News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:07PM (#13878337)
One trouble with fiber is that most people (who have cable) think the cable service they have is "good enough" in terms of performance, but they'd rather pay less for it. In fact, fiber is not that much better than cable, particularly when you factor in that TCP can't move a gigabit per second across the public internet anyway. And particularly when you consider that DOCSIS 3.1 is pretty fast and that cablelabs is working on filling in the gaps such as Full Duplex transmission.

In much of Telco land, however, the problem is that fiber already has competition in the way that your phone company sees it. In my area, a double play costs about $90 a month for 2 Mbps internet. Google Fiber costs less than that, maybe people in my area "should" pay a little more because it costs more to provide, but I can't see it going much past $110 a month (what cable internet would cost for 25x better performance if they ever build out in my valley.) It's not that a fiber service could not be profitable, but it is not a rational decision for a company that can make huge profits by doing nothing.

Another problem is that there is always some new technology that is going to "solve" the problem in the sweet by-in-by so that communities don't show the moral fibre to do the right thing. Google's Willy Wonka approach to fiber optics was one of the first of these, but next it is baloons, then it is WiMax, then it is drones, then it is 4G, then it is 5G, then it is large satellite constellations (if those get built, Elon Musk won't have to bother sending astronauts to the space stations and can head straight for Mars or the Moon because the space station gets shredded by space junk.)

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by mindcrime on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:01PM (#13879276)
One trouble with fiber is that most people (who have cable) think the cable service they have is "good enough" in terms of performance

So wait.. if the customer is satisfied with the service they're receiving (eg, it's "fast enough") then exactly what problem are we trying to solve? The article talks about an "urgent demand" for faster home Internet, but I'm honestly not seeing it. My cable service (from TWC) is "fast enough" to the point that I don't even think about it. I have no idea what bandwidth I have, but I can't recall any time that I felt limited by it.

Would I take 1Gbps (or higher) home service? Sure, I guess. Do I need it? I don't see any reason to say that I do.

Edit: To be fair, I don't live in a rural area. So yes, it is possible that people in rural areas face a more urgent need for higher bandwidth than I do. That said, I grew up in a rural area and when I go home to visit, my friends and family all seem pretty happy with the Internet service they have. So even some rural areas seem to be getting at least a respectable level of service.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by massysett on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:35PM (#13879528)
You're supposed to want "fiber" because it's intrinsically better and shiny and faster. People who write these pieces always assume that we should want "fiber" regardless of what it costs to build, or whether there is demand for it, or how it will improve our lives. The private sector has not found "fiber" to be profitable, so for some reason government should do it because it's inherently good. It never occurs to these "fiber" proponents that maybe "fiber" is not profitable because it's not necessary.

America's wireless operators plow billions into capital investment, because there's market demand for it. That's the future. "Fiber" inspires geek fetishes because it's fast. Non-geeks on the other hand are using their phones to watch video and don't care about the alleged goodness of "fiber". After all, if they did care, FiOS would be expanding and Google would add more Fiber cities.

Government investment in FTTH is a twenty-first century boondoggle waiting to happen. It's nowhere near my list of beneficial things government could do if it wants to start plowing billions of dollars into capital investment.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by adventured on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @10:01PM (#13881760)
There have been numerous studies done on the economic benefits to having broadly deployed, super fast wired Internet. The results are always the same: the economic benefits are dramatically underwhelming. It's true in Romania, Netherlands, Latvia and it's just as true in Kansas City [1]. Finland has had among the fastest Internet speeds for years - they've been stuck in a decade long near-depression economically and could hardly be further away from being in a tech boom from their high average access speeds. So where is the evidence to support the societal benefit of going from good speeds, to extremely high speeds? I've seen no evidence for it over the last decade anywhere on the planet.

For now, it turns out anything beyond ~50 to ~100mbps, is practically useless for consumers in delivering a big leap in productivity or quality of life. That has been the case for a decade (despite the propaganda in favor of spending a trillion dollars so everyone can have 1gbps tomorrow). South Korea for example has had among the fastest wired Internet speeds on the planet for a long time, it hasn't turned them into the next economic juggernaut in any regard (GDP per capita lower than Puerto Rico).

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2017-02-28/why-it-s-...

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by Ygg2 on Thursday March 16, 2017 @08:36AM (#13884479)
Romania switched to fiber for economic reasons. People were stealing and selling copper wires.

Optic cables don't have equivalent black market.

Source: Romanian I worked with.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by zanny on Thursday March 16, 2017 @02:58AM (#13883089)
People didn't know they wanted smartphones until we had them. Or more relevantly, people didn't know how slow their computers were until they got an SSD, and then suddenly mechanical storage was outrageously bad.

Fiber works the same way. There is wild potential for all kinds of new uses for computers if anyone anywhere could transmit at such tremendous data rates, in the same way solid state storage has enabled all matter of technologies through just raw throughput that couldn't be accomplished without it (mainly in the form of the highest definitions of video, or the recording thereof, which are the most common huge-bandwidth consuming tasks for consumers.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by massysett on Thursday March 16, 2017 @05:36AM (#13883688)
Private industry brought us smartphones. Private industry brought us SSDs. Those things are useful. I saw a smartphone and I said "oh, I can get my Gmail on it, cool." I saw SSDs and I said "I won't have to wait while my hard drive spins, cool."

No one has ever told me how my life would be better if I had massive Internet speed. I'm happy with the Internet speed I have now. That's why private investors have not been willing to roll it out, unlike with smartphones or SSDs. Government shouldn't go put up the money either.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by flukus on Thursday March 16, 2017 @01:18AM (#13882725)
In how many places was building copper profitable? If it wasn't for government intervention most of the world would still be waiting for copper connections.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by jedikv on Thursday March 16, 2017 @06:00AM (#13883789)
I'm still waiting on ISPs to make good with the promised infrastructure rollouts when they received all that sweet government subsidies rather than hoarding it.

Hell there's been many times where I thought 'this is good enough' only to have my mind changed when something else improved upon it.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:53PM (#13879676)
FiOS would be expanding if they charged a reasonable price for bottom tier service. I have a FiOS modem in my apartment and get tons of flashy junk mail urging me to sign up. No way will I ever pay for that when cable is good enough.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:14PM (#13879846)
What is a "reasonable price?" It doesn't cost appreciably less for Verizon to wire up a 50/50 customer versus a 500/500 customer. The average FiOS customer spends about $110 per month, and even with that Verizon's wireline division only makes 2-5% operating profit each quarter.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by jseliger on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:40PM (#13880061)
Yes, exactly. In NYC, RCN is charging around $70/mo for 330 mbs down and something like 20 or 30 mbs/sec up. IIRC cable latency is very slightly worse than fiber. Still, Verizon charges well over $100 for more than 100 or 150 mbs down, and they are very keen on two-year contracts. No thanks.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by maksimum on Thursday March 16, 2017 @01:14AM (#13882714)
Do you also believe that investment into physical transportation infrastructure is "unnecessary"? If not, why do you believe digital transportation infrastructure is less "necessary"?
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by massysett on Thursday March 16, 2017 @05:43AM (#13883722)
I believe such investment with taxpayer dollars could be good, but someone needs to make the case first for why this is an effective use of taxpayer dollars. The only case I ever see is "fiber good, fiber fast," and no one makes the case for how it would make our lives better. Roads, bridges, and railroads have tangible positive impacts. What's the impact of rolling fiber to everybody's door, when many people are already served by hybrid fiber-coax and wireless networks that they find good enough?

Even a case for targeted rural broadband investment would be good, if rural areas lack broadband. Even then, the discussion should be about bringing those areas broadband, not bringing them FTTH. Fiber assumes a single solution to any possible problem...I guess because fiber, oh, that sounds cool.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by braveo on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:06PM (#13879314)
I think it's an issue of being good enough for the types of things we do now. If it got astronomically better, it would enable things that we flat out can't even consider doing nowadays.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rhino369 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:16PM (#13879861)
Plenty of people have it now and there isn't really a killer app for it. Even 4k streaming is only like 20mbit at reasonable quality.

"If you build it, they will come" isn't a good reason for such a large investment.

I think it makes more sense to focus on universal access to 50mbit for every household. Someone going from 600kb/sec DSL or Satellite to 50Mbit is a huge benefit. Going from 50Mbit to 1000mbit have very marginal benefits for a single family home.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by mjevans on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:31PM (#13879991)
Some sources: (video encoding guidelines)

https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/1722171?hl=en

For pre-encoded HDR 1080p Google (youtube) recommends 15Mbps target rate for the video and 0.5Mbps for the audio (5.1). For 4K the numbers go up to as high as 85 and 0.5.

I use a rough rule of thumb that 'livestramed' things at the same quality should be double those bit-rates as a maximum.

This gives:

  FHD 16Mb/s
  4K  86Mb/s
I'd say it's reasonable for a 'single household' to have a number of guests over, say if they're having a party or if relatives are visiting for the holidays. Lets call the peak use 12 guests.

86 * 12 ~= 1032 Mb/s ; Thus Gigabit is NOT overkill. It is capacity and freedom for a small family and some guests to enjoy content and/or collaboration without anyone 'hogging' the connection.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rhino369 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:52PM (#13880184)
12 guests streaming different HDR 4k is a ridiculous edge case.

Nobody is going extra for gigabit just to throw crazy 4k LAN parties.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by hvidgaard on Thursday March 16, 2017 @04:06AM (#13883340)
It's not uncommon to have 4-6 simultaneous streams in a household. Two children with a TV and a tablet each, and the parents watching a movie. And they need to be able to game/browse at the same time.

It may not be what the majority to, but it's a non trivial part of the population.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Thursday March 16, 2017 @10:52AM (#13885461)
4-6 simultaneous streams of what? Browsing and gaming require little bandwidth on a sustained basis. 4K is the only thing that makes a dent in modern broadband connections, and it's not like people can watch more than one of those at a time even if they have multiple devices capable of doing so.

We're a "cord cutter" household with three adults and a four year-old who has her own iPad. I wouldn't be surprised if we were top 1% for bandwidth users. Tops for us is probably one 4K stream (25 mbps), 2 HD stream (5 mbps), and then trivial amounts on top of that from the three adults intermittently playing on their phones. I've got 150/150 now, and will be upgrading to 750/750 when Verizon rolls it out in Annapolis. But really only because I can, not because I can use it.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by hvidgaard on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:15AM (#13892599)
Teenagers stream some series to the TV, watch a twitch on the tablet and game. I kid you not, this seems to be a normal usecase for some teenagers. Thats potentially a 4k and 1080p stream. Have two of those in the house and parents that want to watch a movie. That is, with your numbers of todays streaming, 85mbit, so a 100mbit connection will have very little room for improvement.

And improvements are coming, 4k 60fps HDR streams will come sooner rather than later, and they consume upwards of 100mbit pr stream.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by mjevans on Thursday March 16, 2017 @02:59AM (#13883095)
What about two kids, each of which has two streams up because they're watching different 'sports' (or e-sports) events?

How about someone else installing a game they just got or want to re-install to play with friends?

Like I said, it's about having the capacity to handle the WORST case that could get thrown at it without impacting other users in the house.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by magila on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @06:02PM (#13880263)
The fact that you had to concoct such an absurd scenario to get 1Gbps of throughput kind of hammers home just how far we are from having a real use for such speed.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by adrianratnapala on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:43PM (#13879593)
If it got astronomically better, we could download have even bigger JavaScript frameworks to render magazine articles even slower than is done now.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by TeMPOraL on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:19PM (#13879884)
Infrastructure enabling new uses and more waste seem to be intrinsically connected. The same bandwidth increase that enabled video streaming also enabled clueless people to put multi-megabyte hero images (or even worse, videos!) in their articles.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by ovulator on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:25PM (#13879936)
This is the campaign Google sent out when rolling out Google Fiber, imagine the possibilities.

Okay, get me started, what is something? If they possibilities are endless, there must be a concrete example, right?

When I had a 56.6k modem, I was trying things way beyond it's capabilities as far as sending and receiving large files, playing games online, it was a disaster and there was very obvious and very real problems to be solved. And much more came after that, streaming movies!? Who knew.

With fiber, nothing seems to be coming close to pushing that limit from a consumer perspective. If there was something that was kinda shitty but still works okay on cable, what is it? Or what thing just isn't possible that is waiting for a faster connection?

I have a 25mbps connection, slow cable, and it does everything I need pretty flawlessly. Does it have to buffer sometimes for HD movies? Sure, not worth $50 more a month for that. I don't know what I'm missing out on with my slower connection, and if I am, people are doing a horrible job marketing what that is.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by daurnimator on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:56PM (#13881077)
(I help people get faster internet connections): One common example I run into is people trying to stream IP security cameras to off-site. Once you have more than a couple of cameras then the upload on cable and DSL isn't enough.

Once they get things set up for their cameras, they realise that they can suddenly reliably watch 4K netflix; some have started streaming to twitch/youtube because it costs them nothing, and heaps more.

On the other side of the argument, there is the 'privacy' aspect of things: most people would never run a home server that runs email/social/backup for you (and connect to it from your phone while out and about). However once fast home internet connections are ubiquitous, I fully expect people to start taking back their data from google/facebook/etc of the world

Faster internet is like wider roads: the mere presence of it increases demand.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by wtbob on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @10:52PM (#13882055)
Well, with fibre every light bulb, ever thermostat, every smoke detector in your home could be sending all the details of your personal life to the Cloud! think of the possibilities: unaccountable corporations could analyse and parse your daily habits: your health insurance company could charge you more because you don't leave every morning to go for a run, the local Committee for the Promotion of Virtue & the Prevention of Vice could see when you're watching porn, the local fire department could see when you're using your charcoal grill, the local mafia could break in (because of course those unaccountable corporations are running unpatched and poorly-designed served) and see when you're not at home, and only break in when you're away! The future is now!
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by brians on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:13PM (#13880811)
Lots more devices in your home. Think about how many Tvs some people have. Now consider that many 4K TVs each playing a couple streams.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by mindcrime on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:12PM (#13879357)
Fair enough.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by jackmott on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:13PM (#13879363)
> then exactly what problem are we trying to solve?

speed is fine with big city cable internet, usually customer service, price, etc often is not, and those companies have successfully lobbied to do away with net neutrality so it is going to get worse, and cities where google fiber didn't make it, you have no competitor to turn to, who might offer net-neutral service.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by matwood on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:28PM (#13880910)
> Would I take 1Gbps (or higher) home service? Sure, I guess. Do I need it? I don't see any reason to say that I do.

I agree. I have a 125/25 cable connection and am never yearning for more speed. I would take fiber if I could get it for the same price or less, but I'm certainly not going to pay more today. Of course a killer application could be just around the corner that requires 1gb/1gb.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by dboreham on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @10:28PM (#13881905)
I would love to be able to backup my data (usual collection of photo images and family videos ~4TB) over the public network but the fastest retail connection available here is 100/7 so it would take a very long time.

I agree that download capacity of ~100Mbit is plenty for today's applications.

Yes I can write my data to a hard drive and mail it somewhere, and I do that, but that's not network backup.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by twothamendment on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:14PM (#13880820)
I don't live in a rural area, I'd call it "remote". There are about 20,000 people in the county and I don't live in a town - but I have fiber to my house. I started out with the slowest plan of 20 up and down and haven't seen why I should pay more. Sure a 100 or more would be nice once in a while, but I always get what I pay for and it is "fast enough". I work from home, stream everything I watch and it does the job.

I used to live in a city that didn't have a major telco most people were on one of a handful of small WISPs. Wireless worked OK, a tower could cover entire neighborhoods. I had a 20 up and down plan there, but given the shared nature of wireless I rarely saw it.

Where I'm at now, wireless would never work, too many trees, hills and not enough people. At these distances, copper stinks - so fiber it is. It isn't a company, but a co-op, so prices are reasonable. I'm sure there had to be some grants to get fiber all over the place because I'm not sure it could ever exist without them.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:36PM (#13879536)
The last three places I've lived, I've had the option of either Comcast cable or Verizon FiOS (two apartments, and a house). FiOS is way better (much faster upload, much lower ping times). But Comcast has better television packages so all my neighbors have always stuck with cable.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by jimbokun on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @08:13PM (#13881176)
"So wait.. if the customer is satisfied with the service they're receiving (eg, it's "fast enough") then exactly what problem are we trying to solve?"

Too expensive.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by majormajor on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:24PM (#13878476)
> One trouble with fiber is that most people (who have cable) think the cable service they have is "good enough" in terms of performance, but they'd rather pay less for it.

This is where I am. My local speeds and offerings (cable or a smaller local company with an ethernet jack in the condo's closet) are much better than yours, and I don't really need anything better. The tech to push speed requirements dramatically higher isn't there yet. For one or two people doing some streaming and light downloading, 20Mbps is fine for now, I'd just rather pay $20 than $50. 100Mbps for $50 would probably cover me into the near future for 4K streaming, too, but currently my local providers charge more than that for the faster speeds.

I'm not sure what the next big thing network-usage wise that pushes me to want more than 100Mbps would be. Heck, I was mostly happy at 5-6Mbps cable/DSL speeds for close to a decade before video streaming starting pushing those limits - downloading linux distros or such at those speeds kinda sucked, but I didn't do it that often to justify paying a lot more.

EDIT: the commercial world looks quite a bit different, both in need and demand, so maybe there are more opportunities there, but it also seems pretty well served currently, at least in big cities. I have hardly any direct knowledge, but have been at or heard of quite a few office spaces with direct fiber links to datacenters or such. When I worked in a small town it was much worse (Charter Business Cable wasn't the greatest, there, reliability- or speed-wise, to share across the small office), maybe there's a market there?

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:38PM (#13878594)
Note that the case for fiber in rural areas that don't have cable is that DSL doesn't have a real upgrade path for long distances. (Funny there is a standard for long-range high performance DSL, HDSL, but you've never heard of it because it makes fiber look cheap)

Another story you aren't hearing is that big improvements in communication speeds from current commodity protocols (i.e. 1Gig Ethernet, 4G wireless) aren't practical with Silicon-based technology as we know it, and these things are only likely to get affordable if the industry makes a transition to faster semiconductors such as Indium Phosphide.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by pythonaut_16 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:23PM (#13879426)
It would be a strange turn of events for rural areas to become more desirable to technical people because they are the first to get fiber rollouts due to it being the only upgrade path for those areas.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by ak217 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:13PM (#13879839)
No one in their right mind will plow the insane money into rural areas required to trench fiber to the curb. Meanwhile a quiet revolution is happening with point-to-point wireless, where $300 gets you a gigabit connection over up to 10 miles through a directional antenna that you point at your local water tower or something, where your ISP leases space on the roof.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by dboreham on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:27PM (#13879948)
As someone who has a 10 mile wireless connection that I built myself all I can say is : Hahahahahahahaha. Where do I send my $300?
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by ak217 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:51PM (#13880171)
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by dboreham on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @10:42PM (#13881992)
Well that made me laugh since I actually build and operate wireless networks. Few things you should know:

1. When unlicensed wireless gear vendors talk about throughput, you can typically divide that number by 4 to get a real, achievable full-duplex throughput (because the radios are half-duplex and encoding and packet overhead accounts for roughly another factor of 2). So 750 becomes 150 which is an order of magnitude less than 1GBit.

2. That product has a range of roughly....not very far. You can do the path math yourself from their specs, but let's say it will work at full speed over 1Km. Not 10 miles.

3. To achieve the 750MBits they advertise you need to use 80MHz of contiguous spectrum in the 5GHz unlicensed bands. I will eat my keyboard if you can find a location with a water tower where that much usable spectrum is available.

To push 1GBit FD over 10 miles today needs licensed spectrum and 3' dishes with the associated high cost.

And this is before you have found an ISP willing to give you microwave access to their water tower POP (which they will not do since spectrum is so tight and they are using that tower for their own long-haul P2P links), and willing to sell you 1GBit transit for anything less than a fortune.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by ak217 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @11:05PM (#13882134)
Thanks for the thorough reply. I've looked at how unlicensed links are set up in dense urban settings over about 1 km each, and encountered none of the problems you describe. But I can imagine they become issues over longer distances.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by pythonaut_16 on Thursday March 16, 2017 @03:50PM (#13888532)
It's no more insane than the earlier deployments of electric infrastructure. The only difference is connection has to be made to rest of the internet at some point.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by madengr on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:18PM (#13880843)
SiGe is plenty fast as mmwave ICs are using it. No need for InP. Regular Si CMOS/BiCMOS is able to do 10 Gbps transceivers.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by baddox on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:27PM (#13879006)
> 100Mbps for $50 would probably cover me into the near future for 4K streaming, too

Netflix 4K streaming is only about 15mbps (and looks pretty great), so 100mbps is definitely more than enough.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by ovi256 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:50PM (#13879184)
The 15 Mbps is TCP bandwidth, and the 100 Mbps is physical layer bitrate. They are not comparable. There are overheads and latency and packet loss can reduce how much physical bitrate TCP can use. So the 4k stream may or may not do great in 100mpbs.

Also, how about a second 4k screen ? Multiple TVs are the norm in American homes. How about multiple tablets or mobile devices consuming HD streams ?

It seems current access link infrastructure in the US cannot support current TV viewing habits, if all the TVs were switched to 4k digital streams.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @06:28PM (#13880468)
> The 15 Mbps is TCP bandwidth, and the 100 Mbps is physical layer bitrate. They are not comparable.

In practice TCP gets very close to the link rate unless you have latency much higher than what you typically have on cable/fiber. Fast.com (which "performs a series of downloads from Netflix servers" according to Netflix) benchmarks at 155 mbps on my 150/150 connection. (Cable/fiber systems are usually provisioned at a higher link rate than what is marketed: http://www.dslreports.com/faq/15643).

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by brians on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:15PM (#13880829)
I'm pretty sure fast.com, like Netflix, uses either UDP and its own congestion control or multiple TCP streams, depending on client details.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:19PM (#13880848)
I can get over 150 on single TCP stream tests like dslreports as well.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by dboreham on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:31PM (#13879995)
Netflix won't enable 4K on a 15Mbit connection. Perhaps 50, definitely not 15. Remember they have to allow some headroom and for the possibility of more than one concurrent stream to the same subscriber.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by nitinics on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:51PM (#13879194)
I agree that with better modulation techniques on DOCSIS protocols, you could achieve higher throughput on the downstream.

However, IMO - what should have been the focus for Google Fiber is to come up with applications that consume more upstream traffic. That is where DOCSIS lacks in terms of throughput and a fundamental problem docsis nodes face called "noise funneling". To avoid that - cable companies push fiber nodes closer to last mile.

If Google would have been successful in creating a FTTH marketplace, it wouldn't be that difficult for cable companies to start investing on ONU/ONT and GPON solutions to compete. With competition, Google wouldn't really get the ROI they were expecting unless they really bring about change in applications that utilize the upstream bandwidth heavy.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by myrandomcomment on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:03PM (#13879288)
Not sure about the TCP not moving a gig over the public internet. Care to expand on why you think that?
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by maksimum on Thursday March 16, 2017 @12:58AM (#13882644)
I believe it has to do with the processing power of the intermittent routers/switches able to handle that many packets per second. Not sure how parallelizable ISP-scale switches are though.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by X86BSD on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:44PM (#13878641)
Can you clarify "TCP can't move a gigabit per second across the public internet."

I have google fiber btw and I have gotten a gb/sec from it.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tw04 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:59PM (#13878767)
Single-stream throughput is directly proportional to latency and jitter.

It is nearly impossible to push 1Gb/sec across the public internet because of the latency and jitter that get introduced via physical distance and multiple hops across multiple networks.

Outside of hitting a server within your metro area, and likely on Google's backbone itself, it would be nearly impossible to hit a gigabit (~110MB/sec) of throughput with a single stream of data.

A tool like this does a nice job of doing the math for you: https://www.silver-peak.com/calculator/throughput-calculator

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by greedo on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:08PM (#13878842)
A single stream of data is a bit unimportant, with BT and potentially multiple users on a home network. I'm getting gigE this year, and between 4k streaming, BT, and two teenage daughters, I fully expect to saturate the connection.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tw04 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:23PM (#13878967)
It's not at all unimportant. It's part of the reason people are upset that they paid for XXXMbps connection but "Only get XXXMbps" throughput.

In most households having a limited single-stream throughput isn't a big deal, but it IS a big deal specifically for things like your 4K streaming. It's VERY difficult to do TRUE sustained 4K streaming over any kind of distance. If your ISP happens to have a Netflix caching box at the local pop you're golden. If you need to traverse any kind of distance across the internet - good luck.

edit: I guess I should've also said, more to the point, it's why gigabit hasn't gotten the legs most people were hoping for. When you look at the per-stream throughput on that site - in general if you have any kind of packet loss you're talking about 10Mbps. Who has 100 different streams in an average household???

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by eiz on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:30PM (#13879486)
The calculator you linked to assumes a maximum TCP window size of 64KB for everything but "replication". TCP window scaling has been on by default in every major OS for 10 years or more, allowing much greater throughput. It's true that latency sets a limit on TCP throughput but it's not nearly as bad as your calculator would indicate.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by xapata on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:44PM (#13879136)
> Who has 100 different streams in an average household?

"I think there is a world market for maybe five computers"

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tw04 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:04PM (#13879300)
I don't seem to recall advocating we'd never need 1000Gbit to the home, I said we don't need it for MOST HOUSEHOLDS today.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by squeaky-clean on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:43PM (#13880086)
The cause is a bit cyclical though, isn't it? We don't need Gbit because most people don't use that much. But most people don't use that much because consumer apps/devices rarely need to use that much bandwidth. But consumer apps/devices are designed to not use that much bandwidth because the average consumer doesn't have Gbit internet. And the average consumer doesn't have Gbit because they don't use that much. Etc.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by xapata on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:12PM (#13880804)
> cyclical

Commonly called a "chicken-and-egg" problem, or more often "circular" rather than "cyclical" despite the words being nearly synonyms. Just a vocabulary nit, not disagreeing with the point.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @06:38PM (#13880541)
> It's VERY difficult to do TRUE sustained 4K streaming over any kind of distance.

Your calculator is bunk. I've got a dedicated server in NJ, 11 milliseconds away. Gigabit on that end, 150/150 on mine. Your calculator says I should get under 50 mbps for file downloads, but I can definitely saturate my local link with both downloads and uploads.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tw04 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @11:29PM (#13882244)
I'm not sure what to tell you. It's literally based on a sound mathematics formula and the RFC that dictates how TCP operates. The only way you're getting maxed out gigabit with 11ms latency on a single stream is if you've got something on the pipe telling the TCP/IP stack to violate the RFC - IE: a piece of hardware like cisco waas, silverpeak, riverbed, etc.

There are literally hundreds of TCP throughput calculators out there and they all use the same formula.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by rayiner on Thursday March 16, 2017 @01:12AM (#13882705)
TCP throughout is limited by window size divided by round trip time (I.e. How much you can send before having to wait for an ACK). With RFC 1323, you can specify a window size well above the 65,536 limit that would otherwise exist. With scaling you can have a window size up to a gigabyte. With an RTT of 11 ms, you can saturate a 150 Mbps link with a window size of 160-170kb.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by kalleboo on Thursday March 16, 2017 @09:37PM (#13890659)
I have a cheap shared server on the other side of the planet (250ms latency). Your calculator says I can get at most 2 Mbps(!), which is complete crap. With a single stream (rsync) I typically get around 80 Mbps.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by chimeracoder on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:57PM (#13879242)
> In most households having a limited single-stream throughput isn't a big deal, but it IS a big deal specifically for things like your 4K streaming. It's VERY difficult to do TRUE sustained 4K streaming over any kind of distance. If your ISP happens to have a Netflix caching box at the local pop you're golden. If you need to traverse any kind of distance across the internet - good luck.

We're talking about TCP - but most 4K streaming shouldn't be using TCP though, right? Especially not if you actually have 100MB/s bandwidth.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tw04 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:08PM (#13879326)
I'm happy if someone has a reference stating otherwise, but it's my understanding that both Youtube and Netflix utilize TCP for their video streams whether it's 4K or not.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:49PM (#13879640)
If they use TCP then it's because they feel like it works over real-world networks.

If they need to use UDP, they will. 4K is eminently feasible, and can require a connection faster than 100mbps with a mere two streams.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by lunchables on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @06:25PM (#13880441)
Video buffering. With TCP you can ensure delivery of the traffic ahead of time, retransmitting if necessary before a particular segment needs to be played.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by wmf on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:17PM (#13879395)
All Internet streaming is now over HTTP.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by FireBeyond on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:55PM (#13879224)
It's not 100...

but according to my Unifi Controller at home right now?

> ALL (53) WIRELESS (16) WIRED (37)

(many of the wired devices are bridged VMs for dev work, in case you're wondering).

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tw04 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:05PM (#13879306)
And what would you say, just ballpark mind you, is the average number of VMs for dev work in the average US household?

And how many of those dev boxes are streaming 4K video, every day, all at the same time?

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by trashcan on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:45PM (#13879612)
What kind of 4k streaming are you doing? BT could definitely saturate your link, but 4k Netflix streams are surprisingly only around 25 mbps.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by Symbiote on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:35PM (#13880022)
Using the 280MB Libreoffice source .deb from Ubuntu as a test, and the Ubuntu mirrors -- which are hosted on a mixture of commercial and academic networks.

From here in Denmark, I have no problem downloading at over 95MB/s from servers in the Nordic countries. 111MB/s from the Norwegian mirror!

From the rest Europe, including examples like Bosnia (60MB/s) and Russia (55MB/s), I get at least 50MB/s, 70-80 from GB, DE, NL etc.

Around 70MB/s also for Singapore, South Africa, Canada.

This isn't 1000Gb/s (125MB/s), but it's a lot faster than the 0.002Gb/s that tool predicts.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by phonon on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:36PM (#13879082)
Raptor codes + UDP can saturate any link. Single Stream too. (And guarantee data integrity, so no need for TCP) Try http://openrq-team.github.io/openrq/ for example.

https://www.qualcomm.com/products/raptorq for an optimized commercial implementation.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by nitinics on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:34PM (#13879061)
You are assuming that TCP with current congestion avoidance algorithm is the only transport medium. When you have bigger pipes allowing you more bits to pack/unpack, you might find the era of newer transport protocols that do specific tasks more efficiently while increasing your overall throughput for specific use-cases. I can think of video streaming, gaming, file storage, etc that might add up to consuming the pipe to the ceiling.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by glomph on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:40PM (#13879108)
They literally specified that they were talking about TCP.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by nitinics on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:53PM (#13879210)
Yes. But the point is you cannot assume TCP is the only transport protocol that moves data across the public internet.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:42PM (#13879583)
> Single-stream throughput is directly proportional to latency and jitter.

What? No it's not. This calculator is ridiculously wrong.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by lunchables on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @06:27PM (#13880458)
Care to clarify? Throughput is determined by the bandwidth-delay product which is a function of bandwidth and, just as critically, latency (literally bandwidth * rtt). And jitter is just variable latency.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @07:32PM (#13880931)
The bandwidth delay product is the amount of data in flight. That's not throughput. You can have a huge amount of data in flight on a fast connection just fine. Someone else said the calculator assumes a max window size of 64KB which is extremely unrealistic.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by draw_down on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @06:57PM (#13880700)
I have a fiber internet connection, the building I live in is wired for it and I just plug my router into the wall.

Anyway, I'd actually agree that it isn't materially much better than cable internet, except I never have to deal with a cable company. When I've had Comcast internet, the connection itself was fine. So, I can see why this isn't super compelling for anyone who doesn't have a huge need for bandwidth.

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tekklloneer on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:30PM (#13878528)
I think this is part of why they've embraced microwave internet. I have webpass, owned by google fiber, and it's up to 300 mbps^ for under $50 a month. I think it speaks well to your point though: If I could get 10d/1u for $20/month, I totally would. I don't really use the internet that heavily.

^ usually around 100 mbps (100/100)

Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by 086421357909764 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:44PM (#13879146)
What's the latency like with the service? We had a microwave transit link until our fiber was installed and we noticed that we had great speed but horrible latency on the whole.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by greenleafjacob on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:48PM (#13879632)
When I had MonkeyBrains I had about 2ms ping to Google.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by tekklloneer on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @05:58PM (#13880225)
It's been excellent so far.
Re:Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start by Ensorceled on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @10:14PM (#13881829)
I have 30/5 for around $60CND a month, I can get 100/10 with my current set up $13CDN more a month.

I haven't bothered upgrading. I have no problems with ping or downloads. My SO and I can both watch Netflix at the same time and we both have Backblaze running. When with stream HD TV or movies from iTunes it works fine and we get amazing quality. I get great ping times on WoW or TF2. I'm not sure what fiber would get me that I'm not getting and I'm sure the vast majority of people feel the same.

Now, if real time VR sports or live concerts ever becomes a thing ...