News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by scarface74 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:16AM (#15161840)
What incentive would anyone have in making more then 400K a year if you were going to be taxed at 90%?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by wallawe on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:34AM (#15161937)
This is the correct answer, I don't know why you're being downvoted. This would cause people to either (a) leave the country or (b) work until they made their 395k and then stop working for the year.

It's actually quite terrifying that people would advocate for taking up to 90% of someone's income. We need to work on solving inequality but this simply isn't the answer.

Edit: It's also important to remember that taking more money away from the rich, and feeding it into an already broken and inefficient system (our government) does not equate to lifting people out of poverty.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by osteele on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:47AM (#15162032)
"It's actually quite terrifying that people would advocate for taking up to 90% of someone's income."

Interestingly, the top U.S. tax rate from 1951–1963 was >90%, and it was >50% during the half-century from 1932–1986 – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_State...

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by coredog64 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:59AM (#15162103)
And, due to deductions, literally no one paid that rate. Realized tax rate was lower, combined with a bunch of dead weight losses as people optimized for tax avoidance.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:05PM (#15162145)
yes, very few paid the top rate. but that's the point, the excess income was being thrust back into the economy, driving innovation and creating jobs not just languishing in someone's bank account.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:10PM (#15162165)
> thrust back into the economy

This is another variation on the "rich people hoard cash" theory, which is completely false. Rich people invest all of their money back into the economy. Even bank deposits are invested back into the economy (when the bank loans it out).

Scrooge McDuck cash vaults do not exist.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by collyw on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:23PM (#15162243)
Why do tax havens exist then?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:28PM (#15162280)
Reagan didn't get rid of all of the tax shelters. But the idea that tax havens (i.e. tax shelters) are relatively crummy investments remains.

The reason Apple, etc., invest a lot of their cash overseas is not because those are better investments, but because the US corporate taxes are so much higher those foreign investments become more attractive.

Level the taxes, and the money will be reinvested back in the US.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by samsonradu on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:43PM (#15163417)
Media keeps telling us Apple is not investing, but hoarding cash overseas to avoid the taxation. Care to elaborate how and what they are investing in?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:17PM (#15163975)
The media consists of people with journalism degrees, not economics. Such journalists commonly believe in the "cash hoard" theory.

To know what they are investing in, consult the Apple Annual Report, which says. Even if the balance sheet says "cash", what they mean is "bank deposits". Bank deposits get loaned out to others, and those others spend it.

Nobody borrows money in order to hoard a pile of currency.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by collyw on Monday September 04, 2017 @04:35PM (#15170701)
Actually when I started worked for a bank, we got an initial talk on the financial system and how it works. It showed that most companies do reinvest most of the cash or pay it out as dividends, it was pointed out that the exception at the time was Microsoft who basally hoarded it. That was 12 years ago. Now Apple are the bigger player and seem to be doing exactly the same.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by RealityNow on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:56PM (#15162480)
Parking money in index/hedge funds is not "investing it back in the economy". Bank lending is driven by demand, not deposits.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:21PM (#15162598)
> Parking money in index/hedge funds is not "investing it back in the economy".

Of course it is. What do you think those funds invest in? Piles of cash?

> Bank lending is driven by demand, not deposits.

If that were true, banks wouldn't need deposits and certainly wouldn't offer free checking. They're not charities.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by RealityNow on Monday September 04, 2017 @12:51AM (#15165811)
Buying a stock on the secondary stock market is not investing in the economy. Buy that logic, high-frequency traders are investing in the economy.

> If that were true, banks wouldn't need deposits

That doesn't follow from what I said. Banks are required by law to back their loans up with reserves. So when they don't have enough reserves, they borrow on the interbank lending market or from the central bank.

http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarte...

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:34PM (#15170016)
> Buying a stock on the secondary stock market is not investing in the economy.

Of course it is. Buying a piece of a company is investing in it.

> Buy that logic, high-frequency traders are investing in the economy.

And they are - even if they hold a particular stock for a millisecond. The aggregate invested across the market is what matters.

It's a bit like calculus. All those infinitesimal bits add up to real amounts.

> That doesn't follow from what I said.

Maybe you can explain why banks offer free checking.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by RealityNow on Monday September 04, 2017 @10:49PM (#15172168)
Yes, technically buying a stock makes you a part owner of that company. But if the stock is already on the secondary market, you're simply purchasing a piece of ownership from someone else that already exists. This is not an investment in the sense of directly enabling something in the real economy to happen that wouldn't have otherwise (eg. venture capital). Sure you're providing liquidity to a current shareholder, but that's a fairly marginal benefit, and selling your shares will involve taking an equivalent amount of liquidity. This is no more an "investment" in the economy than buying a second-hand home.

The original comment was implying that rich people contribute to the economy by investing their spare savings back into it. I'm not claiming that there's no benefit to buying secondary stocks and derivatives on them, just that this is not even remotely the same in terms of creating economic growth as actually investing in creating new business opportunities and such. It's kind of like saying that trust fund kids who don't work contribute to the economy by spending money. And often this "investment" in the stock market is the mere fueling of bubbles.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by Chris2048 on Monday September 04, 2017 @01:23PM (#15169570)
> Buy that logic, high-frequency traders are investing..

HF traders don't hold for long, so why are they equivalent?

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:20PM (#15162222)
"Rich people invest all of their money back into the economy" - if it really worked like that we wouldn't be discussing inequality.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ChemicalWarfare on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:41PM (#15162371)
not following your logic here.

"investing" != "giving it out". "growing economy" != "less inequality".

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:25PM (#15162256)
I'm curious where you think their money is.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by pcrh on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:01PM (#15162497)
I suspect a lot of it has been invested in overseas locations, including manufacturing operations globally. It may be that the money did indeed "trickle down", but not into the US.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by sokoloff on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:10PM (#15164940)
I agree. If the US makes it even less attractive to invest capital here, do we think we'll get more or less capital investment and job creation here?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:36PM (#15170027)
Yup. Investment flows to where the most returns are, and taxes loom large in such calculations. But that isn't the point here, which is it is invested, not stuffed in a mattress.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:47PM (#15162427)
invested in siloed low risk fixed income vehicles ensuring that the funds don't circulate through the broader economy.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:57PM (#15162487)
The reason fixed income vehicles pay out income is because those funds are spent on productive investments.

So, they do circulate through the broader economy. There's no silo of cash sitting somewhere paying dividends.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ericd on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:38PM (#15163764)
Low risk fixed income doesn't currently keep up with inflation.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by sokoloff on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:11PM (#15164943)
Yes, it does, at least in the case of TIPS:

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/tips.asp

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ericd on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:43PM (#15165562)
Actually, almost by definition TIPS don't, because you're taxed on the inflation adjustment.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ams6110 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:24PM (#15164774)
> languishing in someone's bank account

Money in bank accounts is loaned to others and "thrust back" into the economy.

Money in other investments (stocks, bonds) also funds economic activity.

Your argument only makes sense if the wealthy are hoarding cash under their mattresses, which is not what they do.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by tnzn on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:22AM (#15161868)
Why would anyone need more than 400k a year for himself in the first place though ?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:34AM (#15161939)
To invest in 2 hippies starting a personal computer company in 1976. To invest in 2 guys in starting a search engine in 1996. To invest in a kid in Harvard making a social network in 2004....
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by existencebox on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:48AM (#15162040)
I just _had_ to rebut some of these:

Apple got initial funding of only 250k, and that was split between equity and loan, very feasible even with a 400k yearly cap. (And I'd also note that 10% of "any money over that" still adds up given some of the salaries paid to top execs)

Secondly, Google's initial funding was only 100k in 98` dollars. The significant 25m round was from kleiner perkins and sequoia, and I certainly imagine that corporate funds for investment would not be held to the same limits as personal income tax.

Finally, facebook was bootstrapped out of their own pocket until they got a 500k invesmtent from thiel in 04 $'s. Once again the "big" investment a year later came from a firm.

In all of these cases the initial seed/bootstrapping money would come FAR under the 400k limit expressed, adjusted for inflation, and that assumes people wouldn't both save over multiple years, or that we wouldn't see more reliance on companies rather than individuals in early stage investment if the tax code shifted such that it was more advantageous.

I defend this largely because in my own readings of history I've attributed a large amount of the current economic state to events of the late 70's and 80s, the tax code changes being a major one of them, and I think your points unfairly detract from the validity of reintroducing such tax structures.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:18PM (#15162213)
Great, now rewind and re-run that history but with the Mike Marrkula, Andres Bectolsheim, and Peter Theil being taxed and 90 percent above 400k. How motivated would they have been to risk their capital knowing that 1)They have much less of it 2)What they do make will be taxed at 90 percent 3)Bonds are a safer bet. Further, in this thought experiment, assume that Perkins and Seqouia are much smaller, less successful firms with less money to invest because most wealthy individuals have made the rational choice that risk capital is not worth it.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by existencebox on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:27PM (#15162271)
One would hope that we could draw the appropriate logarithmic taxation curve to constrain risky investment without eliminating it outright. I personally do not see a massive problem with curtailing some of the power/amount of money flowing around in some of these entities; but don't see it as an all or nothing as you suggest.

I'd note however that my original point was to emphasize the smallness of most of the initial investments. One does not need to be a billion dollar entity to have enough diversification in high risk investments to make it a worthwhile component of your portfolio.

(I'd also defend America's ingenuity prior to the advent of VC; we were a pioneer in the sciences and technology long before venture capital was a thing. This is an entirely separate discussion about the viability of various forms of tech. growth stimulus that I'm neither qualified nor desirous to have, but I mention it to suggest that if we've found success in other systems before, there may be reason to experiment further when we observe a clearly deleterious trend in the current state.)

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:11PM (#15162552)
Also, if you could, would you direct me to the sources of some of your readings of history so I can better understand the perspective you presented, especially regarding the 70s and 80s.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:36PM (#15162333)
Im not completely dismissing your argument; I agree with you that something has to be done with unprecedented inequality. Also, Im not suggesting that is an all-or-nothing dichotomy, Im asking you to think of the investor behavioural consequences of that type of tax policy. We of course can never know what those investors would have done given those circumstances, but its important to try to understand what the possibly nonlinear effects would be.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by topdopfrop on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:34PM (#15162319)
And what about all the other companies funded by the same people who funded Apple, Google, and Facebook, that never became profitable? I'm curious how much capital is spent on failures in addition to the companies that pan out.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:47PM (#15162426)
Most ( >85 percent) of venture investments are failures. It's a hits driven business, just like the movies or record labels.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by vanderZwan on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:54AM (#15162079)
Since when do we need investment to come from one person?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:11PM (#15162173)
We don't. But many good investments don't look good at first, and often it has taken a single person to go out on faith to put money into a high risk/high rate of return investment. If their capital gets taxed at a much higher rate, they will more likely be conservative with what they are allowed to keep and wont place risky bets on the future.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by acidburnNSA on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:46AM (#15162026)
True, but also for multiple homes, fancy cars, world travel, etc.

When I worked at a hardware store we had a brochure we could order in a gold-plated Ducane grill for $4 million.

That recent graph showing the top 1% having a 6% wealth growth rate is wholly unsustainable for any society. So there's something to be said for trying to level it off.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aswanson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:50AM (#15162048)
What makes you think the government would be better at job creation through confiscating more capital than individuals who created the wealth redistributing it through investments and purchases? Every summer home or car bought puts people to work as well, its not like the money disappears.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by acidburnNSA on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:09PM (#15162164)
I'm not sure that tasking the government with job creation is a good solution. There are many kinds of wealth redistribution that people are talking about these days and I'm only pointing out that it may be necessary. What fraction of wealth are the richest among us spending and investing rather than saving? Yes Bill Gates and Warren Buffett are saving millions of lives, and yes we have Facebook now. But what should we tell Marta Ramos? Enjoy the $0.50 raise after all that hard work!

If the wealth continues the trend to concentrate at the top then there will be an increasingly large and unhappy group of people who will elect increasingly non-mainstream politicians who promise to help them, eventually leading to who knows what kind of unpleasantries for all.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:13PM (#15162188)
> What fraction of wealth are the richest among us spending and investing rather than saving?

100%. Nobody has a Scrooge McDuck cash vault. Bank deposits are also spent, in the form of depositor's money being loaned out by the bank.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by acidburnNSA on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:04PM (#15162518)
I should said: "Investing in things that help society." Arguably, the bit of money in banks that gets loaned out as mortgages and then repackaged and sold off as mortgage-backed securities which then get bet on with even more leverage as collateralized debt obligations is helping the financial industry middle-men who cash out on the fees a lot.

Obviously the classic depositing/loaning service of banks is essential for progress. But hundreds of billions of those deposits are going to making the rich richer. It would be nice if we could come up with a way to provide capital to people who need it while also maintaining a strong middle class. I don't know how to do this but it's worth talking about.

What I really want to know is how much of people's savings (passively invested in banks and things like index funds) is going to fund things like the new Facebook vs. how much is not really doing that much.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:15PM (#15162571)
> Investing in things that help society.

People tend to invest in things with a high rate of return. That high rate signals it is doing things that people want done and are willing to pay for. I.e. it helps society.

> a way to provide capital to people who need it

That's exactly what banks do. My bank branch is plastered with posters trying to sell a loan to everyone who walks in.

> passively invested in banks and things like index funds

If you're arguing those are not productive investments, I don't think that's very defensible.

> how much is not really doing that much.

If you're arguing that rich people tend to invest in low performing investments, that doesn't make much pragmatic sense. People get rich by investing in highly performing investments, not dogs.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by acidburnNSA on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:53PM (#15163473)
Have you seen The Big Short? It's on Netflix and is pretty good. The CDO manager in it claims that society must value what he does very much because he has an extraordinary net worth [1]. I'm trying to express the point expressed in that scene. You can get very rich and have high net worth while actively hurting most people. Things with high rates of return may be good investments but they may also be massive frauds, as we all learned in 2007.

Banks want people to take out loans because they collect fees and offload the risk via MBS. They give people loans who can't afford them and that's not good for anyone, but then they know they'll get bailed out again if something goes south. None of this is sustainable, healthy, or productive.

[1] https://youtu.be/A25EUhZGBws?t=331

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:15PM (#15163966)
Government bailouts are not free market, and do indeed cause distortion and mis-allocation of investments.

That's not a good argument for raising taxes, though.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:27PM (#15162269)
it's already happened; trump, al-right, etc.. there used to be all these middle class jobs that kept everyone occupied, now without that we have lots of anger and automatic weapons.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:10PM (#15162168)
but that isn't going to produce broad based results. for every vacation home and extra car purchased there's millions being underutilized. the tax policy enacted in 1954 saw to it that those funds were put to good use or taxed aggressively.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by cakedoggie on Monday September 04, 2017 @01:08AM (#15165864)
Because we know what the alternative is, it is happening now.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by chrisco255 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:05PM (#15162852)
So you can sell PayPal one day for $200 million and have the capital to build a space ship company and the first viable fully electric car manufacturer.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by lancewiggs on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:19PM (#15164282)
Sadly Musk is an outlier. Very few entrepreneurs have had his impact on the world.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by chrisco255 on Monday September 04, 2017 @03:25AM (#15166387)
I don't think so. I think most successful entrepreneurs continue to reinvest their profits. They may not do so at the scale of Musk individually, but collectively, the activity of millions of business owners across the U.S., reinvesting their profits and continuing to risk it, has a huge net effect on the economy.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ams6110 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:34PM (#15164803)
Anyone with his wealth is by definition an outlier.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by banned1 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:21PM (#15164762)
What impact?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by layble on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:25AM (#15161891)
$400k adjusted for 1954 dollars would be $3.6M.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mamon on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:14PM (#15162905)
That's for them to decide. Stay away from other people's money and focus on earning your own.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by legendiriz68 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:33AM (#15161935)
To buy(/invest in) stuff? Not your or mine business anyway.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by sw00pur on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:29AM (#15161911)
That's like if you had two cars and the government took one of them. "What do you need two cars for?"
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by adwhit on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:32AM (#15161929)
More like if you had 40 cars and the government said they were going to charge you 90% tax for your 41st.

In other words, nothing like that.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by chrisco255 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:11PM (#15162891)
No, more like we are going to tax you 90% on everything from that point on. 90% is insane, folks. We don't have the same economy or tax laws today that they had in the 50s. You can't ignore what's changed.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by cakedoggie on Monday September 04, 2017 @01:10AM (#15165867)
> 90% is insane, folks.

Why? Why is that the magic number that is insane??

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by hacking_again on Monday September 04, 2017 @01:14AM (#15165877)
even clinically, sane vs. insane is a judgment call
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mnx on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:42AM (#15161997)
400k is not quite 40 cars level of income though. 4 million might be more in that range.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by foepys on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:30AM (#15161922)
No, it would be like I had three big houses, two boats, and 10 cars. What do I need half of this for?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by jfnixon on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:24PM (#15162246)
Bernie Sanders has the 3 houses part of it. Dunno about the boats or cars, but he has the houses. Why don't we ask him why he needs 3 houses?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by JSONwebtoken on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:28PM (#15162637)
Bernie Sanders has three big houses, a boat, several cars, and multi-million dollar book deals. What does he need half that stuff for?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by foepys on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:02PM (#15163176)
I don't know. I'm German and how Americans continue to almost exclusively elect millionaires into federal positions amazes me.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by fapjacks on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:36PM (#15163388)
It's because our system is heavily skewed to reward the biggest campaign spenders.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ams6110 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:35PM (#15164806)
The people who build houses, boats, and cars might be pretty happy about it.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by stale2002 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:47PM (#15163095)
"need" is besides the point.

The point is incentives. People doing work and providing value is a good thing that we don't want to discourage.

There is zero point in doing extra work if it will be taxed at 90%. People would just work for half a year, then take the rest off.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by thescribe on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:11PM (#15163240)
Just like income tax, inflation will eventually push this down to everyone.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:24AM (#15161883)
avoid the taxes by taking the deductions, invest in new jobs and businesses with the possibility if those investments pan out of making even more money.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by eli_gottlieb on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:25PM (#15163327)
Why should people be incentivized to take home more than 400k/year? Why not reinvest that money in the business and have the executives take home only $150k/year?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aoeuasdf1 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:40PM (#15163772)
Suppose you have two options:

- Work for MEGACORP and produce $400k/year of value

- Develop a new business which has a 30% chance of succeeding. If it succeeds, you estimate it will be worth $50M.

Suppose the marginal tax rate for income above $400k/year is 40%, and you want to maximize your expected earnings (say, to donate to a charity you think is particularly effective). Which option is rational?

Now suppose the marginal tax rate for income above $400k/year is 100%. Now no matter how high we change that $50M number to be, it's always better to just work for $MEGACORP, because you get a guaranteed paycheck.

This is known as a distortion, and is the true cost of taxes. I personally don't care too much where the wealth people creates goes, and I'd like to see less income inequality - but let's not kill the golden goose while we're at it. There are far less distortionary taxes than extremely high income tax rates.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by eli_gottlieb on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:00PM (#15164180)
Hypothetical scenarios are only valuable insofar as they're close to reality.

In real life, if I'm taking home $400k/year in salary it's because I'm creating $1 million/year in revenue. Also in real life, a start-up business that will be worth $50 million usually has more like a 1% chance of success, so it's expected value is actually just about 25% more than the proposed salaried job -- less than my value-per-year at my job, actually.

Finally, in real life, most people don't want to maximize expected income -- its buying power in terms of personal needs decreases logarithmically.

Tax law really has little effect once we use a less imaginative scenario.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by aoeuasdf1 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:33PM (#15164358)
If one can create $1 million/year in revenue for $BIGCORP it's completely plausible that they could create $5 million/year in expected value on some better, innovative idea of they own (or a startup's). The only problem is that the second option comes with a double-digit probability of failure. Extremely progressive tax systems artificially distort this decision towards complacency and mediocrity.

You mention people are risk averse (logarithmic utility of money). I posit that that is only true for non-altruists. An altruist prefers to save 10000 lives nearly exactly 10 times as much as they prefer to save 1000 lives. Given a secure enough financial base off of which the logarithmic personal rewards factor is a non-issue, this is the primary driver for plenty of people that I personally know.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by eli_gottlieb on Monday September 04, 2017 @10:04AM (#15168269)
>artificially distort this decision towards complacency and mediocrity.

You seem to be assuming that Starting a Business is always better, more of an achievement, more awesome, than not starting one. I see no reason for this to be true. Maximizing revenue tends to have more to do with building market power than with achieving anything at all.

You're also deliberately shifting the goalposts here. You started out by saying that progressive taxes were bad because they penalize making more money. Now you're saying they're bad because they incentivize complacency and mediocrity, which are life-achievement qualities rather than economic quantities.

It looks like your underlying belief is: "people who make lots of money are heroes, and we need to encourage more people to be heroes, irrespective of what's good for the rest of society."

>Given a secure enough financial base off of which the logarithmic personal rewards factor is a non-issue, this is the primary driver for plenty of people that I personally know.

To be frank, it's their primary excuse for what they really wanted to do, which was to make as much money as possible. After all, how many are giving away their extra money to the most efficient administrator of human-welfare programs around, the state?

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by tpallarino on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:25AM (#15166131)
There's also much less of an incentive to do shitty unethical things if there's a cap on how much you can reasonably make.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by Buttons840 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:37PM (#15162681)
Well. After they've already taken in 400k they could continue to take in money at about 40k per year. If you want to know why people are willing to work for 40k a year, there are lots of people you could ask in our society.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by scarface74 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:46PM (#15163088)
Have you ever thought that while you're looking at 400K a year as excessive, there are millions of people like the janitors who think our $130K+ tech salaries should also be taxed more heavily and redistributed?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by fapjacks on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:41PM (#15163410)
That's part of the problem. Janitors think we're part of the big wealthy one percent, when we're bringing home far more similar wages than the actually wealthy folks. The problem is that the truth differs so greatly from everyone's perception. And how can anybody expect to solve a problem when we can't identify the constituents properly?
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by ericd on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:50PM (#15163830)
The marginal utility of money decreases drastically as you climb, so someone who is already making 400k obviously isn't going to do double the work to make an additional $40k.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by collyw on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:22PM (#15162233)
Tax rates are usually progressive (I think thats the word). So you get taxed the same as everyone else up until a certain point. Only one you are already making "silly money" do you get taxed at 90%
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by dionidium on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:11PM (#15163587)
The incentive to keep 10% of every dollar earned over $400k, obviously.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by lisper on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:24AM (#15161877)
You get to keep 10%. Or you can give the money to charities.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mathiasben on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:25AM (#15161888)
not charities, more like angel investments
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by hasenj on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:28AM (#15161906)
We talk all your things. You get to keep 10%. You should be glad we didn't kill your wife too.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by deepnotderp on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:45PM (#15163806)
See, people aren't advocating such high taxes on people making 400K a year, they're advocating it for people making 4 million+ a year.

This is a major misconception I see on both sides of the argument, (but definitely more of an issue on the "rah rah Laissez-faire crowd") the worry isn't really about the "1%" who are doctors and engineers who make ~$250K/year after working hard, the worry is really the people who make 20 million dollars a year with nowhere near a proportional value add.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by mmierz on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:19AM (#15161852)
Because of the 10% they keep, which can still be a huge sum.
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by dozzie on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:17PM (#15162207)
> What incentive would anyone have in making more then 400K a year if you were going to be taxed at 90%?

I would be quite happy to earn more, and then 400K a year, as you say, even if he was taxed at 90%.

Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by fapjacks on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:44PM (#15163427)
Right, it's so ridiculous that people act like suddenly there would be a dearth of people "willing" to work for $400k salaries. Like raising the tax rate would suddenly dry up the pool of people wanting to be millionaires. Gimme a break!
Re:To Understand Rising Inequality, Consider Janitors by throwawayjava on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:24AM (#15161875)
In addition to the 10 percent cut, "or reinvested" is the answer.