Ask HN: What is your company's maximum vacation (at one time) policy?
My company (which shall remain nameless for obvious legal reasons) has recently implemented a policy that limits the "maximum amount of vacation time you can take at once" to 2 weeks at a time.
This hasn't affected me (I tend to take vacations shorter than 2 weeks at a time). The policy really seems to disproportionately affect my Indian co-workers -- who save up vacation and tend to take it in 3-4 week increments to visit family overseas.
I started to wonder: Is this a common practice to limit the maximum vacation time that can be taken at once? What is your company's policy on the subject?
(
79 comments
| 38 points
| on HN
)
I do take long weekends and the occational day off beside that though.
Sounds to me like your company got burned by someone taking advantage of their PTO, then overcompensated with this rule.
If your other coworkers aren't happy about it either, band together and bring it up as something to talk about. Explore other solutions together as a company.
Previously, when the vacation time was actually vacation time, you had to get manager approval in advance for anything more than five consecutive business days. For us, it was a matter of filling in a form and getting it rubber-stamped, but I can see how that policy might be more selectively enforced for different classes of worker.
The common practice now is to limit the amount of PTO that accrues per pay period in the first place, and then cap the amount you can bank for the future. I have never had enough to take more than seven consecutive business days at once. And that has happened exactly once.
American employers (overgeneralizing) do not care about employee morale. They will use us up and throw us out if they can. The onus is entirely upon the employee to avoid their own burnout.
The letter-of-the-policy move here would be to take two weeks, work remotely or from a satellite office for one day, then take another two weeks. But I think this company may be treading on thin ice, legally. If the policy de facto discriminates against Indian employees, they may want to consult with an employment-law lawyer.
ps. I have a tool to help workers get the longest possible vacation. Am I allowed to publish the link here?
I don't see why that'd not be allowed -- please do go ahead!
Is there anything in UK law that prevents businesses from requesting that the 5.6 weeks be spread out throughout the year from their employees?
Do enough people take off the day after Thanksgiving that it's considered a holiday? I don't get Black Friday off unless I specifically request it. Otherwise it's just a normal workday (though often the office is empty that day, so I guess it's a distinction without a difference).
At some companies employees with seniority abuse that trick. They use vacation days before and after statutory holidays so it works out to be one long vacation. They often do this when lower ranks don't have first pick forcing them to use bigger blocks of vacation time. It creates a toxic work environment because everyone knows when a holiday is coming up "you know who" will be gone longer.
Yes. If it's your own work, and it meets the rules, you can post it as a "Show HN" too. https://news.ycombinator.com/show
In my division many people take one calendar month off, especially those with family overseas.
I did work one place that mandated you needed to be out of the office for at least 5 consecutive days each calendar year. I'm not sure if it's still required, but there was a banking regulation that mandated it. The rationale was that if you were out of the office for at least a week, it would be harder to commit and easier to discover fraud.
I took a month off for hunting and camping a few years back (possibly a decade ago) and what it amounted to was: go document the little things that no one knows you do to keep the ship afloat and cross train this guy in how to do it.
My last job was at a technology company. While there was no limit of vacation time, the unsaid rule was to limit it to 1.5 week - 2 weekends + 5 days.
The FDIC recommendation: https://www.fdic.gov/news/news/financial/1995/fil9552.html
Or even more, I could get my 6 weeks and negotiate some more unpaid vacation days if/when needed, I know people who took 3+ months off for personal projects.
- you have a certain amount of days off (varies by job, in my case about 40 days a year)
- you have to take 10 days in a row (2 weeks) during the "hot season" (June to September IIRC)
Beside that this is an agreement between you and your boss. I guess it would be illegal to formally set a cap on continous vacation, in practice it may happen but I've never heard of that.
People will typically take 2 to 4 weeks during summer (with an average of 3). In smaller companies one can be forced to go on vacation in August when the company closes.
Is this information outdated/incorrect?
My employer does officially close on some days on Christmas, but you are allowed to work from home (if you have a job where home office is possible).
I took 3 weeks over xmas.
The most annoying thing here is they say they want 4 weeks notice for any vacation, even just a day, however I've not really seen it enforced.
Most companies more lax than that. I have two extra weeks over the mandated, and can take them basically how I want as long I ask in advance.
Employees who have been here for X years (10 for salaried, 13 for hourly) get two months of PTO.
An additional month of PTO can be taken at the same time.
Edited for formatting.
Eg https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights/booking-time-o...
https://worksmart.org.uk/work-rights/hours-and-holidays/holi...
For every day early we delivered a point release, the whole team got double days holiday, half paid for bonus.
Editing got in s twist somehow I have dumped the context in my profile because have to go away just now.