Perspective:
* 60 years ago, we didn't have highways.
* 45 years ago, seat belts weren't required.
* 40 years ago, we expected engines to last 10s of thousands of miles. We didn't really understand crumple zones. Open containers and even drinking while driving.
* 30 years, we added fuel injection, computers, and airbags.
* 20 years ago, the hybrid car, better fuel efficiency, and side airbags
Imagine what we'll know tomorrow.
Vast sums of money have been sunk into developing exceptionally reliable avionics systems since then.
Passenger carrying aircraft still all have a pilot or two.
If the cost of that automation (programmers, testing, etc) is greater than the cost of training pilots, then pilots are going to remain.
Usually, there ends up being a middle ground - you automate the low-hanging fruit, and leave the last percentage points to the humans.
EDIT: I understand that there is research going into making computers recognize "novel" situations. My comment only applies to algorithms that contain "checklists".
Sure, it can be tough to tease out the algorithm from the minds of current pilots. Luckily in aviation we already have training manuals. In other domains it'd be tougher to know when we're done extracting knowledge from humans.
b) Said human pilot was aided considerably by the airplane's autopilot system
c) I'm not sure why you think software would find this particularly challenging?
Some on-ground duty pilot sitting in a simulator who's suddenly placed in control of an aircraft that's notified an anomaly seconds before landing has absolutely zero chance of being able to make the same judgement call as a human (co)pilot who's been sitting at the controls for the last few hours. And the likelihood of human input being required is highly correlated with the possibility the aircraft has lost connectivity and/or some of the equipment that's supposed to be sending back data is malfunctioning (and yeah, you could build in more redundancy, but that still doesn't eliminate the problem and probably costs more than the pilot)
Not quite. Here's the US highway system in 1955.[1] Construction of the US Interstate Highway System started in 1956.
[1] http://www.mappery.com/map-of/Pre-Interstate-US-Highway-Syst...
[0] - http://www.historylink.org/index.cfm?DisplayPage=output.cfm&...
What?
> 30 years, we added fuel injection, computers, and airbags.
But we knew about them for a lot longer than that. Fuel injection was used in aircraft during WWII.
It could be a lot more straightforward than you suspect. The three things we have going for us:
1. Car accidents are almost always resolved by deals made between insurance companies (this will be doubly true with unpiloted cars, which will presumably not commit criminal acts)
2. The same few large companies are likely to deal in insurance of piloted and autonomous vehicles, so there's not a huge incentive to go sue-crazy
3. If autonomous vehicles cause significantly fewer accidents and companies can charge the same amount for insurance covering them, that is a huge win for some very large companies with the power to get the ball rolling.
Increased vehicle safety will be a big win for these companies in the short term, although in the long term some price discounts might be factored into the cost of autonomous vehicle insurance.
Once the first ones are available on the open market, I'd expect at least 10 years of them being very expensive rich peoples' toys while the remaining edge cases and kinks in the tech are worked out, manufacturing scales up, insurance and legal issues get sorted out, various road maintenance departments learn to deal with their needs, etc.
It's possible that such vehicles will have 5x-10x total occupancy per day of regular vehicles(which sit idle at most times). And it could imagine how the right financial incentives would shift a large share of the manufacturing capacity towards such cars. And considering the car replacement rate at probably something like 20 years - maybe 10 years is a possibility of starting to have that conversation.
I could believe that the first generation of fully automated cars might be available for purchase in ten years.
To be there I do think we need the first generation of fully automated cars available to the general public in 5 years or less, which I think we're actually close to or we wouldn't be having this very discussion...
Cars sit idle 95% of the time. That means you only need to flip 5-10% of the total fleet. Tesla could do it by themselves building 2-4 million cars/year, with the amount of cars needed per year declining the higher the utilization level you can achieve.
Disincentivize rush hour using congestion pricing.
40K people a year die in the US from vehicle accidents. Why would you not ban humans from driving if machines were objectively superior? Where do you find the "right" to drive to be? Driving is a privilege granted by the government, not a right.
If fully-automated vehicles become commercially available (which seems likely at some point, though not in the immediate future), we will likely see rapid adoption in the applications where they are very well suited, followed by a long, slow, gradual trend toward broader usage. The hardest cases will be the ones sticking around longest, and one can't simply legislate them out of existence. Just replacing a small percentage of the fleet won't come anywhere close! It's only when automated cars have become so dominant that only a small percentage of the fleet still depends on manual drivers that it will become practical to start talking about a ban on manual operation.
Self-driving, electric cars will make future taxi-equivalents affordable enough that it's considered for many instances. That makes for a massive market.
It's not as though current taxis have a sparkling reputation as drivers either. Not many will be sad to see the end of them.
Let's go with that. Say that tomorrow Google finished the development of the car. It works very well.
Than it just need to find a single city that would agree to a wide scale deployment. And I imagine there are plenty of reasons why a city might want to do that. Heck if Google cared, they could legally bribe politicians. And it doesn't even have to be a city in the west. It could be a city ruled by a dictator somewhere in africa. Or it could be a self driving car created by a chinese company, and china would be willing to take the risk to lead in this field.
So maybe the first city isn't as hard as it seems.
Now what happens after a car has proven itself in a city for a year or two ?Showing almost zero accidents, and all the other benefits of a self-driving car. How much will people everywhere would want it ? how much political support would it gather ? i imagine a lot.
Would such support and proof be enough for relatively rapid deployment of self-driving cars ?
If you're talking about _everyone_ in major economies having a driverless car, yeah, I think 40 years is realistic given the replacement rate for cars alone, nevermind the legal issues.
¹ Additional car inspection, criminal record check on the driver, etc.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_Kingdom...
Food for thought.
We defined self-driving cars: When I can pull out my phone in any of at least 5 major metropolitan areas around the world, order a driverless car, have it pick me up and deliver me to a specified location within the city in a timely fashion, with as little risk as getting in a taxi.
He is sub 20 years. I'm thinking more like 40-50 mark.
My thesis? We can solve the technical challenges, but so much physical, legal, and regulatory infrastructure needs to change to make this viable that it will be more than 2 decades until we see self-driving cars as a reality across multiple cities. Of course, I would be more than happy to lose the $100 as it would make everyone's lives better that much sooner. But I'm skeptical.