Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli...
by coldtea on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @01:32PM
(#12038080)
>When you say Persian is likely superior to English, you're using the word in an abstract, philosophical sense, as if you're comparing two pieces of ancient art, not concerned with their practical uses. You say Persian could be "superior", but if anyone asks which language one should learn, you will have no problem suggesting English, as that's the practical choice with much more utility.
That's correct.
AAVE, on the other hand is both (for me) poorer in the philosophical sense (which I tie to overall cultural significance), and to utility. It's a very special purpose group language, that even its speakers abandon in different contexts.
So I don't see the conflict you mention. If practicality wasn't an issue, I would suggest people study Persian (or Chinese, or several others beautiful and rich ancient languages), not English. But as it is, I would suggest English (besides, in terms of cultural significance for the modern world, it holds quite well, ever since the 20th century -- before I might have suggested French).
Similarly, for English vs AAVE, I would suggest English both for their overall cultural significance over AAVE and their practicality.
That's correct.
AAVE, on the other hand is both (for me) poorer in the philosophical sense (which I tie to overall cultural significance), and to utility. It's a very special purpose group language, that even its speakers abandon in different contexts.
So I don't see the conflict you mention. If practicality wasn't an issue, I would suggest people study Persian (or Chinese, or several others beautiful and rich ancient languages), not English. But as it is, I would suggest English (besides, in terms of cultural significance for the modern world, it holds quite well, ever since the 20th century -- before I might have suggested French).
Similarly, for English vs AAVE, I would suggest English both for their overall cultural significance over AAVE and their practicality.