Humans are also not known for keeping track of how fast they run to millisecond precision but people do it to achieve a goal.
If your goal is to lose weight, track calories to do it. I can lose weight on demand eating nothing but junk but keeping track of how much of it I'm eating.
Here's a blog post breaking down a recent paper on the topic: http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.co.uk/2016/03/boiled-mash...
So saying there is some truth to that is extremely snarky and dismissive.
No, not even if you keep your exercise regimen constant. The body is a complicated self-regulating feedback control system. It's not even surprising for it to reduce the burn rate when the input gets leaner.
"The results of our study challenge the notion that a calorie is a calorie from a metabolic perspective. During isocaloric feeding ... total energy expenditure differed by approximately 300 kcal/d between very-low-carb and low-fat diets, an effect corresponding with the amount of energy typically expended in 1 hour of moderate-intensity physical activity."
"In conclusion, our study demonstrates that commonly consumed diets can affect metabolism and components of the metabolic syndrome in markedly different ways during weight-loss maintenance, independent of energy content. The low-fat diet produced changes in energy expenditure and serum leptin42- 44 that would predict weight regain. In addition, this conventionally recommended diet had unfavorable effects on most of the metabolic syndrome components studied herein."
Side note: "as long as you receive fewer calories that you burn" ignores the fact that how much you burn can change.
If you're managing satiety and glycemic index and ignoring calorie intake, you're not going to manage weight well. These are all tools in managing calorie inputs, not replacements for it.
Too simplistic? Okay, try drastically increasing or decreasing your salt intake and keep all other factors the same - you'll see a weight change from water retention.
Again too simplistic? Okay, try substituting 500 calories a standard diet with 500 calories of celery. Note that even keeping all other factors constant, you lose more weight with the celery.
[1] Because the sugar replacements are artificial 'plastics' that apparently don't burn when set on fire; how can that possibly be healthy?
It is physically impossible not to. You could be fed a drip of pure sugar and you will lose weight as long as you receive fewer calories that you burn.