For assets traded on an exchange at least (e.g., not directly-invested real estate), it's more of a logistical problem than anything else: how do you track indices that you want to track by dripping money into and out of the market, both trying not to affect supply/demand too much, but while not deviating from the index too much. It's the same problem that a BlackRock or Vanguard face but at slightly smaller (!) scale, and one more for computer programmers with knowledge of market microstructure than people that demand outsize bonuses who think they have "alpha" and get lucky (or not).
Would make for a good headline, too. "$60 Million for a coin flip!"
There's simply no evidence that is true at all. Every study of this issue says the exact opposite: there's no one out there who can pick stocks.
Yet remember that active mutual funds manager fees are close to 1%. If you pay $60M on $900B, we're talking about paying less than 1 bp! So if you have an average active mutual fund manager running your $900B fund for $60M, you might hope to beat the market by a few basis points.
It seems a bit contradictory, but BH is a holding company versus a hedge fund.
http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/berkshire-hathaway-stock-warre...
Let's say the best performing fund is (fictional) Xanadu Investments we'd ask, how do we explain Xanadu's performance.
This requires a source. Many of the companies he purchases are public companies. If they are selling "cheaper" because they like Mr. Buffet, there's a problem.
The public stock acquisitions that they talk about on the 13-F are really a minority of Berkshire's activity, but sometimes he really does get a better price because he's willing and able to negotiate weird deals like the Bank of America warrants.
That said, you have to hold for a long time to see that edge. If you don't the odds go negative again.
http://www.investmentnews.com/article/20160318/FREE/16031992...
[...] and no one else could/would have performed better for less than $60M.
The parent comment sort of implied that the fund couldn't possibly have overpaid, because 60M$ is such a small fraction of profits. All I'm saying is that they might have overpaid, at the time of signing the contract, if another equally skilled manager would have taken the job for a smaller compensation package.
Even beyond that, there are only about 200 sovereign states in the world. I'd say a country like Norway, with fewer citizens than the state of Washington, controlling 1% of global anything is noteworthy and undeserving of scoff.
The fund has also started to become active in pushing for lower executive pay...
That said, $60MM per year for $325MM AuM does seem a lot.
Anyway, that manager needs to negotiate a better deal if they only get 60m annually with almost a trillion AUM
Also, it depends on how much he brings in. For example, there are US based asset managers with private funds that generate 20-30-40% per annum, for over 20 years. If the performance is there, they should get compensated well for that. Otherwise, why put up with the stress of managing billions of dollars?
It is impossible, at least continuously. Nobody has ever managed to do that. You'd be lucky if you could beat the market by a few points on average over a 20 years time period. Compensation well for good performance does not make sense when you aren't penalized for losses.
Joel Greenblatt's fund beat an annualized return of 40% from 1985 to 2006.
Carl Icahn got over a 30% per year annualized return from 1968 to 2011. That's almost 50 years!
None of that matters if you can't pick the winning players in advance. With enough variance and enough players, someone will eventually have double-digit annualized returns over decades, it doesn't mean that they are necessarily superb investors.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/antoinegara/2015/07/31/value-gur...
http://gdsinvestments.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/The-Sup...
That said, a fund this size should be taking as passive of an approach as possible.
AKA, if you think there are people that do better than average, then picking people who have beaten the odds for 10 years and see how they do over the next 10 years. Repeat over a few decades.
There are things that seem to work. The most common way to 'beat the market' is trading a low chance and ideally hidden chance of failure for inflated returns. EX: A 1 percent change of losing 95% of your investment should be worth lot's of money on good years. This is really appealing when investing other peoples money as you don't share in their downside.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/antoinegara/2015/07/31/value-gur...
Citation? This would turn a $10,000 initial investment into $13BB. I have a hard time believing that.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_Technologies
"...famed for one of the best records in investing history, returning more than 35 percent annualized over a 20-year span..."
So, cynicism and economic orthodoxy aside, that sounds like a really cool company. Has anyone tried just tossing a big dumb neural network on stock data and investigated whether it can make money? It sounds very obvious, but a quick googling returns little. But I guess the investment industry is pretty secretive by nature.
... yes.
Renaissance technology is a quantitative trading company, meaning they use computers to trade; they probably do thousands of trades per day, and consistently make a profit. There's approximately 0% chance that it's just luck.
Now, you might say, they were lucky to stumble upon a strategy that works. You can also say that the strategy will stop working at some point (because of competition), so their "luck" will run out, and they might not get "lucky" in time to find a new strategy. But their past performance was most definitely not just "luck".
Btw, in most other professions (e.g. the arts, technical inventions, sports) we call this kind of "luck", "skill".
CNNs can be used in other fields as well.
Dell's market cap at IPO was $80M.
You can't just pick one good company to invest in. What would these funds do with the other, oh, $10Bn they need to invest?
However, Buffett and Soros managed to average above 20% annual returns over 30 plus years.
For example in the 1960s Berkshire returned 28.3% per year averaged. In the 1970s it returned 22.2% per year averaged. In the 1980s it averaged 39.1% (!) per year. In the 1990s it averaged 20.5% per year.
Nobody would hold their breath on another investor matching Buffett or Soros. It is in fact possible though. The big problem for the Norway fund is obviously the scale. Berkshire at $360b in market cap, will struggle perpetually going forward with keeping up with the S&P 500 over time (as is frequently noted by Buffett).
I absolutely agree that the average person should stick to passive index funds. But if you have nearly a trillion dollars to invest, you'd be a fool to stick to passive strategies.
> there are US based asset managers with private funds that generate 20-30-40% per annum, for over 20 years.
That seems extremely dubious. Do you have any sources?
In other words: it's easy to pick the lottery numbers with hindsight.
Pure Horseshit. Plain and simple.
Or, in other words: "Pics. Or it didn't happen."
Guess public sentiment hasn't caught up to such practices, yet, so they can get away with it.
What is the failure rate for such private funds? Obviously, we may never hear of their failures, just as we don't hear of their successes.
I feel you really taking a bias stance here without understanding the mechanics. Yes privilege exists, the same as you friend might tell you a job is opening before its open knowledge. But deals will be shopped about. The big difference is many deals cant reasonably go to the public market. Costs for listing regulations would be significant and unnecessary. Consider, you need to be called as a 'sophisticated' investor even to trade options. This is to protect the public from unscrupulous pyramid schemes and business that carries high knowledge levels to understand what your buying into. It's as much about protecting the public keeping some deals away from open markets as being 'privileged'.
> Obviously, we may never hear of their failures If your around this industry you hear plenty of both sides. Bigger ones go to public news like Madoff.
The fund spends a lot on being actively managed, one manager received ~$60 million in bonuses in 2010. However, they won't reply when people ask if bonuses are actually financially beneficial.
https://tv.nrk.no/serie/folkeopplysningen/KMTE50009215/seson... @ 28:30