News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:32PM (#13428905)
Also, don't forget that the food pyramid is defined by the Department of Agriculture (whose job it is to sell food and maintain food surplus) and not the Department of Health and Human Services (whose job it is to pay for all the trillions in health issues resulting from the billions in subsidies).

The calorie is a calorie argument is old and dumb. It ignores insulin which is a BIG deal. It also ignores that high blood sugar can cause a temporary endorphin rush. Ever hear anyone talk about a "protein high" or "fat high"?

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by temp246810 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:40PM (#13429007)
Don't let r/fitness see this or you will get absolutely destroyed.

I agree with you - but saying a calorie is a calorie makes people feel like they are gifted physicists preaching to people that live in the dark ages.

Nutrition's become a bit of a religious/political issue.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by qeternity on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:51PM (#13429125)
The reason r/fitness says this is because for active people it largely holds true, with the exception of certain bulking/cutting phases for lifters. It's people who are sedentary, or in chronic caloric surplus where the macros become more of a concern. You're not going to wreak havoc on your insulin sensitivity by having a Coke every day if you get up and run a 10k every morning, because things like glycogen levels will be replenished. But if you're sedentary, your body deals with it very differently.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by xherberta on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:23PM (#13429959)
The composition of one's microbiome is also a major factor in metabolism (and is interrelated with activity level, too.)

https://microbewiki.kenyon.edu/index.php/Firmicutes_and_Obes...

The article didn't tread much into the satiety effect: while sugar- and carb-laden foods generally leave you wanting more, it's difficult to overeat naturally fatty things like bacon, cream, or eggs. Until just now, these foods have been frowned upon so hard that few people think of combining them with veggies to create tasty, affordable, satisfying, and nutritious meals.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by kmm on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:16PM (#13431791)
The linked page doesn't say the microbiome influences metabolism, only that it is suspected to be involved in digestion and fat absorption.

Metabolism doesn't happen in the gut, but in the cells and mostly in the mitochondria. It is controlled by the hypothalamus, which keeps your body at the same temperature, as this is the bulk of what food energy is used for.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by kapauldo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:45PM (#13433082)
This does not explain the 600% obesity increase.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by jrowley on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:24PM (#13429966)
Yes this is it exactly. It's not so clean cut to say a 'calorie isn't a calorie' because for me an active recreational distance runner, I can pretty much eat/drink my calories however I please while remaining relatively thin.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by Y201K on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:56PM (#13431247)
Definitely. However, it's also just the most important factor in weight control, with macronutrients, nutrient timing, and food composition playing lesser roles.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by narag on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:43PM (#13429630)
Nutrition's become a bit of a religious/political issue.

It just makes sense if you believe that studies are biased. It seems like trust in authorities (in this case to determine dietetic recommendations) would be a common factor with religious/political differences between persons.

Edit: or you could say that some people seems to trust facts more, other ones trust persons more.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by EpicEng on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:05PM (#13429805)
Well, /r/fitness isn't necessarily meant for everyone. I work out regularly and heavily. For me, a calorie is pretty much a calorie. I'm well above average in terms of fitness and can eat a ton of food without gaining any weight. Not good advice for Joe schmoe
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by antisthenes on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:07PM (#13430286)
The sequitur from this isn't that "calorie is a calorie" is wrong, it's that Joe Schmoe is wrong about nutrition and uneducated about the consequences of his habits.

Whatever happened to personal responsibility? Has the concept been abolished in the last decade?

Another tidbit in evidence of CIAC holding true is that 99.9% of people would lose weight if they cut their meal sizes in the same proportion (let's say by 20%).

They wouldn't lose equal amounts, but they would all lose weight.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:54PM (#13429715)
Anecdotal evidence _for_ a calorie being a calorie: lost 5 kgs in three months by cutting food intake evenly by just reducing the size of meals. Also consumed slightly over 10% of daily intake in sugar (saccarose) which surpasses the recommended level (10% absolute max). Otherwise stuck to official recommendations. Sedentary lifestyle, moderate alcohol consumption.

The magic trick is being able to measure your weight for the first week or two and then keep the same habits until the goal is reached. No fancy apps or diets or nutritionists or whatever required. So a calorie is a calorie.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by EpicEng on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:12PM (#13429856)
I don't know why you're getting downvoted. A calorie is a calorie in isolation. Eating at a surplus because you don't feel full after eating a bag of M&M's doesn't change that fact.

It certainly helps (in many ways) to e.g. increase protein in leue of sugar, but that you will certainly ly lose weight if calories burned > calories consumed.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:43PM (#13430112)
It's because people want to have a sense of control and that is achieved in this case by making wild hypotheses about losing weight. It's further complicated by authors like in the linked article wanting to sell controversy and/or diets that are unsustainable or uncomfortable in the long term (soup diets, atkins, feral, etc). Controversy feeds rebellion which in turn is a way of feeling in control.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by overgard on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:29PM (#13430456)
You could make the alternate case that people want to believe that "a calorie is a calorie" despite the evidence to the contrary because it means they don't need to change their habits. Defense against change. It's not surprising that people prefer the "science" that conveniently reinforces their life choices. The USDA and the food industry is also perfectly happy with the status-quo, because processed foods are a lot more profitable than whole foods are. In that sense, it's not surprising that people suggesting healthy foods are considered "radicals" -- people don't want to change what they eat, and the food industry doesn't want to change what they sell.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:02PM (#13430734)
The medical scientists / professors I know have gone through several revolutions in medical science (statins, diabetes treatments, resuscitation procedures, surgical procedures, dialysis, etc.). I wouldn't call them unable to change their habits. In fact, they are few of the smartest people I know.

I don't know about the margins of food, but I consider preparing food from the basic ingredients somewhat time-wasting and costly (when I actually order or buy and prepare them myself). As they can have fine nutritional values, I don't think processed foods can be generalized to be bad per se.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by overgard on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:37PM (#13430524)
The problem with anecdotal evidence is there's no particular reason to think that others metabolism is going to react the same as yours does, or that your weight loss will continue indefinitely. For instance, a diabetic on insulin would likely gain weight following the diet you follow while you lose weight, because the insulin would signal to the body to store the calories as fat.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:06PM (#13430775)
Since you're an expert in the field: How does the insulin for a diabetic patient differ in its fat-storing capabilities from the normal insulin secretion of a healthy person? I agree that there are metabolic differences in people but rarely non-pathological and rarely not age or body mass related. Pathological cases where the difference in metabolism is indicable, we already know how to treat / be unable to treat them. Moreover: type I diabetics tend to be lean / normal weight. So the question is: what is the metabolical difference you are referring to?
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by overgard on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @08:58PM (#13432319)
I'm referring to insulin resistance. Chronic high levels of insulin will result in cells not responding to the signal from insulin to store blood sugar (because they've already saturated their glucose storage capacity), which will result in the pancreas releasing more insulin to compensate. The more insulin resistant you become, the more your pancreas ramps up its insulin levels (to diminishing returns, unfortunately), until it reaches the point where your pancreas can't make enough insulin to control blood sugar. (Type 2 diabetes). Your body can't/won't burn fat when insulin levels are high, and the insulin resistance results in insulin never dropping an appropriate amount, which results in fat not being burned despite the meal not being particularly egregious.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by gambiting on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:25PM (#13430955)
So if that diabetic was eating 1000 calories/day, they would not loose weight? That's literally, physically impossible.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by overgard on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:12PM (#13432385)
The word you're looking for is "lose", not "loose".

In the short term, they'd absolutely lose weight. After a certain point (probably about six weeks), their basal metabolic rate will drop though, in adaptation to the new situation where their body adapts to living off a lowered caloric intake. Then the weight loss will plateau, or at least significantly slow down, while any deviation from the diet would generally result in a sharp uptake in fat storage (because now the metabolism is significantly slower and more greedy)

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by gamblor956 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:05PM (#13431721)
Anecdotal evidence that a calorie is not just a calorie:

4 of my buddies are doing a weight-loss challenge ahead of this spring's local marathon. They're each losing about 10-12 pounds over the month of January.

3 of them kept their calorie intakes roughly the same but changed their macros to favor protein and fat (and no changes to their exercise regimes). All 3 have already reached their goal without significant loss of muscle mass. One guy switch to the keto diet for January (<25g carbs/day), and is at 16 pounds lost as of last night. The 4th guy lowered his caloric intake but maintained his carb-heavy diet. He's lost 4 pounds, and he's struggling with hunger and trying to lose more weight.

You'll definitely still lose weight if you calories consumed < calories burned. But you'll lose more fat if those calories are consumed in the proper ratios. Increasing protein consumption while at a caloric deficit minimizes muscle loss, especially when combined with (even minimal) weight training.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @09:19AM (#13435912)
"...and he's struggling with hunger and trying to lose more weight."

This is all I was really trying to emphasize. When it comes time to burn energy, calories are the same, but this isn't true when eating.

High sugar affects insulin and other things that may it hard for people to stick with it. Eating meals high in fat provides higher satiety (you feel full longer). Eating vegetables high in fiber fills your stomach with large mass but low sugar so you'll feel full longer while that breaks down.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Thursday January 19, 2017 @01:59AM (#13433715)
Keto is the absolute worst you can do as an athlete since carbohydrates are required for fast recovery. No professional athlete would be on keto while training. The idea that an athlete should have even slightly over 1g/kg of protein intake per day is correct. However, over 2g/kg/day poses a risk of permanent kidney damage.

Moreover, losing 4 kgs or more of fat in a month increases the risk for cardiovascular disease: the blood cholesterol levels of the subjects may rise to unhealthy levels. Some are resistant to high cholesterol, but statistically it's a risk.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by cableshaft on Thursday January 19, 2017 @04:41PM (#13439734)
Keto can result in (somewhat) worse performance depending on how professional you're trying to be and what activity you're doing, but most people aren't trying to compete at that level and they can work out while on a keto diet.

Also, some people up their carb intake a little before their workout, so it'll burn off and they'll still be in keto afterwards while not risking performance loss.

Finally, you don't double your protein intake on keto, you replace your carb intake with fat, so you wouldn't be at 2g/kg/day danger levels you're suggesting if you're doing the diet properly.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by prostoalex on Friday January 20, 2017 @12:30AM (#13441892)
If it works for you, keep it up.

Caloric restriction seems to fail large groups of people to the point where short-term weight loss that is followed by respective gain (and more) has its own Wikipedia page https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yo-yo_effect

Many people who try caloric restriction suffer from pangs of hunger, general weakness, brain fog, lack of energy, daytime sleepiness, loss of mental clarity and focus, etc. Diets based strictly on calorie restrictions are not sustainable for their specific age+gender+body type combo, but might be effective for yours.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:04PM (#13429786)
Don't take this as aggressive, I'm glad you've dropped some weight. I'm not sure how overweight you are/were. How much of a calorie deficit did you have on a daily basis?

Also, I wouldn't count 10 lbs over 3 month proof that a calorie is a calorie. Actually, I think it proves the opposite. A person who is 30+ lbs over weight should drop 10lbs in around two weeks with a 500 calorie deficit per day. (Generally considered the max safe range for sustained weight loss)

I'd really be curious to how much you would lose if you cut the sugar completely.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:21PM (#13429943)
I didn't want to cut sugar because -- apart from the size of portions -- I didn't want to change the type of food I was eating or my eating habits. The habits include some chocolate with coffee almost every day and moderate alcohol in the weekends (so it's more like a 5/7-day thing). This means I can easily continue the diet and habits indefinitely even after reaching the goal as I reach the equilibrum.

Overweight from start was minimal (4, maybe 5 kgs over BMI 25) but I got rid of the "gut" that was starting to form and it was extremely successful. I actually have no idea what the calorie deficiency was: I just ballparked it for the first two weeks and then kept that while measuring my weight every morning. I'd say it's about 600-700 max with the weekends reserved for no fat-loss.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by EpicEng on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:09PM (#13429836)
Where did you get those numbers? You're saying that 1lb for this person ~= 700 calories, which is absurdly low, based on my own personal experience as well as everything I've ever read on the topic.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:27PM (#13429991)
I never said all the weight was from calories, most of it is water and waste.

For an "average" person they store 400g of glycogen in their muscles and 100g of glycogen in their liver. In this form, it is bound to 3-4 times as much water. So 500 * 3.5 is 2250g = 5 pounds just from this depletion.

As far as fat burning, a pound of fat has about 3500 calories. A 500 per day deficit will lead to 1 pound of weight loss. However, fat is also bound to water in a roughly 1:1 ratio so you'll also lose a pound of water too. So call this 2 pounds for the second week.

Add in all the weight in your digestive system over that two week period and you'll be ~10 pounds or more in two weeks. Again this assumes a person that is 30+ pounds overweight and has full glycogen stores.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:38PM (#13430076)
I think this is making things too complicated with the water calculations, namely the 1:1 ratio. Adipose tissue is almost completely fat, which in turn is hydrophobic. See the picture on this wikipedia page for reference: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adipocyte. The excess fluid (if any relevant amount exists in the body at the beginning of the diet) is lost fast (days) and early in the course of diest and the key is to have a constant, relatively slow (2-4 kgs / month) weight loss.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:57PM (#13430211)
I'll need to redo some reading but I was under the impression that the TG (Triglyceride) which make up 90% of the Adipocyte require a gram of water for each gram of TG. I see some things that indicate the same thing online but it is less clear.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:20PM (#13430391)
This is not true. 50% is too much even if you take into account the whole fat tissue (which is not what you lose when losing weight) and even there for extremely lean subjects with very little fat in the adipose cells. (Maybe anorectic / cacectic subjects are different in this regard for whole-body-average). You've probably read the conclusions of a confused self-taught "expert" who is making hypotheses based on exaggerated figures of water in fat _tissue_ vs. the fat that is lost when losing weight.

As an interesting sidenote: fat people have relatively a lot less water in their fat tissue than lean people.

You can also think about the fact that when you drop triglycerides in water, it will not solute at all. Also, human body creates fatty membranes (cell walls) to absolutely _prevent_ the influx / efflux of water.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by WorldMaker on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:05PM (#13429799)
I very much feel that food/nutrition calories are the last bastion of Phlogiston Theory in any science and that in every other scientific discipline the proponents of calories and calorie counting would be laughed at as unscientific, at best.

Humans aren't ideal furnaces and food/drink energy content isn't just its temperature output when burnt in a furnace.

It's maybe fine that that's our current best approximation, but seeing it as anything more than a seriously crazy, wild eyed approximation is not good math or science.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by kmm on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:11PM (#13431759)
> Humans aren't ideal furnaces and food/drink energy content isn't just its temperature output when burnt in a furnace.

Yes we are. We get all our energy from oxidizing reduced carbon. The chemical equation is exactly the same and thus the energy produced must be as well. Burning a gram of sugar will yield 4 calories of heat, whether in a furnace or in a mitochondrion.

And because the waste heat is useful in keeping us warm, it's a 100% efficient process.

The sugar, fats or protein you ingest cannot simply stay in your body, and it's not leaving you either (feces has no nutritional value and unless you have diabetes your urine won't be sweet either). So if your body is already at the right temperature, it is going to be stored as fat. There is simply no other way for it to go!

There is no significant interperson difference in metabolisms. Any difference would raise your body temperature, which is what banned dieting aids used to do (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2,4-Dinitrophenol)

Your comparison to phlogiston is frankly insulting. As a physicist, I'm not too fond of the practices in nutrition either, but this is just basic biochemistry that has been known for decades.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by WorldMaker on Thursday January 19, 2017 @11:12AM (#13436867)
«Your comparison to phlogiston is frankly insulting.»

That's why I like the comparison: it's designed to be insulting to anyone that has studied science. It's also a pretty good summary, I feel, of the state of nutrition "science". Key foundational figures of nutrition "science", especially in America, were fellows like Mr. Kellogg that very much were phlogiston-based snake oil salesmen, and we still use a lot of the same methods to view nutrition, just slightly updated.

So in your analysis we have a black box system where the body is a machine (which you claim to be highly efficient) whose inputs are only food and outputs are merely heat, feces, urine, and stored fat. Looking at even just the Wikipedia page on Biochemistry [1], and assuming I have no further training on this subject, this analysis seems to me to be such a gross oversimplification of a lot of very complex processes.

Can you honestly tell me, as a person of physics, that this doesn't look like the biochemical equivalent of the "spherical cow fallacy"? Assume the body is a furnace / assume the cow is spherical.

If we want to cherry pick simplifying assumptions, allow me to bring up the toroidal simplification of the human body. The toroidal simplification suggests that the human body can be simplified to a donut: the gastrointestinal tract being the "hole" in the donut. This assumption is equally "silly" to the "spherical cow", but I think is also a useful simplifying assumption to point out some immediate holes in bare CICO "furnace" assumption. From the toroidal point of view, the GI microbiome is "outside" the body, it's complex signals and hormone productions and biochemical processes are definitely inputs into the body. That brings up the question of how much input the microbiome on the epidermis/skin may input/output, and the obvious other factors that your simplified model above fails to account for outputs such as sweat and exhalation...

Yes, calories can be a useful approximation model, but I have a hard time believing its the best possible approximation model science can build for us.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochemistry

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by kmm on Thursday January 19, 2017 @10:28PM (#13441552)
When considering just the energy balance, calories aren't an approximation. You see, energy is what we call a state function, it depends only on the state of the system and not how we got there. The catabolism of lipids, sugars and proteins into carbon dioxide, water and urea is an extremely complicated process, which I'm not sure we've even completely mapped yet. Last time I counted, the oxidation of glucose in our body takes about 33 steps. However, because we know the difference in energy (actually enthalpy but let's not split hairs) between the input and the output, we know the exact total amount of energy released in all those steps. And it has to be exactly the same as the energy released when simply burning the food in a furnace, because even though the process is wholly different, the begin and end products are the same.

This is barely nutrition, this is just basic thermodynamics. Again, because energy is a state function, no assumptions need to be made about the efficiency of any of the intermediate processes or about how the muscles/mitochondria/liver/kidneys/... work, energy conservation keeps us from having to mess with that.

The reason this analysis is so useful is because we're an endothermic species. The core of all of our bodies are at pretty much the same temperature. And as anyone who's had to pay a heating bill knows, heat isn't cheap. In fact, the bulk of our food energy is expended on keeping us warm. This is why there are no such things as slow or fast metabolism. If your metabolism were too slow to burn your resting energy expenditure in 24 hours, you'd die of undercooling. If your metabolism were significantly faster than normal, you'd die of overheating (or at least you'd feel significantly warm to the touch, be constantly sweating/flushed). In fact, a person's resting metabolic rate can be accurately predicted from their body composition [0], and doesn't differ between age or gender, as would be expected. This puts a pretty high lower limit on one's energy expenditure, absolutely nobody can maintain their weight on, say, 600 calories per day. You simply can't keep a 70 kg sack of mostly water at the right temperature with that energy budget, not with how badly isolated we are.

Even if it does seem oversimplified, it's no spherical cow. The energy balance is exact, because of basic physics and biochemistry: we have only one way of generating energy (oxidizing reduced carbon), only one way of storing energy for the long term (long chains of reduced carbon), no energy is lost (because heat generation is a 100% efficient process) and our digestion is very efficient (not feces, urine nor sweat contain significant amounts of carbohydrates, lipids, protein or any other high-energy compound). It's also useful because we have an unflexible lower limit to the amount of energy we expend in a day because of the way our bodies work. The wiggle-room on the previous assumptions only serves to make calories-in smaller (e.g. malabsorption) or calories-out larger (e.g. exercise), and thus would only make it easier to lose weight.

I won't deny the microbiome is important. There is a probably a correlation between gut biome and obesity. But that can only because it influences things like satiety or mood, because none of those bacteria seem to change the eventual energy equation, nor do they change how much heat you need to produce to keep warm or energy expended when lifting a weight. They're relevant because willpower is a finite resource, but they don't change the fact that any diet will in some sense need to consist of eating less calories than you burn in a day

0: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3139779/

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by WorldMaker on Friday January 20, 2017 @11:15AM (#13444800)
« When considering just the energy balance »

Which is a simplifying assumption that I'm having trouble with here. "Energy balance" does not directly correlate with mass. Yes, there are a lot of indirect relationships and I appreciate you expanding upon them, but in the supposed logic chain of balance energy and thus balance mass, I think there are too many simplifying assumptions that black box the variety and depth of biochemical processes without factoring for them or building an error model for them. There is nothing wrong with using a black box model for a first order estimation/approximation, knowing your error bars and limitations and what next steps you would need to get more accurate data. I think there is something wrong with putting blinders on and pretending that your black box model is the entirety of the facts and can contain no error.

You mention enthalpy, but roughly ignore the entirety of entropy in the equation; you are essentially handwaving it as an unimportant. I think it's lack in the model is telling. (There are multiple reasons the SI switched from calories to Joules as the measure of energy, and phlogiston-influenced thermodynamic baggage is part of that.)

« we have only one way of generating energy (oxidizing reduced carbon) »

We absolutely have anaerobic energy processes at work in our bodies every day. Muscle tissues are an example. The long tail variety of microorganism in our microbiome certainly includes plenty of other examples, our old friend yeast being a prime example.

I could pick apart the other incorrect assumptions from your oversimplifying model, but this one alone is telling enough.

« They're relevant because willpower is a finite resource »

Here's the real problem: there is no direct correlation between mass and "willpower". Bringing up willpower here is slippery slope attempt to make a connection between weight and morality that is unjust at best. That is where the "calories in, calories out" rhetoric absolutely swerves to become more religious revival (the Protestant work ethic applied to food and exercise) than anything resembling science. Teach the controversy.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by kmm on Saturday January 21, 2017 @08:38PM (#13453090)
Our mass directly correlates with the energy balance because we can't make energy from nothing, we get it from stores of high energy compounds containing reduced carbon (Preferably fat, but strict diets can lead to loss of muscle mass as well). I've already explained the key assumptions that make the black box model perform so well, and I don't see a massive problem with any of them. Definitely not any that make weight loss impossible or an insurmountable task (i.e. requiring to eat minuscule amounts)

Entropy is irrelevant and I can't explain why if I don't know why you think it is (possible retorts: we don't use heat engines to perform work, the bulk of our food energy goes to heat and producing heat is always 100% efficient, the reaction rates are not dependent on Gibbs energy because of enzymes etc..).

I never said my black box model is completely accurate. It would be if we had all the parameters, but we don't. The calories-in part is 99% accurate and it helps that it's an upper limit. The calories-out part is harder to predict, but one can get close enough when considering just the basal metabolic rate necessary for survival, that even mechanically ventilated people need to live.

> We absolutely have anaerobic energy processes at work in our bodies every day. Muscle tissues are an example. The long tail variety of microorganism in our microbiome certainly includes plenty of other examples, our old friend yeast being a prime example.

First of all, I explicitly mentioned exercise as one of caveats. But unless you're a top athlete, it's a pretty small part of the energy balance anyways, and on my usual day my muscles are rarely starved of oxygen. And it still doesn't matter because it doesn't change the energy equation! The rest product of anaerobic fermentation in our body is a relatively high energy compound called lactate. We don't expel most of it, so it's not part of calories-out. It gets converted back into glucose and stays part of our mass. Same with the anaerobic microbiome. They don't make our feces more nutritious and they don't perform useful work (in the physics sense), so either they make heat or they expel high energy compounds that we then absorb and metabolize as part of calories-in.

I think it's unfair for you to accuse me of having blinders on. I don't pretend to know everything about the biochemistry of the human body. But I do know the constraints physics puts on it. I'm lucky that our body just so happens to work in a way that I can quite confidently state these things because of a few key assumptions that allow me to abstract over it using basic physics. I'm more than willing to revise my ideas, but you or someone else will first have to give strong facts which is not what I've seen here. One would also have to explain why caloric restriction works perfectly fine in a controlled environment (as many, many articles prove). Or simply explain how with a reduced caloric intake, one could supposedly stay alive without losing mass. Heck, as much as I rue anecdotal evidence, you can try it yourself.

> Here's the real problem: there is no direct correlation between mass and "willpower". Bringing up willpower here is slippery slope attempt to make a connection between weight and morality that is unjust at best. That is where the "calories in, calories out" rhetoric absolutely swerves to become more religious revival (the Protestant work ethic applied to food and exercise) than anything resembling science. Teach the controversy.

Good thing I'm Catholic then, and not even American. Diet is nothing but willpower. I won't pretend it's easy. Life is already hard and dieting takes a long time of fighting a basic instinct. But even if you don't believe in "calories-in, calories-out" (which I still don't think is justified), everyone believes in conservation of mass. If you eat less, you'll lose weight: http://blog.ifac-control.org/2016/12/05/closed-loop-weight-c...

I don't make any moral judgments about this, as I rarely do: I could never pretend to know another person's struggle. I don't think the recent obesity epidemic is a sudden widespread moral failure, but rather an change in environment that had an unexpected effect. But I also don't like ungrounded excuses, nor how quite a few of the comments on this page don't provide any evidence for quite extraordinary claims.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by agumonkey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @06:06PM (#13431331)
I feel alone when I cringe at the linear combustion engine metaphor from the 50s that drives nutrition.

How many people don't agree with this ? our body is full of variables that can impede or accelerate processes.

I could eat a nutella jar and not weight a gram, some people almost get fat at the sight of sweets.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by diabeetusman on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:48PM (#13429104)
I'm seeing studies showing the reverse-- endorphins can suppress insulin creation (and lead to hyperglycemia) (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2944808). Got any links? Really interested in reading more (see username)
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by opportune on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:12PM (#13429339)
Warning, informal logic ahead:

A substance A can be a net promoter of both a compound B and a compound C, even if the compound B suppresses C, provided that the direct promotion of A on C is greater than the direct suppression of B on C per the changed in B.

In other words, when I ignite a pile of wood(A), the wood releases (among other things) both water(B) and smoke(C). Now, independently high amounts of water will tend to put out smoke, but in these quantities much more smoke is released than the water required to put it out.

I don't have a source on how much endorphins sugar releases but I would imagine it's an analogous case. In fact, things like this are really common in the human body because if the half lives of action are different, they can help return the body to homeostasis. In this case, I hypothesize that the endorphin effect on insulin could serve to reduce insulin to more normal levels in the blood-stream after the initial spike due to sugar intake.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by gukov on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:03PM (#13429781)
I'm a fellow T1 that's also a coder. I literally count grams for living. That's how I'm able to achieve a 5.0% A1C. Different macros absolutely affect your brain differently. A lunch high in carbs hinders my coding.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:10PM (#13429322)
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20648910

Also, more anecdotally, how many people do you know who get hangry from low blood sugar? How many people eat when they are sad to feel better?

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by GordonS on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:31PM (#13429529)
I'm not sure if 'hangry' was meant to be 'angry' or 'hungry', but low blood sugar can cause both.

A medical condition means I can get hypoglycemic, and when I do I can become completely irrational and very aggressive. Also, a drop in blood sugar can signal hunger.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by mediocrejoker on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:38PM (#13429592)
Hangry is a deliberate portmanteau of hungry and angry
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by NikolaeVarius on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:57PM (#13429188)
The endorphin rush is completely independent of a calorie. If you eat less you will lose weight.

It is physically impossible not to. You could be fed a drip of pure sugar and you will lose weight as long as you receive fewer calories that you burn.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by opportune on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:32PM (#13429535)
Because humans are not robots, typically instead of laboriously calculating how many calories we eat each day, we eat to a point of satiety. Some foods are better and some are worse at causing satiety. So in that sense, a kcal of sugar isn't the "same" as a kcal of protein because one makes you feel more "full" than the other and thus naturally encourages you to eat less.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by NikolaeVarius on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:19PM (#13429929)
Irrelevant.

Humans are also not known for keeping track of how fast they run to millisecond precision but people do it to achieve a goal.

If your goal is to lose weight, track calories to do it. I can lose weight on demand eating nothing but junk but keeping track of how much of it I'm eating.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by joecool1029 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:26PM (#13429473)
While there is some truth to that... (Google 'potato hack') there's a ton of biochemical signaling that goes on to affect satiety and whether the cells burn or store that calorie input.

Here's a blog post breaking down a recent paper on the topic: http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.co.uk/2016/03/boiled-mash...

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by antisthenes on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:09PM (#13430298)
Satiety is orthogonal to losing weight.

So saying there is some truth to that is extremely snarky and dismissive.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by abecedarius on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:07PM (#13429821)
Do you burn a constant number of calories as you vary the calories consumed?

No, not even if you keep your exercise regimen constant. The body is a complicated self-regulating feedback control system. It's not even surprising for it to reduce the burn rate when the input gets leaner.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by xherberta on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:34PM (#13430050)
In an older discussion on this issue, travisp shared this article: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=1199154 >Effects of Dietary Composition on Energy Expenditure During Weight-Loss Maintenance >

"The results of our study challenge the notion that a calorie is a calorie from a metabolic perspective. During isocaloric feeding ... total energy expenditure differed by approximately 300 kcal/d between very-low-carb and low-fat diets, an effect corresponding with the amount of energy typically expended in 1 hour of moderate-intensity physical activity."

"In conclusion, our study demonstrates that commonly consumed diets can affect metabolism and components of the metabolic syndrome in markedly different ways during weight-loss maintenance, independent of energy content. The low-fat diet produced changes in energy expenditure and serum leptin42- 44 that would predict weight regain. In addition, this conventionally recommended diet had unfavorable effects on most of the metabolic syndrome components studied herein."

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by ceejayoz on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:18PM (#13429394)
"Put me in solitary confinement with an IV drip" isn't a very feasible diet plan, so managing non-calorie stuff like satiety, glycemic index, etc. can still have value.

Side note: "as long as you receive fewer calories that you burn" ignores the fact that how much you burn can change.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by cheald on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:55PM (#13429720)
My own personal experience has been that managing nothing but calories is the most successful approach by a mile, but that sticking to decent macros is the best way to manage my satiation and stick to my calorie budget.

If you're managing satiety and glycemic index and ignoring calorie intake, you're not going to manage weight well. These are all tools in managing calorie inputs, not replacements for it.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by alasdair_ on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:12PM (#13430321)
Weigh yourself, drink a gallon of zero-calorie water, weigh yourself again.

Too simplistic? Okay, try drastically increasing or decreasing your salt intake and keep all other factors the same - you'll see a weight change from water retention.

Again too simplistic? Okay, try substituting 500 calories a standard diet with 500 calories of celery. Note that even keeping all other factors constant, you lose more weight with the celery.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by WorldMaker on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @06:27PM (#13431493)
Don't forget too that there fun things on the market like "zero-calorie soda". If there is a simple proof that a calorie is not a calorie, it's that an oxymoron like "zero-calorie soda" is even possible, that the metric even allows for such an edge case/loophole [1].

[1] Because the sugar replacements are artificial 'plastics' that apparently don't burn when set on fire; how can that possibly be healthy?

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by agumonkey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:56PM (#13431257)
Western lifestyle is built on such pretentious lies ...