News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:24PM (#12409863)
They don't want to do it because the consumer would not accept it as a solution because the minute that their competitor ditches that dongle and puts those features internally they have the "advantage".

Sunny sells you dongles that take a port, buy symsyng and have all your ports for other devices.

If you are an advanced enough user that you can use a streamer/dongle/set top box or w/e it doesn't matter what the TV has as long as it comes with display input ports.

For the majority of the shopping channel BIG BOX mart consumers this isn't really an option and they want one box that does everything even if it's not the most optimal solution.

What you are asking for is simply something that the TV maker has no reason or interest to do not because they are greedy but because they don't want to deal with that. They aren't stopping you from buying whatever dongle you want so what exactly is the complaint? The majority of the cost of the TV is still the tuner, panel, and LED and optical assembly the 11$ SoC they use for the smart features won't make the TV's cheaper. If somehow removing those features would allow them to focus on more important things I would understand but in reality it doesn't add up to much if anything.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by ghaff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:30PM (#12409888)
>the 11$ SoC they use for the smart features won't make the TV's cheaper

And that's the good news in all this.

I can buy and use the TVs of my choice and the reality is that I don't really need to pay a material premium because they have YouTube which may or may not continue to work after some day in the future. So I can choose to ignore those features if I want. It's not really a choice between buying SmartTV for $X and DumbTV (which is otherwise equivalent) for $X/2.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:27PM (#12410405)
My concern about the "smart" TVs isn't things I can ignore, it's things I can't.

For example, I don't want a TV with its own network connection, a built-in camera and microphone, and hideously insecure firmware right in my living room.

Literally the only controls I ever use on my TV are power/standby, volume, and input selector. Everything else already comes from external sources like a set top box or PVR or Chromecast, and it's not like only A/V nerds have that arrangement.

I just want good video, good audio, and decent manufacturing quality and longevity. How on earth did we lose the plot as badly as we seem to have with the "smart" marketing?

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by dogma1138 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:53PM (#12410493)
Then you want to buy a display not a TV they are sold as their own product there is a link somewhere below.

And even still if you buy a smart TV you do not have to plug it into the network, a streamer will work regardless of what the TV can do.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Silhouette on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:01PM (#12410527)
Unfortunately, being able to see and hear the actual model you're thinking of buying is rather important if you care about audio and visual quality, and certainly in my city, even the relatively high-end stores have been full of "smart" models lately.

Also, the next logical step for "smart" devices is to establish their own wireless connections via alternative channels if they aren't connected to a household network. Privacy is fast becoming a thing of the past if you let anything with sensors onto the premises, and short of wrapping their home or office in a Faraday cage, there is disturbingly little anyone can do about it as more manufacturers reach agreements with network providers to handle their phone-home data needs.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by pmontra on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:31AM (#12411504)
So do what I did: don't connect the TV to your network. I bought the cheapest smart TV with a screen that I liked. That was some 50 Euros more that the most expensive dumb TV of the same size. It works well and I watch YouTube on my tablet, which has more pixels and at a arm length is as big as my TV.
Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by int_19h on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:43AM (#12411323)
What advantage? Guy A gets TV with dongle pre-connected, turns it on, things Just Work. Guy B gets TV with the same functionality embedded directly, turns it on, things Just Work. What's the difference?

If you want to make it really foolproof, make a mounting bracket for the dongle on the TV itself, such that it would require mucking around with screws to remove.

Re:Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs by Someone on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:00AM (#12411397)
The company integrating it doesn't have to pay for the connector, for soldering it into the system, or for routing the signals form wherever they are on the main board to the connector. He just solders the chip that would be inside the dongle on the motherboard, in a location that is convenient for him.

A few generations in, he doesn't even have to do that soldering; the functionality will be integrated with something else on a single chip.

That makes the integrated TV set cheaper to produce. Guy A pays more.

Margins are paper-thin for televisions, so that takes most of the market. Eventually, guy A can't even buy that set.