News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:07PM (#9128149)
In Germany the film is rated 16+, so this story strikes me as really odd. I wouldn't have thought of showing the film to children any younger than 14, personally.

But I guess this is a cultural thing. We tend to be more prudish when it comes to violence but are a lot more relaxed when it comes to nudity or sexuality.

I do remember watching Alien under age (no idea at what age exactly) and thinking it's the scariest thing I had ever seen, though. However I think it's difficult to tell whether that did me any harm or not. We tend to overestimate our own psyche, just as we tend to overestimate how "adult" our children really are.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by SixSigma on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:01PM (#9128384)
It's an 18 in the US. 15 in the UK (though it was an 18 until 2010).

I would be rather annoyed if my 11 y.o. kid came home saying someone's parent had shown them that film.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by bencollier49 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:29PM (#9128967)
Agreed, I'm actually pretty shocked that they reduced it to a 15, there's some pretty strong stuff in there.

11-year-olds are young enough to get terrible nightmares from films like Aliens - if it was my child who wanted to watch something age-appropriate and got shouted down, I'd be pretty furious.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by brazzy on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:58PM (#9129060)
Meh. I've had nightmares from a movie once in my life.

Which one? That lovely children's classic "The Wizard of Oz".

That witch was scary!!

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by walshemj on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:33PM (#9129417)
They removed the realy dark scene Dorothy is in the Witch's dungeon and sings a dark reprise of "some where over the rainbow"

It only exists as a outtake (its on yahoo) as it was to upsetting.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by lamuerteflaca on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:15PM (#9129951)
For me it was The Exorcist. Watched it at 7 or 8. Had nightmares every night for a week. Didn't really learn my lesson though.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by psykovsky on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:58AM (#9131132)
Happened to me with A Nightmare on Elm Street. I was 6. Also didn't learn my lesson, but never again in my life I had a nightmare. Freddie was really scary, all else can said to be a dream if Freddie isn't there. :)
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by jasonwocky on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:45PM (#9129240)
> Meh. I've had nightmares from a movie once in my life.

Some of us weren't so lucky.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by thret on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:29PM (#9129184)
Really? It was the monkeys with wheels that were too freaky for me.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:51PM (#9129482)
That was The Wiz?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by thret on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:49PM (#9129692)
Oh, you're right in that I was wrong. I was thinking of the movie Return to Oz (1985).
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by fennecfoxen on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:34PM (#9130023)
The wheelers? Freakier than the witch with the gallery of heads? If you say so.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by vidarh on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:56AM (#9131438)
Chaplin's "Limelight" haunted me for years, because I got it into my head that he actually died in the scene were his role persona died.

I saw plenty of much more graphic stuff that didn't phase me for a moment.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by thaumasiotes on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:42AM (#9131535)
I've had nightmares from a movie once (and only once) too.

It was The Care Bears Movie.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by celticninja on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:52AM (#9131427)
The flying monkeys scared that shit out of me.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:09AM (#9132114)
My mother took me to the theater and watched it with me. I was 11.

No nightmares.

If anything, I was the weird kid at school, because everyone else was watching Nightmare on Elm Street when they were 8 and 9, and mom wouldn't let me.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by bashinator on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:43PM (#9129455)
The only movie that gave me severe nightmares at that age, was E.T.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by RexRollman on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:38PM (#9129218)
Rated R is 17.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by walshemj on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:33PM (#9129422)
I think Alien was an 18 (X rated) in the Uk not sure about Aliens
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by nsgi on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:07PM (#9129535)
Both films have been re-rated to 15, but the DVDs still seem to be 18 for some reason.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by SixSigma on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:21AM (#9130884)
This is the Internet, go look on imdb.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by alahache on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:58AM (#9130972)
In France it's rated 12+.

It's almost the same for all movies with just violence/blood in it. When I was 11, I used to watch a lot of them. I guess it's okay if the parent is there watching the film with them.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by asdfologist on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:57PM (#9128372)
Speaking of movie ratings, is there actual evidence that watching "adult" movies at a young age is really bad for you? Kids watch pretty much whatever they want on the Internet these days, anyway.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by nl on Sunday March 01, 2015 @10:05PM (#9130117)
There's an academic consensus that exposure to violent media increases violent and aggressive behavior, eg[1][2].

Needless to say, this is very widely disputed and fought over. It's possibly more controversial than climate change.

However, it's quite widely studied[3], and the consensus position is fairly settled.

[1] http://www.jaacap.com/article/S0890-8567%2809%2960387-7/abst... (This is a meta-study)

[2] http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/2014-41977-001/

[3] http://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0,5&q=impa...

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by jazzdev on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @01:18PM (#9139461)
Reason.com reports that this consensus is cracking [1] And the correction at the end begs a fascinating question about whether the media should present both sides of an issue. If 99% of research says A and 1% says not-A, is the media being misleading by reporting both views? If the media doesn't present not-A, then is it censoring opposing views?

[1] http://reason.com/archives/2014/11/14/video-game-violence-a-...

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by nl on Thursday March 05, 2015 @01:30AM (#9149563)
Actually, they published an article highlighting the different view of a single researcher (ok - he had a co-author in one paper). Note that the paper showing the decrease in violence makes no claims for the reasons behind it.

I find his argument compelling, but that doesn't mean the consensus is any different.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by aswanson on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:32PM (#9128978)
I can only speak for myself. Being exposed to pornographic images at 9-10 years old had a negative effect on me. It made me want sex far earlier than I would be ready for the physical and emotional consequences.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by mod on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:39PM (#9129830)
Speaking for myself, I was exposed to pornography at 8 until about 10 pretty consistently (friends' dad worked until dinnertime, they were home alone, they found his porn stash [not stache]).

I can't say I wanted or didn't want it, but I turned down some opportunities in high school and was fairly old, compared to the average in my circles, by the time I had sex.

I don't think the pornographic images (movies, not softcore, in my case) had much effect.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:41PM (#9129832)
It's a complicated topic. Being exposed to porn at a similar age definitely affected my attitude and desire for sexual encounters, though I still didn't get one until being in a serious relationship at 24.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Crito on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:47PM (#9129466)
Maybe these children are going to want to shoot aliens at an earlier age now. Wait...

Edit: Am I wrong? What exactly is the concern with Aliens here? Kids already like guys shooting aliens. Is there some sort of "alien-violence puberty" that I am not aware of?

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by scarygliders on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:17AM (#9131331)
I've upvoted you because I'm noticing a pattern on this topic where anyone questioning the "think of the children!" attitude is being downvoted.

Before you guys downvote me; I'm a parent. The boy is now 13yo and has been growing up with Star Trek, Dr Who, and whatever other sci-fi I like to watch. Even some Dr Who and Star Trek had material some of you would consider to be a bit 'iffy' to show kids. Doesn't seem to have done my son any harm - he's growing into a well balanced kid who goes to the Air Cadets, is popular, and does well at school.

As a parent, I see no harm in showing 11 year old boys Aliens.

Listen - you cannot wrap your kids up in cotton wool. The reality of life is way more brutal and uncaring than is shown in a mere film.

As long as these kids understand that it's just a story, that it involves plastic and latex models, these are actors, and so on and so forth - where's the harm for these 11yo kids?

Like I say - life is hard. I for one don't want my son growing up to be some limp-wristed little snowflake because I shielded him from all sorts of things. Seriously guys, get real.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:20AM (#9131337)
> Even some Dr Who and Star Trek had material some of you would consider to be a bit 'iffy' to show kids

No, people are arguing against films like Saw or their 1980s equivalents.

> Like I say - life is hard. I for one don't want my son growing up to be some limp-wristed little snowflake because I shielded him from all sorts of things. Seriously guys, get real.

What life lessons is a child going to learn from watching "Hostel"?

Also, "limp wristed"? FFS.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by scarygliders on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:25AM (#9131351)
I'm specifically talking about whether it's 'bad' or not for 11yo boys to watch Aliens. Keep to the subject. Why mention some other film when I'm talking about Aliens?

I despise people who try to 'win' their argument by constantly shifting the goalposts.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:30AM (#9131368)
Other people are talkig about films like Saw. Why are you trying to win the argument that nobody here is having?

But, if you want to talk about Aliens: plenty of people in this thread have spoken about the distress they felt when watching Aliens as teenagers. What life lesson is an eleven year old going to learn from watching Aliens?

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by scarygliders on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:56AM (#9131437)
Other people may be talking about Saw, I'm not. I'm specifically talking about the film that was mentioned in the first place and is being talked about in the original post.

I'm also not trying to win any argument. I'm presenting my opinion - on that one specific topic of the original post.

A small selection of posters say they were 'distressed' when watching Aliens? What they call 'stress', I call 'being thrilled' - exactly the intention of the film.

"What life lesson is an eleven year old going to learn from watching Aliens?" - you learn whether or not you like watching these types of films or not. Don't like it? Don't watch another one. Lesson learned. Think you got traumatised over it in some way? Go find someone to talk about it and help you through it - nevertheless, a lesson was learned one way or the other.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by psykovsky on Monday March 02, 2015 @05:03AM (#9131149)
Don't even get me started on the crap cartoons show these days. Violence everywhere.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by wishinghand on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @01:53AM (#9136439)
I kind of had the opposite reaction to the same effect- I was exposed around 10 years old to pornographic images (Playboy) and also read the articles about sex. I wanted it far earlier than I was ready for but I felt like it had a positive effect on me- more at ease with the idea of it, my body, how others might react, how to communicate what I want and figure out what my partner wants.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by belorn on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:41AM (#9131087)
I don't think kids will reach puberty earlier because of what images they view. From everything we know about growth and hormones, exposer to images has never really been suggested to have an impact.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by guard-of-terra on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:08PM (#9129325)
Do you really think keeping people in the dark about things they are supposed to want is a good things?

Are we now factory-farmed chicken (with our consent) and not humans?

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by philsnow on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:13AM (#9130708)
> Do you really think keeping _people_ in the dark

Yes they're "people", but the young are also our charges, and we are responsible for their right upbringing.

If you found your 9yo kid-plus-friends going through your "best of" porn folder at a sleepover or whatever, would you stop them?

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by scarygliders on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:19AM (#9131336)
I refer you to a reply I made before this.

Also, we're not talking about 9yo kids/porn here - stop changing the goalposts - we're talking about 11yo boys and Aliens specifically.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by zo1 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:49PM (#9129262)
If by "adult" you mean horror/grotesque movies, then yes. I watched them from a young age with (I have no idea how) my parents blessing.

To this day, I struggle being alone at night. I'm jumpy, imagine all sorts of weird and nasties creeping and crawling around the dark recesses of whatever room I'm in. It's not debilitating, as I've learned to consciously reason out of my fear of irrational things, but it still pops up in my head. Still makes me jumpy. Still makes my heart-race, and still pisses me off that my mind would do that to me.

Needless to say, I'm not showing any such movies to my kids until they're at-least mid-teens.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by jaredmcateer on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:31PM (#9129631)
To counter your anecdote, my parents never really censored what I viewed as a kid either. Aliens was (and is) one of my favourites as a kid. My babysitter used to "force" me to watch horror movies, she and my parents thought it was funny or something. I don't feel I'm any more or less uncomfortable in the dark by myself than the average person is.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by philsnow on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:25AM (#9130732)
zo1's anecdote shows that at least some kids get lifelong anxiety issues from watching horror/slasher movies at an early age.

Your anecdote shows that at least some kids do _not_ get those lifelong anxiety issues from the same.

How does yours "counter" zo1's in the slightest? That would be like the tobacco industry saying "but look at all the smokers who never got cancer!".

I'm (honestly, as a human being to another) glad you don't seem to have been affected (overly) by your caretakers abusing you, but you can't seriously be advocating this kind of behavior, enough to argue for it?

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by shawabawa3 on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:47AM (#9131106)
> zo1's anecdote shows that at least some kids get lifelong anxiety issues from watching horror/slasher movies at an early age.

No it doesn't.

It shows that at least one person has lifelong anxiety issues that they attribute to having watched horror movies.

I don't have anxiety issues and I watched horror movies at a young age, maybe I would have anxiety issues if I hadn't? Maybe on average it has a positive effect on anxiety? Maybe it's completely unrelated. You can't draw any conclusions from a couple of anecdotes

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by psykovsky on Monday March 02, 2015 @05:06AM (#9131156)
zo1's anecdote shows he has lifelong anxiety issues. Not sure how you diagnosed the cause to be horror/movies and not something else.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by enraged_camel on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:35PM (#9129647)
>>To this day, I struggle being alone at night.

I think most people do, actually, regardless of what types of movies they watched when they were little.

Darkness invokes a primal fear in animals that have not evolved to operate comfortably in it (such as felines).

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:39PM (#9129828)
I don't get why you were downvoted.

Anyway, I think so too. Humans seem to have an innate fear of the dark, and any recent memory of danger will increase that effect. Heck, I'm an adult and still after watching something like Aliens I get seriously stressed when going to bathroom at night. And my closest friend openly refuses to watch scary movies when she expects to be alone home at night.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by mod on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:32PM (#9129811)
Not trying to be "that guy."

This is not evidence, it's an anecdote. It's speculation on your part that this is the reason you're scared. It could be, and maybe it's even likely--but it takes a wider study to have any kind of assurance that you're correct.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by zo1 on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:43AM (#9130772)
Fair enough, of course. I guess I am just assuming the link between the two. But it's a little hard not to see a link as the things I imagine/see are based on the things I saw in those movies.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by jfroma on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:58AM (#9130670)
I saw "Pet Sematary" when I was ~10 and I regret. I haven't seen the movie again but I remember that as a traumatic episode.

I have seen a lot of movies rated for adult with my daughter but not horror like that. I think every person is different, use the common sense.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by JohnBooty on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:04PM (#9130264)
Also anecdotally: as a young teenager I'd remember scenes from movies like Aliens in order to psyche myself up for doing things that were scary. Like: "Okay, self. You can go into that dark basement. It's scary, but not as scary as a bunch of marines going into an alien-infested death trap."

Don't get me wrong: Aliens was really freaking scary to me. Probably the most a movie has ever scared me. As soon as they encounter the first xenomorph it's pretty much sheer terror for the next hour.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by __david__ on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:59AM (#9131140)
> To this day, I struggle being alone at night. I'm jumpy, imagine all sorts of weird and nasties creeping and crawling around the dark recesses of whatever room I'm in.

That is one of the reasons that I got a dog. Having another being in the house is a massive difference from being alone, even if that being can't talk and is a bit of a scaredy cat himself.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:12PM (#9128440)
And hey, before Internet they also were watching anything they wanted anyway - it only takes one kid who gets a VHS from somewhere (e.g. from an older brother)...
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by ptaipale on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:29PM (#9128961)
Using a smartphone to watch a horror or porn flick without adults noticing is much easier than what it was to sneak to someone's home with a CRT TV and a VHS recorder and a cassette to watch.

Not that kids didn't see bad things in the bad old times - they probably saw more of it in real life - but the ubiquitousness of these devices is not necessarily only a good thing.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:44PM (#9129022)
I agree. The point is, kids back then (which includes myself) had their ways. You want some porn or horror/action movie? That's what older brothers are for ;).
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Spooky23 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:24PM (#9130323)
Some kids react poorly to things. I love movies and want the kids to enjoy the experience.

Personally, I'm pretty unflappable, although things like horror movies don't do anything for me at all. My wife cannot tolerate gross stuff at all. Criminal Minds (prime time TV fare) kills her appetite.

My son is too little to develop preferences, but my one nephew hates movies where someone pops from an off camera to attack somebody. Freaks him out, even in a not scary movie.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by wvenable on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:41PM (#9128319)
As a kid in the 80's, there was a pretty big disconnect between the movie rating and what we would eventually watch on VHS at home. Over time I effectively saw every popular 80's movie, every martial arts movie, and a good chunk of horror movies before the age of 12 on home video.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by ptaipale on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:54PM (#9128841)
Talking about disconnects in movie ratings, the DVD releases of "Little House on the Prairie" were rated 18+ in Finland.

This was because the State Motion Picture Inspection Agency got greedy, and wanted to collect a new fee from the distributor who had already paid for the VHS releases.

Distributors had to pay to get a rating, but were allowed to release stuff as 18+ without paying. So the distributor of Little House just told the agency to go climb a tree and released this horrible nightmarish series with a 18+ rating, and since everyone now realised how the inspection agency had made itself completely ridiculous, they gave up and changed the rules.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by neckro23 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:13PM (#9128177)
In the US it's rated "R" (17+). If it wasn't for all the bad language though, I bet it would only be PG-13 by modern standards.

Attitudes vary. My own parents would never have let me see Aliens when I was 11. I think I was 14 or 15 by the time I finally saw it.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by JohnBooty on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:34PM (#9128285)
To clarify for those not from the US: an MPAA "R" rating means that children under 17 are not admitted unless accompanied by an adult. http://www.mpaa.org/film-ratings/

In other words, it's movies we're okay with kids seeing - but they need to see it with an adult, presumably one who knows it's something this specific child will be able to handle.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by zanny on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:15PM (#9130299)
I read this and thought "I'd be amazed any parent would let their child see any movie by themselves".

Then I realized I did it all the time with friends when I was 10-16 and we had a cinema 3 miles into town we would walk to, and I am only 24 this year. Its like the American Family went over-protectionist deep end in just this decade or something, because my brother who lives with his mother can't even walk to the school bus stop down the street by himself without it potentially resulting in a police call.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by acdha on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:01PM (#9128870)
Making sure that children are ready for something is a valid concern but I did want to quote the first sentence of the third paragraph:

“some of them had seen the first one anyway, and nearly all had seen at least one film with a xenomorph in it”

I'm sure there are plenty of kids who aren't ready for this but based on that and some of the other comments about recognizing cliches from similar movies, it sounds like these boys weren't pushing the boundaries too far.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by krylon on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:25PM (#9128485)
The funny thing, though, is that parents routinely read fairy tales to their children, that are just as grim. Just think of Hansel and Gretel.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by gensym on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:37PM (#9130034)
Your logic makes sense, but there's something special about visual imagery - the way the images go directly into our brains without being filtered through our imaginations - that gives it true power.

When I was a kid, I read a lot of horror. Mostly Stephen King, and Clive Barker, which were far more than my 8-year-old self should have been reading, but for the most part, I could handle it, just fine. (Stephen King's It was really the only book that scared me beyond the moments I was reading). On the other hand, the violent films I saw (Aliens, Robocop, etc) proved much harder to shake off. Remember the end of Robocop where they guy gets toxic waste dumped all over him, and his flesh starts dripping off? I spent weeks trying to get that image out of my head. Hell, even the end of Raiders, or the Ceti Eels from Wrath of Khan disturbed me far more than anything I read.

As an adult, I watched Devils Rejects - a truly great film that I cannot recommend to anyone because of how disturbing I found some of the imagery in that.

Or, to take a real life example - plenty of us are fine with reading accounts of terrorist beheadings but purposefully avoid watching the videos of the events.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by dougk16 on Monday March 02, 2015 @12:18AM (#9130418)
Just to show how different people are, my experience was the opposite. My parents never censored anything (within reason), but reading let my imagination fill in the blanks to a more disturbing level than movies could offer. Even stories from pretty silly books like "Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark" would leave me freaked out for days, and then of course I would go back and read them again like an idiot. Audio tapes by Jackie Torrence, a great storyteller, would also get me good. Meanwhile I could watch all the classic horror movies, Freddy, et al. without as much issue...still scary as hell but in a more superficial, short-term way. It also could have something to do with the fact that I watched movies with other people, whereas reading/listening I was usually alone in my bed at night.

You have a point about terrorist beheadings though...can't watch them. I guess cause I know it's real life and the empathy is too much.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by gensym on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:07PM (#9134328)
Oh, man. I totally forgot about "Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark". Yeah, those freaked me out. Granted, the drawings in those books were pretty gruesome, but the stories themselves were pretty scary. Totally forgot about that.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by scotty79 on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:46AM (#9131104)
No movie ever scared me as much as stories. Because you can always close your eyes. But horrible story gets straight into your brain before you even know it's scary and stay there invoking horrors.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by benjohnson on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:55PM (#9128602)
My kids love the really 'German' tales - but I won't let them watch Aliens (just yet). The difference is that the reading gives us the opportunity to discuss the tale, allay fears, and try to find a moral message within the tale.

A movie tends to be presented without an ongoing parental filter as the images go directly to the psyche without pause.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Retra on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:20PM (#9128926)
I feel like you could fix that by watching 'making of' videos before hand, or by pausing between scenes and discussing them.

It's just not a habit people have.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by icebraining on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:41PM (#9129663)
I don't see how you could do that without ruining the experience of watching the film.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by mod on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:41PM (#9129835)
A parental filter is going to "ruin the film" too. I think that's the whole point of this smaller conversation.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by eru on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:04AM (#9130688)
The kids in the article seemed quite reflective.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by MichaelGG on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:07PM (#9128412)
Ratings systems aren't really anything to go by, at least in the US. My rule is: it's gotta be good. I'd prefer my own kids to watch something good than to watch something crappy. The children aimed stuff, for the most part, is junk.

The only stuff I skip is really when there's a explicit sex act talk only because I don't want to explain jokes regarding specific sex acts and slang. My girls are 6 & 8, so I figure that's reasonable for another 5-6 years. Is that prudish? (I've only got cultural input from North America, which seems to recoil at stuff everyone sees in showers everyday, so all I know is that their scale is off, not where it should be.)

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by minopret on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:37PM (#9128783)
I like Common Sense Media. I didn't think I would like any media monitor for parents, but I think this one provides enough depth of information to put decisions into parents' hands. They rate and discuss several factors including not only sex and violence, but also consumerism, "is it any good," and "will kids want it." On the other hand, they also offer simple summaries. A parent who has specific criteria can generally just get a list of current products that meet those criteria.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Tyrannosaurs on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:07PM (#9129533)
The thing I like about CSM is if you hover over (or click on, I can't recall exactly) the ratings for each category they outline why which helps you make your own mind up how flexible you want to be with their recommendation.

Also gives good age ranges, not just the broad certificates.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by greendestiny on Monday March 02, 2015 @12:31AM (#9130448)
I love Common Sense Media. My kids don't like to be scared, it negatively impacts their sleeping and frankly their general well being but I'm not really concerned about bad language or minor innuendo - CSM is the best way to get an idea if my kids are going to enjoy something.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by nsgi on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:12PM (#9129556)
Do you view films like Toy Story, Star Wars and E.T. as junk?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by psykovsky on Monday March 02, 2015 @05:14AM (#9131180)
I do. All 3 of them.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by xgbi on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:50PM (#9128577)
Woud you show them Drive then?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by MichaelGG on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:10PM (#9128662)
If it's as I recall, it was rather boring, but otherwise rather tame. Edit: I just rewatched the trailer, and it looks fine. I just recall not enjoying the movie a whole lot.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by girvo on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:44PM (#9129239)
The last 20 minutes of it are realistically violent. I cringed watching some of the scenes as an adult. I don't think kids would appreciate the build-up to it, either, the fact it's boring is what makes it so damned good when it finally releases the tension it's built to that point.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by xgbi on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:44PM (#9128802)
You might be interested in not showing your kids the lift scene where he stomps a guys's head, or when he shoots another point blank with a shotgun.

My comment was aimed at highlighting that the rating is not dumb BS, some movies contains really disturbing scenes.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by MichaelGG on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:13PM (#9129942)
I'm not saying the ratings are always inaccurate, just that they aren't calibrated to most things I care about. Compared to some folks that go "Oh I would never let my child watch a movie rated R" as if that was some kind of determining factor.

People swearing, using drugs, and nudity will get an R rating even if the movie is fantastic. Those three things I'm annoyed that people find objectionable for children, as it only increases the stigma as they get older, for what should be very positive things. Violence, meh, so long it's not deliberately cruel or scary, I don't see why it'd be disturbing. Over-the-top stuff like you say sounds more funny than anything else. (The children's shows, Golden Compass, and RWBY, both contain scenes where the jaw/head of an enemy is blown right off.)

As another poster mentioned, Common Sense Media is a far better rating system. They address specific points so you can make a good determination. Even then, I find my kids often enjoy stuff that CSM rates well over their current age.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Crito on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:49PM (#9129475)
When I was a kid, I would have just fast-forwarded straight to those scenes. The rest of the movie would have bored kid-me to tears.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by afterburner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:47PM (#9128813)
"Germany" "We tend to be more prudish when it comes to violence but are a lot more relaxed when it comes to nudity or sexuality."

Other way around in North America.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by steveax on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:37PM (#9128995)
Indeed. I saw Sin City (an exceedingly violent movie) in a theater. A woman (presumably the mother) and two young boys (~8 and 11) were seated in the row in front of me. She didn't bat an eye at the violence, but yelped and shielded the boys' eyes when breasts appeared. I still don't really know what to make of that.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by thret on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:31PM (#9129191)
Wow. That movie is so violent I wish I hadn't seen it. I won't watch Sin City 2. I can't imagine how I would have felt watching it at that age.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by 72deluxe on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:43AM (#9131093)
I've not seen it at all but you're right that there are some strange attitudes with some people and letting their children watch horrific things at a young age. Even on this very topic, some of the comments are "meh violence isn't a problem, I don't see why it would be disturbing to my child" which is clearly a case of desensitisation influencing the stuff they show to their children.

I have same many films that I wish I had never seen as I can't "unremember" things or wipe bits of my brain out. The incessant flow of violence in films only serves to desensitise: something is truly shocking the first time, not so the next time, and repeatedly it isn't shocking anymore.

To see that some people use their own level of how shocking a film is to THEM to decide whether to show it to their children is distressing; "I wasn't shocked, so why would my children be??". Very sad.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by aswanson on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:29PM (#9128959)
Yeah, that's one thing that bugged me out when I visited Deutschland...nudity on public television. Totally unheard of in the states.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by bjelkeman-again on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:43PM (#9129231)
It is interesting that nudity is considered so bad, as it is part of healthy and normal relationships between adults. Whilst violence isn't. I think I'd rather have young adults be tolerant about nudity than violence.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by aswanson on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:27PM (#9129612)
I totally agree. American cultural norms are strange in that regard. To be clear, i was not being judgemental, but just relating shock at something i was not used to having been raised in the US.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by westiseast on Monday March 02, 2015 @12:01AM (#9130405)
I live in China, and it's not uncommon for people to take their very young kids to the movies. Japanese 'bad guys' in movies can be stabbed, shot, dismembered and blood flying everywhere, and tge parents don't bat an eyelid. A PG-rated kiss however and the parents are covering the kids eyes with their hands :D
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by ekianjo on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:31PM (#9129806)
> normal relationships between adults.

People don't walk naked in the streets so why do you need to show naked people at peak TV times on public television?

It's "normal between adults" in private places.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by gurkendoktor on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:30PM (#9130012)
People do walk naked on German beaches though, or in the sauna. Maybe I grew up in the wrong parts of Germany, but it all seems pretty normal to me.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by MichaelGG on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:18PM (#9129959)
It's normal for humans of all ages. Does no one look in a mirror or take showers? My kids bathe together, sometimes with my wife. It's, uh, not a big deal, nor should it be.

And who said there's a "need"? Might as well why do you need TV at all? Nude bodies can look cool, so it seems as valid to show that as someone wearing sunglasses.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by darklajid on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:05AM (#9130988)
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by zeyus on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:23PM (#9129981)
Except they do in other countries, maybe not in yours, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

Everyone has the same bits...everyone! (for nipples, for other parts it's more like 50%)

I can't believe that people are still afraid of something everyone has

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by 72deluxe on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:45AM (#9131102)
Everyone defecates too but I don't need to see that :-)
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:16AM (#9131484)
But would you seriously have problems with a scene where someone goes to the toilet?

I'm not talking extreme scatological close-ups. It's an analogy for nudity, not hardcore pornography.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:52AM (#9131426)
People don't have aliens bursting out of their chests in the street so why do you need to show aliens bursting out of people's chests at peak TV times on public television?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by chrismcb on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:09PM (#9130281)
So you watch no tv shows that show people in private places?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by rmc on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:47AM (#9131790)
> People don't walk naked in the streets

They do in Germany.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by rmc on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:46AM (#9131785)
Friend of mine who lived in Germany said: "If you can do it, the Germans have a way to do it naked". Naked hiking, naked sports, whatever
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by sebastianconcpt on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:03AM (#9131450)
The scariest film I saw when I was ~10 was The Day After http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0085404/
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by madaxe_again on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:06AM (#9131456)
Ah, I watched Aliens for the first time aged about 7, in '90 or so... nightmares, for months, and months, and months.

Definitely not one for the under-tens...

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by ekianjo on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:18PM (#9129369)
It may have been rated 16+ at the time it came out, but it's really something that can be watched by younger kids nowadays.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by MBlume on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:10PM (#9130284)
> just as we tend to overestimate how "adult" our children really are.

...who does this? Who, anywhere, does this?

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:32AM (#9131508)
Well, my parents did, for example. I was pretty "rational" at an early age and my parents misinterpreted that as maturity, which at some points got me into situations I shouldn't have been expected to be able to handle at that age.

It's not unheard of for parents to want their children to consider them peers rather than parents. The problem is that you can't really be both. The roles and responsibilities of a parent and a peer in a child's life are very different.

Also, if you signal to your child that you would prefer them to act more maturely, that child can become pretty good at faking maturity without the emotional and psychological stability that would come with it if it came naturally. As a parent you have to look past that superficial behaviour.

And for a less personal example, just look at child prodigies, child actors, child pop stars, or for a particularly disturbing example, child beauty pageants. That a child shows a particular trait normally associated with maturity or adulthood doesn't mean the child should be treated as an adult. Yet, this is exactly what happens to many such children who happily play along because their make-believe is positively reinforced by the adults around them.

There are plenty of people willing to believe an eight year old is "very mature for their age" when they should know better. Heck, the entire premise of NAMBLA is a reflection of this (simply taking the illusion to its disgusting logical extreme).

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pyre on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:22PM (#9130319)
Sometimes children can mature faster in someways than others, and parents can 'forget' that their child is still only X years old.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by mineo on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:54PM (#9128842)
Some of the movies those kids had already seen are rated 16+ as well.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by powertower on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:08PM (#9128415)
For all the "think of the children" commentators here and in the blog - why is it that kids who have parents that hide them from everything "bad", wind up so messed up, narcissistic, and are generally unable to cope with life?

The answer is of course right there, by putting them in a "safe place" you've removed every adversary and every challenge - right when the mind needs those things the most so it can form abilities necessary to deal with and move forward in life (a life that will throw all kinds of issues, disasters, and curve balls at you).

Its kind of like the peanut allergy study that was posted here a day or two ago... The infants and children that don't get exposed to peanuts at an early age - so their systems can get familiar and use to it, are most likely to end up in the highly allergic group. [this is just an analogy]

edit:

This isn't about movies (that word is not mentioned in my post). Some of the replies so far are red-herrings (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_herring).

I'm not suggesting that children should be constantly exposed (or made to watch) graphic and horror movies to prepare them for life.

And I'm sure there are cases of children who just can't handle these things at the age of 10-15... Though most will be fine - and won't need therapy, will not have their lives ruined, nor will their well-beings be negatively impacted.

I am also not suggesting that they should have no supervision.

What I am suggesting is that there are too many over-protective and helicopter parents who are making "special children" that can only live and function inside bubbles.

And if the child get's broken by watching "Aliens" at the age of 11, then the problem is with the parenting - rather than the friend's dad who let them watch it.

In which case, please, attach a note to the child with all the rather available things that he/she should not be exposed to or is allergic to (like peanut butter).

We live in a society where a child would have to sit on a park bench for 700,000 years before he/she would get kidnapped, but if you leave him/her in a car to pay the gas station clerk, someone can take a picture of that child being untended and send it to the police, which will then charge you with a misdemeanor.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by benjohnson on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:51PM (#9128581)
In my parental opinion, there's more meaningful adversity for parents to give their children than terrifying movies. For my own childhood, a diet of passive and disjointed media led to learned helplessness.

My own children are forced to hike adult distances and work hard on tasks they find unpleasant. Hopefully this will lead to strength in the face of adversity.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by ChrisPebble on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:35PM (#9128773)
> there's more meaningful adversity for parents to give their children than terrifying movies

I grew up in a (relatively) rough part Chicago and in spite or because of the depressed nature of the place never saw a lot of horror movies growing up.

Now working with a lot of people who grew up and live in suburbia on a steady diet of horror movies, I am amazed at the amount of fear and anxiety they demonstrate when dealing with anything vaguely paranormal or the thought of an intruder.

I know numerous people who sleep with a gun under their pillow even though statistically crime (especially violent crime) is stunningly low in the places we now live. They take precautions I never even considered growing up even though break-ins and muggings happened regularly in the neighborhood.

This is 100% idle conjecture on my part, but I always wondered if horror movies played some part in such behavior.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Crito on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:23PM (#9129590)
I've got to say, I've never actually met anybody that admitted to taking paranormal nonsense seriously. People understand that "Freddy" isn't real, and that kind of slasher-fic is not why people own guns for home defense.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by anigbrowl on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:34PM (#9130024)
Of course they know the stuff on screen isn't real. It's what it symbolizes that they're scared of.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Crito on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:33PM (#9133790)
Isn't that the point of a horror movie though? The audience is supposed to know that it isn't real, and are supposed to be scared of what it symbolizes.

If kids aren't scared by Aliens, then the movie failed. Being scared by Aliens even though they know it isn't real doesn't mean that the movie inappropriate for them, it means that they are handling the movie as adults do.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by anigbrowl on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:36PM (#9134491)
Well you can still be scared by something while knowing its not real, eg there are parts of Alien that always make me jump even though I've seen it many times (I personally prefer original Alien it to the more shoot-em-up sequel).

Sticking with your original context of people owning guns for home defense, while I would never assert that they do so directly in response to horror movies or suchlike, I would argue that such movies often serve an ideological function of embodying our social fears so as to domesticate them, and that this can heighten the perception of risk.

Drop me a line about this if you'd like to continue the conversation. I'm very interested in psychoananalytic approaches to film theory and would be happy to discuss it further.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by baby on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:29PM (#9128745)
My uncle back when I was really young showed me and my cousin "Full Metal Jacket". I still remember some scenes, the film traumatized me, literally. I don't know what age I was but I was way too young for that.

Kids can get terrified by horror and violence. Sex? Not so much. I don't understand why we hide nudity from kids.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:17PM (#9129570)
I don't understand why we hide nudity from kids.

Because we are afraid of harming them, because we are conditioned to be afraid of ourselves. !Kung Bushmen often lived in hand-made temporary huts. Therefore it was basically normal for couples to make love in front of the kids. !Kung Bushmen brides were also once prized by neighboring agricultural people, as they were thought to be particularly uninhibited and enthusiastic sexually.

The US is still very much a puritan culture in some weirdly sublimed ways.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by baby on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:07AM (#9132109)
Making love in front of someone is different though. I think it's for the same reason someone doesn't like to be sober around drunk people, or the reverse.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by psykovsky on Monday March 02, 2015 @05:22AM (#9131201)
Not sure why you were downvoted. I never saw dogs or cats hiding to screw. Fact.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by omnibrain on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:22PM (#9128935)
I got "traumatized" by Baywatch (something with a ghost on the beach) and the short (2-4 sentences) teaser texts of mystery/horror-books in a book catalogue (with very broad sortiment) that came to our house. On the other hand I coped well with Mad Max and Missing in Action. You just can't predict what hits.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by angersock on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:43PM (#9128551)
I saw Event Horizon when I was like ten or eleven. I saw IT when I was about the same age. I used to stay up and watch old reruns of Alfred Hitchcock Presents with my dad.

...I'm not convinced that that was a good thing.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Zelphyr on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:07PM (#9128889)
When I saw Event Horizon I thought, "that... SUCKED!" But then, I was an adult at the time.

I wonder if it was like seeing Salem's Lot as a kid vs as an adult? As a kid it terrified me (well, the floating kid in the window scene anyway) but as an adult I wondered how such horrible acting and filmmaking could ever get green lit. I've heard the same from others in my generation.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by davesque on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:55PM (#9129876)
I saw Event Horizon in the theater when I was seventeen or so and I was traumatized. That movie was pretty twisted. I felt completely exhausted when I came out of the theater.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:55PM (#9128601)
I'll grant you Event Horizon (I haven't seen the other too). I was scared shitless for a long time after this movie.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by angersock on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:31PM (#9128754)
On the plus side, it kind of planted the seeds of insanity required for my current career doing web development in enterprise healthcare.

Where we're going, we won't need modern practices.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:18PM (#9128922)
Yeah. I think I'm gonna rewatch it soon as I've been tasked to bolt on WSDL support to a REST API app just because the top can save some money on an outsourced mobile app, whose developers have automated class generators for WSDL...

Libera te tutemet ex inferis...

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by davesque on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:57PM (#9129881)
Probably a good time to tear your eyes out.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:02PM (#9129896)
Yeah. Or someone elses...
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by scarygliders on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:09AM (#9131311)
A bit offtopic but relevant to your post: When I was an SGI customer support engineer, I repaired an SGI system for one of the film video production companies in SOHO in London - one of the SGI's was being used to render a scene in Event Horizon in which a fire extinguisher was being blown past the camera by an explosion.

Loved the movie when it came out.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by leppr on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:43PM (#9128798)
More than the simple fact of whether the child has access to 'adult' material or not, what's important is how it's presented to them. Whether they see a film with friends who got a copy from another friend, or whether their parents actually show it to them makes a big difference in how they analyze what they see. So not putting your child in a bubble and not wanting to show them disturbing media aren't mutually exclusive at all.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Sunday March 01, 2015 @06:59PM (#9129507)
why is it that kids who have parents that hide them from everything "bad", wind up so messed up, narcissistic, and are generally unable to cope with life?

Precisely because!

As the Japanese say, "You only know true kindness through suffering."

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by 72deluxe on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:52AM (#9131117)
What a strange expression. Does this mean to truly appreciate how good my car is I must drive it into a tree and wreck it?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:31PM (#9133425)
If you drove your car into a tree and became paralyzed, you might become much kinder from a firsthand understanding of deep suffering. (You might also become angry and bitter. You might even do both these things at the same time!)
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:10AM (#9131641)
I think it's more along the lines of "to truly appreciate how good your car is you must drive one that is a lot worse".
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:35PM (#9133452)
No. I'm thinking more along the lines of stuff that happened to members of my family and their friends in Korea under the Japanese occupation. Yours is indeed a first world perspective. To borrow your phrase: "To truly appreciate how good your life is, you must first 'drive' one that is a lot worse."
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:06AM (#9131622)
Strawman much? I didn't argue for complete prohibition. That's silly, even if it seems to be popular in some parts of the world (e.g. state-sponsored sexual abstinence programs in the US).
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by kyberias on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:31PM (#9128505)
Wow, what a wildly ignorant comment.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by sanderjd on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:49PM (#9128572)
Could you expand on this? As someone with no kids yet, your parent's comment resonated with me as I often feel that kids are being shielded far more than I recall from my childhood, to their detriment, but I'd love to see it from the other side.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by facepalm on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:18PM (#9128695)
Well, provide any data at all? What percentage of kids that are being shielded from stuff end up being messed up? And what does it even mean - do you mean kids should not be protected from anything at all? Or what, specifically, should they not be protected from?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by sanderjd on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:02PM (#9129076)
Ah, gotcha, if by "ignorant" it was meant "unsupported and unspecific" then I certainly see that point.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by CamperBob2 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:46PM (#9128806)
I tend to agree. The biggest problem I have is that movie ratings for all practical purposes carry the force of law even here in the US, despite the lack of anything resembling valid evidence of harm that kids under 16 or 17 might undergo by exposure to a movie. The Germans in particular are ridiculously overprotective in this sense. Um, guys, I'm pretty sure Hitler never saw Aliens. Lighten up already.

The second, more serious criticism I have is that the moral panic associated with exposure to children to onscreen violence, sex, and drugs can only diminish the real outrage that we ought to feel when kids in war-torn countries, inner-city slums, and refugee zones actually experience real-life violence and horror beyond anything Hollywood can conjure, and on a daily basis. If most of those kids don't grow up to be serial killers, I somehow doubt a movie is going to do it.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by acdha on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:10PM (#9128902)
> If most of those kids don't grow up to be serial killers, I somehow doubt a movie is going to do it.

1. Anyone in those conditions isn't seeing violence glorified the way it is in movies, where the guys you were rooting for win at the end and you rarely see prolonged consequences. Someone in a refugee camp knows all too well that the bad guys can leave people broken and pay no consequences for it.

2. Perhaps not serial killers out of a horror film but it's not like the concept of cycles of violence is unknown: children who grow up in horrible conditions do have a higher rate of either becoming gang/cartel/etc. members, soldiers, etc.[1] or have escalated rates of suicide, domestic violence, substance abuse, etc. because they've never recovered from what happened.

1. either because they have no choice or because they're all too familiar with what happens when you don't represent enough of a threat to deter violence. Closer to home, This American Life had a great interview with kids talking about how they had to join gangs because they'd be getting attacked either way so it was a question of either being afraid to leave your house or having enough allies to be relatively safe most days:

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/487/h...

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:22PM (#9128934)
> If most of those kids don't grow up to be serial killers, I somehow doubt a movie is going to do it.

That's not why most people want to restrict the amount of violent content their children watch.

See, for example, the "You've been Tango'd" ads in the UK. There's a soda called "Tango". One advert showed someone drinking the can, than a fat near naked man painted orage runs in, and slaps the drinker's face with both hands. Children imitated this, causing several perforated eardrums. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Man_%28advertisement%2... (see controversy section). That's one example of children imitating what they saw on tv, and other children being harmed as a result.

EDIT: i'm not saying children copy everything. But this example proves that children do imitate some behaviours; that children are influenced by some things they watch. Ask any parent about the children's show "Caillou" and the change of their children into whiners. Parents realise that some content will cause mild behaviour changes or nightmares and they want to be prepared.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by powertower on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:33PM (#9128981)
So how are half of the children, who play violent video-games all day long, not imitating the behavior they see and do in those games?

We should be at least overrun by car-jackings at this point thanks to Grand Theft Auto.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:07PM (#9129532)
So how are half of the children, who play violent video-games all day long, not imitating the behavior they see and do in those games?

A lot of those games involve hardware the children do not have access to. The games also often portray consequences in a way which the kids still know to be very bad. (As much as children play "war," they know viscerally that being in pain and bleeding is generally not fun.

We should be at least overrun by car-jackings at this point thanks to Grand Theft Auto.

There was one young man who enacted a GTA scenario and shot his way out of a police station with a gun he stole from a police officer. However, he is very much the exception.

What the orange advert did was to portray an activity with bad consequences as a trivial and harmless one, in a way that specifically worked around the built in understanding that otherwise deters kids from doing things like that. (Unless they mean harm. That's also within the possible range of behaviors of children. However, it's not so common in many places for children to want to really harm their playmates.)

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:59AM (#9131443)
> A lot of those games involve hardware the children do not have access to.

You mean things like fists, feet, pipes, kitchen knives, crowbars, hammers, that kinda thing? Like others said, if video games made normal people violent you'd see a lot more violence.

That anecdote about the 'enacting a GTA scenario' would also have happened just like that without the GTA link. Then it becomes a guy with a gun in a police station.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by stcredzero on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:03PM (#9133264)
You mean things like fists, feet, pipes, kitchen knives, crowbars, hammers, that kinda thing?

Yes. Actually, there was an incident I was personally witness to involving someone's 8 year old son and an ordinary clawhammer. There is clearly such a thing as "desensitization," and opposition to the notion is usually the kind of unconscious bias one generally sees in politics. < http://lesswrong.com/lw/gw/politics_is_the_mindkiller/ > Note that my position is not so simpleminded as to be simply placed on one side or another of the typical Internet argument.

If you believe that widespread gun ownership generally increases the incidence of gun injuries, then you are subscribing to the same general theory, that availability increases likelihood. Do I believe that's a justification for banning things? No, but we should be honest about the existence of such effects. (Also, fists and feet are an entirely different category, as they are naturally part of your body. And while I said it wasn't common in some places, in others kids do use those to enact violence.)

Like others said, if video games made normal people violent you'd see a lot more violence.

I would put good odds on your repeating what lots of people angrily repeat on the Internet in defense of their hobby. In the grand scheme of things, people are violent! We are extraordinarily violent as animals. In particular, we have an ability to band together in groups and murder each other in a coordinated fashion, one that probably predates our getting language! We also accomplish fantastic things living together, so we also have fantastic mechanisms for coexisting. Seeing things in media does have the effect of reinforcing the portrayed actions and scenarios in our minds. However, human minds are very complex and robust. We have mental defenses, much as we have homeostatic mechanisms.

That anecdote about the 'enacting a GTA scenario' would also have happened just like that without the GTA link. Then it becomes a guy with a gun in a police station.

Read up on the incident and honestly tell me that GTA had nothing to do with putting the idea into his head. Of course, one could also find other pieces of media he was exposed to conveying much the same message. The systemic problems resulting in his violence are probably more serious and of greater import to society than the content of some video game.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by CamperBob2 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:28PM (#9129801)
A lot of those games involve hardware the children do not have access to.

I guess that's one theory.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by 72deluxe on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:55AM (#9131125)
I am sure that Hitler never had a diet of fast food and burgers, yet if he ate them constantly he'd get fat.

The same goes with what you put in your brain; if you watch slime, slime is more acceptable to you and what comes out of you is only a product of what goes in - slime. Just because someone in the past did horrific things doesn't mean we need to expose ourselves to a barrage of horrific things.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by anigbrowl on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:39PM (#9130040)
movie ratings for all practical purposes carry the force of law even here in the US

?! Is this some leftover trauma from not being allowed in to an R-rated film when you where 13? The only people who are constrained by ratings are producers, and then only in the sense that producers push for an R rating (thereby pushing the envelope of what's acceptable for an 'R') because many theater chains refuse to show NC-17 movies for commercial reasons.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by beachstartup on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:48PM (#9128345)
the idea that you could somehow prevent your child (edit: teenagers, middle/high school aged) from seeing sex, profanity, violence by restricting their movie watching choices is just completely laughable to me. i can understand why people try, i just think it seems rather futile.

since the advent of the internet, the world is now completely uncensored to everyone, and imposing these arbitrary and anachronistic restrictions on your child will only undermine your own credibility for the things that actually matter.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:53PM (#9128363)
You don't say whether you have children or not.

Reducing the graphic sexual content or violent content that children see is normal, rational, position that is widely held by individuals and society.

People who think it's okay to expose their children to graphic violent or sexual content are weird.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by JohnBooty on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:13PM (#9128441)
Anecdotally it's been my observation that the most sheltered kids often grow up to have the most problems - they "run wild" as soon as they move off to college or otherwise get that first taste of freedom.

You certainly don't want to give your children free reign to watch all the sex and violence they want (Will I sit down and watch a porn with my kids? Heck no!) but I think that discussing sex and violence with them is probably a lot more valuable than simply shielding them from it.

I watched Aliens when I was 12 or 13, along with a bunch of other dumb 1980s action movies. I didn't grow up to be violent, because my parents gave me a strong moral grounding and I understood the line between fantasy and reality - blowing things up and doing martial arts on people was okay in a movie, but not okay in real life. I understood that, so no movie was ever going to be able to change me.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:21PM (#9128472)
Indeed.

I also watched Saving Private Ryan and Band of Brothers somewhen around 13 and those movies deeply touched me. Yes, I was pretty much crying and trying not to vomit on the D-Day scene, but it left me with deep impression about horrors of war, something that school never gives you. I didn't become more violent because of that - on the contrary, it reinforced my wish for peace and compassion for people living in places trapped in war.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:02AM (#9131603)
Funny. All the fake violence I saw as a child on TV desensitized me to the real violence I now see in the news.

I'm not even disturbed by beheading videos or actual raw footage of violent murders (i.e. whatever's new on LiveLeak this month). I don't seek them out directly or find them entertaining. I just don't have any more visceral reactions than to a video of a guy getting kicked in the groin.

I think some part of what my parents taught me about TV got lodged in the wrong part of my brain: "What you see on TV isn't real, it's just make believe." I do have very strong (and natural) reactions when seeing violence or cruelty in person. I just barely react to seeing these things on tape (beyond the ick factor). Except for (real) violence against animals, that is.

It's actually pretty gruelling what's considered acceptable to show on the 8 o'clock news these days. But I'm not sure whether this is a cultural thing again -- I hear American news channels have a policy of never showing dead US soldiers.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by TeMPOraL on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:07AM (#9131625)
For me it's exactly the opposite - while I'm pretty desensitized to the TV violence (but not completely, I still feel bad about unnecessary killing, like poor guards getting executed because they were just in the way), I'm still extremely sensitive if I know what I'm seeing is real. The cry/try-not-to-vomit/get-angry-afterwards kind of sensitive.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:09AM (#9132117)
> Anecdotally it's been my observation that the most sheltered kids often grow up to have the most problems - they "run wild" as soon as they move off to college or otherwise get that first taste of freedom.

So, I agree that over-protecting your children is probably a bad thing.

That doesn't mean that reducing the amount of graphic violent or sexual content your children are exposed to is over-protective. I might be happy for a teen child to watch Aliens with me at home, and less happy for them to watch it with their friends with no adults around. I might be okay with full nudity but less happy with sex.

But, as soon as someone says they want to restrict the content available to their children people just leap to the assumption that that person wants some fucking weird over-protective most restrictive cocoon where the child doesn't get to experience anything but Wholesome Christian Content of good people singing their praise for The Lord.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by marincounty on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:46PM (#9129245)
Yea, I went to two public high schools and a private catholic high school in four years in the same county. Parents thought their kids were sheltered from drugs and whatnot at the catholic private school, but it was the exact opposite? It was almost like the kids at the private school thought they were missing out on something, and went buck wild?
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:04AM (#9131611)
Well, obviously it's about moderation. Too much exposure to sex, drugs and violence is bad, but no exposure is bad as well. Think of it as inoculation: if a child is sheltered completely, it doesn't know how to deal with these things when it is eventually exposed to them in the real world.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:52PM (#9129041)
We agree.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by beachstartup on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:18PM (#9128460)
i guess i wasn't clear in my post, but i'm talking about teenagers. they're still "children".
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by DanBC on Sunday March 01, 2015 @05:30PM (#9129188)
Ah, cool. That does make a difference.
Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by CamperBob2 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:47PM (#9128816)
Reducing the graphic sexual content or violent content that children see is normal, rational, position that is widely held by individuals and society.

... without a single shred of reproducible evidence behind it.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by 72deluxe on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:50AM (#9131112)
Isn't the problem that children have unrestricted access to the Internet and various parts of it that are pretty much cesspools? If you jump in muck, you're going to get dirty.

I was surprised to see how little monitoring / filtering there was available on modern smartphones/tablets! Is there any filtering available on an iPad / iPhone? If so, I couldn't find it.

I certainly wouldn't want to give an iPad to my child and send them away for private browsing. The problem would lie with me in that I wasn't monitoring them; in the older days when you needed a PC, at least the PC could be in a public area of the house and everyone could see what was going on but it isn't so easy now.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by pluma on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:51AM (#9131564)
I still find it disturbing at how early an age children these days have Internet-enabled smartphones. I'm a techy myself and well-aware of the "back in my days" factor, but knowing what this can expose a child to, I still find it pretty shocking.

Not just that, but more often than not I see children with expensive high-end devices. I don't think a child needs the most recent iPhone, peer pressure or not. I realise it's a fashion accessory in addition to its utilitarian purposes, but I don't think a child needs a Giorgio Armani suit or Louis Vuitton handbag either. If they buy it from their own money, sure, but I wouldn't buy a child a new $500 smartphone every two years.

Re:Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with... by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:56AM (#9131436)
TBH it's not about preventing, it's about teaching them morals and normality. It's fine if they watch, idk, videos of randomly slapping people in the streets, just as long as they realise that's not normal or desired behaviour.