News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by cwyers on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:32AM (#9269855)
I don't see how Dropbox wins this. Dropbox isn't going to be able to beat Amazon on price reselling Amazon's own cloud. Dropbox doesn't have any complements, like Google does with Google Docs and Gmail and Android or Microsoft has with Windows and Office or Amazon has with their MP3 marketplace and their Fire devices. It's the whole Jobs thing with 'you're a feature, not a product.'
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by wanderingstan on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:38AM (#9269894)
At least for now, Dropbox wins with better software and features. Google drive has crapped out on me several times in the last years, forcing me to re-download everything from the server to my local box. I've also had cases where it couldn't resolve a sync issue and split a file into two versions. Neither of these has happened with dropbox.

Given Google's obvious prowess with servers, I'm actually amazed Google drive isn't better than it is.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by JohnTHaller on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:14AM (#9270208)
Google is great with server stuff, but they've never been as good at end user software. (And they're awful at support across the board.) Witness all the folks that now regularly lose their Chrome extensions and data if they don't login to Google due to a new security feature.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by 300bps on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:49AM (#9269981)
I agree with you that DropBox is the gold standard in "it just works" but I have been using Google Drive for about a year now on a 1 TB plan consuming 850 GB of space without a single issue.

I store everything on there including JPGs, AVCHD videos, TrueCrypt volumes and every other kind of file type. Never had a single sync issue or slow sync speed.

OneDrive (formerly SkyDrive) on the other hand... That constantly left filename.machinename split versions and the sync speed was uselessly slow.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by mb_72 on Thursday March 26, 2015 @01:25PM (#9271422)
I tried Google Drive about a year ago, and it appeared to choke on large files (I had a couple of 4Gb VMs), and pausing during attempted uploads always resulted in having to start over the upload from scratch. Still sticking with CrashPlan for now.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by driverdan on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:32PM (#9272049)
CrashPlan is a backup service and not directly comparable to standard file storage services.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by gnufied on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:05PM (#9271806)
Try https://www.insynchq.com/ . I am not affiliated with them whatsoever, but for work I am sorta forced to use Google Drive. And to my surprise I have found insync client to be far superior than google's own. Among many things, insync works beautifully on Linux.

One can easily argue though that, Google Drive may make a change which breaks insync - but for past year and half, I have had zero problems.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by theshrike79 on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:13AM (#9275417)
Insync seems nice, but I personally never did manage to get it to work. It just spent over a week "synchronizing" and not a single file appeared on my PC.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by danieldk on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:59PM (#9271151)
Indeed. I wanted to switch to Google Drive a couple of times because cheaper storage. But the client is always slow and crashes regularly for me (without any notice).

Also, Google Drive misses some basic functionality, like getting an actual list of of shared folders and with whom they were shared [1]. Instead you have to check every folder manually.

[1] http://webapps.stackexchange.com/questions/46135/how-can-i-s...

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by mark_l_watson on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:24PM (#9271993)
I pay for extra Google Drive storage, but I do NOT use their client. I use their web interface to basically use GD as a date stamped deep backup for my stuff.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by zo1 on Thursday March 26, 2015 @01:37PM (#9271544)
Also, one other thing to consider, GoogleDrive does not work well (at all, currently) with NTFS junctions. Big deal breaker for me.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by bmelton on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:49AM (#9269983)
And all things being equal, for some reason, Dropbox syncing is much faster than Google Drive.

If I empty out both drives and start from scratch, then put the same files in both, it seems to take Google Drive around 350% time to sync the same files.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by dayone on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:26AM (#9270297)
Dropbox is a resource hog. Unless i want my windows machine to fireup on RAM, fan speed, hard disk usage and stall, I avoid running Dropbox in background. Onedrive works better for me!
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by semerda on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:57AM (#9270549)
Are you on a mac? I have the same issue :( and only run Dropbox when I'm not engaged with my computer to let it do its thing.

Saying that, as a paying customer, I still love Dropbox since it's sync quality & ease is outstanding. I'm also a fan of their Datastore API.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by danieldk on Thursday March 26, 2015 @01:00PM (#9271164)
I am on a Mac and don't have that problem. Did you try to trace the Dropbox process to see if anything weird is happening?
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by sandGorgon on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:59PM (#9271156)
Same here !

Microsoft's Onedrive has been surprisingly good for me - on Android as well.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by osxrand on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:07AM (#9270137)
I've always viewed Google drive as a checklist item to compete with others. Cloud storage? Check! Gets the job done but not a main focus.

The OS X client is passable, and the fact that you can't do things like LAN sync or rate limit the upload speed make it no good for many clients of mine.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by dontblink on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:51AM (#9270503)
You can rate limit in Google Drive in 1.19+
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by kule on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:43AM (#9269926)
I don't think Dropbox has ever tried to compete on price though, have they?

For me, there are two things that make Dropbox a better option than MS/Amazon/Google:

1) It's their core business. You know it's not going to be dropped next week because the side project wasn't popular enough or it's not making enough money.

2) The on iPhone/Mac apps that I use quite often offer a sync option with Dropbox not many sync with other providers.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by cwyers on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:47AM (#9269964)
Ignoring Google and their "empire where the sun always sets," cloud storage is going to become a thing like MP3 players and web browsers -- it's going to become part of the base expectation of having a platform. It's already in Windows, iOS and Android. It's not going away.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by danieldk on Thursday March 26, 2015 @01:04PM (#9271204)
Definitely. But so far, Dropbox is faster and has better sharing functionality (e.g. show me a list of folders that I shared, which e.g. Google Drive cannot do).

For business use, the $10 per month is peanuts for a more seamless experience.

Besides that, Dropbox seems to be branching out. There is Carousel, which I like quite much compared to the cl*sterfuck that is Google Plus photos. I can put my photos in regular Dropbox folders, but still have a Flickr-like experience. Also, there is Mailbox.

Of course, they need a better collaborative editing story than 'you can save from Office on Android/iOS to Dropbox'.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by hyperbovine on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:39PM (#9272109)
The fact that people think Dropbox is so vulnerable tells me how secure they really are as a leader in this space. Let me explain. Dropbox works so beautifully and transparently that people mistakenly assume that what they are doing must be easy. (Netflix suffers / benefits from a similar fallacy with respect to streaming.) In reality, distributed storage and sync is quite a challenging engineering problem, which Dropbox has about a 10 year jump on solving. There is a notorious surfeit of brilliant engineers at Google, but have you actually used Google Drive? I tried it when it came out and it crashed at least once a day. Maybe it's gotten better since, but so has Dropbox. Overcoming these technical deficits is really hard and expensive (just look at Apple Maps) and often painful for the end user. I wouldn't write Dropbox off just yet. Also, with the forthcoming IPO it's conceivable that they will start to build out their own data centers.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by sangnoir on Thursday March 26, 2015 @07:06PM (#9273755)
I highly doubt that Dropbox has a 10 year head-start (over Google and Amazon) in the area of "distributed storage and sync" - unless you meant it in the narrow case of building desktop sync clients.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by johnchristopher on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:44AM (#9269932)
Dropbox user experience hasn't changed that much over the years.

Amazon, Google and MS are after users to absorb them into their other products and then merge or drop those products years letter.

My Dropbox account still works the same after all those years, I can't say the same of Google Drive/Doc SkyDrive/OneDrive/LiveMesh/etc.

> It's the whole Jobs thing with 'you're a feature, not a product.'

I'd turned that the other way. Dropbox is a product while Google, MS and Amazon's dropbox-like offers are a side-feature of other business.

edit: Then there is the `brand` argument. Dropbox is solid.

Note: I am not convinced those arguments are valid in the business space but this is how I think it pans out for most `standard` users (free and paying).

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by eloisant on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:51AM (#9269995)
The problem is not Dropbox being "a feature, not a product". It's a perfectly fine product, but it's hard to compete with products given away as loss leaders by companies who have other sources of revenue.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by danieldk on Thursday March 26, 2015 @01:06PM (#9271223)
That's why people should stick with Dropbox (or others like SpiderOak). Because the companies who give it away as loss leaders will probably neglect their products or index your data for advertising, etc.

(Perhaps with the exception of Microsoft, who seem to want to sell Office with OneDrive.)

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by niels_olson on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:07PM (#9272303)
> Perhaps with the exception of Microsoft, who seem to want to sell Office with OneDrive.

I think this may be the most prescient comment here. I wonder if Dropbox and Microsoft may start looking more and more alike. MSFT with a OS as a side business and Dropbox with an office suite as a side business.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by choppaface on Thursday March 26, 2015 @07:00PM (#9273724)
Dropbox can still win.

First, have you tried the Cloud Drive UI? It's barely hackathon-level quality. They have basic photo browsing, which is nice, but the Dropbox UX is orders of magnitude better at the time of writing.

Second, a lot of people use Dropbox to share files. Amazon's service is currently about back-ups. They're somewhat different use cases, and sharing is arguably a harder problem than backup because the sharing experience must have much less friction to succeed. So Dropbox is already years ahead of Amazon in this regard.

Third, storage at scale is still much cheaper than what anybody is charging. A 4U of RAID 5 SATA drives costs quite a bit less than Amazon's $59/yr/TB price point. (I know Cloud Drive is "unlimited" at that price, but survey data suggest to me most users have less than 1TB of data or unwilling to upload that much). While Dropbox purportedly uses S3 heavily, S3 is about $360/yr/TB. Clearly Dropbox must have storage hedged with something else to back their Pro service (even if that tech is still under development).

Dropbox can, with high probability, meet Amazon's offering here, and they'll likely blow Amazon's UX out of the park.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by rattray on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:53AM (#9270026)
It'll be tough for Dropbox. I imagine the #1 thing they have going for them is a strong consumer-facing brand and a bunch of existing customers (who are likely still telling their friends to download Dropbox, though who knows how fast). I also suspect they're working on a full office suite - they acquired Mailbox and Hackpad more recently.

Amazon doesn't have much strength as a consumer-facing tech brand, afaict. As a developer, I trust S3. But as a consumer, do I trust Amazon's software to be usable or reliable? I'm not so sure.

Still, long-term, I find it hard to see things panning out for good ol DBX without something big coming out soon...

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by crypt1d on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:43AM (#9269930)
Well I was about try out Amazon but then I saw they don't have a Linux client... so I'm sticking with Dropbox for now.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by cozzyd on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:08PM (#9272708)
I know... I have an Amazon Prime account and it irks me that I can only use the web interface.... although I wonder if https://github.com/handyman5/acd_fuse still works. a FUSE interface would be much more convenient than any desktop client.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by lsaferite on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:28AM (#9270313)
Well, since it's an open API I have no doubt there will be a Linux client soon.

Personally I'll wait until I can get a client that can encrypt my data.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by bjacobel on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:29PM (#9272024)
The API is open, but undocumented and unversioned (ie, liable to introduce breaking changes at any time).

I would never try to build a third-party product based on this service. That's what S3 is for.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by beambot on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:10AM (#9270169)
Dropbox should convert their storage backend to a single account on Amazon's new "unlimited" service so that their per-user hosting costs are approximately nil... ;-)

Relevant xkcd: http://xkcd.com/1499/

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by andrewaylett on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:41AM (#9270401)
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by phamilton on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:55AM (#9270038)
Do we know for a fact that Dropbox is still just am S3 reseller? I would be very surprised if that were still true.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by vidarh on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:10AM (#9270168)
It appears to be true, though I'd imagine they're getting very substantial discounts from Amazon. Otherwise it'd be far cheaper for them to self-host at their scale.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by semerda on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:05PM (#9270635)
If that's true wouldn't it make sense for Dropbox to form some sort of a a whitelabel partnership with Amazon? Building cross platform reliable software to sync and method of storing data (ie. avoiding duplicates et al) is still an important piece in creating a smooth user experience while minimizing cost on the storage side.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by stingraycharles on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:02AM (#9270098)
Well the data is hosted on s3.amazonaws.com at least once, judging by the urls. So they either use it as a complement, or exclusively.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by randall on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:48AM (#9269980)
They already have network effects. I wouldn't underestimate those. Also startups are rarely zero sum, so for Dropbox to be successfulâ„¢ it doesn't have to absolutely murder the competition, just be significant enough that the competition doesn't murder it.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by josho on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:40AM (#9270390)
To expand on that, the primary network effect that I see are applications integrating into the dropbox storage system. Smart move by Dropbox.

I wonder if Amazon can somehow leverage their own network effects into this product. e.g. Lots of content is already stored in S3.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by jkmcf on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:15AM (#9270213)
Dropbox has great integration on mobile apps. I don't recall more than a few of my apps having integration beyond Dropbox and iCloud.

I don't know about Android, but I really hope iOS moves towards a generic cloud storage interface so that competitors can more easily get traction, but I know this isn't in Apple's interest.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by yalogin on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:15PM (#9271914)
I don't understand how Google and Microsoft let Dropbox (and Box) to gain any market share at all. It's poor execution from both these giants, particularly Google. I am surprised Dropbox was able to grow for this long.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by semerda on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:02PM (#9270596)
How about their MBaaS? I'm a fan of their Datastore API. Would welcome Dropbox expanding their apps ecosystem support.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by artursapek on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:35AM (#9269872)
Is Dropbox working on moving to its own hardware? It seems like being bound to S3 must be a big business risk for them.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by minimaxir on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:37AM (#9269885)
Dropbox's business strategies (Carousel) and acquisitions ("Dropbox for Music", "Dropbox for Documents") make it seem like Dropbox is opting for diversity instead of opting for efficiency, that could be passed down to the end-user with lower prices.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by cwyers on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:41AM (#9269914)
And that's probably wise -- it's not like the markup on S3 is so huge that it's an obvious big win to move off it once you consider the size of the up-front investment to build up a similarly featured, distributed and redundant cloud storage system of their own. Diversification is a good idea for them, I just think it's a very low probability of success.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by vidarh on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:13AM (#9270201)
Unless they have substantial discounts over the public S3 prices (which is certainly possible - even likely), you can cut 50% or more off the S3 costs very easily. The AWS markups are crazy high.

You can even save substantial money over "pure" S3 just by proxying and caching requests for the most heavily trafficked objects somewhere with lower bandwidth costs.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by cwyers on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:26PM (#9270835)
We don't know the rate they're getting, except that it's likely that it's lower than the public rate. They DO know what the rate is, and they're still using S3.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by amalag on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:42AM (#9269924)
Dropbox can merge with Backblaze ;-)
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by res0nat0r on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:55AM (#9270040)
All of the syncing is done via ec2 instances, so moving the backend storage offsite would cost a ton more, and be a lot slower :(
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by amalag on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:52AM (#9270511)
If you have a machine for storage, you can assume you will have a machine next to it (or on it) for syncing. Anyway they have to pay for their sync machines but at their scale I don't know if it would cost more than ec2.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by sschueller on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:07PM (#9270654)
One word: pre-install

Dropbox is pre-installed on a lot of samsung smartphones and can not be removed. This removes the hurdle for people who don't know much about cloud storage from picking one.

Although I consider this bloatware it appears to be a very good marketing strategy.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by notatoad on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:04PM (#9271800)
Not for long. The new Galaxy S6 has OneDrive pre-installed instead of DropBox, and samsung has indicated that the rest of their lineup will be going this way too. And of course, all new windows computers come with OneDrive pre-installed as well. I think HTC is the only OEM still pre-installing DropBox.
Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by higherpurpose on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:44AM (#9269944)
Dropbox, which has its whole business around selling storage, unlike companies like Amazon and Google, who also want to mine your data, could offer end-to-end encryption for the files like Spideroak.

Of course, I can't imagine its most influential board member, Condoleezza Rice, will ever agree to that.

Re:Amazon Goes After Dropbox, Google, Microsoft with Unlimit... by lsaferite on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:31AM (#9270337)
Well, since the ACS API is open, why couldn't you just write a client that encrypts your data as well?