclists have been given a right to be on these roads, which can't safely handle them, by legislation.

* Having them there does impede traffic that the road WAS designed for.

* The US culture has devolved lately into a "my rights" based one.

* Both the car drivers who have historical precedent with "rights to be there" and the cyclists with the newfound legislative "right to be there" willfully fail to recognize the rights of the other.

* Both sets of drivers blame the other for the lack of adherence to safety and traffic laws. Both are correct.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dasil003 on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:38AM (#17733605)
I’ve been a bicycle commuter for 25 years, primarily in the US (Minneapolis, Santa Fe, Bay Area) but also 3 years in London. Your last 3 points are much more important than the first three, there’s simply an attitude problem in the US, and it goes both ways, both drivers, and riders (and even pedestrians) are militant and angry about the space they feel entitled to.

Compare to London where the streets were designed for neither automobiles nor bicycles. In London there’s a culture of acknowledgement that we all have to make do with the available space. So pedestrians spill into the street, cars occasionally have to go up onto the pavement (aka. Sidewalk) and bicycles achieving critical mass happens naturally during peak times. London is 10 times as congested as SF and yet everyone is 10 times as calm.

It’s amazing to me the success the auto lobby had in America a century ago to create a culture where the default is that everyone should be able to drive super fast and have parking available in every square inch of developed land, and anyone who uses anyone who uses any other form of transportation is an uncivilized pleb deserving of second rate accommodations at best.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by sli on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:59AM (#17734498)
There is absolutely weird entitlement problem in the US with regards to drivers, and motorcycle riders feel it, too. It becomes clear when a common response to supporting filtering (motorcycles being allowed to move to the front at intersections for visibility reasons) is, "Why should they get to go first?"

Which, of course, is completely irrelevant complaint regardless of ones views on filtering. There's this notion that a driver is entitled to both their place on the road and some sort of ill-defined spot in a queue that isn't there.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by mannykannot on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:07PM (#17735541)
I don't buy your characterization of car drivers' rights as having "historical precedent" while cyclists (only) have "newfound legislative" rights. Cyclists' rights to use public roads go back at least as far as motorists' do, and the subsequent poor design of roads with respect to cyclists' rights did not annul them.

If anything, it is the more recent (and sensible) restriction of cycle use on certain major roads that is "newfound".

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dionidium on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:53AM (#17733231)
> Most US roads are not bicycle ready. They weren't designed to have mixed vehicles, they weren't built for it, and they don't do it well.

This is true, but many of the roads in my hometown that people insist were "built for cars" predate the automobile, which is just to say that they can be (and have been) changed to support whatever we want them to support.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by gbrown on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:24AM (#17733479)
As an interesting side note, in my area "road diets" were recently proposed, turning a four lane road into 2+turning lane+bike lanes. The planners had data indicating that this would lead to less congestion and higher safety... and many people lost their minds in fury at the idea of giving up lanes to cyclists.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by bhandziuk on Friday August 10, 2018 @12:35PM (#17734784)
Where is this? I like this
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by gbrown on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:40PM (#17735285)
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by bhandziuk on Monday August 13, 2018 @12:44PM (#17751439)
Cool, thanks!
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by michaelcampbell on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:55AM (#17733245)
This is also true, and they DON'T currently support cars + bicycles. That they can be made to do so is interesting, but irrelevant to the current situation.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dionidium on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:19PM (#17735138)
It's relevant in countering the assertion that roads were built for cars. A lot of roads were built for horses, but nobody thinks that's a compelling argument for, well, anything.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by frockington on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:57AM (#17733795)
As a US citizen I am the biggest hypocrite when it comes to cyclists/pedestrians in the road. When in a car I think "They'll get out of my way, I'll win in a fight" while riding a bicycle I think "What are they going to do? Hit me".
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by bunderbunder on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:54AM (#17734449)
That's such a normal way of thinking in the US's transportation culture. What's chronically absent from it is any sense of common courtesy.

So, inevitably, we end up in an inherently acrimonious situation: Everyone smaller than you is treated as nothing but an obstacle to be avoided, and everyone bigger than you is understood as a threat to your safety, and everyone about your same size is regarded as that asshole who just cut you off, or that asshole who needs to speed up and quit holding up traffic, etc.

We've become such misanthropists when it comes to transportation that it's even common for people to aver that they don't like using public transportation because they don't like how it brings them into regular social contact with people they don't know, and nobody thinks that attitude the least bit strange.

It's really quite odd, when you step back and look at it. Sad, too.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dwaltrip on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:09AM (#17733954)
Dissonance mitigation is a fascinating and scary thing. Observing it happen in oneself is a real treat. Kudos for being so honestly reflective.

Cognitive dissonance and how we respond to it is the main topic of the first episode of Sean Carroll's new podcast Mindscape. I found it very interesting.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by silentmars on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:48PM (#17735828)
This sounds more psychotic than hypocritical to me. "I'll win in a fight", is this a normal way of thinking? I'm a US citizen and I can honestly say this thought has never crossed my mind while driving. My thought when passing a cyclist is to make sure I'm giving them enough room and hope I'm not doing anything to make them fearful. I thought most people were this way, and it seems obvious to me that it's the right way to act. How prevalent is this other, "I'll win in a fight" attitude?
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by bluntfang on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:16PM (#17735116)
* Most US roads are not car ready. They weren't designed to have mixed vehicles, they weren't built for it, and they don't do it well.

* Motor vehicles have been given a right to be on these roads, which can't safely handle them, by legislation.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by AmericanChopper on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:46AM (#17732166)
Having lived in Jakarta, Bangkok and Manila, I can tell you that getting angry at cyclists wouldn’t make much sense. The roads are complete chaos in all those places, everything on the road is a deadly hazard.

The roads where I live now are a lot more orderly, but cyclists get a free pass in a lot of ways. You’ll get a ticket for passing within 5 feet of a cyclist, so you better hope they’re a fast cyclist when you get stuck behind one. I also see them run reds frequently and ride across pedestrian crossings. For a group that makes up about 1% of commuters, they manage to make a disproportionate nuisance of themselves. I’m not an anti-cycling nut, but it’s not hard to see where the frustration comes from.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:48AM (#17732176)
Depends. If you happen to come across extremist cyclists and at the same time oblivious or even arrogant car drivers, it can get out of hand real quick in Germany, as well.

There is lots of hatred on both sides. Drivers see cyclist running a red light and generalize about those criminal cyclists.

Cyclists take an idea like Critical Mass that was originally supposed to be a demonstration, a traffic-political statement, and don‘t even care about traffic policy anymore, but openly talk about how to disrupt car traffic the most so those „carholes“ get the traffic jam they deserve. It‘s just fun to them, a bit of trolling.

I don‘t see the relationship improve, unless many more „common“ people use the bike. Then they would have much more understanding for the other side when driving a car, and the bike extremists would vanish in the mass as statistical noise.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Fricken on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:18AM (#17733439)
What little legitimacy cyclists have established for themselves was accomplished by being pushy, not by being pushovers. With cars it was the same, they secured their rights to the road by running people over back in the early days, which makes critical mass look pretty quaint by comparison.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:45AM (#17733671)
Breaking law doesn‘t give you legitimacy.

Injuring pedestrians doesn‘t give you legitimacy, either.

You simply illustrate the extremist biker that will achieve nothing but more hatred from all other participants in traffic.

That‘s why I‘m hoping for more „casual“ bikers who don‘t see the war on the street as their focal point of life.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by KozmoNau7 on Sunday August 12, 2018 @06:16AM (#17743763)
Unfortunately there is a lot of anti-cyclist sentiment going on, and it seems to have been increasing over the last decade or so.

From my perspective in Copenhagen -- one of the foremost cycling cities in the world -- I think this is happening because policies are increasingly being enacted to favor cyclists and public transit. A lot of road improvements have favored bicycle lanes, often by decreasing the number of lanes available for cars, or by making a lot of streets one-way only for cars.

Some car drivers see these as direct attacks on their chosen mode of transportation, or even their lifestyle as a whole.

I see this as a necessary evil. You cannot improve conditions for one type of transport beyond a certain point, without also making conditions worse for other types of transport. Cycling, walking and public transit go very well hand-in-hand, but personal car traffic doesn't really mesh that well with anything other than car traffic.

So for high-density living, car traffic must necessarily be down-prioritized in favor of higher-density and less polluting traffic, namely cycling and public transit, both of which work best in cities. Roads and parking lots simply take up way too much space that could be used for parks, homes, shopping streets and people instead.

Conversely, it is hard to make public transit work efficiently in rural areas, and cycling 10-15km between towns for social activities (in all kinds of weather) is not acceptable to most people. Electric bicycles mitigate this somewhat, but in most less densely populated areas, cars still make a lot of sense for most people.

I'm a city person, so I favor cycling and public transit, and I would love to see the center of Copenhagen completely closed off to personal car traffic, only allowing delivery drivers and other professionals with a legitimate need to drive through the city center. I don't condone violent activism or similar methods, nor do I condone breaking traffic laws through methods like Critical Mass and the like. The "critical mass" I want is simply for there to be so many cyclists in traffic that they cannot be ignored or marginalized.

I would also never try to ban cars in other less-densely populated places, because that's simply not realistic. At least not yet, not without some major revolution in living conditions or public transit feasibility.

At some point, we have to realize just how ridiculously wasteful personal car traffic really is, and do something major to disrupt it. I don't think self-driving cars are the answer.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by francisofascii on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:00PM (#17735006)
Not disagreeing, but it can go both ways. When Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat and broke the law, I'm sure that created some angry white hatred, but in the end advanced equal rights for African Americans.
[dead]
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dang on Friday August 10, 2018 @12:06PM (#17734563)
We've warned you before that posting uncivilly will get you banned here. Please don't do this again.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by smelendez on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:01AM (#17731964)
I think you're right, and it's frustrating.

I'm pretty much neutral: I'm a licensed driver, and I've cycled to work in the past, but right now I don't have a bike or a car.

I saw a discussion on a local forum recently where cyclists and motorists just refused to accept that both camps use their vehicles as transportation. Drivers acted like cyclists were just silly kids, despite some being eligible for Social Security, and cyclists acted like drivers were robber barons having their chauffeurs mow down poor people.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by holstvoogd on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:16AM (#17732020)
I've seen it change too. When I was younger, I visited Vienna yearly and there the attitude has changed I feel. 15-20 years back you had better stay on the sidewalk or risk being cut off etc by cars, but now it seems they love their cyclists.

On a side-note: cyclist in Berlin are very annoying they park their bike in front of you at EVERY traffic light and are then exceedingly slow to get moving again.

Now that I think about it, it might just be that the attitude changes with the introduction of cycling lanes to keep cars and bikes separated

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dsego on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:53AM (#17732194)
Stopping in front of cars is done to gain the best visibility. That's why cities are introducing bicycle boxes at intersections. A bicycle is alway slow to get moving, unless it has an electric motor, that's why cyclist hate stopping and will sometimes cruise through a stop sign or red, because it feels safer than trying to pick up speed while cars are revving behind you and trying to squeeze by.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Balero on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:48AM (#17732177)
In the UK there is a specific area at the front (which cars will often decide to stop in) just for bikes to stop, called a bike box. I believe it is safer for them to be out in front rather than pushed to a side, or caught between cars.[0]

In my experience, in an urban environment, it doesn't matter how fast you get moving again, there's another traffic light right ahead

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_stop_line

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Steltek on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:28AM (#17733522)
We have quite a few of those in Boston. I'm often hesitant to use them as intended because I'm pretty sure it'll just piss some ignoramus off. It's just not worth the chance. And in other cases, the lead car is already stopped on it (and also encroaching into the crosswalk as well).

One change I'd really love to see implemented is moving the traffic light pole to the near corner (as opposed to the far corner or suspended in the middle). This encourages drivers not to creep into the intersections because they wouldn't be able to see the light.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:11AM (#17733395)
You wouldn't have thought that these things would be enforced, but an employee of mine got caught stopped in one in his car by a camera and had to take a 1-day course to avoid getting points on his license. He had absolutely no idea about them as apparently they don't have them in his home country of Portugal.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by jspash on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:56AM (#17734468)
I've often wondered how much preparation/study of the local laws does one need when driving in another country?

If you lived in country A and were planning a holiday in country B, then yes I'd spend a bit of time googling their laws. But on a 2 week "coast to coast" road trip travelling through a dozen countries? I probably wouldn't bother.

However, if I knew nothing about the UK "bike box" and was driving as a guest, something tells me it would be blindingly obvious what it was for. No? I mean, it's a symbol a bike surrounded by thick white lines. https://goo.gl/maps/zz1TvLM6fcv

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Symbiote on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:44AM (#17734360)
That's no excuse — Portugal uses the same road markings, as does most of the world. A solid line across the road shows where to stop when the light is red. It's defined in the Vienna Convention on Road Traffic Signs and Signals:

"A transverse marking consisting of a continuous line across one or more traffic lanes shall mark the line behind which drivers are required by the sign B, 2, "STOP", referred to in Article 10, paragraph 3, of this Convention, to stop. Such a marking may also be used to show the line be hind which drivers may be required to stop by a light signal"

http://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/trans/conventn/Conv_road_...

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Balero on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:42AM (#17734342)
In fairness its a different coloured bit with a giant bike on it. All behind a solid white line.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:54AM (#17732195)
We have that, too. And I don‘t really understand it.

I mean, bikes accelerate much slower. So what realistically happens is that bikes weasel through cars and the right curb to the front, distribute themselves over the whole width of the lane. And when they get green they... have to go over to the right side again (single-file!) and are being overtaken (usually with little room) by all the cars.

I‘ve just read the article you linked, and the HGV aspect is a good one. But in my home town, those bike boxes aren‘t on streets with real goods traffic, but on residential streets.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by WkndTriathlete on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:54AM (#17732781)
The main problem with cycling is that some cyclists are safer in the road while others are safer off of the road.

I happen to live in an area with wide (car width+ shoulders) so most of the time I'm there. However, there are a handful of left turns I make that result in me being in the vehicle left-turn lane at the signal lights. When the green arrow shows I'm lights-out sprinting through the intersection so I'm not holding up vehicle traffic. Cyclists can actually accelerate much faster than vehicles over the first couple of seconds and it's only 5 seconds or less through an intersection.

Having said that, my sprint power from a dead stop is from 6 - 15 watts / kg, depending on my motivation level. If someone is coming away from a dead stop at a lower power-to-weight ratio they should probably not be in the road since they will unnecessarily hold up traffic.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by saltcured on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:47AM (#17734391)
Also, it's not just the athletic power, but the bike design and the technique of the rider.

I ride a hard-tail mountain bike I converted for commuting with some more appropriate city tires. I am no triathlete, but I know enough to shift into the right starting gear before I stop and to sit with one pedal up in a position that allows a good power stroke to get rolling again. I am often first across a large intersection when the light changes, although a few drag-racing cars may catch up (against the general trend in which drivers seem more distracted and slower to respond to light changes these days).

I see younger, healthier riders who wobble all over the intersection like a little kid learning to ride. They have their bikes in the wrong gear or have a bike with fixed gearing. They fumble around trying to get both feet on the pedals before they even have enough forward movement to balance. And, some ride bikes that seem to be configured in the worst possible way for balance and efficiency, with bad geometry, seats and handlebars in the wrong place, or absurdly heavy materials...

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by KozmoNau7 on Sunday August 12, 2018 @06:30AM (#17743798)
>"there are a handful of left turns I make that result in me being in the vehicle left-turn lane at the signal lights"

This is caused by traffic laws seeing everything in the road as being similar to a car, which is counter-productive, forcing slower traffic such as bikes to cross lanes for left turns.

It is much more sensible and safer for cyclists to do hook turns, instead of using the vehicle left turn lanes.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by SketchySeaBeast on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:43AM (#17733147)
> 6 - 15 watts / kg

How do you measure this on a bicycle? I know you can do that on a stationary rower (I was exceedingly happy when I could hold > 1 hp for 30 seconds) - do you measure on gym stationary bikes?

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by tomjakubowski on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:46AM (#17733164)
You can install a device on an ordinary bicycle to measure the power input to the pedals.

https://www.cyclingweekly.com/group-tests/power-meters-every...

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by SketchySeaBeast on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:19AM (#17733445)
Very cool! Thanks.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by wolfgke on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:09AM (#17733957)
> It seems like a regional thing though. In many European and Asian countries there may be animosity between some cyclists and some drivers of cars, but not the extreme polarisation seen in American (perhaps Australian and a few other countries too?) communities.

As a German, I say: you hang around with the "wrong" cyclists and motorists to perceive the strong polarization. I know people of the more militant kind from both sides.

Let me tell you: these cyclists typically know the exact subtle details of the road traffic regulations (Straßenverkehrsordnung) much better than most motorists (who had to do an exam about this topic to get their driving license). This is also very necessary, since lots of motorists feel so much entitled and do not actually know the laws. In this case only knowing the law exactly helps and if discussions are futile (they often are), the only thing that you can do is to file a criminal charge against the motorist.

To give my private opinion (after having heard lots of arguments from both sides): The fact that there exist obligatory driving licences is a lot at fault for all these escalations. Their mere existence leads to a lot of the entitlement of the motorists ("I had to take the driving exam and learn a lot about traffic laws before, while the cyclists did not. So the motorists feel 'more entitled to know what is right and wrong in traffic'").

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by gadders on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:06AM (#17733351)
The culture between the UK an Europe is quite different for cycling.

In the UK, 90% of the cyclists are older men in the latest lycra racing gear on //edit//road bikes. In Brugges, people just get on a regular bike with a basket on the front wearing their normal clothes.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by twak on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:32AM (#17733562)
Within the UK there is a large variety of cycling cultures. Cambridge is a city where everyone cycles to work in jeans/office clothes.

(Don't confuse "track bikes" and "road bikes"...)

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by NLips on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:16AM (#17733424)
It may sound like a minor correction, but track bikes are uncommon* on the road. You probably mean road bikes.

The important difference is that track bikes do not have brakes. Most bikes on the road do.

*Yes - there are people cycling on the road using bikes without brakes. However, that's not 90% - it's a small minority. Cycling on the road in the UK without two braking systems (e.g. front brake, rear brake) is illegal, and unusual. Regardless, anyone cycling without a front brake is an idiot.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by gadders on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:49AM (#17734400)
Done. In my day they were called "racers". I'm not au fait with the distinctions on modern types.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by robinwassen on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:00AM (#17731956)
Cyclists usually have a strong pride in commuting with bike and has a style (looking fast) that separates them from the rest of the population.

Combine that with the number of conflict surfaces such as pedestrians walking in biking lanes, car drivers failing to properly look for incoming cyclists, cyclists speeding and more frequently breaking traffic law and order than others (my anecdata).

I understand the frustration that exists in all groups.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by zerebubuth on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:05AM (#17732249)
I wonder if part of the problem might be a natural tendency to generalise bad behaviour of a small number onto the whole group?

For example, I might see several instances of individual cyclists running red lights and generalise that to "all cyclists run red lights". Or see several instances of individual motorists "dooring" cyclists and generalise that to "all motorists are dangerously inconsiderate".

It's probably easy to go from that generalisation to an overt dislike of the other group. Therefore, I try to force myself to attribute bad behaviour to the individual rather than any groups they might be a member of.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Arainach on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:50AM (#17733198)
Part of it is that it's a necessary mindset. When cycling, you have to assume that every driver is trying to kill you and every parked car is waiting to throw a door open and knock you off (and possibly kill you). Even where malicious intent is lacking, distracted driving is such a pervasive problem that you have to adopt a mindset of "everyone else is awful"....because statistically speaking, enough of them really are.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by zerebubuth on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:28PM (#17735690)
I think there's a big difference between "everyone else is awful", "there's statistically enough awful individuals" and "every driver is trying to kill me". Only the last one of those is going to lead me to incorrectly blame a whole group.

I agree that a statistically significant subset of drivers cause problems (and a statistically significant subset of cyclists, too), but the vast majority of individual drivers (and cyclists) are safe and do not deserve to be grouped in with the the problem-causers.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Arainach on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:47PM (#17736613)
They have to be grouped in, as there's no way to differentiate them.

Also, you're proposing a false equivalence. When drivers cause problems, other people (pedestrians, cyclists, other drivers) die. When cyclists cause problems, they're usually the only ones that get hurt. The urgency of the two problems is dramatically different.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by marcandre on Saturday August 11, 2018 @10:14AM (#17739744)
I really wish "a bike running a red light" wasn't seen as such a problem. In many places, pedestrian cross on red lights also. In other places, cars can turn right on red lights. In at least one state, bikes can use red lights as stop signs, and stop signs as yield signs. It is easy run a red light on a bike (or as a pedestrian) in a safe manner, but it often isn't in a car.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by stefan_ on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:27AM (#17732071)
Cyclists speeding? I hope your car is set to a maximum of 20 mph or you might as well join that FB group.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by germinalphrase on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:38AM (#17732124)
We have some shared bike/pedestrian paths that twist and turn through a nice wooded area. The paths have a very well marked 10 mph speed limit; however, there is a certain kind of cyclist that can’t be bothered to slow down and whip through these paths at top speed. 10 mph isn’t all that fast, are these cyclists clearly speeding and putting pedestrians at risk.

Perhaps this is somewhat like what the other commenter insoeaking about.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by robinwassen on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:19AM (#17732306)
They might not be able to break the law enforced speed limit. My definition of speeding is that they go at a speed that is reckless for the situation.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by tonyedgecombe on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:02AM (#17731966)
more frequently breaking traffic law

I can't find it right now but there was some research done in the UK recently that showed the opposite was the case.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by rogual on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:11AM (#17732007)
Surprising. In London at least, when you cross at a crossing, you always have to check for cyclists skipping the lights.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by InitialLastName on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:52AM (#17732185)
Sure, but what % of the drivers habitually go faster than the listed speed limit? In the parts of the US I live in, the difference between that number and 100 is imperceptible, especially on the roads with speed limits on the lower end (~25 mph).
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by pja on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:56AM (#17732206)
IIRC the two road users tended to break the rules in different ways, so it's unsurprising that as a pedestrians you might be more aware of one class than the other.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Symbiote on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:50AM (#17734407)
When I'm in London, I check that the first car is going to stop at the crossing. That's by no means guaranteed.

Once the first car is stopped, the others have no choice. All cyclists reaching the crossing can pass on red if they choose, so the comparison needs to take that into account.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by twak on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:25AM (#17733487)
a counter point: when cycling in London you have to be aware that 30% of the time there will be be a vehicle stopped the protected bike zone in front of the lights...
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by foldr on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:17AM (#17732024)
It's certainly routine to see cyclists running red lights in London. I'm sure cars do that sometimes, but I can't recall ever having seen a car do it while I was crossing the road.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Arnt on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:25AM (#17732058)
Indeed. But if a car does it someone may die. Even a fast cyclist needs a lot of bad luck to run over and kill someone.

Finding a fair way to count these things is really difficult.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by chopin on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:37AM (#17732117)
But you can hit hard enough for lifelong suffering easily. There is no excuse for reckless driving even with a bike.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Arnt on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:42AM (#17732142)
I upvoted this because I probably should've said it myself.

I said in another comment that I think it's really difficult to find a fair way to count. I meant that. I didn't mean "it's difficult to count such that I look like an angel and make that counting mode look fair".

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Steltek on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:51AM (#17733734)
But in this discussion, we're readily avoiding the daily mayhem and death that cars actually perpetrate. A new perspective is seriously in order. Which is most prevalent and presents the greatest risk in an urban environment?

Should bikes yield to pedestrians? Yes, absolutely. Is that equivalent to drivers speeding, swerving, texting, road-raging, etc? Not in the slightest.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by gadders on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:08AM (#17733373)
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Steltek on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:45AM (#17733676)
You're proving his point. It's so rare that it makes national news (or international, when you're an idiot with no brakes). Cars kill dozens of people in the US a day. Bikes kill far less than one person a year.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by DmenshunlAnlsis on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:33AM (#17732105)
A cyclist can cause a swerve and crash, or just be the one killed. You can argue in the latter case that the cyclist is the only one hurt, but fault aside, most people will be devestated if they kill someone else.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:37AM (#17732120)
I‘m really tired of this apology.

Yes, chances are slim you‘re killing a pedestrian. Chances are very real you severely hurt and injure him. Ask the pedestrian how much fun that is.

Those casual dismissals are evil, IMO.

Add to that the attitude that I just read again on Twitter unrelatedly, that pedestrians shouldn‘t blame bicyclists endangering them on pedestrian lanes, because it‘s ultimately the cars‘ fault.

Bicyclists most vocal about traffic issues often don‘t care about weaker participants in traffic when they are not the weaker ones.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by aidos on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:41AM (#17732410)
There are different types of running red lights (and the dangers are country dependent). I myself frequently pull away at the lights while still red a second before they go green. I do it to get out ahead of the traffic for my own safety and to get clear of the traffic so I’m not in the way. This is in London, where all pedestrians are crossing at the same time and there are no cars moving.

The main danger in it is drivers becoming angry (totally irrationally) and reckless.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by foldr on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:33AM (#17732101)
Sure, but cyclists can't use that as an excuse for bad behavior. I mean, if I punch someone, it's unlikely to kill them, but that doesn't mean I can just take a swing at someone whenever I feel like it.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by quicklime on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:20AM (#17732310)
Sure, it's in no way a valid excuse. But one act is much more dangerous than the other - a cyclist running a red light and a driver doing it are not morally equivalent, and it's slightly offensive to cyclists to claim that it is.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:31AM (#17732359)
Of course it is just as dangerous. We‘re not talking about a cyclist killing a car driver, we‘re talking about a cyclist getting killed. That can easily happen with a cyclist running a red light.

I find it strange that cyclists love to discuss things as if bad outcomes to themselves didn‘t matter as long as they are the ones responsible. That‘s no way to sensibly talk about traffic safety.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by pbhjpbhj on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:10AM (#17733385)
At some UK junctions a cyclist riding through red will make virtually no difference to anyone; in the same way as motorist on some sections of motorway (ie freeway), in good conditions, driving over the speed limit will make virtually no difference.

A car jumping the light leaves no room for another car; a cyclist doing it leaves more than enough room.

Yes, if they're busting through a pedestrian crossing with pedestrians on, or going on to a narrow junction, etc.. then you're in to dangers similar to "not indicating" (something that puts me in danger as a pedestrian every day).

A cyclist hitting a car, it's extraordinarily unlikely to kill anyone including themselves. The contrary is not so. That's why cyclists don't worry as much about the possibility of hurting others on the roads. Of course interactions with pedestrians are bad all round, but much worse physically for cyclists than for vehicle drivers.

There are imbalances, ignoring them doesn't make anyone safer.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:38AM (#17733604)
Are you really claiming that a car running a red light with speed v1 and crashing into a cyclist with speed v2 is more dangerous than a cyclist running a red light with speed v2 and crashing into a car with speed v1? That‘s ludicrous. The situations are perfectly symmetrical.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Fishkins on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:15PM (#17735110)
The research I've read recently indicates (responsibly) running red lights and stop signs decreases a cyclist's chance of getting hit. When stopped, a cyclist is less visible and mobile. Vehicles can be less likely to see them, and they're less able to maneuver out of dangerous situations.

http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/ct-bike-st... (I've seen other sources, but this is the first one I found first just now)

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:08PM (#17735551)
That's only a discussion on the probability of a crash. I'm talking about the effect, given a crash has occured.

Because people in this thread claim that it's virtually impossible for a cyclist to get killed when crashing into a car. Only a car crashing into a cyclist could possibly kill the latter.

And that's nonsense.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by dasil003 on Friday August 10, 2018 @10:56AM (#17733791)
There’s a difference between reckless driving/cycling and running a red light. There are in fact many ways to safely or unsafely do so for both types of vehicles. This needs to be acknowledged first, because there are situations where it’s actually safer (getting out of the way of aggro drivers just as the light turns) or necessary (lights only triggered by sensor that doesn’t pick up a bike).
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Tomte on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:35AM (#17734266)
Sure, but who wouldn‘t acknowledge that? Nobody is talking about these edge cases.
Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by arethuza on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:29AM (#17732085)
I remember while I was cycling to work through Edinburgh (and always stopping for lights) a cyclist running through a red light outside a police station with a police car also waiting at the red light.

No idea what he was thinking - the police car did set off in pursuit.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by robinwassen on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:24AM (#17732328)
Might be so statistically, but people do not experience statistics and build their perspective from it.

Emotionally seeing someone running a red light or making up their own lane has a higher impact than someone speeding in a car lane. I think it has to do with cultural acceptance.

Re:The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group by Arnt on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:20AM (#17732039)
It may plausibly depend on how you add your apples and oranges. How are you going to count a traffic accident with two deaths against a bicycle leaning against a shop's display window (that's a really extreme example, yes)?