I had the immense pleasure of meeting him once. My favorite quote from the interaction: "With a shell you have all the expressibility of a language. With pointy-clicky you're reduced to pointing at things and grunting."
I 100% agree about the quality of this paper and the quote above. It took me years of trial-and-error in black schools to learn to spot or speak correct versions of their language. I won't even say I mastered it or anything: just passable. I watched plenty of times when people transfered in, talked like they're hood, slipped on some little rule, and had a whole room stare at them. They almost always got called out then usually admitted they were faking it to be cool or blend or whatever. Even the whites like me learned to spot what was authentic or fake due to those intricate details you mention.
Fun to finally read a detailed analysis of it. One thing that might be worth more research and writeups is one of reasons even I resisted it to a degree: changing words with a common meaning to mean the total opposite. It was really hard to keep up with without watching shows or listening to music they did... my guess at where many trends started. Confirmed it for some. I nearly got into a fight over a guy I was told acted "so cold" to a specific woman I was friends with not knowing they redefined it to mean something like "awesome." Usually just awkward situations rather than violent but it did and still seems like a foolish practice. Interestingly, they later made same recommendation in a different form about rebel flag: had intrinsic, established, and negative meaning that can't be erased by merely using it in different meaning/context.
Rest was just how they talk far as I figured. The country whites had their own form of English, too. There was the "true Southern" accent some upper-class people had. People in from the cities in the North had theirs. Some whites and blacks stayed speaking Standard English. My words and style are a combo of all these as is probably obvious. Once exposed to enough styles, I never let myself get to hating AAVE as it was clear many people just spoke differently. More like just straining to keep up with its changing definitions so I could seize a good opportunity or avoid an assault.
Note: Strange enough, this is also the first time I've ever heard "AAVE." I don't follow linguistics or the debates in the papers since I figured it would just be closet racism. I just listened to what people around me said since they followed all that. The blacks themselves, including English teachers, explained the AAVE concept in school by saying (1) it wasn't broken English, (2) it was their own language/culture, and (3) it's called Ebonics. Reading Pullum's education on that word was ironic and funny given blacks, not whites, spent years hammering it into my head. Whites just said "talks/talked black" with a few using "ebonics" for mockery. Now, I'm going to try to forget it in favor of AAVE which is indeed a better term. Just can't believe I haven't seen it or heard it so little from blacks that it went away with my memory. Strange.
"That book was well wicked mate!" "That book was extremely good friend"
In other words, in the UK the word "wicked" always stands on its own, could be replaced by "good", "excellent", "amazing" or indeed, "sick" (in the modern sense of the word.)
I think "wicked" is not a bit cliched now though. It sounds quite quaint to me. I wouldn't use it anymore except to be ironic.
But on the other hand, I only hear US usage more like "wicked cool" - which sounds very artificial and "Dadspeak"(1) to me. Can the US usage be stand alone, or is it only used as an adjective?
(1) Dadspeak - when a Dad tries to sound cool and fails horribly by incorrectly using slang terms they don't really understand.
This is a word that's changing pretty rapidly because nobody's pushing back against it. No one shouts "you're stupid and wrong" at people who use the word "flammable" instead of "inflammable". Every sensible person can recognize that "flammable" is the clearer version of the word, and being clear is important in this case, so who cares what the word used to be.
So as opposed to cases where people get angry about language changing, this is a case to get angry that language hasn't completely changed yet.
Flammable is a word, invented several times over history (most recently in the 1940s), to mean that same thing as "inflammable" (able to become inflamed) because it's important to get correct and the in- prefix confuses people into thinking it means the opposite.
French and Italian apparently have words beginning ininflam- which mean "not-inflammable". Americans prefer an the less ambiguous concoction: "non-flammable".
I can see only advantages in using the same word again.
While there is a definite meme around exasperation at this (and apparently some dictionaries are on board), I think they have it wrong.
In every example I've seen, including those proffered by those promulgating the meme, the difference intended by addition of "literally" is emphasis. Omission would not have lead to the listener/reader being more likely to conclude that the utterance was literal. It's simply hyperbole. "It was figuratively X so much that it was almost literally X, but obviously you understand that it was still only figurative."
This doesn't mean it's completely harmless - overuse of the word in that role does make it marginally harder to convey that something was actually, literally the case when it's expected that it would be figuratively the case. But it's not a reversal of sense.
When someone says, "I've walked miles around the store looking for you", we don't conclude that there is a new use of the word "miles" to mean "hundreds of feet". We say they were exaggerating for emphasis.
In that case, I know Japanese. Just not the same one that anyone else knows...
Maybe, but the fact that you have to learn it, or that it has "rigorous rules" does't mean it's not a simpler variety of English. It's both a variety of English, and simpler.
To non-AAVE speakers AAVE has the appearance of simplicity because its productions "look like" simplified English. This is actually what Pullum debunks in the article: the rules to produce "simplifications" like dropped consonants and auxiliaries are actually complex (i.e. it's not at all arbitrary as you would expect if it had less rules).
But even if we put all that aside and assume you (and the racists you're being lumped in together with based on that assertion) were right. How exactly is "simpler" worse? Is Finnish superior because it has fifteen noun cases?
This is basically the line of thinking that resulted in generations of English students being tortured by self-styled (prescriptivist) "linguists" who were convinced that English is only "correct" when you try to pretend it is actually Latin (giving us nonsensical rules like "don't split infinitives" and "no dangling prepositions" -- although they are entirely based on limitations of Latin).
I'll probably get downvoted for posting that. But I don't see how this essay supports any notion that AAVE is simpler than standard English, and coldtea doesn't supply any alternative source to support the claim.
Is calling it "simpler" a rigorous statment of some measurable quantity? If so, which one?
Or is it a way to impose a value judgment on the dialect and the people who created it and speak it today?
There is certainly a giant pile of American cultural precedent for the latter.
If you need any more evidence of this dynamic, recall Harry Reid before the '08 Election. He characterized Obama as a ‘light-skinned’ African-American ‘with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one.’
It has a lot of linguistic traits of those dialects. Which would make sense if the Irish and Scottish slaves taught them their english.
I don't think that makes it "simple", that is a judgement I think is invalid and ignores the reality of the dialect.
Do you really need sources to tell you that a subgroup's language is poorer than a mainstream language with a many times its history, speakers, artifacts and literary works?
>Or is it a way to impose a value judgment on the dialect and the people who created it and speak it today?
No, it's a value judgement on the people who enslaved them and deprived them of opportunities for education and participation in the mainstream culture and language for centuries.
And who continue to oppress them through faux-progressive, but essentially condescending, praise for their make-shift language they were forced to come up with.
Perhaps you, like several other commenters on this thread, believe the point of the essay is that AAVE should be nurtured, or even spread to students not acquainted with it. Nobody is making that argument. The closest the essay comes to a moral judgement about AAVE is in pointing out that if AAVE-aware educational strategies produce better outcomes for learning Standard English, our ignorance and prejudice shouldn't prevent use from creating those outcomes.
But most of the essay is spent making fun of people who feel they understand AAVE well enough to dismiss it. It's a funny piece, by an universally respected authority. You should read it again with an open mind!
Again, the essay is about what AAVE actually is, not about whether AAVE is better or worse than Standard Written English.
What's interesting is how this thread demonstrates some of the same effects the essay comments on. As overwhelmingly non-AAVE speakers of Standard English, we seem to have powerful cognitive biases working to convince us that AAVE is, if not broken, then at least an intrinsically lesser form of our own language.
Most of us probably have no trouble dismissing the notion that Persian is intrinsically inferior to English. But because AAVE is so close to our own dialects, we're convinced we understand it well enough to judge it.
Obviously if a dialect or language is the primary or only means of interaction with a population group (as Persian is with Persians) it is not inferior - it is what it is. But if a borderline unintelligible dialect coexists with the understandable main language, its inferiority is not a moral judgement by evil racists, but a straightforward utilitarian rejection.
It also doesn't matter how high-prestige the group speaking a hard-to-understand dialect is. Swiss German is mocked and looked down upon by non-native-speakers, as is speaking the Swabian German dialect - though you likely won't find any population groups with higher social status (+wealth/prestige) in Germany.
In fact, it was the AAVE that's derived from English and not the other way around. Without English there would be no AAVE.
Plus it's also tied to a particular subgroup (and not even for all of its communicational needs).
Oh, and about all that racism stuff that easily flows, I don't have a horse in this race (no pun intended) as I'm not American, and we didn't really do slavery. If anything, when my people came to the US they were treated exactly like blacks were treated at the time by the racist white majority, KKK-visits included.
Most of which (British, American, Irish, Australian, etc) are trivial variations of the single originating British English language.
>I'm not aware of any single dialect that has anything close to a billion speakers.
English, the language, however, has. Dialects are just regional and group variations of it.
AAVE isn't particularly notable, other than the politics surrounding it.
That's not surprising, since I don't agree with the essay in the first place, including the very premise (common to modern linguistics) that all languages are created equal as long as they serve the communication needs of their groups.
I also disagree to dispensing with "moral judgements about language" (or the way modern social sciences rush to dispense with moral judgements about almost everything -- and I mean this in a Christopher Lasch way).
>Most of us probably have no trouble dismissing the notion that Persian is intrinsically inferior to English. But because AAVE is so close to our own dialects, we're convinced we understand it well enough to judge it.
Persian is an ancient language, of a historically great empire with an important literary canon, written rules and more than a couple of millennia of refinement by speakers, scholars, poets, etc. If anything, it could be superior to English.
An ad-hoc minority dialect of a couple of centuries vintage that slaves and ex-slaves had to adapt and develop to establish group identity and as a secret code against the racist white population, is not the same thing at all.
When you say Persian is likely superior to English, you're using the word in an abstract, philosophical sense, as if you're comparing two pieces of ancient art, not concerned with their practical uses. You say Persian could be "superior", but if anyone asks which language one should learn, you will have no problem suggesting English, as that's the practical choice with much more utility.
Similarly, if anyone suggests English speakers should change their linguistic habit to match the superior grammar of Persian, I'm sure you will (like me) just roll your eyes.
Yet when you compare Standard English and AAVE, I have a feeling that you will encourage people to speak Standard English because it is "superior", and you will likely tell AAVE speakers to adopt the rules of Standard English because it is more sophisticated.
Sounds to me like you're mixing two different meanings to win one argument and then the other.
That's correct.
AAVE, on the other hand is both (for me) poorer in the philosophical sense (which I tie to overall cultural significance), and to utility. It's a very special purpose group language, that even its speakers abandon in different contexts.
So I don't see the conflict you mention. If practicality wasn't an issue, I would suggest people study Persian (or Chinese, or several others beautiful and rich ancient languages), not English. But as it is, I would suggest English (besides, in terms of cultural significance for the modern world, it holds quite well, ever since the 20th century -- before I might have suggested French).
Similarly, for English vs AAVE, I would suggest English both for their overall cultural significance over AAVE and their practicality.
You haven't so much "disagreed" with the essay as you've opted to pursue an orthogonal concern to which it doesn't expend any attention at all: whether AAVE is "good" or "bad". Pullum, in this piece, doesn't care. All he's saying is that when considering AAVE, we should at least understand what it is.
Yeah, but what we're pushing under the carpet is that they were forced, by racism, to be raised with it as their first language.
>Pullum, in this piece, doesn't care. All he's saying is that when considering AAVE, we should at least understand what it is.
In the essay he basically collects its syntactic and lexicographical differences, to prove that it's "a whole other language".
That it may be, what's of interest to me is its standing as a language in general (and its historical roots and development), not whether it has coherent rules and thus it cannot be said to be just "mistaken english". That I can give him, but it's far from the real essence of the matter.
Separating from the society at large is how you create and enforce such dialects to particular subgroups.
And segregation didn't end in the 60s: "Despite recent trends, blacks remain the most segregated racial group. The dissimilarity-index indices in 1980, 1990 and 2000 are 72.7, 67.8, and 64.0, respectively.[8] Blacks are hypersegregated in most of the largest metropolitan areas across the U.S., including Atlanta, Baltimore, Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, Houston, Los Angeles, New Orleans, New York, Philadelphia and Washington, DC.[4] For Hispanics, the second most segregated racial group, the indices from 1980, 1990 and 2000 are 50.2, 50.0, and 50.9, respectively".
And: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_segregation_in_the_Uni... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
Besides that, as I'm sure you know, such discussion is often skewed by unspoken agendas around why people want to call one thing 'simpler' than another in the first place. I'm not imputing that to your comment here, just pointing out that it's frequently in play, probably the more so as a topic is more politicized.
* (as, offtopically, is rampant in the software business)
Yeah, because literary history and written culture is a trivial matter when speaking about languages.
What's important is if we can find syntactic rules, tenses, etc, in them to classify them as languages.
Because any language, whether Klingon or French, is the same thing, a language, and we don't need anything more when we have that tautology...
I also don't think you do your your argument, whatever it may be at this point, any favors by comparing AAVE and Navajo to Klingon.
Isn't the parent's question:
"yet your standard on a languages complexity favour of "how many books do those people write""
snark in the first place, as if that's unimportant, and as if literary history is merely a quantity issue? Sorry, but to my European eyes that's not even in question.
And how is the "surprising complexity of the tense system" relevant? Surprising to whom? Racists who thought an african american dialect couldn't be formal enough? Perhaps they haven't heard of creole languages either.
Racist expectations aside, what's "surprising" about its complexity? At best it is more or less comparable to that of English. That's not some "surprising complexity" that can help us access a language, except in the lowest level, of it's internal workings. Of course the main claim of the original article is indeed only that "it's a language too".
To which I say, this doesn't say much.
And that's part of what makes a language significant or not.
If by some strange accident humanity totally lost Latin, for example, a great deal of cultural knowledge would be lost. If humanity lost Navajo, not so much.(Of course as a language extremely important for the Navajo and their culture).
This thread, interesting as it may be, was germinated in that argument, not the new one you introduced 38 minutes ago.
Please do not follow me around in different threads and try to police my comments in different contexts, with earlier quotations taken out of context.
I am more than able to reply in a single thread to any objection you want to raise -- so that the narrative of the thread is kept intact and people can follow what each party said.
Also, you can criticise my points and disagree or totally consider them BS, but criticising my commenting, with whatever assumptions you made and didn't check with me (e.g. that I "moved the goalposts") I find rude.
My "simpler" and "less significant" refer to the same criticism. Pretending that I meant "simpler" in some "simpler syntax/tenses" way, and now I've "moved the goalposts" to "less significant" is disingenuous given what I've written in this thread.
I made it absolutely clear from the start of the thread that by "simpler" I meant less significant overall.
I was asked "by which criteria I say it's simpler", and I said "Vocabulary size for one. Applicability in different social contexts. Historical roots. Volumes of works created in it".
And I also extended that reply in follow-up comments, e.g. going on to say that standard english "is a more established language, with a longer history (literals and otherwise), written rules, plethora of books, and billions of speakers the world over. In fact, it was the AAVE that's derived from English and not the other way around. Without English there would be no AAVE. Plus it's also tied to a particular subgroup (and not even for all of its communicational needs)."
Where are those "changing goalposts"? I was talking about a language being less developed (simpler) from the beginning, and I articulated quite clearly what I meant by that, which is the same as the language's general significance, not just as a organized way of talking (syntax/etc) but as a historical/cultural artifacts.
If anything I find the opposing team playing with invisible goalposts, as if only syntax/grammar/etc counts in evaluating a language, that is, as if a language is just some formal linguistic construct, and does not have an associated culture, applications, history, literature, etc.
I guess this is part of the continental divide in thinking about culture.
In the very first response I got, I was asked to clarify "simpler", and I explained that I mean the overall "ecosystem" (history, culture, literature, vocabulary, applications) of the language.
Maybe a better word instead of "simpler" would be "poorer" and "richer". In the sense of the Java and Nim ecosystem's for example.
So, not the syntactic/etc rules (of which I don't care much at all -- anybody can create a full set of syntax rules for a new language, that doesn't make his language important).
AAVE is simpler is that it's a special purpose dialect with a smaller history, less applications, and limited development (due to racism, lack of an official state, non representation in most forms of writing, etc). It's more an artifact of racism (and a group identity thing to combat it) than an actual language (even if it has the "complex syntax" that some people thing is the only thing that matters).
Geoffrey Pullum is a research professor specializing in the description of English and a contributor to the always-excellent Language Log. He is, as a friend of mine described him, an "Internet Linguistics Super Hero".
This is the nerdiest and most interesting piece on African-American dialect you will ever read. Every Standard-English-speaking elite with an opinion on AAVE is wrong about it! And when they're wrong about it, they're wrong in funny ways! The payoff towards the end with William Raspberry trying to mimic AAVE is worth all the build-up --- not that it needs to be, since I couldn't stop reading that build-up either.
The central thesis of the essay is this: elites dismiss AAVE as simplified or "street-talk" English. But it isn't: its rules are rigorous and intricate. You can't simply simplify Standard English and arrive at AAVE. You have to learn it, like any other dialect. Some of AAVE's rules are shared with other dialects, like Cockney. Some of its more idiosyncratic rules, like double-negatives, are mainstream features of other high-status languages. Whatever your political affiliation is, it's hard to read this piece and come away thinking anything other than AAVE should should take its place among all the other well-accepted English dialects.
Having read the whole thread here, I'll take a second to point out what the essay is not about:
* It's not about "teaching AAVE at school". The only case it makes for AAVE's role in education is to suggest that AAVE-aware instruction will improve outcomes for learning Standard English.
* It's not about whether we should take special efforts to preserve AAVE, which makes about as much sense as contriving a long argument about whether we should preserve Cockney or Quebecois.
* It's not about whether AAVE speakers should speak only AAVE. In fact, the essay heavily implies the opposite. Had it not been written before the mainstreaming of the term "code-switching", I imagine code-switching would factor heavily in the essay.