News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by gamblor956 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:05PM (#13431721)
Anecdotal evidence that a calorie is not just a calorie:

4 of my buddies are doing a weight-loss challenge ahead of this spring's local marathon. They're each losing about 10-12 pounds over the month of January.

3 of them kept their calorie intakes roughly the same but changed their macros to favor protein and fat (and no changes to their exercise regimes). All 3 have already reached their goal without significant loss of muscle mass. One guy switch to the keto diet for January (<25g carbs/day), and is at 16 pounds lost as of last night. The 4th guy lowered his caloric intake but maintained his carb-heavy diet. He's lost 4 pounds, and he's struggling with hunger and trying to lose more weight.

You'll definitely still lose weight if you calories consumed < calories burned. But you'll lose more fat if those calories are consumed in the proper ratios. Increasing protein consumption while at a caloric deficit minimizes muscle loss, especially when combined with (even minimal) weight training.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by snarf21 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @09:19AM (#13435912)
"...and he's struggling with hunger and trying to lose more weight."

This is all I was really trying to emphasize. When it comes time to burn energy, calories are the same, but this isn't true when eating.

High sugar affects insulin and other things that may it hard for people to stick with it. Eating meals high in fat provides higher satiety (you feel full longer). Eating vegetables high in fiber fills your stomach with large mass but low sugar so you'll feel full longer while that breaks down.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by QSIITurbo on Thursday January 19, 2017 @01:59AM (#13433715)
Keto is the absolute worst you can do as an athlete since carbohydrates are required for fast recovery. No professional athlete would be on keto while training. The idea that an athlete should have even slightly over 1g/kg of protein intake per day is correct. However, over 2g/kg/day poses a risk of permanent kidney damage.

Moreover, losing 4 kgs or more of fat in a month increases the risk for cardiovascular disease: the blood cholesterol levels of the subjects may rise to unhealthy levels. Some are resistant to high cholesterol, but statistically it's a risk.

Re:Big Sugar’s Secret Ally? Nutritionists by cableshaft on Thursday January 19, 2017 @04:41PM (#13439734)
Keto can result in (somewhat) worse performance depending on how professional you're trying to be and what activity you're doing, but most people aren't trying to compete at that level and they can work out while on a keto diet.

Also, some people up their carb intake a little before their workout, so it'll burn off and they'll still be in keto afterwards while not risking performance loss.

Finally, you don't double your protein intake on keto, you replace your carb intake with fat, so you wouldn't be at 2g/kg/day danger levels you're suggesting if you're doing the diet properly.