News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by TazeTSchnitzel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:16PM (#9923879)
It's worth remembering why the GPL was invented.

Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. He couldn't. He created the GPL so that, in future, people wouldn't have this problem.

Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by minot on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:32PM (#9924059)
This is so important that it is worth repeating.

> Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom.

> Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom.

As GPL has evolved, the focus on user freedom has gotten clearer. It is not that GPL is against freedom for developers or software vendors. However, the way I understand it the consequences in this area are more side effects than guiding principles.

It is not like the focus suddenly changed at some point. It has alwasy been this way. Let us look at how FSF defines free software:

> A program is free software if the program's users have the four essential freedoms:

> The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose (freedom 0). > The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish (freedom 1). Access to the source code is a precondition for this. > The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor (freedom 2). > The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others (freedom 3). By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes. Access to the source code is a precondition for this.

Without even reading the four points, we already see that what defines a software as free software is whether or not the "program's users" have certain freedoms. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html

(I am not a lawyer. This is just my personal interpretation.)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:47PM (#9924221)
This also bears repeating:

>Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver.

>Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver.

In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer. This is a "freedom 1" activity, which is a freedom that is only useful for developers.

The user and the developer can not be fully separated when it comes to freedom here. Modification of software, and redistribution of that modification is fundamentally a developer activity. Non-developer users can hire developers to do what they want, but ultimately there's a developer involved in this, otherwise what's the point of source code?

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mikegerwitz on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:55PM (#9924288)
This was a story today:

  http://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/
Let's say I'm a user of that vehicle. I read this article. I want my Jeep audited and fixed, and I want the code modified to indicate any time the vehicle is accepting remote commands.

You cannot separate developers and users, because users can hire developers to perform actions on their behalf. I can't fix my own car, but I have problems with it, and I want to be able to hire someone of my choosing to fix it.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by bunderbunder on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:04PM (#9924359)
Consider an alternative scenario: malware.

In that situation, as a consumer, I'm actually pretty jazzed about living inside Apple's walled garden on my iPhone. The phone refusing to run unsigned code gives me a little bit more security.

It also largely defeats the scenario where I can hire someone to modify my phone's software. But I'm OK with that tradeoff, because I think it puts me on the side of greatest benefit to myself. I suspect most non-programmer users would fall in the same camp.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:20PM (#9924499)
If you think about it, package repositories are just like app stores. They're curated, centralized places to obtain software where you can have high confidence it's free of malware.

...And it's free software with no arbitrary usage restrictions. Meaning you can actually audit it if you so desire, and in fact you'll be doing a great service to users and developers in the process.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by llllllllllllll on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:48PM (#9924734)
Exactly linux distributions have had app stores for ages which have a lot of freedom. And then there are things like the arch user repository which is even less controlled and also great.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pjc50 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:41PM (#9925161)
This is what Schneier calls "security feudalism": https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/12/feudal_sec.ht...

It's a rational choice given the complexity, but makes you totally vulnerable to your feu lord. And their feu lord.

By the way, there is no necessary conflict between signing and software freedom if the system allows you to replace the master keys. Matthew Garrett is doing a collection of work to enable Linux users to use UEFI and TPM hardware to secure themselves against malware.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mikegerwitz on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:12PM (#9924431)
Bugs are by definition unintentional. Surely Jeep did not intentionally introduce those flaws. Code signing does not help there.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by llllllllllllll on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:16PM (#9924468)
You should think what malware is. Maybe apple software is malware as well. Anyways if you could review the source code of the "malware" you (or people who can read it)could know what it does in advance and avoid it. And code could be signed and verified and still be free software. Linux distros verify software signatures and have almost no malware problems and at the same time use a lot of free software. So free software makes users more secure if anything.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by weland on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:47PM (#9924716)
What you're describing is security by obscurity, and it has been shown countless times that it never, ever works.

It does not prevent flaws from being discovered. It slows down the discovery of some flaws, but this also means that the people who discover them can exploit them for years if they're malicious, because flaws are equally hard to discover as part of a well-intentioned an audit as they are as part of an evil plan.

It also allows flaws that have been intentionally introduced to be hidden from sight for a long time -- and allows companies who do so to escape untarnished; since the commit logs are not available (and the source code is often only available in disassembled form), they can always claim it's a bug, not a feature.

It does not provide additional safety, it provides only an illusion of safety -- while making actual safety a lot harder to implement, for everyone.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by ewzimm on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:04PM (#9924857)
Locking a computer into running signed code is just like programming Firefox to refuse to access https sites without properly signed certificates. There's nothing about it that's incompatible with a fully free, GPL software stack. In the case of Firefox, you're trusting the Certificate Authorities. In the case of the iPhone, you're trusting Apple.

You could argue that Firefox leaves open vulnerabilities to things like Superfish (that Windows root CA didn't actually affect Firefox in most cases since Firefox keeps its own list), but you can take the signing concept as low-level as you like, including requiring a signed OS with a hard-coded, single software delivery mechanism which could still be fully GPL.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pessimizer on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:36PM (#9924633)
It also allows Apple to attack its users at will.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by ArneBab on Thursday July 23, 2015 @04:33AM (#9934600)
You get a little bit of security by trusting Apple. But Apple does not give you the option to also trust someone else.

You trade your freedom against short-term convenience. On the long-term it means that you have to accept all decisions Apple takes, even if you dislike them.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:11PM (#9924422)
Your last paragraph seems to be a complete copy of my last paragraph. I'm not sure what point you're trying to make here?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:58PM (#9924823)
You seen to be implying that the user is empowered only if he is also a developer, or has access to a developer. The respondent is trying to show how this is still empowerment.

Would you rather be in a position where you can't hire a developer to improve your software, or more likely download the patch that was donated to the community?

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:39PM (#9925144)
But his point was also that access to a developer is empowerment, which is exactly what I said.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @07:52PM (#9926754)
I say he's trying to tell you that like I know; I should have said I presume that's what he was getting at. On a first reading, that was my interpretation. A very common argument criticising free software is that, since most users can't code, they cannot benefit from the 4 freedoms. This probably prejudiced my interpretation of your comment. Reading it back now I can see what you meant.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by copsarebastards on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:59PM (#9925306)
Your intentions were unclear. When I read your post it sounded like you were arguing that the GPL was to protect developers, not users. The edge case where user = developer isn't an immediately obvious one so it bears clarification.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mikegerwitz on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:22PM (#9925004)
Sorry about that: I misread "can not" as "can".
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:54PM (#9924782)
> In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer. This is a "freedom 1" activity, which is a freedom that is only useful for developers.

If a "pure user" has an issue, and that issue is with free software, that user can go to the open market and hire a developer to solve the issue.

You don't have to be a programmer to benefit from the freedom; that is a fallacy. All users benefit, programmers or not.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:57PM (#9925289)
As I indicate in the very next paragraph.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by betenoire on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:56PM (#9924299)
He was a user of the printer first, and his needs arose as a user of the printer. You can't discount that just because he was also the developer.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by richardjs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:59PM (#9924317)
Any user can become a developer if he or she chooses. The user may decide it requires too much work to learn to code in order to implement a given change, but the option is there nonetheless.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by tome on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:24PM (#9924539)
The user can also pay a developer for modifications to open source software. They typically can't do that if the software is proprietary.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:54PM (#9924280)
Sure, that's freedom 1. But there's also the freedom to redistribute unfettered with no restrictions (sharing with your neighbor), no usage restrictions (freedom 0) and then even non-developer users can know how to make custom builds of a program.

Besides, every developer is also a user. Reciprocal guarantees like copyleft ensure user freedom is preserved because all changes are shared across the community, meaning that technical and non-technical users alike benefit from using modified and enhanced copies.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Nursie on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:45PM (#9925672)
That seems a rather odd distinction to make. Developers are also users, and users can more easily cross the line into tinkerers and developers if they have source access.

In fact I think it's a false distinction.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by bluedino on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:07PM (#9924883)
>> In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer.

At one time they were very often the same thing

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by hasenj on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:37PM (#9925604)
They are not anymore. Insisting on old ideas because they used to make sense in the past is .. well .. kind of dogmatic.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:08PM (#9927087)
No, but that's not relevant because what quickly happened is that communities of programmers grew around free software projects on which they collaborated, and they made their work widely and easily available at cost of distribution only, which quickly became zero. This means that users of free software don't have to be programmers to benefit from it, and indeed most of them aren't.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by asanagi on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @01:22PM (#9930969)
You're striking at the core of the issue here.

In RMS's ideal version of the world, there is no distinction: every "user" is also a "developer". The freedom guaranteed by the GPL enables society to reach a state in which every individual is not merely a consumer of solutions, but a producer. In this vision, we all cooperate to solve problems together because solving problems in the world makes the world better for everyone.

In reality, problem-solving ability (the intersection of the cognitive ability, skill set, drive, and opportunity to solve problems) is a limited resource. There are problem solvers and there are sheep, a configuration that results in a natural kind of economy. "Corporate" with all its lawyers and sales hucksters, i.e. persons not directly engaged in the work of solving problems, are a necessary demon. They connect problem solvers with users that have problems to solve. Users, for their part, exist to give us their money as a reward for the work of solving their problems.

Whether to support the GPL is really a moral decision about which world you believe in. Do you solve problems to make the world a better place, or to make more money for yourself? I personally wish RMS' vision would come true even though I don't believe it's possible. There are natural limitations to problem-solving ability other than the psychological effects of the capitalist environment on those who grow up in it. Still. When you really dig to the bottom of opposition to the GPL, you always find one thing, and one thing only. Money. "ME".

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by vog on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:25PM (#9924547)
Indeed, you can't repeat this often enough.

I have the impression that most anti-GPL sentiment comes from developers who claim their role as something more precious than the role of the users.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by higherpurpose on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:07PM (#9924392)
I remember a big argument in the early years of Android. Google kept promoting it (to the users) as a liberating "open source" OS - except it only worked that way until it reached the manufacturers and carriers. After that, completely locked down, and often with many pre-installed annoying things on it.

So next time another company promotes "freedom" and "open source" let's make sure it actually directly benefits the user.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:28PM (#9924009)
And that's a great thing to care about, and a great reason to create a license. The secondary question is: which license is best at perpetuating user freedom? This is a separate question than that of whether users should have freedom to mess with code. IMHO, the GPL is not the best license for perpetuating the most user freedom. Many people disagree with me on this, but their disagreement usually comes down to "the GPL is best for user freedom because it was created for user freedom and RMS is talking about user freedom." I'm not yet convinced that MIT-like, BSD-like, and Apache-like are any worse at perpetuating user freedom, and may in fact be far better at perpetuating user freedom due to their greater acceptance.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:42PM (#9924172)
> I'm not yet convinced that MIT-like, BSD-like, and Apache-like are any worse at perpetuating user freedom, and may in fact be far better at perpetuating user freedom due to their greater acceptance.

Well, the GPL mandates the right to use the application, and that a redistributor cannot restrict it (section 0, preambule and section 6, IIRC); that right is not guaranteed by MIT, BSD, MPL or Apache.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:55PM (#9924290)
>Well, the GPL mandates the right to use the application, and that a redistributor cannot restrict it (section 0, preambule and section 6, IIRC); that right is not guaranteed by MIT, BSD, MPL or Apache.

Yeah, and because of the additional restrictions of GPL, big companies are simply avoiding it or writing software to replace it.

See: CLANG/LLVM. GCC used to be the king of the compiler heap; now it's well on its way to becoming an historical footnote.

It's far better to convince people to help you by being trusting and generous than by coercion. The GPL uses coercion.

Yes, some companies use BSD/MIT software and lock it up, never to send improvements back upstream. But they ultimately are harming themselves, as they can't trivially update to new versions of the the software, because they're now maintaining a fork, and the longer their code diverges, the harder it will be to maintain. So they are motivated to send improvements upstream. And many (most?) big companies do.

When there's another game in town, people will play the one where they're more welcome. Open source software benefits by many eyes and many hands; the GPL (especially GPLv3) cuts off access to just about everyone in big companies, which means the size of the potential user base is a fraction of what it can be.

Linux is a notable exception, obviously. But with Linux there's a clear way to use it that doesn't risk your proprietary code. Most other software, not so much.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by xirdstl on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:17PM (#9924480)
I'd go further and say it's not just big companies. I've worked for big companies and small, and they have all avoided GPL as much as possible.

It is worse, though, in larger companies. There is generally several layers more of bureaucracy to get through to be able to use GPL licensed software.

To be clear, I'm speaking of my role as a developer and using GPL software in developing proprietary software.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by weland on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:50PM (#9924744)
I've worked for a small company and we had similar problems. It's not that you have to convince six layers of bureaucrats who have no idea what GPL is but they read in eWeek that it's scary -- it's simply that, when you're that small, long-winded consulting services from IP lawyers is not the kind of stuff you want to spend money on.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Nelson69 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:52PM (#9924768)
> Yes, some companies use BSD/MIT software and lock it up, never to send improvements back upstream. But they ultimately are harming themselves, as they can't trivially update to new versions of the the software, because they're now maintaining a fork, and the longer their code diverges, the harder it will be to maintain. So they are motivated to send improvements upstream. And many (most?) big companies do.

Is there any evidence of this?

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by 0x09 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:50PM (#9925710)
Sony has spoken about the problems associated with maintaining a private fork of Clang for the toolchain of the then-unreleased PS4.

See "Working with the LLVM community": http://llvm.org/devmtg/2013-11/slides/Robinson-PS4Toolchain....

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dman on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:03PM (#9924354)
Could you provide some supporting arguments / evidence for this statement - "GCC used to be the king of the compiler heap; now it's well on its way to becoming an historical footnote." ?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:15PM (#9924451)
* As pointed out by another commenter, Apple switched away from GCC as the default to CLANG.

* Microsoft is supporting CLANG.

* Android switched from GCC default to CLANG default.

* The CLANG development community, combined with the LLVM development community, are both extremely robust.

* GCC used to have full time commercial developer contributors working for Google and Apple and other large companies; most such companies have migrated almost entirely to CLANG/LLVM support.

* Because of better management and the army of full time commercial developers contributing to it, CLANG is better in practically every conceivable way at this point than GCC. If GCC weren't GPL, CLANG would likely be (at most) a fork of GCC, and may have been merged back into trunk by now (this happened to GCC once before).

CLANG is also an excellent example of how a completely permissive license can be sufficient to encourage big companies to contribute their changes back to the commons. All of the GPL fearmongering would have you believe that CLANG couldn't exist, and yet it thrives.

And printer drivers are still almost all proprietary [1]. So GPL didn't even achieve the objective that inspired it.

GPL did prove that open source CAN work, and it jumpstarted the open source movement. But its time has past; enough people understand the benefits of contributing to open source that the coercion is no longer necessary, and in fact is harmful.

[1] Some printer drivers have been reverse-engineered for Linux, certainly. But modern printers frequently leave so much processing for the host that their drivers are nontrivial, and even when there exists "free" drivers for Linux, they pale in comparison feature-wise to the proprietary drivers. I'm sure there are exceptions.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by timtadh on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:49PM (#9924735)
LLVM was not created as reaction against the licensing model of GCC. It was created as a research project exploring: "transparent, lifelong program analysis and transformation for arbitrary programs."[1] GCC and other compilers were not setup to do this. They needed to build an intermediate representation of a kind that was highly unusual for the time. That is where it originated, as pure research. Trying to build a better mouse trap. Not to become a GCC competitor. It did become one because it turned out they had some rather good ideas!

The GPL is not harmful and I encourage you to utilize it when appropriate for it protects you (the original author) and your target users far more than BSD or other similar licenses.

[1] http://llvm.org/pubs/2004-01-30-CGO-LLVM.html Read full paper not just the abstract to get the full picture.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by bsder on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:15PM (#9925427)
> It was created as a research project exploring: "transparent, lifelong program analysis and transformation for arbitrary programs."[1] GCC and other compilers were not setup to do this.

gcc was in fact set up to explicitly not be able to do this.

The developers of gcc made understanding the intermediate forms as well as creating plugins as hard as possible specifically so that you couldn't get around the GPL.

clang a direct result of attempting to coerce people with real money with the GPL.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by timtadh on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @05:15PM (#9925868)
> > It was created as a research project exploring: "transparent, lifelong program analysis and transformation for arbitrary programs."[1] GCC and other compilers were not setup to do this.

> gcc was in fact set up to explicitly not be able to do this.

GCC was originally very difficult to integrate with so that non-free programs could not be built on top of it. However, the creation of LLVM does not reduce to: "GCC was difficult to work with so we made this." There had been many attempts to make "Universal Compiler IRs". These attempts had not gone well. LLVM instead chose to do something at a unique level of abstraction that wasn't good for everything but was very good for its particular niche. Once again, read the paper, LLVM really wasn't created as a reaction against GCC.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Tyr42 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:34PM (#9924613)
I feel like the GPL-ness of gcc was less material than the fact that it's developers were afraid of closed source frontends benefiting from their work, and obfuscating the front end so that it was hard to use without pulling in the rest of the codebase.

And the reason I switched was because Clang had better error messages.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:57PM (#9924815)
c.f. Stallman squashing the exportation of ASTs from gcc for use in emacs earlier this year.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:18PM (#9924979)
Like other commenters, I think GPL had little to do with switch to Clang/LLVM. I liked it for its better, versatile design with a community turning it into the program analysis/transformation baseline to beat them all (minus Semantic Design stuff maybe). However, I think your overall point is supported by the fact that many virtualization solutions in embedded space are marketing GPL isolation as a benefit worth buying them. They probably wouldn't be saying it unless they had lots of customers talking about that problem.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @08:03PM (#9926802)
Interesting point about the virtualization. MANY companies are scared of GPL, for certain.

Thinking about Clang, its better design didn't evolve in a vacuum. Clang was primarily developed by Apple [1] so that they would have (with LLVM) a full compiler toolchain that didn't include GPL code (and as others have mentioned, Clang is designed to integrate with editors for parsing, while GCC is explicitly designed to be HARD to integrate that way so that it can't be snuck into a proprietary project).

YOUR choice to change to Clang may not have been about licensing, but licensing and design choices in support of that license philosophy are what caused Clang to exist.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clang

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by wooger on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @07:41AM (#9928959)
This gives the worrying possibiltiy that Apple can benefit from an open source Clang and LLVM now, and in future can make thecomponents required to compile code to their platforms (mainly thinking iOS) proprietary.

They're already moving to encourage / require iOS devs to ship them LLVM IR code - the most logical reason for this is so that they can keep the last part of compilation entirely proprietary in future, taking further freedoms from users and developers.

They design and fab their own ARM chips already, so this is plausible.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @12:57PM (#9930813)
Exactly. They did that sort of thing with Mac OS and iOS on Darwin. They're doing it with Clang. They always do it. It's how they make billions of dollars. Not sure why you worry whether a particular company might scheme: simply don't buy their stuff.

See how that works? And despite Google's BS, I have plenty of ways to keep Android devices largely under my control. On that side of the fence, people stopped worrying and started modding en masse. :)

Further, mobile security vendors such as OK Labs w/ OKL4 let us isolate that mess while programming directly on the kernel or a custom runtime (think MirageOS for mobile). So, we have plenty of options because we aligned with a company doing open-source mobile with little lock-in. Align with closed-source and lock-in loving companies then you get what you had coming. ;)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by TD-Linux on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @10:24AM (#9929789)
They also of course did the opposite with Swift - created a proprietary front end.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @11:36PM (#9927598)
My choice was about licensing and design but 90+% design given GCC was a pain to work with. Your link shows two paragraphs of text talking about design issues with one sentence on licensing. So, it seems Apple's justifications were more similar to my own than different.

The best part is that so many have jumped on the LLVM bandwagon. There's even a formal semantics to get formal verification work going. Mainstream coders, tool developers, and high assurance people all under the same roof contributing a bit to the same tool. Lots of potential there.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by fegu on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:53PM (#9924770)
FreeBSD has switched from GCC to clang as well.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dman on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:54PM (#9924783)
Thanks for writing this up, you make some excellent points. Could you comment on why the BSD's (FreeBSD / OpenBSD / NetBSD) has so far not made inroads against Linux which happens to be GPL2 licensed?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by microtherion on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @06:43PM (#9926401)
First of all, BSD, in the form of OS X and iOS, is more than holding its own.

On the desktop, I believe that BSD was (a) hamstrung by the AT&T / BSDI lawsuit at a critical time and (b) suffered from fragmentation brought about more by incompatible forceful personalities than by technical issues.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by wooger on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @07:43AM (#9928971)
Please stop this bizarre insistence that OS X = BSD. Different kernel, radically different OS overall, not open sourced.

Still shares some userland, but this is irrelevant.

For a true picture, look at how well their open sourced Darwin OS project is doing in terms of update and support.

Apple gutted the FreeBSD core team back in the 90s, hiring them all away.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by microtherion on Thursday July 23, 2015 @04:14PM (#9938205)
Different kernel

But fairly similar userland.

Still shares some userland, but this is irrelevant.

I would say that for most people, the API matters far more than the kernel implementing it.

not open sourced

http://www.opensource.apple.com has the kernel sources under "xnu". I don't think that substantially less is open sourced than e.g. for Android.

look at how well their open sourced Darwin OS project is doing in terms of update and support

The updates are fairly current (10.10.1 corresponds to the version of OS X shipped last fall), though there doesn't seem to be a very large community building on it.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by cjbprime on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @11:13PM (#9927537)
> First of all, BSD, in the form of OS X and iOS, is more than holding its own.

Those are proprietary forms. I think we were talking about whether the decision to be BSD-licensed has been good for the health and contribution of the *BSD projects that OS X and iOS originated from. Then we can draw a conclusion (but hopefully after gathering more data) on whether releasing your codebase GPL or BSD is more likely to lead to long-term health for that open source codebase.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by cwyers on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:58PM (#9924816)
But was GCC ever top of the heap, compared to stuff like Intel's compiler and Microsoft VC++?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dman on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:05PM (#9924865)
http://blog.pgaddict.com/posts/postgresql-performance-with-g...

https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=clang-gc...

Show gcc and clang to be broadly competitive without a clear winner in terms of speed of execution.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jcranmer on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:21PM (#9924517)
A more accurate statement would be that gcc ceded an entire market to Clang. Clang made a big deal about static analysis and tooling for C++ programs, in effect bringing advances in software engineering and tooling made for Java/C# to C/C++. The hostility to making gcc's parsers be more usable by other applications (GCC plugins only very barely made it into the tree) makes Clang the de facto solution; given differences between ASTs, there's also a strong network effect--if you start using Clang, you'll find it hard to switch to gcc and vice versa.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dman on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:00PM (#9924833)
I dont know if licensing was the only reason why GCC missed out on this market. Using parts of the compiler as a library to aid tool building, refactoring and analysis is one of those great ideas that seems obvious in retrospect. To the credit of LLVM's early authors they had a larger vision of what a compiler ought to be than other compilers at the time. I dont recall gcc or any of the other commercial compilers having this expansionary vision of a compiler stack back in the 2000s. Once LLVM was able to move the goalposts on what users expect from a compiler stack, I can see that the license could have eased the decision for the likes of Google and Apple to come on board. It would be interesting if someone from Google / Apple / Microsoft commented on what the thought process was regarding moving to LLVM / Clang and if licensing played a role.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by david-given on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:16PM (#9924469)
Evidence, not so much, but I've got anecdata, if that's any help:

I used to work for a company which produced a game-playing virtual machine. We had a toolchain that allowed building C and C++ programs for it. The toolchain was based on LLVM and gcc (because clang wasn't around at the time).

Integrating gcc into our toolchain was appallingly hard, solely due to GPL restrictions. The extra work in dividing everything into GPL and non-GPL parts, interfacing between the two, producing split packaging and distribution etc was basically half a full time job.

If the company had survived long enough for clang to have become stable --- which, sigh, it didn't --- we would have switched to it like a shot.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jcl on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @02:26AM (#9928016)
Clang is not a good example... It was adopted by Apple for its technical merits over gcc rather than its license. And, in fact, Apple tried to license clang/llvm under the GPL as a contribution to gcc but was rejected:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTU4MzE

That clang is not GPL is more an accident of history than a preference of licenses:

https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2015-02/msg00...

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by andmarios on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:51PM (#9924761)
Webkit is GPL. Android (Linux) kernel is GPL. CUPS is GPL. Busybox is GPL.

Companies may try to avoid GPL but only if they have another, viable choice.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by xyzzyz on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @06:40PM (#9926388)
Nit: Webkit is not GPL. It's partially LGPL, and partially BSD.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by microtherion on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @06:45PM (#9926411)
In the case of CUPS, Apple's choice appears to have been to buy a license exemption for themselves.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:16PM (#9924463)
> Yeah, and because of the additional restrictions of GPL, big companies are simply avoiding it or writing software to replace it.

Sure, and my point was to answer the parent about what freedom does the GPL grant to the users.

Your point is interesting, but is totally besides what I was saying, or the parent.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:36PM (#9924640)
No, his point was exactly why I don't believe that permissive licenses are any worse at perpetuating user freedom than coercive licenses like the GPL: when one feels coerced by a license, the option is to just not take it at all. Whereas with a permissive license, one is far more likely to take it initially, and then perhaps share alike afterwards.

Those who wouldn't share under a permissive license wouldn't accept the GPL to start with, so what additional user freedom can the GPL possibly create in the world that's not already there with permissive licenses?

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:43PM (#9924680)
You are speaking of feelings, I speak about facts and what's actually written in the license: the GPL forbids restricting the freedom to use, even when redistributing; the other licenses don't. This is a clear user freedom that is guaranteed by the GPL.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @02:26AM (#9928018)
>This is a clear user freedom that is guaranteed by the GPL.

Yes, and that freedom is being guaranteed to fewer and fewer end users of GPLed software because of those feelings you're dismissing.

Linux is probably the success story for GPL, and even in that case Google has bundled it with proprietary software (Android now outnumbers all other operating system installs, IIRC). Yes people can make their own distributions, but they're for the most part irrelevant to 99% of users of Android devices. Probably 99.99% if you include people who never install Google proprietary apps (the Play Store; Google Maps; etc.) on their devices.

The point of GPL wasn't to serve the 1%, but to expand software freedoms to everyone. To start a revolution in software, and to supplant closed source and restrictive licenses. Look around, though; most people are ignoring what freedoms they are offered and basking in proprietary software options.

Open source is beautiful when it works. But freedom to redistribute something without value is about as relevant as debating whether a tree falling alone in a forest makes a noise.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:38PM (#9925130)
Feelings are incredibly important around these things! Dismissing them as unimportant misses a huge part of humanity, and of freedom itself.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:38PM (#9924647)
> but is totally besides what I was saying, or the parent.

No, it's not.

GPL is only relevant if it can grant freedom to modify software that's relevant. Freedom to modify something you don't really want to use has no value.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:45PM (#9924693)
The parents speaks about USER freedom, not about developers or redistributors. You argue that freedom of developers is more important, and that's fine. But don't say that the GPL does not guarantee more user freedom.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by cwyers on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:17PM (#9924970)
I think you're talking past each other. The GPL only guarantees user freedoms if you're a user of software licensed under the GPL. If you're using non-GPL software, then the GPL's protections don't matter. If GPL software isn't as good as non-GPL software (for many different, sometimes conflicting definitions of good), it will have fewer users and thus the GPL will provide freedoms to fewer users.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @02:09AM (#9927973)
Thank you.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by clacke2 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:20PM (#9932365)
Non-coercion fails with LLVM:

"indeed there are multiple proprietary compilers and utilities built on top of LLVM—including Apple's Xcode and NVIDIA's CUDA compiler."

https://lwn.net/Articles/582697/

OpenStack is one of the biggest permissively-licensed free software projects out there:

""" Everyone I know who is deploying OpenStack has forked. Not publicly, but they have. No one can run the mainline code, it’s a disaster, and OpenStack politics of the “Big Tent” are going to make that problem a lot worse. Because everyone has their own fork, very little code is making it back upstream. """

http://gigofham.com/archives/47

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Aldo_MX on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:50PM (#9924247)
>Well, the GPL mandates the right to use the application, and that a redistributor cannot restrict it (section 0, preambule and section 6, IIRC); that right is not guaranteed by MIT, BSD, MPL or Apache.

I've yet to see a person who hasn't been able to get the free version of Lua/zlib/libjpeg/libpng/etc. just because some of its rights were restricted by a commercial product (ex. a game).

I'm not saying that the GPL is a bad license, but I personally believe that people who defend it by saying it gives you "more freedom" than MIT/BSD/Apache-like licenses should do a reality check first. More freedom in legalese doesn't equal more freedom in practice.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pornel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:22PM (#9925012)
There are two different situations where this matters:

1. When lua/zlib/libjpeg is compiled into a closed system (perhaps even with DRM), you can't modify that copy of the library. For example you don't have freedom to replace your iPhone's JPEG encoder with MozJPEG.

2. GPL code only helps projects that respect users' freedom, so only Free projects can benefit from it. OTOH do-whatever-you-want code helps both Free and closed projects alike. It allows user-hostile projects to take gratis code, add one (mis)feature, and with little effort compete with the open-source version (see: majority of Android market share belongs to derivatives with unremovable crapware and locked bootloaders).

It's hard to argue about overall effect in practice — it expands problem from legalese to politics. Maybe carriers would never let Android to take off if it was GPL-licensed, but OTOH a GPL3-licensed Android now would be great: it would still allow vendors to customize and extend it, but wouldn't force users to put up with unremovable crapware.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Aldo_MX on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:27PM (#9925534)
1. Actually you can, it's not pretty because it involves code injection, but you can.

But anyway, the question is "which kind of end user would want to switch a JPEG encoder and doesn't know about code injection"? Certainly not many.

Quoting a comment from above:

GPL is only relevant if it can grant freedom to modify software that's relevant. Freedom to modify something you don't really want to use has no value.

2. I hardly see the issue with the Android example, even if Android were GPL-ed, the carriers would include unremovable crapware, because the GPL license doesn't apply to external files.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pornel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @05:56PM (#9926149)
1. I've meant "can" more as allowed by proprietary licenses and laws like DMCA (by which you can't), than in the hacker sense that you can break all DRM you want and declare copyright is bullshit anyway.

> the question is "which kind of end user would want to …

No, that's completely missing the point. It's like "We don't need freedom of speech, because most people have nothing interesting to say".

2. GPL3 has anti-tivoization clause, so if they modified Android to prevent removal of any program (closed or not) you would have right to reverse that change and get rid of the crapware.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:14PM (#9924450)
I'm sorry, but you are answering on the side to what I've said. It's about freedom to use, not to get/modify/redistribute.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Aldo_MX on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:31PM (#9924594)
What's the difference? If you want to use zlib in a project you are making, you proceed to get the free version of zlib first, you are not going to take the version of zlib from a commercial product.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:36PM (#9924634)
You are speaking of developer freedom, not end-user freedom, which was parent's question. zlib is a library, not an end-user application.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by thegeomaster on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:41PM (#9924154)
I understand your argument, but there's another side of that coin. An MIT licensed piece of software can be taken by a company, improved in-house and distributed as proprietary, thereby depleting the community of improvements to the work they have made freely available under good faith. GPL also demands that all distributions contain source code so the user has freedom of tinkering with and inspecting the piece of software as they see fit; the core philosophy, as I understand it, is that since software is to be run on users' computers, they have a right to see how it works, what it does, and change its behavior if there is a need for that. I'm not advocating for blindly using GPL wherever one gets a chance (even RMS and the FSF use the more permissive LGPL for some of their work, most notably GNU Readline), but there are some compelling reasons for releasing your code under GPL, which are of course dependent on your particular case (there seems to be no one-size-fits-all solution for open-source/free software licensing).
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Karunamon on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:43PM (#9924176)
An MIT licensed piece of software can be taken by a company, improved in-house and distributed as proprietary, thereby depleting the community of improvements to the work they have made freely available under good faith.

However, this hypothetical ignores the reality that companies will often simply not touch GPL code rather than deal with compliance. It's not a choice between the MIT licensed code and the GPL licensed code, it's a choice between the MIT licensed code or anything else. Including reinventing that particular wheel in house.

(opinion follows)

In other words, the GPL reduces the amount of quality (software) in the world and ties developers' hands for the purposes of an ill-thought-out political goal. More annoyingly, it does so in the guise of user freedom, when in reality, the GPL does almost nothing for people who don't hack on code.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mordocai on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:51PM (#9924256)
See Linux as a counter-point to this argument.

If your software is good enough, has enough grass-roots support from developers, and has a good/large community around it then companies will bit the bullet and use it despite it being GPL.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by baddox on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:21PM (#9924514)
An example of a GPL project that companies do touch is not a counterpoint to the argument that lots of companies refuse to touch lots of GPL code.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pessimizer on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:29PM (#9924572)
An example of a GPL project that most companies do touch is a counterpoint to the argument that the GPL prevents companies from using software.

That lots of companies refuse to touch GPL code is not an argument for the proposition that "the GPL reduces the amount of quality (software) in the world."

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Aldo_MX on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:19PM (#9924492)
The kernel? Because I've yet to see a Linux distro that doesn't work better with non-GPL parts (ex. Proprietary Drivers).
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mordocai on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:47PM (#9924724)
Only for hardware. Typically for wireless and video drivers. If you use an Intel video card and Intel wireless (the former of which you can only do if you don't care for intensive 3D apps) then you can get away with no OS level proprietary software.

Pretty easy to do if your only use of the machine is development work. Once you get into gaming you have to pile a ton of proprietary software (OS and otherwise) if you want to play anything recent.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by minot on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:55PM (#9924292)
> In other words, the GPL reduces the amount of quality (software) in the world and ties developers' hands for the purposes of an ill-thought-out political goal.

I believe this is a plus point of GPLv3 (although more of a side-effect than a goal). I cheer for companies like Artifex which develops Ghostscript. It makes sense to me that if you're not willing to pay forward, you must pay back towards the cost of developing software.

But then, I've never had to make these hard choices so my naivety shows here.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by rdtsc on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:51PM (#9924258)
> However, this hypothetical ignores the reality that companies will often simply not touch GPL code rather than deal with compliances

Some companies do they get a proprietary license from the authors in return for payment. I've seen companies pay for that. So answer doesn't necessarily have to be "we have to release all our code" it could also be the common business answer of -- pay and get a license.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:56PM (#9924302)
the GPL does almost nothing for people who don't hack on code

Yes, it does. Because of copyleft reciprocity, all users benefit from modified and enhanced copies to the software.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kstenerud on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:26PM (#9924559)
Except for the loss in innovation due to companies that will not touch GPL for fear of being forced to divulge the trade secrets in their code.

If a company could be sure that nothing in their code could jeopardize their competitive advantage, there'd be no problem with exposing it to the world. But the real world often doesn't work that way. And to make matters even worse, people often get it wrong when deciding what needs to be protected, and what doesn't.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Spivak on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:08PM (#9924902)
> Except for the loss in innovation due to companies that will not touch GPL for fear of being forced to divulge the trade secrets in their code.

That's exactly the point of the GPL. Look, we as human beings would be all better off without trade secrets, without closed source, and with the explicit permission to tinker, modify, and improve the products we use every day.

You as a user should want all of the rights afforded to you by the GPL. You should want to know how all of your devices work. You should want to be able to do what you please with them and not just what the company you bought it from wants you to do with it.

Yes, we get it, companies don't want to tell people their secrets, but that's not the fault of the GPL. It's the fault of every user like you who is apathetic toward proprietary software, who thinks it's okay to exploit and profit off of others ignorance while perpetuating a legal framework that mandates that ignorance.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pbreit on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:21PM (#9925478)
"we as human beings would be all better off without trade secrets, without closed source, and with the explicit permission to tinker, modify, and improve the products we use every day."

So, without Apple products? I don't think so. Far from it.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:54PM (#9927261)
Are you joking? Apple products are the most locked down and functionally inept of them all. Remind me again how I can drag and drop music onto my iPod, or for that matter play an ogg or flac file on it, or switch to a different task on my Mac without its app and all of its windows taking over my entire desktop, or lock my screen without knowing some arcane keyboard shortcut, or find my home directory in the finder?

Not only is OS X by far the hardest to learn and use of any of the desktops, free or non-free, it is also the least customisable. I can't even buy software to make the window manager usable because Apple won't provide the API to make it possible.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by zobzu on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:57PM (#9924811)
Since MIT-style licensed code gets close sourced I don't see how your logic works at all. Only few huge projects will share back, and generally only share back partially.

If companies are going to choose closed-source license over open sourcing their own code if not GPL or MIT or similar code is available, they weren't going to help open source code to being with.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:08PM (#9924401)
>depleting the community of improvements to the work they have made freely available under good faith

What is this insane logic?

If someone modifies my code and doesn't give it to me, it doesn't deplete me of anything. For that to be true I would have to lose something I already possessed.

You maybe meant "deprive," but at no time did I ever have a right to anything that they created. It seems you're asserting that because they used my code I suddenly should have a right to use their modifications. I think that logic is flawed.

I do believe I should have a right to use anything I've created [1]. And if someone feels they've made changes that would be generally useful, and submits code to add to the code I've released, then I would be thankful.

But I wouldn't feel that I had the right to something created by someone else just because I gave them a gift that didn't even cost me anything to give them (aside from possible opportunity costs).

That's not to say that GPLv2 isn't useful for dual-licensing situations (like Qt), so as to convince companies to pay for full commercial use. But the latter situation does NOT guarantee user freedom (people will only pay if they AREN'T willing to release code, after all), and the pro-GPL arguments on this article seem to focus on user freedom, so you can't really have it both ways.

[1] I would love to see a programmer's bill-of-rights that guaranteed a developer the ability to reuse any code that they'd ever written that didn't include any actual business or trade secrets. I once wrote an awesome string class for one employer that was even actually open source, but that was licensed in such an annoying proprietary manner that, even though I can still legally have and use the source code, I can never redistribute the source code. The company made games, so there was nothing at all about the string class that anyone would ever have cared about in a business sense.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by chongli on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:41PM (#9924668)
For that to be true I would have to lose something I already possessed.

It's important to recognize that software -- all software -- is subject to network effects. The more popular a piece of software is, the more work is likely to go into it, more features added etc. If your favourite MIT-licensed software gets forked by a proprietary company and the proprietary version eclipses the original in popularity, you are very likely to be deprived of future support. In a way, software is analogous to a river: it's important to preserve everybody's access not just to the part of the river they live near but also its entire length upstream and downstream.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @07:27PM (#9926638)
The opposite has been the case, though, in practice: When using MIT-licensed software that's popular, proprietary software companies have been happy to contribute back upstream, because it reduces their maintenance requirements.

And since when does a for-pay piece of software eclipse the original free version in popularity? If it did happen, then I'd assert that the "proprietary company" must have done a lot of work to make that possible. In that unlikely case, they must have invested a nontrivial amount in the creation of a powerful tool, and they deserve the profits it generates.

A far more likely scenario is that a proprietary company forks an MIT-licensed project, does something creative with it, sells it to a few people, and then the open-source community would copy the cool features and add them to the MIT project. The actual code to a new feature is typically not as hard to create as the design of the feature, which has already been done by our hypothetical proprietary company. Then the company will need to innovate again to stay relevant, and the free project can copy those features as well.

A healthy ecosystem can include some companies that don't share. It's all part of the network effect. If you can cite any situation where a community surrounding a free software library or other product has been killed or even harmed by a piece of proprietary software that is based on the same code, then you might have a point, but I don't think it's happened.

It DOES happen that proprietary software runs circles around the equivalent free software (Adobe Photoshop, for instance), but that's not because the for-pay software is stealing free code. It's because when you have hundreds of full-time developers you can produce a lot more than the same number of people can do in their spare time. And when those full-time paid developers can contribute to open source (as is frequently the case with MIT/BSD licensed projects), those open source projects flourish as well. Again, see LLVM/Clang.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:27PM (#9927374)
But all of the examples you cite (with the exception of Photoshop) are used by developers. The article was talking specifically about serving the interests of users of applications.

I actually think you chose a bad example with the Adobe suite. Not one of the creative apps runs on Linux, I need an internet connection to keep the DRM system happy, and I have no guarantee that I will be able to open a PSD/AI/etc that I created 10 years ago on an older version of the software - a major concern for a serious amateur.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @01:53AM (#9927936)
>I actually think you chose a bad example with the Adobe suite.

It's actually a perfect example:

* Any DRM it has obviously is annoying and could prevent you from using a valid copy (though I've never seen it not work).

* It's crazy expensive.

* Its UI is annoying.

And yet it's by far the most used piece of software when it comes to editing photos (with the possible exception of Adobe Lightroom).

FWIW, PSD is a pretty well standardized file format, and files created in older versions of PhotoShop have always reliably worked in newer versions of the app. It's the other way around, especially if you're using transformations that don't exist in the older app, where you most frequently encounter problems. Which means that if you don't pay their ongoing extortion fees, you might end up getting a PSD that you can't open because of some new feature the older app doesn't support.

Yes it's annoying. But it's also hands down the best, and no professional graphic artist would be taken seriously without it. Gimp doesn't even come close in functionality -- but even worse, the various tutorials and scripts you can follow or acquire for PhotoShop don't work in Gimp.

>The article was talking specifically about serving the interests of users of applications.

Sure it was, but in my example I point out one of many apps that is vastly superior to its open source equivalents, and yet it is the one that serves users the best. Yes Adobe extorts money from those users. Yes it would be nice if it were just open and free. But the reason that Adobe can make software that is so much better is that it can extort that money from users.

So what good is the GPL in fighting apps like this? It accomplishes nothing with respect to large companies like Adobe, because they can just pay to reimplement what they need.

The argument is that the GPL will allow better software to be written with capital-f-Freedom than proprietary. That the GPLed libraries will grow in quantity and eventually outcompete proprietary tools. Other than developer tools (and precious few of those even qualify, honestly), name a GPL application that's better than its closed source rivals. Write a list of all of them that you can think of, in fact. If you hit a half dozen, I'd be surprised -- and there are dozens if not hundreds of solid proprietary packages that make the open source packages look embarrassingly bad by comparison.

Yes you can find GPL apps that are Good Enough for some purposes. I do know people who use and swear by Gimp, for example, or Inkscape. But except for people who use Free tools for philosophical (or financial) reasons, the vast majority of end users want the mainstream, proprietary software that for the most part works the way they expect.

Users are being better served by apps that work well and have the features they need. It happens those apps typically are proprietary. Some philosophies sound good on paper, but in reality fall apart. The GPL largely falls into that trap, IMO, except for the awesome developer tools that are available for free. And Firefox. I still like Firefox. :)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:11AM (#9928477)
I'm sorry but PS is not vastly superior to Gimp; it's largely equivalent. PS has tools that Gimp doesn't have and Gimp has tool that PS doesn't have. Given the choice, I use Gimp over PS because of the reasons I mentioned in my previous post, and also because I find its UI to be much less obtrusive, and because I can't find equivalent tools in PS for the work I do.

I deliberately avoided comparing the 2 apps in terms of features in my last post to avoid the tit for tat that will inevitably follow.

PS is required by professionals because it is the de facto standard image editing tool and it's the one graphic designers learnt to use in school, and because once you've bought a copy you're locked in. Frankly, if XCF was the industry file format and Gimp was taught in school, Gimp would be the tool everyone uses.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @02:06PM (#9931274)
I've used both, and Gimp falls flat in the implementation of the features that it does have. It's not about filling in boxes in a feature comparison table. It's about how well each key feature works. [1]

And that's where most open source software completely falls down, because getting UI and polish into an app takes tons of time and experimentation to get right. Open source apps typically get to 80% and leave it there. Problem is, the last 20% of UI and feature improvement typically requires 80% of the time.

But even that is irrelevant, as you point out, because PS is the de facto standard, and Gimp can't open a multi-layer PSD and be expected to render it perfectly if it uses any nontrivial effects.

[1] Gimp seems to still be missing "adjustment layers," which I swear are used in 95% of the nontrivial tutorials I've seen for PhotoShop. I'm sure you can work around that, but that is a key feature of PhotoShop. Just because you don't find a feature important doesn't mean it isn't used by 90% of graphic professionals who use PhotoShop.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @06:11PM (#9932717)

    I've used both, and Gimp falls flat in the implementation
    of the features that it does have.
I've also used both, regularly and for many years, and my experience is the opposite. As I keep saying, Gimp's UI and portability is what makes me keep using Gimp despite also having Adobe CC installed on my workstation.

    And that's where most open source software completely
    falls down, because getting UI and polish into an app
    takes tons of time and experimentation to get right.
I could just as easily say that this is where proprietary software falls down because software vendors sell their wares on features, not polish. As a professional software engineer, I know this first hand. PS continues to get feature after feature but its basic rectangle select tool is still a complete pain to use. Last time I checked, the Gimp team flat out refused to add support for 3D rendering. It took them along time to come round to the idea of adding vectors.

Actually, if you look at Gimp's development history, you will find that their approach for a long time now has been to work very hard on making the features they deliver as powerful and usable as possible.

This is partly why features are added so slowly. The other reason is because the development team are a handful of people who work on the tool in their spare time.

Yet despite this, they have built an excellent image manipulation tool in Gimp itself, they've developed the GTK+ UI toolkit that is the backbone of the excellent Gnome and XFCE desktop environments and countless applications. They've also developed the excellent GEGL library, the non-destructive rendering engine built precisely to enable adjustment layers (or their equivalent) in Gimp that you can't live without, which in the meantime has enabled the rapid development of Darktable, a very capable alternative to Lightroom.

In a futile attempt to keep this conversation on topic, I'll just point out that both GEGL and GTK are licensed under the LGPL, while Gimp and Darktable are both licensed under the GPL.

    Just because you don't find a feature important...
That's got nothing to do with it. I started working with Gimp because it was the only tool that ran on Linux that was capable enough to do what I required.

A user of a tool like Gimp or Photoshop makes the application work for him. Before adjustment layers existed, Photoshop users duplicated layers and blended them with the original to get the flexibility they required. I do the same in Gimp. As Gimp introduces more powerful features, I will take advantage of them.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by baddox on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:20PM (#9924500)
It's the same kind of logic that the RIAA would use to conclude that my downloading a terabyte of music is equivalent to my stealing x trillion dollars from the record labels, regardless of whether I ever would have spent money on the music (or whether I ever even listen to it). It is, simply put, the logic of intellectual property laws. It's why I don't like intellectual property laws or things that rely on them (like the GPL).
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Thursday July 23, 2015 @05:13AM (#9934706)
All software licenses rely on them. Copyright and patents are the only provisions under the law for licensing software, and both are used.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by superuser2 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:04PM (#9924363)
>depleting the community of improvements to the work they have made freely available under good faith.

You pretend those improvements would happen anyway. In RMS's world, proprietary software is not a business. The only way those improvements get created are

1) People individually fix their own problems and support their own use cases. Then boring, unsexy problems that no one is passionate about don't get solved. See: Linux desktop.

2) Businesses perform the least amount of development they can as a cost center; their actual business is consulting.

3) Some wealthy, benevolent patron lights money on fire so that the engineers making that software can keep warm.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dllthomas on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:23PM (#9924532)
Listing "Linux Desktop" as a problem unsolved because of a lack of sex appeal is bizarre. It has long seemed to be treated as "sexier" than it (to my mind) has deserved, and a tremendous amount of work has gone into a plethora of projects in this area.

Moreover, in my experience it has always been basically solved (handwringing articles notwithstanding). I wouldn't be surprised if a part of that has been my needs being unusual, though.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dzsekijo on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:24PM (#9925506)
> even RMS and the FSF use the more permissive LGPL for some of their work, most notably GNU Readline

"Readline is free software, distributed under the terms of the GNU General Public License, version 3" -- https://cnswww.cns.cwru.edu/php/chet/readline/rltop.html#Int...

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by thegeomaster on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:35PM (#9927192)
Oh, it was a slip of the tongue---I was thinking of this essay [1], and remembered it mentioning Readline and GNU libc, but for some reason thought that Readline was LGPL and libc was GPL (when the opposite is true and indeed makes way more sense).

[1]: http://www.gnu.org/licenses/why-not-lgpl.en.html

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by phkahler on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:04PM (#9924357)
>> I'm not yet convinced that MIT-like, BSD-like, and Apache-like are any worse at perpetuating user freedom, and may in fact be far better at perpetuating user freedom due to their greater acceptance.

Just try to get source code to any of the Apple or Microsoft OS parts that were BSD licensed so you can tweak them. Then come back and tell me how free you feel. I know you probably don't have a desire to change most of that, but my point is that you can't - for the parts that were changed from their BSD origins with no source released.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by 0x09 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:58PM (#9925761)
>Just try to get source code to any of the Apple or Microsoft OS parts that were BSD licensed so you can tweak them.

The bulk of projects available on opensource.apple.com are not GPL, including not least of all the kernel.

Anecdotally I have personally used the BSD-licensed file_cmds source package to fix some birthtime-related behaviors in cp, mv, and touch that I didn't like.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by liviu- on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:39PM (#9924129)
>Many people disagree with me on this, but their disagreement usually comes down to "the GPL is best for user freedom because it was created for user freedom and RMS is talking about user freedom."

I don't think there's a need to create weak straw arguments, when an obvious argument is that GPL forces companies creating new products based on GPL-licenced software to open-source these products, thus aggressively perpetuating "user freedom". This may or may not be efficient in the long term, but I don't think the answer is very clear cut with the current knowledge base.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by epistasis on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:53PM (#9924278)
I didn't mean to create a straw man, and I kind of intended exactly what you say there (if I'm understanding you): being "aggressive" means that it does the most for user freedom. I like your terminology better though and will use it in the future.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:58PM (#9924821)
> I don't think there's a need to create weak straw arguments, when an obvious argument is that GPL forces companies creating new products based on GPL-licenced software to open-source these products.

The obvious argument is that several people disagree with you on this (see the comment about linux being GPL or using GPL software at a bank.), so the GPL is not serving its purpose because people don't understand its purpose.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by llllllllllllll on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:59PM (#9924828)
As far as i know Apache License, Version 2.0 is considered a free software license. To quote from gnu.org "This is a free software license, compatible with version 3 of the GNU GPL." source: http://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.en.html
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by clacke2 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @04:32PM (#9932124)
Nobody is questioning that ASL2, MIT, BSD, Expat etc are free software licenses. The thesis is that they are not always as good as e.g. the GPLv3 at spreading lasting user freedom.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:08PM (#9924893)
The problem that Stallman faced could be solved with a law that prohibits software from being distributed in compiled form only.

All executable images delivered to users should be accompanied by buildable source code corresponding to the image, if at all the image can be upgraded.

Moreover, it should be lawful for licensed users of a program to share source code modifications with each other.

This is not a copyright issue at all; the rule would apply equally to freeware as well as to programs which are not freely redistributable.

The whole problem is that software can be machine translated from an easily understandable and modifiable from to a cryptic form that is vastly more difficult to understand and modify. This source-to-image translation paradigm gives rise to abuses and problems which were not imagined by the people who invented copyright.

For instance, if you and I both buy copies of the same novel written in the English language, all of its sentences are plainly understandable. You and I can discuss, say, alternative endings for the novel, and even write them up in our mutual correspondence. We could do the analogous thing with software: all that stops us is that we received it in a gobbledygook compiled form. (Plus some idiotic EULA clauses about "reverse engineering").

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by clacke2 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @04:25PM (#9932074)
RMS advocates such a law.

In the meantime, to increase the amount of software that does come with source, he decided to replace critical proprietary software with free software that requires any derivative to come with source. Decades later, the law is still nonexistant, so the workaround has turned out to be quite important.

Copyright is just the tool that happened to be useful for implementing the workaround.

Freeware is irrelevant to the discussion, it is just proprietary software that happens to have a zero price.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:11PM (#9924917)
Good point. I made a similar one referencing the fact that Burroughs mainframes used to come with source to let customers do exactly that. So, it's a proven model. Plus, there's all the dual-licensed code out there proving you can make it charging reasonable rates for commercial use, let free use be free, and give source to both.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:17PM (#9924972)
Indeed. Higher level languages (and that includes symbolic assembly languages) were invented by some smart and kind people in order to make computers easier to program, allowing more kinds of people to be programmers. The idea that you can hold users hostage with compiled code came later; it is an accidental by-product of the model of compiling richly annotated, symbolic, high level code into a bit pattern for the machine.

There is a slight analogy in music. A symbolic musical score is "compiled" into a recording. If someone wants to change the music, they have to either obtain the score or "reverse engineer" it by ear. However, recordings do not have algorithmic behaviors; a "bug" in a recording has only an esthetic consequence. Nobody is the victim of a security bug or malware due to a flaw in a music recording. Performances are also art in their own right. They exhibit nuance and style.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:38PM (#9925128)
Interesting points. I'll go further on the security aspect to say that having a high-level version can dramatically improve ability of customers to secure their operation. The reason is that they can apply countless improvements to static analysis, transformation of unsafe to safe, hardware, and so on. Hard to do this on platform-locked binaries. I've seen some impressive results but their impressiveness came from the uphill battle they fight. Better to make software maintenance and security a downhill battle using every trick we can.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by ctb_mg on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:28PM (#9925044)
Who is claiming this is a copyright issue? Software licensing and copyright are two different things. Are you saying this is also not a software licensing issue?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @05:02PM (#9925786)
> Who is claiming this is a copyright issue?

Why, Stallman and the FSF. Their license is even called "copyleft".

Software licensing is not separate from copyright. Licensing restrictions are made possible by copyright.

There are fantasy clauses in software agreements which don't have anything to do with copying; they are probably bogus. (Like that you can't look at the code to understand how it works, even though you paid for it, and are doing the looking on the machine which holds the licensed copy.)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by insertnickname on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:08PM (#9925373)
Software licensing is based on copyright. It is copyright licensing for software.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jewbacca on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:54PM (#9924281)
Free as in Freedom: Richard Stallman's Crusade for Free Software

Chapter 1

For Want of a Printer

http://www.oreilly.com/openbook/freedom/ch01.html

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:08PM (#9924900)
Doesn't need a GPL: just an irrevocable license to paying customers to be able to obtain and modify the source for their own uses. GPL is clearly superior in freedom but open-source, flexible, and proprietary model solves that with ROI for company. There's been companies, going back to Burrough's MCP OS in 60's, that did that for paying customers. We could push for more companies to do this, especially putting it in writing, to eliminate a lot of our problems.

Device drivers and firmware will still be tricky due to trade secrets involved. I'd say encourage such companies to keep a team around for paid audits and extensions of their product. That's happened with embedded and fabless semiconductor companies for quite a while. We've recently seen AMD and Intel start doing something similar for purposes of customization.

Many potential solutions that don't require convincing a company to go all free and annihilate their existence outside support contracts' race-to-the-bottom profits.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Mithaldu on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:46PM (#9924203)
Sheer curiosity: Do we have any printer with libre drivers now?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by yellowapple on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:52PM (#9924265)
HP's and Brother's printers have entirely-FOSS drivers, IIRC. At least the former's printers will work on my GNU/Linux systems without installing drivers (as opposed to other vendors - like Canon or Epson - that require separate driver installation in most cases).
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by vetrom on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:25PM (#9932401)
MFPs can be a bit hard to deal with, but my Epson 7890 runs entirely from CUPS/GhostScript. Now, the printer itself, runs what's definitely a proprietary OS. Most of the printing problems in that line go into the printer itself. Blobs all the way down!
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by yellowapple on Thursday July 23, 2015 @02:17PM (#9937495)
Interesting; maybe Epson's turning around a bit.

Last I checked, I still need a proprietary driver for the Epson WorkForce printer my grandparents use for color printing (alongside the HP Laserjet 1320n I gave them for greyscale). Then again, some vendors will be hit-and-miss when it comes to out-of-the-box driver support (my Konica-Minolta color laser is one such example), and I guess Epsons are in that category.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by TD-Linux on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @10:30AM (#9929825)
I've plugged in a few friends' Epson printers and it just worked. I don't think I have yet to run across a printer that didn't work in the last 5 years or so (maybe it's just because my printer usage is declining)
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by microtherion on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @06:32PM (#9926346)
Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver.

So how did that work out? As far as I know, there are pretty much no printer manufacturers who open source their drivers.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:31PM (#9927399)
Every printer I've ever owned has worked out of the box with Linux, so pretty well it would seem.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by amelius on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:57PM (#9924307)
But it is also worth noting that any software released under a restrictive license (e.g. GPL) will eventually be replaced by software with a more liberal license (e.g. MIT).
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by phkahler on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:09PM (#9924407)
>> But it is also worth considering that any software released under a restrictive license (e.g. GPL) will eventually be replaced by software with a more liberal license (e.g. MIT).

Which can then be relicensed under GPL ;-) Also consider the OpenOffice fork over to LibreOffice, where the GPL version won out after they relicensed it.

Most FreeSoftware is trying to replace commercial code, so the reverse of what you say is also true.

Also worth noting is that if you like commercial software, why not just use commercial software instead of rolling your own under a permissive license? It seems those developers are not as pro-commercial as they sometimes indicate.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by amelius on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:35PM (#9924628)
> Which can then be relicensed under GPL ;-)

Doesn't matter, it is a different project. All your blood, toil, tears and sweat have been put into that original GPL project that is now replaced by something forked off of an MIT licensed project.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by davidgerard on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:07PM (#9924890)
e.g., Linux.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by legulere on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:56PM (#9925278)
Typical users aren't programmers. For them there isn't a difference. GPL or BSD usually mean for the user to get Software for free.

Where free licences really matter is for developers. The question is wether they have to give back their work that is based on other software.

A really important point in this discussion is the question if something is still the same thing when you change it. In my opinion this isn't true for software. The orignal will still be preserved and still be free.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by anon3_ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:26PM (#9923981)
> user freedom.

He was an academic.

Did he anticipate user demand, market forces or that a corporation (Google, Microsoft, Hashcorp) could drive a permissive licensed open source project in the open?

It turns out the Firefox and Chromium, both liberally licensed projects, usurped Internet Explorer's monopoly on browsers. Both ultimately are backed financially by corporations with huge troths of patents and proprietary code.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by icebraining on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:33PM (#9924066)
Chromium certainly didn't usurp anything. Chrome, the proprietary browser, did.

As for Firefox, the Mozilla Public License is actually a (weak) copyleft license, since if you modify any file, you must distribute your changes - it's closer to the LGPL than to MIT/BSD. And the other licenses under which Firefox is distributed (it's tri-licensed) are GPL and LGPL.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by TazeTSchnitzel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:49PM (#9924243)
Yes, the MPL is like a non-viral copyleft. It lets you keep user freedom mostly intact without being unable to link to code under certain licenses.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by comex on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:26PM (#9925523)
You're nitpicking. Chrome has always been very close to Chromium. Even if some crap like the recent voice activation thing, DRM, and in the past the PDF reader (but that was open sourced) has remained proprietary, the vast majority of the code is permissively licensed and open to external contributions.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by anon3_ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:51PM (#9924257)
Exactly, this supports my view.

Chromium is permissively licensed, and Chrome integrates proprietary components. Strengthening the product with features and giving it marketing.

I see the point on MPL. As for bundling more restrictive licenses - as a developer - you have to judge by the most permissive to see how free it really is.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dalke on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:39PM (#9924130)
There's no need to anticipate something that already existed. Permissive licensed user-developed projects existed a few decades before Stallman's involvement. Quoting from the Wikipedia page on SHARE at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SHARE_%28computing%29 :

> SHARE Inc. is a volunteer-run user group for IBM mainframe computers that was founded in 1955 by Los Angeles-area users of the IBM 701 computer system. ... A major resource of SHARE from the beginning was the SHARE library. Originally, IBM distributed its operating systems in source form[1][2][3] and systems programmers commonly made small local additions or modifications and exchanged them with other users. The SHARE library and the process of distributed development it fostered was one of the major origins of open source software.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by wedowhatwedo on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:31PM (#9924038)
But on the other hand, VLC was packaged for the iphone at one point to let users of that platform use it. Source was made available to everyone. It was decided that GPL version 3 wouldn't allow GPL software on the iphone so users were not free to use GPL software on their platform. It is available now for iphone so I'm not sure what changed. I thought it was very odd that GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:47PM (#9924216)
Seriously, most of your facts are wrong. Source: I'm the president of VideoLAN, I did the VLC relicensing[1], and spent a lot of time on GPL/stores compatibility [2].

VLC was GPLv2+ and so was libVLC (the engine library that was spawned from VLC). VLC was put on iOS store as a GPLv2 app, which was not compatible with Apple ToS, and was therefore removed by Apple.

At the same time, libVLC was relicensed over 2 years to LGPLv2.1+ for reasons that were non related to appstores.

As a side-effect, VLC for iOS was rewritten and licensed as MPLv2 to be on the AppStore, with a slight bit less features.

For your information, the main reason that the AppStore is not GPL compatible, is because the AppStore DOES NOT allow you to use an application as you want (even non-open-source ones). This is forbidden by the GPL. Which shows exactly that the GPL tries to enforce the users freedom.

[1] http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/I-did-it [2] https://archive.fosdem.org/2015/schedule/event/appstores/

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by minot on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:01PM (#9924331)
Thank you for your work. I have a question about copyright assignment. You wrote:

>Unlike a lot of large open source projects, authors of VLC keep all their rights on their code, even if the code is minimal.

http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/How-to-properly-relice...

For an entirely new project, would you rather require all contributors to assign copyright to a single entity which then manages licensing or would you have individuals retain copyright? (Off topic: is this even possible in France?)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:20PM (#9924506)
> For an entirely new project, would you rather require all contributors to assign copyright to a single entity which then manages licensing or would you have individuals retain copyright? (Off topic: is this even possible in France?)

First, there are more than 2 options. I'd say there are 3.

Copyright assignment is ALWAYS the wrong answer. It's a bad idea, and I would even that this is unethical, and illegal in numerous countries.

If you want more control, notably for a potential future license change, do a Copyright agreement that is not an assignment. Explain clearly what is in the agreement and what is not.

Total individual copyright is a great idea, but if you care about an application that will go on an appstore, don't go this route. If you integrate a lot of library, same. But if you do a new cool software, just for fun, yes, keep it like this.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pornel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:16PM (#9924470)
> GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case.

That's disingenuous. GPL advocates don't want to limit users' freedom. GPL's Freedom 0 is allowing users to run code for any purpose.

The problem is that users don't decide what they can run on iPhones. Apple does, and Apple chose to forbid GPL code in the App Store.

---

I've licensed my code under GPL (and sent takedown requests to App Store multiple times) specifically to avoid supporting Apple's user-hostile policies with my gratis work.

App Store users have to give up their software freedom for privilege of using Apple's locked-down system. When my code helps increase number of App Store users, it helps increasing number of users who don't have software freedom.

If I license my app under a DRM-friendly license, then it gives competitive advantage to those who don't want to give users' freedom. Instead I license my apps under a DRM-incompatible license, so they give competitive advantage to those who respect users' freedom.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by stephenr on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @11:17PM (#9927549)
The right to choose a "locked down" platform like iOS is inherently a user right.

If you don't want your software to be used on that platform that's your choice, but pretending its about "user rights" is ridiculous.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by JupiterMoon on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:34PM (#9924081)
That is a very specific case.

But since you bring up the iphone. You know that the iphone is fundamentally based open permissive licensed software? I can't think of a more user freedom hostile platform than the iphone...

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dublinben on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:39PM (#9924140)
The problem there is not the GPL, it is the restrictive Terms of Service that Apple has created for their App Store. In order to publish on their closed platform, you must use DRM, which is in violation of the GPL. Apple has it within their power to change their ToS to be compliant with the GPL, and allow more Free Software in the App Store. For obvious reasons, they do not.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by bruo on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:43PM (#9924174)
I think GPL is forbidden from the AppStore. That's Apple's rules to enforcing it.

And yet, the whole iOS environment uses several permissive licensed software. This is a very good example how they damage user freedom, thank you.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by DanBC on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:47PM (#9924219)
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:52PM (#9924262)
This analysis is very outdated.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by DanBC on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:32PM (#9925082)
It would have been useful for you to say which bots are wrong, and why.

Here's a more recent release, still urging people to avoid Apple.

https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/watch-your-freedom-becau...

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Saturday July 25, 2015 @09:59AM (#9947586)
I already said so, in comments above and various talks quite easy to find.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by daveloyall on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:30PM (#9924581)
#fsf on freenode might want to know that and/or receive a patch. I'm sure you're busy, but it sounds like you're a subject matter expert on this topic!
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:35PM (#9924622)
I already gave them the patch in form of a conference at FOSDEM.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by davexunit on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:39PM (#9924133)
>I thought it was very odd that GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case.

You have it backwards. Apple limits user freedom with their licensing restrictions on iOS. Copyleft isn't welcome on iOS, and we shouldn't blame free software advocates for that.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pbreit on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:23PM (#9925495)
I don't think the advocates should fully exonerated either. The problem is clear so it's just a difference of opinion.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by tedks on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:06PM (#9924385)
What changed was that VLC relicensed to LGPL, I believe, for this very reason. (Edit: This is incorrect, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9924529 )

However, there is a distortion in your post that is very, very critical for this argument.

Like all software licenses, the GPL controls DISTRIBUTION of the software. This is a legal concept, not a technical one. Downloading software to your computer and copying it to your iPhone isn't distribution, because you own both devices.

The GPL, as a copyleft license, specifies that a distributor may not make any additional restrictions on future distributors (like users). This is so I can't redistribute Linux as proprietary software, for example.

However, Apple had, at the time of the VLC removal (and likely has similar wording today), this clause in the App store ToS:

>You acknowledge that Products contain security technology that limits your usage of Products to the following applicable Usage Rules, and, whether or not Products are limited by security technology, you agree to use Products in compliance with the applicable Usage Rules.

And, in the Usage Rules:

>The Usage Rules shall govern your rights with respect to the Products, IN ADDITION (emphasis added) to any other terms or rules that may have been established between you and another party.

TL/DR? Apple places ADDITIONAL restrictions on software distributed through the app store. This violates the GPL.

You have this backwards in your post. You say that the GPLv3 prohibits use on the iPhone, but in fact, the Apple ToS prohibits DISTRIBUTION of GPL'd software through the App Store.

End-users are perfectly free to install VLC on their devices. They aren't breaking any laws by doing so. The GPL expressly allows using the software for any purpose. They could install it on a DRM'd toaster if they wanted to. However, DRMOaster Inc. can't distribute GPL'd software.

Instead of modifying its ToS to be more user-friendly, Apple decided to pull VLC from the app store. It could have gone differently.

(quotes pulled from https://www.fsf.org/blogs/licensing/more-about-the-app-store...)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jbk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:23PM (#9924529)
> What changed was that VLC relicensed to LGPL, I believe, for this very reason.

This is incorrect. We changed for other reasons, notably competition and corporate acceptance of the libVLC engine. That relicensing was started way before the port to the AppStore.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by tedks on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:29PM (#9924573)
Thanks for enlightening me! I've edited my post with a link to your comment.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by ben0x539 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:45PM (#9925665)
> TL/DR? Apple places ADDITIONAL restrictions on software distributed through the app store. This violates the GPL. > > [...] You say that the GPLv3 prohibits use on the iPhone,

Didn't you just basically say the same thing? The GPL forbids distribution under the App Store ToS, no?

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by tedks on Thursday July 23, 2015 @12:53PM (#9936956)
"The GPL prohibits use on the iPhone" is not an equivalent statement to "The Apple ToS is incompatible with the GPL". Nominally, consumers own their devices, and in most regions it is legal to circumvent Apple's digital manacles to install software you choose on your hardware. If you want to do this to install GPL'd software, you are fully within your rights to do so.

I think it's rather backwards to say "the GPL forbids distribution under the App Store ToS", because the GPL has no concept of Apple's app store. The GPL predates the Apple App Store ToS by decades. Apple was actually forced to consider this policy when the VLC event happened, and chose to maintain it.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by istvan__ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:33PM (#9924065)
"Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom."

vs.

"The GPL attempts to force people and businesses to release their source code. There is nothing wrong with that, except I don't think it qualifies as "free software". I want anybody to be able to do anything they want with my programs and/or its source code."[1]

And I agree pretty much with the latter.

1. http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/5935

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:53PM (#9924272)
Does true freedom include being bound to a duty to protect that freedom?

With GPL, it works within the existing legal system to ensure that you have full freedom with GPL software as long as you continue to give such freedom to those who use your own versions of GPL.

It reminds me of the issue with a democracy. Does a true democracy allow the voters to replace the democracy with another form of government (say a theocracy) or does a true democracy uphold that the one choice they cannot make is to remove democracy (individually they can stop voting, but they cannot take the vote away from anyone else).

Or take the question of a free market. Given a free market, no man is bound as a slave by default. But does a fully free market allow for a man to sell himself into slavery (and to what degree, as taking on debt might be considered a really light form of indentured servitude, college debt which cannot be discharged could be considered a stronger form, and child support where one can be sentenced to jail could be considered full indentured servitude)?

All of these seem to share a core underlying question, perhaps even an underlying paradox. I'm still not sure what it is, though it does remind me a bit of Russel's paradox in an absolutely rigorless way.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by coldpie on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:14PM (#9924449)
> The GPL attempts to force people and businesses to release their source code.

LOL No. The cost of using GPL code is that you have to release your source code. Just like the cost of using some proprietary software is $X. If you don't want to pay that price, don't use the software.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @09:13AM (#9929383)
I think you mean the cost of distribution. A business can keep its modifications as secret as it likes so long as it doesn't distribute the modified binary.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by istvan__ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:32PM (#9924597)
Exactly as you said, if you want to use GPL you have to do something, while if you want to use BSDL you don't. Surprisingly the definition of freedom:

"the power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint."

Now you tell me which of these licenses are closer to the definition.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by coldpie on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:50PM (#9924752)
I'm not really interested in dictionary-lawyering definitions. I'm most concerned about what I, the end user, can do with the software I obtain. To me, it's very important that I be able to modify the software I use. GPL guarantees I will be able to do that forever. BSD does not.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by istvan__ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:03PM (#9927064)
If you are not interested in the dictionary definition, than please provide your dictionary so we can have a discussion in your language. Until that happens I will use the definitions from the dictionary.

Thank you in advance.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by davexunit on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:46PM (#9924707)
Is the freedom to restrict someone else's freedom really a freedom?

Here's a little haiku by RMS:

Using GPL

is encroaching on our rights

to encroach on yours

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mordocai on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:57PM (#9924805)
To be fair, with nearly every license you have to do something. GPL just has you do extra things.

Almost every license requires you to include the Copyright notice and copy of the license along with your code and usually in the running program as well.

Of course, that's a ton easier than being required to release your source code and not DRM the binaries.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by TazeTSchnitzel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:47PM (#9924217)
This entails giving your users freedom, yet they can take it away from theirs.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by istvan__ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:35PM (#9924618)
free·dom ˈfrēdəm/Submit noun the power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint.

I don't think that restraining what the users can do or have to do while using your "free" software can hold up against the definition of freedom.

I think what you are talking about is the moral superiority here, you are thinking that you are in a better position to define freedom for users that is different from the definition in the dictionary. This is pretty common patter in the society nowadays. Anyways, I am sticking to the original definition. :)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by pessimizer on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:48PM (#9924728)
As your interpretation of freedom requires the freedom to enslave others, it's not something I would support as a social good.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by yarrel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:41PM (#9925630)
Nobody is forced to release their source code.

They just can't release binaries without the source, as they would be preventing other people from doing anything they want with it.

Arguing against that on the basis of freedom is hypocritical.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by angersock on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:21PM (#9923933)
Our users are shittier than his users.

I'm not sure their freedom is really worth caring about, after we've spent so long trying to help them. Our freedom, sure! The freedom of fellow hackers, sure!

The freedom of people who give my email address to linkedin? Who tag me in photos on Facebook? Who use Google Voice and Amazon Echo around me? Who tweet photos of me without asking and thus put my likeness along with EXIF data of my position?

Might as well monetize them.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mwcampbell on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:35PM (#9924092)
The users you disparage are mostly good people who just aren't obsessed with technology, or its implications on privacy, as we are. They just don't know any better than to do what they do on LinkedIn and Facebook. I daresay you need to get out more; then you'll see these users as real people, and not one-dimensional subhuman things to be monetized.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by angersock on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:50PM (#9924742)
At this point, they're willfully ignorant and incurious.

The only thing they're good for (in a software relationship) is being mined for revenue.

Do they pay enough for their no/low cost apps and software to be treated otherwise? No.

Do they vote for smarter politicians to have a better regulatory climate for our business and their privacy? No.

Do they do anything other than lap up the bullshit gawker and buzzfeed ads, the simple pandering of Apple ads extolling faux-quality, the lazy hero worhsip of Musk? No.

We've got numbers--hell, millions and billions of dollars of business built around the numbers--proving the users are saps whose only interest is getting sold to.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by mwcampbell on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:16PM (#9924962)
I don't think they're willfully ignorant. They just have lives outside of the narrow set of interests that are so important to us. And if they don't vote for smarter politicians, it's probably because they've been duped or distracted.

If you're talking generally about non-tech-savvy people who like Facebook and other popular apps and websites, then that would include most of my family and some of my friends. It's easy to paint a whole category of people with a broad brush and hold them all in contempt when you don't know any of them personally.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by marrs on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:45PM (#9927446)
I don't think they're wilfully ignorant either, but they are woefully ignorant, and actually software is tightly woven into their lives so they need to be educated.

It's more serious than you might realise. People have found themselves charged with serious felons either because they or their prosecutors didn't understand what they were doing. And then there's the issue of state surveillance being used as a weapon against activists and campaigners who might embarrass those in positions of power.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by liviu- on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:31PM (#9924042)
If this is of any consolation to you, I'm pretty sure Twitter strips EXIF data on upload.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by angersock on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:51PM (#9924760)
Why would they do a silly thing like that? That data has got to be worth a lot--imagine, for example, doing accurate brand spread analysis by searching for brand logos in photos and looking at where they're being displayed via that data.

It'd be stupid not to hang onto that data.