News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ghaff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:34PM (#12409635)
I get why the TV manufacturers don't like the concept but TVs should really be dumb displays. Using something like a ChromeCast to get content to the TV makes so much more sense than embedding "intelligence" in a display.

It's the same mismatch of lifecycles that you get with entertainment (and navigation) electronics in cars.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by violentvinyl on Friday September 02, 2016 @05:40AM (#12411912)
It's interesting that Smart TVs seem to have two lives, the first as a Smart TV, and the later as a dumb display.

At least in some cars, you can still replace the ICE if it accomodates single or double DIN units. The newer cars with hidden "brains" and a proprietary display though, will that be the equivalent of having an 8-track player mounted under the dash in a few years?

It reminds me of a very good Mitch Hedberg quote: "An escalator can never break: it can only become stairs. You should never see an Escalator Temporarily Out Of Order sign, just Escalator Temporarily Stairs. Sorry for the convenience."

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by titzer on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:36AM (#12412093)
I've certainly seen escalators undergoing maintenance where the floor at the base was opened up and workers were standing inside. Wouldn't want to take those stairs in that case :)
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by masklinn on Friday September 02, 2016 @07:31AM (#12412276)
And I've taken some escalators which might as well be broken when they "become stairs", I wouldn't walk up and down the StPetersburg metro escalators (most of the stations are >50m below ground).
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by DrJokepu on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:01AM (#12412680)
Not true at all! Escalators don't necessarily fail safe. If the brake is faulty, it is very dangerous to use an out of service escalator as stairs.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ced on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:07AM (#12412713)
What happens?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by riskable on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:40AM (#12412949)
Best case: "I don't seem to be making any progress going up."

Worst case: "This is moving down way too fast! Aaaahhhhh!!!" -screamed by hundreds of people, many of which will die as they pile up at the bottom of the escalator.

Now imagine the brakes failing on an escalator that leads down into a subway with an electrified rail.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by scandox on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:46AM (#12412989)
You've really upset my lunch break
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by DrJokepu on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:45AM (#12412981)
The weight of your body will set the escalator in motion and it will keep accelerating. As you approach the bottom end at ever increasing speeds you will have a few moments to contemplate on what a mistake it was to not take physics class in high school. Once you reach the end of the line your journey will end in a rather unpleasant manner due to the high velocity. You could get injured very seriously or even killed.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by sitkack on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:13AM (#12413154)
Sounds like a gravity powered human rail-gun.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by hiddenkrypt on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:08AM (#12413518)
That describes a playground slide.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by joshstrange on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:15AM (#12413167)
This [0] is the first thing that comes to mind. IIRC the elevator had an OOO sign on it but this women went on it anyways.

[0] NSFL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RcpjOIH7bG4

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by criddell on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:07AM (#12412714)
For me, a big part of the problem has been that smart tv's were anything but smart. They were slow, threatened to overlay ads, assaulted your privacy, had terrible UIs, and were difficult to use.

The usability issue is starting to be fixed. My daughter bought a cheap TV from Amazon that has the Roku software and it works incredibly well. The TV was something like $165 for a 32" display.

I don't know what the long term prospects are for this. What happens if our LAN goes IPV6? Or Roku's agreement with Netflix changes? etc... I'm not terribly concerned because in a few years a replacement will be $100.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by joombaga on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:19AM (#12412791)
The premium for the "smart" version of TV "x" is getting lower. I just bought a Roku TV last month. For the 55" Roku TV I bought last month, it was basically $0. If it becomes a dumb TV in 4 years I won't be too bothered. The 2020 FooNexusCastWebFireBar will probably be better anyway.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by criddell on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:16AM (#12413176)
> The premium for the "smart" version of TV "x" is getting lower.

That's great, as long as it isn't because they are making money on showing ads, replacing ads, or selling your viewing data (without proper disclosure, of course).

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:28AM (#12413251)
It doesn't help much if they're doing it with proper disclosure, if buyers have no realistic alternative because everyone is doing it.

At some point, if we value our privacy at all, real laws are going to be required to halt the race to the bottom that is already well underway.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by criddell on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:47AM (#12413816)
If we value our privacy? Some of us do, some of us don't.

I value my privacy, but I don't put a terribly high value on it. If Google or Apple wanted to track my TV habits with the promise of serving me better in some way, I would probably sign up for that in a heartbeat. But when my off-brand TV wants to, I would decline.

That may mean some products and services aren't easily available to those that put a high value on their privacy.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:22PM (#12414125)
That may mean some products and services aren't easily available to those that put a high value on their privacy.

Or we could decide that some things are too high a price to pay and not allow the businesses to include mandatory surveillance technologies. Are TV makers really going to stop making TVs if they aren't allowed to spy on their customers as well? Are TV prices really going to be lower with that spying going on if everyone in the industry is doing it anyway?

Regulation is what you do when competition no longer provides an acceptable level of choice in the market. What constitutes an acceptable level of choice may well depend on how important or even essential a certain type of product or service is, but in any case preventing a lack of real competition from causing this kind of customer-hostile race to the bottom is a valid use of statutory regulation IMHO.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by criddell on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:19PM (#12414592)
Everything you say is true. I just think you value your privacy far more than the general public does. People seem to be willing to surrender an astonishing amount of data to get very little in return.

I personally have changed from being that guy who always used cash, who responded to every privacy notice that was mailed to me, who never signed up for loyalty programs, to really not caring about it anymore. For me, I see tangible benefits and only theoretical harm.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:47PM (#12414796)
I certainly do value my privacy much more than the average person. I don't even have accounts on the likes of Facebook, for example. I am not even close to an average level of concern, and I fully acknowledge that.

On the other hand, I am also far more technically knowledgeable about the potential implications of privacy intrusions than the average person, and unfortunately I have all too often seen what can happen to friends and colleagues who aren't as careful as me and wind up victims.

The harm may only be theoretical in your experience, and I've no reason to doubt you. However, just thinking about my personal contacts over the years, I have heard of lost jobs (multiple times), credit denied for a mortgage, a gay friend living in my country whose society back home is still hostile to homosexuality being publicly outed by mistake, identity thefts (multiple) including a huge financial loss to a company I sometimes work with where someone authorised to make large payments was very carefully impersonated using a range of information gathered over a considerable period of time, leaks of potentially embarrassing healthcare records (multiple times from multiple sources), cyberstalking (really creepy remote access to unsecured in-house devices like baby monitors and cameras) and a couple of big surprises (on the scale of a marriage proposal) spoiled by careless disclosures. I'm not aware of any personal contact of mine who has been a victim of something like burglary or having their children taken as a result of a criminal discovering and exploiting their household routines, but obviously these aren't out of the question either.

Now, obviously I'm not suggesting that someone spying on your TV habits is necessarily going to lead to harm on that scale (though I note in passing that if you hold a public office and watch the "wrong" TV programmes then it's not entirely inconceivable, hence laws like the Video Privacy Protection Act in the US). But the risks from excessive surveillance, including the collection and use of incomplete or inaccurate data, are not theoretical at all. If you've never known anyone suffer the kinds of problems I mentioned above then I'd guess you and your friends have been extremely lucky; it's not like this stuff happens in my social group all the time, but I'd estimate that I've heard about at least one or two serious problems a year over the past decade or so.

All of this affects my opinions, naturally. However, perhaps the thing that sways me more than anything else is that I've been noticing recently how much some people are put off by privacy intrusions if they are better informed about what is really happening and the implications. I think a lot of people simply don't understand what they are allegedly consenting to or what might happen as a result, and sometimes you can't even see the results. After all, how do you know whether your insurance premium has been increased, your credit limit affected, or your job application denied, on the basis of information you never knew someone else had and never had any opportunity to check or refute? Realistically, I don't think it's possible to educate everyone sufficiently on these issues for them to protect themselves as much as they might choose to if they were fully informed, any more than you can make everyone an expert on how financial services work or the shady practices of used car dealers. This is why we delegate some amount of protection to people who do have the time and resources to become experts, and who do have a mandate to balance allowing businesses to do business against looking out for the interests of society as a whole.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by touristtam on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:36AM (#12413288)
The issue is when the onboard computer comes bundled with sypware.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by danudey on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:29PM (#12416037)
You mean like those Samsung TVs that scanned your network shares even if you told it not to and sent the names of all the files it saw to a server somewhere?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:43PM (#12409672)
It's not the TV manufacturers that don't like that concept it's that consumers don't like the concept. Every TV is a "dumb display", consumers wanted more features.

Sony, LG, Samsung and w/e would love nothing more than to sell you only a panel with video input ports but that is not what people want to buy. People are constantly buying the most feature loaded TV's even at the expense of getting lesser panel quality, inch size and various other things.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by killbrad on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:10AM (#12410785)
Do you have any evidence of this? I've never ever talked to anyone that wanted a feature like this in their TV. The manufacturers have incentive, but the consumers aren't asking for it.

And -all- of the interfaces built in to TVs for such things I've used are terrible. Hell, most TVs still can't make a remote/on-screen UI work reasonably. People can talk to their voice agents ("hello assistant, who is the president of the USA") on the toilet and generally expect a reasonable answer. And yet we still have to point some wand at an exact spot on our TVs, press buttons, and hope they register and change channels.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by aedron on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:56AM (#12411378)
I actually have a 2012 Bravia. It has a webcam and a Skype app. When we get a Skype call, a little popup appears in the bottom left corner, and I can accept/decline with the remote. I can then carry out a video call in either full 50 inches or composited with the TV signal. Coolest thing ever.

Digital recording is a great feature too, plug in a USB stick for storage then control and manage recordings with the remote. I actually like to have everything integrated, rather than having to fiddle with my OSMC, which, as an example, in the case of recording would need its own signal input.

My only (yet pretty big) issue with the Sony software is that it is slow to start up. From turning on the TV until it will respond to the remote is easily 40-50 seconds, long after the picture appears. You can't even change the channel or volume.

And, oh yeah, the YouTube app has been broken for years, but I use the OSMC for that.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by gst on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:02AM (#12412688)
> I actually have a 2012 Bravia. It has a webcam and a Skype app.

Skype is the next thing that's going to disappear from that TV: https://support.skype.com/en/faq/FA34642/is-the-skype-for-tv...

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by danieldk on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:33AM (#12412567)
I can then carry out a video call in either full 50 inches or composited with the TV signal. Coolest thing ever.

So can my XBox One :). I agree that this is a nice feature, but there is no reason why this can't be part of an external replaceable/upgradable peripheral. I'm also kind of surprised that Apple and Google didn't create an add-on for Apple TV/Chromecast yet, or we could give it to our daughters' grandparents as well ;).

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pmontra on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:16AM (#12411451)
What happens when you're on a Skype call on the TV and want to move to another room? I guess it's like with the old wired phones, you don't move. A 50" display is cool but a tablet or a phone are usually better suited to answer calls.

The only smart feature I'm using of my LG TV is playing videos from USB sticks. It doesn't have some audio codecs common in MKV containers, but when it works 40" is better than a tablet screen. BTW, the LG is quick enough at starting up. I usually keep it completely off, not in standby. Switch on the power, push the remote, get the image: 9 seconds. Maybe on par with old analog CRTs.

I never enabled WiFi because of the terms of service. Even if they are not as invasive as other ToS I saw from other manufacturers, they are way more than they should. I should use the TV to watch things, not to be watched. I already have the PC, tablet and phone for that :-) and at least I can fight there with adblockers and the like.

I have a Raspberry 3 connected to the TV and I could do YouTube with that (it's quite OK). Still the tablet is much better. I could chromecast to the TV but it's not worth the trouble.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by will_hughes on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:41AM (#12411540)
> What happens when you're on a Skype call on the TV and want to move to another room? I

I imagine the same thing that happens when you get a call on your Desktop and want to move to another room. "Hey, let me call you back."

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by aedron on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:48AM (#12412129)
If I'm sitting in the sofa and answer the call from there, it usually means I am fine staying put. We usually use it for family abroad, and here the format has the obvious advantage that the whole family can gather around the TV and see/be seen in the call.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by kozak on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:20AM (#12411684)
Samsung has discontinued their Skype TV app this summer, I think Sony will follow soon.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by cstrat on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:54AM (#12411790)
I agree that a lot of features are generally pretty useless... however I love that I can download the Netflix app to my TV directly. It saves me having to use a second device and I can update to another VOD provider if my TV outlives Netflix...
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by riskable on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:47AM (#12412997)
My "smart" LG TV has a Netflix app. Still have a Chromecast hooked up for Netflix. Why? Because it is several orders of magnitude faster for me to find the video I want to play on my phone than it is with a TV remote.

This same wisdom holds true for TV remotes that have full QWERTY keyboards! TV interfaces just plain suck. They are so slow as to be painful and they are perpetually out of date and always user-unfriendly.

I really hoped Apple would come out with a TV that set a baseline for what a TV interface should be just like the original iPhone did for smart phones (which weren't all that smart at the time).

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ksk on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:41AM (#12413776)
Well if you believe that consumers can vote with their wallets, at least in part, then they've already shown you what they prefer.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by IANAD on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:50PM (#12410253)
> consumers wanted more features

Maybe so, but I never personally asked the TV manufacturers for a smart TV.

Who I think came up with the idea: TV manufacturers.

Selling hardware that has software/firmware, that will become obsolete in 4-8 years, will result in more TVs sold in 4-8 years than would have been.

We just got rid of a TV that we've had since the late 1990s- about 18 years. It was not smart. We just bought a smart TV and I'm betting we won't get more than 8 years out of it.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by kbutler on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:32PM (#12410652)
When the "smart" features age out to obsolescence, you can still hook up a chromecast/roku/etc., just like to a "dumb" TV.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by flukus on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:01AM (#12411403)
There are other issues with not recieving software updates. How many millions of people will end up with zombie TV's sitting in their living rooms?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by deadbunny on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:09AM (#12412444)
Exactly. My TV was connected to my network for initial setup then promptly disconnected and used as a dumb display. I don't trust other people to keep devices on my network patched and up to date even during their supported lifetime.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by IANAD on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:40PM (#12410680)
The Roku is built into this TV such that I must use the Roku OS and remote when the TV comes on. It is much slicker than the other crap smart TV interfaces I've used, but when it goes out of style, that means I'll have to use one Roku remote to turn the TV on, browse to the port of the other one, click ok, and now I'm in the second Roku OS. That won't be as nice. Still- for now, it's fine, which is why I bought it.

If I could have gotten the same TV without any smart features and an external Roku, that would have been better long-term, but almost all newer TVs now are smart.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @06:39PM (#12439781)
> If I could have gotten the same TV without any smart features and an external Roku, that would have been better long-term, but almost all newer TVs now are smart.

Its important to remember that "TVs" are just "displays whose bundled additional features include at least a TV tuner".

Unless you absolutely need a TV tuner, you can get displays that include neither a TV tuner nor smart features, but they aren't sold as "TVs" because they aren't.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:18PM (#12410373)
If you were OK with a TV for 18 years you would be OK with another TV for 18 years.

This is simply a fallacy the fact that the software would become obsolete doesn't make the TV obsolete as long as it can still receive a video input and display it - this has nothing to do with the "smart" features of the TV.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by red_admiral on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:32AM (#12411506)
Here in the UK, the BBC has something they call the "red button" feature - most of the time, it just brings up "teletext 2.0" with some news headlines etc. but when there's something like the olympics on, you can use it to switch between coverage of different events.

On my "dumb" TV that is not and never will be connected to the 'net, this feature works fine and has done so for years. On my friend's "smart" TV, the red button feature has been replaced by an "app" that we had to update and fiddle with to get it working, and it won't do anything at all without an internet connection despite the key feature just being a kind of switch between two sub-channels, both of which are served over the usual aerial/cable. You can't even turn this off to get the normal red button back.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by memsom on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:06AM (#12413508)
That works on FreeView by broadcasting extra channels. They have something like 2 to 4 slots I think. It's nothing more than smoke and mirrors really, and there is still an element of software getting in there - it just switches you to the appropriate channel in the background.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by brassic on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:25AM (#12413646)
There's not much smoke even. The red button channels are normal channels at 600 and 601. If the red button is broken you can switch to them directly. And switching directly is usually quicker than navigating the red button nonsense.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by thisone on Friday September 02, 2016 @07:45AM (#12412327)
Looks like smart TVs may have Red Button+ which gets its data differently than dumb TVs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC_Red_Button
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by IANAD on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:29PM (#12410642)
I have one of the "newer generation" smart TVs driven by Roku's interface- completely. In other words, you turn the TV on with a Roku remote and when the TV comes on, you see the Roku interface which you must use to choose which HDMI or game port to use, etc.

I like the interface a lot, but I bought it knowing that at some point, it will not be as cool as it is now. It will probably get in the way, as I'll have to use the Roku remote to browse via the old Roku OS to the port with the box that is the new browseable streaming OS. Maybe the Roku one will get borked by a system update because my hardware is unsupported- I don't know; I hope that doesn't happen, and have had a good experience with my old Roku external box, but it is a possibility several years from now.

Years ago when I bought a TV, never did it cross my mind that "one day the user interface is going to be obsolete".

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by nibnib on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:21AM (#12412042)
>If you were OK with a TV for 18 years you would be OK with another TV for 18 years.

A TV manufactured today is very unlikely to last 18 years without some kind of hardware failure. There is a big difference in complexity/points of failure and cost-cutting between 1998 and 2016.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by xchaotic on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:14AM (#12413161)
This is wrong. Modern TV follow standard 'bathtub' curve for failures. If the TV hasn't had any faults when new, it's not very likely to develop any new ones as it hasn't got any moving parts and things that wear and tear. The exceptions are capacitors quality and pixel burn-in, but even after 18 years they might work, you just won't like the picture quality.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by nibnib on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:25AM (#12429100)
Anything manufactured with some process control should follow a bathtub curve for failures. It's the width of the tub that matters. I don't know if LCDs have been on the market long enough to have much data for end-of-life failures (probably not 18 years?) and that data probably wouldn't be publicly available.

It's hard to believe that TV manufactures are shooting for an 18 year mean lifetime. They might work after 18 years, but it is unlikely.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ghaff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:48PM (#12409692)
Maybe. I'll accept that TV manufacturers have convinced many consumers to pay attention to the arms race over features. But were consumers really clamoring for 3D, for example?

I haven't been on the market for a TV for a few years but I'm not convinced that a lot of people see more apps on a TV as a critical selling point.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by PhantomGremlin on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:40PM (#12409929)
But were consumers really clamoring for 3D, for example?

No they weren't. IMO it wasn't worth the extra money. After all, just how many times can someone re-watch Avatar? Most other 3D movies weren't actually shot in 3D, they were just faked in post production.

Here's a headline that shows just how dead 3D is:

With a bullet to the head from Samsung, 3D TV is now deader than ever

It may shamble forward zombie-style for a few more years, but without the world's No. 1 TV maker on board, 3D TV is doomed.

http://www.cnet.com/news/3d-tv-is-now-more-dead-than-ever/

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by tempestn on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:59AM (#12410943)
3D isn't really that much extra money though. If you've got a quality panel, you already have a high refresh rate. So all you need to add 3D, beyond a bit of software, is polarization or active glasses. It adds so little to the cost that it doesn't make much sense for manufacturers not to include it on high end TVs.

Saying that 3D is "doomed" because one manufacturer is not bringing out new 3D models this year is, IMO, ridiculous. Eventually of course it will get much better, with no glasses, head tracking setups that are already in development. So 3D as we know it now of course won't last forever. But it's not like it's going away. Look at the percentage of movies released in 3D today compared to 5 years ago.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pmontra on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:25AM (#12411480)
Do you have to stay in front of the tv or can you move around the room and do whatever you have to do? I almost never stay put in front of the tv, even when I watch movies. It's the advantage of being at home. I think 3D is really dying. Maybe VR headsets will revive it, but without TV screens. Or in a shorter time the head tracking technology you're writing about. But the problem is that having to stay in front of a screen in a fixed location of the house to watch something is becoming an alien concept, the same thing that happened to having to be there at exactly that hour to watch a show.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ZeroGravitas on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:18AM (#12411678)
"faked in post production" could cover a large amount of modern movie content, even when not in 3D.

To give one example, the Foley artist who makes footsteps and other sound effects not captured live.

Not necessarily a bad thing if it's done well

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ghaff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:49PM (#12409982)
I actually have a 3D TV that I got on a pre-Christmas sale. My story is that I didn't really pay a premium for the 3D aspects of the TV (which included glasses) and I'm sticking to that story :-) I think I've maybe watched a half dozen 3D movies on it.

I've watched a few films that did a good job with it. But they're few and far between.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:00PM (#12410027)
The reason why most people avoided them especially the "passive" ones is that the "filter" they used on the panels made the normal TV experience slightly worse if you are pedantic about image quality. The image tends to be bit more fuzzy and dimmer than on 2D displays but again it's a compromise some of the latest 3D TV's pretty much are indistinguishable from 2D only panels but overall the lack of content was what killed it rather than the performance of the TV itself.

Sure you still have some viewing angle issues which might make some living/TV room setups not optimal for 3D and most TV's only came initially with 1-2 pairs of glasses and if it was a active 3D setup (had an active switching component inside of them) they could be somewhat expensive but if the content was there it wouldn't matter.

If there were more 3D blurays and DVD's out there and especially if Netflix or any other streaming service would have supported 3D content (3D streaming is still not a solved issue somewhat) the outcome would've been different.

Overall once 3D content is going to be easily streamable (and it's being worked on) and "glassesless" 3D/Stereoscopic panels become slightly cheaper it might make a comeback. Avatar was a nice experience but overall even in the cinema many people avoid 3D atm simply because it's still not there, these issues would be solved eventually and when every content would go through stereoscopic processing it would look pretty nice :)

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ghaff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:10PM (#12410072)
Mine is a Panasonic Viera that I got a year or so before they stopped making Plasmas. It's a nice panel even if, in retrospect, I might have gotten something less reflective for the room it's in. (Still, I use it very little when it's light out.)

If there's a 3D Bluray of a movie I genuinely want to watch, I'll pick it up but there are very few. Funnily enough, I've never bought Avatar as I saw it in Imax 3D in the theatre and was pretty much "That was an impressive experience but I don't really need to watch an echo of a not-so-great movie again at home."

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by rzzzt on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:07AM (#12411186)
There always seems to be a scene in which a random shrapnel or some object flies directly towards the viewer's face. I thoroughly dislike those; you don't have to remind me that we are watching a 3D movie.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by douche on Friday September 02, 2016 @07:26AM (#12412259)
There are always the gimmicky scenes that are so clearly added in for the IMax and 3D "experience." My conclusion is that 3D must only be effective for chaotic and nonsensical chase sequences.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by rodgerd on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:43PM (#12410687)
> Most other 3D movies weren't actually shot in 3D, they were just faked in post production.

In general, animated movies work very well, having watched the 3D versions of Frozen, Inside Out, and sundry others.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by JimmyAustin on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:20PM (#12410594)
I've always been very meh towards 3D, but found that it works quite well in a VR cinema. The 3D effect is more pronounced, more natural, and there are none of the downsides (blurrier/dimmer). On the other hand, the 2 hours with a DK2 on watching the Jurassic Park remaster wasn't very comfortable ergonomically. A great deal of potential if they reduce the weight however.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by mnutt on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:48PM (#12409690)
If that was the case, they could sell a TV with 5 HDMI ports with a Chromecast pre-plugged into one of them.

But I suspect after a year or two people would buy a new $35 Chromecast, rather than replacing their entire TV.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:55PM (#12409736)
They can still do it, most people don't use Chromecast most people want the YouTube, NetFlix, W/E logo on the box.

And they sell a TV with 5 HDMI ports because their competitors sell 4, this what happens when you have a features arms race, there are only what 2-3 panel makes so most TV's are pretty identical (like Cars that you only have a few chassis/wheelbase for each price range) so to have the advantage they load the TV's with other features like more ports, better WIFI, more this more that (just like cars which sell you BS things you don't need).

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by int_19h on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:17PM (#12409832)
Chromecast doesn't have to be a literal Chromecast. It just has to be some kind of dongle that uses a standard interface (e.g. HDMI, and maybe USB for remote command handling), and can be upgraded on its own.

Of course, the TV manufacturers don't want to do that, because they profit when you have to upgrade the entire TV.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:24PM (#12409863)
They don't want to do it because the consumer would not accept it as a solution because the minute that their competitor ditches that dongle and puts those features internally they have the "advantage".

Sunny sells you dongles that take a port, buy symsyng and have all your ports for other devices.

If you are an advanced enough user that you can use a streamer/dongle/set top box or w/e it doesn't matter what the TV has as long as it comes with display input ports.

For the majority of the shopping channel BIG BOX mart consumers this isn't really an option and they want one box that does everything even if it's not the most optimal solution.

What you are asking for is simply something that the TV maker has no reason or interest to do not because they are greedy but because they don't want to deal with that. They aren't stopping you from buying whatever dongle you want so what exactly is the complaint? The majority of the cost of the TV is still the tuner, panel, and LED and optical assembly the 11$ SoC they use for the smart features won't make the TV's cheaper. If somehow removing those features would allow them to focus on more important things I would understand but in reality it doesn't add up to much if anything.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ghaff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:30PM (#12409888)
>the 11$ SoC they use for the smart features won't make the TV's cheaper

And that's the good news in all this.

I can buy and use the TVs of my choice and the reality is that I don't really need to pay a material premium because they have YouTube which may or may not continue to work after some day in the future. So I can choose to ignore those features if I want. It's not really a choice between buying SmartTV for $X and DumbTV (which is otherwise equivalent) for $X/2.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:27PM (#12410405)
My concern about the "smart" TVs isn't things I can ignore, it's things I can't.

For example, I don't want a TV with its own network connection, a built-in camera and microphone, and hideously insecure firmware right in my living room.

Literally the only controls I ever use on my TV are power/standby, volume, and input selector. Everything else already comes from external sources like a set top box or PVR or Chromecast, and it's not like only A/V nerds have that arrangement.

I just want good video, good audio, and decent manufacturing quality and longevity. How on earth did we lose the plot as badly as we seem to have with the "smart" marketing?

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:53PM (#12410493)
Then you want to buy a display not a TV they are sold as their own product there is a link somewhere below.

And even still if you buy a smart TV you do not have to plug it into the network, a streamer will work regardless of what the TV can do.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:01PM (#12410527)
Unfortunately, being able to see and hear the actual model you're thinking of buying is rather important if you care about audio and visual quality, and certainly in my city, even the relatively high-end stores have been full of "smart" models lately.

Also, the next logical step for "smart" devices is to establish their own wireless connections via alternative channels if they aren't connected to a household network. Privacy is fast becoming a thing of the past if you let anything with sensors onto the premises, and short of wrapping their home or office in a Faraday cage, there is disturbingly little anyone can do about it as more manufacturers reach agreements with network providers to handle their phone-home data needs.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pmontra on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:31AM (#12411504)
So do what I did: don't connect the TV to your network. I bought the cheapest smart TV with a screen that I liked. That was some 50 Euros more that the most expensive dumb TV of the same size. It works well and I watch YouTube on my tablet, which has more pixels and at a arm length is as big as my TV.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by int_19h on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:43AM (#12411323)
What advantage? Guy A gets TV with dongle pre-connected, turns it on, things Just Work. Guy B gets TV with the same functionality embedded directly, turns it on, things Just Work. What's the difference?

If you want to make it really foolproof, make a mounting bracket for the dongle on the TV itself, such that it would require mucking around with screws to remove.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Someone on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:00AM (#12411397)
The company integrating it doesn't have to pay for the connector, for soldering it into the system, or for routing the signals form wherever they are on the main board to the connector. He just solders the chip that would be inside the dongle on the motherboard, in a location that is convenient for him.

A few generations in, he doesn't even have to do that soldering; the functionality will be integrated with something else on a single chip.

That makes the integrated TV set cheaper to produce. Guy A pays more.

Margins are paper-thin for televisions, so that takes most of the market. Eventually, guy A can't even buy that set.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by faragon on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:25AM (#12412060)
They already do: DLNA. Which is pretty much like what Chromecast, and its clones, do.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by IntelMiner on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:19AM (#12413194)
Going from (what would now be considered "old school") an original Xbox running XBMC to a friends Playstation 3 with DLNA felt like a monumental step back

With the Xbox, I simply mapped a Samba share (something like \\NAS\XBMC\) full of content and it brought it up without issue and simply played it

DLNA meanwhile every time something changed, I'd have to restart the whole thing to regenerate the "index". It also played maybe half the file formats XBMC did, despite being newer and an order of magnitude more powerful

Things have finally more or less come full circle again, these days I can run "Plex" on my NAS to just spew out media to everything, as long as it runs the Plex app anyway (which covers my Xbox One and Phone, at least). The only downside is having to pay for it, of course

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by rietta on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:34PM (#12409908)
Because there is absolutely nothing that confuses many people more than having more than one remote! My mother still cannot figure out how to change the volume on my dad's home theater setup.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by scurvy on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:30PM (#12410646)
HDMI CEC fixes that. It works remarkably well.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by toast0 on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:37AM (#12412928)
What devices do you have where HDMI cec works remarkably well? (and what year did they come from)

My experience was that cross brand interop is not quite there, but the experience is so inconsistent it doesn't matter. If configured to do it, turning on the blu ray player would consistent turn on the tv, but only sometimes set the right input. That kind of thing.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by scurvy on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:34PM (#12416757)
All 2016 and all Sony. You gotta stay in the same family. It's like the Apple ecosystem.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by s_kilk on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:08AM (#12412436)
>> consumers wanted more features.

Do they though?

I mean, everyone I've asked just wants their Microwave to have two dials, Power and Time, yet no such thing exists on the market. Instead it's a sea of bullshit Microwaves with bullshit "value add" features.

I'd wager the same is true of TVs, and myriad other consumer products. The end-users just want simple tech that works for years on end, while Product Managers and Designers want to boost their own status by sheparding these mindless "improvements" into production.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by outworlder on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:40PM (#12415217)
Not entirely true. At work we have a microwave oven with a single dial for time (haven't bothered to even check if it has power settings). It also doesn't rotate.

It's branded as a "commercial microwave oven" or something.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ebiester on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:05AM (#12413094)
People would flip their shit if their microwaves didn't rotate anymore, for example. But what "Value Add" features are you talking about that are non-trivial to implement?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by marcosdumay on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:59PM (#12414434)
It's not a microwave, but... I've lost my fridge manual and have no idea how to set its clock anymore - so it's just there, blinking, for eternity.

Yes, I brought this fridge model because of "features". I even did a feature comparison while searching for a model. The caveat is that all the features I looked for were related to chilling things, or easy maintenance.

I would pay extra for getting rid of the clock - and more yet for just some different software that displayed temperature instead of time.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by cududa on Saturday September 03, 2016 @02:53AM (#12418090)
Have you considered using the internet to find a copy of the manual?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by hsivonen on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:45AM (#12412622)
Does customer demand drive "overscan on HDMI" by default, too? Who are those people?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by 4ad on Saturday September 03, 2016 @08:33AM (#12418955)
This is pretty much the best argument I've heard on this issue. I always hear "people want this", but there are "features", like "overscan on HDMI" that nobody wants, and yet these features exist. It's the manufacturers who are pushing shit down the throats of people.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by TrevorJ on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:52PM (#12410258)
I think it is more a matter of manufacturers wanting to sell TV's sooner than a 5-10 year life cycle. To do that, you have to come up with new features to try to entice.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by LeifCarrotson on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:35PM (#12409911)
But if the average consumer compares the Sony and LG 'smart' TVs with YouTube and Netflix and 47 other apps to a by extension 'dumb' Samsung display, they won't pick the Samsung, even if it has better panel quality that can't be readily quantified or seen on the hypersaturated demo.

Well, you and I might buy the Samsung, but most consumers aren't as informed or as savvy with a Chromecast.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:42PM (#12409939)
If I'm buying a TV for my mom neither would I. If you want a "dumb" display then buy a display it's a product category of it's own and virtually every company that makes TV/Panels sells them e.g. http://www.necdisplay.com/category/large-screen-displays these are the ones that they sell for display purposes for advertisement, boardrooms etc. but they are not "TV's", some of them have slightly better panels than some TV's some of them don't.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by khedoros on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:05AM (#12411418)
They're also much more expensive, have fewer input options than my current (dumb) tv, and have some remote configuration options that would more conveniently be put into menus, in a consumer device. So...what's the point, besides pigheadedness over not buying a "smart" TV? It's not like there's a way to even go see what I'm buying before I do it.

I'm not a big fan of smart devices, but I'm not going to pay more for a display with "meh" connectivity that doesn't really seem to be optimized as a home entertainment device. Although annoying, it makes more sense to buy the smart TV and ignore the extra features.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by tudorw on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:56AM (#12410927)
again, if manufacturers engage in the most basic 'mine is bigger than yours' playground games then it's not surprising that the users, who love shiny things, are not making a decision based on fact, if instead of releasing a new shape box every year, they really focused on a consistent product line then they could delivery incremental improvements and show users over time why their product is the better 'viewing experience' which is what it's all about really!
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by 1_2__3 on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:03AM (#12410959)
What possible evidence do you have of this? It sounds wholly speculative.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by danudey on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:28PM (#12416032)
My wishlist for a 'TV':

1. High quality LCD panel 2. 'good enough' speakers (optional) 3. 4+ HDMI ports 4. no TV tuner, composite, component, etc. 5. Proper working HDMI CEC support 6. Make it as 'always on' as my Macbook or Apple Cinema Display – hit a button or activate a display and the screen comes on instantly.

For the premium model, add:

1. Ambient light detection to adjust brightness 2. Embedded RPi-like (or actually RPi) on a fifth 'overlay' input (i.e. the HUD/guide/etc). Make it open source, let people hack it and do fun stuff with it, build widgets, whatever.

Don't sell me on 'Your TV can do Netflix now!' Every device in my house with an LCD can play Netflix. My iPad from 2010 can play Netflix, and it can do it better than most smart TVs can. The only thing I own that uses 2.4 GHz that doesn't play Netflix is my microwave, and if it did I might actually use it.

If I buy a $70 AppleTV and it becomes obsolete, outdated, or can't support what I want, I can buy another $70 AppleTV. If I buy an $1800 SmartTV and the 'Smart' features become obsolete, outdated, or can't do what I want, then 50% of my value is gone.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by riffic on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:26PM (#12409867)
The "concept" is planned obsolescence:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dlhavema on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:15PM (#12410360)
I totally agree, they have no plans to maintain 5 year old TV apps...

I love my 4 year old Sony tv. Sure, none of the pre-built apps work anymore... but our Blu-ray player does all of it and better.. the screen works great so I'll keep it till that part dies.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by simplexion on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:43PM (#12409668)
I agree with this. There was a time where smart TVs were useful but it is dying out. The other big issue with Smart TVs is they try to put the lowest powered SoC in that they can and tiny amounts of RAM.

They should all just be monitors now. The cost of a Chromecast, Raspberry Pi, or Apple TV is so low that it makes Smart TVs redundant. I actually don't understand why these manufacturers haven't moved to making their own versions of casting/streaming devices. I remember when I bought my Bravia a long time ago it didn't come with WiFi but you could buy their wireless USB device for AUD$80 (they blocked all others). Why don't they do that but instead a Chromecast like device (without blocking out 3rd parties)?

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by rconti on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:25PM (#12409864)
I don't disagree, but I've gone the opposite way. Just last week I replaced a 46" Samsung 1080p set from 9 years ago with a brand-new top-of-the-line Sony 4k set that has all this fancy AndroidTV stuff I neither knew I wanted nor really understood.

Thing is, it's the ONLY way I can get 4k content. I have an HTPC, WDTV, AppleTV, FireStick, PS3, and TiVo all plugged into my receiver (which was a very high end unit just 1 year ago). However, while the receiver supports 4k, it does NOT support HDCP 2.2 which either is required for 4k content, or WILL be once they start using HDCP 2.2. (I'm not quite clear on this point.. I don't know if today's UHD BluRay discs use HDCP 2.2).

And I'd argue that the SmartTV stuff is not really a reason many people buy a TV; regardless, having it does not remove your ability to use external devices in the future. If Sony drops my AndroidTV apps in 4 years, it probably won't much matter because the devices of the future will do far more for $35 than the software on the TV.

It's a frustrating situation, but, IMO, the Smart TV stuff only adds value (unless you're talking about the microphone in my remote and the possibility of said devices being used to backdoor my network, of course).

I forgot to add, new things pop up all the time that you don't know you want until they arrive. I noticed Google Photos being advertised on TV. I gave it a go on my iPhone and notice a Google Cast button. I don't have any of Google's streaming devices yet, nor do I have an HDMI port free on my receiver to support another device. Well, I hit the button, and what do you know, it automagically knew all about my TV and displayed my pictures at the touch of a button. Sometimes having fancy new stuff is cool, and you get added features you never expected. I sure wouldn't buy a Google streaming device just for this one novelty, but I'm not going to complain about having it.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pm90 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:34PM (#12410180)
About the latter part, I've noticed the same thing on my Sony Bravia TV as well. I believe the TV's may have a sort of "inbuilt chromecast": so I can cast youtube and netflix on my TV, and it will play the content via the TV-native app. I found this a LOT more convenient than having to deal with chromecast per-se; since I can't really control the TV much with the remote control once chromecast is in play.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by hawski on Friday September 02, 2016 @05:27AM (#12411880)
I think that Chromecast supports HDMI CEC so it should work with compatible TV's remotes.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by asteadman on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:09PM (#12413992)
Yes and no. Support varies by the "app". Currently Netflix/PlayMusic works great with pause/stop, but no support for other buttons (next track, fast forward, rewind, etc...). I mostly just want pause though, so it works for me.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by minipci1321 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:06PM (#12409786)
> I actually don't understand why these manufacturers haven't moved to making their own versions of casting/streaming devices.

Well, because streaming as a service to a customer is largely about the contents and about customer support. This is area that Internet providers are controlling exclusively (over here anyway). Every triple play offer has a TV part which comes with a set-top box, and a random streaming device simply cannot compete with "state-supported" traffic (CDNs in close proximity, multicast channels).

Why do the ISPs provide their own set-top box device? 1) They are trying to reduce the volume of calls to hotline, and this area of tech can generate many; 2) They use the customer-premises device as a shop front in selling even more VOD contents. A streaming stick would require lots of customization per every ISP in order to address these points.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:52PM (#12409714)
>They should all just be monitors now. The cost of a Chromecast, Raspberry Pi, or Apple TV is so low that it makes Smart TVs redundant. I actually don't understand why these manufacturers haven't moved to making their own versions of casting/streaming devices.

The vast majority of TV viewers do not use and do not even understand how to use these devices.

Chromecast/Firestick is at least somewhat usable to the masses, some of the other streamers are more complicated but do you really expect some random person to buy and build a RasPi streaming set top box?

The TV makers can't take out features because people would not buy that TV, people want features, and these features are what the guy at the store can sell TV's by.

And for Samsung/Sony and the likes to get into the streamer business it's pointless, and it would not change the issue it would just move it to another component albit considerably cheaper one. Streaming devices also need to be constantly updated, many of them need to be updated more often than the TV their SoC's get obsolete just as fast if not faster and YouTube can make changes tomorrow that would make the current version of Chromecast incompatible as well.

If you are an Advanced user you don't care for all that crap, my best TV still by far is now what a 7-8 year old Toshiba 42" with a 10 bit panel which was actually made in Germany, dumb as you can get (it can show images, play MP3, maybe some MPEG) it has a PCMCIA slot which I used to hack into it and the image quality is still better than virtually every TV out there that doesn't cost 1500 GBP. But I can use it because I'm an "advanced" user I run my own streaming and transcoding server and have a media center PC. But for some one who wants a no hassle turn on TV and get netflix this isn't really an option, even Chromecast isn't very ideal quality isn't that great and it can lag pretty badly on congested networks. The more expensive streamers give you quality that matches the TV native app but they also tend to cost considerably more than the cheap sticks, unless you buy the Android unbranded chinese SoC sticks.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by DougWebb on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:15PM (#12409822)
The point is that tv manufacturers can still sell all of those features in-the-box, but provide it as a dumb screen + a separate device that's replacable when it becomes obsolete before the screen does.

I think a key competitive feature would be to have their own device integrated better than third-party devices. A usb connection to share commands from the tv's remote, for example. Maybe integrated menus of some sort.

If the add-on device is fairly cheap, and major upgrades require replacement rather than just software, the tv manufacturers could get more upgrade sales than they can get for whole tv upgrades.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:31PM (#12409893)
But this isn't mutually exclusive, you are complicating a design for no reason, 99% of the people would never upgrade either, and if it's too complicated they wouldn't want to use it.

You can buy any add-on yourself they work with every TV you don't have to worry about brand compatibility or lockouts why ask the TV makers to make the market worse? The minute that Sony or whoever starts selling dongles is the minute they block all other dongles from working on their TV's and everyone would do the same.

As for the TV remote thing this already works, HDMI-CEC is a protocol that allows you to send commands from the TV to the device via HDMI and virtually every TV I had for the past what almost 10 years with HDMI had the support for it. I have several streamers at home that all work with it without any issues.

Every TV is a dumb panel, removing the "smart" features from it won't make it any cheaper those SoC's are cheap as dirt, you gain nothing by removing it and you lose the simple crowd that doesn't want to add other devices and worry about setting them up or figuring how they work, they want to turn on the TV and click on netflix and that's it.

When it comes to the point where it doesn't work anymore they have the choice to buy a dongle or buy a new TV they do not have to do it and there is no commercial trickery or anything that forces them to buy a new TV over a Chromecast or a Roku or Firestick or w/e.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by rjsw on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:07PM (#12409789)
I remember a certain TV manufacturer [1] making a system with a separate tuner and monitor, they were able to sell it as a high end product.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20060627134424/http://www.sony.n...

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:34PM (#12409906)
Selling a high end "gimmick" by forcing people to pay for features that are needed for the TV to work like speakers because you can sell a few rich yuppies the idea of a minimalist design is a nice anecdote but nothing more :)
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by niftich on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:53PM (#12409722)
Because they'd rather take your $500-$1000+ for a new TV every couple years than your $100 for a new streaming stick
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by DougWebb on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:19PM (#12409846)
How many people can afford to spend that much every couple of years on a new tv? I'd bet most tvs in most us homes are 5-15 years old. My tv, which happens to be a bravia, is 13 years old and still works perfectly.

EDIT: for what it's worth, my tv is predates smart tvs by a year or two. I use an old Tivo with a lifetime service plan and a roku (3rd gen I think, upgraded once) for the smarts.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by caf on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:25AM (#12411246)
They may make more profit from the latter if the margin is higher and upgrades more frequent.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by xchaotic on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:41AM (#12413325)
This. No matter how you spin it, shipping and handling large TVs is costly. Even a small % of failed units is going to cost you plenty for shipping returns alone. And the margins on TVs are as slim as modern TVs, I think the likes of Sony could get the same amount of margin on a small 'smart' box packing something like a PS3 equivalent in a tiny box mounted behind the TV.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by marcosdumay on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:53PM (#12414397)
There shouldn't be any lifetime mismatch by now. A first release Raspberry PI is powerful enough to fill a full HD TV nowadays, and while it takes a more powerful computer for a 4K TV, this is not something that changes with time while you are not looking.

The only "lifetime mismatch" that still exist on smart TVs is manufacturer DRM that is fulfilling its design goal of not letting you use your device.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by cptskippy on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:24AM (#12413223)
TV Manufacturers actually subsidize the cost of the TV by adding user tracking features into their smart TVs. The on by default "features" gather valuable marketing data that companies can then sell to the highest bidder. That's why all TVs these days are smart, even the super cheap ones.

The best thing you can do with a Smart TV is never connect it to the internet.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by voycey on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:57PM (#12409743)
Totally agree, Dumb TV's and something like an NUC are the way forward!
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Pengwin on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:46PM (#12409965)
I Have a NUC at home, but its power as a computer seems to be wasted on being the smart part of a TV to me. So I use a nexus player for its interface and the NUC runs its DLNA and lives its life as a full-fledged desktop PC.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by samsolomon on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:56AM (#12412664)
This is how all of Vizio's new TVs work.

There's no interface for the television. It just has Chromecast built in.

Downside (of the M-Series at least) is they don't come with a tuner installed. If you want a cable or an antenna you'll have to dish out $100 more for a tuner.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by a_imho on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:35AM (#12412090)
It is really hard to get a top end dumb TV the same way it is hard to get a top end dumb phone.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by kelvin0 on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:55AM (#12412656)
Actually that seems like a great business plan/startup idea! I would be first in line ...
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by antimatter on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:20AM (#12413205)
Exactly this. I would absolutely love one of the new high end LG OLED panels with none of the smart tv features and no network connectivity (privacy & security). I'm really curious how big of a market this would be.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by roel_v on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:00PM (#12414888)
No you wouldn't. There are many niche 'simple high end phone' products, the majority of which fail, despite forums full of people claiming 'take my money', 'I'd be first in line' etc.

The reality is that these products are as expensive or more as regular products (because small batches), and everybody wants a different 20 pct of the full functionality.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by SloopJon on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:37PM (#12410665)
My recollection is that TV manufacturers didn't even want to include digital tuners until the FCC required them to. Of course, that tuner isn't doing me any good now that the FCC allows Comcast to encrypt broadcast channels.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by xigency on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:42PM (#12410684)
Unless of course you want to watch local television, in which case you would need a digital tuner. That is why the FCC requires the tuner. There were subsidized coupons for tuner boxes when the switch was made, so that everyone and their grandparents could continue watching television.

Unfortunately, YouTube doesn't have the same kind of support.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by yuhong on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:50PM (#12410711)
And are TVs and monitors really different these days other than inclusion of the tuner?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by 4ad on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:18AM (#12412026)
Most monitors can't/won't do 23.976Hz, nor 24Hz refresh rate. They require resampling. Some will do it, but are expensive. Large good monitors are very expensive, much more expensive than TVs.

When Rec. 2020 becomes a thing, TVs and monitors will have a vastly different gamut and will use different color primaries.

My personal opinion is that if you need a TV, or a display to watch movies on, buy an 1080p plasma (not LCD) that nobody wants anymore. There are models (search the Internet) which have almost reference-grade color reproduction, something you will not find in any LCD that is cheaper than your car, and contrast is much better than LCD too.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by stuaxo on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:48AM (#12411573)
You get internal speakers and much more io: scart, aerial in etc, all good for connecting just about anything
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by niftich on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:51PM (#12410718)
Next up on terrible ideas: CableCARD slots on TVs!
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by signal11 on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:29PM (#12414201)
I had the same problem with my 2011 Samsung Smart TV. It had an app for Amazon's Prime Video. Amazon eventually abandoned it and sent me part-credit for a Fire TV stick.

I also have a Chromecast and am generally positive about it, however it's very laggy to controller (i.e. app) input. For example, here's a feature I see as pretty basic for a "smart" display: select a bunch of photos from my phone, beam them to my TV, and flick through them using the phone. All the Chromecast-enabled slideshow apps I've tried for this have been laggy and disappointing, unfortunately.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by orionblastar on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:19AM (#12413195)
The companies only add the software as a way to make more money. If a smart tv costs more and offers free Youtube videos, then people see it as a added value. But technology changes so fast that sometimes the smart tv sets can't keep up.

My wife got a smart tv from her employer out of a catalog for being a loyal employee for a long time. It has Roku built in. One day that will be obsolete.

My son is thinking of an Amazon Fire TV stick to use and cancel our Cable TV subscriptions. It is only supposed to be $40 and plugs into an HDMI port. So if you need to buy a new one, it should be only $40 later on.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by SeeDave on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:21PM (#12417099)
Totally agree. I currently have a SmartTv, a Blu-Ray player with very similar apps, and an X-Box with similar apps. They all have so much in common: streaming media from a network attached PC, youtube videos, amazon prime video, Netflix, etc. It seems like a complete and total waste of developer time to reinvent the wheel for what is essentially the same thing on different devices.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pbhowmic on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:54AM (#12413421)
Exactly right. The TV itself is a durable product my TV is 8 years old. This is what I like about the modular approach of "pluggable" smarts. Upgrade the smarts by upgrading the cheaper smart module in this case Chromecast or Fire or Apple TV.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ksk on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:40AM (#12413757)
> Using something like a ChromeCast to get content to the TV makes so much more sense than embedding "intelligence" in a display.

Can you explain why it makes more sense?

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pcurve on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:39PM (#12409927)
I agree.

To me, best smart tv is tv with best, long lasting picture quality.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by torrent-of-ions on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:17AM (#12412475)
Oh how I'd love a TV with a physical switch which connects the HDMI input to the display and bypasses the onboard crap.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by tsmarsh on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:29AM (#12412544)
Why doesn't a monitor fill your needs?
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by xchaotic on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:36AM (#12413289)
Show me those cheap 55" 4k monitors that you speak of. I know Vizio TV that are cheap, but to my knowledge no 'monitors' exist in that size or price range.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by 4ad on Saturday September 03, 2016 @08:38AM (#12418969)
You are right, good monitors are more expensive than TVs. Especially monitors that can do 23.976Hz and 24Hz refresh without resampling.

But why do you need a 4k monitor, to use as a TV, since all current material is 1080p? Better buy 4k when there is a need for 4k, then the price will be lower.