Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli...
by coldtea on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @01:23PM
(#12038027)
I did say simpler -- but I explained straight away I don't mean it in the "Go is simpler than C++" sense.
In the very first response I got, I was asked to clarify "simpler", and I explained that I mean the overall "ecosystem" (history, culture, literature, vocabulary, applications) of the language.
Maybe a better word instead of "simpler" would be "poorer" and "richer". In the sense of the Java and Nim ecosystem's for example.
So, not the syntactic/etc rules (of which I don't care much at all -- anybody can create a full set of syntax rules for a new language, that doesn't make his language important).
AAVE is simpler is that it's a special purpose dialect with a smaller history, less applications, and limited development (due to racism, lack of an official state, non representation in most forms of writing, etc). It's more an artifact of racism (and a group identity thing to combat it) than an actual language (even if it has the "complex syntax" that some people thing is the only thing that matters).
In the very first response I got, I was asked to clarify "simpler", and I explained that I mean the overall "ecosystem" (history, culture, literature, vocabulary, applications) of the language.
Maybe a better word instead of "simpler" would be "poorer" and "richer". In the sense of the Java and Nim ecosystem's for example.
So, not the syntactic/etc rules (of which I don't care much at all -- anybody can create a full set of syntax rules for a new language, that doesn't make his language important).
AAVE is simpler is that it's a special purpose dialect with a smaller history, less applications, and limited development (due to racism, lack of an official state, non representation in most forms of writing, etc). It's more an artifact of racism (and a group identity thing to combat it) than an actual language (even if it has the "complex syntax" that some people thing is the only thing that matters).