News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by vxxzy on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:12AM (#13774067)
Wow. AMD has really pulled through on this one. They are really giving Intel a run for their money. This is going to be great for consumers. What is interesting is the HUGE jump in multi-threaded performance on AMD. Very interesting.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by rbanffy on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:49PM (#13776312)
> What is interesting is the HUGE jump in multi-threaded performance on AMD. Very interesting.

Indeed. Single threaded performance, however, seems bad. Virtual cores most likely share less of the actual core than on Intel parts, allowing one to compete less with the other and get more done. On my i7 laptop, on anything more demanding, I see half the "cores" idling, probably because one is using the actual underlying core while the other is waiting.

Still, while AMD obviously did a good job, it will not make the Intel guys lose any sleep for now.

The server parts are another story. If they manage to reliably outperform Xeons (even if it's only on a per watt basis), it'll be fun to watch.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by pmalynin on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:33PM (#13776801)
>"half the "cores" idling"

Right, thats exactly what happens with Hyper-Threading. If you can fully utilize the physical core, Hyper-Threading can't do much.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by rbanffy on Friday March 03, 2017 @05:33AM (#13781940)
It seems the AMD parts can squeeze a little more work from the two threads, judging by the multi-threeaded benchmarks, than competing Intel parts.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by TwoBit on Friday March 03, 2017 @04:20AM (#13781686)
Single threaded perf isn't bad, it's just not outstanding. Many of the cases where I care about perf are cases in which the app is multithread savvy.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by zer0t3ch on Friday March 03, 2017 @10:07PM (#13788948)
> Many of the cases where I care about perf are cases in which the app is multithread savvy

Yeah, as would be expected from most people on this site. Sad thing is, there's a bunch of pissed-off gamers right now who were on the hype train expecting Ryzen to be the next big thing in gaming, but it's far from it. Ryzen is great, just not amazing for gaming.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by michaelmrose on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:10PM (#13780682)
Hyperthreading is not a virtual core and as it doesn't exist as a separate core its hard for it to be idling. Bad analogies make for less than adequate understanding.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by rbanffy on Friday March 03, 2017 @05:32AM (#13781935)
They are also called "logical cores" (I think Intel documents prefers "logical" and Sun - they invented the concept - prefers "virtual"). One logical core can appear to be idling to the OS if the parts of the physical core are in use by another (SPARC and POWER go up to 8) logical core (as it's resource starved). It seems, from the benchmarks, the AMD parts have less shared resources between logical cores (or a finer granularity for allocating) than the i7 in my laptop.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by michaelmrose on Friday March 03, 2017 @02:57PM (#13785790)
Pre Ryzen AMD didn't have anything like hyperthreading. The prior generation had n physical cores wherein each 2 shared a fairly significant chunk of hardware. The new generation of AMD and many generations of intel have extra hardware in each physical core that makes it look and act like additional cores. If I understand it correctly, and please correct me if I'm wrong, it mainly serves to ensure that the core is better utilized in general.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by rbanffy on Friday March 03, 2017 @06:13PM (#13787799)
You are correct.

From the benchmarks, it seems a single thread can fully utilize all resources from an Intel processor while it can't on the new AMD ones and that's why their single-thread performance is lower and their multi-thread performance is higher.

We should keep in mind the benchmarks know nothing about the new AMD parts and how to keep all parts of the processor busy.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by deepnotderp on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:59PM (#13777075)
Server supplies ~60% of Intel's total profits.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by yread on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:20AM (#13774116)
But it's still losing in every web and office single threaded benchmark. EDIT: compared to 7700k that costs about the same
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by tomku on Thursday March 02, 2017 @02:24PM (#13777320)
And? Intel's $1,600 6950X loses to their own $170 i3-7350K in single-threaded benchmarks. When you pay extra for a CPU with more cores, you almost always get less single-threaded compute because of power/heat/design constraints forcing the clock speed down. Dual cores will often beat quad-cores, which will almost always beat hex/octo-cores.

What's happening here is that AMD has priced Ryzen so inexpensively that it actually broke the usual market segmentation by driving high-thread-count workstation CPUs (usually $1k+) into the same price range as high-end gaming CPUs (~$300-400). Think of it as being able to buy an industrial dump truck for the same price as a pickup truck. The dump truck is clearly a better value in terms of hauling capacity, but most people would be far better off with a pickup truck for their daily traveling.

AMD's pickup truck (the 1400X) doesn't launch until later this year. The 7700K will probably still beat it on single-threaded workloads due to the difference in clock speed, but it should get you most of the way there for substantially less money, around $200 if the leaks are accurate.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by jrockway on Friday March 03, 2017 @01:26AM (#13781126)
I think Intel severely underclocks the 6950X by default, so that it fits within the stated TDP of 140W with all 10 cores at full load. If you have adequate cooling, it is very easy to overclock. I think I ended up at 4.2GHz for 10 core loads, 4.4GHz for 4 cores.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by jdietrich on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:26AM (#13774660)
The R7 1700 is within shouting distance of the 6900k in most serious tasks - rendering, encoding, compilation etc. A $330 65w CPU is a credible alternative to an $1100 140w CPU. That is absolutely remarkable. The cherry on the cake is that the cheapest AM4 motherboards are half the price of the cheapest 2011-v3 boards.

For the first time in a decade, AMD are seriously competing at the high end. That's great news for everyone except Intel.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by slantyyz on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:37AM (#13774773)
I'm hoping things get more interesting when the Ryzen Mobile chips come out later in the year.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by MLR on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:33PM (#13776121)
The Zen based APU platform is going to cause real problems for Intel in the laptop/ultrabook market, Ryzen's power consumption looks very low and their iGPU technology is years ahead of Intel's.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by slantyyz on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:36PM (#13776833)
>> The Zen based APU platform is going to cause real problems for Intel in the laptop/ultrabook market

Technically this is true, but unlike the desktop market where you can buy stuff in pieces, it really depends on how the laptop manufacturers adopt them. As in how fast they show up in product lines, and in which laptop segments they show up in.

If, for example, Intel gives laptop manufacturers pricing incentives (legally or not) to stick with their chips, it may not cause any problems at all with respect to actual customer purchases.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by karpodiem on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:26AM (#13775317)
and this is exactly why I'm getting one.

Cheap, power efficient, eight cores. It may not win everything, but it works for me.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by lostmsu on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:54AM (#13775655)
According to Web performance chart, it looses to 7700T, which has 1/2 TDP and 5% lower price.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:10PM (#13775838)
> According to Web performance chart, it looses to 7700T, which has 1/2 TDP and 5% lower price.

It also has 1/2 cores, which doesn't show up on the single threaded benchmarks but explains the price and TDP differences.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:08AM (#13774490)
> But it's still losing in every web and office single threaded benchmark.

By ~15% compared to >160% for Bulldozer.

And this is day zero before any applications have been optimized for the new microarchitecture, compared with Core which everything has been targeting for more than a decade.

They did good.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by robotjosh on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:35AM (#13774750)
Good reason to wait for the next chip cycle. AMD will have smoothed out any rough edges and Intel will show us what they've really got.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:39AM (#13774784)
Not actually necessary. You can buy one now and just install the new software next year.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Tom1971 on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:14AM (#13774538)
I don't think spending time and effort to optimize code for Ryzen will be time well spent.

Would you do it if you had the choice between that or adding new money making features/fixing bugs?

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by JamesMcMinn on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:36AM (#13774757)
Give compilers some time and the optimizations will be "free" to developers.

Besides, if your application is one where performance is a serious issue, then you are going to spend some time optimizing rather than adding features. For some applications, performance is a feature.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by JohnTHaller on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:39AM (#13775456)
People always seem to forget this in terms of CPU optimizations. It's both good and bad, though. If you're pegged to a given version of a compiler, the point releases likely won't see any optimization while the major releases will likely include additional optimizations for newer chipsets. And I'd wager AMD will be working to get optimizations into both open source compilers as well as things like Visual Studio. One thing to note is that switching to a newer compilker will likely be easier for most of Linux-land as opposed to Windows land. Upping the compiler version with your code compiled in GCC is often much easier than switching to a newer version of Visual Studio due to both cost and dropping older operating systems (the latest won't support Windows XP and Vista for instance, which may matter to some specific business lines and consumer areas).
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by phamilton on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:34AM (#13774739)
This is a compiler optimization, not an application optimization. I'd certainly add -march=zen as a compiler flag for my application.

As for the priorities of the compiler devs, I think it will get some love.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by clarry on Friday March 03, 2017 @06:56AM (#13782266)
Maybe it is time to run Gentoo again.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:32AM (#13774712)
> Would you do it if you had the choice between that or adding new money making features/fixing bugs?

Of course I would, because people are going to benchmark my software against my competitor's software and choose the one that runs faster on their hardware.

Especially if my software is a compiler and people are benchmarking the programs it produces against other compilers, which is where most of the optimizing actually happens these days.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by lorenzhs on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:36AM (#13774763)
It is for compiler authors, or libc etc. There's very little most application authors would need to do.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Analemma_ on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:26AM (#13774145)
They're coming in at half the price of equivalent Intel chips. They don't need to win, necessarily (which I didn't think was going to happen), they need to be competitive for a lot less money.

EDIT, in response to the other edit: sorry about that, I wasn't sure which comparison you were making. Still, the difference is slim enough that if I were in the market, I'd go with this one just to put the heat on Intel.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by RUG3Y on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:06AM (#13775095)
I'm definitely going to be building a PC with one of these CPUs some time this year. I've been holding off on an upgrade because I couldn't justify the cost. This is a lot more reasonable.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Vanayad on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:39AM (#13774231)
You do have to consider that this is an 8 core, and more and more applications are being developed with this in mind. Whoever still thinks that Single threaded performance is the most important, lives in the past.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Geee on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:17AM (#13775214)
That's not true. 2 weak horses != 1 strong horse. 1 strong horse can do the work of 2 weak horses, but not the other way around. A single core can run multiple threads, but multiple cores can't work together on a single-thread task.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by timlin on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:13PM (#13775860)
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by anthonybsd on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:03AM (#13774441)
Consumer applications? Doubt it. Not a whole lot of consumer-oriented applications parallelize that well to be honest.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by qaq on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:16AM (#13774561)
look at how many threads your Chrome is running
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by whyever on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:07AM (#13775101)
Only Servo parallelizes single-page rendering as far as I know.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by anentropic on Friday March 03, 2017 @05:46AM (#13781987)
but they're moving in that direction
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by MLR on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:36PM (#13776159)
This review has a CPU web test section, you can see performance is mostly a function of IPC and clock speed.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by yborg on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:37AM (#13774767)
All but one set (for the active tab) of which are probably idle or effectively so most of the time.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by caf on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:00PM (#13780175)
Even crusty old Microsoft Excel parallelises worksheet recalculation.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by smitherfield on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:09PM (#13780456)
Sure, but Excel is presumably one of the most optimized (in terms of the amount of money and brainpower devoted to optimizing it) applications in existence.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by caf on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:31PM (#13780553)
That's not the feeling you get when you use it, it seems more like the underlying engine hasn't really changed a great deal in 20 years.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by smitherfield on Friday March 03, 2017 @12:19AM (#13780918)
That's the price of backward compatibility. But I think it's a bit of a "Seinfeld is unfunny"[1] situation; if Microsoft decided to save on the nine-figure budget and outsource Excel development to, say, your favorite purveyor of antivirus software, you'd notice real fast.

[1] http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SeinfeldIsUnfunny (apologies for the TVTropes link at night!)

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by anentropic on Friday March 03, 2017 @05:47AM (#13781994)
don't you run more than one of them at a time though?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by olegkikin on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:11AM (#13774509)
But it wins in every case where performance truly matters: multi-threaded calculations, archiving, encoding. You know, the things that actually do take up time.

Do you really care if your webpage renders for half a second longer?

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Geee on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:50AM (#13774908)
Yes, I do care. A lot. Actually if it's just 50ms I care. Slow main thread is a huge annoyance, and that's 99% of my computer use. On the other hand, I don't care if asynchronous tasks (encoding etc.) take 30 or 40 seconds or whatever; I can get a cup of coffee or check my email. Also, major parallel workloads are done on the GPU anyway.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by tbrowbdidnso on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:44PM (#13776907)
What? I've never run a parallel op on the GPU but I do on my CPU multiple times a day. GPU acceleration besides games is still extremely rare. You're grasping straws here.

You're also missing that even on chrome the js and layout engines run different threads. Same with audio and video rendering. Same with downloads. The average page is probably running things on 10-20 random threads. And the average user has multiple tabs open.

Multicore CPU is so common these days that any performance critical code that can be parallelized, is. This includes GZIP and HTTP which are used heavily by web browsers. The network stacks underneath those in the OS are also multi core capable.

Single thread performance is not all that important anymore. It's better to have 2x the number of fast cores than half the number of slightly faster cores in almost every situation these days.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by lightedman on Thursday March 02, 2017 @04:35PM (#13778457)
"GPU acceleration besides games is still extremely rare"

Not even. Video acceleration, browser acceleration, flash acceleration, and much more, are becoming increasingly GPU-oriented.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by slizard on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:23PM (#13776678)
FTFY: some major parallel workloads are done on the GPU anyway, so parallel work on CPUs is often still relevant. ;)
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by ganfortran on Thursday March 02, 2017 @07:00PM (#13779560)
I don't so it is good for me
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by ldev on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:14AM (#13775184)
I'm actually using my computer and not running it as a build server. I'd take 16 ghz single core CPU over 4 core 4ghz any time of the day.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Symmetry on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:49PM (#13776951)
Generally speaking the price of a processor is going to be the square of the single threaded performance times the number of cores. So your choice is more like one 8 GHz core versus 4 4GHz cores. Which might be good or bad depending on your use case. Well, there's a threshold below which you only get linear per-core scaling but outside microcontrollers you're not going to have to worry about that.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by rockdoe on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:56PM (#13776387)
Anyone would. That's not the option on offer though.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by teilo on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:22AM (#13774620)
No, it doesn't. Their hyperthreading model is clearly not as good as Intel's. Take a look at the Handbrake tests, which take full advantage of hyperthreading. The 7700K, with half the cores, is only a few frames/sec. behind.

If I was after encoding performance, I wouldn't buy a Ryzen. If I was after rendering performance, I wouldn't buy a Ryzen. Throw an mid-range nVidia on there for OpenCL, and the only CPU that makes sense for that price range is the 7700K.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by DannyBee on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:46AM (#13774847)
It's funny that the article mentions that Intel went through a number of these projects and optimized them, just so they could try to say that :)

I expect if AMD went back through again, they could improve them even more.

(In the handbrake case, most likely it's half-speed AVX2 that is hurting them)

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by ElatedOwl on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:59AM (#13775030)
>If I was after rendering performance, I wouldn't buy a Ryzen

But why? http://www.anandtech.com/show/11170/the-amd-zen-and-ryzen-7-...

The benchmarks show Ryzen being the obvious choice other than cinebench single threaded.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by carspically on Thursday March 02, 2017 @02:00PM (#13777092)
The reason he said that is because it makes infinitely more sense to use a renderer that does it's work on the GPU with CUDA or OpenCL.

Only if you are using a shitty software renderer or are completely stupid would you do rendering on the CPU.

The Ryzen performs nicely on the encoding tests, though that will be performed by the GPU soon. It already can be (NVENC and AMD VCE), but the quality isn't quite as good as everyone's favorite h.264 encoder, x264.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by skykooler on Thursday March 02, 2017 @04:40PM (#13778489)
Depending on rendering task, GPU rendering isn't always feasible. In particular, for very large scenes consuming a large amount of RAM, it is difficult to find graphics cards with over 8 GB of VRAM, while 32gb or 64gb of desktop RAM are easily accessible.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by untoreh on Thursday March 02, 2017 @05:01PM (#13778669)
are you saying gpu x264 encoding is reaching bitrate/quality ratio similar to cpu x264 soon ?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by slantyyz on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:40AM (#13774794)
From everything I've seen, the Ryzen's main appeal is bang for the buck.

If you're after pure performance, then you simply go with the best for your use case, whether it is Ryzen or not.

If you're on a tight budget, however, things get interesting.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Geee on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:28AM (#13775337)
It's not so clear, because 7700K offers more bang for the buck in single-threading cases, which is more important in typical computer use.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by slantyyz on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:56AM (#13775681)
> It's not so clear, because 7700K offers more bang for the buck in single-threading cases

hence, "things get interesting"

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by cynic_ on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:44AM (#13774836)
Looking at most benchmarks hyperthreading model is equal or better on Ryzen. Ryzen 1800x and 6900k have almost the exact single threaded score on Cinebench. But 1800x beats 6900k on Cinebench and Handbrake
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by simias on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:30AM (#13774171)
By a pretty small margin compared to equivalent Intel CPUs from what I've seen[1]. And the ryzen chips are a whole lot cheaper and beat Intel for parallel tasks.

I'm about to buy a beefy machine for FPGA development, I'm definitely considering AMD. Seems like I'd get better performance for a much lower price. I'm still waiting for more in-depth reviews though.

[1] http://core0.staticworld.net/images/article/2017/03/ryzen_ci...

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by FullyFunctional on Saturday March 04, 2017 @01:01AM (#13789555)
It's interesting that you'd mention that workload as it's traditionally been completely single threaded (where it matters), and exceedingly memory intensive. Do you have first hand experience with how well it scales with cores?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by O5vYtytb on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:28AM (#13774162)
Who buys a $350+ processor with 8C/16T for web/office?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by flukus on Thursday March 02, 2017 @05:36PM (#13778952)
It's 2017, we need that just to read a website these days.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by washadjeffmad on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:43AM (#13774825)
Universities and government institutions that haven't spent all of their funding by year-end, for one.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by toss1941 on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:20PM (#13776654)
Quad cores are the absolute minimum I would want for a standard office machine, unless it's only for a handful of basic applications. My latest work laptop is a quad core with 32 GB of RAM for running multiple VM's, but they couldn't give me an SSD which ends up wasting at least a few hours of productivity a week.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by O5vYtytb on Thursday March 02, 2017 @07:30PM (#13779742)
Right, I guess that's my point. The minimal gains in CPU are widely offset by upgrading other components like a SSD. So what if Ryzen is a few percent slower on a javascript benchmark? Does this actually noticeably affect any apps that people actually use?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by mrb on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:56PM (#13776388)
Or, seen another way (better representation of the overall reality):

The 7700k is losing in all aspects below w.r.t. the Ryzen 7 1800X, except absolute single-threaded perf. Intel is losing in:

- absolute multi-threaded performance

- relative multi-threaded performance per $

- memory bandwidth

- L3-cache bound workloads (AMD has twice more L3)

- price of motherboards

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by keldaris on Thursday March 02, 2017 @08:45PM (#13780116)
I'll have to disagree on a few of the points on that list:

> - relative multi-threaded performance per $

Highly depends on the particular workload. Given the few benchmarks we have right now, it seems to go 50-50 once you factor in the lower price of the 7700k. At the very least, this one is close.

> - memory bandwidth

Seems about equal from the measurements I've seen (the theoretical numbers are irrelevant).

> - L3-cache bound workloads (AMD has twice more L3)

Cache-size bound workloads to be precise. Cache latency still seems higher, even on L3.

Overall, the 1800X seems to make the entire Broadwell-E series redundant on price/performance (at least at current price), no argument there. Against the 7700k, however, it's a very interesting decision, entirely based on the distribution of your workloads. And if Intel drops the prices on Kaby Lake, the value equation can change very quickly indeed.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by mrb on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:58PM (#13780418)
Ryzen 7 1800X unambiguously beats the 7700k on memory bandwidth:

http://www.guru3d.com/articles_pages/amd_ryzen_7_1800x_proce...

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by keldaris on Friday March 03, 2017 @09:48AM (#13783172)
Guru3D seem to be the only ones to manage memory frequencies over 3 Ghz, most reviewers report a lot of issues with the memory subsystem at the moment. In many reviews (see [1] for a representative example) the 1800X is on par or even slightly behind the 7700k in memory bandwidth, so at the very least the situation is far from unambiguous.

[1] https://www.pcper.com/reviews/Processors/AMD-Ryzen-7-1800X-R...

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by dfrey on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:20PM (#13776650)
You left out the tiny detail that the 7700k is $150USD cheaper than the 1800X.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by mrb on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:30PM (#13776774)
True. But IMHO justified and worth it because AMD beats Intel in all these areas.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by r00fus on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:10PM (#13780685)
What about when you factor in mobo costs?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by TwoBit on Friday March 03, 2017 @04:24AM (#13781701)
Don't forget power consumption.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by geezerjay on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:35AM (#13774209)
> But it's still losing in every web and office single threaded benchmark.

Web and office? Single-threaded?

Why are these benchmarks, specially in 2018?

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by matthewmacleod on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:58AM (#13774399)
Because people still buy new computers and use those applications on them – that's why single-thread performance is (for the moment at least) still important.

I do understand where you're coming from, but real-world performance is important, especially when that world is imperfect.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by floatboth on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:39AM (#13774788)
For these applications, any modern desktop CPU is enough, and enough is all you need for them. People browse the web and do office tasks just fine on tiny 10W "Ultrabook" CPUs.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by contingencies on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:01PM (#13780182)
Just this week I bought three systems for PXE-boot office use at http://infinite-food.com/ and settled on Kaby Lake G3950 dual core Celerons with integrated Intel HD graphics. Here in China a whole mini-ITX system (including case, 180W power supply, 8GB DDR4 2133 RAM, G3950 CPU, motherboard, keyboard and mouse but not screen) is ~USD$174 (inc. parts shipping). I think Intel's integrated GPUs are still very attractive at the lower end of the market.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by geezerjay on Thursday March 02, 2017 @02:54PM (#13777597)
> Because people still buy new computers and use those applications on them – that's why single-thread performance is (for the moment at least) still important.

That's a load of bullshit. No one ever complained that the web is unbrowsable or an excel spreadsheet is unworkable without a high-end boutique processor. Those benchmarks are simply a load of bullshit that evaluate something that is utterly irrelevant.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by stolsvik on Friday March 03, 2017 @01:50AM (#13781195)
Hi geezerjay, I'm trying to find a way to contact you - I was wondering whether you could comment on a previous comment about used opterons for "Budget HPC": Where would I go to find this, and build myself such a rig? Links?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by geezerjay on Friday March 03, 2017 @02:28PM (#13785503)
You can check ebay, where they are being sold for spare change. That's where I've bought mine.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by drzaiusapelord on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:54AM (#13775658)
Because enterprise sales dwarf consumer sales? Enterprise is replacing servers and workstations every 3 years. Your 7 year old home beater will run until it dies.

With AMD's previous offerings, they benched well but ran like crap because so many applications are single-threaded. These single thread tests are important to know how these chips will work in real world scenarios.

This is the data enterprise buyers want to hear. If AMD can match Intel at a much lower cost, expect enterprise buyers to switch.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by hajile on Friday March 03, 2017 @10:30AM (#13783485)
If single-threaded benchmarks didn't matter, then bulldozer would have easily won with its smaller, less efficient cores (it was actually best for a while at some very parallel workloads).

That said, those numbers aren't particularly bad for a new CPU running un-optimized software. All the important software will be updated soon enough once the compilers are in order.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by M_Grey on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:25AM (#13774143)
Maybe I'm being a bit harsh, but so what? You don't buy a high-end graphics card because office or websites are chugging...
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by raverbashing on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:37AM (#13774218)
Yeah, like I'm going to buy a new computer to open PDF files, not to play games, render graphics or do complex simulations
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by yread on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:51AM (#13774338)
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by snovv_crash on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:54AM (#13774361)
It's also up to 30% faster. That's how variance works.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by floatboth on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:43AM (#13774824)
It's also 0.1fps faster than the 6950X in the Civ VI AI test. And the 6950X is literally fucking $1700, that's over THREE TIMES more expensive than the top Ryzen.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by onli on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:21AM (#13775266)
But you ignore that the i7-7700K is faster in that benchmark. And that one is cheaper. So is the i5.

If you do more than games, the Ryzen seems like a a good choice. It has serious power in applications, and is still fast in Games - which is a big step up compared to the FX. But no, it is not the goto choice for a gaming PC.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by floatboth on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:03PM (#13775769)
Yeah, I'm not arguing with that, I actually made that same exact point in a different thread :) I'm just pointing out how it compares to more expensive 8/10-core CPUs.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by nottorp on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:30PM (#13776084)
If the 6C/8T and 4C/8T parts will launch at the same frequency as the high end (and i've read that at least for the 6C they will) we'll end up with a CPU that is as fast as the 1800X in games (which is good enough no matter what the 120 fps enthusiasts say) but this time is cheaper than the 7700K. That will be the sweet spot for just gaming performance, not these ones.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by ldev on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:18AM (#13775229)
Those linked benchmarks are useless. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/03/amd-ryzen-review/

I'd take Intel CPU that runs 120 FPS average over AMD that runs 130 FPS average, when lowest FPS for Intel drops to 100 FPS and for AMD it drops to 80 FPS...

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by ahoka on Friday March 03, 2017 @09:45AM (#13783150)
Both average and min/max are useless metrics.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by Asooka on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:15AM (#13774547)
Well yeah but will you buy an alternate CPU that might be faster or might be slower in some games, or will you buy standard Intel, for which every game was definitely tested and will run with standard performance?
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by nottorp on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:36PM (#13776158)
Your standard Intel is running a 64 bit instruction set designed by umm... AMD.

Perhaps you'd like to restrict yourself to 32 bit software just to be standards conformant?

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by raverbashing on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:48AM (#13774877)
It's been more than 10 years since I've read such an uninformed comment
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by phamilton on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:37AM (#13774766)
Frame of reference fallacy going on here. One could just as easily say the Intel is 30% faster or slower.
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by reitzensteinm on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:55AM (#13774366)
But so does a 6900K, and that costs a fortune.

The Ryzen quads will come. I'm not at all sure what your point is here.

Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by ascendantlogic on Thursday March 02, 2017 @04:16PM (#13778302)
Ryzen 7 chips focus on heavily multithreaded work. When you are dealing with every day apps and games you are more concerned with IPC (instructions per cycle) and I'm sure we'll see better performance in that arena with Ryzen 3 and 5
Re:AMD Zen and Ryzen 7 Review: A Deep Dive by lallysingh on Thursday March 02, 2017 @04:08PM (#13778232)
I think people run enough browser tabs (+ their office suite + background OS tasks) where the core difference will outshine the single-core speed. It's not hard to overwhelm 4 real cores.