News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by smcg on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @04:50PM (#14807781)
One of the reasons why the Renault Kwid is $4000 is because, well, it uses cheap materials, and with that comes a very bad safety rating. This is enabled by India's nearly non-existent car safety regulations. Everything has a "price".
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by weeksie on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:19PM (#14808042)
Ahhh safety, driving, and the developing world. Ugh. I haven't tested the hypothesis but I think the switch from mopeds to cars has resulted in a huge number of traffic fatalities. This was super evident in Thailand as it's quite clear that non tuk-tuk/rickshaw or motorcycle transport is a very new thing. There's an obliviousness to the fact that they're driving thousands of pounds of steel and nobody else on the road is protected in the same way.

India's drivers are actually pretty awesome, but they've had cars for a lot longer. Still. More people driving and perhaps being the first in their families to actually own a car means bad news.

Not that I see any good solution other than waiting a few generations, widespread driver's ed is probably cost prohibitive. Still. Ugh.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by gnarmis on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @07:14PM (#14808808)
You may find this interesting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...

Sorting by the second column gives a good picture about which country has more dangerous drivers. And Thailand is #2... so your claim tracks well against this reality.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by m_mueller on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:42PM (#14809448)
Also interesting: The US has about two thirds the amount of fatalities by 100k people compared to India. I.e. the US should first improve its own stats before trying to school anyone else, especially considering that countries like the UK show that it could be improved 4-fold.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by swimfar on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:19PM (#14809607)
Comparing fatalities per 100k people seems like a pretty useless statistic when we're talking about safety standards. If you look at fatalities per 100,000 motor vehicles it's 12.9 compared to 130. So 10x as much. An even better statistic to use would be fatalities per 1 billion vehicle miles. But that data isn't available for India.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by jdavis703 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:53PM (#14809738)
Non-motorized transportation options aren't counted in vehicle miles. So accidents involving pedastrians, bicycles and other bystanders would skew this some. Since car accidents don't just hurt other motorists it's useful to measure this against the total population.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by skinnymuch on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:54AM (#14810287)
Is it not useful to look at both the statistic you mention along with the ones you responded to? They may not be equal in importance, but merit some consideration, no?
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by gibberfish on Thursday July 20, 2017 @08:54AM (#14812019)
Also, looking at accidents per distance driven hides hides the fact that more time spent on the road is a societal choice that also leads to more fatalities.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by CalRobert on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:11AM (#14810568)
To get a decent idea of what's going on, you need to know VMT per capita, fatalities per vmt, how many crashes are fatal, and ideally quite a few other things (urban/rural mix, etc.).

One of the best ways to make roads safer would be to just let people drive less. The US has fairly safe roads per VMT (by world standards), but people end up driving a lot more than in most other places, which negates this somewhat.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by m_mueller on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:12AM (#14810794)
I'd argue that even by VMT the US isn't that safe - it's still double the fatalities compared to the UK.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by CalRobert on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:28AM (#14811064)
Agreed - thus my comment that this is comparing to the world. Western Europe has remarkably "safe" roads (scare quotes because we call them safe despite tens of thousands of people dying per year).

Of course, one problem is that despite being a very small percentage of the distance traveled, people walking account for 22% of deaths. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/...

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by weeksie on Thursday July 20, 2017 @11:52AM (#14813533)
HAhahaha, and if you believe Indian government statistics I have a bridge to sell you in Brooklyn . . .
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by threeseed on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:10PM (#14809077)
Those statistics aren't a reflection of who has the better drivers.

If you looked at the page, the road fatalities per 100,000 motor vehicles ranks Thailand somewhere in the middle out of all countries.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by gnarmis on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:11AM (#14810146)
I was considering the first column, which does list Thailand as second highest in terms of road fatalities per 100k inhabitants. By second column, I didn't mean to say skip the column with country names -- that may be the mixup. Here's the source data too: http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/road_safety_st.... I think considering the number of road fatalities and accounting for population seems like a good enough comparative measure.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by seshagiric on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @07:49PM (#14808987)
I wouldn't put much into that data - a number of accidents go unreported by involved parties or not published by govt. for various reasons.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by ploek on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:13AM (#14810572)
For fender benders or even total car writeoffs, sure. But for fatalities? From my admittedly narrow and predominantly first-world view that doesn't sound plausible.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Symbiote on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:45AM (#14810702)
I saw two fatal accidents in Vietnam in the three weeks I was visiting. This wasn't unusual, other tourists saw similar numbers.

I'd guess wealthy drivers simply paid the deceased's family (and the police if necessary), or in other cases the pedestrian or cyclist was blamed entirely and the accident not recorded as a motor vehicle accident.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by threeseed on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:08PM (#14809067)
Not sure what you mean about Thailand and cars. Cars have been popular in popular areas like Bangkok and Udon Thani for well over a decade and it definitely isn't some new thing.

In 2015 they had the largest car industry in SE Asia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_industry_in_Thailan...

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by weeksie on Thursday July 20, 2017 @11:56AM (#14813579)
Thailand is _very recently_ a much more wealthy country than it was even twenty years ago. The per capita car ownership has certainly gone up drastically in the last twenty years, particularly on the islands and more rural areas where the primary form of transport is still mostly tuk tuks and scooters. Automotive manufacturing doesn't necessarily reflect the car ownership of the local population.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by pedalpete on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @07:01PM (#14808752)
Could the answer be to save extra money on the body work and provide less safety for the passengers? I'm wondering if it is like US football compared to rugby. In football the players have so much padding, they run into each other much harder, as they've got protection. In rugby, the players are much more tactical in how they intercept the opposing team.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by greglindahl on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:39PM (#14808215)
Driver's ed isn't cost-prohibitive, wages for drivers' ed instructors are relatively low compared to the price of cars, even these inexpensive cars.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by toomanybeersies on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:24PM (#14808546)
> There's an obliviousness to the fact that they're driving thousands of pounds of steel and nobody else on the road is protected in the same way.

I think they are, they just don't care in that part of the world. I remember in Cambodia seeing the Lexus SUVs constantly almost running pedestrians and riders over, if you can afford a Lexus in Cambodia, you can afford to get out of trouble for running someone over (although most of the owners had drivers, who would end up taking the fall).

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by dageshi on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:52PM (#14808704)
All second hand. I dunno how Lexus got to be the only luxury car in Cambodia (I assume some deal involving Japanese loans for bridges/roads e.t.c) but all those cars are second hand. Still very expensive given the average income in Cambodia but anyone who's got the moeny ends up with a second hand lexus suv.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:44PM (#14809230)
Japanese have strict rules on used cars, meaning all of them wind up going abroad relatively early. I wouldn't be surprised if those lexuses are right hand even though Cambodia is left hand.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by dm319 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:55AM (#14810940)
Reputation - according to the half of my family from Cambodia/Vietnam, Toyota are the Rolls-Royce of the East, Lexus is the luxury division of Toyota. They are also very reliable cars.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by cakedoggie on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:36PM (#14809431)
Do you imagine this is different in any other part of the world? In the West, if you run someone down and even kill them, you will often escape any serious penalty.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by toomanybeersies on Thursday July 20, 2017 @12:38AM (#14810038)
You can't bribe a cop to make a problem go away in the West. Money will get you almost anything in South East Asia, especially in Indochina.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by vetinari on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:33AM (#14811285)
In the west, you don't bribe the cop, you let them do his job. "Problems" like this are being "solved" in another way.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:48PM (#14809711)
What constitutes a "serious penalty" is a function of who you are, how much money you have and who's judging. You and I can probably escape "serious" consequences but most people cannot.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by skinnymuch on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:56AM (#14810295)
I believe all that is already assumed and known by all talking. I assumed people reading also already know that.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:46PM (#14809705)
>More people driving and perhaps being the first in their families to actually own a car means bad news.

Yeah, god forbid the masses get access to effective means of personal transportation. /s

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by jdavis703 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:56PM (#14809748)
Effective means of personal transportation shouldn't mean four wheeled vehicles by default. Bikes, motor scooters, motorcycles, Oneboards, skateboards, etc are all probably much more effective than single occupancy drivers in a 4-5 seat vehicle.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by briandear on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:35AM (#14811291)
When it’s convenient to carry a family’s worth of groceries on a skateboard, perhaps your argument might make sense.

Regarding a skateboard.. seriously? Effective isn’t just about energy consumption, it’s about time as well. A five mile trip on a skateboard doesn’t sound very “effective” and it’s pretty much impossible in a place like India. Riding a bicycle in India (or a motorcycle) is also rather ineffective unless you want to be scorched by the unrelenting sun and covered with the ubiquitous dirt and dust. If you have a child, it becomes even more ridiculous.

For a single person going from point A to B with zero cargo, a bike or motorcycle might be effective, but as a primary means for family transportation, it’s ludicrous.

“Effective” means safe, reliable and multipurpose, not “smallest possible footprint.”

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by jdavis703 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @11:49AM (#14813516)
I guess my four mile commute on a skateboard isn't effective, despite the fact that I'm going faster than the cars and buses stuck in traffic, not to mention pedestrians. Also I can easily fit dinner from the grocery in my backpack.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by dsfyu404ed on Friday July 21, 2017 @12:16PM (#14821681)
Edge

Case

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by thrownblown on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:34PM (#14808174)
the robots will be doing all the driving by then
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by 0x006A on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:23PM (#14808540)
did anyone let a robot try its luck on an urban street in india yet? looking forward to see how that works out... for sure it will need another mode that is more agressive to not just get stuck.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:39PM (#14809440)
Hmm. If the pedestrians know they're not engaged in a dominance game with an aggressive human driver, they might actually be more likely to get out of the way.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by skinnymuch on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:58AM (#14810302)
Why? We don't know what'll happen, but if you know an automated car will stop for you even if you're in the wrong, then why not go for it if you're already in an environment and culture with aggressive pedestrians and drivers.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by CamperBob2 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @02:17AM (#14810385)
Because you'll be more likely to feel sorry for the driver, and less likely to feel defensive.

It will be no more socially acceptable to jaywalk in front of an autonomous car than it would be to cut in line. (And yes, I know, line-cutting is rampant in China... but in India?)

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by 7952 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:50AM (#14811356)
You can easily see it the other way around. That cars act rudely by obstructing pedestrians and "cut the line" continuously. A lot of the paraphernalia in western style roads just reinforces the status of cars at the expense of other users.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by CamperBob2 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @07:47PM (#14817132)
And yet it somehow works in those Western cities, maybe because the people aren't dicks to each other.

But yeah, totally, let's blame cars.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by nsomaru on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:28AM (#14810859)
It's rampant in India. People just ignore you and step in front. They will then pointedly ignore you.

Once in Bangalore airport I brought it to the attention of a guy who just did it, and he said "do you know where you are? You're in India, man."

I love India, but this one aspect is frustrating sometimes. (Along with the mini war that happens when boarding/disembarking local trains)

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by mantas on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:25AM (#14810848)
India is famous for belly-to-back lines. Google images for "india line"
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by briandear on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:45AM (#14811336)
Have you ever been to Delhi or Bombay? Spend 30 seconds on a street there then come back and comment.

There is no “dominance game” – unless you’re trying to dominate the random cows standing in the street, negotiate a path around some random trash fire in the road, avoiding getting ensnarled in a swarm of tuk-tuts or navigating streets with potholes the size of Rhode Island or buses that will deftly try to squeeze you onto the sidewalks without any regard for anything else. Then there is the sea of people flowing along and through the road like refugees fleeing Smyrna.

India is not Brooklyn or San Jose.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Kluny on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:03AM (#14810535)
A car is a tool that a poor family can use to multiply their effectiveness and pull themselves out of poverty. Lots of people are willing to gamble their safety for the chance.

edit: plus, it can hardly be worse than 6 children in a moped... http://www.nydailynews.com/news/overloaded-vehicles-gallery-...

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by pwython on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:05PM (#14807923)
For those in that area that can't afford a safe, reliable car, perhaps it's a step up from a motorbike though. Not to mention, it allows for more passengers in the death trap.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Retric on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:35PM (#14808181)
Depends on top speed. If you moped never breaks 25mph then a car doing 50mph could easily be less safe. It's also much more dangerous to people around you.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by NoPiece on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:39PM (#14808212)
The most reliable mopeds still crash and get hit. Fatalities per mile are greater bicycles and motorcycles than cars.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by apendleton on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:04PM (#14808413)
Fatalities per mile is a tricky metric for comparing across modes, though. At least in the US, people getting cars often comes with adopting a car-centric lifestyle: you move to the suburbs, your commute and trips to the grocery store get significantly longer, etc. This is why fatalities per mile are higher on a bike, but fatalities per trip are actually slightly lower than a car: people with cars take longer trips.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by mastazi on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @11:46PM (#14809893)
> This is why fatalities per mile are higher on a bike, but fatalities per trip are actually slightly lower than a car: people with cars take longer trips.

Maybe I'm just dense but how does that invalidate parent's point? Based on what you are saying (difference in trip length), it appears that fatalities per mile actually does a better job (than fatalities per trip) at representing the relative safety of different classes of vehicles...

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by lmm on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:13AM (#14811216)
The question most people care about is something like "would buying a car make me more or less likely to die". If buying a car means you're safer per-mile but leads you to take longer trips, then not buying a car is safer.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Retric on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:58PM (#14808369)
Depends if you limit it to moped - moped collision then the numbers are different. But a car - moped collision is arguably a car fatality not a moped fatality.

That said walking is very dangerous per mile, but cars get a lot more miles on them.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by agumonkey on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:14AM (#14810803)
I'd be very curious about the stats. Above 35-40 you quickly notice a change in momentum. At least a car might have better brakes and stability.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by gorkonsine on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:51PM (#14808321)
Where?

If you're in a place where everyone drives a moped or bicycle and cars are rare, then mopeds are a lot safer. Stick the moped in traffic surrounded by clueless SUV drivers and now the moped is a death-trap.

Go to a place where everyone rides a bicycle and there's no cars and I guarantee the fatality-per-mile rate is ridiculously low. See downtown Copenhagen for example.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by tinus_hn on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:57AM (#14811381)
In the Netherlands you are about 4 times more likely to be seriously injured or killed due to an accident by distance driven on a moped compared to in a car. This is due to the safety features of cars and to a lesser extent the fact that young people, who end up in a lot of accidents are allowed to ride a moped but not a car.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Retric on Thursday July 20, 2017 @11:19AM (#14813224)
How many of those collisions are with cars?

Because cars kill a lot of pedestrians, but those count more vs people walking than vs people driving due to the relative distances involved.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by tux1968 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:06PM (#14807929)
Although if the alternative is to be riding a moped, and in many cases without a helmet, this still represents a step forward in safety.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by weberc2 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:28PM (#14808566)
For the driver and passengers; not necessarily for pedestrians, cyclists, or mopedestrians/motorcyclists.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by albertgoeswoof on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:37PM (#14808202)
All moped drivers in cities wear helmets, only the passengers don't
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by johnmaguire2013 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:01PM (#14809310)
What? This definitely is not true in the United States. In Michigan, both the driver and passenger are required to wear a helmet on a motorcycle unless they have special medical insurance -- as far as I know, mopeds do not have the same requirement and it is very evident if you spend any time in our cities.

Having a slower vehicle doesn't always mean safer, despite contrary belief -- I can get out of the way of a car merging into my lane far easier on my motorcycle than any moped rider can.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by albertgoeswoof on Thursday July 20, 2017 @02:57AM (#14810521)
In India
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by lucaspiller on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:32PM (#14809412)
Unfortunately this is no different to any other car sold at the same price point in India. There isn't anything special about this price (other than clickbait for Westerners) - other cars like the Suzuki Alto which also don't come with airbags as standard cost the same.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by princekolt on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:25AM (#14811258)
The disruption of the Model 3 (or any Tesla car so far) has never been about being cheap, but just more appealing than the crappy electric cars from before while being, on average, marginally cheaper when you consider the costs of fuel+maintenance. For this only reason the entire premise of this article is already crap. This whole article sounds a lot like a Koch Bros funded piece (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/koch-electric-vehicles_u...).
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by prawn on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:11PM (#14809079)
Almost every month, I think about William Gibson's talk of cardboard car bodies in The Peripheral, and wait to see it eventuate.

If the cars drive themselves and we are then less rushed as we can entertain/work during a drive, will lower speeds be accepted? And if they're safer as a result of the self-driving and lower speed, could a cheaper shell work? And even more so if price is a primary consideration and you don't own the car?

In Australia, a scrape on your car feels like the beginning of the end. In Europe, where people cram into tiny parks out of necessity, bumps and scrapes seem more like a fact of life.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by ido on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:33AM (#14810218)
It is extremely variable in Europe - in Italy most of the cars seem scraped where as in Germany it's more like how you make Australia sound.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by ciconia on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:17AM (#14811027)
Bear in mind that driving conditions in India are very different than those in the western world. From what I've seen when I was there on most roads cars go at 50-60 kph (30-40 mph).
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by puranjay on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:30AM (#14810866)
A car, howsoever unsafe, is still an upgrade from a 2-wheeler.

Given that this car is targeting people who own 2-wheelers and want to upgrade, I'd still say it is a safer option

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by jbmorgado on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:15AM (#14811014)
Not for pedestrians, that's the point.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by harigov on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:24PM (#14808094)
Traffic speed in cities is usually so bad that you will rarely if ever meet with a major accident using these cars. That doesn't mean that safety isn't important. It's just that we are not talking about 70mph American freeway speeds.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by overcast on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:52PM (#14809265)
I spent a month traveling ALL of India last year.

In the immediate cities sure. But go outside to the "highways", and it's like Mad Max out there. Seriously. Everyone is hauling ass on no lane roads, passing each other constantly into oncoming traffic. Also NO ONE wears seat belts. I had to demand them in cars that were picking me up. Usually they were either disconnected, or hiding away never used. It's terrifying.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by apexalpha on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:46AM (#14810707)
You did an entire (sub)continent in one month? Did you spend all your time on the road/tracks?
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by overcast on Thursday July 20, 2017 @07:52AM (#14811616)
Chennai, Pondicherry, Bangalore, Mumbai, Jaipur, Pushkar, Delhi, Noida, Kolkata, and just about every road in between.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by danans on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:37PM (#14808203)
Traffic speed is not constrained on the brand new inter-city freeways being built in India, though. I had that experience as a passenger not too long ago, and the high speeds + Indian driving habits were ... exciting.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by danans on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:48PM (#14809716)
And by exciting, I don't mean fun or pleasant.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by justin66 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:20PM (#14808517)
I wouldn't want to get in a partial-overlap head-on collision in one of these things, at even a third of the speed you're talking about.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:06PM (#14807933)
> One of the reasons why the Renault Kwid is $4000 is because, well, it uses cheap materials, and with that comes a very bad safety rating.

Still, better safety rating than a scooter, and that's the most important part (next to way better emission control, as scooters generally use nasty 2-stroke engines).

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by barrkel on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:55PM (#14808339)
Can you name a 2-stroke model scooter being sold new in India? Everything I can find currently being sold is 4-stroke. In fact AFAICT 2-strokes are illegal to sell new in India.

(Personally I'd rather ride a scooter than drive a tiny car in a dense urban area, because my awareness is much higher on a scooter, and also I've ridden scooters around London for a decade.)

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @07:21PM (#14808849)
TIL. My level of knowledge apparently is at 2014 (e.g. http://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/twostroke-vehicles-are-th...).

The problem is, even if no new ones are sold, there will be a mass of old 2-stroke scooters being used/sold until they break...

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by lmm on Thursday July 20, 2017 @06:15AM (#14811226)
Sure, but comparing a newly-released car to 3+-year-old scooters seems likely to be misleading.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by kamaal on Thursday July 20, 2017 @12:37AM (#14810034)
As an India staying in Bangalore, this is spot on.

There is one more important thing its urban parking spaces. You can never build enough car parking for India's urban population density. This is apart from the fact that scooters give better mileage(Motorcycles even better).

My Bajaj discover 150cc gives 60-70 kilometers/litre.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by chrisseaton on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:23PM (#14808078)
> Still, better safety rating than a scooter

Is it? I mean maybe it is, I don't know, but I'm guessing you don't really know either. I can imagine that maybe a scooter could be safer than a very bad car. You can get crushed in a car, cars go faster, you've got less situational awareness.

I'm not sure this is one of those things that is just obviously true.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by lclarkmichalek on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:51PM (#14808314)
Safety ratings do not account for different speeds, and different driving styles, so it's probably best to assume those are equal, for the sake of the conversion (which is about _safety rating_).

Cars are slow to crush. If you're involved in a collision while on a scooter, you don't have a crumple zone to slow down whatever might be eventually hitting you.

Cars have seatbelts. If you're hit on a scooter, you are more likely to be thrown out of the vehicle, compared to being hit while in a car. Being thrown out of a vehicle is not good for your survival rate.

I actually have no clue what safety features scooters have, if any. Cars have a ton.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by chrisseaton on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:01PM (#14808393)
Maybe on a scooter you can nimbly get out of the way of a situation on a crowded Indian road that in a car you can't. More safety features don't help you if the other option doesn't even have a crash in the first place.

In the UK you can drive a scooter at 16 but not a car until 17. Is that because they are safer for an inexperienced driver and other road users?

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by JamesMcMinn on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:19PM (#14809379)
You can drive a Scooter with a _very_ limited power and top speed at 16. They're safer because they don't go any faster than someone with a road bike can cycle.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Shorel on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:45PM (#14808271)
I drive both, and any car is much safer than the scooter.

But the scooter beats traffic jams.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by alasdair_ on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:45PM (#14809237)
A car is much safer to the DRIVER but it's likely less safe to everyone else on the road.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by Shorel on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:09AM (#14810137)
Not necessarily true.

In my experience, motorcycle riders are much less attentive to blinkers and take a lot more risks on the road.

This affects all drivers.

However, AFAIK, in most of the USA (that's it, not in California) motorcycle riding is a lot more strict, with regard to lane-splitting. Only where lane-splitting is banned I can agree with your point.

In most of the world, where lane-splitting is the norm, my point stands.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:42PM (#14808240)
A car at least can handle potholes etc. while an overlooked pothole, oil spill etc will bring you to fall (and likely injury) on a scooter.

Situational awareness is a thing, though - especially in extremely crowded traffic.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by weeksie on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:19PM (#14808053)
Better safety for the driver of the car, not the poor bastard on a scooter that gets mowed down ;)
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:22PM (#14808074)
If you're on a scooter you get mowed down regardless if the colliding party is a scooter, a car or a truck. And even if the colliding party is a scooter, there's still all the traffic behind it. So it doesn't matter.

That is a job for the government to actually hire and train cops to enforce traffic rules (red lights, DUI, right-of-way)...

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by gorkonsine on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @06:34PM (#14808597)
Cars are generally faster than scooters. If everyone else is driving a scooter too, you're much less likely to get hurt in a crash, or to have a crash, because the energies are much lower and the speeds are much lower (low speeds make it easier to avoid crashes). Also, momentum is a real thing. Getting hit by a scooter at 10mph isn't nearly as bad as getting hit by a truck at 10mph.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by smcg on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:15PM (#14808009)
A valid point. I honestly don't know what is best for India, but the Kwid is a step forward in innovation, at least. It would have been nice if the article covered these points, like some of the others I've read on the Kwid.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by jriot on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:20PM (#14808058)
As long as the consumer is aware of the lack of safety there is no reason why it can't be sold.
Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by nopinsight on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @08:59PM (#14809302)
It is still safer than mopeds, the prevalent alternative for most people there.

Also, if we think of other road users, less safe cars might encourage the driver to drive more carefully and less likely to endanger others.

Edit: I mean that in the context of India where cars, mopeds, bikes, tuk-tuks, and pedestrains intermingle. See the image in the article.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by JamesMcMinn on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:11PM (#14809343)
> Also, if we think of other road users, less safe cars might encourage the driver to drive more carefully and less likely to endanger others.

I really hope you intended this as satire. Over a million people die each year in road traffic accidents because people aren't perfect and have accidents. Feeling safe in a car has very little to do with how safe the car itself it, and more to do with how "normal" travelling in a car feels.

Re:$4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3 by nopinsight on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @09:28PM (#14809404)
If the driver risk compensates, as suggested in research below, the risk to people in the car stays the same by having fewer accidents in less safe cars but the risks to other road users also decrease.

Also, the driving and road culture in most lower income developing countries are very different from those in developed countries.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-lock_braking_system#Eff...

"Anti-lock brakes are the subject of some experiments centred around risk compensation theory, which asserts that drivers adapt to the safety benefit of ABS by driving more aggressively. In a Munich study, half a fleet of taxicabs was equipped with anti-lock brakes, while the other half had conventional brake systems. The crash rate was substantially the same for both types of cab, and Wilde concludes this was due to drivers of ABS-equipped cabs taking more risks, assuming that ABS would take care of them, while the non-ABS drivers drove more carefully since ABS would not be there to help in case of a dangerous situation.[26]"