News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by anon3_ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:26PM (#9923981)
> user freedom.

He was an academic.

Did he anticipate user demand, market forces or that a corporation (Google, Microsoft, Hashcorp) could drive a permissive licensed open source project in the open?

It turns out the Firefox and Chromium, both liberally licensed projects, usurped Internet Explorer's monopoly on browsers. Both ultimately are backed financially by corporations with huge troths of patents and proprietary code.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by icebraining on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:33PM (#9924066)
Chromium certainly didn't usurp anything. Chrome, the proprietary browser, did.

As for Firefox, the Mozilla Public License is actually a (weak) copyleft license, since if you modify any file, you must distribute your changes - it's closer to the LGPL than to MIT/BSD. And the other licenses under which Firefox is distributed (it's tri-licensed) are GPL and LGPL.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by TazeTSchnitzel on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:49PM (#9924243)
Yes, the MPL is like a non-viral copyleft. It lets you keep user freedom mostly intact without being unable to link to code under certain licenses.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by comex on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:26PM (#9925523)
You're nitpicking. Chrome has always been very close to Chromium. Even if some crap like the recent voice activation thing, DRM, and in the past the PDF reader (but that was open sourced) has remained proprietary, the vast majority of the code is permissively licensed and open to external contributions.
Re:Why I am pro-GPL by anon3_ on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:51PM (#9924257)
Exactly, this supports my view.

Chromium is permissively licensed, and Chrome integrates proprietary components. Strengthening the product with features and giving it marketing.

I see the point on MPL. As for bundling more restrictive licenses - as a developer - you have to judge by the most permissive to see how free it really is.

Re:Why I am pro-GPL by dalke on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:39PM (#9924130)
There's no need to anticipate something that already existed. Permissive licensed user-developed projects existed a few decades before Stallman's involvement. Quoting from the Wikipedia page on SHARE at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SHARE_%28computing%29 :

> SHARE Inc. is a volunteer-run user group for IBM mainframe computers that was founded in 1955 by Los Angeles-area users of the IBM 701 computer system. ... A major resource of SHARE from the beginning was the SHARE library. Originally, IBM distributed its operating systems in source form[1][2][3] and systems programmers commonly made small local additions or modifications and exchanged them with other users. The SHARE library and the process of distributed development it fostered was one of the major origins of open source software.