Obviously if a dialect or language is the primary or only means of interaction with a population group (as Persian is with Persians) it is not inferior - it is what it is. But if a borderline unintelligible dialect coexists with the understandable main language, its inferiority is not a moral judgement by evil racists, but a straightforward utilitarian rejection.
It also doesn't matter how high-prestige the group speaking a hard-to-understand dialect is. Swiss German is mocked and looked down upon by non-native-speakers, as is speaking the Swabian German dialect - though you likely won't find any population groups with higher social status (+wealth/prestige) in Germany.
In fact, it was the AAVE that's derived from English and not the other way around. Without English there would be no AAVE.
Plus it's also tied to a particular subgroup (and not even for all of its communicational needs).
Oh, and about all that racism stuff that easily flows, I don't have a horse in this race (no pun intended) as I'm not American, and we didn't really do slavery. If anything, when my people came to the US they were treated exactly like blacks were treated at the time by the racist white majority, KKK-visits included.
Most of which (British, American, Irish, Australian, etc) are trivial variations of the single originating British English language.
>I'm not aware of any single dialect that has anything close to a billion speakers.
English, the language, however, has. Dialects are just regional and group variations of it.
AAVE isn't particularly notable, other than the politics surrounding it.
That's not surprising, since I don't agree with the essay in the first place, including the very premise (common to modern linguistics) that all languages are created equal as long as they serve the communication needs of their groups.
I also disagree to dispensing with "moral judgements about language" (or the way modern social sciences rush to dispense with moral judgements about almost everything -- and I mean this in a Christopher Lasch way).
>Most of us probably have no trouble dismissing the notion that Persian is intrinsically inferior to English. But because AAVE is so close to our own dialects, we're convinced we understand it well enough to judge it.
Persian is an ancient language, of a historically great empire with an important literary canon, written rules and more than a couple of millennia of refinement by speakers, scholars, poets, etc. If anything, it could be superior to English.
An ad-hoc minority dialect of a couple of centuries vintage that slaves and ex-slaves had to adapt and develop to establish group identity and as a secret code against the racist white population, is not the same thing at all.
When you say Persian is likely superior to English, you're using the word in an abstract, philosophical sense, as if you're comparing two pieces of ancient art, not concerned with their practical uses. You say Persian could be "superior", but if anyone asks which language one should learn, you will have no problem suggesting English, as that's the practical choice with much more utility.
Similarly, if anyone suggests English speakers should change their linguistic habit to match the superior grammar of Persian, I'm sure you will (like me) just roll your eyes.
Yet when you compare Standard English and AAVE, I have a feeling that you will encourage people to speak Standard English because it is "superior", and you will likely tell AAVE speakers to adopt the rules of Standard English because it is more sophisticated.
Sounds to me like you're mixing two different meanings to win one argument and then the other.
That's correct.
AAVE, on the other hand is both (for me) poorer in the philosophical sense (which I tie to overall cultural significance), and to utility. It's a very special purpose group language, that even its speakers abandon in different contexts.
So I don't see the conflict you mention. If practicality wasn't an issue, I would suggest people study Persian (or Chinese, or several others beautiful and rich ancient languages), not English. But as it is, I would suggest English (besides, in terms of cultural significance for the modern world, it holds quite well, ever since the 20th century -- before I might have suggested French).
Similarly, for English vs AAVE, I would suggest English both for their overall cultural significance over AAVE and their practicality.
You haven't so much "disagreed" with the essay as you've opted to pursue an orthogonal concern to which it doesn't expend any attention at all: whether AAVE is "good" or "bad". Pullum, in this piece, doesn't care. All he's saying is that when considering AAVE, we should at least understand what it is.
Yeah, but what we're pushing under the carpet is that they were forced, by racism, to be raised with it as their first language.
>Pullum, in this piece, doesn't care. All he's saying is that when considering AAVE, we should at least understand what it is.
In the essay he basically collects its syntactic and lexicographical differences, to prove that it's "a whole other language".
That it may be, what's of interest to me is its standing as a language in general (and its historical roots and development), not whether it has coherent rules and thus it cannot be said to be just "mistaken english". That I can give him, but it's far from the real essence of the matter.
Separating from the society at large is how you create and enforce such dialects to particular subgroups.
And segregation didn't end in the 60s: "Despite recent trends, blacks remain the most segregated racial group. The dissimilarity-index indices in 1980, 1990 and 2000 are 72.7, 67.8, and 64.0, respectively.[8] Blacks are hypersegregated in most of the largest metropolitan areas across the U.S., including Atlanta, Baltimore, Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, Houston, Los Angeles, New Orleans, New York, Philadelphia and Washington, DC.[4] For Hispanics, the second most segregated racial group, the indices from 1980, 1990 and 2000 are 50.2, 50.0, and 50.9, respectively".
And: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_segregation_in_the_Uni... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
Again, the essay is about what AAVE actually is, not about whether AAVE is better or worse than Standard Written English.
What's interesting is how this thread demonstrates some of the same effects the essay comments on. As overwhelmingly non-AAVE speakers of Standard English, we seem to have powerful cognitive biases working to convince us that AAVE is, if not broken, then at least an intrinsically lesser form of our own language.
Most of us probably have no trouble dismissing the notion that Persian is intrinsically inferior to English. But because AAVE is so close to our own dialects, we're convinced we understand it well enough to judge it.