News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by jcranmer on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:21PM (#9924517)
A more accurate statement would be that gcc ceded an entire market to Clang. Clang made a big deal about static analysis and tooling for C++ programs, in effect bringing advances in software engineering and tooling made for Java/C# to C/C++. The hostility to making gcc's parsers be more usable by other applications (GCC plugins only very barely made it into the tree) makes Clang the de facto solution; given differences between ASTs, there's also a strong network effect--if you start using Clang, you'll find it hard to switch to gcc and vice versa.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dman on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:00PM (#9924833)
I dont know if licensing was the only reason why GCC missed out on this market. Using parts of the compiler as a library to aid tool building, refactoring and analysis is one of those great ideas that seems obvious in retrospect. To the credit of LLVM's early authors they had a larger vision of what a compiler ought to be than other compilers at the time. I dont recall gcc or any of the other commercial compilers having this expansionary vision of a compiler stack back in the 2000s. Once LLVM was able to move the goalposts on what users expect from a compiler stack, I can see that the license could have eased the decision for the likes of Google and Apple to come on board. It would be interesting if someone from Google / Apple / Microsoft commented on what the thought process was regarding moving to LLVM / Clang and if licensing played a role.