I suppose once statistics start to prove that these cars are safer than human-driven ones, we can chalk it up to an irrational fear, but for now it seems crazy to me to put my life in the hands of an AI, when a mistake means that I die or kill someone, rather than play the wrong song on Spotify.
I don't fully understand why more effort is not put into a hardware solution, where roads are simply marked up for self-driving vehicles, e.g. magnets lining the lanes or something like that. Of course a more expensive solution, but seems like it would make the vehicles themselves a whole lot simpler and safer. Begin with inner cities, where the area is limited and traffic is most complex.
Do you not drive using only your eyes? If you are not terrified of the sensors, then software? Turing's central belief was that the human brain was 'just' a computer.
Regards doing things like embedding reflectors in roads and other ways to simplify lane holding, completely agree. But we can't forego the cameras etc that deal with situations that don't contain reflectors.
I suppose you could make ML avoid sharp changes in recognition, but I don't trust the current neural-network models to do so reliably.
This is the same thing..
The truth is people really really stuck a driving, but it's easy enough that the vast majority of mistakes don't result in any problems.
For a naive definition of "vaiable" that does not take into account other people that need to use the roadways. A car stopping or even slowing drastically in a lane will have the same negative affect on the transportation system as a minor accident.
Slowing for a turn then deciding to continue on, merging without checking blindspots, running red lights, speeding next to the short on-ramp lane, not following a yield to right turn sign, ignoring people in crosswalks, etc. All of these things happen all the time, I see at least one example every time I go out somewhere.
Now, we could get into hypothetical situations, but the reality is minor accidents are already really common like with so many other things machines can be better than people without being perfect.
I posit now: "as the problems with automated cars become evident, solutions provided will tend towards Skynet as t increases."
There's plenty of conditions that are more difficult to humans: cars that are painted with the same color of asphalt seem to disappear in highways. Also, fog.
Also, I'm more worried about temporary, unexpected configuration of things that suddenly make a NN see something weird.
Humans don't see elephants suddenly because a prior is telling them that an elephant is improbable in that context.
Something like that in a computer system shouldn't be above the current capabilities.
As a human, if you asked me to match these synthetic images to a most-likely real-world match, then my responses will also look "confused."
https://codewords.recurse.com/issues/five/why-do-neural-netw...
Or when the graffiti becomes intentionally malicious (thinking of a variation of Wiley E. Coyote's tricks with paint and solid walls)?
I don't understand where some people get the belief that automated vehicles will suddenly become targets of murderous or sociopathic pranksters?
There is precedent when it comes to the automation of people's jobs (truckers, cab drivers, courier services) and fanatical condemnation of technological advancement; see everything from the Luddite's infamous wooden shoes to the spiking of trees to stop logging.
In the forests near my hometown, some environmental fanatics will string up wire across motorcycle and ATV tracks, or create blockages and attack riders with crowbars and pipes. I wish I were kidding.
As for current graffiti artists - they're taking down stop signs and road markers, defacing handicapped parking signs with stickers, tagging any and all road signs, and so forth. They're minor nuisances for human drivers, who can usually easily identify compensate for such changes. Computers, even those running neural networks, are not able to compensate so easily.
yeah, instead you get hallucinations, muscle twitches, seizures, mental breaks and many more ways a brain can fail to do it's job.
A computer isn't going to look down at a text message on their phone, fall asleep at the wheel, or get in a car while intoxicated. All which occur literally every day. People take driving for granted, because (at least in the US) we have to. Our sprawling suburbs couldn't function without it, so the barrier to entry is simply being a teenager.
Would I completely trust Tesla's auto-driving? No, not at all. But I at least trust them as much as I do an average driver, which is still just barely. The difference with Tesla's system is that one failure leads to improvement of the entire fleet, whereas one human failure maybe improves that one human driver. That means self-driving cars will continuously improve, while humans will just continue to be terrible drivers.
Whereas humans get the same kinds of fatal crashes over, and over, and over...
The Australian government has a "Black Spot" [1] program to provide federal funds (often millions) to fix up locations with a history of crashes. Bet it's cheaper to make those fixes to software.
[1] http://investment.infrastructure.gov.au/funding/blackspots/
For a human, the noise isn't bad recognition, it's corrupted sensor data via distraction. It's one of the most common causes of accidents. For the AI agent an elephant will never appear unless it's been trained to be recognized. More likely it's recognized as an obstacle, which is ok. But keep in mind that years of Google's autonomous vehicle success make this pretty improbable, certainly less than in the average driver.
Much of the fear here is irrational and natural when humans lose control.
I was just answering about the concerns of self-driving systems relying solely (or primarily) on visual data from cameras. It's true this is how humans drive, but human visual system is much more complicated than what the current (published) state of the art in image processing seems to be. I do not trust visual-only systems today (especially if they employ deep learning shenanigans).
I know those problems aren't insurmountable, but I'd feel much safer if they threw in a LIDAR there too.
You'd be surprised. All kinds of conditions can do really weird things to your vision. Migraine auras probably being the most common.
If you take the example of Chess, humans and machines play very different styles. Computers replace predictive understanding with excellent memory and fast search.
Similarly for cars, we want to replace the lack of a powerful predictive model with some compensatory mechanism, such as sophisticated sensors. The problem is that, even with faster reaction times, better sensors and fuller awareness, these cars' compensatory abilities against a lack of powerful predictive models are still far from sufficient.
At this point in time, a car with more sensors and failsafes to augment the human against collision is safer than a self-driving car that depends on a lack of lapses of attention. That depends on proper behavior in the customer. Even dividing tasks, with the human controlling the steering (but allowing the car to takeover when highly certain of danger) and the car controlling acceleration would be safer. This set up acknowledges the human propensity to mind wander when attention is not engaged.
Until self-driving cars no longer require human rescue in difficult situations, one can't rightly say that self-driving software are better drivers than humans.
Sure, it's worse in many other ways.
Another thing is that your eyes can last you 100+ years, technology is not that durable and breaks more often, the objectives in cameras get dirty etc.
The cameras typically aren't as good as human eye, for example there are reports where Tesla wanted to jam into a truck in front only because its back in the camera couldn't be differentiated from the sky.
Yes, relying on cameras only is perfectly fine when you play PS4 game, but when life is on the line you want extra safety checks. Kind of like cars have brakes on every wheel and then also a handbrake. How every car has minimum of 3 stop lights (how often you see that one or more lights are bad in other cars?)
Your belief that we have hard AI (and this is kind of indirectly created by companies like Tesla, Google, Amazon, IBM etc) gives you conclusion that just two cameras should be enough in reality we did not made much progress in that area and instead just concentrated on specialized AI that is capable solving specialized problems, that kind of approach absolutely works better with more sensors.
http://i.imgur.com/fk3OvEW.jpg
This situation generated constant lane departure warnings for the driver.
How would "magnets" be any improvement over visual markings? Is there some sensor that can track magnets at greater distance, or with greater reliability than visual markings?
Besides, how many millions of miles of road would need to be equipped with these magnets around the world? What would that cost? Would it be acceptable that autonomous cars could only drive on roads that have been properly equipped?
It's worth remembering that self-driving AI does not solely rely on lane markings to navigate. It also can see the road edge, follow other vehicles, and cross-reference with a (learned/crowd-sourced) navigation model of the laneway. Additional sensor types, like LIDAR and radar, are often used in addition to cameras.
You can see a lot of this at work, in a complex London traffic environment, in this demo:
Volvo is plugging for magnets in roads in Sweden, so they can find lanes in the snow. It might happen, because it can also be used for snowplow guidance. In heavy-snow areas, posts, poles, and even over-road arrows (Japan uses this in Hokkaido) are placed to provide guidance. It's not intended to replace vision and LIDAR, just as additional guidance hints for bad conditions.
It wouldn't need to do anything but "ping", the battery could last for years. You could even have a mechanism to disable it when the lines are repainted, though normally roads that use the existing version of these reflectors would have them removed when moving lines.
The transmitter would have to be powerful enough to go through a small amount of snow in some states.
The question is can we get the car companies to agree on a standard for this? Would it make sense to put it in the frequency range allocated for vehicle radar systems?
What we get instead is an attempt to define the whole system de jure, including full V2V protocols and specifications.
OK, RF would mean the lane geometry can be "seen" through all weather conditions (fog, snow). But so does precise-enough mapping/fleet learning. Neither would help in detecting traffic and transitory obstacles that might be hidden by that fog - you still need other sensors for that!
A "safe" autonomous vehicle should perhaps simply slow down in adverse weather conditions just as a human driver would. Even without additional sensors, their ability to see through snow and fog is certainly no worse than a humans.
Reading road signs optically is a solved problem. Mobileye and similar systems have been doing this for a decade or more.
Further, it would help learning in limited visibility, although they can already do it by remembering locations of signs (people do that, do autonomous cars store city/state/worldwide road data?)
I'm not sure that's a fair analogy. Without the canal network to cheaply transport goods and resources in bulk, it's hard to imagine how Britain could ever have industrialised to the point where building a railway network became possible in the first place!
Besides, railways did not immediately obsolete the canals as you seem to suggest. Some canals were still being built and extended until the early 1900s (70+ years after the railway boom), and the last commercial freight services lasted until as late as 1970 - suggesting it was really motorways that "killed off" commercial canal traffic.
One key point of difference is that (like road freight) pretty much anyone could operate a freight service using canals, where as the railways were in the hands of a few huge corporations. That meant a lot of niche, point-to-point freight was more viable to transport over water than rail.
They probably use GPS+map for a low resolution location and trajectory planning. Vision should only be used for fine positioning and obstacle detection.
It should probably be both to avoid moving goal posts. That would make even chess algorithms still AI.
Self driving cars and image recognition are both definitely still AI.
"AI" does not typically mean strong or general AI.
This is Los Altos - Los Altos Hills - Palo Alto route to Tesla's HQ on Deer Creek Rd. A very expensive area to live and therefore well maintained.
That's a bit of an overkill.
Regardless, there was two points in the video ~48 sec, and ~1.40 min/sec mark. The car stopped AFTER turning... I thought that was really strange behavior. Then when it passes the pedestrians, it almost went to a complete stop, instead of going slightly to the left and mildly slowly down.
Overall, it's a great case study. I think your criticism is technical snobbery instead of what this means for the average person. The future is here, get ready. When techies complain that someone is doing something with 'x tool' and not 'y tool'...I think those people are just throwing mud around and not actually contributing to the conversation. Build something better if you're going to nitpik over the technical details. It would serve you better and all of humanity.
Here's Tesla's "Autopilot" killing someone.[1] This is the Mobileye "does not recognize obstacles protruding into left edge of lane" bug.
Here's another crash from that defect.[2]
Here's Tesla's "Autopilot" hitting a traffic barrier.[3] Again, it's an obstacle at the left edge of a lane.
This is what happens when you take Level 2 lane-keeping and automatic cruise control and hype it into automatic driving. Other carmakers have offered comparable systems, but with much stronger driver-must-have-hands-on-wheel enforcement. Tesla didn't do that, encouraging drivers to relax and let the computers drive.
Waymo and Volvo take the position that when the automatic system is in control, the manufacturer is responsible. Tesla tries to blame the driver.
(Been there, done that. Ran a DARPA Grand Challenge team 2003-2005. Too old now to work on this.)
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fc0yYJ8-Dyo [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQkx-4pFjus [3] http://video.dailymail.co.uk/video/mol/2017/03/02/5177969943...
Also, what is the car doing at 1:33. It takes a right turn, then just stops in the lane, then proceeds.
This shows why the Tesla approach isn't good enough. The vehicle is on a freeway, an supported environment for the old "Autopilot". Everything is going just fine. Until there's something unexpected the system can't handle, appearing fast enough that the driver couldn't take over in time.
Tesla is somewhere between Level 2 and Level 3. Good enough that the driver is tempted to tune out, not good enough that they can.
[1] http://video.dailymail.co.uk/video/mol/2017/03/02/5177969943...
If you look across the roof of the Tesla it totally failed to imitate the car in front of it too, that's a double fault, it had more than one indication the lane was changing direction.
Here is an article with a bit more info about that crash:
https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/tesla-driver-error-autopi...
There's more like these:
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/oct/21/tesla-aut...
I would love to see some work made towards configuring HOV lanes that many interstates have (toll or otherwise) to have not only clear visible markings but in road indicators to facilitate easier autonomous driving in a more controlled environment.
It would have so much safer to Tesla to have trademarked (not sure of proper legal term) Autopilot for later use and call it CoPilot until its safe on its own
Yet here we are, driving forwards up hills.
Waymo want a system that has a zero accident rate, even if that means it can't operate in the rain.
Perfecting safety on human drivers first is the way to go and will most of the risk of lettings computers drive.
Humans are still better at interpreting many things and probably dealing with weather and construction and when there is no data.
That sounds speculative.
The inputs seem to be road line recognition, optical flow for the road, and solid object recognition, all vision-driven. Object recognition is limited. It doesn't recognize traffic cones as obstacles, either on the road centerline or on the road edge. Nor does it seem to be aware of guard rails or bridge railings just outside the road edge. It probably can't drive around an obstacle; we never see it do that in the video.
This looks like lane following plus smart cruise control plus GPS-based route guidance. That's nice, but it's not good enough that you can go to sleep while it's driving.