News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:08PM (#9924893)
The problem that Stallman faced could be solved with a law that prohibits software from being distributed in compiled form only.

All executable images delivered to users should be accompanied by buildable source code corresponding to the image, if at all the image can be upgraded.

Moreover, it should be lawful for licensed users of a program to share source code modifications with each other.

This is not a copyright issue at all; the rule would apply equally to freeware as well as to programs which are not freely redistributable.

The whole problem is that software can be machine translated from an easily understandable and modifiable from to a cryptic form that is vastly more difficult to understand and modify. This source-to-image translation paradigm gives rise to abuses and problems which were not imagined by the people who invented copyright.

For instance, if you and I both buy copies of the same novel written in the English language, all of its sentences are plainly understandable. You and I can discuss, say, alternative endings for the novel, and even write them up in our mutual correspondence. We could do the analogous thing with software: all that stops us is that we received it in a gobbledygook compiled form. (Plus some idiotic EULA clauses about "reverse engineering").

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by clacke2 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @04:25PM (#9932074)
RMS advocates such a law.

In the meantime, to increase the amount of software that does come with source, he decided to replace critical proprietary software with free software that requires any derivative to come with source. Decades later, the law is still nonexistant, so the workaround has turned out to be quite important.

Copyright is just the tool that happened to be useful for implementing the workaround.

Freeware is irrelevant to the discussion, it is just proprietary software that happens to have a zero price.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:11PM (#9924917)
Good point. I made a similar one referencing the fact that Burroughs mainframes used to come with source to let customers do exactly that. So, it's a proven model. Plus, there's all the dual-licensed code out there proving you can make it charging reasonable rates for commercial use, let free use be free, and give source to both.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:17PM (#9924972)
Indeed. Higher level languages (and that includes symbolic assembly languages) were invented by some smart and kind people in order to make computers easier to program, allowing more kinds of people to be programmers. The idea that you can hold users hostage with compiled code came later; it is an accidental by-product of the model of compiling richly annotated, symbolic, high level code into a bit pattern for the machine.

There is a slight analogy in music. A symbolic musical score is "compiled" into a recording. If someone wants to change the music, they have to either obtain the score or "reverse engineer" it by ear. However, recordings do not have algorithmic behaviors; a "bug" in a recording has only an esthetic consequence. Nobody is the victim of a security bug or malware due to a flaw in a music recording. Performances are also art in their own right. They exhibit nuance and style.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by nickpsecurity on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:38PM (#9925128)
Interesting points. I'll go further on the security aspect to say that having a high-level version can dramatically improve ability of customers to secure their operation. The reason is that they can apply countless improvements to static analysis, transformation of unsafe to safe, hardware, and so on. Hard to do this on platform-locked binaries. I've seen some impressive results but their impressiveness came from the uphill battle they fight. Better to make software maintenance and security a downhill battle using every trick we can.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by ctb_mg on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:28PM (#9925044)
Who is claiming this is a copyright issue? Software licensing and copyright are two different things. Are you saying this is also not a software licensing issue?
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by kazinator on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @05:02PM (#9925786)
> Who is claiming this is a copyright issue?

Why, Stallman and the FSF. Their license is even called "copyleft".

Software licensing is not separate from copyright. Licensing restrictions are made possible by copyright.

There are fantasy clauses in software agreements which don't have anything to do with copying; they are probably bogus. (Like that you can't look at the code to understand how it works, even though you paid for it, and are doing the looking on the machine which holds the licensed copy.)

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by insertnickname on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:08PM (#9925373)
Software licensing is based on copyright. It is copyright licensing for software.