News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nulagrithom on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:20PM (#16216580)
> What future does an asset have if people don't actually buy stuff with it?

I look at it (maybe naively) like a solid gold bar. You're not going to walk in to a convenience store and pay with a bar of solid gold; you might flee the country with one though.

Beyond that, I totally agree with your read on the post. Linking the pull request[0] was especially backhanded. It feels like there's some underlying frustration there that was expounded upon using good references and kind words.

[0]: https://github.com/bitcoin-dot-org/bitcoin.org/pull/2010/fil...

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by EnFinlay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:53PM (#16216966)
Reading your comment finally made it click to me why cryptocurrencies (specifically Bitcoin) are distinct from a gold bar or other non-currency stores of value. A gold bar is going to remain a gold bar forever, people's perception of its value will change even though the supply will remain mostly steady, but it will stay a gold bar no matter what.

Bitcoin may change in value based on perception, it's supply will remain constant after it has all been mined, but it's existence and integrity relies on a large network continuing to exist.

To put it differently, in 50 years a gold bar is a gold bar, but in 50 years a Bitcoin may have no value because everyone stopped mining and the blockchain was destroyed by 51% attacks.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by root_axis on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:00PM (#16217054)
> it's supply will remain constant after it has all been mined

Even this could change if the miners and thought-leaders decide that it should.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by WorldMaker on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:42PM (#16217474)
You can't hard fork gold, either. You don't suddenly wind up with two copies of a gold bar because someone decided to Xerox your ledger to start a new one.

The scarcity of Bitcoins is entirely a cultural delusion.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by milcron on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:06PM (#16218230)
If your payment is denominated in BTC, you can't pay it with BCH even though they're a fork of the same blockchain.

BTC proper is scarce, regardless of how many times the chain is forked.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by root_axis on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:27PM (#16218420)
And "BCH proper" has identical scarcity characteristics to BTC and it's not as if the creation of BCH negatively impacted the price of BTC - suddenly a new "scarce" token was created and everyone who was holding BTC before the fork is $1600 USD per coin richer today. The scarcity aspect is purely a social construct.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by WorldMaker on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:16PM (#16218327)
The distinction between "BTC" and "BCH" (and "BTCS" and "BCD" and so on ad infinitum) is cultural convention. There's no inherent technical merit (or alchemical nature) to one ledger over all other contenders, it's entirely a state of mind of its users.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by milcron on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:17PM (#16219808)
Yes and no. Once the blockchain forks, the distinction between all those coins is very technical. Coins from one ledger cannot be spent on another ledger.

You're right though, cultural convention decides which blockchain is the "real" Bitcoin. Most people are using BTC at the moment, but Bitmain takes payment exclusively in BCH.

This might seem like a semantic quibble, but I think it's important. There will only ever be 21 million BTC, and only ever 21 million BCH. If Bitmain decided to charge 22 million BCH for their latest ASIC miner, nobody would ever be able to pay that bill regardless of how many forks there are.

For a blockchain fork to have any value whatsoever, people need to want to own it. Bitmain ASIC sales are driving demand for BCH. Every other Bitcoin fork is doing rather poorly.

Forks aren't diluting the value of BTC, because people know that BTC is the real asset. Everything else is like fool's gold.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by root_axis on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:15PM (#16220032)
There is no intrinsic property that makes it "the real asset", it is a completely arbitrary distinction based on social coordination not on any fundamental property of the ledger.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by milcron on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @02:19PM (#16225479)
That's true. But regardless of which ledger is "the real asset", there will only be 21 million of that coin.

You can clone the technology, but you can't clone societal acceptance.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by WorldMaker on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @05:07PM (#16226798)
Only supposing there isn't a soft fork accepted by miners upping the maximum limit of coins.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by eric_cc on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:08PM (#16219764)
What you’re saying makes no sense and is in no way shape or form accurate.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by juancampa on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:44PM (#16218021)
Not refuting your point but this could also change for precious metals in the mid/far future: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_mining#Scarcity

"the relative abundance of asteroidal ore gives asteroid mining the potential to provide nearly unlimited resources, which would essentially eliminate scarcity for those materials"

Apparently with the lack of a strong gravity like Earth's to sink down heavy metals, they are way more accessible in smaller bodies like asteroids (Ceres and Vesta maybe?)

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by make3 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @06:17PM (#16218828)
I think thought-leaders just might be the cringiest buzzword being thrown around currently
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by EnFinlay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:03PM (#16217080)
Haha, good point.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:55PM (#16217005)
To be fair, people could also stop thinking gold is worth much. Maybe a modern-day alchemist finally figures out the formula. I don't know. Probably far less likely than the Bitcoin scenarios though.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by michaelbuckbee on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:09PM (#16217143)
Consider aluminium. At one point it was more expensive than gold (due to mining+refining challenges). When those were overcome the cost plummeted to it's current "cheap" level.

Personally, I think a better comparison is to the diamond trade. Through a series of machinations (price fixing, artificial supply constraint, marketing) diamonds are deeply overvalued if you consider just the fundamentals of them - aka they're in a bubble. However, due to those same expertly administered steps they've maintained a high retail value for decades.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:54PM (#16217587)
Yes, I had the same thought about aluminum. Another example is, in older parts of the Iliad, iron is considered a precious metal, while in other parts it is not.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by vkou on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:22PM (#16217274)
But only a one-way retail value. No diamond dealer will give you anything close to their retail price, when you try to sell them diamonds.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Brockenstein on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:42PM (#16217476)
Madden games have the same problem.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:56PM (#16217600)
I always wonder about this when I see films where criminals mastermind a plan to steal diamonds.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by vkou on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:57PM (#16218145)
Films also have criminal masterminds ask undercover police officers "Are you a cop?", followed by a tense musical score, and a close-up shot of the cop's face...

And a "Ha, ha, just kidding, of course you're not a cop."

Crime dramas and action films tend to have an incredibly poor understanding of money, crime, policing, and Newton's laws of physics.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Trundle on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:40PM (#16217992)
Significant diamonds still hold their value when resold.

It's kind of like art. Spend $5k on some locals work and you might get $50 at a garage sale later on if you're lucky. Spend $5mil on a big name and you'll likely make it back, maybe profit, when you move it. The high and low end are basically different products that function differently in the market.

It's only shmucks overpaying for mediocre diamonds that lose out.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by caf on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:29PM (#16219855)
Kind of makes you wonder if some of those films are marketing for the diamond industry.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by kaybe on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:28PM (#16217879)
Maybe they have a diamond shop somewhere.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:44PM (#16218018)
I found that sequel to The Asphalt Jungle a bit less interesting than the original.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by jtbayly on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:00PM (#16217642)
Fascinating point. Could this hold true for Bitcoin in some way, in the future?
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by masklinn on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:59PM (#16217047)
> To be fair, people could also stop thinking gold is worth much.

They've already noted that:

> people's perception of its value will change

But as they say, a gold bar will remain a gold bar, until and unless it is actively destroyed. Not so for bitcoins, which only remain so as long as they're actively maintained (not just individual coins but the mining networks which allows the creation of new transactions)

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by mikeash on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:16PM (#16217215)
I’m not entirely convinced, although I’m partway there. When you “have” a Bitcoin, that means you have the private key to a wallet which the blockchain says has such-and-such amount in it. You can have that even if the miners all disappear. You can still use it to sign transactions, although they won’t get confirmed. You can even confirm them by mining a new block yourself with your transactions in it. (If all the miners are gone, the difficulty has hopefully dropped precipitously. And if not, you could always fork it to have a lower difficulty, since the only thing that stops forks currently is network consensus.)

This doesn’t sound super useful, but it sounds about as useful as a bar of gold in a world where nobody considers gold to be valuable.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by kibwen on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:38PM (#16217434)
> it sounds about as useful as a bar of gold in a world where nobody considers gold to be valuable

Nah, if civilization collapses then you'll still be able to use your bar of gold to bash in someone's skull and steal their canned beans (which, in the grim solar-flare induced darkness of 2020, will be worth their weight in bitcoins).

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by mikeash on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:45PM (#16217499)
Bitcoin wallets have to be stored on something. Maybe there’s an untapped market for really sturdy and massive hardware wallets.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by scoggs on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:31PM (#16219590)
You just sent me down a 3 minute rabbit hole / day dream about Wall-E, the last robot in the universe connected to the blockchain quietly and very easily mining coins from every type of crytocurrency created over the centuries since the early 2000's. Thanks!
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by bradjohnson on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:29PM (#16218441)
If the miners are all gone, there's nothing to stop malicious parties from doing 51% attacks and making the entire thing not only valueless, but also completely unreliable.

At least when you give a person a gold bar, you know that they now have the gold bar.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by masklinn on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:26PM (#16217312)
> If all the miners are gone, the difficulty has hopefully dropped precipitously

AFAIK there is no mechanism for the difficulty of new blocks to fall. And if the only use is creating transactions between yourself and yourself, well you can also collect gravel.

> This doesn’t sound super useful, but it sounds about as useful as a bar of gold in a world where nobody considers gold to be valuable.

Even in a sub-industrial context and ignoring pretty much all of human history and assuming your gold has lost all of its extrinsic worth, your bar of gold could be molded or cast into plenty of useful things (light reflectors, heat shields, baubles, weights). Bitcoins, not so much.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by clarkmoody on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:42PM (#16217477)
Difficulty falls when block times exceed 10 minutes over the adjustment period. It's happened plenty of times in the history of Bitcoin.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by mikeash on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:46PM (#16217522)
The catch is that the difficulty adjustment only happens every ~2k blocks. If a mass exodus of mining capacity happens really quickly, it could leave the network stranded. But if they leave at a reasonable pace, it will ramp down. That’s why I said “hopefully” before.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:04PM (#16217093)
I imagined that was talking about a certain level of fluctuation in the exchange rate of gold to dollars, not a radical change like happened to, say, aluminum (considered rare and precious at the time it was put on top of the Washington Monument; not so much today).
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by egeozcan on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:05PM (#16217102)
How do you think the story would end for gold, if it became unpopular and the exchanges closed? You can sell your gold bar, and you can sell your private key. I see them as the same and no, I don't own Bitcoins.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by masklinn on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:10PM (#16217148)
> You can sell your gold bar, and you can sell your private key. I see them as the same and no, I don't own Bitcoins.

If there's no support network for your bitcoins, their value is 0, exactly. Even if you assume people stop caring for shiny imputrescible metals, its intrinsic property (of being shiny and imputrescible) pretty much ensures there will always be some demand for gold, and thus it will keep a non-zero price. Possibly low, but not actually zero.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by egeozcan on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @05:11AM (#16221617)
I would say, the intrinsic property of gold is insignificant. Other metals which are naturally more abundant and in a usable shape would have more value, in other words, probably you would get more money by selling your monitor stand than a gold bar, if gold were to lose its scarcity.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:57PM (#16217610)
But what does it matter which one has a larger "intrinsic value"? Both prices are determined more by speculation and group consciousness.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by root_axis on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @11:54PM (#16220423)
It matters because one is a physical object with static properties and the other is a digital abstraction with characteristics that can change arbitrarily based on network consensus. One is fundamentally a thing that can be looked at and held, the other isn't even a thing you can know you have without consulting a quorum of nodes about the status of the ledger (for all you know, you don't actually own any tokens because an attacker has stolen them)
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @03:58AM (#16221332)
But what does that matter in a world where people spend numbers on a bank account, never questioning if the money is actually there or not? I fear you are putting too much emphasis on physical things, as if the quality of being "able to be touched" somehow matters in the modern world.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by root_axis on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @11:14AM (#16223819)
And? So what? A bank account is nothing like gold either so that statement is totally meaningless in the context of this thread.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:22PM (#16220060)
> But what does it matter which one has a larger "intrinsic value"?

It matters a lot of part of the reason to invest in them is as a hedge against general collapse of social institutions.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @03:55AM (#16221329)
But are you really hedging against the collpase of _everything_ so that we are at a completely primative level. Or do we mean collapse as in another collapse of the world economy?

If you mean the former, then yes, gold is a good hedge. But if you mean the latter, then I would argue Bitcoin beats gold 100x.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @09:36AM (#16222966)
> But are you really hedging against the collpase of _everything_ so that we are at a completely primative level. Or do we mean collapse as in another collapse of the world economy?

The world economy has never collapsed, and if it did, it would be equivalent to the first option.

If you mean a short-term market downturn like the one that occurred with the ~2009 financial crisis, why would I even bother to hedge against that—and, if I did, why would I use an asset with high volatility to hedge against short-term market movement?

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by sumedh on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:14PM (#16220029)
I think the parent comment is implying that in a worst case scenario bitcoin will be 0 but gold will still be greater than 0.

During such times you need an asset whose value will be greater than 0.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by joshuaduffy on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:18PM (#16217231)
Just look at the gold price over the past 100 years, even the last 10-15 years have seen an modest increase. It will only go up & it is highly unlikely that it won't ever be perceived as the asset compared to other precious metals.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:28PM (#16217341)
> Just look at the gold price over the past 100 years

Or 2,000 years:

"the researchers look at pay for a Roman legionary, in the era of Emperor Augustus (27 B.C.-14 A.D.), who was paid a salary equivalent to 2.31 ounces of gold. A centurion was paid a salary equivalent to 38.58 ounces of gold.

Compared to modern US Army salaries, a private is making 20% more than the legionary, and a captain is making 30% less than the centurion" [1].

A counterpoint can be found in silver, where unexpected Spanish silver production in the New World prompted inflation around the world [2][3].

TL; DR For historical reasons, gold is grandfathered into our collective consciousness.

[1] http://www.mining.com/what-a-roman-centurions-pay-says-about...

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/mar/21/story-of-citi...

[3] http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/chinawh/web/s5/s5_4.html

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by banku_brougham on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:10PM (#16217733)
One of the properties of gold is that it cant be destroyed by chemical reactions. Physical destruction would amount to powderizing and dispersing over an area too wide to re-mine.

There are other ways though: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058150/

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by banku_brougham on Friday February 02, 2018 @03:50PM (#16294104)
FYI the link is to Goldfinger.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Brendinooo on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:01PM (#16217069)
If someone discovers a huge lode or if something crazy happened like the US Government divesting, it could cause a pretty wild swing, in the manner of Mansa Musa's pilgrimage.

Guess it's one of those things that seems impossible, until it isn't.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by drewm1980 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:19PM (#16217806)
Gold is worth a lot less to me now that I've seen what illegal mining of it by narcos is doing to the rainforests in south america.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:34PM (#16217391)
Or we start mining exponentially more of it on asteroids. After all, more than 90% of the Earth’s gold has been mined since 1848.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by tuna-piano on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @07:28PM (#16219271)
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by darethas on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:55PM (#16217588)
It's more likely that technological advances in mining techniques allow us to extract the millions of tons of gold closer to the upper mantle.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by sonoffett on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:00PM (#16217053)
Or asteroid mining
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by jokermatt999 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:27PM (#16217329)
Asteroid mining would disrupt the market for many rare elements, but I think it could be less chaotic than people think. It's not going to be like the Gold Rush where a deposit was found and prospectors flocked to it. It'll be a massive undertaking, almost certainly with multiple nations working together to achieve. The time between the project becoming public and the resulting mined resources being delivered would give markets time to settle on a price.

That said, yes, asteroids mining could certainly affect the price of gold, but not necessarily destroy all its value. There's a price floor set by the industrial applications for it.

With BitCoin, there is no floor. If no one wants to buy your BitCoins, you can't do anything else with them. They are just data representing proof of work, but no outside value.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by roywiggins on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:50PM (#16217562)
Plus, in a world where you can mine asteroids for gold, suddenly there's potential for growth not only on Earth, but in the solar system at large, and there have to be industrial uses of gold on Mars...
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:16PM (#16219797)
It seems like it'd be hard for such a profligate use of petroleum to ever be profitable.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by TeMPOraL on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:43PM (#16217481)
Asteroid mining won't be able to significantly affect prices of gold downwell, definitely not until we bootstrap a real industrial presence in space - with the way we do space today, mission costs would eat up any profit you could make on shipping raw material down.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by desireco42 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:15PM (#16217199)
I think you are not taking into account 'internet time' ie. 2-3 years is huge time span. No one can predict what will happen in that time.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by 0xcafecafe on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:24PM (#16216634)
Gold as a metal has an inherent value though. If not only for jewelry, it also has important uses in electronics. The value associated with bitcoin seems purely sentimental.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by marshray on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:37PM (#16216808)
Very little though. If the demand for gold were merely industrial it would not need to be mined in such quantities as it has throughout history. I would put jewelry in the 'sentimental' category as well.

Not only is Bitcoin purely sentimental, it represents has huge costs in the form of raw energy.

Bitcoin's only claim to value is that it is an artifact of an act of ritual sacrifice. One might imagine a precedent in some system of tokens issued by some ancient priesthood.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by CPLX on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:51PM (#16216951)
Gold has "real" demand though in jewelry. It's distributed and longstanding and it has utility. People wear it and use it in real life and value it and wish to keep it in order to look at it and possess it.

That's as tangible as anything else. Nobody would say that there's no demand for musical instruments, or baseballs, because they are optional parts of life that aren't food or shelter.

Gold has intrinsic value in part because people seem to intrinsically like it for what it actually is, not just it's utility in exchange. That's fundamentally different.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nerfhammer on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:27PM (#16217327)
the modifier "intrinsic" doesn't add anything though. "people intrinsically like" --> "people like"; "gold is intrinsically valued" --> "gold is valued".

"intrinsic" seems to imply an innate persistence despite not being able to justify such innateness, just empirical persistence. It just implies things that are arguably not justifiable needlessly. gold has been persistently valuable. The universe doesn't give it an innate value.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by marshray on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:59PM (#16217630)
'Intrinsic' here means that the property of the object remains even if people's preferences and culture change. Gold's utility for electronic applications is a fundamental property of the number of atoms in its nucleus, whereas there have been cultures that had it readily available yet didn't find it particularly desirable for jewelry.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by CPLX on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:37PM (#16218527)
That's nonsense. People's long term interest in electronics is far more unproven and fleeting at this point than their interest in gold.

Seeing as how cultures that considered gold a highly valued item developed independently in Europe and uncontacted pre-Columbian America, and the preference remains global today, there's clearly something durable about this concept.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nerfhammer on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @12:05AM (#16220474)
gold has intrinsic physical properties, yes. that does not imply a particular intrinsic value to humans relative to other things humans could be exchanging things for.

you could say that the reasons for valuing gold probably aren't going to go away anytime soon as far as anyone can guess. though even then, the market value of gold has fluctuated by a factor of like 10 in recent history as the durable abstract reasons for wanting it have not apparently changed as much. did anything intrinsic about gold change from 1980-1981, when the price crashed 82%?

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by masklinn on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:00PM (#16217058)
marshray never denied any of that, they just pointed out that the intrinsic value of gold is significantly lower than their valuation.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by ricardobeat on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:31PM (#16217361)
Being valued by people 'liking it' is exactly the opposite of _intrinsic value_.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Retric on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:49PM (#16216921)
Electronics industry actually uses a lot of gold as in 100's of tons. It's use is mostly limited by price so expect increased demand as the price drops.

It's not clear how much demand for gold would increase at say 1/10th the price, but based on other commodities we would probably use more than 10x as much would would represent a solid price floor.

Bitcoin on the other hand has no price floor and can effectively go to zero. Though, in practice much like beanie baby's or other fads people are likely to hold on to good vs sell it for 1/1,000th the price hopping for a comeback. You would expect long term bitcoin sales below 1 cent per coin to be very rare until eventually the network collapses.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by emodendroket on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:56PM (#16217015)
> Not only is Bitcoin purely sentimental, it represents has huge costs in the form of raw energy.

> Bitcoin's only claim to value is that it is an artifact of an act of ritual sacrifice. One might imagine a precedent in some system of tokens issued by some ancient priesthood.

I mean, in this respect the analogy to gold is not an awful fit.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by alanfalcon on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:41PM (#16216853)
I love this imagery. Probably what Neal Stephenson was going for in Reamde, though your simple analogy resonates with me more.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by smogcutter on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:02PM (#16217077)
Someone's been reading their Georges Bataille...

Edit for less smug more content: sacrifice is an interesting lens through which to look at bitcoin. You could argue that burning "excess" compute power is the real point, not the tokens.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by walterbell on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:01PM (#16218195)
It's not excess/surplus when computed on mining-specific ASICs.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by smogcutter on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:39PM (#16218549)
On the contrary, it's even more so (with regard to this line of argument). That capital could've become any number of things instead.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by walterbell on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:42PM (#16216858)
Has the ritual sacrifice angle been explored elsewhere? Would make for good video.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by roywiggins on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:54PM (#16217582)
Charles Stross' Laundry novels, at least, posit a connection between number-crunching and the occult, though unfortunately the series predates Bitcoin, which would have been perfect fodder.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by loeg on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:54PM (#16216989)
In the TV show "Sherlock," the titular main character's self-deprecating videos for the "Everyone" collective (spoof on Anonymous) are a sort of ritual sacrifice as a medium of payment.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by pwinnski on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:22PM (#16217269)
I think you're meaning to reference "Elementary," the other show about Sherlock Holmes.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by loeg on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @02:14AM (#16220957)
Ah, you're absolutely right.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by PascLeRasc on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:46PM (#16216890)
Wait until the Vatican announces their ICO IndulgenceCoin
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by LeonM on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:35PM (#16216779)
So is gold. Most gold ends up in vaults (see [0]), where absolutely nothing is done with it. If we would price it for practical stuff (for it's thermal and electric properties), it would be worth much, much less.

Also, gold is not scarce by any means, just expensive to mine.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CTtf5s2HFkA

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by teilo on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:49PM (#16216920)
The difference is that cryptocurrency is ephemeral, and gold is not. One can create a new crypto-currency at any time. One cannot conjure up gold at any time. Crypto-currency can be wiped out with a hard drive crash or a lost password because it is a social contract. Gold cannot because it is physical. That still makes a difference.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:00PM (#16217637)
..What?

1. You can't create new bitcoin at any time - not after all blocks are mined 2. Same as bitcoin, Gold needs to be mined. This is basically "conjuring" gold. 3. Wiped cryptocurrency can be returned. 4. Gold can be destroyed as well.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:03PM (#16217665)
> You can't create new bitcoin at any time - not after all blocks are mined

Bitcoin Cash did exactly that. New value was conjured up out of nowhere - Bitcoin didn't drop, and every owner of a Bitcoin suddenly had $2-3k worth of Bitcoin Cash.

> Wiped cryptocurrency can be returned.

... What? Are you sitting on a SHA-256 exploit we don't know about?

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @03:50AM (#16221310)
Bitcoin Cash is not Bitcoin. It did not create new Bitcoin. It created another currency called Bitcoin Cash. Not sure what is so hard to understand from this.

Let me break it up to you again:

1. Bitcoin (In it's current form) has a limited supply. If nothing changes, there will be a time when new Bitcoin cannot be mined anymore.

2. Forking Bitcoin does not mean new Bitcoin is created. You are confusing value and supply. Forking creates an alternative currency (which can be called anything you want) that uses the former ledger of Bitcoin to distribute its initial wealth.

3. It is not a guarantee that addresses with lost secrets will be lost forever. Like you said, SHA256 exploits, or maybe quantum computing would be able to recover them.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by ceejayoz on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @10:01AM (#16223164)
When the fork occurred, Bitcoin's value didn't drop, and Bitcoin Cash's market cap was instantly in the billions. Everyone suddenly had more funny money, but we're somehow supposed to believe "Bitcoin isn't inflationary!" still holds.

It's going to get really exciting at tax time, when people declare bankruptcy, go into a nursing home and need to prove they don't have assets for Medicaid, etc.

> Like you said, SHA256 exploits, or maybe quantum computing would be able to recover them.

That's an insane defense of the point. Sure, if that stuff happens, you'll be able to retrieve lost coins. And non-lost coins. So will everyone else. Bitcoin's value would be instantly zero.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by conanbatt on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:59PM (#16218177)
New value was not conjured up. A new crypto was created, but the value of it was proportional to its expected use and some other features. There are plenty of bitcoin forks, but you dont hear about the other ones as much because they flopped entirely.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Aunche on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:10PM (#16219490)
Most gold ends up in jewelry. I can't find a good source, but only a small fraction of the world's 187,000 tons of gold is held in gold reserves.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_reserve

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nxsynonym on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:29PM (#16216695)
This is why I hate the comparison of crypto to gold or any other "value asset'.

Houses are lived in. Stocks act as a cashflow for companies. Even if the world economy collapses you can still use a solid gold bar as a blunt instrument to kill an animal and eat it.

Cryptocurrencies have exactly 0 secondary uses.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by criddell on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:41PM (#16216850)
What's the secondary use of all the shares of AMZN one might have in their eTrade account? That's also just data, right?
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by ggg9990 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:51PM (#16216943)
The United States government enforces, with lethal weapons, the right of Amazon shareholders to Amazon’s assets.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by schoen on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:55PM (#16217000)
I guess their secondary use is offering them in support of a prospective acquisition (or dissolution) of Amazon, in exchange for which the acquirer or trustee would offer some other value at that time.

These events both seem very unlikely right now, but they provide a last-resort value for an ownership interest in Amazon.

(I don't mean to support other people in this thread who are criticizing cryptocurrencies for their lack of inherent value, but stocks do have a particular basis for their value that cryptocurrencies commonly don't.)

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by notatoad on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:49PM (#16216924)
the value backing AMZN shares is the value of the utility that amazon, inc provides to society.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by neosavvy on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:00PM (#16217061)
I agree, I was discussing the total market cap of all coin offerings in general as being around $500B which is just over half of the value of Apple.

I'd take ownership in Apple all day over any coin, as I suspect more people out there value the Apple Stock over the ever-increasingly tough to exchange Bitcoin.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nxsynonym on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:54PM (#16216984)
Exactly. The value of the shares are tied directly to the output and monetary value of the company they are backing - and not hype and word-of-mouth.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by notatoad on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:24PM (#16217294)
there's definitely some hype and word of mouth involved in corporate valuations. but it's at least somewhat based in reality.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by criddell on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:47PM (#16218622)
Yeah but if the world economy collapses so completely that the main value of gold is as a weapon to hit people with, your shares of Amazon will probably be about as useful as your Bitcoin wallet.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by dr_win on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @07:52PM (#16219399)
Bitcoin token's (secondary) value is the right/ability to write a new row into a global eternal immutable append-only decentralised censorship-proof spreadsheet table (blockchain). It is valuable not only in economic context to create a border-less cash-like digital commodity. It could be used for proof of publication or proof of existence and in many other useful ways (smart contracts).

In other words, owning a non-dust amount of Satoshis gives you some useful property. Anything scarce and useful will have value and market will price it. Anything with a price and good properties to become means of exchange, unit of account or store of value could under some circumstances become a form of money.

Similar as with gold. You can use it in electro-industry. That's its secondary value for people who see value in electronic devices. If you were to explain why gold is valuable in electro-industry to a member of native african tribe, he would not see that value, because electricity and electronic devices is something not considered in his mind. You are in the same boat with Bitcoin here :-)

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by paulddraper on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:50PM (#16216932)
Okay....livestock bludgeoning explains 0.001% of gold's value.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nxsynonym on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:52PM (#16216961)
It's a ridiculous example, of course. But it's something. Not to mention the actual real applications that were mentioned above.

The point is - crypto-currencies are fairy dust. There is nothing real or tangible about them.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by zolthrowaway on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:18PM (#16217240)
I don't have a horse in this race, but what about pyrite? It has most of the aesthetic properties of gold (which I think everyone agrees is where most of the value comes from), but almost none of the value. Pyrite is a real, physical thing that will not disappear tomorrow. However, it has almost no value.

I guess what I am trying to say is that there is a lot more that goes into value than utility. That's why I do not think that people always act rationally. Clearly there is something irrational about people's relationship with gold that makes it valuable. I don't see why crypto cannot have a similar irrational evaluation. Sure, it could go "poof" tomorrow, but I don't know if that will stop people from seeing it as valuable.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:50PM (#16217560)
IIRC pyrite does not possess the important qualities of gold aside from sort of looking like it. For example, you can't make it into a chain like you can with gold. For jewelry you're limited mostly to using it as a rock.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:59PM (#16218713)
> but what about pyrite? It has most of the aesthetic properties of gold

Not really. Pyrite has a vaguely similar color to gold and flakes of it can be easily be visually mistaken for gold in certain contexts, it doesn't generally closely resemble gold, even cosmetically.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by noir_lord on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:05PM (#16217097)
> The point is - crypto-currencies are fairy dust. There is nothing real or tangible about them.

Most money in circulation is 0/1's on hard drives.

I'm bearish on cryptocurrencies because frankly the entire thing is hilarious but modern currencies aren't entirely dissimilar.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by wtetzner on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:13PM (#16217758)
> I'm bearish on cryptocurrencies because frankly the entire thing is hilarious but modern currencies aren't entirely dissimilar.

I think this thread started out with someone saying that crypto-currencies aren't very useful as currency, but as assets (like a gold bar) instead. And then it was argued that they're not very good as assets either.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by notahacker on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:16PM (#16217223)
Those 0/1s on hard drives are backed by trillions of dollars of debt and tax obligations people are obliged to trade labour and physical goods for though.

Being backed by demand from the entire economy of a stable polity is certainly better than being backed by sunk (energy) cost fallacy and speculator enthusiasm.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by grahamperich on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:49PM (#16216928)
Gold is not valuable because you can make jewelry with it. Jewelry is valuable because it's made of gold. Important distinction.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by evgen on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:22PM (#16217270)
I believe you are incorrect and have the causality backwards. Gold has several characteristics that, when combined, make it an ideal material for ancient jewellery and whose properties remain to this day. It can be found in its elemental form and is easy to refine using primitive technology. It is extremely malleable and easy to shape for artistic purposes. It’s ductility makes it easy to draw through a die or pound into leaf so it can be made into chain links or leaf to be applied to another material. It resists tarnish and is non-reactive in the presence of most acids. It is rare compared to most other metals available to pre-industrial societies so it has scarcity value. All of these properties make it better than alternatives for jewellery and for thousands of years gold was valuable because it could be made into appealing jewellery while metals of equal rarity were not hoarded and made into jewellery.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by notahacker on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:10PM (#16217150)
Use of gold for jewellery and other status symbols appears to have occurred independently from its use as currency/bullion though (several centuries prior in the case of Eurasian cultures, entirely independently in the case of the Aztecs who used it as jewellery but found the Spanish desire for bullion rather baffling)
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by aje403 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:11PM (#16217160)
A bunch of dudes with spears in separate parts of the globe found some shiny rock that looked really cool. Then they probably started stabbing each other to fight for who gets to keep it. This phenomenon likely continued on for thousands of years, with gradually less spears involved.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by serg_chernata on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:31PM (#16216729)
While true, a gold bar to me has no inherent use. I am not going to smelt it and make jewelry. It is simply a store of value.

I think the gold comparison is quite close.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by EpicEng on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:06PM (#16217108)
But you're not the only person in the world, so I don't see how this is an accurate portrayal at all. To _you_ it's a value store. To electronics companies it's a consumable used in manufacturing. Same to a jeweler, and to a jewelry consumer it's desired.

Crypto has exactly zero real world utility or inherent value. You, Joe Schmoe, do not by yourself and your own desires dictate what does and does not have inherent value.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by mythrwy on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @11:18PM (#16220281)
Abstract mediums of exchange/wealth storage usually decrease in real world utility the more abstracted they become. But they are also more "advanced" so to speak, or useful for modern purposes.

Maybe that's not put very well. Look at it like this.

Primitive civilizations (some of which still exist today) may store their wealth in something like cattle. Often exactly cattle in fact. Obvious real world utility. But cumbersome to trade, can't grow the economy fast, lots of drawbacks and it limit how complex the culture can become.

As civilization gets more complex it moves on to other mediums. Next might be useful metals (tin, bronze, iron). Less immediate use than cattle, slightly more abstracted. Then maybe precious metals or stones, less practical use then the previous stage, even more abstracted. But easier to move around, trade, store and calculate with. Then currency, even more abstracted and even less practical use. Then digital currency in the form IOUs and ledger balances which is essentially what we have now. 0 practical use. Essential for any modern economy.

Point being, "real world use" has nothing to do with value as a currency, a store of wealth or an economic unit in this time and place. The worth is abstracted functionality. And it's entirely possible, in fact even likely in my opinion that blockchains are an evolution along these lines, a next step in abstracting units of trade and ledgers of wealth.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nileshtrivedi on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:22PM (#16217271)
Some tokens have non-zero utility. Example: FileCoin, Ethereum etc.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by oculusthrift on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:23PM (#16217282)
that’s fine. stay away from crypto then.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by EpicEng on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:31PM (#16219587)
well reasoned reply, thanks for that.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by PeterisP on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:24PM (#16217293)
It's like saying a barrel of oil or a truckload of grain have no inherent use, because I'm not personally going to do anything with it.

A gold bar has inherent use because there are (and, more importantly, will be) people who will buy it to smelt it and make jewelry.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by aaroninsf on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:07PM (#16217119)
* except for the bitrot problem

I agree with the observation that the difference is that gold is that which doesn't go away when you stop believing in it. Bitcoin does.

There is a difference between simulated gold, and actual gold, that is. At least, under current conditions.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by richardw on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:27PM (#16217324)
Gold is a greater-fool asset, just like Bitcoin. We buy it hoping a greater fool will pay us more for it later.

Most of the value is what we ascribe to it. Close on 80% is used in jewelry. It doesn't actually make you money, there's no universal law that makes it more valuable over time. It's just stuff we like, same as art or classic cars or Bitcoin. We've just liked it for longer than those things, so we trust it more. but that isn't guaranteed.

You can use non-greater fool assets to make money. A stock is a piece of a business that earned you money over time. A truck can be used to make money. Gold can be fashioned into more-valuable stuff but the real assets are the craftsmanship and tools. Gold is the commodity.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by sumedh on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:19PM (#16220052)
> We buy it hoping a greater fool will pay us more for it later.

Well not exactly, the largest consumer of gold are Indians and they buy gold jewellery to show affluence. Most of the jewellery is passed down generations.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by richardw on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @02:30AM (#16221014)
Even less of an investment then. As an investment it's a greater fool one. If you buy it for non-investment purposes then the investment definition doesn't apply. Same as art or classic cars. If you buy it to resell, that's when it applies. If you buy it as an input into a business process then it doesn't, but that's not the common case.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by chadash on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:08PM (#16217133)
Some things are valuable because of their inherent utility. Soliris (which has the distinction of being one of the world's most expensive drugs) is valuable because it has obvious utility: it treats medical conditions and saves lives. Even if it has inherent value for things like electronics or tooth fillings (it has inherent value for jewelry too, but a large part of why we use it in jewelry is because of its high price), gold is mainly seen as valuable because everyone seems to agree that it's valuable. Even if I live in a culture that doesn't particularly value gold, I know that it has a high market value and I can trade it for things that I do value.

Still, is extremely valuable and has been extremely valuable for hundreds of years. It's got the added benefit of being something that people can show off to display their wealth. Even if it's arbitrary why we value gold in the first place (I think aliens looking at our society would find our gold obsession strange), it's probably not going anywhere as a store of wealth. If I buy gold today, unless Armageddon happens, it's very very likely that it will still be highly valuable in 10 years times.

Bitcoin might be valuable in ten years, but like many manias in the past (for example, tulips in 1637 Holland), its value will probably fade at some point unless it has some inherent usefulness as a medium of trade for other useful goods. Gold might eventually lose it's value as well, but it's been artificially inflated for millennia so I'm not betting on it collapsing anytime soon.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by peterjlee on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:42PM (#16216857)
Whatever inherent value gold has is far below it's current price though. If gold wasn't seen as an asset and was purely valued based on it's utility like iron and copper, it'll be priced far below the current price.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by andybak on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:33PM (#16216753)
> Gold as a metal has an inherent value though.

The price of gold isn't really related to it's use in electronics however.

> The value associated with bitcoin seems purely sentimental.

Scarcity is a factor. Admittedly not all things that are scarce are valuable but it's a necessary precondition.

There are other examples of items that lack inherent utility but have value and they too are often used to store wealth: art, antiques etc. spring to mind.

If everyone decided tomorrow that Ming Vases were rubbish they would cease to be valuable. That's surely as "sentimental" as Bitcoin - value based on scarcity and consensus.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:15PM (#16217206)
The scarcity argument would be great if Bitcoin Cash didn't exist to disprove it.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by stale2002 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:56PM (#16217609)
Dirt also has intrinsic value.

If you don't have enough dirt, then you can't grow food and everyone dies.

But why is dirt not valuable? Well, that's because the supply of dirt vastly outstrips demand.

The same could happen for gold.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by dane-pgp on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:17PM (#16220046)
For completeness, it should also be pointed out that, in the future, the supply of usable (for growing food) dirt maybe be outstripped by demand, making it become more valuable than gold.

Actually, if the price started trending that way, I imagine other factors would have a bigger effect on the economy before it reached that stage.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by piyh on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:31PM (#16216721)
Jewelry doesn't have inherent value. Guns, cars, food and shelter has inherent value. Gold has been a luxury good long before it had any practical applications.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by neosavvy on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:03PM (#16217079)
I do think the value in all these currencies is that it will change the value Banks in general bring to society.

If we see a widely traded and daily useful crypto-currency in use for general goods and services, we'll see a deleveraging of the banking system.

Right now how often do you exchange a real Dollar or Nickel for goods or services. Chances are your token of exchange is your credit or debit card, with a balance maintained by a bank.

Would be very interesting to imagine the world we will live in if the banks are no longer keeping the ledger for society.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:42PM (#16217472)
> If we see a widely traded and daily useful crypto-currency in use for general goods and services, we'll see a deleveraging of the banking system

Based on what? Cryptocurrency markets went from zero to doing practically every financial fraud, scam and deception in the book in a matter of months. Excessive leverage? See Tether. Ponzi scheme? See Bitconnect. Backroom dealing to help the well connected? See Ethereum.

Banks don't lever up, lie about the value of their holdings and borrow short to buy long because they're evil and destructive. They do it because there are massive monetary incentives to do those things. Those same incentives are present in cryptocurrencies. The only difference is the regulators haven't tuned in yet.

> banks are no longer keeping the ledger for society

Banking laws would be updated to regulate Coinbase, Bitfinex, et cetera.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:02PM (#16217659)
Not sure what is your point, could you open a bit?
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:07PM (#16217708)
Cryptocurrencies have prompted central trusted parties which have done everything we don't like banks doing times ten. If cryptocurrencies take over, which is a big if, we'll probably see the same people forming similar institutions with similar behaviors and similar regulators. This isn't because of some unseen conspiracy. It's because banks do the banks things they do because they're incentivized to do them. Those same incentives apply to cryptocurrency exchanges, wallet services, payment processors, et cetera.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by ImSkeptical on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:58PM (#16217039)
If you want to make this argument, then guns, shelter, food etc have no inherent value, if you don't value survival. Gold, and jewelry, have been appreciated for millennia as pretty objects. Pretty objects improve life quality - and so, if you care about life, you can say that gold has some inherent value.

Finally, you could also reduce it to the fact that possession and distribution of pretty objects can increase your likelihood of reproduction. From an evolutionary standpoint, access to reproduction is an inherently valuable thing.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by PascLeRasc on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:45PM (#16216876)
That's only recently. Gold had a perceived asset-value for thousands of years before we knew what electricity was.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by psyc on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:32PM (#16216745)
Its usefulness as a metal/ornament is not why it's priced as it is. That's due to rarity, authenticity, and acceptance as a value store. And that's just another way of saying it's good for debt accounting. Bitcoin, seashells, obsidian, and gold share(d) those properties. The price is what people are willing to pay for N units in the literal or de facto “ledger”.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Goladus on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @09:36AM (#16222961)
The question is, if gold did not have properties that made it useful as an ornament and symbol of high status (and therefore high mate value), would it have ever become accepted as a store of value?
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by oculusthrift on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:21PM (#16217263)
golds inherent value is worth like 10 percent of the value people put in it for speculation purposes. If gold was only used for electronics it’d be worth a lot less. in fact, there are things far rarer than gold and actually used more but worth a lot less.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by nkkollaw on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:29PM (#16216705)
How about stock.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by appleiigs on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:32PM (#16216744)
Not stock. With stock you have a share of physical assets and cash flow.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by UnbornSoul on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:30PM (#16216708)
That's the case now, but that was certainly not the case in the late 19th century when gold fever struck. The only use back then was jewelry and the fact that is was rare.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by kgwgk on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:48PM (#16216913)
Gold has been used in dentistry for centuries (and millenia).
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by janekm on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:47PM (#16216900)
And teeth.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by TeMPOraL on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:38PM (#16217435)
The difference between Bitcoin and gold isn't in how either stores value. It's in maintenance costs.

For gold to retain value, you need to maintain human civilization, so that gold can be used in trade. For Bitcoin, you have to maintain it too, plus you need to keep paying an unbounded, ever-increasing, absurdly high price in energy use. This is IMO why cryptocurrencies are a serious problem, and also why they're unsustainable in the long run.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by Jommi on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:05PM (#16217685)
You're only talking about proof-of-work cryptocurrencies, and bitcoin especially. You should research more on currencies that use a less power intensive PoW algorithm, or a different algorithm altogether that might not use anything more than the energy of one computer.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by peterjlee on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:10PM (#16217147)
I agree with the gold comparison. Gold is priced far higher than it's industrial usefulness because it's seen as an value holding asset.

The properties that make gold a good value holding asset is:

1. It's rare and supply is limited (holds value in low physical volume) 2. It doesn't decay or rust 3. It's easy to split into smaller pieces or combine into a larger one.

Bitcoin is good at all three plus added benefit of easy, fast, cheap global transaction (compared to gold at least).

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by microtherion on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:59PM (#16218708)
I'll grant you (2) and (3), but (1) seems more debatable. Even though the overall number of Bitcoins is fixed (By fiat ;-), cryptocurrencies are multiplying like rabbits. Each Bitcoin fork alone creates 21 million potential new coins. New elements, in contrast, are added rarely, and stable new elements seem rather unlikely at this point.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by joosters on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @06:54PM (#16219070)
'Fraud Protection' ???

I'd love to hear how they think they can justify that.

Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by rb808 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:37PM (#16216814)
Who ever buys a solid gold bar? nobody. Even gold coins etc as an investment are very unusual.
Re:Ending Bitcoin Support by rkuykendall-com on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:53PM (#16216973)
Watch more Fox News and Info Wars. Somebody is paying for all those ads.